Boston College and the Crucifix

This is in from the Cardinal Newman Society:

Students and faculty returned to Boston College (BC), a Jesuit Catholic institution, for the Spring 2009 semester to find that crucifixes and icons had been placed in many classrooms that had been long bereft of sacred art. This move, which helps strengthen the university’s Catholic identity, came by direct request of President Rev. William P. Leahy, S.J., according to a campus newspaper editor. …

 

I would shout the "A" word… but this is now the tempus Septuagesimae.

Read the rest of the piece here.

Posted in Brick by Brick |
28 Comments

POLL (and a rant): Where’s the band?

POLL (and a rant): Where's the band?There are criteria for music during the liturgical action.

It must be sacred and it must be art.

That is, the idiom of the music should be sacred – not blatantly secular – it must present sacred texts and it must be artistic, both as a composition and by performance.

Idiom is a little hard to describe, but it has to do with connotation.  For example, certain instruments and styles of music invoke smokey jazz night clubs or summer parades.  Those are connotations which shift very slowly.  Other music or instruments, such as pipe organ, instantly makes you think of church.

Some people think that beauty is in the ear of the listener and that you cannot dispute tastes in music.  I disagree.  Some music really is better.

Another thing which complicates discussion of sacred music for liturgy is the issue of "active participation".  The shallow, false understanding of "active participation" which has been dominant for so long convinced most people that the congregation has to be doing stuff or otherwise they are not being "active".  So, as far as music is concerned, people weren’t to listen, they were to sing!  And sing everything. Listening was "passive".  That is wrong, of course, for listening is tremendous active.  It is active receptivity. 

Still, the result of the false notion of music and participation resulted in a dumbing down of music.  Music became a mere tool to spur participation (incorrectly understood) rather than an "integrating part" of the liturgical action: prayer itself. 

POLL (and a rant): Where's the band?To get everyone to sing, music had to be in the vernacular and it had to be simplistic.  People with the wrong idea of participation and no serious musical preparation started pushing out catchy junk inspired by the Campbell soup jingle or Gilligan’s Island theme.  Musical garbage for the lowest denominator. 

Stuff everyone can sing!

Thus was the door to our treasury of sacred music slammed shut. 

To spur the singing of this rubbish, even more people were co-opted into doing stuff, song leaders and combos, etc., were pushed up to the front of the church because doing stuff and seeing it being done was now the point of participation in the less and less sacred action.

Here is a little poll question.

Where is your band or music combo or choir situated in your church.

It is possible that in some places with more than one Sunday Mass you may have a band in front for one Mass and a choir in the loft for the other.  Or, the choir is up top in the loft for most Masses but then there is the single "contemporary" or "youth" Mass.

But for the most part, where are they?

POLL CLOSED

Where’s the liturgical band/choir?

  • Tucked away (in the choir loft or out of view) (56%, 420 Votes)
  • In full view (up front or close to the sanctuary) (44%, 329 Votes)

Total Voters: 749

Posted in POLLS |
41 Comments

UK – alarming!

I picked this up from UKLifeLeague.com

Call for Two-Child Limit on Families from Government Adviser

Couples who have more than two children are putting an ‘irresponsible’ burden on the environment, the Government’s leading green adviser has warned.  Jonathon Porritt called on ministers to take action to reduce population growth in Britain.

The LifeLeague says: Please click here to contact Jonathon Porritt.  Remind him that the UK is not China and urge him to rethink his anti-life opinions.

This has a surreal, P.D. James-ish, quality to it.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
23 Comments

Fr. Perrone – A Septuagesima Sermon

The great Fr. Eduard Perrone of the fortunate Assumption Grotto parish in Detroit delivered a fine sermon for Septuagesima Sunday. 

A reader here, a parishioner there, Diane of the blog Te Deum Laudamus sent me some rough audio which I scrubbed and boosted.

Here is Father’s excellent sermon your edification.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
4 Comments

A fortunate flock in Grand Rapids, MI

A reader sent the following.  It is posted on the parish website as a PDF, but he took the time to send me the text, which aided me in posting what comes below.

This parish priest has made a determination for the good of his flock.  Let’s read what he has to say with my emphases and comments.  First comes the intro from the man who sent this piece:

Fr. Z, this is from this Sunday’s bulletin from the Sacred Heart of Jesus parish in Grand Rapids, Mich. Sacred Heart has a weekly Sunday TLM at 12:30pm. They alternate celebrants from our diocese and have a rotation of Low Mass, High Mass with (mixed sexes) choir and High Mass with schola. (The column is titled "Twin Towers" because the church has two, large bell towers.)

TWIN TOWERS

Last month, on the 15th of January, I celebrated a weekday Mass a bit differently. The appropriate word for what I did is described by the Latin term ad orientem. That means "towards the east". Or some would say, "the priest turning his back to the people". Why am I doing this?

To celebrate the current Mass properly, the Liturgy of the Word is done with the priest at the chair. [He is talking about the Novus Ordo, of course.] He only comes to the Altar for the preparation of the Gifts and then the Eucharistic Prayer. After Communion he normally goes back to the chair for the concluding rites. So the time at the altar is not that long.  [Nor would it be for a solemn Mass with, say, orchestral music.]

I was ordained in 1979, so I always celebrated the Mass in this manner. But to be very honest with you, I’ve never understood why. What was there to see? [good] It takes Faith, belief that bread and wine become the Body and Blood of Christ. Our human eyes cannot see that happen – only our hearts & souls do. So again, what is there to "see"?

Unfortunately, what has happened to the Mass – which has been a topic of some objections to the reforms that began in 1964 – is that at times, the Mass has become a human-priest centered event. But the human-priest is a physical stand-in for the true priest of the Mass, Jesus Christ the Eternal High Priest. The Mass is HIS; He leads us all to the Father in worship, in the Eucharistic Sacrifice. The idea is for the human-priest AND the rest of the worshiping community to stand in the same direction "following Jesus" to the Father. Picture Moses leading the Hebrews to the Promised Land.  [So… here is one image: the priest is leading the people toward something.]

"Ad orientem", literally "facing the East", comes from the Book of Ezekiel in which the People of God await the coming of the Lord FROM THE EAST (43:2). And St. Matthew declared the return of the Lord Jesus: "As the lightening from the east flashes to the west, so will the coming of the Son of Man be" (24:27).

Churches used to be built purposely facing the direction of the coming of the Lord – the East. [There is a second point: the Lord is coming from the East, so we face that direction in expectation.] The point of all this is not that we have to all face the East – although that would seem to be the most desirable direction – but that the priest and people are on a spiritual journey together. [Right!  "East" in this sense is not limited to geographical East, as some enemies of ad orientem worship will at times obtusely blither.] The priest is not an entertainer that he has to face an audience, unless he is specifically talking to them: when he says "The Lord be with you", reading the Scriptures, or giving a homily or some other liturgical instruction. Otherwise, the priest is NOT TALKING TO OR LOOKING AT THE PEOPLE. The prayers of the Mass for the most part are addressed to God the Father, not the people.  [This reminds me of a something that happened to me once at St. Peter’s Basilica… but.. another time…]

It has taken me some time to come to an understanding, that "facing the people" as if I were doing a cooking show on TV seemed to go against what the Mass was all about. Looking at the congregation as I pray and talk to God just didn’t make sense.

The fact is however, that that’s the way Mass has been celebrated for nearly 40 years now and little old Edie Hankiewicz is not about to change things. But then something else has happened, Pope Benedict, from time to time, celebrates Mass "ad orientem"! What I believe he has been trying to do, among other changes he’s made in celebrating Mass (like insisting people kneel for Communion and receive only on the tongue) is the fulfillment of a lot he was written about Roman Catholic Liturgy for many, many years.  [Yes… this priest gets it.  Also, the so-called "Benedictine arrangment" of the altar is really a transitional arrangement back to true ad orientem or ad Deum worship.]

I believe I’ve made this change (once a month) for good, spiritual reasons, not whim or simply to be different. I will continue to do so, with advance notice, (with the Latin words, "ad orientem" next to the Mass time) so if anyone doesn’t like this idea, one can go to another Mass in the area. That will be the case this coming Thursday, 12 FEB at the 7:30am Mass.

Father [Edward] Hankiewicz

Big WDTPRS kudos to Fr. Hankiewicz and his fortunate flock in Grand Rapids.

Posted in Brick by Brick |
29 Comments

UK FSSP TLM DVD

The FSSP has made available their TLM training DVD in the UK.

I reviewed it here.

I encourage priests in the UK interested in learning the older form of Mass to check out this useful tool.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
3 Comments

A decision in Brisbane about renegade St. Mary’s and Fr. Kennedy

You all know about the wacky St. Mary’s in Brisbane and the wackier Fr. Kennedy, who has led his flock toward the cliff.

This is in from ABC.

Brisbane priest sacked over Catholic feud

By Kim Lyell and Kerrin Binnie

Posted Sun Feb 8, 2009 12:36pm AEDT

A priest has been sacked from a Brisbane church after a long-running feud with the Vatican.

St Mary’s Roman Catholic Church at South Brisbane has been accused of performing unorthodox mass and not respecting the church hierarchy.

The Archbishop of Brisbane, John Bathersby, previously warned Father Peter Kennedy to stop flouting church rules or face the sack.

In a letter received on Friday, Archbishop Bathersby said Father Kennedy and "the community have not budged an inch".

It says Father Kennedy’s appointment will be terminated on February 21, unless he resigns first.

Father Kennedy says he is considering his options. [?]

"I’ve been here 28 years and I know this community is solidly behind me, and so we could go elsewhere," he said. 

In the letter, Archbishop Bathersby says parishioners cannot be stopped from breaking away but has warned them they will not be in communion with the Roman Catholic Church.

Around 700 people repeated the familiar [to whom?] Catholic rites at mass at St Mary’s in south Brisbane this morning.

The letter visibly upset the congregation.

Parishioners at the Brisbane parish say will continue to celebrate mass in their own way.

Margaret Ortiz from the St Mary’s leadership group says the congregation is staying put and Father Kennedy will continue to say mass.

"They would have to come a physically remove us," she said.

Vince Knauth, also from St Mary’s leadership group, says it is not right that Father Kennedy is being singled out.

"Statistically this week 4,392 priests and deacons of the United States were subject to allegations of child molestation – that’s between 1950 and 2002," he said.  [that again?]

"Two per cent of those were actually put behind bars.

"Peter [Kennedy] would be in better books with the Catholic church if he’d molested a child than what we’re doing here." 

Father Kennedy has appealed to the Archbishop to reconsider

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
51 Comments

Double Standard

I recently heard on TV a media wonk challenge a racial double-standard in sentencing guidelines for cocaine and for crack.  Cocaine is used more by white people but the sentencing guidelines are less harsh than those for crack, used more by black people.  I don’t know enough about this issue to assess it, but a good question is raised.  

This was on in the background while I was looking at some newly released diocesan guidelines for the implementation of Summorum Pontificum, by which Pope Benedict emancipated Catholics who desire Holy Mass with the 1962 Missale Romanum.

For a long while we, blessedly, hadn’t seen dioceses impose additional "norms" on the Supreme Pontiff’s provisions.  This week we have seen a couple more instances. One was pretty good and the other dreadful, even insulting to the Pope.  Interesting timing, give the lifting of the excommunications of the bishops of the SSPX.

As I reviewed these very different documents I had the odd sense that there was buried in them both something not unlike the possible racial bias of those sentencing guidelines.

Since ’07, when Summorum Pontificum came out, diocesan norms imposed on the Supreme Pontiff’s provisions will at times include something like "this Mass must not be celebrated for people who deny the validity of the Novus Ordo".

Well… okay.  Bishops want to keep the knuckle-headed stuff out of the mix. 

But this is nothing other than a policing of thoughts.  Their very ideas must be assessed before a Mass may be celebrated in a legitimate Catholic Rite.

In contrast, there is far less urgency to police people’s thoughts on issues of grave importance for how we live and die as Catholics.  I should say their thoughts and their actions.

We don’t know how grave a sin it may be for a Catholic to think the Novus Ordo is invalid and then act so as to avoid going to Novus Ordo Masses.  Go ahead and argue that it’s bad to say it’s invalid.  Can you go to Hell for it?  I wonder.

It is, however, a sin for a Catholic to think persistently, even after instruction, that the Church is wrong about abortion and then act in such a way as to defy or undermine the Church’s teaching.

We wonder if you risk Hell for the former.  We know you can go to Hell for the later.

Pastors of souls must above all else protect the immortal souls of their flock.  What could possibly override that concern?

In the case of those who don’t like the Novus Ordo, or maybe have other crass ideas or behaviors, some bishops and priests would seek to bar such folks from having Holy Mass with the 1962 Missale Romanum.  Perhaps they should even be barred from the Church.

But obstinate public dissenters who concretely act in defiance of the Church’s teaching on the sanctity of life are treated quite differently. 

Pro-abortion politicians attend Masses all the time.  They receive Communion all the time.  Their thoughts and actions are known to all.  They create scandal and confusion.  They are at risk of eternal Hell and threaten to take others with them.

But great oversight must be exercised in the matter of Summorum Pontificum.  Priests must be assessed.  The very thoughts of the faithful have to be judged before they can have a legitimate liturgy of Holy Church. The older form of Mass is such a grave matter that additional guidelines must be imposed.

The judgment and sentence given to the one group by our shepherds is often quite different from that which they impose on the other.

Double standard.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
31 Comments

Archd. of Milwaukee: norms for Summorum Pontificum

The Archbishop of Milwaukee, His Excellency Most Rev. Timothy Dolan published norms for the Archdiocese for the Extraordinary Form of the Mass.

My emphases and comments.

Archbishop promulgates guidelines for Extraordinary Form celebrations

In order to ensure an orderly implementation of the norms of Summorum Pontificum, Archbishop Dolan has promulgated diocesan guidelines for liturgical celebrations with the use of the 1962 Missal. These norms are effective immediately.

GUIDELINES FOR CELEBRATION OF THE EXTRAORDINARY FORM LITURGY AT PARISHES IN THE
ARCHDIOCESE OF MILWAUKEE

The motu proprio issued by Pope Benedict XVI entitled Summorum Pontificum allows for the exercise of discretion [A curious phrase.  Does the MP talk about "discretion"?  The MP says that pastors of parishes are to receive willingly requests from the faithful.  I suppose at that point he uses discretion, the power or right to decide or act according to one’s own judgment.] in the use of the 1962 Missal at parishes. The applicable text reads as follows:

Art. 5. § 1 In parishes, where there is a stable group of faithful [The Latin says "where there is stably present a group…"] who adhere to the earlier liturgical tradition, the pastor should willingly accept their requests to celebrate the Mass according to the rite of the Roman Missal published in 1962, and ensure that the welfare of these faithful harmonizes with the ordinary pastoral care of the parish, under the guidance of the bishop in accordance with canon 392, avoiding discord and favoring the unity of the whole Church.
§ 2 Celebration in accordance with the Missal of Bl. John XXIII may take place on working days; while on Sundays and feast days one such celebration may also be held.
§ 3 For faithful and priests who request it, the pastor should also allow celebrations in this extraordinary form for special circumstances such as marriages, funerals or occasional celebrations, e.g. pilgrimages.
§ 4 Priests who use the Missal of Bl. John XXIII must be qualified to do so and not juridically impeded.

Art. 6. In Masses celebrated in the presence of the people in accordance with the Missal of Bl. John XXIII, the readings may be given in the vernacular, using editions recognized by the Apostolic See.

[Now we get to the meat…] To ensure an orderly application of these norms the following guidelines are to be observed:

•    The request for celebrations in the extraordinary form arises from a stable group [Remember: that is not quite what the MP says] who have adhered to this usage over time. The use of the extraordinary form is not used with groups that reject the validity of the ordinary form. The extra-ordinary form is not to be used only at the discretion or personal preference of the pastor/priest without a request from the people.  [There is a lot of debate about this point around the world.  Some strongly argue that the priest can, in fact, implement the older form of Mass even without requests.  I believe Card. Castrillon holds this view.]

•    The use of the extraordinary form is not to be used if it will create a divisive or elitist spirit in the parish. [This "elitist" label is an unfortunate addition to these "norms".  But let’s try to put a good spin on it.  It is likely that this is aimed at the people who prefer the TLM.  But, we can also take this to mean that there shouldn’t be a bunch of snooty supporters of the Novus Ordo who take on an elitist attitude!  I am not convinced that is what the author intended, but the language bears this interpretation as well.] Prior catechesis for the whole parish, not just to those who are making the request, is required. [Should be going on anyway, actually!  This is a good idea.] The extraordinary form is not to be used as a “novelty” or “teaching tool.”  [RIGHT!  Holy Mass is not a "didactic moment".  Sure, people can learn many things from Mass at many levels.  Attending a TLM could open eyes about certain aspects of the Novus Ordo.  But Mass is first and foremost to be an encounter with MYSTERY.]

•    Since the norms require that the priest celebrating in the extraordinary form be qualified to do so, there needs to be an assessment of readiness for such celebrations. Priests who were not trained in the 1962 Missal, or who have lost touch with the rituals therein, are to demonstrate their qualifications prior to such a celebration. The priests of the Institute of Christ the King (St. Stanislaus Parish) will be delegated to make such assessments and provide assistance as needed.  [This seems on the surface to be reasonable, since we don’t want some priest running off half-cocked who will make a mess of things.  But again there is a possibility of a double standard.  Who is overseeing the competence of priests who use the Novus Ordo?]

Okay… well.  Not so bad, really.

I am pleased that this seems to concern mainly public celebrations of Holy Mass.

The only thing that causes concern is the suggestion of a double standard in some of the language here.

First, there was the "elistist" comment.   Yes.  This is a problem.  There are some who prefer the TLM who get pretty snooty about it.  It is possible to argue that the TLM is superior to the NO without getting snooty.  However, there are an equal, nay rather, greater number of people who sneer at the TLM, preferring the NO.  They take an an equally "elitist" attitude.  Furthermore, some elitist supporters of the Novus Ordo actually have been in positions of influence in the Church for a long time.  Their treatment of supporters of the TLM has been somewhat less than just or kind over the years.  So, to my mind this word "elitist" should have been left out.

Also, the "assessment of readiness" is troubling.  I repeat: it is not unreasonable to require that a priest be competent to celebrate Holy Mass in his Rite.  I am glad that the document did not mention competence in the Latin language.

In fairness we must therefore ask two questions.

What vigilance will be exercised for celebrations of the Novus Ordo?  Will there be an equal oversight concerning competence? 

Still, that leads to the other question.  Since priests of the Latin Church now have faculties to use the 1962MR, will the ordinary also make sure that his new priests and his seminarians know the older form?  In fact, it is necessary and proper that oversight of competence of priests to say Holy Mass in their Rite should include both uses and not just one.  Otherwise, would that not be a confirmation that there in fact is a double standard?  That an elitist attitude does in fact exist, but in favor of the Novus Ordo?  "You don’t have to learn that Mass."

And yet the thoughts of the faithful about whether the Novus Ordo is valid need to be assessed before they may be allowed to have a TLM.  Troubling.  I will write more on that elsewhere.

Is this not all a subtle admission that the TLM is of greater weight and substance in some way?  That it is harder?  More demanding?

 

In any even, consider the contrast between these norms and those recently issued in on the other side of the world in Manila. 

You folks in Milwaukee have it pretty good.
 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
54 Comments

A replacement for Williamson in Argentina?

In a story in La Nacion, there is speculation that perhaps SSPX Bishop Galaretta could take over at the seminary in La Reya, Argentina in place of SSPX Bp Williamson.

Whatever move they make, clearly Bp. Williamson will be assuming more and more a non-public role in the SSPX.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
17 Comments