No matter what the Pope would do, it wouldn’t be enough for this lot

This there a sadder city in North America than Detroit? 

They have a dreadful pro-abortion "Catholic" governor who has helped to make their state’s economy the worst in the country, they are bleeding businesses and people, the mayor of Detroit… well…

And then there is their newspaper, the Freep.

This is an editorial from the Detroit Free Press Editorial Board, so it represents the official stand of the paper.

My emphases and comments.

February 6, 2009

In demanding that British Bishop Richard Williamson recant, the Vatican did little [No matter what the Vatican would have done, for some it would never have been enough.] to mitigate the public relations damage done by the decision of Pope Benedict XVI to return this Holocaust-denier to the church. Williamson has never repudiated his outlandish views about the extent of Jewish suffering under the Nazis. Taking them back now would show nothing but political expediency. [Because for some in the Fourth Estate, there is no such thing as changing your mind unless you are a liberal.  They can change their mind in any way they want, but conservatives are forever guilty for any past crime.] The Pope ought to acknowledge his own error and reinstate the ex-communication of Williamson.  [And that would be just HOW?  Williamson was excomm’d for an entirely different issue that had NOTHING to do with his views, historical or theological.  They want the Pope to treat Williamson with the injustice with which they are accustomed to treat the Pope.]

The pope’s decision to lift Williamson’s excommunication from the Roman Catholic Church last month, along with those of three other bishops appointed by an ultra-conservative breakaway archbishop more than 20 years ago, has caused an international uproar. Williamson recently told Swedish TV that no Jew was killed by gas chambers during World War II. He insulted the memory of the 6 million Jews murdered in Nazi death camps by stating that only 200,000 or 300,000 perished.

For a crackpot to spout this nonsense is troubling — for a person invited back into the church by the pope to do so is outrageous and dangerous.  [Because sinners shouldn’t be invited to belong to any Church.  Right?]

[Now watch this incredible cheap shot….] History makes the pope’s actions even more significant. As a teen-ager, Pope Benedict was briefly a member of the Hitler Youth. When the Pope visited Auschwitz, he did little to ease Jewish concerns about anti-Semitism, making no mention of his personal experiences during the war or explicitly asking forgiveness on behalf of Catholics or Germans. Many Jewish groups had also accused the wartime-era Pope Pius of indifference to Jewish suffering under the Nazis.  [This simply STINKS of bigotry.]

Pope Benedict should not be judged by his brief, and compulsory, membership in the Hitler Youth.  [Liars.  Why did they bring it up?  This is mendacious.  It is precisely this point that they want you to carry away: the Pope did this because he is really a Nazi.  He’s German after all.  And now this Williamson thing?  Well… you know what that means!] Nothing in his record suggests prejudice or malice toward anyone. Still, his own experience ought to compel him to show greater sensitivity to the grotesque inhumanity of the Holocaust, or risk fomenting anti-Semitism and damaging the progress in Catholic-Jewish relations made by Pope John Paul II.

He can start by permanently barring a prelate who desecrates the memory of millions of Jews from the church.   

The Church or the Pope could never do enough to satisfy the people who wrote this yellow hit piece.

If the Pope were to flail himself in sackcloth and rub gravel through his hair at the Western Wall, it would not be enough for them. 

Were he to exhume Pius XII and posthumously excommunicate him , it would not be enough for them.

And since this is really because they hate the Church and the Pope because of the Catholic teaching on abortion and contraception, were the Pope to give a contribution to Planned Parenthood and then toss condoms from his window to the crowd below during his Sunday Angelus, well… it would not be enough for them.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
31 Comments

Amusing wymynpryst interview

Does every network have to have a couple of tame priests?

Anyway this odd interview was on ABC.  I was alerted to it by a priest friend of mine, Fr. JM.

How many flaws in the arguments can you identify?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
20 Comments

The 5th

Now we know!

But… what do we know?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
11 Comments

A Friday evening

Pretty evening. 

A Friday evening

Tonight I have moved from

"Oh Jo, please don’t say awful; it’s slang." … during the sweet squash and curry soup I made today from an old squash about to go bad…

A Friday evening

(the prep photos didn’t turn out for some reason)
… to…

"They put creatures in our bodies!", for the main course of perch fillets from the freezer with wilted lettuce.  Just a touch of wine to deglaze and wilt.

A Friday evening

On to Battlestar Galactica!

I wonder what Fr. L had.

Posted in Fr. Z's Kitchen |
18 Comments

Soooo… Fr. Longenecker is going after Fr. Z, is he?

I have – with brow furrowed and full of concern – received word that Fr. Dwight Longenecker, for whom I have such great esteem, has decided to toss darts at WDTPRS!

He was wondering aloud if, given that I do not restrict myself to serious subjects only… though how fixing good food isn’t serious I can’t tell, …  if WDTPRS perhaps will next hSoooo... Fr. Longenecker is going after Fr. Z, is he?ave a fashion section.

Then, he slings yet another barb! After provoking me with the title "King" he then contumaciously posted a photo of himself in a spiffing cappa!

QUAERITUR: Is this anything but a toss of the chiroteca?

Fine…  have it your way!

I too have a cappa.

Here is a shot from a couple years ago on my way to do an Epiphany house blessing.

Soooo... Fr. Longenecker is going after Fr. Z, is he?

And please note, Reverend and Dear Father, that I am walking on water in this photo as well.

How about a ferraiuolo?  I trust, Father, that you have one of those too!

o{]:¬)

In the meantime, please vote for WDTPRS in the Bloggers Choice Awards!

WDTPRS always needs your kind help.

Soooo... Fr. Longenecker is going after Fr. Z, is he?

Posted in Mail from priests |
62 Comments

QUAERITUR: non-concelebrating priests and Communion

From a priest reader:

Except when the Archbishop (or another Bishop) is celebrating here at the parish I am not inclined to concelebrate. I prefer to attend in choir as does my associate when one or the other or a visiting preacher is the celebrant ( special feasts, school masses, etc.). What is the protocol for the reception of Holy Communion for when a priest attends in choir dress? We know what it is when a Bishop is present but unsure if the same concessions go to a priest.

 

I agree. Concelebration should be safe, legal and rare.  Attendance in choir is better on most occasions.

In that case wear proper choir dress, which is cassock and surplice, with biretta.  If you are a canon or rector, etc. that would be a little different.

For reception of Communion, I don’t think there is anything to note, other than priests should always receive Communion wearing a stole.  In the older form (there is no concelebration of course) you would go to the altar and receive kneeling at the step below the footpace.  In the Novus Ordo, I suppose you could do this also, or Communion could be brought to you as you kneel.

I remember in Rome some years ago at a papal Mass in the Basilica of St. Peter seeing a line of canons/clerics receiving from the Holy Father.  One would receive, remove his stole, kiss it, hand it to the next man who kissed it, put it on… received… removed the stole… kissed it… handed it to the next man…

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Mail from priests |
14 Comments

Request from Fr. Z: links to pages supporting Benedict XVI

Request from Fr. Z: links to pages supporting Benedict XVIThere are quite a few initiatives on the web to express support for Pope Benedict during this time of media frenzy.

I have posted about a couple of them already, but people keep sending me the same links over and over.

Let’s see if we can collect as many as we can here.

Remember: my combox is functioning, something is broken on the blog right now and the comments are not counting accurately.  Check below for updates
.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
12 Comments

SSPX priest expelled due to remarks on the Holocaust

This is in from APCOM

The SSPX has expelled the priest, Fr. Florian Abrahamowicz (more here), who made statements which, like those of SSPX Bp. Williamson, reduced the extent of the massacre of Jews during WWII.

Lefebvriani; Fraternita’ italiana, espulso prete negazionista

Roma, 6 feb. (Apcom) – La Fraternità San Pio X annuncia l’espulsione di don Floriano Abrahamowicz, il prete responsabile della provincia del Nord-Est, che – come il vescovo Richard Williamson – ha negato la Shoah, dichiarando che le camere a gas sono servite solo per disinfettare. "Il provvedimento – si legge in una nota diffusa dal distretto italiano della Fraternità – ha effetto a partire da venerdì 6 febbraio ed è stato preso per gravi motivi di disciplina. Don Floriano Abrahamowicz da tempo esprimeva posizioni diverse da quelle ufficiali della Fraternità San Pio X. La decisione dell’espulsione, pur dolorosa – conclude la nota – si è resa necessaria per evitare che venga ulteriormente distorta l’immagine della Fraternità San Pio X e, di conseguenza, sia danneggiata la sua opera al servizio della Chiesa". Ssa

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
29 Comments

“Home at last!”

"Home at last!"

Just to put things in perspective.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
6 Comments

Archd. of Manila on Summorum Pontificum

MANY… I mean MANY people have sent me the text of the Archdiocese of Manila’s incredible restrictions on the use the 1962 Missale Romanum.

I wasn’t going to post it here.  Instead , I immediately forwarded what I received to proper authority in the Holy See.

Pretty outrageous stuff, actually.

I thought this sort of thing was behind us.

It is as if Summorum Pontificum didn’t exist or maybe even Ecclesia Dei adflicta didn’t exist!

Although the date is in December this was just posted on the website of the Archdiocese of Manila.  I wonder why it was left until now?

Surely this isn’t a stab at Pope Benedict who is trying to reconcile the SSPX… strike now while they are unpopular in some circles.

ARCHDIOCESAN GUIDELINES
ON THE CELEBRATION OF THE MASS
ACCORDING TO THE RITE OF THE ROMAN MISSAL
PUBLISHED IN 1962 (TRIDENTINE MASS)

In accordance [?!?] with the norms laid down by the Apostolic Letter, issued motu propio, of His Holiness, Pope Benedict XVI, Summorum Pontificum,  [As you read, try to see anything of Summorum Pontificum in these harshly restrictive "guidlines and conditions".] We hereby establish the following guidelines and conditions on the celebration of the Mass according to the rite of the Roman Missal published in 1962 (Tridentine Mass) in the Archdiocese of Manila:

   1. The regulation of the celebration of this extraordinary form of the Mass belongs to the Archbishop of Manila, through the Minister of the Ministry for Liturgical Affairs of the Archdiocese of Manila. [The MP says that parish priests make these determinations and that the faithful have the right to action on their requests.]

   2. This form of Mass is to be celebrated only at the Christ the King Chapel of the Metropolitan Cathedral of Manila once a month, but not on Sundays and Solemnities.  [The MP says that parish priests make these decisions in their parishes and that the bishop serves only to help when the parish priest can’t or won’t provide for the requests of the faithful.]

   3. The presider at this form of celebration should be a priest duly appointed by the Archbishop of Manila.  [The Motu Proprio says that all priests with faculties to say Holy Mass at all, also have the faculty to use the older form, because there is, juridically speaking, one Roman Rite in two uses.  Bishops can restrict who says Mass in their diocese by denying them faculties.  Is that what he is doing?]

   4. To ensure the solemnity and orderliness of the celebration of this form of Mass, the participation of other ministers (i.e., lectors, Master of Ceremonies, servers, choir, etc.) in the liturgy is to be determined and regulated by the Ministry for Liturgical Affairs of the Archdiocese of Manila. [So… the office of liturgy gets to determine who may serve Mass?]

   5. The celebration of the extraordinary form of the Mass in this Chapel is open to any individual or group in the Archdiocese of Manila who may have the desire to participate in such celebrations.  Further requests from individuals or groups from the parishes of or who belong to the Archdiocese of Manila to celebrate this form of Mass is to be directed to join the monthly celebration at the Manila Cathedral. [So… he is telling priests to ignore their requests and send them to the Cathedral.]

   6. It is highly encouraged that a missal / booklet of the rite in Latin and English be prepared to help the faithful follow the celebration.  It is like wise encouraged that those who will participate in this Mass undergo a catechetical orientation before the celebration. [Will there be a similar request concern attendance of the Novus Ordo?]

   7. The Archbishop of Manila has jurisdiction over this celebration and, therefore, can decide to limit or discontinue this monthly celebration anytime he judges that this is not consonance with the whole pastoral direction of the Local Church.

Given in Manila, this 8th day of December 2008.

+GAUDENCIO B. CARDINAL ROSALES
Archbishop of Manila

 

These are "guidelines and conditions".  I don’t know what that means.  But the intent is clear.

Summorum Pontificum is not in force in Manila.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Archd. of Manila on Summorum Pontificum