CREEPING INFANTICIDE: NY style ghoulish abortion bill now introduced in Virginia

It had to happen.  If it was successful in NY, it would be attempted in other states..

Read at LifeSite about a bill in Virginia that would allow abortion even at the point of giving birth.   Good heavens… is “abortion” even the right word at that point.

HERE

Known as the Repeal Act, Virginia House Bill 2491 would eliminate current restrictions on late-term abortions.

According to the bill’s summary, the proposed law:

  • Eliminates the requirement that an abortion in the second trimester of pregnancy and prior to the third trimester be performed in a hospital.

  • The bill eliminates all the procedures and processes, including the performance of an ultrasound, required to effect a woman’s informed written consent to the performance of an abortion; however, the bill does not change the requirement that a woman’s informed written consent be first obtained.

  • The bill eliminates the requirement that two other physicians certify that a third trimester abortion is necessary to prevent the woman’s death or impairment of her mental or physical health, as well as the need to find that any such impairment to the woman’s health would be substantial and irremediable.

  • The bill also removes language classifying facilities that perform five or more first-trimester abortions per month as hospitals for the purpose of complying with regulations establishing minimum standards for hospitals.

Posted in Emanations from Penumbras, You must be joking! | Tagged
14 Comments

Canonist Ed Peters on trying Gov. Andrew “the Ghoul” Cuomo for heresy. Fr. Z makes some observations.

When I was travel back to these USA from Tokyo, I was addressed by fellow travelers about Gov. Cuomo.  “When is he going to excommunicated?”  They were really angry.

People are angry.  Rightly so.  They want action, not words, from bishops.  Rightly so.  They have vague notions about something dramatic called “excommunication”, so they want that.

Frankly, I wouldn’t mind some Richard Burton/Becket style bell, book and candle against Cuomo’s backside, but only if the law truly supported it.

However, the fact remains that we have laws in the Church.  When it comes to application of censures to people who commit sins we have to interpret the law as strictly as possible in order to protect the rights of the accused.  That makes the “prosecution’s” case much harder to argue.

Today, canonist-galore Ed Peters has long and pretty comprehensive look at another canonists idea that Gov. Cuomo could be tried for heresy: “the obstinate denial or obstinate doubt after reception of baptism of some truth which is to be believed by divine and Catholic faith”.  Peters breaks down all the terms and looks at the feasibility of such a case.

Anyone interested in what “heresy” is, or how canonical procedures work, would do well to read his whole offering.  It is a mini-workshop and very informative.  At the very least it will give the average reader a new view of how high the bar is for imposing a sanction on a person.

Peters also make the point that a failed attempt at imposing a censure on Cuomo would make matters worse.  Whatever is undertaken has to be done meticulously.

NB:  In another state capital, Springfield of Illinois, after the governor signed same-sex marriage legislation, Bp. Paprocki performed an exorcism over the whole state.  HERE  It may be that excommunication will be difficult to impose.  That doesn’t mean that bishops must do nothing.   

Every single bishop of New York can take up his copy of the Rituale Romanum and perform an exorcism over the whole state.

Abortions are sins that attract demonic influence and oppression.  Exorcism of any place where abortions are performed is appropriate and necessary.

Once again, the well-known observation of St Thomas More comes to mind, that was strikingly portrayed in the movie A Man For All Seasons.  According to Thomas’ biographer William Roper, the saint did say indicate something along these lines, and it made it into Robert Bolt’s play and screenplay.  But the dramatic version makes the point crystal clear.

Scene: Richard Rich, who later betrays Thomas, leaves the room.

ALICE MORE: Arrest him!
SIR THOMAS MORE: For what?
ALICE: He’s dangerous!
WILLIAM ROPER: For libel, he’s a spy!
MARGARET MORE: Father, that man’s bad.
MORE: There is no law against that.
ROPER: There is! God’s law!
MORE: Then God can arrest him.
ALICE: While you talk, he’s gone!
MORE: And go he should, if he were the Devil himself, until he broke the law!
ROPER: So! Now you’d give the Devil benefit of law!
MORE: Yes. What would you do? Cut a great road through the law to get after the Devil?
ROPER: Yes! I’d cut down every law in England to do that!
MORE: Oh? And when the last law was down, and the Devil turned round on you, where would you hide, Roper, the laws all being flat? This country is planted thick with laws, from coast to coast — man’s laws, not God’s — and if you cut them down — and you’re just the man to do it — do you really think you could stand upright in the winds that would blow then? Yes, I’d give the Devil benefit of law, for my own safety’s sake!

Play video

And just because I mentioned Becket, above, here are scenes which serve to increase my desire to see bishops of this stripe today.

When people come up to priests on airplanes and in airports to vent about Gov. Cuomo, what they are really calling for a bishops who bishop.

First, how a bishop ought to deal with errant, obstinate Catholic politicians in serious matters.  Sure, it reverses the role here, where the state accuses a bishop, instead of the other way around, but… damn… backbone!

Play video

Very dramatic.   But people today long for the spirit of this episcopal display.

Next, the excommunication scene.  Again, theatrical.  But, people want the strength and conviction of this moment, after decades of hand-wringing and placating.

Play video

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , , , , , ,
19 Comments

ASK FATHER: Marijuana and validity of marriage

ASK FATHER: Marijuana and validity of marriageFrom a reader…

QUAERITUR:

Recently marijuana was legalized in Canada. As such, the issue has come up that Marijuana can stay within the system for a very long time and a habitual user can be impaired by marijuana even if he/she hasn’t used it recently. My understanding is that Catholics cannot be impaired by drugs and alcohol at the time of the wedding for the sake of validity because of their inability to give free consent to the marriage. Would this mean that habitual pot heads wouldn’t be able to marry in the Catholic Church? If so, what would you recommend if, hypothetically speaking, a legal pot head were to be planning on getting married in the Church and is concerned about validity?

GUEST PRIEST RESPONSE: Fr. Tim Ferguson

Whether or not marijuana is civil legal or not, the question is a good one. Habitual use of any intoxicant can impede a person from being able to use his discretionary faculty – that faculty which allows us to freely choose something, in this case, marriage.

To marry, the Church requires that a person have the ability to exercise his free will. Without internal and external freedom, matrimonial consent can fall under a shadow of possible invalidity. The Church would presume – before any investigation is done – that the consent is valid, but upon investigation, someone who was shown to be regularly under the influence of marijuana – and under that influence at the time of the wedding in particular – might be proven to have not posited a valid act of consent.

If someone accustomed to using marijuana – or alcohol, or any intoxicant that numbs the senses – with regularity were to come to me preparing for marriage, I would first take pains to remind him of the moral gravity of surrendering his free will through the use of intoxicants. Our free will is a precious gift from God, and should not be lightly surrendered.

Secondly, I would urge him, at the very least, to observe a period of sobriety of at least several days before and certainly during the wedding. If I were a priest preparing such a person, I would inform him that, unless I had confidence that he was sober and clear of mind the morning of the wedding, said wedding would not be taking place.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000, One Man & One Woman | Tagged ,
6 Comments

BOOKS RECEIVED: Breviarium Romanum

As you know, Summorum Pontificum affirms that priests and those obliged to say the Office, can use the traditional, pre-Conciliar Breviarium Romanum.  A while back I answered a query about use of the Breviarium Romanum published by the SSPX.  HERE  I came down on the side “Yes, you can use it.”

In that answer I mentioned that I didn’t have the edition about which I was being queried.

So, turn the clock to the present day and, having returned from Tokyo, I find a box from Angelus Press with – lo and behold – breviaries.  HERE

Behold.

BOOKS RECEIVED: Breviarium Romanum

These volumes are of bible paper, bound imitation black leather. There are four ribbons tops in different colors.  The pages are gilded.

BOOKS RECEIVED: Breviarium Romanum

BOOKS RECEIVED: Breviarium Romanum

Helpful cards.

BOOKS RECEIVED: Breviarium Romanum

Note the publisher, in France.

BOOKS RECEIVED: Breviarium Romanum

What edition is this?  This is the last decree included in the front of the first volume.  1960.

BOOKS RECEIVED: Breviarium Romanum

By contrast, the three volume, English/Latin facing edition reprinted by Baronius Press is the 1961.

BOOKS RECEIVED: Breviarium Romanum

Note that the psalms go across the page.

BOOKS RECEIVED: Breviarium Romanum

The appendix has all the bits one expects.

BOOKS RECEIVED: Breviarium Romanum

I am very grateful for the set.  I will spend a little time with the present volume, to see how we get along.

Posted in Liturgy Science Theatre 3000, REVIEWS, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM | Tagged , ,
7 Comments

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

The adventure to Tokyo has wrapped up, and the long flight home endured. I thought some of you might like a few more images.

First, I am a bit of a sucker for Tokyo subway posters. I marvel at them. So very… odd.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

Another kind of subway poster, however, lead me to trek to Roppongi Hills to see a fantastic exhibit of a favorite, Katsushika Hokusai.   He had some 30 names over his career.  He died at 90.  His production was olympian.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

This was a different exhibit from the one I saw at the Hokusai Museum near the Edo-Tokyo Museum and the Sumo Stadium.  In this exhibit there were about 500 pieces!

Alas, photos were not permitted in the exhibit.  I bought the catalog, however.  I only do that for the vest best exhibits.

He is most famous for the magnificent wave print.

At the cafe there I had some curry.  Gimmicky, but fun.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

The view from the museum floor.  In Tokyo, you have get used to thinking vertically.  The museum was on the 54th floor.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

Back to food.

One of the best places for pork-based ramen is in Shijuku.  Fuunji.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji\

Happily the queue was short.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

Heavenly stuff, this ramen.

One of the more interesting buildings.  Cocoon.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

Of course we had to go to the food hall at Isetan.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

Photos are frowned on.  However, let’s just say that there are an underground football field’s worth of showcases with the most beautiful food you have ever seen, either prepared or produce.   I’d like a couple months in Tokyo to cook myself through some of these marvels.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

An example of one of the beautiful presented preparations.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

One evening we went to have tempura from a true master of the art.  Here is a leaf called shisu with uni, sea urchin.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

There was a great deal more, to be sure.

Dessert, two large red beans.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

There was, in the entry way, an antique set of playing cards for a game based on a set of poems by 100 poets called Ogura Hyakunin Isshu.  This is played, as it was explained by the great Augustin-san who was with us, in January.  He plays it and his children are learning.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

The basic idea is that that you draw a card.  There is half of a poem on the card.  You have to complete the poem.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

On a more commercial them.  I am amazed at the artificial food on display outside of restaurants.  Sort of a 3D menu to entice you in.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

Which drink is mine?

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

A nice way to prepare a lime slice for your Gins and Tonic.  Or is it Gin and Tonics?

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

We touched most of the bases in Tokyo: Shabushabu, ramen, tempura, sukiyaki.  Of course we had sushi in Tsukiji.

Here’s our set, with a few closeups.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

This ain’t your grocery store sushi friends.  It’s in a whole different class.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

With a slight char.   I prefer without, but they were outstanding, nevertheless.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

At the end of the set, we had an elective.  Augustin-san and I went for the two on the right – shrimp – still twitching.  I have a video HERE.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

After those, the heads, after a bath in hot oil.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

Crunchy.

A tsukiji street at night.  Lot’s of places to try.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

Some people have wondered about my Mass set up during trips.  Here is how I set up this time in my little hotel room.  Frankly, the space is not completely set up yet, and you can see, of the vestments, only the little antependium, and you can’t see the antimensium.  This is from the reversible travel vestments that were given by JS, J&MS, JD.  I remember you when I use them.  I didn’t bring the travel altar this time. Maybe next time.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

The room had a view, however.  Fuji is in the background.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

And so, having concluded a great trip, and having met wonderful Catholics and eaten good food and seen spectacular exhibits and enjoyed the sumo basho, it was off to the airport.

Surely Hoksusai would have made the following, final view of Mount Fuji into one of his (more than) 36 Views.

TOKYO – Day 4-8: Woodblocks, Chow and Fuji

Posted in On the road, What Fr. Z is up to | Tagged , , ,
17 Comments

A 4 year-old and the rubrics

A 4 year-old and the rubricsFrom a reader…

Good evening Father,

A funny story that you might appreciate. My 4 year old son was sitting with me while putting my 2 year old to sleep, and he was watching my phone. I was praying Vespers (via DivinumOfficium.org) and he asked me:

“Daddy, are you saying the black parts and doing the red ones?”

“Yes, kiddo, that’s right.”

Kids absorb a lot more than we think they do! Tradition is for the young.

That’s wonderful.

Children have a strong liturgical sense.  I’ll bet lots of you parents out there can bear witness to that.

Posted in Lighter fare, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000, Our Catholic Identity | Tagged
17 Comments

@DanHoranOFM -The Horan of Babylon – calls #MarchForLife “repulsive and futile”

@DanHoranOFM -The Horan of Babylon - calls #MarchForLife "repulsive and futile"Breitbart has a piece which shows the fruits of decades of slack theological training and compromised religious formation.  An LBGT promoting Franciscan, who teaches heaven knows what in the theological Babylon called Chicago Theological Union, has called the March For Life “repulsive and futile”.

The Franciscan, Daniel P. Horan, from now on to be known as the Horan of Babylon.

However, as per Breitbart:

Horan has praised the pro-abortion Women’s March as consistent with Catholic social teaching. The fact that pro-life women and organizations are not welcomed at the event seems not to bother his conscience in the slightest.

Think about this.

He is anti-March for Life.  That means that he has little interest in the aims for which the March was born: defense of human life.  He sidesteps the life issue by super-imposing his own irrelevant, left-wing political views on the March.

He is pro-sodomy.   That means he promotes fruitless, sterile sex which also leads to any number of other problems.

He praises a pro-abortion rally.  That means he supports something that kills the fruit of naturally ordered sexual relations.

A while back at Fishwrap, he denigrated traditional liturgical worship of God together along with John Paul II’s “theology of the body”.

Are you seeing a pattern?

The Horan of Babylon, ladies and gentlemen.

He seems to be failing around for attention.

The moderation queue is ON.

Posted in Emanations from Penumbras, Liberals | Tagged , ,
30 Comments

D. Albany Bp. Scharfenberger calls out hypocrite Gov. Cuomo

It seems that Albany’s bishop, Most Rev. Edward B. Scharfenberger, is not remaining silent about Gov. Cuomo and his hypocrisy.

From Fox:

NY Bishop Calls Out Cuomo Over State’s New Abortion Law: ‘It Goes Way Beyond Roe vs. Wade’

A bishop in Albany, New York, called out Gov. Andrew Cuomo for citing his Catholic faith and supporting recent legislation that legalizes abortion up until birth.

Cuomo (D) signed the Reproductive Health Act on Tuesday, which he called “a historic victory for New Yorkers and for our progressive values.”

Days earlier, though, the governor touted his Catholic faith during his ninth State of the State address.

In an open letter to Cuomo, Albany Bishop Rev. Edward B. Scharfenberger said it was “very difficult to understand” how the governor can cite his faith, yet advocate for such a “profoundly destructive legislation.”

Scharfenberger said Saturday on Fox & Friends that although Cuomo’s bill advertised bringing more equality to women, it excludes the class of women who are unborn.

“It goes way beyond Roe vs. Wade in so many ways, so certainly I don’t see it’s something to celebrate,” he said.

He added the governor’s excommunication from the Catholic Church may occur if he continues to distance himself.

“I can certainly understand the outrage and the anger,” he said. “My hope is that since his faith is important to him, he will reconsider the importance of maintaining that communion and not continue to distance himself.”

Posted in ¡Hagan lío!, Emanations from Penumbras | Tagged , , ,
27 Comments

ASK FATHER: What happens to Guardian Angels after we die?

ASK FATHER: What happens to Guardian Angels after we die?From a reader…

QUAERITUR:

What happens to your guardian angel after you die? Did he necessarily exist before you were conceived? If so, was he possibly somebody else’s guardian before? Indeed are angels the guardians of more than one soul?

Thanks for the question about angels.   Angels are fantastic and fascinating.

Yes, all the angels who exist, existed before material creation.  When we profess that God created all that invisible, “unseen”, that means the angelic realm.

There are two kinds of persons, created and uncreated.  The uncreated Persons are obviously the three Persons of God, the Holy Trinity.  The created persons are in two categories, those who are individuated in matter and those who are not.   Because we human beings are individuated in matter, we all belong to one species, the human race.  Because angels are not individuated in matter, each angel is his own species, as different from each other as alligators are from giraffes.

There is no telling how many angels there are.  Scripture indicates at certain points that there are so many angels that they are hardly to be counted.  God knows, but we couldn’t count them if we tried.  As a matter of fact, some think that there may be an angel for everything that moves, guiding it according to God’s great plan.   In any event, there are far more angels than there are of us.

We know from Scripture that we have angel guardians.  Christ even refers to the angels of little ones who see the face of God.  Angels, not having bodies, are not limited to one place as we all.  They are where they need to be acting. In seeing the face of God at the same time as they guard us, they watch over us according to God’s will.

What happens to our guardian angels after we die?  They remain angels, of course.  They can never be anything other than what they are.  They do not lose their angelness.  Could God assign them to some other person?  Sure.  Does He?  Who knows.   There are so many angels that every human every born could have a new one, from any of the choirs of heaven, high or low.

And even the least of the angels, at the very bottom of the angelic heap, by far transcends this material realm.  Angels are mighty beings, indeed.

Aside: Remember that St. Francis said that were he to meet a priest and an angel on the road, he would reverence the priest first.  An angel can’t do what a priest can, such as forgive sins and confect the Eucharist.

Nevertheless, angels perpetually behold the face of God and worship Him in the heavenly hosts, wreathed and thronging around the celestial altar of the Lamb, singing praises… KADOSH… KADOSH… KADOSH… DOXA DOXA DOXA… SANCTUS SANCTUS SANCTUS… HOLY HOLY HOLY.  Holy angels are never not worshipping God, even when they have a job to do that refers to our lives.  A “job”, a mission from God that makes these incredible pure spirit persons “messengers… heralds…”.  “Angel is from Greek, “messenger”, Hebrew malakh.  Once the mission is done, they are not then “messengers” but their nature doesn’t change.

Speaking of choirs of angels, the mightiest of the Angels whom we think about, Michael, is from what we identify as one of the lower choirs.   At the top are the magnificent seraphim and cherubim described in Scripture.

There is a lot more to be said about angels, but that will suffice.   There is, however, a story told in a letter St. Jerome to a friend, Eustochium, about a nightmare. Jerome was questioned by an angel. The angel asked him who he was.  Jerome said that he was a Christian.  The angel said, “No, you are a Ciceronian!”, because Jerome was a great admirer of Cicero.  Then the angel beat him.

They can do that.

 

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box | Tagged , ,
17 Comments

Fr. Murray on the Covington Matter and NY State abortion debacle

My good friend Fr. Gerald Murray was on EWTN commenting on the Covington Matter and on the abortion debacle in NY.

You won’t find a better commentator.

Play video

Posted in The Drill |
2 Comments