QUAERITUR: “flee to orthodoxy”

From a reader:

I have been reading and enjoying your blog over the past year while by God’s grace He has restored me to the Church. (Most of my adult life I spent in the wilderness until He worked a conversion in my heart in 2002 and I landed in the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod (LCMS).  There I served in lay ministry and attend seminary classes in theology until the need for a more developed interior life led me to pray the Chaplet of St. Michael.  That’s when all the trouble began….  :)
 
All this is to say that this prodigal daughter has come home to the Church with a distinctly conservative hermeneutic. There are many beautiful parishes and devoted clergy in my area and I pray for those who pour themselves out in vocation for God.

But I have been surprised to encounter "centering" prayers, the not so subtle blurring of women’s roles in liturgy and leadership, some forms of higher criticism that the LCMS itself purged in the 1970’s, syncretism, the rewriting of the Hours to use gender inclusive pronouns and… if it could be worse…. the dulcet sounds of Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young and James Taylor lyrics emanating from ordained clergy at the lectern. 
 
Meanwhile me and all my books by Pope Benedict and 4 volume Liturgy of the Hours are in hiding, not sure what to make of all this.
 
In the LCMS, pastors would urge the faithful to "flee to orthodoxy" under such circumstances.  I want to spend the rest of my life loving God as best a sinner can, and I recognize that I have much to (re)learn and judgmentalism is a sin.  But is a layman, respecting authority, able to flee to orthodoxy in the Church, and how does one find it?

Yours is a story many converts and reverts can share, as well as many who have never fallen away from the Church but have rather suffered these long decades of the post-Conciliar silly season… now happily coming to a close.

So much depends on where you live, that I cannot give any precise answer.  But I must say that as a revert you need a stable period to get used to yourself as being Catholic. 

Find yourself the best possible parish and then hunker down and do your best there. 

It seems to me that you can "flee to orthodoxy" in some simple steps. 

First, say your prayers.  I don’t mean that to be flippant.  Say your daily prayers regularly.  When you rise and when you retire.  When you eat and when you have finished.  The Angelus at noon and 6 pm.   Say your Rosary.

Examine your conscience in the evening before sleep. 

Read some Scripture for a few minutes (if your volumes of the LOTH are still in hiding). 

Use sacramentals, such as Holy Water in your home. 

Use the Sacrament of Penance, regularly.

Be conscious of what you can do to gain indulgences for the poor souls even as you ask the saints to intercede for you.

We are all connected.  We are in this together.  They are on your side.

At Holy Mass put all your cares and aspirations, your sacrifices and petitions and thanks on the altar with the host and into the chalice with the wine.  Seek that encounter with mystery even when it is being obscured.

Just be a Catholic for a while.  Settle in.

When you see an abuse or catch a whiff of some something not right, don’t fret.  Remember that Satan hates the Church and priests with a savagery we humans cannot fathom.  Priests and those close to them in ministry will be the Enemy’s most urgent target.  It must not surprise us when we see things that are wrong or weird in the Church or during Mass, sad as that is. 

Be sober and alert about these things and do not allow them to be a drag on your spirit, for Old Scratch will use them if possible to erode your faith.

Also, when you consider a "flight to orthodoxy" consider that you have already arrived.  Holy Catholic Church is the spotless bride of Christ.  Her members are flawed, but she without error and hell’s minions can never prevail.

Finally, I don’t know whether or not you have ever received the sacrament of Confirmation, but this is an important tool of your spiritual life.  Confirmation strengthens the Christian in the trials of his or her life.  We can call upon the grace of that great sacrament in time of testing.

In the meantime, I sense that good changes are picking up speed in the Church.  The biological solution is taking care of the aging-hippies.  Young people don’t have the baggage of the previous generations.  Summorum Pontificum and the Holy Father’s other initiatives are exerting their "gravitational pull" on many spheres of the Church’s life.  Catholics are waking up to their identity, just as you are.

You have many resources at your fingertips, books, internet, church.

You have the sacraments.

You have lots and lots of company.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
62 Comments

A priest’s reflection on bishops

From up close or from afar many of you know about the story being told that a Benedictine Abbot in England declined to become or postponed becoming the next Archbishop of Westminster, which is normally brings a red hat.

My friend Fr. Ray Blake, of St. Mary Magdalen in Brighton, has some pointed comments about the whole scenario to which any man who thinks he should be a bishop might pay close attention.

As you go in, remember that there is a strong current of hearsay going on in the background.  But certain rumors have that ineffable….sorry… that’s a hard word for some enemies of Liturgiam authenticam… an ineffable quality of being true.

My emphases and comments.

I am not too sure I believe the rumour about Dom Hugh Gilbert, Abbot of Pluscarden being offered then turning down or delaying taking the diocese of Westminster, because of problems in the monastery.

If the story has a basis in truth then the implications are pretty radical. I do not know much about Abbot Hugh, except he is known for his holiness and Pluscarden has a reputation even amongst monastics as being ascetic and contemplative and conservative. It has no school, no parish, the community is small, less than thirty. There is really no comparison here with the appointment of Basil Hume. Ampleforth with its school and dependent parishes is comparable to a small diocese, Pluscarden is more like a small isolated country parish.

If this story has a basis in truth, [and here is the meat of the nut] then the Pope has passed over our present bishops, therefore he is not looking to administrative ability, or to those who have "proved" themselves in the present narrow and narrowing system.  [What Damian of Holy Smoke and others have dubbed "the Magic Circle"]

He is looking to a radical commitment to Christ and holiness, and a rootedness in Tradition, and from what I have heard of Dom Hugh an ability to draw people to Christ.  [Which one might consider a good quality in a bishop.]

Like many priests I have become increasingly concerned by the way in which bishops have been appointed in England and Wales. This is apparently the questionnaire that is sent by the nuncio to gather information on candidates. [It is sent out confidentially] Amongst other things it asks about Orthodoxy:

    6- ORTHODOXY
    Doctrinal orientation. Loyalty to the Doctrine and Magisterium of the Church. In particular: the attitude of the candidate to the Documents of the Holy See on the Ministerial Priesthood, on the Priestly Ordination of Women, on marriage, on sexual Ethics and on Social Justice. Fidelity to the genuine Tradition of the Church and commitment to the authentic renewal promoted by Vatican 11, and adherence to the "Statement of Conclusions, 1998".

but nowhere does it ask if the candidate actually believes in God or can communicate that belief. [Not an idle question.  Though if a man adheres to the "Doctrine and Magisterium" I suppose it can be assumed that he adheres to the Creed.] Some readers might be scandalised by this suggestion that a bishop might not believe but today the Church needs bishops whose belief in God transforms them and their priests and [here it is…] is immediately evident.

It is not unusual to sit through a sermon preached by a few of our bishops, which never mention God or refer to the scriptures, [But may in fact mention "fair trade" and "global warming"] which not only fail to inspire, but leave one wondering if the preacher believes anything at all. Nor is it unusual to attend a confirmation that seems more like a rather shoddy graduation ceremony rather than the completion of Christian Initiation and bestowing of the Seal of the Holy Spirit. [Well done, Father.]

England and Wales desperately needs evangelisation, evangelisation isn’t about clever techniques or sociology, it is certainly not about cunning schemes, [Amen and amen.] small groups or large groups, it is about holiness which comes from living faith and a deep personal desire for Christ, and a firm hope in Divine Providence. I pray that I am wrong about the Abbot, and he really will be the next Archbishop of Westminster. If it is true, then his appointment will be criticised for his lack worldliness and of administrative experience, but quite frankly I suspect holiness trumps administrative ability, and we all know about worldly bank managers nowadays.

If His Hermeneuticalness can’t be the next Archbishop… then maybe … after this Abbot?

Good work, Fr. Blake.  WDTPRS kudos to you.

Posted in The future and our choices |
30 Comments

QUAERITUR: Extraordinary ministers giving blessings at Communion

From a reader:

I was hoping you might be able to shed some light on a question which has been bothering me since my reception into the Church a little while ago.  Everytime I receive Commnunion from one of the EMHCs, she tries to raise her hand over my infant son to bless him.  What’s going on here?  Is this licit?  I’ve seen this practice many places within this diocese (Baltimore) but have a hard time believing this is authorized.

The first question to be asked is whether the EMHC is really needed.  (I think not.)

The second question is whether Communion time is really the time for blessings.  (I think not.)

That said, no lay person should attempt to imitate what a priest does.

Anyone can ask God to bless anyone else.  Everyone should ask God to bless others.

But lay people should not make gestures, in imitation of priests, and give the impression that he or she is trying to bless in the manner of the priest.

The way lay people ask blessings and the way priests invoke God’s blessing are very different.

Lay people: don’t imitate priests in this regard.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000 | Tagged , ,
97 Comments

QUAERITUR: Funeral on a Sunday with the Novus Ordo

From a priest reader:

I have a liturgical question for you. According to the Ordinary Form, do you know how a funeral Mass is celebrated on Sunday? Are the Proper Sunday readings and prayers used, or those for a Mass for the dead? Neither the Instiutio nor the Order of Christian Funerals give an answer. Thanks for your help!

First, people should know that funerals can be celebrated even on Sundays, except if those Sundays are solemnities.  For example, you cannot have a funeral on a Sunday to which Epiphany has been moved.

In this case, I am supposing that you would use the Sunday readings and prayers, for the most part.

However, given that in the Novus Ordo just about anything can be substituted for anything else "for pastoral reasons", perhaps you can use the requiem readings and prayers.  After all, you can celebrate All Souls on a Sunday.

Perhaps some priest readers out there have faced this and know what to do.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Mail from priests |
18 Comments

“Red Planet Rover! Red Planet Rover!…”

It just hit me.

Today is the 5th anniversary of the landing of the intrepid little Mars rover “Spirit”, still plugging away.

Amazing.

And I thought my little broadcasts were complicated.

Spirit is in serious but stable condition.

I remember clearly watching over the internet the coverage of the landing and getting the first images back from the surface.  The rovers are resting right now because of the annual solar conjunction.

 

Posted in Just Too Cool | Tagged ,
6 Comments

WDTPRS – Epiphany – Roman Station: San Pietro in Vaticano (2002MR)

The Roman Station for Epiphany is San Pietro in Vaticano.  The only problem is that Epiphany in the Vatican is celebrated on 6 January, when it ought to be.  In the rest of the world, sadly, Epiphany is moved around, thus obliterating it’s fixed character in relation to Christmas Day.

“Epiphany” comes from the Greek word for a divine “manifestation” or “revelation”.  The antiphons for Vespers reflect the tradition that Epiphany was thought to be the day not only on which the Magi came to adore Christ, but also the day Jesus changed water into wine at Cana, and when He was baptized in the Jordan by St. John.  All three events reveal Jesus as more than a mere man: He is God.   There are many “epiphanies” or “theophanies” in Scripture, such as when Moses saw God in the burning bush. 

The celebration of Epiphany stretches back to the Church’s earliest times.   In the Greek East, Epiphany was of far greater importance than Christmas, which was a relative latecomer.  In the Latin West, Christmas developed first, and Epiphany later. 

In many countries people exchange gifts on Epiphany, in imitation of the Magi with their gifts.  Epiphany truly falls on 6 January, the twelfth day after Christmas, as in “On the Twelfth day of Christmas, my true love gave to me…”, and also the title of Shakespeare’s play Twelfth Night.  In the reformed, post-Conciliar calendar Epiphany is usually transferred to a Sunday, so that more people can attend the Mass. 

I think it is a mistake to transfer important feasts like Epiphany, in Christmastide, and Ascension Thursday in Eastertide.  These feasts are pegged to the great celebrations of Christmas and Easter for a reason.  When we transfer these feasts to Sunday, we diminish the meaning of the liturgical year. By making our obligations as Catholics ever more lax and easier to fulfill, a subtle signal is sent that none of our obligations, practices or teachings are important enough to warrant a place and, at times, sacrifice in our daily lives.  

Exquisite customs grace Epiphany.  The most famous is the blessing of chalk used to hallow homes. On the lintels of the doors the priest writes with the chalk “20 + C + M + B + 09”, i.e., the year and initials of the names of the Magi indicated in Rituale Romanum: Gaspar (G and C being related), Melchior et Baltássar. 

The names of the Magi are traditional, not scriptural and some ancient authors thought there were as many as 24.  

Some say “C + M + B” stands for “Christus Mansionem Benedicat… May Christ bless this dwelling”. Though clever, that’s probably wrong.

Water is blessed at Epiphany because of Christ’s Baptism in the Jordan.  People give presents and enjoy King Cake and Lamb’s Wool (a drink made from cider or ale with roasted apples, sugar and spices).  Apple trees were blessed by pouring cider on them! 

In Italy children wait for “la Befana” (from Italian “Epifania”). La Befana is old woman who was invited by the Magi to accompany them on their journey to find the newborn King. She declined because she was busy sweeping her house. Later, she realized her error followed the Magi but never caught up.  Thus, la Befana is still searching for Jesus, zooming around Harry Potter-like on her broomstick.  Santa-like, however, she visits homes and leaves toys and candy for good children, and the nasty lumps of coal for the naughty. 

In today’s technological society, instead of coal she and jolly old St. Nick would do better to leave an obsolete cellular phone or maybe a first generation X-Box.

Santa gets cookies and milk by fireplaces to sustain him on his way, but Italians appropriately leave wine and oranges for la Befana.

COLLECT (1962MR):
Deus, qui hodierna die Unigenitum tuum gentibus stella duce revelasti:
concede propitius; ut, qui iam te ex fide cognovimus,
usque ad contemplandam speciem tuae celsitudinis perducamur.

This ancient prayer, already in the 8th century Gregorian Sacramentary, survived the cutting table of the post-Conciliar reform: it is still the Collect in the Novus Ordo.  Celsitudo, in your revelatory Lewis & Short Dictionary, indicates in older Latin a “loftiness of carriage” while in later Latin it points to “majesty”, as in the title “Highness”.  In case you are trying to figure out the ending of revelasti it is a syncopated (shortened) form of revelavistiStella duce is an ablative absolute (duce is from dux).   The adjective hodiernus, a, um, is “of this day, today’s”, so hodierna dies literally is “today’s day”, stronger than a simple “today”.  Perhaps we could say, “this day of day’s” or “this of all days”.

LITERAL TRANSLATION:

O God, who this very day revealed your Only-begotten, a star having been the guide,
graciously grant,
that we, who have already come to know you from faith,
may be led all the way unto the contemplation of the beauty of your majesty.

In this life we know God only indirectly, by faith.  This is St. Paul’s “dark glass” (1 Cor 13:12) through which we peer toward Him in longing.  In the next life we will not need faith because we will have direct knowledge.  In this phrase usque ad contemplandam speciem (a gerundive construction indicating purpose) we are praying to be brought “all the way to the beauty” of God “which is to be contemplated”.  This vision of His beauty will increase our knowledge of Him and therefore our love for all eternity.  This is what we were made for: His glory and splendor.  St. Hilary of Poitiers (+367) spoke of the gloria of God as a transforming power which divinizes us by conforming us more and more to His image.  In our prayer, there is a move from faith to knowledge in the Beatific Vision. Christ is the visible image of the invisible God. He is the Beauty and Truth of the Father. 

Our true Catholic faith and our splendid liturgy show forth the truth and beauty of God.  We must find the most accurate and beautiful words, actions, music we can possibly summon from human genius, labor and love for Holy Mass.  What we say and do in church ought to be a foretaste of heaven and the Beatific Vision.  Think simply of the effect music has on people.  Last year National Review stated that, “if good music does not always save the soul, bad music never does. When the electric guitar sounds during the Sacrifice of the Mass, the cherubim weep.

The Church is reclaiming her great liturgical treasury, especially since Pope Benedict gave us Summorum Pontificum.  Even the new translation of the Novus Ordo Missale Romanum should work wonders.

SECRET (1962MR):
Ecclesiae tuae, quaesumus, Domine, dona propitius intuere,
quibus non iam aurum, thus et myrrha profertur,
sed quod eisdem muneribus declaratur, immolatur et sumitur,
Iesus Christus.

This prayer, also in the ancient Gregorian Sacramentary, happily survived as the Super Oblata for Epiphany in the Novus Ordo.  Notice all the passive forms (-tur).  They provide an excellent internal cohesion and create a powerful climax at the end when the Holy Name suddenly comes to our ears… like a little epiphany

Note the two different words for “gift”: donum and munus.  The L&S says that in classical Latin literature donum is associated with gifts of incense in a passage from the Aeneid of Virgil: dona turea (6, 225).  The verb sumo is basically “to take, take up, lay hold of, assume.”  In some contexts it can be also “consume”.  Declaro is “to make clear, plain, evident (by disclosing, uncovering), to show, manifest, declare.”

LITERAL TRANSLATION
Graciously gaze down, we beseech You, O Lord, upon the gifts of Your Church,
in which gold, frankincense, and myrrh are no longer laid before You,
but rather that which is revealed, sacrificed and received by means of those same gifts,
Jesus Christ.

The tokens brought by the Magi, representing the hopes of the nations of the earth, were “types”, foreshadows of the Lord who would offer Himself on the Cross.  Fathers of the Church and medieval writers such as Jacobus de Voragine (+1298) wrote with creativity and insight about these symbols.  Gold symbolizes the kingship of God, to be mirrored in the purity our hearts which are so precious to Christ and which He as King desires for His throne.  Frankincense symbolizes Christ’s divinity because only God should receive sacrifices.  The burning of something so precious reminds us of the utter immolation to which Christ submitted Himself on our behalf.  The total destruction of incense produces smoke, which rises like our prayers upward to God.  During a Traditional High Mass the priest incenses the altar while saying quietly, “May this incense, which Thou hast blessed, O Lord, ascend to Thee, and may Thy mercy descend upon us. Let my prayer, O Lord, be directed as incense in Thy sight: the lifting up of my hands as an evening sacrifice. Set a watch, O Lord, before my mouth, and a door round about my lips. May my heart not incline to evil words, to make excuses for sins.  May the Lord enkindle within us the fire of His love, and the flame of everlasting charity. Amen.”   This prayer was done away with in the Novus Ordo, as were many references to sin.  Myrrh, the balm used to prepare the bodies of the dead, underscores Christ’s humanity, through which He endured suffering and then resurrection.  The Offertory prayers help the attentive Christian dispose himself for an encounter with mystery. 

POSTCOMMUNIO (1962MR):
Praesta, quaesumus, omnipotens Deus:
ut quae solemni celebramus officio,
purificatae mentis intellegentia consequamur
.

This ancient prayer did not make the cut in the Novus Ordo.  Intellegentia is obviously the “power of discerning or understanding”, but ancient authors such as St. Jerome (+420) and John Cassian (+435) also use it for the ability to see the deeper, symbolic meaning of Scripture, allegorical meanings. 

LITERAL TRANSLATION: 
Grant, we beseech You, Almighty God,
that we may attain with the understanding of a purified mind,
the things we are celebrating with solemn observance.
         

Our participation at Holy Mass should be truly full, conscious and active.  We actively engage all we see and hear so as to receive with an eager embrace everything God offers through our Holy Church’s sacred mysteries.  We will have our own “epiphanies” during Mass, moments of “revelation”, often about ourselves and the state of our soul, or what we ought to do in life.  Remember that the Word, who is God eternal, became flesh also in order to reveal us more fully to ourselves (cf. Gaudium et spes 22).  In the life to come, only the pure may see God.  This should give us ample motive to participate actively, with interiorly active receptivity, to the graces and insights which come from our encounter with mystery.  This should give us more than enough motive to be purified of our sins through confession and sacramental absolution.  The reality of our unavoidable judgment must at some point dawn upon us like a thunderclap.  When you finally understand that you must one day die and face judgment, you begin to understand why Holy Mass must be nothing other than an encounter with mystery.

When we go to Mass we should be like Moses’, putting off his shoes before God in the burning bush which was mysteriously not consumed. We must be like Magi, whose penetrating sight was fixed on no one but the infant Jesus, in whose perfect image something of the invisible Father is mysteriously revealed.

Posted in Christmas and Epiphany, WDTPRS |
15 Comments

The Nuthatch Life

The feeder has been busy, as usual. 

Living the Nuthatch Life:

And when you are not eating, you’re just hangin’ out waiting.


Coming in for a snack.

The enemy.

Posted in My View |
15 Comments

TLM aboard USS THEODORE ROOSEVELT

I picked this up from Breviarium Romanum.

I am including only one of the photos.  Be sure to visit them for a few more shots.

Go Navy Part III: Feast of Saint John the Apostle

The Reverend Charles Johnson, Navy chaplain, celebrates the liturgy of the Feast of Saint John the Apostle aboard the aircraft carrier USS THEODORE ROOSEVELT (CVN 71).

Note the Gesu Bambino placed near the altar crucifix.

A statue of Our Lady is placed to the left of the altar for the celebration of Holy Mass. A US Navy Sailor serves as acolyte.

Please visit again for more details about the origin of Father’s Roman vestments in a festive floral style on a white ground.

Larger Navy ships such as aircraft carriers usually have a dedicated chapel space which must be maintained as a “neutral”, or non-denominational, space when not in use by a particular religious group in order to better facilitate the beliefs of all.

The materials necessary for the celebration of the liturgy are stored away to be set up for each Holy Mass and then taken down again afterward.

 

I happily recall my visit to this carrier and meeting the fine Fr. Johnson.

Blessings upon him and thanks for his service and that of all good chaplains.

Posted in Brick by Brick | Tagged
12 Comments

Paris – 4 January TLM at St Eugène—Ste Cécile – Card. Vingt-Trois

From a reader:

Some readers may be interested in the news that Cardinal Vingt-Trois, the Archbishop of Paris, will celebrate Mass in the Extraordinary Rite at the Parish Church of St Eugène—Ste Cécile, Paris, on Sunday, 4th January 2009 (the feast of Ste Geneviève, patroness of the city). The occasion will be a farewell to Mgr Batut, the curé and friend of the TLM, who is to be ordained Auxiliary Bishop of Lyon.

Posted in Brick by Brick |
17 Comments

Cistercians in Sparta, WI – saving the world

From a reader:

This morning at Spring Bank Abbey, [Sparta, WI] the Conventual Mass for the Solemnity of Mary the Mother of God was celebrated ad orientem, which will now be the normative manner for saying Mass at the abbey. (The Mass was solemn Latin in the ordinary form using the Cistercian Graduale.)

There are still many kinks and questions to address pertaining to the rank of feasts, the customs of the ordinary form v. surviving Cistercian usages, the size of our community, and the layout of our oratory. The draft customary will certainly see much fleshing-out and many amendments over the coming months, but Fr. Prior thought that today was the appropriate day to begin to face God together, it being the first of the year and a solemnity of Mary.

I thought that you and your readers might be interested.

I’ve attached a photo and there are more here.

Here is a shot.

 

This is, IMO, the sort of thing which will help to save the world.

 

Posted in Brick by Brick |
22 Comments