Card. Levada on the present clerical sexual abuser controversies

The former Archbishop of San Francisco, now CDF Prefect, His Eminence William Card. Levada, offered a piece to his former archdiocesan newspaper about the recent controversies.

His Eminence is now the head of the Vatican dicastery that handles the cases of clerical sexual child abusers.  I believe that Pope Benedict needed to have an American in that office because of the backlog of cases in the English language, especially from the USA.

He is responding to the way the New York Times (aka Hell’s Bible) and others have reported and distorted the issues.

Let’s have a look with my emphases and comments.  It is on the long side, so I had to edit.   Read the whole thing yourself. 

The Cardinal’s tone is nothing short of scathing.  I believe it is a fair treatment of what the Times and their writers, especially, Laurie Goodstein, worked together to accomplish.

It was written on 26 March.

Cardinal Levada to NY Times: Reconsider ‘attack mode’ against Pope Benedict
March 30th, 2010

The New York Times and Pope Benedict XVI:
how it looks to an American in the Vatican

By Cardinal William J. Levada
Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith

[…]

[Laurie] Goodstein’s account bounces back and forth as if there were not some 20 plus years intervening between reports in the 1960 and 70’s to the Archdiocese of Milwaukee and local police, and Archbishop Weakland’s appeal for help to the Vatican in 1996. Why? Because the point of the article is not about failures on the part of church and civil authorities to act properly at the time. I, for one, looking back at this report agree that Fr. Murphy deserved to be dismissed from the clerical state for his egregious criminal behavior, which would normally have resulted from a canonical trial.

The point of Goodstein’s article, however, is to attribute the failure to accomplish this dismissal to Pope Benedict, instead of to diocesan decisions at the time. She uses the technique of repeating the many escalating charges and accusations from various sources (not least from her own newspaper), and tries to use these “newly unearthed files” as the basis for accusing the pope of leniency and inaction in this case and presumably in others.

It seems to me, on the other hand, that we owe Pope Benedict a great debt of gratitude for introducing the procedures that have helped the Church to take action in the face of the scandal of priestly sexual abuse of minors. These efforts began when the Pope served as Cardinal Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith and continued after he was elected Pope. That the Times has published a series of articles in which the important contribution he has made – especially in the development and implementation of Sacramentorum Sanctitatis Tutela, [SST] the Motu proprio issued by Pope John Paul II in 2001 – is ignored, seems to me to warrant the charge of lack of fairness which should be the hallmark of any reputable newspaper.

Let me tell you what I think a fair reading of the Milwaukee case would seem to indicate. The reasons why church and civil authorities took no action in the 1960’s and 70’s is apparently not contained in these “newly emerged files.” Nor does the Times seem interested in finding out why. But what does emerge is this: after almost 20 years as Archbishop, Weakland wrote to the Congregation asking for help in dealing with this terrible case of serial abuse. The Congregation approved his decision to undertake a canonical trial, since the case involved solicitation in confession – one of the graviora delicta (most grave crimes) for which the Congregation had responsibility to investigate and take appropriate action.

Only when it learned that Murphy was dying did the Congregation suggest to Weakland that the canonical trial be suspended, since it would involve a lengthy process of taking testimony from a number of deaf victims from prior decades, as well as from the accused priest. Instead it proposed measures to ensure that appropriate restrictions on his ministry be taken. [NB] Goodstein infers that this action implies “leniency” toward a priest guilty of heinous crimes. [I think he is using "infer" in its meaning of "imply".] My interpretation would be that the Congregation realized that the complex canonical process would be useless if the priest were dying. Indeed, I have recently received an unsolicited letter from the judicial vicar who was presiding judge in the canonical trial telling me that he never received any communication about suspending the trial, and would not have agreed to it. But Fr. Murphy had died in the meantime. As a believer, I have no doubt that Murphy will face the One who judges both the living and the dead.

Goodstein also refers to what she calls “other accusations” about the reassignment of a priest who had previously abused a child/children in another diocese by the Archdiocese of Munich. But the Archdiocese has repeatedly explained that the responsible Vicar General, Mons. Gruber, admitted his mistake in making that assignment. [You decide if the following is a good argument.  I think it is.  Many don’t think so.] It is anachronistic for Goodstein and the Times to imply that the knowledge about sexual abuse that we have in 2010 should have somehow been intuited by those in authority in 1980. It is not difficult for me to think that Professor Ratzinger, appointed as Archbishop of Munich in 1977, would have done as most new bishops do: [NB!] allow those already in place in an administration of 400 or 500 people to do the jobs assigned to them.  [Furthermore, the role of a Vicar General in a German diocese usually involves personnel.]

[…]

From the point of view of ecclesiastical procedures, the explosion of the sexual abuse question in the United States led to the adoption, at a meeting of the Bishops’ Conference in Dallas in 2002, of a “Charter for the Protection of Minors from Sexual Abuse.” This Charter provides for uniform guidelines on reporting sexual abuse, on structures of accountability (Boards involving clergy, religious and laity, including experts), reports to a national Board, and education programs for parishes and schools in raising awareness and prevention of sexual abuse of children. In a number of other countries similar programs have been adopted by Church authorities: one of the first was adopted by the Bishops’ Conference of England and Wales in response to the Nolan Report made by a high-level commission of independent experts in 2001.

It was only in 2001, with the publication of Pope John Paul II’s Motu proprio Sacramentorum Sanctitatis Tutela (SST), that responsibility for guiding the Catholic Church’s response to the problem of sexual abuse of minors by clerics was assigned to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. This papal document was prepared for Pope John Paul II [NB] under the guidance of Cardinal Ratzinger as Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.

Contrary to some media reports, SST did not remove the local bishop’s responsibility for acting in cases of reported sexual abuse of minors by clerics. Nor was it, as some have theorized, part of a plot from on high to interfere with civil jurisdiction in such cases. Instead, SST directs bishops to report credible allegations of abuse to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, which is able to provide a service to the bishops to ensure that cases are handled properly, in accord with applicable ecclesiastical law.

Here are some of the advances made by this new Church legislation (SST). It has allowed for a streamlined administrative process in arriving at a judgment, thus reserving the more formal process of a canonical trial to more complex cases. This has been of particular advantage in missionary and small dioceses that do not have a strong complement of well-trained canon lawyers. It provides for erecting inter-diocesan tribunals to assist small dioceses. The Congregation has faculties allowing it derogate from the prescription of a crime (statute of limitations) in order to permit justice to be done even for “historical” cases. Moreover, SST has amended canon law in cases of sexual abuse to adjust the age of a minor to 18 to correspond with the civil law in many countries today. It provides a point of reference for bishops and religious superiors to obtain uniform advice about handling priests’ cases. Perhaps most of all, it has designated cases of sexual abuse of minors by clerics as graviora delicta: most grave crimes, like the crimes against the sacraments of Eucharist and Penance perennially assigned to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. This in itself has shown the seriousness with which today’s Church undertakes its responsibility to assist bishops and religious superiors to prevent these crimes from happening in the future, and to punish them when they happen. Here is a legacy of Pope Benedict that greatly facilitates the work of the Congregation which I now have the privilege to lead, to the benefit of the entire Church.

[…]

The Times editorial wonders “how Vatican officials did not draw the lessons of the grueling scandal in the United States, where more than 700 priests were dismissed over a three-year period.” I can assure the Times that the Vatican in reality did not then and does not now ignore those lessons. But the Times editorial goes on to show the usual bias: “But then we read Laurie Goodstein’s disturbing report . . .about how the pope, while he was still a cardinal, was personally warned about a priest … But church leaders chose to protect the church instead of children. The report illuminated the kind of behavior the church was willing to excuse to avoid scandal.” Excuse me, editors. Even the Goodstein article, based on “newly unearthed files,” places the words about protecting the Church from scandal on the lips of Archbishop Weakland, not the pope. It is just this kind of anachronistic conflation that I think warrants my accusation that the Times, in rushing to a guilty verdict, lacks fairness in its coverage of Pope Benedict.

As a full-time member of the Roman Curia, the governing structure that carries out the Holy See’s tasks, I do not have time to deal with the Times’s subsequent almost daily articles by Rachel Donadio and others, much less with Maureen Dowd’s silly parroting of Goodstein’s “disturbing report.” [Well said.  I think Mo is a serial scribal truth abuser.]  But about a man with and for whom I have the privilege of working, as his “successor” Prefect, a pope whose encyclicals on love and hope and economic virtue have both surprised us and made us think, whose weekly catecheses and Holy Week homilies inspire us, and yes, whose pro-active work to help the Church deal effectively with the sexual abuse of minors continues to enable us today, I ask the Times to reconsider its attack mode about Pope Benedict XVI and give the world a more balanced view of a leader it can and should count on. 

Do everyone a favor.

Share some of this, and other posts on this and other blogs, about the distortions by the New York Times.  Share this with at least 5 other people.   E-mail some links with a note that, in service of the truth, people need to get a fuller picture of this recent controversy.  Ask them to forward it as well.

We don’t mind the truth coming out, even if it is painful.  We just want it to be the truth.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , , ,
24 Comments

Archbp. Dolan on the New York Times

It’s war between the Times and Archbishop Timothy Dolan of New York.

Archbp. Dolan has posted a strong statement on his blog about the recent mistreatment of the Pope and the Catholic by the New York Times (aka Hell’s Bible).

Among the many good points raised by Archbp. Dolan these are of particular note:

First,…

Last fall I wrote in this blog about anti-Catholicism in the New York Times and other media, providing a list of contemporary examples. A few tried to slap me back into place, suggesting that I stupidly believed the Church to be immune from scrutiny.

Baloney!  The Church needs criticism; we want it; we welcome it; we do a good bit of it ourselves; we do not expect any special treatment…so bring it on.

All we ask is that it be fair and accurate.

The reporting on Pope Benedict XVI has not been so.

Well said.

Farther along, Archbp. Dolan adds with my emphases and comments.

 

Here’s a summary of the key points:

  • The New York Times relied on tort lawyers who currently have civil suits pending against the Archdiocese of Milwaukee and the Holy See, who are aggressively supporting the radical measure right now before the Wisconsin legislature to abrogate the statute of limitations on civil cases of abuse, and who have high financial interest in the matter being reported.  Hardly an impartial source…  [In fact, it seems that there was very little actual investigative journalism done here.  People gave things to the Times.  Think of how certain types of pipes take certain types of things away from your house and into a larger pipe.]
  • The documentation that allegedly supports these sensational charges is published on the website of the New York Times; rather than confirming their theory, the documents instead show that there is no evidence at all that Cardinal Ratzinger ever blocked any decision about Murphy.  Even a New York Times columnist, Ross Douthat, calls this charge “unfair” in his column of March 29.
  • We also find on the website a detailed timeline of all the sickening information about Murphy, data not “uncovered” by any reporter but freely released by the Archdiocese of Milwaukee a number of years back, and thoroughly covered at that time by the local media in Milwaukee.  One wonders why this story, quite exhaustively reported in the past, rose again this very week.  It is hardly “news.” One might therefore ask: Why is this news now? The only reason it is news at all is because of the implication that Cardinal Ratzinger was involved. Yet the documentation does not support that charge, and thus they should have no place in a putatively respectable newspaper.

I am glad that the former Archbishop of Milwaukee, now Archbishop of the city where the New York Times is published, has weighed in.  He is uniquely positioned to raise his voice in protest against the injustice being done to the Pope and the Church in this matter.

I also appreciate that Archbp. Dolan so forcefully confirmed that the Church is in no way afraid of dealing with any cases of harm done to children.  His confirmation resonates with my quote the other day from I, Claudius.  We have to rid ourselves of all the "poisons that lurk in the mud".

WDTPRS sends forceful kudos to Archbishop Dolan.   

I am sure you readers will, along with me say, a prayer for his spiritual support each day as this continues.

You might drop him a note.

 

Posted in Brick by Brick, Our Catholic Identity | Tagged
27 Comments

Bp. DiMarzio (D. Brooklyn) “besiege The New York Times”

There is a press release from the Diocese of Brooklyn about the New York Times’s (aka Hell’s Bible) concerted attacks on Pope Benedict and the Catholic Church.

My emphases and comments.

Bishop DiMarzio Calls Upon the Priests and Parishioners
to Besiege The New York Times

In his homily to the priests and people of the Diocese of Brooklyn, Bishop Nicholas DiMarzio, called upon the priests and people of the Diocese of Brooklyn to stand up with him and “besiege The New York Times.  Send a message loud and clear that the Pope, our Church, and bishops and our priests will no longer be the personal punching bag of The New York Times.”

Bishop DiMarzio’s spirited defense of the Holy Father was based on the decision of The New York Times editors to, “Omit significant facts,” and ignore the reality that the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, which Cardinal Ratzinger headed up, did not have competency over Canonical Trials in 1996.  Moreover, Bishop DiMarzio continued “…the priest in question, Father Murphy was in the midst of a Canonical Trial.  He died before a verdict was rendered.”

Reflecting on the timing of the stories, DiMarzio stated “Two weeks of articles about a story from many decades ago, in the midst of the Most Holy Season of the Church year is both callous and smacks of calumny!”  He continued “This evening, I am asking you to join me making your displeasure known to the editors by letters or emails.”  [Do I hear an "Amen!"?]

[…]

 

Are you going to saddle up?

executive-editor@nytimes.com

Posted in Brick by Brick, Our Catholic Identity | Tagged
25 Comments

“The documents were not written by me and do not resemble my handwriting.”

Just a reminder about how everyone must question the veracity and motives behind all reporting by the New York Times (aka Hell’s Bible).

A few days ago I posted – and many others have now posted – a statement by Fr. Thomas Brundage who was the judicial vicar for the Archdiocese of Milwaukee at the time that the monstrous Fr. Murphy was being tried in an ecclesiastical process.

Fr. Brundage makes some things clear – within the parameters of what he was free to reveal – about the bad reporting of the New York Times and others.  I conclude that the mass media outlets were either abysmally incompetent in their "reporting" or they were intentionally and with malice trying to smear the reputation of the Pope, and the Church, by distorting the information they were given. 

Fr. Brundage posted his own clarifications on CatholicAnchor.org.

Let’s have a look at a section of Fr. Brundage’s clarification.  You have probably read this, but some things bear repetition for the sake of the truth.   With my emphases and comments.

[…]

With regard to the inaccurate reporting on behalf of the New York Times, the Associated Press, and those that utilized these resources, first of all, [NB] I was never contacted by any of these news agencies but they felt free to quote me. Almost all of my quotes are from a document that can be found online with the correspondence between the Holy See and the Archdiocese of Milwaukee. In an October 31, 1997 handwritten document, I am quoted as saying “odds are that this situation may very well be the most horrendous, number wise, and especially because these are physically challenged , vulnerable people.” Also quoted is this: “Children were approached within the confessional where the question of circumcision began the solicitation.”

The problem with these statements attributed to me is that they were handwritten. The documents were not written by me and do not resemble my handwriting. The syntax is similar to what I might have said but I have no idea who wrote these statements, yet I am credited as stating them. As a college freshman at the Marquette University School of Journalism, we were told to check, recheck, and triple check our quotes if necessary. I was never contacted by anyone on this document, written by an unknown source to me. Discerning truth takes time and it is apparent that the New York Times, the Associated Press and others did not take the time to get the facts correct.  [And that is because they are either incompetent or they had a motive.]

Additionally, in the documentation in a letter from Archbishop Weakland to then-secretary of the Vatican’s Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith Archbishop Tarcisio Bertone on August 19, 1998, Archbishop Weakland stated that he [i.e., Archbp. Weakland] had instructed me to abate the proceedings against Father Murphy. [Weakland, not Card. Bertone] […]

Second, with regard to the role of then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger (now Pope Benedict XVI), in this matter, I have no reason to believe that he was involved at all. Placing this matter at his doorstep is a huge leap of logic and information.

Third, the competency to hear cases of sexual abuse of minors shifted from the Roman Rota to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith headed by Cardinal Ratzinger in 2001. Until that time, most appeal cases went to the Rota and it was our experience that cases could languish for years in this court. When the competency was changed to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, in my observation as well as many of my canonical colleagues, sexual abuse cases were handled expeditiously, fairly, and with due regard to the rights of all the parties involved. I have no doubt that this was the work of then Cardinal Ratzinger.

Fourth, Pope Benedict has repeatedly apologized for the shame of the sexual abuse of children in various venues and to a worldwide audience. […]

Finally, over the last 25 years, vigorous action has taken place within the church to avoid harm to children. Potential seminarians receive extensive sexual-psychological evaluation prior to admission. Virtually all seminaries concentrate their efforts on the safe environment for children. There have been very few cases of recent sexual abuse of children by clergy during the last decade or more.

[…]

Father Thomas T. Brundage, JCL

Posted in The Drill, The Last Acceptable Prejudice | Tagged
7 Comments

TO ARMS! WDTPRSers! TO ARMS! MSNBC LIBELS THE POPE

UPDATE:

NBC APOLOGIZES FOR MSNBC’S HIT ON POPE

March 30, 2010

NBC apologized today for an article on MSNBC’s website entitled, “Pope Describes Touching Boys: I Went Too Far.” The article that readers accessed after clicking on it actually had nothing to do with the pope.

Catholic League president Bill Donohue accepted the apology today:

NBC says the attributed quote was erroneous and they have corrected the error. An apology was also extended. The apology is accepted. We hope that whoever was responsible for this outrageous post is questioned about it and that appropriate measures are taken. We look forward to hearing the outcome.

Excellent.

First… say a prayer.

Then, write to the same address of msnbc below to thank them for the correction.

____

ORIGINAL POST
____

From The Catholic League:

March 30, 2010

MSNBC LIBELS THE POPE

Catholic League president Bill Donohue accuses MSNBC of libeling Pope Benedict XVI:

Go to the home page of MSNBC and click on "World News." From there click on "Americas." Next click on the article, "Losing Their Religion? Catholicism in Turmoil." Scroll down and in the "Click for Related Content" section there is an article entitled, "Pope Describes Touching Boys: I Went Too Far." Clicking on this piece takes the reader to an article about a homosexual German priest who had sex with males in the 1980s. It says absolutely nothing about the pope. Yet MSNBC paints Pope Benedict XVI as a child molester in the tease to the article.

A retraction, and a sincere apology, are in order. They should also investigate how this happened and who is responsible.

Contact NBC news president Steve Capus: steve.capus@nbc.com

It may be that, subsequent to the CL post, this has been "corrected".  [See the screenshot detail on this page, below.]
TO ARMS! WDTPRSers! TO ARMS! MSNBC LIBELS THE POPE
But is this adequate?  I don’t think so.

They seem to have changed the headline. 

But I think what they did was malicious.  Look at the other headlines.

Changing the headline was a start, but I think an apology is needed as well.

Even if they think that changing the headline should be the end of it, I suggest that it is not.

Contact NBC news president Steve Capus: steve.capus@nbc.com

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
70 Comments

If enough people stop believing in hell, maybe it’ll cease to exist. No?

Last week I gave a parish mission on the Four Last Things.

As some of you readers might guess, I placed certain emphases on the existence of hell and desirability if avoiding it.

This comes from the acceptable weekly National Catholic REGISTER with my emphases and comments.

As I read, I had in mind the image of a person who covers his own eyes and announces, "You can’t seeeeee meeeee!"

Hell Is Not Hot
 
by Pat Archbold Tuesday, March 30, 2010

I have heard it said that when a baby closes its eyes, it perceives the entire world has gone away rather than just their ability to perceive it.  I have often wondered how scientists can know such a thing, but I think that now I know.  They must have witnessed this same behavior in adults and merely extrapolated backwards.

Case in point, Newsweek’s religion [just how bad is this magazine, anyway?] editor LIf enough people stop believing in hell, maybe it'll cease to exist. No?isa Miller has a new book out on Heaven and the various different notions of it.  In an interview with [Washington Post writer] Sally Quinn, Miller is asked whether she believes in Hell, to which she replies with an emphatic “no.”  Asked why, she cites the dwindling polls numbers for hell.  Hell is not hot right now.  [?!?]

Of course, we know that reality is not altered by poll numbers.  President Obama’s poll numbers have likely fallen faster than hell’s, but he is no less real than when most believed in him back in November 2008.

It seems that some people believe that if enough people ditch belief in Hell, that perhaps Hell will be closed for lack of interest.  No such luck.

The Church teaches the existence of hell because Jesus taught the existence of hell.

    [Catechism of the Catholic Church] 1034 Jesus often speaks of “Gehenna” of “the unquenchable fire” reserved for those who to the end of their lives refuse to believe and be converted, where both soul and body can be lost.  Jesus solemnly proclaims that he “will send his angels, and they will gather . . . all evil doers, and throw them into the furnace of fire,“and that he will pronounce the condemnation: “Depart from me, you cursed, into the eternal fire!”

I would be interested to see how the poll numbers would change if the question changed. [good point]  Instead of “Do you believe in hell?” how about if we asked “Do you believe that all people, no matter what they did in life, go to heaven?”  If you asked them whether Hitler was in heaven, I suspect that the numbers would look drastically different. Most people, I suspect, would exclude Hitler from residency in heaven (whether or not God has is a different question). So, if Hitler is not in Heaven, where is he?  The larger question, I suppose, is “what is not heaven?”  The catechism answers that question as well saying “the chief punishment of hell is eternal separation from God.”  [The horror of the "pain of loss".] In other words, not heaven is Hell, to be separated from God forever.

I would suspect that in any society throughout history that Hell’s polling numbers are inversely proportional to the virtue of that society.  In our society, sin polls well.  You can do the math.  Yet I think that when thrown into the everlasting fire, having poll numbers on your side will be of little comfort.

Consider the shock of the soul finding itself in hell. 

Try to imagine the first 15 seconds.

Go to confession, often, and be sure you can explain the Four Last Things.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
36 Comments

WDTPRS – Tuesday of Holy Week – COLLECT

COLLECT (2002MR):
Omnipotens sempiterne Deus,
da nobis ita dominicae passionis sacramenta peragere,
ut indulgentiam percipere mereamur.

This prayer was in the 1962MR on Tuesday of Holy Week.  It was in the Hadrianum and Paduenese of the ancient Gregorian Sacramentary for the same day, when the Station is at Santa Prisca.  So, it seems that today we have a prayer which cutters and snippers of the Novus Ordo didn’t "improve".  They left it on the same day as it had always been, and didn’t change or cut out any words.

The verb perago means, according to the dark blue bound Lewis & Short Dictionary, in its fundamental sense “to thrust through, pierce through, transfix”.   It can then come to mean by logical extension “to drive about, harass, disturb, disquiet, agitate, annoy a person or thing”.  However, in our context here, it is probably “to carry through, go through with, execute, finish, accomplish, complete”.    However, I ought to reminder readers and even comment posters this blog, as well as myself, that mentio non fit expositio as one of my old profs used to shout.  I cut now to the chase with Blaise/Dumas  who says perago is “célébrer” as in “célébrer les mystères de la Passion du Seigneur”.

The verb percipio is “to take wholly, to seize entirely”.  Often when you see a prepositional prefix per on verbs, you get an intensification of the concept of the verb.  At the same time percipio is “to perceive, observe” and “to feel” and “to learn, know, conceive, comprehend, understand, perceive”.    Blaise/Dumas gives us “recevoir (l’eucharistie)”.  I think this gets us close to the meaning for our prayer. 
 
LITERAL VERSION
Almighty everlasting God,
grant us so to celebrate the mysteries of the Lord’s Passion,
that we may merit to receive pardon.

The words peragere and percipere underscore the intensity with which we ought to participate in the sacred mysteries especially during this Holy Week.  The per prefix suggests to us a thoroughness of our participation, the one per leading to the other per through the connect of the ita… ut.   The peragere is an invitation to us to participate in the mysteries of Holy Week in a way that is “full, conscious and active”, especially in the interior sense.  In this way we can more completely grasp in all senses of that word what the Lord has to offer to us. 

The Second Person of the Trinity took up our human nature and came into this world to reveal man more fully to himself (Gaudium et spes 22).  Our participation in the sacred mysteries at all times of the year help us to grasp and perceive many things.  We learn about ourselves, we learn about the magnalia Dei, we grasp and perceive the fruits and graces of the Eucharist and the other sacraments, we deepen our grasp of the content of the Faith.  The content is both things we can learn and contemplate and, more deeply, the divine Person of the Lord Himself. 

One of the most important things we grasp, as our prayer reminds us, is pardon for our many and black sins which merit hell.  By improving of our grasp on Christ, and allowing His grasp on us, His merit becomes our merit and thus we can receive the saving pardon He grasped for us on the Cross.

LAME-DUCK ICEL VERSION:
Father,
may we receive your forgiveness and mercy
as we celebrate the passion and death of the Lord
.

No.  Really.  It is.

It might be a good idea to meditate a bit on the 1 Cor 11:29-31, in which Paul talks about “discerning” the Body and Blood of the Lord before our reception.  The Greek verb diakrino for “discern” doesn’t quite match in exact meaning the force of percipio but there is a conceptual connection between discerning verbs.  In any event, this verse came to mind and it is good to examine ourselves carefully in this regard.

Posted in WDTPRS |
3 Comments

Is it time simply to cancel your NCR subscriptions?

Is it time simply to cancel your NCR subscriptions?If any of you have a subscription to the ultra-liberal dissenting – dying – National Catholic Reporter I suggest that you cancel it now. 

Urge your parish’s pastor to cancel as well.  Get it out of our churches.

Take a look at the beginning of this piece:

Church reformers have second thoughts on pope
Mar. 30, 2010
By Jeff Diamant, Religion News Service  [Jeff Diamant writes for The Star-Ledger in Newark, N.J.]

To many advocates of reform in the Catholic church, the election of conservative Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger as pope in April 2005 was a blow to hopes the Vatican would change positions on gender, sexuality, divorce, and the church hierarchy.

Yet the result encouraged three prominent reformers who were appointed to a U.S. bishops’ National Review Board. The three American Catholics — a judge, an attorney and a newspaper publisher — were concerned mainly with the clergy sex scandal.

They had met with Ratzinger in his Vatican office in 2004 for an extensive discussion on the cover-ups of clergy sex abuse of children, and came to view Ratzinger as the best churchman anywhere on the issue. A year later, when he became Pope Benedict XVI, they were often quoted praising him in American news articles.

But that was then.

[…]

 

The rest of the piece trashes Pope Benedict.

They embrace the New York Times position and agenda.

And they trash him in their editorial while staging a spittle-flecked nutty.

Read what the hysterics wrote:

We now face the largest institutional crisis in centuries, possibly in church history. How this crisis is handled by Benedict, what he says and does, how he responds and what remedies he seeks, will likely determine the future health of our church for decades, if not centuries, to come.

The sad thing is that they want this.  This is their big chance.

It is hard to justify even wrapping fish in this.

Cancel now.

I want clarity and answers too.  I think that if there are more cases of sexual abuse of children by priests that are lurking in the mud, they need to be brought out and dealt with in justice and in truth. 

The Church has to be cleansed of this.  It will be painful.  We will be beaten up by the Enemy while it goes on.

But the NCR is using the present crisis to attack the Holy Father.  They are trying to damage this pontificate.

Cancel it.

Just cancel it.

Posted in Throwing a Nutty, Wherein Fr. Z Rants | Tagged
34 Comments

wholistic spirituality wholeness can be yours

In the paper of the Archdiocese of Los Angeles, site of the Three Days of Darkness… er um… the 2010 "Catholic" "Education" Congress there is a wrap up of precious moments from their gatherings.

Here is a taste.

Sunday morning keynote speaker, Sister of Notre Dame de Namur Barbara Fiand, [once prohibited from teaching seminarians at the Athenaeum in Ohio, the head of her community signed the infamous sell-out letter] speaking on "Harnessing for God the Energies of Love," told how the writings of the late Jesuit mystic and scientist Teilhard de Chardin are being supported by recent scientific research in the fields of biology and astro physics showing the interconnectedness of all matter.

"We today are beginning to see the world in which we live not as dead matter, detached and indifferent to us, but as a highly complex, interconnected, living and conscious reality," she said. [My desk lamp is unimpressed.]

"Some extraordinary research has shown us that both plants and animals have much more sophisticated conscious life than we have ever given them credit for," said Sister Fiand, who noted that a study using lie detecting equipment hooked up to leaves shows that plants emotionally react to crisis situations, such as the destruction of an adjacent plant.  [OH NO!! SAY IT AIN’T SO!  Don’t eat plants! Or animals!]

"The quantum worldview that’s emerging in our time transcends the [dualistic] split between mind and matter and sees both as interconnected and rooted in the heart of creation…. [this] worldview is wholistic and the spirituality that grows out of this perspective speaks to the wholeness both within ourselves and the larger, global community of nations, cultures, religions, life and love."

Teilhard, she explained, said the cosmic energy that is in all things is love and that this love story in the universe has now reached a self-reflective awareness in humanity. The Jesuit described creation as looking at us and asking, "Will you love?" [?]

"We are called to be shepherds of this earth and of all the creatures that dwell there," said Sister Fiand. " [I wonder if the other apples were annoyed when that woman took the first bite.  I bet the animals God slew to make garments of skins were annoyed.] …Knowing that everyone is interconnected with you – that I believe is harnessing for God the energies of love. And, with this kind of awakening within each one of us, [we will experience] once again the creativity and the energy that the discovery of fire brought to our ancestors long ago. We are children of light. Let us embrace it and live by its power."

 

I must ask my pet rock about all this.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , ,
53 Comments

WDTPRS POLL: Who is to blame for the present crisis?

Over at His Hermeueticalness’s place I picked up a video from Michael Voris.

Watch this and then take the POLL.

Play video

Okay…. now that you have watched that, here is a WDTPRS poll.

Make your best choice.  Feel free to give your reasons in the combox.

Voting in the poll is entirely anonymous.

{democracy:49}

Posted in POLLS |
72 Comments