Great Minds Think Alike: The Pope of Christian Unity

I just had a note from a rather distinguished reader of WDTPRS alerting me to something that appeared in today’s Wall Street Journal. 

BTW… there is a POLL on that page, but you have to search for it.

He wrote: Next to its article titled "For the Vatican, New Resolve to Expand the Catholic Fold", the WSJ captioned a picture of Pope Benedict with "The Great Unifier?"

Here is some of that WSJ piece with my emphases and comments.

Great Minds Think Alike: The Pope of Christian UnityFor the Vatican, New Resolve to Expand the Catholic Fold

By STACY MEICHTRY

ROME — Long regarded as a hard-liner on religious doctrine, Pope Benedict XVI also is emerging as the pontiff of interchurch, or ecumenical, relations.  [Sounds right.  This is the Pope of Christian Unity.]

The 82-year-old pope’s decision Tuesday to amend Vatican laws to make it easier for Anglicans to become Roman Catholic represents his most aggressive attempt to bring more Christians into the Catholic fold.  [Again, this was an overture also in response to Anglican initiatives.]

The pope’s outreach to rival churches has spanned the conservative-liberal spectrum. He has bolstered dialogue with Lutherans and other mainline Protestants. [liberals] He met with the Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew I of Constantinople, regarded by some as the spiritual leader of Eastern Orthodox Churches. And he lifted an excommunication ban on the highly conservative Catholic splinter group Society of St. Pius X.  [conservatives]

Few expected Pope Benedict to reach out to other Christian churches aggressively [there it is again… makes it sound like the Anschluss.] when he was elected in April 2005. Yet the rise of secularism among European Christians and the expansion of Islam on the Continent in recent decades have influenced thinking within Vatican corridors. In addition, this pope considers divisions among rival Christian churches as a threat to Roman Catholicism’s credibility in the market of ideas and faiths, according to Vatican analysts and advisers to the pope.

"Anyone who thought he wasn’t serious about ecumenical dialogue was seriously mistaken," said the Rev. Joseph Fessio, one of Pope Benedict’s former students whom he occasionally consults.

Yet some Christians don’t view Pope Benedict’s latest move as an ecumenical gesture, and they warn that it risks derailing decades of formal dialogue between the Vatican and Anglican leaders.  [This is exactly the point I was making HERE.]

…

You can read the rest there.

Remember: Benedict XVI is the Pope of Christian Unity.

He has the correct ecumenical vision.  A true ecumenism does not compromise essentials of our faith and identity even while it challenges us to stretch.

Posted in Our Catholic Identity, POLLS, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
32 Comments

Whose ecumenism?

Liberals are beginning to twit.

They are just warming up, but soon it will be a grand mal twit.

They are panicking about Pope Benedict and his provisions for Anglicans who, after their long nightmare with liberal on their side of the Tiber, may want unity in the Catholic Church.

Be alert.

The liberal Catholics will try to pull a sleight of hand.  They will attempt to get you to believe that what Pope Benedict is doing is not true ecumenism. 

They will claim to be the sole arbiters of true ecumenism.

They will claim that conservative Catholics, traditional Catholics are not interested in true ecumenism.

Do not accept their definition or their premises.

I want to invite all you readers into a project.  

My idea is that we should start to refer to Pope Benedict XVI as …

… the Pope of Christian Unity.

It becomes clearer each year that Benedict goes beyond his immediate predecessors, but always in continuity with them, in promoting Christian unity.

His efforts in this direction can be seen on several fronts:

1) with the Orthodox in general, and the Russian Orthodox in particular;
2) with the SSPX;
3) with the Anglicans.

I can hear it now.

"But Father! But Father!", my liberal readers will say, squirming. "Pope Benedict’s efforts with the SSPX and with the Anglican trads are not really about ‘Christian unity’!  They aren’t even endorsed by many high-ranking Catholic prelates or conspicuous newspaper theologians!"

Exactly.

That is precisely why Pope Benedict is preeminently the Pope of Christian Unity.

Pope Benedict has been struggling against forces within his own fold to achieve Christian unity.  

His is decidedly not the unity that liberals (Richard McBrien, Gerald O’Collins) have in mind when they think of Christian unity, with its watered-down version of Roman primacy, liturgy, catechesis, sexual ethics and church discipline. In other words, a Christian unity without a Christian identity (christian with a small ‘c’).

No, Benedict’s unity is real unity, true unity that costs something, that stretches people, but that does not compromise what is essential to the Church.

This is not Rahner’s "world church" where anything and anyone goes.  It is the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church founded by Christ Jesus.

Benedict’s true ecumenism is consonant with everything we are as a Church. 

People are going to be stretched, but absolutely nothing essential will be given away.

You see where I am going with this.

Liberals want ecumenism only with those whom they want in their sort of church.

They want ecumenical dialogue with those who agree with the manifestos of, for example, the Leadership Conference of Women Religious.

But true ecumenism is not about compromise on essentials, giving away fundamental elements of our Catholic identity.

True ecumenism requires that we be stretched, to be sure, but that we submit.  We stretch, but we give nothing essential away.

The liberal model of ecumenism gives nearly anything for the sake of bringing in their sort of compromised Christian.

Pope Benedict is the true ecumenist.

He is the Pope of Christian Unity.

Posted in Ecclesiae unitatem, Our Catholic Identity, Pope of Christian Unity, SESSIUNCULA, The future and our choices, What are they REALLY saying? | Tagged
72 Comments

The Anglican Anschluss?

The Times has a piece by their religion writer Ruth Gledhill about the Anglican Provisions being offered by Rome.

My emphases and comments.

From The Times
October 21, 2009
Desperate bishops invited Rome to park its tanks on Archbishop’s lawn

by Ruth Gledhill

Rome has parked its tanks on the Archbishop of Canterbury’s lawn after manoeuvres undertaken by up to fifty bishops and begun two years ago by an Australian archbishop, John Hepworth.  [She makes it sound like the Anschluss.]

As leader of the Traditional Anglican Communion, a breakaway group claiming to represent up to 400,000 laity worldwide, he went to Rome seeking a means to achieve full, visible unity for his flock.

As a former Catholic priest himself, divorced and remarried with three children, he would be unlikely to be recognised by Rome as a priest or bishop, [d’ya think?] even under the structures brought in by the new apostolic constitution. He has nonetheless always received a warm welcome in Rome — in particular from Cardinal William Levada, Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, who has made the running in Rome with the backing of his predecessor at the Congregation, Pope Benedict XVI himself.

In England, negotiations with the Vatican have been led by two of the “flying bishops” [I love that term.  I can picture these guys, with those old leather cap and goggles… somewhere in the background someone is turning the crank on the motor of the biplane.   The "flying bishop" sets that sherry glass down on the silver tray in the hands of an aide, flicks the white silk scarf around his neck, and with a look of resolve looks up at the sky as the engine cough its way into smoky life… ]  — the AngloCatholics sanctioned to provide pastoral care for opponents of the ordination of women as priests. The Bishop of Ebbsfleet, [gotta love that] the Right Rev Andrew Burnham, and the Bishop of Richborough, the Right Rev Keith Newton, visited Rome at Easter last year for talks with Cardinal Levada.

Then in July last year Cardinal Levada wrote to Archbishop Hepworth assuring him and his flock “of the serious attention which the Congregation gives to the prospect of corporate unity” and promising that “as soon as the Congregation is in a position to respond more definitively concerning the proposals you have sent, we will inform you”.

Later that month, the by now desperate flying bishops appealed again to Rome for help. The General Synod of the Church of England had voted to consecrate women bishops without providing statutory protection for traditionalists. A synod revision committee overturned that this month, but too late to shut the gate.

At the start of this year Vatican sources began predicting that the announcement of some form of accommodation for Anglicans was close. But it never came, and less optimistic Anglicans assumed the whole thing was no more than a puff of grey smoke. [From the engine of that biplane.]

They dismissed the hopes of the traditionalists too soon. The reason for the delay was twofold.

Within the Vatican City’s frescoed ceilings and marbled corridors, in the Curia itself and in particular in the College of Cardinals, there were — and there remain — deep divisions about the appropriate response to Anglicans and former Anglicans seeking some form of corporate unity.

The liberals, among them [wait for it!] Cardinal Cormac Murphy-O’Connor, who at the time was Archbishop of Westminster, were reluctant to open the door wide to the traditionalists, partly because of their “more Roman than the Romans” style of churchmanship, but also for fear of upsetting Anglicans and the Church of England in particular. [And his own legacy?]

In the US, where a similar “Anglican usage” model has been in operation for years and will now be incorporated into the new ordinariate structures, there are 77 million Catholics alongside a mere 1.8 million Episcopalians. A few incoming conservative Anglicans have made little difference.  [But a whole bunch more just might!  And they can have seminaries.]

In England and Wales, the proportions are reversed, with 25 million baptised Anglicans but four million Catholics. Not only would a big influx of traditionalist ex-Anglicans undermine ecumenical harmony, it could challenge the identity of the Catholic community itself.  [Right!  They might make the English Catholic Church even more Roman!] Set against this, however, is the more confident American-style Catholicism that this initiative represents.

And while the shortage of Catholic priests would be alleviated by the influx of so many Anglicans, the acceptance of married clergy with families would inevitably shift the focus to a questioning of the insistence that cradle-Catholic priests be celibate.  [Maybe for a little while.]

The Orthodox Church, with which the Pope is also desperate to achieve unity, does not demand a celibate priesthood although its bishops cannot marry. Celibacy is a requirement that is becoming increasingly hard to justify.  [Interesting.]

So it seemed as though nothing would happen. But in May, with the retirement of Cardinal MurphyO’Connor, who is in Rome this week, Archbishop Vincent Nichols was installed as his successor.

Archbishop Nichols is a priest in the same mould as the late Cardinal Basil Hume, who led the moves to welcome in opponents of women priests back in 1994. It was predicted then that 1,000 would go but in the end a mere 441 took the financial compensation package on offer. A priest of remarkable charisma, Archbishop Nichols could easily end up in a senior position in Rome himself, if not the most senior.  [ROFL!  Papabile?  ROFL!]

He was clearly “in charge” at the joint press conference at the Catholic Church’s Eccleston Square administrative offices yesterday, at one point interrupting to answer a question addressed to the Archbishop of Canterbury. He appears to have no compunctions about unsettling a few Anglicans.  [nice!]

Many Catholics believe that their churches and cathedrals were “stolen” from them at the Reformation and want them back.  [Count me among them.  After all… they were stolen!]

Although the established status of the Church of England means this could never be a straightforward process, Rome’s new move undercuts all that by allowing for unity to evolve upwards organically, from the grass roots, as forseen by an ecumenical report produced a few years ago.

The Anglican Anschluss?Every church leader speaks about unity, but they all want it on their terms. Pope Benedict XVI is the first since the Reformation who seems to have hit on a realistic way of turning the clock back by moving it forwards.  [Which is exactly what he did with Summorum Pontificum.  It is called continuity.  Analogy: Think of the movie African Queen.  Consider the case faced by Kate and Humphrey, or "Rose" and "Charile".  They are stuck on a river after going over rapids The propeller is damaged.  They must fix the prop so that they can go faster than the water current.  If they are not able to go faster than the current, they won’t be able to steer the boat. The current will sweep them to their doom.  Without a working engine and prop, you either crash on the rocks or, as Charlie must, you drag the boat by a rope and get leeches all over you.  And who wants that?  "But Father! But Father!" you are surely saying in exasperation.  "What does this have to do with anything in the Church?  The propeller of the boat is the very last part of the boat.  It is simultaneously your connection to the past as it impels you into the future.  With a propeller, you can steer a course.  Without it you are doomed.  You must keep moving to remain alive and come through safely to your desired port.  It is your connection to the past that allows you to chart your future course.  To move the clock forward, you turn it back.]

As evangelicals defect in one direction and traditionalists in the other, and disestablishment beckons with the reform of the House of Lords, the Archbishop of Canterbury faces being left with a dwindling number of liberals in the centre struggling to maintain a heritage of ancient, Grade I listed churches.  [Hey!  We can send the Anglicans a whole bunch more!]

Church-sharing already takes place between Catholics, Anglicans, Methodists, the Orthodox and others. The Catholic Church could, through its new Anglican ordinariate, find itself repossessing its churches, almost by default.  [I’d be happy to take one.]

There was bewilderment yesterday among Anglicans as they struggled to make sense of Rome’s initiative.

It was left to the National Secular Society to say publicly what many Anglicans would only admit privately. “This is a mortal blow to Anglicanism which will inevitably lead to disestablishment as the Church shrinks yet further and become increasingly irrelevant,” it said. “Rowan Williams has failed dismally in his ambitions to avoid schism. His refusal to take a principled moral stand against bigotry has left his Church in tatters.”

In the meantime, also in The Times…

Hundreds of Anglican clergy who oppose women bishops are meeting this weekend to discuss whether to abandon the Church of England for the Roman Catholic church.

About 500 members of Forward in Faith, the leading traditionalist grouping, will be in London to debate Pope Benedict XVI’s offer of an Anglican “ordinariate” or diocese to operate under a new Apostolic Constitution.

Many are waiting for the publication of a Code of Practice by Rome to flesh out the detail of what is on offer before deciding whether to go.

More than 440 took the compensation package on offer and left the Church of England, most for Rome, after the General Synod voted to ordain women priests in 1992. Some subsequently returned.

The Pope has made it it significantly more attractive for Anglicans to move over this time by allowing them to retain crucial aspects of their Anglican identity and allowing them to set up seminaries which will, presumably, train married men for the Catholic priesthood.  [Maybe not.]

But any serving clergyman would face a marked loss of income.  [This is a fairly big issue.  Some of these guys have families.]

A job as a clergyman in the Church of England comes with a stipend of £22,250 and free accommodation. Catholic priests earn about £8,000, paid by their parish and sometimes topped up by a diocese.

The Archbishop of Canterbury Dr Rowan Williams indicated there will be no compensation package on offer this time. It was only introduced at the last minute previously as a way of getting the whole women’s ordination package through the General Synod with the necessary two-thirds majorities.

Dr Michael Nazir-Ali, the former Catholic who retired earlier this year as the Church of England’s Bishop of Rochester, today welcomed the Roman Catholic Church’s “generosity of spirit” its recognition of Anglican patrimony.

But he made clear that many issues needed to be resolved before decisions about leaving could be made.

“Orthodox Anglicans should see this recognition of patrimony by another church as affirming the elements of apostolicity and catholicity in their own church, for which they have always stood.

“In the meantime, there is a need to build confidence in the evangelical basis of the Anglican tradition and to make sure that it survives and flourishes in the face of the many challenges it faces. However, before some fundamental issues are clarified it is difficult to respond further to what the Vatican is offering.”

The two “flying bishops” appointed by the Archbishop of Canterbury to care for opponents of women priests also said this was not a time for “sudden decisions”.  [Yah… because dithering has really helped in the past.]

Bishop of Ebbsfleet Andrew Burnham and Bishop of Richborough Keith Newton, who went last year to Rome to begin talks with the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, said: “Anglicans in the Catholic tradition understandably will want to stay within the Anglican Communion. Others will wish to make individual arrangements as their conscience directs.

“A further group of Anglicans, we think, will begin to form a caravan, rather like the People of Israel crossing the desert in search of the Promised Land.” [But… without the Ark or Moses.]

They suggested February 22 next year, the Feast of The Chair of Peter, as an appropriate day for priests and people “to make an initial decision as to whether they wish to respond positively to and explore further the initiative of the Apostolic Constitution”.

 

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA, The Drill | Tagged , ,
58 Comments

Details about the new Compendium Eucharisticum

Some more detailed news about the new Compendium Eucharisticum:

Contrary to news reports the Compendium was published in Latin not Italian. 

Also, …

  1. It is divided into 3 sections: doctrinal, liturgical, and devotional. 
  2. It has number of appendices: Book IV of the Imitation; section of 1983 Latin Code; section of 1990 Eastern Code on the Eucharist.
  3. The preface is by the Prefect of the Cong. for Divine Worship, Card. Canizares.  It clearly speaks of both forms of the Roman Rite being of equal importance.
  4. The doctrinal section contains excerpts from the the decree of the Council of Trent on the Eucharist; Vatican II; the Compendium of the Catechism on the Eucharist; a commentary on the Four Eucharist prayers.
  5. The liturgical section contains the Ordo Missae of the Novus Ordo; the Ordo Missae of the 1962 Missale Romanum; the Office of Corpus Christi from the Liturgia Horarum; the complete Office for Coprus Christi from the 1961 Breviarium Romanum; two Votive Masses of the Holy Eucharist; the Order of Benediction of the Blessed Sacrament; 7 Litanies; and a number of Eucharistic hymns.
  6. The devotional part contains the prayers before Mass, the prayers after Mass, vesting prayers for the priest and for the bishop, and other devotional prayers.

Posted in Brick by Brick | Tagged
14 Comments

Manual for proper celebration of the Mass officially presented to the Pope

No… it isn’t a clarification of Novus Ordo rubrics.  Nor is it a copy of the 1962 Missale Romanum.

From CNA:

Manual for proper celebration of the Mass officially presented to the Pope

Vatican City, Oct 21, 2009 / 01:38 pm (CNA).- Cardinal Antonio Canizares, Prefect of the Congregation for the Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, today officially presented Pope Benedict XVI with the “Compendium eucharisticum,” aimed at helping priests to properly celebrate Mass.

The compendium, which was officially published on October 19, is a collection of study materials, prayers and meditations related to the celebration of the Eucharist. According to Cardinal Canizares, it is “a response to the desire of the Holy Father and the request made by the bishops during the 2005 Synod on the Eucharist.”

According to the daily edition of L’Osservatore Romano, the document “puts together texts from the Catechism of the Catholic Church, prayers, theological explanations of the Roman Missal’s Eucharistic prayers and everything that may be useful for the correct understanding, celebration and adoration of the Sacrament on the altar.”

L’Osservatore Romano also explained that the Pope’s desire is that the compendium will help both priests and laity in “believing, celebrating and increasingly living out the Eucharistic Mystery.” The Holy Father also hopes that it will stimulate “every faithful person to make of their own lives a spiritual worship,” the paper added.

The compendium has been published in Italian by the Vatican’s publishing house and will soon be available in other languages, including English.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
16 Comments

NB: New book in Italian on liturgy

On the Italian site of ZENIT there is a note about a new book, in Italian, concerned with liturgy by Fr. Mauro Gagliardi dal titolo “Liturgia fonte di vita. Prospettive teologiche” (Fede & Cultura) – "Liturgy – source of life: theological perspectives/outlooks.  Fr. Gagliardi is a priest of the Archdiocese of Salerno, ordained in 1999.  He is a consultor for the Office of Pontifical Ceremonies.

A good sign is that the excellent Secretary of the Congregation for Clergy, Archbp. Mauro Piacenza, wrote the preface.

The ZENIT piece includes an interview.  The topic of the TLM comes up as well as the poll indicating that 2 of 3 people would attend the older form of Mass at least once a month if it were made available.

I don’t have time to translate the piece for you now, but perhaps someone will dig into it and I will be able to put up parts of it here for your edification and discussion.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , ,
Comments Off on NB: New book in Italian on liturgy

REVIEW: Prayer Crusade for Priests (Angelus Press)

I received from Angelus Press a small book I want to bring to your attention.

This little book contains prayers in support of priests.  A very good thing to have during this Year for Priests.

REVIEW: Prayer Crusade for Priests (Angelus Press)

Inside you kind prayers and also classic devotions tailored for the intentions of priests.

REVIEW: Prayer Crusade for Priests (Angelus Press)

In the back there are a few pages where you could write the names of priests for whom you are praying.

REVIEW: Prayer Crusade for Priests (Angelus Press)

This is a very fine little book.

Perhaps you could get some copies and distribute them.

This book seems also to have been published in connection with, as the title suggests, a "Prayer Crusade for Priests", which people can join using a form included in the back.

Posted in REVIEWS, Year of Priests | Tagged ,
5 Comments

Proselytizing?

Proselytize is a bad word these days.

A lot off people are rushing to say that the Holy Father’s Anglican Provisions is not a matter of sheep stealing or, as Card. Kaspar put it “fishing in the Anglican lake”.

Card. Kaspar was stupendously conspicuous at the press conference yesterday – by his absence.

Archbishop Nichols of Westminster said: “This is a response and not an initiative.”

I respond saying: If we open up the door, hang up the open sign, and turn on the lights, we are inviting people to come in.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged ,
45 Comments

Gathering Leaves

Biretta tip to the Laudator

Robert Frost, Gathering Leaves:

    Spades take up leaves
    No better than spoons,
    And bags full of leaves
    Are light as balloons.

    I make a great noise
    Of rustling all day
    Like rabbit and deer
    Running away.

    But the mountains I raise
    Elude my embrace,
    Flowing over my arms
    And into my face.

    I may load and unload
    Again and again
    Till I fill the whole shed,
    And what have I then?

    Next to nothing for weight,
    And since they grew duller
    From contact with earth,
    Next to nothing for color.

    Next to nothing for use.
    But a crop is a crop,
    And who’s to say where
    The harvest shall stop?

Posted in Poetry | Tagged ,
2 Comments

KC Bp. Finn – Priesthood Sunday in the Year For Priests

A reader alerted me to this from the upcoming edition of The Catholic Key:

October 25: Priesthood Sunday in the Year For Priests
By Most Rev. Robert W. Finn
Bishop of Kansas City – St. Joseph

We have in our Diocese of Kansas City-St. Joseph quite a number of fine folks actively engaged as members of the Serra Clubs. Founded under the patronage of Blessed Junipero Serra, the Franciscan Friar who founded the missions in California, these clubs have as their focus the promotion of vocations to the priesthood and Religious life, and the prayerful support of priests, sisters, brothers, and seminarians. Several local Serra clubs meet in different parts of the diocese, and they do so much to encourage our clergy and Religious. Recently in what has become an annual event, Serra and many others, hosted the Priest and Seminarian Appreciation Golf Tournament and dinner. They honored our priests from KCSJ, and our neighbor, the Archdiocese of Kansas City, Kansas. It was clear to all of our priests that these good friends really do care about them.

Read more…

Posted in Year of Priests | Tagged
1 Comment