Philly: building choirs for a TLM

From a reader:

Beginning on October 25,2009, weekly sung Traditional Latin Mass will be celebrated at 12 noon at St. Paul Church in South Philadelphia on Christian Street between 9th and 10th Streets.  St. Paul Parish is forming a mixed choir and a men’s schola cantorum to perform under the direction of Dr. Robert Hall, music director for the traditional liturgy.  Interested singers should demonstrate familiarity with musical notation and sight singing and the men of the schola should demonstrate familiarity with traditional chant notation.  Weekly duties will include preparation of the chant "propers" from the Roman Gradual (men’s Schola) as well as music to be sung by the mixed choir including the Mass "ordinary", chants, motets, and appropriate hymns.  Interested singers should contact Dr. Robert Hall directly … by e-mail at:  headdoc50 {AT] aol {DoT} com for more information. Thank you.

Posted in Brick by Brick, SESSIUNCULA, The Campus Telephone Pole | Tagged
1 Comment

“Caritas in veritate” is now available in LATIN

The Latin text of the Holy Father’s encyclical Caritas in veritate is now available in LATIN on the Vatican website.

PROOEMIUM

1. Caritas in veritate, quam sua terrestri vita ac potissimum suam per mortem et resurrectionem testificatus est Iesus Christus, praecipua est vis, quae verum in omnibus humanis personis universaque humanitate producit progressum. Amor – « caritas » – magna est vis quae personas impellit ut animose studioseque in iustitiae ac pacis provincia agant. Est quidem vis, quae a Deo principium sumit, Amore sane aeterno absolutaque Veritate. Unusquisque suum bonum reperit, Dei de se accipiens consilium, ut in plenitudine perficiatur: hoc in consilio suam veritatem is invenit atque huic veritati adhaerens fit liber (cfr Io 8, 32). Cum quis veritatem tuetur eandemque humiliter certeque in vita testatur, caritatis rationes impellentes praebet, quae substitui non possunt. Ipsa « congaudet autem veritati » (1 Cor 13, 6). Homines universi ad vere amandum ex animo impelluntur: amor perinde ac veritas eos numquam plane deserunt, quandoquidem vocationem prae se ferunt, quam Deus in cuiusque hominis corde menteque posuit. Mundat Iesus Christus et a nostris paupertatibus humanis amorem et veritatem conquirendam abducit atque in plenitudine amoris voluntatem vitaeque verae propositum ostendit, quod pro nobis comparavit Deus. In Christo caritas in veritate Vultus fit eius Personae, vocatio fit nobis ad nostros fratres in veritate eius propositi diligendos. Etenim Ipse Veritas est (cfr Io 14, 6).

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , ,
5 Comments

Sr. Joan and the Usual Suspects

Just when you think the dissidents can’t veer farther into fantasy comes this knee slapper from Sr. Joan and the Usual Suspects.

Notice how I don’t even have to give her last name or the name of the publication?

She compares the unnatural urge for women’s ordination to Ghandi’s salt making revolution.

The catalyst for this was the sad affair of Cincinnati Sister of Charity Louise Akers, which we have read about here.

Savor the reasoning of Sr. Joan and the Usual Suspects:

"As they march in silent ranks to the shore, the Indians are met head on by hundreds and hundreds of British colonial police — many of them Indians themselves — clubs and muskets in hand, who systematically beat every rank of unarmed demonstrators to the ground. But the ranks never stop coming. One after another they come, row after row of them. Beating after beating after beating, they walk over one another in ordered formation into the butt of British rifles, certain of their personhood, sure of their cause, convinced of its right."

Get it?  Get it?

The Pope and bishops are to these noble women what the colonial dictators with their thuggish police and military were to the oppressed freedom seeking Indians.

Remember: we are talking here about the infallible teaching of the Church, namely, that the Church has no authority to ordain women.

More bits from this dopey article:

  • thousands of defenseless peasants risking beatings, imprisonment and even death
  • the injustice of the oppressor and claim the conscience of the world
  • Suppression does not end revolution; it breeds it. It solves nothing.
  • animal resistance
  • those who support the pursuits of women for recognition as full human beings — are getting a taste of the same kind of opposition.
  • Fundamentalist extremists of all ilk and their interpretations of religion everywhere claim one way or another that God is sexist.

You get the idea.

Were I to fisk this, you would barely be able to see the original text.  If you have a few minutes to read this whiny piece, knock yourselves out.

Someone need to find out from Sr. Joan and the Usual Suspects if they accept the Church’s teachings and make a formal, public declaration.

UPDATE:

In the meantime, a contributor, below, said:

Perhaps Sr Joan and her friends will follow the example of India and write a Declaration of Independence from the Church.

 

Exactly!

This is what the Indians did.  They voted with their feet and left the Empire.  They left.  Right?

Then?  Their country split into parts and pretty much went to war with each other. 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
47 Comments

Just Too Cool: College kids build space camera for $148

Watching the destruction of education in the US and elsewhere should be sufficient to prove that throwing lots of money at a project doesn’t always produce results.

Here is a great story.

Just Too Cool: College kids build space camera for $148The $150 Edge-of-Space Camera: MIT Students Beat NASA On Beer-Money Budget

Meet the $150 (almost to) Space Camera.

Bespoke is old hat. Off-the-shelf is in. Even Google runs the world’s biggest and scariest server farms on computers home-made from commodity parts. DIY is cheaper and often better, as Justin Lee and Oliver Yeh found out when they decided to send a camera into space.

The two students (from MIT, of course) put together a low-budget rig to fly a camera high enough to photograph the curvature of the Earth. Instead of rockets, boosters and expensive control systems, they filled a weather balloon with helium and hung a styrofoam beer cooler underneath to carry a cheap Canon A470 compact camera. Instant hand warmers kept things from freezing up and made sure the batteries stayed warm enough to work.  [This will now be every model rock kid’s dream.]

Of course, all this would be pointless if the guys couldn’t find the rig when it landed, so they dropped a prepaid GPS-equipped cellphone inside the box for tracking. Total cost, including duct tape? $148. [LOL]

Launch

Two weeks ago, on Sept. 2, at the leisurely post-breakfast hour of 11:45 a.m., the balloon was launched from Sturbridge, Massachusetts. Lee and Yeh took a road trip in order to compensate for the prevailing winds, which could have otherwise taken the balloon out onto the Atlantic, and checked in on the University of Wyoming’s balloon trajectory website to estimate the landing site.

Because of spotty cellphone coverage in central Massachusetts,[ROFL!] it was important to keep the rig in the center of the state so it could be found upon landing. Light winds meant the guys got lucky and, although the cellphone’s external antenna was buried upon landing, the fix they got as the balloon was coming down was close enough.

The Photographs

The balloon and camera made it up high enough to see the black sky curling around our blue planet. [Is this cool or what!?] The Canon was hacked with the CHDK (Canon Hacker’s Development Kit) open-source firmware, [Oooo… gotta learn more about this…] which adds many features to Canon’s cameras. The intervalometer (interval timer) was set to shoot a picture every five seconds, and the 8-GB memory card was enough to hold pictures for the five-hour duration of the flight.

The picture you see above was shot from around 93,000 feet, just shy of 18 miles high. It’s short of the widely-accepted Kármán line, which is at 100km (62 miles) up, but it’s in the stratosphere, and it’s still impressive. To give you an idea of how high that is, when the balloon burst, the beer-cooler took 40 minutes to come back to Earth.

What is most astonishing about this launch, named Project Icarus, is that anyone could do it. The budget is so small as to be almost nonexistent (the guys slept in their car the night before the launch to save money), so that even if everything went wrong, a second, third or fourth attempt would be easy. All it took was a grand idea and an afternoon poking around the hardware store.

The project website has few details on how the balloon was put together — but the students say they will be posting the step-by-step instructions soon. UPDATE: The instructions will be available for free, not $150, as earlier reported.

Project Icarus page [1337 Arts]

Photo credit: 1337 Arts/Justin Lee and Oliver Yeh

Time lapse actually doesn’t look that great because the cooler was not stabilized.

Posted in Just Too Cool |
9 Comments

“She kept saying, ‘It’s the Pope. That’s the Pope’”

I really like this story from the National Catholic Register:

Emma Watson Meets Her Pope

Posted by Tim Drake

“She kept saying, ‘It’s the Pope. That’s the Pope’”Thursday, September 17, 2009 5:24 AM

Last Wednesday, 7-year-old Emma Watson of Craigmont, Idaho, finally got her wish to meet Pope Benedict XVI. Register readers will remember first meeting Emma through this story.

Nearly aborted, Emma was born with mosaic Turner syndrome and hypoplastic left heart syndrome and has undergone five open-heart surgeries for palliation of her congenital heart condition. She has wanted to meet the Pope since age 3.

Originally scheduled to meet the Pope in February, that trip had to be canceled because Emma had to be hospitalized for intestinal bleeding. The trip was made possible through the Make-A-Wish Foundation, which granted 13,425 wishes to children last year.

This time around, she almost missed seeing the Pope for two different reasons. First, only three weeks before the trip, she was hospitalized with pancreatitis. Then, on the morning of the general audience, the Watson family couldn’t find the Make-A-Wish volunteers in the plaza.

Eventually, they found one another, and the Watsons were rushed in and seated for the general audience just minutes before it began. Emma and her mother, Patti, were given front-row seats.

“Mom was looking the other way when the Pope came out,” said Emma. “I was in awe, and I started crying.”

“She kept saying, ‘It’s the Pope. That’s the Pope,’” said Emma’s mother, Patti.

After the audience, Emma and her mother were brought to greet the Pope.

The Holy Father blessed Emma “in the Name of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit,” and then put his hands on Emma’s shoulders.

“He asked us where we were from,” said Patti. “I said the U.S., and then we were ushered aside.”

Normally quite talkative, Patti said that Emma was “speechless for the first time in her life.”

Emma said that when she looked into the Pope’s eyes she saw “happiness.”

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
11 Comments

“…led by Curiosity and good Company I strolled away to Mother Church…”

"...led by Curiosity and good Company I strolled away to Mother Church..."From a reader:

Good morning, Father.  Reading your comments on the importance of revitalizing the liturgy put me in mind of the comments of John Adams, who later became the second president of the United States.  Adams was rather a Puritan, I’m afraid, and did not at all like the Catholic Church.  However, in a letter to his wife Abigail, he describes a visit to a “Romish Chapel” in the company of George Washington.  The question that he asks in the last paragraph is astounding.  Like him, I also wonder how “Luther ever broke the spell.”  Part of the answer, perhaps, is that the liturgy had deteriorated in Luther’s day, like it has for us.  Note that I came across this passage in the great biography of John Adams written by David McCullough.  Sorry I don’t have the exact citation. 

 
The letter, which I have read before, is online.  Here is the quote from John Adams:
 

Phyladelphia Octr. 9, 1774

…

This afternoon, led by Curiosity and good Company I strolled away to Mother Church, or rather Grandmother Church, I mean the Romish Chapel. Heard a good, short, moral Essay upon the Duty of Parents to their Children, founded in justice and Charity, to take care of their Interests temporal and spiritual.
"...led by Curiosity and good Company I strolled away to Mother Church..."
This afternoon’s entertainment was to me most awful and affecting. The poor wretches fingering their beads, chanting Latin, not a word of which they understood, their Pater Nosters and Ave Marias. Their holy water – their crossing themselves perpetually – their bowing to the name of Jesus wherever they hear it – their bowings, and kneelings, and genuflections before the altar. The dress of the priest was rich with lace– his pulpit was velvet and gold. The altar piece was very rich – little images and crucifixes about – wax candles lighted up. But how shall I describe the picture of our Saviour in a frame of marble over the altar, at full length, upon the cross in the agonies, and the blood dropping and streaming from his wounds.

The music consisting of an organ, and a Choir of singers, went all the afternoon, excepting sermon Time, and the Assembly chanted– most sweetly and exquisitely.

Here is everything which can lay hold of the eye, ear, and imagination. Everything which can charm and bewitch the simple and the ignorant. I wonder how Luther ever broke the spell.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
15 Comments

John Allen on upcoming SSPX Summit

My friend John L. Allen, the nearly ubiquitous fair-minded correspondent of the ultra-lefty dissenting National Catholic Reporter is a good analyst.

In his weekly Friday letter he drills into the upcoming talks that are soon to begin between the SSPX and the Holy See.

Let’s have a look with my emphases and comments.

John Allen on upcoming SSPX SummitHealing the schism with traditionalists

Bishop Bernard Fellay, superior of the Society of St. Pius X, ordains a priest during a ceremony in Econe, Switzerland, June 29. (CNS/Reuters)

From a strictly demographic point of view, one could argue that the intense interest surrounding relations between the Vatican and the Society of St. Pius X, popularly known as the "Lefebvrites," is terribly exaggerated. Worldwide, the society has a little under 500 priests, roughly the same number as the Diocese of Buffalo. It claims one million faithful, a number impossible to confirm but which, even if true, would represent less than one-tenth of one percent of the global Catholic population. [Sure… but… when we are in a political cycle, don’t we pay attention to "likely voters"?  People who go to SSPX chapels are "likely voters", if you get my drift.]

Yet for a variety of reasons, the Vatican’s effort to put Humpty-Dumpty back together again by reconciling with the Lefebvrites carries a significance way out of proportion to those numbers.  [Problem: the Humpty Dumpty image describes the impossible.]

In the first place, the rupture triggered in 1988 by the late French Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre represents the only formal schism in the wake of the Second Vatican Council. (Some traditionalists reject the idea that the society is in schism, usually offering a version of Ronald Reagan’s famous quip about the Democrats: "I didn’t leave the Democratic Party, it left me." Yet Pope John Paul II’s 1988 motu proprio "Ecclesia Dei" was about as clear as possible, asserting that the ordinations "constitute a schismatic act.")  [Mr. Allen is usually a pretty thorough analyst, but he has left out something very important.  For a long time know, the Holy See has been saying that the SSPX is not in "formal schism".  His Eminence Card. Castrillon, former President of the Pont. Comm. Ecclesia Dei, said on more than one occasion that the SSPX was not in schism.  The official line is that what happened at Econe in 1988 was a schismatic act, but that it didn’t necessarily cause a formal schism.  Of course we have to balance that against John Paul II’s use of the word "schism" in the Motu Proprio Ecclesia Dei adflicta.]

Healing the schism [And we go on, after you are supposed to have accepted the premise.] has been a special priority for John Paul II and Benedict XVI, both of whom participated in Vatican II. Throughout history, popes have always tried to end schisms, since it’s a core principle of Catholic theology that any validly ordained bishop can ordain another bishop, and hence a schism can become self-replicating if not nipped in the bud.  [And for deeper ecclesiological reasons as well, not just for practical reasons.]

When it comes to the Society of St. Pius X, several other constituencies also feel an investment in which way things go:

    * Dissidents of various stripes complain that the Vatican’s outreach to the Lefebvrites has not been matched by similar solicitude for other disgruntled Catholics; [Who would they be?  Is he talking about people on the ecclesial left?  Progressivists?]
    * Theologians, church historians and ordinary Catholics alike wonder about the implications of bringing the Lefebvrites back into the fold in terms of the teaching of Vatican II, especially on ecumenical and inter-religious dialogue and on religious freedom; [Yes… but if they are wondering about that, then they may already made up their minds about what Vatican II means for those issues.]
    * Bishops and other church leaders grumble that offering the Lefebvrites too many concessions would mean rewarding them for disobedience; [ROFL!  Yah… right.  Let’s pause to talk about liturgical abuses, the lack of implementation of Ex corde Ecclesiae, years of protecting priests who hurt children, etc. etc. etc.]
    * Experts in Jewish-Catholic relations worry about Jewish reaction to any deal, given the ambivalent track record of some traditionalists on anti-Semitism — fears turbocharged by the recent cause célèbre involving Lefebvrite Bishop Richard Williamson and his comments on the Holocaust;
    * Some liturgical traditionalists hope that readmitting the Lefebvrites, whose signature issue is the pre-Vatican II Latin Mass, will help tip the scales toward a more reverent, classical style of worship. [Guilty as charged.]

Not only are those perspectives different, they’re usually put forward with more than a little bit of mustard. As a result, news that formal talks between the Vatican and the Society of St. Pius X are set for late October is inevitably a big deal, regardless of the society’s demographic footprint. [Considered from just a couple of those issues, listed above, it should be a big deal no matter how big the group is.]

The news was put into circulation on Monday by Cardinal Christoph Schönborn of Vienna, Austria, a theological protégé (and former graduate student) of Pope Benedict XVI as well as a member of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.  [Who has, we have seen more and more over the years, allowed some pretty wierd stuff to go on in Vienna.] In an interview with the German daily Passauer Neue Presse, Schönborn said that talks between the Vatican and the Society of St. Pius X would begin soon, and that the Vatican would make clear "what is not negotiable."

In particular, Schönborn said, the legitimacy of the church’s "dialogue with Jews, other religions and other Christian faiths" is not up for discussion.  [Fine.  St. Francis of Assisi gave us a pretty good example of that in the 13th c.  I think we are all on board with inter-religious dialogue.]

In that sense, the model for the talks with the Lefebvrites is not so much the Middle East peace process, with each side giving up some ground in order to get a deal. It’s more akin to negotiating a friendly corporate takeover, ironing out how much autonomy the smaller operation will still enjoy and where it must toe the line of its parent company.  [Interesting analogy.]

In light of those comments, reporters in Rome pressed Jesuit Fr. Federico Lombardi, the Vatican spokesperson, for details. On Tuesday, Lombardi confirmed that talks will indeed take place toward the second half of October. He also identified three experts who will be participating for the Vatican:

    * Swiss Dominican Fr. Charles Morerod, secretary of the International Theological Commission and rector magnificus of the Dominican-run Angelicum University in Rome;
    * German Jesuit Fr. Karl Josef Becker, an emeritus professor at the Gregorian University in Rome and a longtime advisor to the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith;
    * Spanish Msgr. Fernando Ocáriz, the vicar general of Opus Dei and an advisor to the Vatican’s doctrinal congregation since 1986. (For the record, Ocáriz was actually born in Paris but to Spanish parents, so let’s not quibble about nationality.)  [Not only… Msgr. Ocariz was also a member of the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei for some years.]

A wag might be tempted to say that the talks have thus already produced one miracle: the Jesuits and Opus Dei are on the same side!  [/rimshot]

These three figures appear to be carefully chosen. [Get outta town!] Becker and Ocáriz were both major contributors to Dominus Iesus, the 2000 document from the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, led by then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, on religious pluralism. That text strongly upheld the uniqueness and the universality of the salvation won through Christ, thereby addressing one of the Lefebvrites’ major doctrinal objections to Vatican II. Morerod is a veteran of Anglican-Catholic and Orthodox-Catholic dialogues, and a figure known for bringing a thoroughly orthodox approach to ecumenical efforts.

It would thus be difficult to argue that these three theologians suffer from a fuzzy sense of Catholic identity, [fuzzy… squishy… sounds familiar…] or represent a sharp break with church tradition. In that sense, they’re good interlocutors for the Society of St. Pius X, because they can’t be accused of heresy (not credibly, anyway) when making the points to which Schönborn alluded, about dialogue with Jews, followers of other religions, and other Christians.

Ocáriz brings another bit of expertise that could be useful. One hypothesis occasionally floated about how to bring the Lefebvrites back into communion is to grant them a special canonical status, perhaps a personal prelature. To date, the only personal prelature in the church remains Opus Dei, so Ocáriz is in a position to evaluate the pros and cons of that idea.  [Good point.  [Msgr. Ocariz was also a member of the PCED.]

As for the long-term prospects of these talks, all one can say is that the jury is still out. Speaking on background, Vatican officials generally say that they sense a division in the Society of St. Pius X between a "moderate" camp centered around the superior general, Bishop Bernard Fellay, which is seriously committed to reunion, and a more "hard-line" current that still thinks of the Lefebvrite movement as the Athanasius of the modern age, [a false analogy, btw] standing alone against the heresy of the post-conciliar church. That second group tends to view reconciliation with Rome in a more eschatological key. [That is to say, the Church will be "reunited" at the return of the Lord.  On an ironic side note, I remember that the escahtological point emerged during the controversy over Pope Benedict XVI’s change of the Good Friday prayer for Jews in the 1962 Missale Romanum.]

If that diagnosis is correct, it remains to be seen which camp might prevail — and whether the end result might actually be a "schism within a schism," [or in some respects, the real schism] with some elements of the society willing to accept reconciliation and others repudiating it.

 

There are a couple flaws here, but Mr. Allen offered some interesting insights.  

Posted in Brick by Brick, SESSIUNCULA, The Drill | Tagged , , ,
17 Comments

Caption

I picked this up from the young Papist.  It is a photo screaming for a good caption.

Caption

"OHHHHK-lahoma, where the wind comes sweepin’ down the plain…"

Karaoke Night at the Synod.

Posted in Lighter fare |
27 Comments

QUAERITUR: Gregorian Masses for the living?

From a priest reader:

     I have a question for you or your readers.
 
     Do you think that the Missae Gregorianae can be offered for the living?
 
     I have found this custom here in Barcelona, amongst some of the OF people (not of course amongst the EF).

I don’t need to put this out to the readers.

First, he is not talking about the older form of Mass, the TLM, which some people call the "Gregorian Rite".  The questioner is asking about the 30 consecutive Masses offered for the repose of the soul of a person who has died.  These are called "Gregorian Masses".  I have written about these before.

My understanding is that the Gregorian Masses are celebrated for the dead.

But nothing prohibits that a priest say 30 consecutive Masses for a person who is living, and under roughly the same conditions.

On that note, a friend of mine sent me Mass intentions all the time for his mother saying, "Why wait until she dies?  Why not have Masses for he while she is alive?" 

Exactly!

Masses can be offered for the dead and for the living.

This is why before saying Mass priests always were to say… and really should be saying right now…

Ego volo celebrare Missam iuxta ritum sanctae Romanae ecclesiae, ad laudem omnipotentis Dei, totiusque ecclesiae triumphantis, ad utilitatem meam, totiusque ecclesiae militantis, pro omnibus qui se commendaverunt orationibus meis in genere et in specie, ac pro felici statu sanctae Romanae ecclesiae.

I intend to celebrate Mass according to the rite of the holy Roman Church, to the praise of the almighty God and of the whole Church triumphant, for my benefit and that of the whole Church militant, for all who have commended themselves to my prayers in general and in particular, and for the happy estate of the holy Roman Church.

 

 

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, SESSIUNCULA |
1 Comment

Fr. Roscia of Salt+Light on “the Lifesite crowd” and “EWTN viewers”

Do you remember what Hamlet told Polonius about the players when they come to Elsinore?

Good my lord, will you see the players well
bestowed? Do you hear, let them be well used; for
they are the abstract and brief chronicles of the
time: after your death you were better have a bad
epitaph than their ill report while you live. (Hamlet II,ii.)

From the news site of a Canadian weekly The Catholic Register:

    

 

LifeSite accused of fuelling web war on Salt+Light
Thursday, 17 September 2009

Written by Michael Swan, The Catholic Register,

TORONTO – Salt+Light Television CEO Fr. Tom Rosica has reacted to daily threats against his life, reputation and ministry, blaming LifeSiteNews for stirring up “division, destruction, hatred, vitriol, judgment and violence.”

Since controversy erupted over Senator Ted Kennedy’s funeral in Boston, e-mails and blog postings directed at Rosica have included: “Your grave is dug”; “We will bring down your network”; “We will force you to resign”; and  “We will get the Vatican to rescind your appointment.” [You know… while those messages would be alarming for Fr. Roscia, they are not violent and they do not stir "hatred". People have a right to a "judgment" about the work Fr. Roscia does, and any other Catholic media outlet does.]

Rosica said his office phone messages have included threats and violent language. He called them “vile, vile phone calls.”  [Is that is true, that’s too bad.]

“My secretary is often with me when I download the (telephone) messages, and she says, ‘These are Catholics calling like this?’ ” Rosica told The Catholic Register.  [I can identify with that.]

The controversy started with posts on LifeSiteNews.com condemning Boston’s Cardinal Sean O’Malley for allowing a large, televised funeral Mass for Sen. Kennedy, who supported abortion. LifeSiteNews readers began calling Salt+Light demanding it condemn the funeral. When Rosica refused to chime in on the condemnations, the threats began.  [People had the right to ask.  Didn’t they?  But there are the words and there is the music, too.]

“It’s a mixture of the LifeSite crowd, LifeSite subscribers combined with EWTN viewers who have now set themselves above the church,” said Rosica. ["the Lifesite crowd"?  And who are they?  "EWTN viewers"?  Hmmmm…..]

Rosica went public with his frustration over the threats and bullying in his own blog on saltandlighttv.org and then in an interview on the Sirius Radio Catholic Channel newsmagazine show Across the Nation with Bob Dunning.

LifeSiteNews editor and co-founder John Henry Westen said it should not be blamed for overzealous, intemperate language of a few angry people.

“We’ve gone to great lengths at LifeSite to even develop a document on effective communications, because we know that when people — and sometimes good people, good pro-life people — see things that upset them they tend to go off,” Westen said.

The majority of the hundreds of postings to Rosica’s blog were respectful and charitable, said Weston.

Rosica’s condemnation of pro-life leaders and LifeSiteNews for the actions of a few rogue pro-life activists is uncalled for, he said.

“I’ve never heard this kind of language from a clergyman in public,” he said. “The language was so unbelievably cutting that it was something that I thought obviously wasn’t a reaction to what pro-life leaders of note put out.”

In an attempt to lower the temperature, LifeSiteNews has announced it will refrain from publishing further letters to the editor on the controversy.

Blogs and web sites such as LifeSiteNews have coarsened Catholic dialogue in recent years, said Catholic News Service director and editor-in-chief Tony Spence. [I believe that CNS is paid for by the USCCB.]

“The blogosphere is full of venom and vitriol. [Not every corner.] Certainly there has been a notable loss of civility in the public square and public discourse,” Spence said from Washington.

While traditional Catholic newspaper publishers in North America belong to the Catholic Press Association and subscribe to the association’s fair publishing and practices code, including the standard practices of professional journalism, there are no such guidelines for web sites claiming to be Catholic.

“Now everybody with a computer fancies himself a canon lawyer or a theologian,” said Spence. “Just because I have a blog, it does not make me a theologian, or a particularly good ecclesiologist — or even a good journalist.”  [I think he is nervous about blogs.]

Rosica, who sits on the Pontifical Council for Social Communications, questions whether LifeSiteNews has any notion of journalistic ethics.  [And we now arrive at the point…]

“When they run up against somebody they disagree with they condemn them and they do an ad hominem attack. It’s character assassination,” Rosica said.

“Our reports are accurate and to the point,” countered Westen.

Most LifeSiteNews reports end with e-mail addresses, phone numbers and other contact information, and a warning that communications should be respectful.

“Our mandate is to educate and to activate,” Westen said.

[Look at this… ] The Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops has scheduled a closed-door session on independent blogs and web sites claiming to be Catholic at its October plenary. Rosica said he also hopes the Pontifical Council on Social Communication takes up the issue.

 

They might start with the National Catholic Reporter… America… etc.

Sooo…

Do you remember what Hamlet told the players when they came to Elsinore?

Folks, we all know that some people – behind the screen of anonymity – click off that switch in their brains that allows them to self-edit, to exercise basic self-control, to consider their interlocutors with even a hint of charity. 

We know too that there are some really creepy people out there.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , , ,
67 Comments