Grinding away on the Kennedy funeral – more thoughts

A lot of people are still grinding away about the funeral of the late Sen. Kennedy. 

Some are grinding because they are angry.  Others are grinding in the sense of mulling, thinking through the issues.

I have come to the view that it wasn’t entirely out of bounds to have a funeral for the late Senator.  Reports are that, at the end, he wanted the priest there and I am sure he received the last sacraments. 

However, I said above: funeral.  Actually a funeral.  It should have been a funeral clearly focused on prayers for the repose of the Senator’s soul and begging God’s mercy.  That is not what it was.

Furthermore, because of the risk of scandal, it seems to me that – despite his great public fame – the funeral should have been discreet…. not televised.  So what if he was hugely famous?

Since the Church’s shepherd’s didn’t apply the law to the long-time pro-abortion advocate Sen. Kennedy regarding Holy Communion, it is pretty hard to say that he couldn’t have a funeral.  I know two wrongs don’t make a right… but… as I said… at the end he did seem to want the sacraments and I pray to God he asked forgiveness for all his sins.

If there was public scandal, I am afraid that it is the fault not only of Sen. Kennedy himself, but also our shepherds who did nothing for decades in the face of what the Senator became infamous for doing.

So… people are mulling… grinding.

Two of the grinders are Msgr. Ignacio Barreiro, of the Rome office of Human Life International and Dr. Ed Peters, professor of Canon Law at Sacred Heart in Detroit.

Msgr. Barreiro, a friend of mine wrote an opinion on Lifesite.   Dr. Peters responded to that opinion on his blog.

I must agree with Dr. Peters in this case.

Fr. Brian Harrison , O.S. from the Oblates of Wisdom Study Center, St. Louis, Missouri, also has a piece on Lifesite.

An excerpt:

How would our Church leaders act if they really did take seriously an official Church position from which a prominent deceased Catholic had publicly dissented?

To answer that question, we need only imagine a situation in which some well-known Catholic legislator had for years supported the Church’s social teaching ‘across the board’, in regard to human life, marriage, compassion toward the poor and underprivileged, etc., but had then, in old age, lapsed into supporting some ideological position that was strongly opposed not only by the Church, but also by the dominant Western elites.

Suppose, for instance, that he had come to endorse white supremacism or holocaust denial. …

Would they agree to give him a free pass in regard to this defect?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

Two years later… the “gravitational pull”

From the blog Ten Reasons I find this brick by brick post – with a rather nice turn of phrase in it!

Feeling gravity’s pull

A friend who would know tells me that the Friday 9 AM Latin Mass in the Ordinary Form resumes at St. Cecilia Church on Cincinnati’s East side this Friday, September 11, and will continue every second and fourth Friday. It arrives just in time to celebrate the "gravitational pull" of Summorum Pontificum on the motu proprio’s September 14 second anniversary.

 

 

Posted in Brick by Brick, Our Catholic Identity, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
5 Comments

PODCAzT 91: A hymn dissected “Te lucis ante terminum”; Don Camillo (part VI)

Today we will drill into a hymn sung by Holy Church in the Liturgia horarum for Compline every evening.  It is called Te lucis ante terminum.
PODCAzT 91: A hymn dissected "Te lucis ante terminum"; Don Camillo (part VI)
Since the reforms of the Second Vatican Council, the hymn was rewritten a bit, the words changed… and thus the meaning.  We will see the variations.  As a matter of fact in the making of this audio project I noted that in one recording of the pre-Conciliar version monks were singing “omnipotens” even while I was reading “piissime“!  Shocking!

I dissect this hymn, sing it in the Gregorian chant tone, and we hear different translations and many other musical versions.

I just might ramble a little while drilling into the meaning of the hymn.

Sing along with the hymns! Buy a Liber Hymnarius!

Also, we have another installment of stories about the fictional don Camillo Tarocci, (+ A.D. … ?) parish priest of “The Little World”.
PODCAzT 91: A hymn dissected "Te lucis ante terminum"; Don Camillo (part VI)

PODCAzT 91: A hymn dissected "Te lucis ante terminum"; Don Camillo (part VI)Some time ago, I began a to read stories from The Little World of Don Camillo by Giovanni Guareschi.  There is a Don Camillo tag you can use to find the others easily.

These delightful pieces are set in post-war Northern Italy.  PODCAzT 91: A hymn dissected "Te lucis ante terminum"; Don Camillo (part VI)

They blend brilliant insight into the human condition with solid applied Catholic Faith.

Today we hear two tales:

The AvengerPODCAzT 91: A hymn dissected "Te lucis ante terminum"; Don Camillo (part VI)

https://wdtprs.com/wp-content/legacy/audio-archive/podcazt/09_09_09.mp3
And perhaps in your charity you might listen to:PODCAzT 90: St. Leo on the beatitudes; the sacred, sacrilege and reparation

UPDATE:

By coincidence… ? … there was a story on ZENIT today in Italian on Guareschi!

Posted in don Camillo, PODCAzT, WDTPRS | Tagged , , , , , , , ,
4 Comments

09-09-09 09:09:09

Today won’t there be an

09-09-09 09:09:09?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
14 Comments

QUAERITUR: female servers for Extraordinary Form

QUAERITUR: female servers for Extraordinary FormFrom time to time the question of female servers for the Extraordinary Form of the Roman Rite pops up in my inbox.  Yes… Extraordinary Form or TLM

At present, the 1983 Code of Canon Law is interpreted such that females can substitute for installed acolytes (exclusively male).  That is to say males always and at times females – in those areas where the bishop permits it and where the priest wants it – can substitute for the officially installed acoylte (an all male ministry).

Here at WDTPRS I concluded a long time ago that, the present law being in force, yes, it would be licit for females to serve at a TLM, but … I wouldn’t give much for the life of the priest afterward.  That tar and those feathers are pretty tough to remove, I hear.

Furthermore, according to the present law, male servers are the norm and female servers cannot be imposed on a priest’s celebration of Holy Mass.  Moreover, the local diocesan bishop can decide whether or not female servers will be permitted in his diocese.

Thus, there is no obligation to have female servers at any celebration of Mass, nor is it – in my opinion – desirable in most cases.   Those cases certainly include the TLM.

Now this comes from ZENIT with my emphases and comments.

Female Servers in the Extraordinary Form

And More on the Blessed Sacrament

ROME, SEPT. 8, 2009 (Zenit.org).- Answered by Legionary of Christ Father Edward McNamara, professor of liturgy at the Regina Apostolorum university.

Q: Is there any definitive answer available [no] regarding the use of female servers at celebrations of the extraordinary form of the Roman rite? — A.J., Pontypridd, Wales

A: Although a clarifying instruction on several such questions was frequently described as "imminent," a long time has passed and it would seem that it is still in the pipeline.

All the same, it is important to remember that, even in the ordinary form, the use of female altar servers is in virtue of a specific permission and is not automatic. As the Holy See has explained on several occasions, the local bishop may permit the use of female servers but may not oblige the pastor to use them.

Also, the Holy Father’s motu proprio granting permission for the celebrations of the extraordinary form was for the Roman Missal according to the edition issued under Pope John XXIII. Since the rubrics of this missal in no way contemplate the possibility of female servers, then it must be surmised that only altar boys or adult men are allowed as servers in the extraordinary form of the Roman rite.  [Let’s see if he can be convincing.]

To help us to understand the underlying logic behind this we can reflect on a particular situation.

It appears there was at least one case in which women were allowed some functions habitually carried out by the servers. In the preface to the 1936 first edition of H.E. Calnan’s guide for altar servers, he mentions the following circumstance: "In most parishes, a dozen influences combine to restrict the supply of efficient Mass servers. Layfolk must be asked to serve at short notice, or without warning. A woman with knowledge of Latin may venture, because she has only to answer and not to move about."

The case foreseen here is when there were no assigned altar servers present. In such a plight a woman with knowledge of Latin could do the responses. [And only the responses.]

A woman could carry out this role because it was properly speaking a role of the assembly. [Some will disagree with that, of course.] In making the Latin responses the altar boys in a way represented and substituted the assembly, who frequently did not know the liturgical language. One of the challenges of being an altar boy (and a source of legitimate pride to his parents) was memorizing the Latin texts to be recited.

However, years before the conciliar reform there was already a liturgical movement that encouraged the whole assembly’s recitation of these parts, and not just the server. This practice is relatively common today among communities that habitually celebrate the extraordinary form. [But not universal.]

Father Calnan’s mention that the woman "has only to answer and not move about" makes it clear that she did not carry out any of the other functions of the altar boy in serving the Mass. Since in these roles the altar servers substituted some of the functions of those who had received minor orders (and who were thus canonically numbered among the clergy), only males could carry out these functions.

[And here is the sticky point…] In the ordinary form the clerical minor orders have been replaced by the lay ministries of lector and acolyte. However, even though they are lay ministries, only males may be instituted as lectors and acolytes. Since instituted lectors and acolytes are uncommon in most parishes, other lay readers and servers may be delegated. At this stage the rubrics allow either men or women to be chosen as readers and, were permitted, as servers. [And there, friends, is the smoking gun, I’m afraid.]

In the extraordinary form, though, the minor orders and the liturgical logic behind them still exist. For this reason I would say that in this form the rule reserving altar service to boys or men remains in force. 

Well… then I suppose Fr. McNamara would also conclude that it is proper, nay rather, necessary for priests to deny people Communion in the hand during celebrations of the TLM, even if in that region the bishops have (alas) given approval to the practice.

I think the difference in our opinion lies in the fact that, as I see it, Summorum Pontificum did not revive all the old decrees of the Sacred Congregation of Rites.  I think we have to be guided closely by those old decrees – otherwise we have very little to go by.  Those decrees existed to fill in ambuguities and they were developed over a long time.

That said, the present 1983 Code is in force in the Latin Church.

Finally, having altar girls at a TLM or Communion in the hand for that matter, as so contrary to the spirit of the moment that I have a hard time imagining who would want those aberrations: for that is what they are – aberrations from the norms.  I can imagine some goofy priest who thinks he is being clever and is going to stick it to the TLM group, but… as I said at the top, that whole tar and feather thing has a pretty bad reputation.

Old posts about female servers:

 

 

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, Linking Back, SESSIUNCULA, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
62 Comments

NCReg: formal statement coming on proposals by the CDWDS plenary

Remember how once the intrepid vaticanista Andrea Tornielli posted about the proposals of the plenary session of the Congregation for Divine Worship, the Holy See Press Office issued its non-denial denials?

Tornielli said that the members of the Congregation were asking for measures to foster greater reverence during the Church’s worship.

The Press Office said that nothing was official yet.  Of course, the Congregation studies things for a while before putting the formal proposals on the Pope’s desk… but they are working on them nonetheless.

Now we read in the National Catholic Register:

‘Reform of the Reform’ Update

Posted by Edward Pentin

Tuesday, September 08, 2009 10:02 AM

The Congregation for Divine Worship is declining to comment further on reports that the Vatican is considering a “reform of the reform” of the liturgy, but a formal statement on the matter is expected soon.

An official told the Register this morning that “everything is under study and is progressing” but added that he could say no more until Cardinal Antonio Llovera Cañizares, prefect of the congregation, or the Holy See Press Office, issues an official statement.

At the end of August, veteran Vatican watcher Andrea Tornielli reported that cardinals and bishops of the CDW voted almost unanimously at their plenary meeting in March “in favor” of 30 proposals aimed at increasing reverence in the liturgy.

Tornielli said the bishops also reaffirmed the importance of receiving Communion on the tongue rather than the hand, and that Cardinal Canizares was studying the possibility of “recovering” the practice of celebrating Mass with the priest facing east. However, there are conflicting reports over whether these last two proposals were included in the propositions that Tornielli said were delivered to Pope Benedict XVI on April 4.

The deputy director of the Holy See press office, Passionist Father Ciro Benedettini, played down Tornielli’s report, saying there were “no institutional proposals in existence regarding a modification of the liturgical books currently in use.” However, Tornielli stood by his story, saying that he didn’t mention “institutional proposals,” but had reported instead that a period of “study had begun” on what will probably amount to long-term reform after plenty of consultation.

The lack of clarity over this story is partly due to the absence of senior officials, most notably Cardinal Cañizares, who has been on holiday and returns to Rome later this month. Also the Congregation for Divine Worship’s new secretary, American Archbishop Augustine Di Noia, has only recently been appointed and is not prepared at this time to comment on the cardinal’s behalf.

“We’re waiting for the cardinal to return at the end of the month,” the CDW official told the Register today. “Then there will be a statement from the press office or the cardinal himself.”

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
16 Comments

The Holy See’s team for the SSPX talks?

Our friends at Rorate found a story which seems to report the names of the theologians who will represent the Holy See in the theological talks with the SSPX.

Vatican names chosen?

According to French Vaticanista blog Osservatore Vaticano (followed by the website of Le Nouvelliste), the Vatican would have already chosen its team in the doctrinal talks with the Priestly Fraternity of Saint Pius X (FSSPX / SSPX), which would be composed of Fr. Charles Morerod, O.P., Swiss, Secretary of the International Theological Commission, Deal of the Facoltà of Philosophy of the Angelicum; Fr. Karl Becker, S.I., German, a theologian who is close to the Pope and former professor at the Gregorian; and Mgr. Fernando Ocáriz (Opus Dei), Spaniard, professor at Santa Croce (the Opus Dei university in Rome), and Vicar General of the Prelature.

Posted in Brick by Brick, SESSIUNCULA |
12 Comments

Some blog server problems

Today we have been trying to tidy up a few glitches with the speed of the blog.  Apparently there are a couple sites out that which have, on every page load, bring up lots of sites.  Thus, when people look at those other sites, WDTPRS is being taxed as well (as well as a lot of other blogs and sites).

So… be a little patient today.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Some blog server problems

ND’s McBrien: Eucharistic Adoration “is a doctrinal, theological, and spiritual step backward”

In many places where perpetual, or even frequent, Eucharistic Adoration has been made available, there have been great benefits.

But Richard McBrien of Notre Dame is against Eucharist Adoration.

ND's McBrien: Eucharistic Adoration "is a doctrinal, theological, and spiritual step backward"In his latest piece for the dissenting, ultra-liberal National Catholic Reporter McBrien wrote this with my emphases and comments:

… The practice of eucharistic adoration began in the 12th century, when the Real Presence of Christ was widely rejected by heretics or misunderstood by poorly educated Catholics. The church saw eucharistic adoration as a way of reaffirming its faith in the Real Presence and of promoting renewed devotion to it.

However, as time went on, eucharistic devotions, including adoration, drifted further and further away from their liturgical grounding in the Mass itself.

Notwithstanding Pope Benedict XVI’s personal endorsement of eucharistic adoration [In other words, who cares what the Pope thinks.] and the sporadic restoration of the practice in the archdiocese of Boston and elsewhere, it is difficult to speak favorably about the devotion today.

Now that most Catholics are literate and even well-educated, [In other words, Adoration is probably something only stupid people are interested in.] the Mass is in the language of the people (i.e, the vernacular), and its rituals are relatively easy to understand and follow, [Really? Ask people after Mass what the epiclesis is for? or what the Gospel reading was?] there is little or no need for extraneous eucharistic devotions. The Mass itself provides all that a Catholic needs sacramentally and spiritually.  [No need for confession, either, I suppose.]

Eucharistic adoration, perpetual or not, is a doctrinal, theological, and spiritual step backward, not forward.

 

To which we might want to respond:

  • Blessed be God.
  • Blessed be His Holy Name.
  • Blessed be Jesus Christ, true God and true man.
  • Blessed be the name of Jesus.
  • Blessed be His Most Sacred Heart.
  • Blessed be His Most Precious Blood.
  • Blessed be Jesus in the Most Holy Sacrament of the Altar.
  • Blessed be the Holy Spirit, the Paraclete.
  • Blessed be the great Mother of God, Mary most holy.
  • Blessed be her holy and Immaculate Conception.
  • Blessed be her glorious Assumption.
  • Blessed be the name of Mary, Virgin and Mother.
  • Blessed be Saint Joseph, her most chaste spouse.
  • Blessed be God in His angels and in His Saints.

May the heart of Jesus, in the Most Blessed Sacrament, be praised, adored, and loved with grateful affection, at every moment, in all the tabernacles of the world, even to the end of time. Amen.

Posted in Our Catholic Identity, SESSIUNCULA, The Drill |
135 Comments

Want to use your phone in church? Think again!

Have you ever wished that your car had a phaser option?  That there was a trap door under the pulpit?Buy WDTPRS stuff!

A tip of the biretta to Mulier Fortis for the following.

In the future there may be some serious penalties for cellphone use in church.

I must find out more about this system.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, Just Too Cool, Lighter fare |
27 Comments