Bp. D’Arcy on the Notre Dame Debacle… this is not over

I was told by an American bishop not long ago that, as far as the USCCB was concerned, the Notre Dame Debacle is not over.

Read the article by Bp. D’Arcy in America.

From CNA with my emphases and comments.

Bp. D'Arcy on the Notre Dame Debacle... this is not over
Bishop John M. D’Arcy (in photo)

.- Bishop John M. D’Arcy, whose diocese encompasses the University of Notre Dame, is not letting the issues raised by the university’s honoring of President Obama lie dormant. Instead, the Bishop of Fort Wayne-South Bend has penned a poignant article for the upcoming edition of America magazine that calls on the renowned university to evaluate the consequences of its failure to respect the authority of the bishops. [It is ironic that a Jesuit publication would be the instrument for this development, considering that the Jesuit university Georgetown covered over the Holy Name at the request of the White House.]

In an article that will be the cover story of the Jesuit-run America magazine on August 31, bishop D’Arcy writes that "as summer plays itself out on the beautiful campus by the lake where the young Holy Cross priest, Edward Sorin, C.S.C., pitched his camp 177 years ago and began his great adventure, we must clarify the situation that so sundered the church last spring: What it is all about and what it is not about."  [Qui distinguit bene docet.]

According to the bishop, who had asked Notre Dame’s president, Fr. John Jenkins, not to honor Obama, "it is not about President Obama… It is not about Democrats versus Republicans… It is not about whether it is appropriate for the president of the United States to speak at Notre Dame or any great Catholic university on the pressing issues of the day."  [This is mendactious.  What happened at Notre Dame was EXACTLY about honoring this President.  Notre Dame chose to bestow an honor on this President.   They bestowed on Pres. Obama an honorary doctorate.  And not just any doctorate!  This was not a doctorate in, say, Women’s Studies.  This was an honorary doctorate of LAW.  The invitation to the President to speak at the graduation ceremony need not have included the bestowal of this honor.  The secular Arizona State chose not to bestow an honor on Pres. Obama on the grounds that he had not yet done anything to merit it.  Fr. Jenkin’s needs to be held accountable.  Notre Dame needs to be held accountable for this public act.]

The response of the faithful, Bishop D’Arcy writes, "is not about what this journal [America magazine] called ‘sectarian Catholicism.’ Rather, the response of the faithful derives directly from the Gospel."

The real question posed by the situation is whether or not a Catholic university has a responsibility to give a public witness to the faith, D’Arcy states. "If not, what is the meaning of a life of faith?  [This all has to do with our Catholic identity.] And how can a Catholic institution expect its students to live by faith in the difficult decisions that will confront them in a culture often opposed to the Gospel?" he wonders.

"In its decision to give its highest honor to a president who has repeatedly opposed even the smallest legal protection of the child in the womb, did Notre Dame surrender the responsibility that Pope Benedict believes Catholic universities have to give public witness to the truths revealed by God and taught by the church?" the bishop also asks.

Bishop D’Arcy then takes Notre Dame to task for its multi-year sponsorship of the play "The Vagina Monologues." [Yet another scandal.]

"Although he spoke eloquently about the importance of dialogue with the president of the United States, the president of Notre Dame chose not to dialogue with his bishop on these two matters, both pastoral and both with serious ramifications for the care of souls, which is the core responsibility of the local bishop," he says.  [Furthermore, in spite of the words about dialogue, the Obama Administration still acts so as to expand abortion to every corner of the globe.]

"Both decisions," Bishop D’Arcy reveals, "were shared with me after they were made and, in the case of the honorary degree, after President Obama had accepted."

Noting that he has "never interfered in the internal governance of Notre Dame or any other institution of higher learning within the diocese," D’Arcy explains that "the diocesan bishop must ask whether a Catholic institution compromises its obligation to give public witness by placing prestige over truth."  [Do I head an "Amen!"?]

"The failure to dialogue with the bishop brings a second series of questions," he says.

"What is the relationship of the Catholic university to the local bishop? No relationship? Someone who occasionally offers Mass on campus? Someone who sits on the platform at graduation?" [The relationship was spelled out in the document Ex corde Ecclesiae… which, since the Notre Shame Debacle, seems to be an entirely dead letter.]

"Or is the bishop the teacher in the diocese, responsible for souls, including the souls of students—in this case, the students at Notre Dame? Does the responsibility of the bishop to teach, to govern and to sanctify end at the gate of the university?"

"In the spirit of Ex Corde Ecclesiae," he says, "I am proposing these questions for the university."   [Too little too late?  What actual force does Ex corde Ecclesiae have today?  Sure, it is still on paper a key document.  But, in reality – does it have any importance?   I tend right now to say "No.  It is a dead letter."  But the American Bishops, if they are willing, could still make something of it.]

Bishop D’Arcy then points to the strong spiritual life of many of the faculty members and students at the university, and acknowledges that "the theology department has grown in academic excellence over the years, strengthened by the successful recruiting of professors outstanding in scholarship, in their knowledge of the tradition and in their own living of the Catholic faith."

"Yet," he adds, "the questions about the relationship of the university as a whole to the church still stand, and what happened on campus leading up to and during the graduation is significant for the present debate about Catholic higher education."

Regarding the large number of students and faculty opposed to Obama’s commencement address and honoring, the bishop says that America magazine "and others in the media, Catholic and secular, reporting from afar, failed to make a distinction between the extremists on the one hand, and students and those who joined in the last 48 hours before graduation. This latter group [ND Response] responded with prayer and substantive disagreement. They cooperated with university authorities."  [Can we forget the video images of an elderly priest on the ground being being forcefully and physically manhandled from the grounds of the ND campus, at the direction of Fr. Jenkin’s administration?]

"In this time of crisis at the university," he notes, "these students and professors, with the instinct of faith, turned to the bishop for guidance, encouragement and prayer."

Although he had originally intended to stay away from the graduation ceremony, Bishop D’Arcy writes that "As graduation drew near, I knew I should be with the students. It was only right that the bishop be with them, for they were on the side of truth, and their demonstration was disciplined, rooted in prayer and substantive."

Bishop D’Arcy also takes aim at the university’s board of trustees for saying "nothing" when they met in April for their long-scheduled spring meeting.

"When the meeting was completed, they made no statement and gave no advice. In an age when transparency is urged as a way of life on and off campus, they chose not to enter the conversation going on all around them and shaking the university to its roots," he says.

What the board must do is "take up its responsibility afresh, with appropriate study and prayer… with greater seriousness and in a truly Catholic spirit," the bishop urges. [Remember: we are in a war for our identity as Catholics.]

D’Arcy concludes his article by posing some key questions to Notre Dame "and to other Catholic universities."

Bishop D’Arcy asks: [Get this…]

"Do you consider it a responsibility in your public statements, in your life as a university and in your actions, including your public awards, to give witness to the Catholic faith in all its fullness?

"What is your relationship to the church and, specifically, to the local bishop and his pastoral authority as defined by the Second Vatican Council?

"Finally, a more fundamental question: Where will the great Catholic universities search for a guiding light in the years ahead? Will it be the Land O’Lakes Statement or Ex Corde Ecclesiae?"

The Land O’Lakes Statement was signed in July 1967 by a group of Catholic educators led by then University of Notre Dame president Fr. Theodore Hesburgh. The famous Catholic historian Philip Gleason characterized the statement as a "declaration of independence from the hierarchy," adding that it divorced the Catholic university from the life of faith and set in motion the decline in Catholic identity of several major institutions of higher education.

Bishop D’Arcy describes the statement as coming "from a frantic time, with finances as the driving force. Its understanding of freedom is defensive, absolutist and narrow. It never mentions Christ and barely mentions the truth."

"The second text, Ex Corde Ecclesiae, speaks constantly of truth and the pursuit of truth. It speaks of freedom in the broader, Catholic philosophical and theological tradition, as linked to the common good, to the rights of others and always subject to truth."

"On these three questions, I respectfully submit, rests the future of Catholic higher education in this country and so much else," Bishop D’Arcy finishes.

WDTPRS kudos to Bp. D’Arcy!

Folks, there must consequences for Notre Dame.  The USCCB must make a statement.

But keep this in mind.  The USCCB is, ultimately, a limited body.  Individual bishops must make decisions in their own dioceses.  Don’t heap too much on the USCCB.  The USCCB is a helpful body for coordinating responses, for gaining insights and perhaps even being strengthened in their individual wills to act regarding the Catholic schools within each bishop’s diocese.  The USCCB can be effective in some ways, but individual bishops will have to shoulder this burden.

This is why what Bp. D’Arcy is doing is very important.  He deserves support.  Please give him your support at least through a prayer, perhaps the Prayer to St. Michael and by invoking Our Lady, Seat of Wisdom.

Posted in Our Catholic Identity, SESSIUNCULA, The Drill, The future and our choices |
32 Comments

grrr and again grrr

Well… bad news.

Now there is nothing but BSOD when I try to boot my main computer.  This is an Nvidia driver problem, I believe.  But I can’t get past the BSOD on start up.  I am ready to use a shotgun on this thing.

At this point I am trying to figure out how to change out the driver with access only to the DOS command prompt.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
23 Comments

Saving Western Civilization… One Book and One Reader at a Time

I was in my native place last week and took part of the morning to visit a place I used to haunt… whose rent I used to pay.

Loome Theological Bookseller.

The used bookstore, the largest theological/Catholic used bookstore anywhere, was founded by a fellow named Thomas Loome, whom I ran into at the store as he picked up mail.  Now it is owned and operated by some intense young men who thoroughly know their work… and who have a fine sense of humor.

Here are a few shots, from my phone.

The store is housed in an old protestant church.

Saving Western Civilization... One Book and One Reader at a Time

You can’t even get in the entrance before the temptation begins.

I actually don’t come here very often… for obvious reasons.

Saving Western Civilization... One Book and One Reader at a Time

Liturgical books… stacks of old missals, sets of breviaries including those of religious orders, etc.

Saving Western Civilization... One Book and One Reader at a Time

Since I am particularly interested in the writings of Dante, I was delighted to find a statuette of Il Poeta poised on top of some shelves bearing works by him and about him.  I think I want this statue.

Saving Western Civilization... One Book and One Reader at a Time

Saving Western Civilization... One Book and One Reader at a Time

I mentioned a sense of humor. 

Throughout the store are prints which can be purchased and various books are placed on special display.

This can be found in the bathroom.

Saving Western Civilization... One Book and One Reader at a Time

Since the church had a dwelling for its minister and the family, the bathroom is a full bathroom, replete with bathtub, over which there are classical baptismal certificates.

They are a remarkable ancient and rare book section.

Saving Western Civilization... One Book and One Reader at a Time

A view.  You can see how they have utilized the choir loft.

Saving Western Civilization... One Book and One Reader at a Time

I spotted a hand missal in Irish.

Need a hand missal in Irish?

Saving Western Civilization... One Book and One Reader at a Time

There is so much going on at Loome’s that I will from time to time, post about this store.

You should also take a look at the Loome blog called Ex Libris Theologicis.

However, the real site for the bookstore, which has its catalogue and business stuff is HERE at loomebooks.com.

If you are ever in the area of Minneapolis/St.Paul or Western Wisconsin, you would enjoy a visit to Loome’s.

Posted in Just Too Cool, SESSIUNCULA |
5 Comments

New liturgical provisions? Maybe not.

I didn’t write on this before, though I usually follow the intrepid Andrea Tornelli when he writes about liturgical things.  Still… this struck me as a little odd, for one, and I was really busy.

Have a look at this from CNA:

Vatican denies liturgical reforms being formalized

Vatican City, Aug 24, 2009 / 05:24 pm (CNA).- The Press Office of the Holy See today denied reports in the Italian press that Pope Benedict is poised to make changes to enhance the sacredness of the liturgy.  The statement added that there are currently no institutional proposals to alter the rites being used to celebrate the Mass. [The key here is "institutional".]

The Assistant Director of the Press Office, Father Ciro Benedettini, said that "so far there are no institutional proposals for amendment of the books currently in use."

Fr. Benedettini made the statement after the Vatican watcher Andrea Tornielli wrote that the bishops who comprise the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments had voted on March 12 to recommend a series of liturgical reforms to the Pope.

Tornielli wrote that the bishops of the Congregation voted almost unanimously to “restore greater sacredness to the rite, to recover the meaning of Eucharistic adoration, to restore Latin [!] in the celebration and to revamp the introductory parts of the Missal to put an end to abuses, experimentation and inappropriate creativity.”  [hmmm]
 
The bishops also reportedly voted to reaffirm that the norm for receiving Holy Communion is on the tongue and not the hand. [Do I hear an "Amen!"?] However, noted Tornielli, some bishops’ conferences have received an indult from Rome to allow the reception of the Eucharist on the hand.

 

 Here is the deal.

We don’t need new provisions.  We need to have a few exceptions and options canceled.

We don’t need new provisions.  We need to have greater liturgical discipline and oversight from ecclesial authority.

We don’t need new provisions.  We need to stop tolerating liturgical abuses.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
25 Comments

another grrrrr update

As you know I have been having some rather serious computer problems. Last week I managed to back up some files when I had gotten it working for a while. Then it crashed again and I decided to let it rest over the weekend.

Tonight I got it working again. I used a key finder program to dig up my important program keys. Now I am doing a complete backup. Hopefully it will keep running to the end. Then I suspect I will have to reinstall everything.

grrrr

another grrrrr update

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

The end of liturgical dance

From a friend:

“If you deliver the Ammonites into my power,” he said, “whoever comes out of the doors of my house to meet me when I return in triumph from the Ammonites shall belong to the LORD. I shall offer him up as a burnt offering.” … When Jephthah returned to his house in Mizpah, it was his daughter who came forth, playing the tambourines and dancing…. At the end of the two months she returned to her father, who did to her as he had vowed.– Judges 11

 

Thus endeth the lesson.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
22 Comments

Taking notice of America taking notice of The Bitter Pill

Here is something in passing, just so you know what is going on.

This, from the leftist America magazine published by the Jesuits.  It is a piece about the recent training conference in the Archdiocese of Westminster for priests to learn the TLM.  You will recall that the new Archbishop of Westminster, Most. Rev. Vincent Nichols, wrote a foreword for the booklet published for the men who attended the training conference.  The Bitter Pill then tried to use that foreword to pit the Archbishop against Pope Benedict.

Then came the decision of H.E. Most Rev. Edward Slattery of Tulsa to celebrate only ad orientem when in his cathedral church.

Now America weighs in.

Ad Orientem, Pars Secundus  [Ummm… pars is feminine, no?  Pars Secunda?]
Posted at: 2009-08-23 15:01:12.0
Author: James Martin, S.J.

Thanks to an alert reader who spotted this in the Letters section of the London Tablet [aka RU-486].  In my earlier post on the decision of the archbishop of Tulsa to celebrate Masses ad orientem, I included the Tablet’s editorial about Archbishop Vincent Nichols’ (Westminster) communications with the Latin Mass Society, to shed light on how other bishops were approaching those who were enthusiastic about rites other than the common Mass in the vernacular (ad orientem, the Latin Mass, the "Tridentine Mass," etc.).  Now his auxiliary says that the archbishop has been misunderstood.  The Tablet is here, but I’m copying the letter below for those who don’t subscribe (though you should). [He is peddling RU-486?  Figures.]  The Tablet had praised the new archbishop for his "timely display of clear leadership."

Hereafter, Fr. Martin reproduces the letter of the Auxilliary of Westminster who clarified precisely how wrong RU-486 was in its malevolent interpretation of Archbp. Nichols aforementioned foreword.

I repeat: I think Archbp. Nichols should ask his brother bishops why any support should be given to The Tablet given their willingness to pit the Archbishop of Westminster against Pope Benedict.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
6 Comments

Chinese market

Such interesting things to try.

Chinese market

Chinese market

Chinese market

Chinese market

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
6 Comments

NCReporter whines about Bp. Slattery’s choice for “ad orientem”

From the dissenting ultra-liberal National Catholic Reporter comes this whiny piece jabbing at the Bishop of Tulsa, Most Rev. Edward Slattery, over his choice to offer Holy Mass ad orientem versus when in the cathedral.

Let’s have a look with my emphases and comments.

Okla. bishop no longer faces people at Mass
Aug. 21, 2009
By Kristen May, Religion News Service

Bishop Edward Slattery of Tulsa, Okla., will no longer face his parishioners during Mass, in an effort to “recover a more authentic Catholic worship.”  [This isn’t really an accurate statement, is it.  The Bishop has chosen ad orientem worship when at the altar, for the Eucharistic Prayer, etc.  There are going to many times when he is, yes, "facing the people".]

[Let us now see just how confused this really is….]  Since the Second Vatican Council in the 1960’s, Catholic Mass has been preformed [sic] in the local language and with the priest facing the congregation. [The Council documents say that Latin must be preserved and and the rubrics of the Missale Romanum assume that Mass is ad orientem, but, keep reading…] In a July 2007 decree, however, Pope Benedict XVI offered priests the option of celebrating the so-called “old Latin Mass.”  [Is that what it is called?  And, as I scratch my head, what does that have to do with Bishop Slattery’s decision?  Bishop Slattery is talking about his celebrations of the Novus Ordo.  Still, to be fair, perhaps this whole thing is a result of the gravitational pull we know had to result from the provisions of Summorum Pontificum.]

Slattery, in the September issue of the Eastern Oklahoma Catholic magazine, said Vatican II misplaced the crucial “orientation” (direction) of worship for Catholics.  [Is that what the Bishop said, Kristen?  Bp. Slattery said that Vatican II screwed things up?  I don’t think so.  He actually said that this was an innovation introduced after the Council.]

“The priest faces the people while the people face the priest, even though the Eucharistic prayer is directed to the Father and not to the people,” says Slattery in his From the Bishop article.

Although both the Latin Mass and the Vatican II Mass are currently acceptable within the Catholic Church, the pope does not want to divide the church based on those who face the congregation and those who do not.  [… ?!?… Can anyone tell me what that meant?  Can it be… that… she thinks that the older form, the TLM must be said ad orientem and the Novus Ordo must be "facing the people"?]

Echoing that sentiment, Slattery does not want his congregation to feel slighted by the change of orientation.

“This change ought not to be misconstrued as the bishop `turning his back on the faithful,’ as if I am being inconsiderate or hostile,” he wrote.

The change [Please consider that "the change" was actually the turning around of the altars and Mass "facing the people".  This is a correction rather than a change.] is not being enforced in other Oklahoma parishes. Slattery mentions only that he will revive the forward-facing position at the cathedral in Tulsa.  [And I believe only when he is at the cathedral.  If I read his article correctly, I believe he is making this decision for his own Masses, and not necessarily for the other Masses at the cathedral, though I sincerely hope that is what happens!]

The most interesting thing in this odd little piece is the connection made between Summorum Pontificum and ad orientem worship.

Despite the strange reasoning here, the little article reveals that the Holy Father’s "Marshall Plan" to revitalize our Catholic identity is actually getting some traction… and the liberals don’t like it.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA, The Drill |
45 Comments

QUAERITUR: Sunday’s Mass on Monday

From a reader:

A local parish has a Spanish-language Mass on Monday night, but uses Sunday’s liturgy.  Is this ever allowed, even with a dispensation?  If so, would it fulfill one’s Sunday obligation?  It seems very strange to me.

 

When there is no saint or other feast celebrated during the week days, you can use the previous Sunday’s Mass formulary, though you wouldn’t use the Gloria or Creed or Sunday Preface and you use the proper readings assigned for that week day.

However, you don’t fulfill your Sunday Mass obligation on Monday, right?  You fulfill your Sunday obligation on Sunday, or the Saturday evening which – liturgically speaking – is already considered to be Sunday.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
6 Comments