Any good news?

I need some, even if it is someone else’s.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
19 Comments

QUAERITUR: the bishop/priest ignores the Pope

From a reader:

In our parish in the diocese of ___ our parish priest announced that until further notice there would be no Holy Communion given on the tongue nor would there be a kiss of peace.

When I spoke to him afterwards although he had every sympathy with us he said he must be obedient to the Bishop.The Bishop however is still allowing Holy Communion under both kinds which doesn’t make a great deal of sense to me. Please could you tell us if the Bishop can legally do this. I have never received Holy Communion in the hand.

…

Since our Bishop ignores the wishes of The Holy Father are we obliged to obey our Bishop ?

 

I think you at least are obliged not simply to defy the bishop.

I don’t know how to answer these questions except to suggest what I have suggested several times before in regard to Communion in the hand issues… in time of "plague", or whatever this is.

First, Redemptionis Sacramentum says that people may not be denied Communion on the tongue.  Diocesan bishops do not have the authority to override this, since it is something determined by the Holy See.

On the other hand, common sense must be used.  There may be legitimate special circumstances why what the bishop says is a good thing to follow.

I am not an epidemiologist.

If you have had some recourse to the bishop or the bishop has pretty much made it plain that he is not interested in speaking more about this issue, then you can always avail yourself of your right to connect Rome and ask for a clarification, sending copies of your correspondence.

Again, this is one of those situations in which common sense must prevail.

Also, this affords everyone the opportunity to clarify precisely what the law of the Church is in this regard. 

You can use the circumstances to put good information into – sorry about this – people’s hands.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, SESSIUNCULA |
2 Comments

While I was away…

… "something" happened here. 

I am guessing something weather related has knocked down my main computer.

I have already spent quite a bit of time trying to recover it.

Things are not looking good.

Sign from God? 

Grrrr

It always seems that these things happen when I am away.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on While I was away…

On my way

It was an early rise this morning for the sake of the airport.

Father Basden, the great pastor of St. Bede’s – long may and his tribe he thrive – was the consummate host during my time here. He even made sure – Bless Him – I would be fortified with strong coffee and toast with marmelade!

On my way

On the way to the airport we passed by a sight which was quite common during my sojourn: the Clapham South tube station.

BTW… I eventually asked the station manager there about their penchant for playing Gregorian chant or Beethoven over the PA. He said that the music was assigned centrally, that they didn’t choose their own music. I found that rather interesting. Still, I recall now that in the USA there are some cities wherein, in places where rapscallions might congregate and, subsequently, think about mischief, speakers were wired up and tunes suitable to the Lawrence Welk crowd were played. The rapscallions would very quickly cease to congregate in those places and go elsewhere. I am supposing that the same theory applied to the tube station.

On my way

No problems on the way to Heathrow. The trip took 35 minutes… at this early hour, that is.

On my way

Problems, however, began at Heathrow. Surprised?

First there was the queue for the queue to which I was directed by a very officious and self-confident young lady. Incorrectly directed, I might add. I rapidly figured that one out. I had already checked in via internet and printed my pass. All I had to do was check my bag. I had mentioned that, of course, but… well…. Having spotted the BAG DROP sign where there was another, shorter queue, I thus jumped out of the queue’s queue for the check in and queued in the bag drop queue, which didn’t have a queue for its queue. About ten minutes later I was through and on to security.

“But Father! But Father!”, you are no doubt saying. “THAT doesn’t sound like much of a problem! Why are complaining about problems when so far it has been smooth sailing?”

Aside from the fact that the queue (yes… I simply like typing that word) to which I was officiously and officially directed was the wrong queue, and it began as a queue for another queue – did I mention that? – and that I would still be out there now, had I not worked the problem, at the very counter itself I was issued a new boarding pass.

“Hmmm…” quoth I.

Apparently, my flight will be delayed a couple hours because of a late arrival. That will make my connection on the other end a little sporty depending on how security goes on Stateside Terra Firma.

At least there is a good lounge here. The Sky Team lounge at Heathrow is by far better than any of the increasingly dismal Delta, etc., lounges at US airports. Hands down.

And the wifi here is excellent, so far.

On my way

I can pick up my SlingBox perfectly… which I haven’t really had much chance to look at in the last couple weeks, and thus tap back in to the secular news.

On my way

On my way

On my way

On my way

On my way

On my way

UPDATE

After hours of unexplained, rolling delays, we have boarded.

UPDATE

Back in the USA, I am rebooked and waiting for my last leg to take off!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
12 Comments

Caunterbury

And specially from every shires ende
Of Engelond, to Caunterbury they wende,
The hooly blisful martir for to seke
That hem hath holpen, whan that they were seeke
.

Caunterbury

Caunterbury

Caunterbury

Caunterbury

Caunterbury

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
6 Comments

Aylesford

A stop at Aylesford. Reclaimed for God after its theft. Here are the relics of St. Simon Stock.

Aylesford

Aylesford

Aylesford

Aylesford

Aylesford 

Aylesford 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
6 Comments

Interesting letter from the PCED to a Brazilian questioner

Interesting letter from the PCED to a Brazilian questionerFrom a reader I received a rather difficult to use transcript of a letter from the new de facto head of the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei, now under the guidance of Msgr. Guido Pozzo for His Eminence Card. Levada, Prefect of the CDF and Pres. of the PCED.

I smoothed out the format to make it more readable.  There was a of the letter. 

Original questions (in portuguese, then translation).  My emphases:

1 – Após ter entrado em vigor o Motu Proprio “Summorum Pontificum”, é necessária a permissão do Bispo Diocesano para que algum padre possa celebrar a Missa Gregoriana?

[After being in effect the Motu Proprio "Summorum Pontificum", is it necessary the permission of the Diocesan Bishop so that any priest can celebrate the Gregorian Mass?]

2 – Os fiéis devem dominar a língua latina para poderem assistir a Missa Gregoriana? Ou bastaria apenas um folheto do missal em formato bilíngue (Latim – Português) para que os fiéis possam assistí-la?

[The faithful must dominate the latin language to be able to attend the Gregorian Mass? Or it is sufficient only a single pamphlete of the missal in bilingual format (Latin – Portuguese) so that the faithful can attend it?]

3 – Um grupo pequeno de fiéis (por exemplo: 8 pessoas), embora seja estável, é insuficiente para que seja celebrada a Missa na Forma Extraordinária?

[A small group of faithful (for example: 8 people), although stable, is insufficient for the celebration of the Mass in the Extraordinary Form?]

4 – O Bispo Diocesano deve cooperar para que o pedido de Missa Gregoriana feito por um grupo estável de fiéis seja realizado?

[The Diocesan Bishop must cooperate so that the request for the Gregoriam Mass made by a stable group of faithful be fulfilled?]

5 – Os fiéis que não fazem parte do grupo estável poderão assistir a Missa Gregoriana?

[The faithful that don’t make part of the stable group will be able to attend the Gregorian Mass?]

6 – Poderão ser realizados matrimônios na Forma Extraordinária do Rito Romano?

[May marriages be done in the Extraordinary Form of the Roman Rite?]

7 – Com a publicação do Motu Proprio “Summorum Pontificum”, o Papa Bento XVI deseja que a Missa Gregoriana seja amplamente ofertada nas Dioceses?

[With the publication of the Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum, the Pope Benedict XVI desires that the Gregorian Mass be widely offered in the Dioceses?]

8 – O Santo Padre deseja que o ensino do Latim volte a fazer parte do currículo dos seminários para que os futuros padres possam celebrar Missas na língua latina?

[The Holy Father desires that the teaching of Latin do come back of the seminaries’ curriculum so that the future priests may be able to celebrate Masses in latin language?]

9 – Os Bispos Diocesanos devem seguir as orientações da Comissão Pontifícia Ecclesia Dei sobre a aplicação do Motu Proprio “Summorum Pontificum” mesmo que o Núncio Apostólico no Brasil possa, hipoteticamente, emitir opinião contrária?

[ The Diocesan Bishops must follow the orientations of the Pontifical Comission Ecclesia Dei about the application of the Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum even though the Apostolic Nuncio in Brazil may, hypothetically, issue a contrary opinion? ]

The answers were given in Portuguese, the originals are on the scanned letter, the translation is below:

"Protocol 97/09
Vatican, July 18th 2009

Mr. X,

To the questions on your letter from April 29 2009, it is answered, according to the Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum, what follows:

1 – The Pontifical Document doesn’t foresee a special permission of the Diocesan Bishop so that any priest celebrates the Holy Mass in the extraordinary form (art. 2);

2 – The faithful are not required to have wide knowledge of the latin language, being sufficient to have any bilingual missal or a leaflet;

3 – The number of faithful in the stable group depends much on the local circumstances, which will show if a priest may or want, albeit his pastoral duties, to occupy himself with a so small group.

4 – The diocesan bishop must be in agreement with the directives set forth in the pontifical document (art 5 par 1; and CIC c. 392); other thing is to verify the effective practicability, in according to the provisions of the Motu Proprio.

5 – The faithful who don’t make part of the stable group may, obviously [evidently], participate in the mass in the Extraordinary Form.

6 – The marriages according to the Extraordinary Form are possible, depending on the parish pastor (art. 9, par. 1);

7 – About the wide application of the pontifical document in a diocese, it is just necessary to follow the indications in the own document.

8- About the teaching of latin in the seminaries, refer to the always valid rule of the current Code of Canon Law, c. 249 (follows the citation in the original latin with "lingua latina bene calleant" in bold.

[Note of the translator: question 9 has not been answered in this letter]

In all other questions, the pontifical document will always be quoted, being the Holy Father the supreme Ecclesiastic authority, to whom, by divine institution, we are linked by love, respect, obedience.

Esteems, etc. – Signs Msg. Guido Pozzo

 

Even though this transcript is a little messy, you get a strong sense of what the lay questioner has been experiencing from clerics in his area.

This also gives us a sense of the general orientation of the new leadership of the Pontifical Commission "Ecclesia Dei".  Among the various things this tells us is the important fact that Msgr. Pozzo is responding to correspondence.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, Brick by Brick, SESSIUNCULA, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
2 Comments

Prayer Request

I received some very bad news.

May I ask your prayers for an intention?

Thanks!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Prayer Request

Off to Blackfen! Fr. Finigan’s Silver Jubilee!

UPDATE:

More at the blog of His Hermeneuticalness HERE and HERE.

Check also:

Mulier Fortis
Bara Brith
Singulare Ingenium

St Mary Magdalen, Brighton
Roman Christendom
Puella Paschalis
That the bones you have crushed may thrill
Catholic Commentary

______________

We are off to the event! A few of us jumped up to the upper deck of our Routemaster RM5.

Off to Blackfen! Fr. Finigan's Silver Jubilee!

Off to Blackfen! Fr. Finigan's Silver Jubilee!

Off to Blackfen! Fr. Finigan's Silver Jubilee!

Off to Blackfen! Fr. Finigan's Silver Jubilee!

Off to Blackfen! Fr. Finigan's Silver Jubilee!

Off to Blackfen! Fr. Finigan's Silver Jubilee!

Off to Blackfen! Fr. Finigan's Silver Jubilee!

Off to Blackfen! Fr. Finigan's Silver Jubilee!

Off to Blackfen! Fr. Finigan's Silver Jubilee!

Off to Blackfen! Fr. Finigan's Silver Jubilee!

Off to Blackfen! Fr. Finigan's Silver Jubilee!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

QUAERITUR: “pro multis” and validity

From a reader:

I’ve not written to you before, but I’m really looking for some help here.  I am from England.  I go to the Traditional Mass, which I love, at the London Oratory every Saturday and Sunday, and the Latin Novus Ordo in the week, when possible, also at the Oratory.  Very occasionally, when I am away from home, I attend the Novus Ordo in the vernacular.  I recently got a book by Father Paul L Kramer, B.Ph., S.T.B., M. Div., S.T.L (Cand) called "The Suicide of altering the Faith in the Liturgy".  I was very disturbed when I read it.  Trying to find some further advice/guidance, I found your four articles on the ‘Pro Multis’ issue, https://wdtprs.com/category/wdtprs/pro-multis which I read.  Fr Kramer’s book is very worrying to say the least [I think not.]  . . . in light of what you have written in your four articles, what do you make of this paragraph from the book?
 
"It needs to be emphasised that a Mass which is probably invalid or even probably valid, even if there is a relatively high probability of validity, is totally and gravely illicit, since the Church’s moral doctrine, set forth by Pope Innocent XI (see Footnote) clearly forbids probably valid sacraments.  Thus, it is gravely sinful (in the objective moral order) for anyone to celebrate or attend Mass when the vernacular expression "for all" is used in the consecration of the chalice, since that formula of consecration is not certainly valid . . . "
 
Footnote:- "In conferring the sacraments, as also in the consecration in the Mass, it is never allowed to adopt a probable course of action as to validity and to abandon the safer course.  The contrary was explicitly condemned by Pope Innocent XI (1670-1676)" – Fr Henry Davis, S.J. Moral and Pastoral Theology, v.3, p27.
 
I would be grateful for some advice.  I know that you say that the term "For All" doesn’t invalidate the Mass, but I wondered what you made of the above quotation.  Some friends of mine advise that I should go to the SSPX . . . I don’t know what to do sometimes.

What do I make of the quotation?  I suggest that Fr. Kramer has very little standing to make any such interpretation.

Paul VI and John Paul II were Popes.  They were no less Popes than Innocent XI.  They promulgated the post-Conciliar editions of the Missal.  Popes don’t give Holy Church Missals with texts for invalid Masses. You might not like what they promulgated in every respect, but the Masses are not invalid.  You might think that the texts of the previous Missal were superior, but the newer texts are not invalid.

Fr. Kramer’s insinuations were imprudent.

People can argue about whether or not the texts of the Novus Ordo rite of Mass are good, or whether they convey a somewhat different theology than that of the older, pre-Conciliar Missale Romanum.  People can like or not like, for various reasons, the Novus Ordo.  But it is wrong to say that Mass with the post-Conciliar editions is invalid.  To do so implies that you think your own authority is above that of the Vicar of Christ. 

I will be delighted with the new translation of the Novus Ordo is released, with its correct rendering of pro multis, and this tired controversy is put to rest.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, PRO MULTIS, SESSIUNCULA |
14 Comments