QUAERITUR: reconsecration of a ciboration as others are consecrated?

From a reader:

I was at Mass a little early today and noticed that a few lay helpers approached the tabernacle, and then I watched as they took a ciborium back to the narthex where the rest the of the gifts were waiting for the presentation later during Mass. Is this normal? I would believe that unconsecrated hosts used during Mass would have originated from the sacristy and not the Tabernacle. Did I just witness them try to reconsecrate already consecrated hosts?!
 
Thanks in advance for any info Father. If that’s the case I will be contacting the Bishop immediately.

A few things strike me about this.

First, it is all a little vague.

I don’t know what you saw.  You too, apparently, don’t know what you saw.

And yet you are pretty worked up about it, it seems.

Do you really think that some priest would be trying to consecrate consecrated Hosts?

That said, it would be very incorrect to have ciboria of consecrated Hosts on the altar in full view at the time of the consecration, or that they should be brought to the altar at the time of the offertory.   It would cause people to wonder… as you are wondering.

Back to your observations.  If this happens all the time at Mass, and this can be documentation, then something ought to be done about it.

You see… even if you don’t really know what happened, if it were to be repeated, there might be a very grave abuse going on.  In no way should the impression be given that any Host have to be reconsecrated for that Mass.  That would be a sort of Lutheran thing to do.  While they believe that their eucharist has somehow the presence of Christ together with the bread and wine, after that presence is no longer need, it is not there.  You have simple bread and wine again, which you could return to the bottle or basket or reuse if need be.  Some Lutherans are become more strongly sacramental about their eucharist, but this is generally the way it goes.

God forbid that any Catholic priest should ever develop any practice that might cause people to wonder about his sacramental theology.

If you were to see this again, I might approach the pastor/priest and ask what happened.  You might follow up his answer (if it indeed tells you something strange) with a letter just to get things straight.  Then you have a start of some documentation before you involve the bishop.

Of course if the guy is entirely off the wall and uncooperative, then the bishop must be contacted right away, as well, perhaps, as the CDW.

But I would admonish you: sometimes people think they see something and they didn’t.  Sometimes people think they understood what what they saw, but didn’t.

Check yourself before huffing and puffing.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, SESSIUNCULA |
2 Comments

Lifesite interview with Card Canizares: Save the Liturgy – Save the World

Lifesite hLifesite interview with Card Canizares: Save the Liturgy - Save the Worldas a transcript of an interview with His Eminence Antonio Card. Cañizares Llovera, Prefect of the Cong. for Divine Worship.

 

Formerly Archbishop of Toledo, Spain, Cardinal Cañizares is the current Prefect of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, that has competence over the way in which Mass is celebrated throughout the world. He was elevated to the cardinalate in 2006 by Pope Benedict XVI.

ROME, Italy, July 27, 2009 (LifeSiteNews.com) – With the help of a translator, the Cardinal kindly consented to speak with LifeSiteNews.com on July 24th at the offices of the Congregation on the Via della Conciliazione in Rome, down the road from St. Peter’s Basilica and the Apostolic Palace.

* * *

LSN: What is the connection between faithfulness to the norms of the liturgy and faithfulness to the Church’s moral teachings?

Cardinal Canizares Llovera: There is no doubt about the connection.

To recognise what is the Eucharist is to recognise Jesus Christ. Jesus Christ is the Son of God that became man. Christ is the most absolute ‘yes’ of God to man. He is the revelation of God and the revelation of the truth about man. Man cannot be separated from God; man was created in the image and likeness of God.

In creation, God manifests Himself as love in favour of man. In His Son, the true image of the Father, we have been created in the image of the Son. For that reason, all human beings have a greatness and a dignity that cannot be separated or violated.

Jesus Christ shows the face of God that loves man to the utter extremes. The biggest demonstration of this love of Jesus for Man is seen on the cross, dying for man. But this love could not be destroyed or chained by death. It has triumphed over death. The love of Jesus, Son of God, brought to an extreme on the cross, shows how all men are loved by God with a love from which nothing and no one can separate us. Each man has been saved or repurchased by the blood of Christ, which is the blood of God. This is how much every human being is worth, the blood of God. [The Cardinal points out that God loves man so much that He deigned to shed His Blood for him.  However, I think it is useful to point out that that phrase "This is how much every being is worth", might be over stating it is.  The fact is that nothing human is on the same level of "worth" as the divine, even the divine which is also human.  With that slight caveat, let’s get to the important conclusion the Cardinal wants to make:]

For that reason, between the Eucharist and the defence of life there is a link that cannot be separated. To live the Eucharist, is to enter in communion with Jesus Christ and as a consequence with His love. This is a communion of life and makes us participate in the life which is Christ. Divine life, eternal life, but at the same time it makes us be givers or carriers of love and defenders of life. [Note the connection of Eucharist and a consequence.  Let’s take "Eucharist" as being not only the Blesses Sacrament Itself but also the celebration of the Eucharist, which is Holy Mass.  The "Eucharist" in this sense is, as the Second Vatican Council stated, the "source and summit".]

If the Christians would live all that the Eucharist means, we would be defenders of life in every moment.

LSN: We were wondering since the issue is very serious in the US and growing more so in Britain and Canada if there is planned a definitive statement or teaching on the reception of Communion by politicians and public figures who reject the Church’s teaching on life. The issue still hasn’t been resolved since the US election in 2004. [A great question!]

Cardinal Canizares Llovera: I think that the strongest words are found in St. Paul: one who goes to the Eucharist and is not properly prepared, duly prepared, "he eats his own condemnation." This is the strongest thing that we can say and what is the most truthful statement.

When the Church states that to take part in or request an abortion, to take an active role in one way or the other, the person incurs automatically excommunication. This means that politicians should become aware and they should be helped to become aware of the gravity of their conduct. When they approve laws against life, in favour of abortion or euthanasia, priest and bishops should say this.

I don’t know if there’s going to be a document on the politicians who are in favour of abortion, [He doesn’t know this… but he mentions it…. why…?] but the politicians have to be conscious of the teachings of the Church that I have just pointed out.

LSN: There’s a conflict in the US now. There are some bishops who are saying they will speak to, educate and address the issue with these people but they refuse to refuse. Others are saying, ‘No, you may not receive Communion in my diocese". How is that conflict going to be resolved?

Lifesite interview with Card Canizares: Save the Liturgy - Save the WorldCardinal Canizares Llovera: I cannot judge one group of bishops or the other group of bishops but I think that all of us know what has to be done, or should be done. In the presence of cases of public sinners … at the same time we don’t know what is happening in the consciences of those politicians. [That’s right.  We don’t.  But do we have to?  We see their actions.  When their actions have been seen by everyone, when they are public, they have committed public scandal.  That must be repaired in a similarly public way.  It seems to me that a bishop could deny Communion to a very visible and public pro-abortion Catholic politician, even one who has privately repented his views, on the grounds that he has not yet taken steps to repair the public scandal he caused.]  I understand the prudence with which we have to act. But I think also that it is our duty to clarify their consciences. To help the person to act in accordance with a right and true conscience. Bishops have a function to help the due formation of conscience. To form consciences in such a way that people should act in accordance with the truth. [His Eminence was, until recently, also Archbishop of Toledo.  I don’t know enough about what happened in Spain, in Toledo, with the problem of pro-abortion Catholic public figures, but I wonder how Card. Canizares handled the situation or what he said at the level of the Spanish bishops conference.]

The pope JPII in his encyclical Evangelium Vitae offers criteria that show how politicians should act with regards to the questions of life. Also the congregation of the Doctrine of the Faith published an instruction when Cardinal Ratzinger was the prefect on the way politicians should act on these questions of life. Also the most recent encyclical of Pope Benedict XVI, when he was referring to abortion offers criteria in such a way that politicians should act in accordance with truth.

I believe that the Pauline principle, that gives the title to the most recent encyclical of Benedict XVI, Caritas in Veritate, should be the principle that guides us to speak about this question. This principle, Caritas in Veritate [Love in Truth] should be the principle first for politicians when they come to Communion, and second it should be the rule for bishops when they decide to give or to withdraw Communion.

LSN: Is there a movement in the Vatican to return to the traditional manner of reception of Communion? (With the recipient kneeling and the host placed directly on the tongue.)

Cardinal Canizares Llovera: There is no resolution that forbids giving Communion in the mouth. [Except, Your Eminence, where some local bishops are doing just that, right?]  In the same way, there is no norm that forbids Communion in the hand. [Hmmm… in a sense there is, no?  The norm is that Communion is to be received on the tongue and there is presently an exception for that norm in those places where local bishops permit the exception to be applied.] Neither can be forbidden. Neither one nor the other. [Well… Redemptionis Sacramentum 92 states that it is not to be give where there is risk of profanation.] This means that Communion in the mouth has a long history and tradition that expresses in a profound way the sense of adoration, reverence in the presence of the body of Christ. Everything that is at stake in the real presence of Christ. If Communion in the mouth goes with the gesture of kneeling, it expresses in a stronger way, with stronger force, the real presence of Christ, the sense of adoration, the participation in the body of Christ that offers Himself for us. [Sooo… if this is the better way to do it… why isn’t it the only norm?]

If the papal liturgy is a sign, an indication for all the Church, we should promote Communion kneeling and in the mouth. But, this does not mean not permitting or forbidding Communion in the hand if it is done with due respect. [Though clearly this is a "weaker way, with weaker force", right?] With a previous gesture of adoration. This could be kneeling, or a genuflection or with a deep bow. And also in the moment of receiving Communion, the right hand should be placed under the left hand forming a cross expressing in this way the recognition of the real presence of the body of Christ offered for us. We should take care that no particle should be lost. [Harder to do with Communion in the hand though, right?] And the body of Christ should be received in front of the priest.

We should recognise that frequently Communion in the hand many times is not received in this way.

It is very lamentable. [So lamentable that maybe we should… I don’t know… do something about it?  Just askin’.]

LSN: We know that over the years a great many people have seen and complained about abuses of the liturgy at Mass. What can the faithful do when they see these?

Cardinal Canizares Llovera: They should say to the priest immediately after Mass as a part of fraternal correction. [Hmmm… I am not trying to be contrary, but it seems to me that people often think some things which are actually right are wrong.] If it is not possible, they should say to the bishop. If the bishop does not act, they should come here and report it to the Congregation. [And Redemptionis Sacramentum also says that people can always have direct recourse to the Holy See.]

There are two documents that are important. One by the Cong. for Divine Worship, Redemptionis Sacramentum, that talks about some of these abuses and talks about the rights of the faithful and how they should act.

The other is Sacramentum Caritatis, of Benedict XVI that also gives criteria on the way that the Eucharist is abused. [As well as guidelines for better celebration.]

Lifesite interview with Card Canizares: Save the Liturgy - Save the WorldWe should all fight to avoid abuses against the Eucharist. It is the holiest, greatest, most important [thing] in the Church and in life. We should respect the Eucharist and the rules and discipline of the Church that give the warranty of ecclesial communion that has its sources, its roots, its truth in the Eucharist, in the celebration of the Eucharist, in the rite that the Church has indicated.

LSN: Is the liturgical revolution over? Is the Church in general becoming more balanced about the liturgy?

We’re still suffering it but also we are in a moment of great hope. The Pope Benedict XVI makes the renewal of the spirit of liturgy to rekindle in the conscience of all the true sense of the liturgy. [As a matter of fact, I think it is clear that Pope Benedict has a plan for the revitalization of the Church.  I call it his "Marshall Plan".] Which should help to impose a great new unstoppable liturgical movement. ["a great new unstoppable liturgical movement"] Nevertheless, [get this…] we have not yet applied in a truthful way the teachings of Vatican II read in continuity with the tradition of the Church. [Exactly.] This is the commitment of this congregation continuing the [work of the] Holy Father that presides over us in faith and charity and over the whole Church.

We want a Church that should be present in the world, [or, active in the public square…] that is ready to transform the world and [lead] the renewal of mankind in accordance with God’s will. Lifesite interview with Card Canizares: Save the Liturgy - Save the WorldThis will not be possible without Sacrosanctum Concilium, without liturgy, adoration,  without putting God in the centre of all, living of God’s gift, and offering Him whatever we are in order to bring about His will.

In other words, there is no new humanity [This is an important point.  Progressivists are very keen on claiming that modern man is "all grown up" now.  We don’t have to do childish things such as kneel.  We are now homo sapiens sapiens.  Aren’t we special now?  But Card. Canizares is exactly right.  Change as we may through various advancements, human beings remain fundamentally the same.] and there is no hope for man that is not grounded in God that would come from God and would return everything to God as His glory. The future of humanity is in the liturgy. When we read the last encyclical of the Holy Father, we can understand that the liturgy occupies a central role in the concerns of the Holy Father.

Lifesite interview with Card Canizares: Save the Liturgy - Save the World

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
1 Comment

Fr. Bux on the manner of reception of Holy Communion

The great Fr. Nicola Bux has excellent comments about the reception of Holy Communion.  They are posted (back on 20 July) on the Italian language site Pontifex.Roma.

He makes the observation that reception of Holy Communion standing is not necessarily bad.  It can be reverent, especially when received with a proper understanding, signs of reverence, head coverings for women, etc.  But often it seems as if people are queuing for buffet.

Furthermore, people often go to Communion rather mechanically, without a sense of what they are about or what Communion is.

Reception of Holy Communion kneeling could be a real help for a return to greater understanding and devotion.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

Save The Liturgy – Save The World

Save The Liturgy - Save The World

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Save The Liturgy – Save The World

First impression of a TLM

From a reader:

To begin with, I was born in the late 1970’s in the Milwaukee Archdiocese, so I’ve had my share of erroneous interpretation and liturgical abuse.  I have also found small bastions of the OF ["Ordinary Form" or Novus Ordo] celebrated with an attempt towards dignity.

I also am aware of the complaints that some of my older relatives had towards the EF, [Extraordinary Form or "old Mass" or Traditional Latin Mass] namely the incomprehensibility of Latin.  [NB: Not the fault of the Mass.] I have learned some in high school, but I am awfully rusty.  I went without a Missal.

So, with that in mind, I went to a Low Mass this morning. 

My first impression when I walked in the door was, "good, I’m not late".  My second was, "hmm…lots of reserved signs for small children".  The back half was, in fact, entirely reserved for such.  It took me some time to run the numbers in the back of my head before Mass began.  There were probably a little over a hundred people there, at least ten of which were less than a year old.  That is probably the same number of infants in a given Mass in my parish of a thousand families.  I also noted that the vast majority of adults attending were my age or younger.  It is just stunning to see people actually serious about the hard parts of their Faith.  [A common experience for new comers: they are amazed at the number of young people, young families.]

The Church is beautiful, perhaps not a masterpiece of art and splendour, but nothing to laugh at either.  I’d certainly prefer to be there today than the Cathedral in terms of ambiance.  [Especially after what Archbp. Weakland did to it.]

Father speaks a few announcements, and I notice a heavy French accent, though not Parisian.  This might be odd, and a little tough, but I’ve comprehended worse.

Mass begins, and I am rather taken aback by how quickly he speaks the prayers.  I may be rusty, but I have enormous difficulty even catching individual words.  There are no breaks except when he moves from book to book.  I ask myself, "how does he breath?" [Yes… I think this is a legitimate criticism.  Sometimes priests don’t account for the fact that the prayers are language and not merely formulas.]

We then hear the reading, Gospel and Homily.  I’d say it is a very solid homily, especially for one of the more difficult Gospels.  He wasn’t Fulton Sheen, but I do wish such homilies were more common.  [Not many priests are.] Even so, he does speak longer than the average OF homily.

For the most part, I can ape through the various postures,  though the genuflections are a bit akward (I’m a big guy, so it takes a little longer). 

By the time Communion begins, I rue that I didn’t sit further back.  I’ve never received Communion like this before. [!] I thankfully figured out that my hands must be beneath the cloth when I receive the Sacrament in time.  My mind is still racing while I get up that I go back to my pew the wrong way.  I felt silly by the time I figured this out, but that’s just how it goes.  Oh well.   [Yes.  But the next time will be much easier.]

Mass concludes, and I am still reeling.  I pray for a little, then leave quietly.  On my way out I notice a rack of pamphlets.  There is one that catches my eye – an encyclical concerning atheistic communism.  I didn’t know if I had to pay for any of these, as this one was rather thick.  It would be an interesting read, and it’s a shame that it has been forgotten as much as H.V.

All in all, it was a positive experience.  Even so, I kinda wished Father hadn’t rattled off the prayers quite so much. 

It is always interesting to hear or read first impressions of the older form, especially from people who are young enough not to have known it at all when growing up.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
9 Comments

Supper Monday

I am thinking La Porte des Indes on Bryanston Street: 7-ish.

UPDATE

After my errand, I dashed to Marble Arch for my supper appointment.

Now in the bar for g&t with two WDTPRSers!

Supper Monday

Supper Monday

Supper Monday

Supper Monday

Supper Monday

Supper Monday

Supper Monday

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Supper Monday

Best (modern) painting in Britain?

Perhaps.

Best (modern) painting in Britain?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
3 Comments

QUAERITUR: Rosary during Mass

From a reader:

Is it okay to say the rosary at Low Mass?  My Latin is proficient enough to the point where I’ve moved beyond having to rely on a missal.  What would be the harm of saying a rosary as a meditation on Jesus through Mary?  At Dialogue Mass I always stop my rosary when I say the server’s responses.  I don’t understand why some people are very much against people praying rosaries at Masses.  Some even say that bringing a rosary to Mass scandalizes others!  I think that private devotions can also bring a person closer to the sacrifice.    

 

I don’t think saying the Holy Rosary during Mass is a bad thing.

I think there are more perfect ways of participating.  I generally think that remaining in the texts of Mass is better during Mass.

But, that said, there is not simply one acceptable manner of active participation at Mass.  People can choose now this, now that method.  You can following the texts closely.  You can follow commentaries on the parts of Mass, sometimes in hand missals.  You can say the Rosary.  You can pray according to the four classic points of prayer: glorification of God, prayers of sorrow for sins, petitions, expressions of thanksgiving.  You can focus on a sacred image.

Perhaps on this day you will need this method, and on that day some other.

What I would try to avoid is distraction.  Your fruitful participation can be aided by having a regular routine, or even perhaps a bit of a plan before you go to church for Mass.  Knowing what you are going to do today can help.

People have different spiritual needs when they enter the sacred precincts of the church.  Different methods of participation can help them in the exigencies they are facing. 

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box |
7 Comments

A favorite place

A favorite place

A favorite place

A favorite place

A favorite place

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
4 Comments

Supper tonight?

Thinking ahead, anyone want to meet for supper in central London?

Otherwise I may just have a snack and head home.

Might be good to think about that now.

SMS me!

____

UPDATE

Lunch

Supper tonight?

As I eat I am listening to an audio book of Reverse Of The Medal at the point when Jack is in the Marshalsea! I should have eaten in Borough near St George!

Supper tonight?

Supper tonight?

Supper tonight?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
2 Comments