Changes at Basilica of Holy Cross of Jerusalem in Rome due to “liturgical abuses”

I picked up from the Papa Ratzinger blog, an Italian site, that at the Basilica of the Holy Cross of Jerusalem in Rome, a basilica of profound historical importance, the Cistercian Abott of the monastery has been removed as the pastor of the parish and the pastoral care of the basilica has been removed from the Cistercians.

One of the reasons cite: liturgical abuses.

ABUSI LITURGICI: COMMISSARIATA S. CROCE IN GERUSALEMME

(AGI) – CdV, 4 giu.

Una visita canonica inviata dalla Santa Sede ha deciso la sostituzione dell’abate di Santa Croce in Gerusalemme, padre Simone Fioraso.
Il vicario di Roma, card. Agostino Vallini, nominera’ a breve un sacerdote della diocesi come parroco in quanto la comunita’ dei cistercensi non ha nella Capitale forze sufficienti per garantire la cura della parrocchia annessa al Monastero. Lo ha confermato all’Agi mons. Marco Fibbi, direttore dell’ufficio Comunicazioni Sociali della diocesi di Roma. Padre Domenico Paccherini resta invece priore dei monaci e rappresentante legale.
I rilievi mossi all’abate riguarderebbero abusi liturgici e la conduzione della Comunita’.
La Basilica aveva ospitato in ottobre l’iniziativa "La Bibbia giorno e notte", lettura integrale della Sacra Scrittura promossa dalla struttura Rai Vaticano, manifestazione che era stata aperta con un collegamento con il Papa in Vaticano e chiusa dal segretario di Stato Tarcisio Bertone.
Ed e’ nota anche per il coro delle "Matite Colorate", il cui direttore artistico, fanno sapere gli organizzatori, rimane il cistercense padre Luca Zecchetto.

 

Followup articles in Italian:

Messa In Latino

Repubblica

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
37 Comments

Need to refresh your Vatican batteries?

Need to refresh your Vatican batteries?When you simply have to know about the weather in the Vatican City State.

Need to refresh your Vatican batteries?

And when you need a view of St. Peter’s Square.

Need to refresh your Vatican batteries?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

Gate of Heaven – 20 years today

Catholics used to put the words Porta Caeli over the doors of their churches.

But another gate, the Gate of Heavenly Peace or Tian’anmén was the site of a terrible thing 20 years ago.

Gate of Heaven - 20 years today

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
15 Comments

Request to readers about Confirmation preparation materials

Would you readers, priests and lay people alike, do me a favor?

Post here suggestions and reviews of good materials for preparation both of young people and adults for the Sacrament of Confirmation.

This might be a helpful resource!

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes |
31 Comments

QUAERITUR: Communion for a non-celebrating priest

From a priest reader:

Perhaps you or your readers could help me with a question regarding communion etiquette for priests in the Ordinary Form of the Mass.  When a priest is in attendance at a mass and not concelebrating, should he self-communicate and take the host directly from the ciborium, or should he receive communion as would any layperson and have it placed on his tongue or in his hand?  Thanks for any help you could give myself and my confreres in this regard.

 

Whether the form of Holy Mass is the Ordinary or the Extraordinary, the Novus Ordo or the TLM, the priest receives, he does not self-communicate.

A bishop, priest or deacon, when in choir-dress, should wear the proper stole when receiving Communion.   Sometimes it may happen, and this would be pretty rare, that a priest might be in the congregation.  He would receive in the normal manner and not self-communicate.  But it is not the ideal that the priest should receive in the congregation with the laity.  He should be, if possible, properly dressed in the sanctuary and receive there.

UPDATE:

I couldn’t immediately remember the document for this, but it is Redemptionis Sacramentum 128.

Holy Mass and other liturgical celebrations, which are acts of Christ and of the people of God hierarchically constituted, are ordered in such a way that the sacred ministers and the lay faithful manifestly take part in them each according to his own condition. It is preferable therefore that “Priests who are present at a Eucharistic Celebration, unless excused for a good reason, should as a rule exercise the office proper to their Order and thus take part as concelebrants, wearing the sacred vestments. Otherwise, they wear their proper choir dress or a surplice over a cassock.” It is not fitting, except in rare and exceptional cases and with reasonable cause, for them to participate at Mass, as regards to externals, in the manner of the lay faithful.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Mail from priests |
25 Comments

Thanks to readers

First, many thanks to you who have voted for WDTPRS in the many categories of the Catholic Media Awards!  Please let your friends know about the voting and ask them to help WDTPRS.

Thanks to readersAlso, I am deeply grateful to the MA of CA for using my amazon.com wish list to send me the copy of Augustine and the Jews: A Christian Defense of Jews and Judaism by Paula Fredriksen.  While this is not directly related to my main interests in Augustine, it is good to have this.  A trusted colleague told me that the book as merits.  People bring up Augustine on Jews once in a while.  It is good to have this resource.

Some of you have been so kind as to send donations through the donation button on the left sidebar and on some posts, for example, on the PRAYERCAzT and PODCAzT entries and some of the entries on the Sabine bird feeder.  Some also have used the little "cup of coffee" link on the sidebar. 

Both the birds and I are grateful.  These winged gluttons can really eat.  Your donations have helped to keep them going.  This was very important during the winter and early spring, especially.  There are many more birds here this year and many more varieties than I have seen in the past.  Thank you!

Speaking of the feeder….

Here is Mrs. Rose-breasted Grosbeak having a little preen in between feasts.

Thanks to readers

Thanks to readersIt seems these finches also like the orange slices I put out for orioles.

Thanks to readers

This chipmunk is baffled.

Thanks to readers

I haven’t seen this before.  Two male Orioles feeding at the same.

I suppose they haven’t paired up with mates yet and are therefore less territorial.

Thanks to readers

Just a nice and peaceful view from the window late in the afternoon.

Thanks to readers

To those of you who have sent things or made donations, please know that I remember you in prayer, as is fitting for benefactors, and from time to time I say Mass for the intention of those who have been so kind.  I will do this again on Friday, the Ember Friday of Pentecost.

Posted in Lighter fare, SESSIUNCULA, The Feeder Feed |
12 Comments

QUAERITUR: Should I stand or should I kneel?

From a reader:

I am a bit of an amateur rubricist (God help us all), and know the rules in the Ordinary Form.  The bishops of the United States, under the permission of the Holy See, have mandated kneeling during the Canon and after the Agnus Dei.  This is clear. 

After attending sung and solemn Masses in the EF each Sunday for nearly two years, I have finally seen the rubrics which specify kneeling for the consecration and during the communion of the faithful and standing at other times. (Rubricae Generales Missi 571, if I recall) I have never observed this (but our servers at Mass tend to get confused anyway), but I have read that kneeling for the whole Canon is a long-standing practice in the United States. 

My question is this:  is there, or was there ever legislation in the United States for kneeling more than the rubrics dictate?  If not, then can it be really proper to ignore the rubrics in such a way?

I know in the EF the people are not bound by the rubrics, but still ought to follow the practice of the servers and those in choir.

QUAERITUR: Should I stand or should I kneel?I think the best source right now for some clarity may be the newest revised edition of Fortescue/O’Connell, The Ceremonies of the Roman Rite Described, done by Alcuin Reid.

 

In the Missale Romanum there are no directions for the laity.  However, there are some conventions.  Lay people should follow, as closely as is reasonable, the rules for clergy in choir.

So, they kneel during the prayers at the foot of the altar up to the Oremus, but stand for the Introit, Kyrie and Gloria.  The sit when the celebrant sits and stand when he stands.  They stand during orations.  They sit for the offertory preparations and rise to be incensed.  They stand at the words before the Preface per omnia saecula saeculorum and then kneel at the end of the Sanctus and remain kneeling to the end of the Canon.  Unless they go to Communion they basically remain kneeling until the tabernacle door is closed at the end of Communion.  They kneel for the blessing. Etc.

It could be that there is a certain tension between the perception of Mass as a celebratory moment and Mass as either an encounter with mystery or a moment of personal examination.  If in ancient times the faithful stoop more, in an ancient position of prayer, over time people would kneel for the whole of the anaphora in an attitude of penance.  During the penitential times (Ember Days, Lent, the fast times, etc.) even those who were not formally doing public penance would kneel.

After the Novus Ordo came into effect, the universal law was that all are to kneel for the consecration from the epiklesis to the Mysterium fidei. 

In the USA, the bishops obtained permission from the Holy See for particular law for the USA that all would effectively continue with the older convention, that is, to kneel from the end of the Sanctus to the end of the Doxology.  So, people should be kneeling for the whole Eucharistic Prayer.  Some will point out that the Preface and Sanctus should also be considered part of the Eucharistic Prayer, but the older convention is followed and there is a natural transition point at the Sanctus.

So, yes.  In the USA there was legislation approved by the Holy See to kneel for more than was customary in the rest of the world.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box | Tagged , ,
31 Comments

Some ammunition in defense of Ven. John Henry Newman

The cause for beatification of Venerable John Henry Newman, the convert, Cardinal, and theologian is going apace.

From time to time you may have read some revisionist theory from a self-interested writer absurdly suggesting that Newman was homosexual.  

Rubbish.

A friend of mine, Fr. Ian Ker, is probably the world’s greatest scholar of Newman.  He has written the definitive biography.

Since the cause for Newman’s beatification seems to be moving along, I want to share this article from The Catholic Herald, the UK’s best Catholic weekly.   You may need ammunition if this subject comes up in conversation.

My emphases and comments.

Biographer challenges Newman revisionists
By Simon Caldwell

29 May 2009

Claims that Cardinal John Henry Newman was a closet homosexual have been debunked in a new version of the definitive biography of him.

Fr Ian Ker, author of John Henry Newman, used private letters and diaries to show that the Victorian convert and theologian was a heterosexual.

He said the cardinal’s wish to be buried in the grave of his friend, Fr Ambrose St John, meant it was "inevitable" there would be speculation about his sexuality in an age that has "lost the concept of affectionate friendship untouched by sexual attraction".  [Exactly!  A friend of mine years ago opined that in many cases homosexual relationship were "friendship gone very very wrong".   It is more complicated than that, but it is a possible starting point in some cases.]

But a diary entry of December 1816, when Newman was a 15-year-old Anglican, showed he was worried that dances and parties with girls would be a sexual temptation for him. As an adult Newman later wrote about the deep pain of the "sacrifice" of the life of celibacy to which he felt he had been called. "A modern reader should not need to be reminded that in 19th-century England homosexuality was illegal and generally considered to be immoral," wrote Fr Ker. "The only ‘sacrifice’ that Newman could possibly be referring to was that of marriage," he said. "And he readily acknowledges that from time to time he continued to feel the natural attraction for marriage that any heterosexual man would feel."

Fr Ker wrote that in the Victorian period there was nothing unusual in friends sharing the same graves. "Newman would scarcely have left such an instruction had he even dreamed that it could ever be interpreted as having any significance beyond the significance which he attached to it – nor would the oratory or the Church authorities have ever permitted a joint burial if they had the slightest suspicion about what must have seemed to them a totally innocent, not to say praiseworthy gesture," he said.  [This is pretty compelling.  It cuts through the rubbish with the axe of commonsense.  Some people (usually progressivists or others who deviate from the obvious) constantly ask you, require you, even threaten you into denying the evidence of your senses or deny commonsense itself.]

"Newman had plenty of critics, not to say enemies, in his time; yet not one of them, not one newspaper, not one casual observer, even dreamed of reading a significance into an act of loving friendship, and indeed humility, such as was left to the 20th century to read into it."

Fr Ker said he always knew that such speculation was "baseless" but acknowledged he might have been "wrong in not specifically dealing with it" in earlier editions of his 1988 book. Claims that Newman had homosexual inclinations first emerged in Geoffrey Faber’s 1933 Freudian psychobiography Oxford Apostles. Newman’s Autobiographical Writings, published in 1957, provided evidence to disprove them.

Cardinal Newman retained most of his friends throughout his life and his friendship with Fr St John lasted 30 years.  [Sometime I wonder if some denizens of the 21st century aren’t embarassed and disturbed by goodness.  They seek to distort it or mar it when they find it.  For example, think of the movie version of The Lord of the Rings, which simply had to mar the nobility of Aragorn or Faramir in certain ways.  It is as if the screenwriters simply couldn’t cope with clarity and nobility.  But I digress…]

He felt partly to blame for Fr St John’s death in 1875 because he had asked him to translate a book on papal infallibility by the Austrian theologian Joseph Fessler, a work which left the priest exhausted.

Newman later wrote: "I have ever thought no bereavement was equal to that of a husband’s or a wife’s, but I feel it difficult to believe that any can be greater, or any one’s sorrow greater, than mine." He stated on three occasions his desire to be buried with his friend and shortly before his own death in 1890, aged 89, he wrote: "I wish, with all my heart, to be buried in Fr Ambrose St John’s grave – and I give this as my last, my imperative will … this I confirm and insist on."

Gay rights activists have argued that such words indicated that Newman was a closet homosexual.  [PIFFLE]

Last year they opposed the exhumation and transfer of his body to the Birmingham Oratory ahead of his likely beatification, saying that it was wrong to separate the cardinal from "the man he loved".

The dispute petered out after the undertakers who opened the grave at a secluded cemetery in Rednal, Worcestershire, last October found the body had totally disintegrated.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
60 Comments

If Harry Knox is anti-Catholic, why is he at the White House?

From CNA with my emphases and comments:

White House ‘comfortable’ with controversial faith-based council appointee

Washington D.C., Jun 4, 2009 / 06:15 am (CNA).- The White House spokesman has said that President Obama is “comfortable” with the makeup of his faith-based advisory council despite protests alleging anti-Catholic bigotry from one appointee who characterized Pope Benedict as a “discredited leader” and called the Knights of Columbus “foot soldiers” in an “army of oppression.”

Harry Knox, the controversial appointee, is a former licensed minister of the United Methodist Church and a leader with the homosexual activist group Human Rights Council.

Before being appointed to the president’s advisory council on faith-based partnerships, Knox had attacked Pope Benedict and some Catholic bishops as "discredited leaders" because of their opposition to same-sex "marriage."  [So, apparently the Catholic Church does not have a right to its own teaching.]

Knox was also critical of Pope Benedict’s comments on condoms and AIDS in Africa. Writing on the Human Rights Campaign’s web site, Knox claimed the Pope’s statement was a “blatant falsehood” which was “morally reprehensible to spread.” He also suggested the Pope was further harming “the marginalized and the downtrodden.”

Though granting that the Knights of Columbus had done good works, he nevertheless has characterized its members as "foot soldiers of a discredited army of oppression" because of the Catholic charitable fraternity’s support for the successful California ballot measure Proposition 8.  [So… this person seems to filter everything through his homosexual hermeneutic.]

Proposition 8 restored the definition of marriage to being between a man and a woman.

A group of twenty Catholic and conservative leaders wrote a letter to President Obama protesting Knox’s appointment, characterizing him as "a virulent anti-Catholic bigot.” Lamenting what they said was the president’s “failure to act,” they called for Knox’s removal from the council.  [Of course the President wants this man on that Council!]

CNSNews.com on Tuesday asked White House Press Secretary Robert Gibbs if President Obama disagreed with Knox’s characterization of the Pope and if the president would take any action regarding requests for Knox’s removal.

“I haven’t seen that letter, but the president is comfortable with the makeup of his faith advisory council,” Gibbs said.  [So… this is the sort of reasonableness and dialogue we heard about at Notre Dame.  This is the civility we can expect.  Didn’t Pres. Obama call for an end to name calling?  Let’s review his appointee’s characterization of Catholics such as Pope Benedict and the KoC.]

This marked the White House’s first response to the Knox controversy, CNSNews.com reports.

Knox responded to the letter protesting his appointment in statements to the news site Newsmax. Professing his love for the Catholic Church and his Catholic “brothers and sisters,” he said he has “tremendous” respect for the Catholic Church and “all the good that it does.”  [Yah… right.  So long as they don’t mention or adhere to Catholic teaching.]

“I do think that we have a real disagreement about the role of lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender people, both in the role of the church and in the role of public service,” he added.  [This is his preferred hermeneutic.]

 

Imagine a person saying those sorts of things about Jews or Muslims. 

Then try to imagine a President, of either party, appointing such a person to any position in the administration.

If you can imagine that, can you then imagine the rage that would well up and the attack on that appointment in the press and from Jews and Muslims?

I’m just askin’

But it the object of the appointee’s derision are Catholics… no problem!

They’re comfortable with that.

Let’s be reasonable.

Posted in I'm just askin'..., The Drill |
17 Comments

PODCAzT 87: Veni Sancte Spiritus – The Pentecost Sequence dissected

PODCAzT 87: Veni Sancte Spiritus - The Pentecost Sequence dissectedI started this one thinking that I could make a fast audio project and then move on.  Ha!

In this PODCAzT I dissect the Pentecost Sequence, Veni Sancte Spiritus, also used during the Octave of Pentecost in the traditional Roman calendar.

I give you some background on what a sequence is, what an octave is and then we start drilling.

First we hear the Latin text and a good translation.   Then see start looking at the structure of the prayer.

That is when things get interesting.  I found a few things I had never noticed.

This is a profound glimpse at mystery, folks.

This is the Roman Rite at her finest.

 


https://wdtprs.com/wp-content/legacy/audio-archive/podcazt/09_06_03.mp3

086 09-05-30 Year for Priests; Pius IX on priests, Mass and Holy Days of obligation
085 09-05-03 Gregory the Great on the Good Shepherd
084 09-04-30 St. Pius V and Quo primum
083 09-04-19 St. Augustine on the challenge of remaining faithful
082 09-03-19 St. Joseph: a hymn dissected & sermon of Bernardine of Siena
081 09-03-13 Benedict XVI’s Letter on SSPX excomms; your voicemail

Please VOTE for WDTPRS in the Catholic New Media Awards.  WDTPRS is nominated in many categories.

Veni Sancte Spiritus – The Pentecost Sequence

Posted in EASTER, Just Too Cool, PODCAzT, WDTPRS | Tagged , , , , , , ,
12 Comments