Politics and worship

In the wake of the Notre Dame scandal, I have been having discussions lately with a friend about the nexus of liturgy and politics under the eyes of St. Augustine of Hippo.

What we saw at the Notre Dame commencement was a kind of secular/political liturgy but in an ecclesiastical setting.  Corruptio optimi pessima.

If politics should be about the social expression of the City of God, liturgy is the sacramental expression of the City of God.

The language and effect of the one will be in discord or harmony with the language and effect of the other.

It may be that the only way we can emphasize the hollow sound of their progressivist, secularizing cymbals is through authentic Catholic worship.

Politics and worshipTo that end I found an interesting quote today in a very good book by R. Dodaro, Christ and the Just Society in Augustine.  Anyone really interested in digging into Augustine and wants a good, very hard, but clear book, should have this one. 

Anyway, I was using this to parse that awful piece by O’Malley, SJ, when I found this in Dodaro:  

"Satan’s is, therefore, the archetypal seduction because it embodies the form of all future misdirection of the soul.  Similarly, it constitutes the prototype for all secular political discourse, in that it displaces within the soul the original blessing of life lived for the sake of authentic spiritual communion, and introduces in its stead the illusion of self-sufficiency and of satisfaction with a lack of moral rectitude. In Augustine’s view, this retreat into a rival ‘creation’ by Adam and Eve inaugurates the realm of the essentially private.  Such, indeed, as the political form of Satan’s own pride: a self-deception which rejected the exclusive divine claim to hegemony, and substituted the domain of self-rule.  Satan’s rival city remains eternally devoid of truth because its genesis represents an act of usurpation.  Augustine’s insistence upon the fundamental mendacity of Satan’s actions is intended to establish the eloquent lie as the cause of social and political disruption characteristic of the earthly city, where he holds sway."  Genesis 3 marks the primordial transition of natural desire away from beatitude in human existence, as it was order, toward the ‘mimetic desire’ of longing to have what God alone posses.  Augustine maintains that human beings seek to create good works out of their own capacities, but that these attempts, which stem from the original act of defiance, are doomed to failure.  When good does result from human efforts, it is because they are never without divine assistance.  Knowledge and love of God, the proper worship of God, are impeded by the dissonance of this free-floating selfhood.  Augustine describes the sin of Adam and Eve as self-worship as opposed to the correct worship of God…  (pp. 68-69).

Then, right on cue, a reader sent the following:

I ran across the following quote in reading Machiavelli’s Discourses for a political theory class I’m taking:

"Princes or republics that wish to maintain themselves without corruption must, above all else, maintain free of corruption the ceremonies of their religion and must hold them constantly in veneration; for there is no greater indication of the ruin of a country than to see its religious worship not respected." (The Discourses, Book I, Chapter XII)

Just thought I’d let you know!  I’m a big fan of your blog – thank you for taking the time to write it.

A direct hit.

Posted in Linking Back, Saints: Stories & Symbols, SESSIUNCULA, The future and our choices | Tagged , , ,
15 Comments

waste not want not

From a priest reader:

Finally, a good use for a glass chalice.

waste not want not

 

Thanks, Father!  And Cheers!

Posted in Brick by Brick, Lighter fare, Mail from priests |
21 Comments

Dropping the Pentecost petals

I had posted about the dropping of rose petals through the oculus of the Pantheon on Pentecost Sunday.

A few people alerted me to other places where this custom is observed.

This is from a reader, with photos of St. John Cantius in Chicago:

Dropping the Pentecost petals

Dropping the Pentecost petals

Dropping the Pentecost petals

Dropping the Pentecost petals

Posted in Just Too Cool |
23 Comments

Georgetown Jesuit makes Pres. Obama into America’s Pope

There is a particularly disgusting article in the Jesuit-run America Magazine by John W. O’Malley, S.J., of the theology department at Georgetown University.

While this is sort of old news now, I think it deserves a fisk.

Before continuing, please note that I spoke my piece about Notre Dame and Pres. Obama.  While I will revisit the event from time to time, I won’t be hammering away at it too much.

I address this new piece not merely for the Notre Dame issue, but other issues which interest me.

Mainly, you should note that this America article puts on display how deeply mired some of these people are in the hermeneutic of discontinuity and rupture which Pope Benedict is trying to correct.

Also, the writer misappropriates the "Fathers of the Church" in a particularly egregious way.

Anyway, a little background – since the writer is a Jesuit and a prof at the suborned Georgetown.  Georgetown bent over backwards for the Obama White House and covered over the Holy Name of Jesus at his request.

Also, highly placed progressivist Catholics have been openly pandering to power.   They have compromised themselves and the Church in the United States on the matter of abortion.

Moreover, in past entries I suggested that, since Georgetown and Notre Dame, the progressivists have declared Pres. Obama to be their new Pope?  The article below from America provides more evidence.  

Not only is there a new Pope, it seems we know have a new Magisterium, a progressivist and discontinuous Magisterium of rupture built around select buzz words from the Second Vatican Council.

Let’s read the America piece with my emphases and comments.

Barack Obama and Vatican II
The president’s persona and the spirit of the council
John W. O’Malley | MAY 25, 2009
 
We have a Vatican II president. Barack Obama, I am sure, does not think of himself in those terms, but when I heard his speech at Grant Park in Chicago the night he was elected, and more recently his commencement address at Notre Dame, that is what immediately struck me. On those occasions he embodied and professed in his public persona the spirit of the council. In making that statement I know that I am entering a minefield. Catholics who denounce the president for his stance on abortion are of course responsible for many of the mines in the field, but their mines have been so thoroughly discussed lately that for the sake of brevity I will bypass them here.  [Only to bring it up again at the end… tuck this little note away.]

The other set of mines in the field comes from the expression “the spirit of Vatican II.” The expression, used widely at the time of the council and given a certain official standing at the Synod of Bishops in 1985, ["a certain official status"?  I have no idea what "certain official status" means. If you look at the final document of the Synod, that expression doesn’t appear.  And even if it is, that wouldn’t give it any sort of "official status".  Synods gather to talk about what the Pope wants them to talk about and the Pope uses what he wants from their deliberations.  They cannot do anything on their own.] has lately in Roman circles been quietly downgraded, if not dismissed as meaningless. No doubt, the expression has been abused to justify interpretations far removed from what the bishops intended, and it has seemed all too prone to ideological manipulation. Your “spirit of the council” is not my “spirit of the council.”

Yet [This is where things get interesting…] the expression has a legitimate place in our vocabulary and is in fact almost indispensable for grasping the big message the council wanted to deliver. By “the spirit of the council” I mean [He defines his own use of the term, which is fair.  Just remember to dismiss that twaddle about "certain official status", above…] simply general orientations that transcended particular issues.  In my book, What Happened at Vatican II, I argue that beneath the particular issues the council dealt with—episcopal collegiality, for instance, and religious liberty—more profound and far-reaching issues lurked. [A conciliar
"sub-text"?  What the Council really said?]
I call these the issues-under-the-issues. I ground them in the texts of the council and in that way ground “the spirit of the council” and give it verifiable substance. [A nice slight of hand.  Clever.]   

[I think we have to agree that he is right about this next part.] Among the issues-under-the issues was style, ["style" is a slippery word, but read on…] the issue especially pertinent for grounding “the spirit of the council.” The council spoke in a new style, a style different from all previous councils. [Okay…..]  It eschewed words implying punishment, surveillance, hostility, distrust and coerced behavior-modification that characterized previous councils. [Yah… okay….]  It employed words that espoused a new model for Christian behavior—not new, of course, to the Christian tradition as such, but new to council vocabulary. [Right… and this was a "pastoral Council", right?]  I am referring to words like brothers and sisters, cooperation, partnership, human family, conscience, collegiality and especially dialogue. [The magic word… ] The new words cannot be dismissed as casual asides or mere window dressing.  The council used them too insistently, intentionally and characteristically for them to be that. This new vocabulary made the council a major language-event in the history of the church.   [We stipulate.  The problem is that Vatican II does not magically take precedence over all other Councils.  The fact that it employs new vocabulary doesn’t mean that we discount other Councils because they didn’t  use that vocabulary.  What he is has jammed in here is the thin-edge of discontinuity.]

The shift in vocabulary had profound ramifications. It meant a shift in values and priorities. [Do you hear it?  That hermeneutic of discontinuity and rupture?  He is detaching V2 from previous Councils.]  Critical among these new values was [wait for it] civility [!!] in dealing with persons of different faiths or convictions and a willingness to listen to them with docile heart and mind. This civility was not a superficial tactic but a manifestation of an inner conversion. [Perhaps he has written a book on this… and I have not read it… perhaps some who lived in those days possess a knowledge of the documents younger people do not]…  but this smacks of secret doctrine, gnosticism.]  It of course did not mean surrendering one’s beliefs, but it did mean surrendering one’s beliefs, but it did mean a willingness to learn from others and a refusal to condemn them without a hearing. Such openness of mind and heart is the essence of genuine dialogue.  [We have to agree with some of these statements.  We do have a new tone today because of V2.  This new tone is applied to those with whom we previously dealt in a colder way, Protestants, Communists, non-Christians, etc.  What we won’t admit is a shift in priorities and values…. unless you have secret knowledge of what the texts really mean.  Yes the Vatican Council included this conciliatory language together with other traditional terms.  For example it condemned abortion as an unspeakable crime, as if the Council Fathers foresaw the liberalization of abortion that would occur in the near future….]

The council hoped that this new style of being, which brings with it a new way of proceeding, would lead to cooperation among all persons of good will—Catholics and non-Catholics, Christians and non-Christians, believers and non-believers—on the new, massive, and sometimes terrifying problems that face humanity today. This new way of proceeding in large part constituted “the spirit of the council.” It was one of the big messages the council delivered to the church and to the world at large. [Be careful.  Don’t just admit all this weight behind "the spirit of Vatican II", the weight the writer gives to it.]

That is why when I heard Obama’s two speeches I was struck by how much he spoke in accord with the spirit of Vatican II.  [He set up his premise, which you were supposed to accept, and now he is running with it.] In those two addresses, as well as in his other speeches, he called for civility, for the end of name-calling, and for a willingness to work together to deal with our common problems, including abortion, [This is really all about abortion.  Also, doesn’t this sound like the view of a Rawlsian?  This is Rawls-speak.] rather than a stand-off determination to impose one’s principles without reckoning what the cost to the common good might be. ["Imposing one’s principles" is bad.  "Civility", for O’Malley, is in opposition to "imposing principles".   This sounds like John Rawls, the patron saint of reasonableness and civility.  O’Malley is basically saying "shut up about abortion" because the President wants you to shut up about abortion.  Liberals hate "imposing principles", unless their own principles are the principles being imposed.  BTW… weren’t soldiers sent to impose principles of desegregation?   And do not forget that Gaudium et spes called abortion an unspeakable crime.  But we are simply to SHUT UP about abortion.  If we don’t, we are not being "civil".    We are "unreasonable".] 

President Jenkins of Notre Dame called attention to Obama’s oratorical gifts. Such gifts are consonant with the rhetorical tradition that produced the spirit of Vatican II. The council deliberately chose to speak as much as possible “in the pastoral style of the Fathers,” who were schooled from their earliest days in the rhetorical tradition. That tradition is what made them such effective preachers and leaders of their communities. [Problem: Eloquentia in the Church Fathers included polemic.  O’Malley conveniently leaves out polemic.  The Fathers were not irenic with people who prompted unspeakable crimes.  Shall we look at some of St. Augustine’s gentle, reasonable, pastoral remarks about the Bishop of Eclanum?  Shall we muse about how Jerome wrote about some people?  And John Chrysostom to the Empress a model of gentleness and reasonableness in his pastoral style.  For O’Malley, "pastoral" means … well… kissing up, I think.   I prefer Archbp. Chaput’s approach.]

Classical theorists about rhetoric like Cicero and Quintilian described it as the art of winning consensus, [ROFL!  It was the art of winning.  Rhetorical skills were used to bring people to your side.  And when it came to pastors such as Augustine of Hippo, even using force from time to time.] the art of bringing people together for a common cause. It is an art, please note, closely related to ethics, for those same theorists described the truly successful orator as vir bonus dicendi peritus–a good man, skilled in public speaking. It is an art in which Obama excels and which, certainly unwittingly, puts him in touch with the spirit of Vatican II. [Sounds like a gnostic, pointing to the acquisition of knowledge through, what… a seance?  Also, this morning a friend pointed out what Augustine says, in City of God, namely, that one of the most effective public speakers is SATAN.   "You shall be as gods", was the first political speech of the City of Man, or rather the City of the Devil.  Political discourse is rooted in the rhetoric of the devil, a deceptive rhetoric.  Politicians try to persuade us always along these lines: we shall live as gods.  The writer might review Dodaro, R. Christ and the Just Society in Augustine, p. 66-69.   "Satan’s is, therefore, the archetypal seduction because it embodies the form of all future misdirection of the soul.  Similarly, it constitutes the prototype for all secular political discourse, in that it displaces within the soul the original blessing of life lived for the sake of authentic spiritual communion, and introduces in its stead the illusion of self-sufficiency and of satisfaction with a lack of moral rectitude."  "In Augustine’s view, this retreat into a rival ‘creation’ by Adam and Eve inaugurates the realm of the essentially private.  Such, indeed, as the political form of Satan’s own pride: a self-deception whcih rejected the exclusive divine claim to hegemony, and substituted the domain of self-rule.  Satan’s rival city remains eternally devoid of truth because its genesis represents an act of usurpation.  Augustine’s insistence upon the fundamental mendacity of Satan’s actions is intended to establish the eloquent lie as the cause of social and political disruption characteristic of the earthly city, where he holds sway."  (see ciu. 14.4.)]

I often hear laments that the spirit of Vatican II is dead in the church. [In some circles I am sure that it so.]  Is it not ironic that not a bishop but the President of the United States [episkopos ton ekton?] should today be the most effective spokesperson for that spirit? [Behold, the new papacy… the new Magisterium!] To judge from the enthusiastic response he received from the graduates at Notre Dame, his message captured their minds and hearts.  [Yah.. right… there’s a good measure…] Maybe through young Catholics like those at Notre Dame who are responding to Obama’s message the spirit of Vatican II will, almost through the back door, reenter the church. [Soooo… they aren’t in it now?  Even after being at Notre Dame?] The history of the church has, after all, taken stranger turns than that.   [And we know where they lead.]

John W. O’Malley, S.J., is university professor, theology department, at Georgetown University and author of What Happened at Vatican II.

There is much more to say… but after that trudge… I need to go wash.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
60 Comments

Pray for the Subprior of Clear Creek Monastery in Oklahoma

From a reader:

The Subprior of Clear Creek, Dom Francois de Feydeau, recently underwent an operation in which the doctors removed three cancerous brain tumors.  The guestmaster, Father Bethel, has told me on more than one occasion that he does not know how they could ever have made the foundation at Clear Creek without Father de Feydeau.  He is enormously talented in so many ways – a superb artist, an able builder & amateur engineer, an authority on Romanesque art, architecture, & spirituality without equal in the Western Hemisphere, above all a perfect model of a Christian following the Rule of St Benedict.  I received a note from Father Prior, excerpts of which are below, asking that friends of the monastery join in this novena to Bishop Valdes, beginning TODAY, Tuesday the 2nd.

—–

+pax

Dear Friends of Clear Creek Monastery,

Father Abbot of Fontgombault composed the attached novena prayer.
Bishop Francisco Valdes was a Capuchin bishop from Chile, who befriended Fontgombault in the early 1980s.  He ordained Father de Feydeau (and Father Bethel) to the diaconate.  Since dying in the odor of sanctity in 1982, his diocese of Osorno has begun the procedure to obtain his possible beatification.

Father de Feydeau is recovering very well from his brain surgery, but his cancer is medically incurable.  This is why we are asking you to join in our novena for his cure, by the grace of God and the intercession of Our Lady, St. Benedict, St. Francis and the holy Bishop Valdes.

In Our Lord and Our Lady,
Brother Philip Anderson, Prior of Clear Creek Monastery

—–

+ Special Novena
(June 2-10 2009)
Composed by Dom Antoine Forgeot, Abbot of Fontgombault

Bishop Francisco Valdes, our friend, we know through experience the power of your intercession; humbly and with confidence we pray to you on behalf of another Francis, severely stricken in his health: obtain for him a complete and prompt healing, for the good of his soul, the service of his community and the glory of God.  Through Christ Our Lord. Amen.

Sacred Heart of Jesus, I trust in Thee.
Our Lady, Health of the Sick, Pray for us.
Our Lady of Lourdes, Pray for us.
Our Blessed Father, Saint Benedict, Pray for us.
Saint Francis of Assisi, Pray for us.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
12 Comments

IN THE WILD! Roman Vestment Sighting

From a reader:

In the window at Orpheum Cleaners, Grand Blvd & Wyoming St , St. Louis, MO on Tuesday morning.

IN THE WILD! Roman Vestment Sighting

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
27 Comments

Chickadee-mail

Chickadee-mailI received this fun e-mail from a reader:

Dear Fr. Z.,
 
The brood of black-capped chickadees in our bird box fledged on Pentecost Sunday. Four of them fledged within a 10 minute period. The fifth and last one delayed another 25 minutes before embarking upon the world outside of the nest box. I was able to catch a few snapshots of the grand event, which my family and I have looked forward to with great anticipation.
 
In one shot I’m sending the little guy is getting ready to make the big leap. In the other shot I captured the fledging’s first flight on his way to a nearby tree in the backyard.
 
It strikes me that there is a message for us in the fact that the Lord sent these little creatures forth on Pentecost Sunday.

 

I really enjoy the chickadees.  They are fearless!   They will often flutter down nearly on top of me as I refill the feeder.  I have learned to imitate their contact call and, in the morning and evening, I can whistle them in.  Sometimes I can get a little group to follow me around as I walk, if I don’t go too far from their zone.

Anyway… here are the photos sent with the e-mail:

Chickadee-mail

Chickadee-mail

Posted in Just Too Cool |
10 Comments

WDTPRS roast

They say imitation is the highest form of flattery.

I received a link from a reader in California who alerted me to some light-hearted ribbing, or would "roasting" be more appropriate, on Monterey TLM:

What Does the Blog Really Say?
Now is the time at MTLM when we do pale imitations!*

WDTPRS roast

Here is one dish that was prepared with Cous-Cous, and at least two different types of pasta.

WDTPRS roast

Minnesota may have a rich variety of birds, but we have chickens at San Juan Bautista!

WDTPRS roast The Night sky over San Juan Bautista from Fremont Peak State Park.

WDTPRS roast

Paisano has no comment on the above, as he is in Salinas, and was not invited to the Potluck.

*With many, many apologies to Fr. Zuhlsdorf.

LOL!  Thanks for that!

Posted in Lighter fare, Linking Back |
27 Comments

WDTPRS: Whit Tuesday

WDTPRS: Whit TuesdayIt is Tuesday in the Octave of Pentecost

Here is an oldie PODCAzT I made for this day last year: 

057 08-05-13 John Paul II on the unforgivable sin; Our Lady of Fatima and the vision of Hell – TUESDAY

On this day is the traditional "Dancing Procession" in Echternach, Luxembourg, founded by St. Willibrord.   As bands play, the people move forward slowly in lines, holding white handkerchiefs.  They "dance" with little kicks to the left and right and thus make slow progress.

Play video

The Collect for Holy Mass in the Extraordinary Form is a bit more solemn than the procession.

COLLECT (1962MR):
Adsit nobis, quaesumus, Domine,
virtus Spiritus Sancti:
quae et corda nostra clementer expurget,
et ab omnibus tueatur adversis.

This prayer struck me as having an ancient pedigree.  Thus, I opened my copy of the critical edition of the Liber sacramentorum Gellonensis, and scanned the index of incipits.   There were very many prayers which begin with the "comic/legal" imperative adesto, from the same verb adsum, but very few with adsit.  Sure enough, I found today’s prayer in the days after Pentecost: CXLVIIII FER III. AD SCA ANASTASIAM.  Today.  The Roman Station today is at St. Anastasia.   Thus, this is an ancient Roman oration.

That verb adsum means "to be present".  When ordinands are called by name… the technically precise moment of a man’s "vocation" or "calling"… he responds "Adsum … I am present".   The form here is in the subjunctive, and it functions as a mild imperative.  Along the way it looks as if we have a characteristic result clause, which needs the subjunctive as well.  Note the et…et… construction, to say "both…and…".  There is a nice stylish division of omnibus… adversis, giving us an elegant rhythm.  I also like the assonance in the first two lines with "u".

LITERAL VERSION:
May there be present to us, O Lord, we beseech You,
the power of the Holy Spirit:
with the result that it both mercifully cleanses our hearts,
and protects (them) from every adverse thing.

When we are baptized the Holy Spirit begins to inhabit our hearts, abiding with us, remaining in us in a habitual manner.  The Holy Spirit imparts the theological virtues of faith, hope and charity together with the fruits and gifts.  The Holy Spirit abiding in us gives us sanctifying grace, the grace we call "habitual" grace.  There are also "actual" graces, given for this or that purpose. 

By our baptism we are justified before God and also sanctified.

We can lose the state of grace, sanctifying grace.

Usually this happens when our choice to love some created thing moves us to act out of accord with God’s law and in disharmony with the image of God in us and in others.  We in effect drive the Holy Spirit from us.  Indeed, since all the Persons of the Trinity act together, we push the God, Three and One, from our souls.

Through actual graces God urges us to be reconciled.

The way in which God Himself desires that we be reconciled is by means of the Sacrament of Penance/Reconciliation through the ministry of the Church He instituted.  Before His Ascension, Christ breathed is SPIRIT on the Apostles and gave them His own power and authority to forgive sins.  This is the way Christ wants us to seek forgiveness: otherwise He would not have given us this sacrament.

In the Collect, we ask God to cleanse from our hearts anything that would be an obstacle to the indwelling of the Persons of the Trinity.  Then we beg that the power of the Holy Spirit protect our hearts from anything which might be bad for us.  This need not be merely the aggressive attacks of the Enemy of the soul.  It might also be our own disordered passions and appetites which, fixing on some created thing, begins to love it or use it in a disordered way, placing that created thing in the place God alone should be entited to possess.

The bottom line: The way to salvation has been opened to us.  We can lose that way by our choices.  We must never supplant God from His rightful place in our souls by choosing to enthrone there any creature… person, thing or state.

Posted in EASTER, SESSIUNCULA, WDTPRS | Tagged , ,
3 Comments

The Roman Church’s new Major Penitentiary

Francis Card. Stafford has stepped down as the Penitenziere Maggiore for reasons of age and his successor appointed.

The new Penitenziere is Archbp. Fortunato Baldelli, who had been Nuncio in France.

From the daily Bolletino:

#  RINUNCIA DEL PENITENZIERE MAGGIORE E NOMINA DEL SUCCESSORE

Il Santo Padre ha accolto la rinuncia, presentata per limiti d’età, dall’Em.mo Card. James Francis Stafford, all’incarico di Penitenziere Maggiore, ed ha chiamato a succedergli nel medesimo incarico l’Ecc.mo Mons. Fortunato Baldelli, Arcivescovo tit. di Bevagna, finora Nunzio Apostolico in Francia.

 

The Apostolic Penitentiary is one of the the Roman Church’s three great tribunals, and it has the highest dignity.   It deals with matters of conscience, internal forum or confession issues, some particular censures and the concession of indulgences.  It is so important that even with the death of a Pope, the Major Penitentiary of the Church, usually a Cardinal, does not lose his office as do most of the members of the Curia.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
18 Comments