Biology 101: the embryo

Creative Minority Report is all over this and I simply bring that entry over here.

Please give CMR’s stats a bump.

But first:

From Dictionary.com (my emphases).

em·bry·o  n.   pl. em·bry·os

   1.
         1. An organism in its early stages of development, especially before it has reached a distinctively recognizable form.
         2. An organism at any time before full development, birth, or hatching.
         3. The fertilized egg of a vertebrate animal following cleavage.
         4. In humans, the prefetal product of conception from implantation through the eighth week of development.

   2.
         1. The fertilized egg of a vertebrate animal following cleavage.
         2. In humans, the prefetal product of conception from implantation through the eighth week of development.

And now….

Newsflash! Embryos Aren’t Fertilized! So it’s ok to kill them. So said former President Bill Clinton five times in an interview last night. And what’s worse is that the brain surgeon who was nominated by President Obama to be Surgeon General didn’t even correct him.

Either CNN’s Sanjay Gupta doesn’t know what Clinton said is laughably wrong or he is so cravenly submissive to power that he failed to point out that of course embryos are fertilized, you dunce.

What do they think an embryo is, if not fertilized?

Transcript fo rthe video challenged:

Gupta: Let’s talk about something you talked a lot about in the early part of your presidency, stem cells. There was an order today providing federal money for embryonic stem cell research. First of all, let me just ask you, as someone who studied this, is this going to always be as divisive an issue as it is now? Is this going to be the abortion of the next generation? Or are people going to come around?

Clinton: I think – the answer is I think that we’ll work it through. If – particularly if it’s done right. If it’s obvious that we’re not taking embryos that can – that under any conceivable scenario would be used for a process that would allow them to be fertilized and become little babies, and I think if it’s obvious that we’re not talking about some science fiction cloning of human beings, then I think the American people will support this….

Gupta: Any reservations?

Clinton: I don’t know that I have any reservations, but I was – he has apparently decided to leave to the relevant professional committees the definition of which frozen embryos are basically going to be discarded, because they’re not going to be fertilized. I believe the American people believe it’s a pro-life decision to use an embryo that’s frozen and never going to be fertilized for embryonic stem cell research….

But those committees need to be really careful to make sure if they don’t want a big storm to be stirred up here, that any of the embryos that are used clearly have been placed beyond the pale of being fertilized before their use. There are a large number of embryos that we know are never going to be fertilized, where the people who are in control of them have made that clear. The research ought to be confined to those….

But there are values involved that we all ought to feel free to discuss in all scientific research. And that is the one thing that I think these committees need to make it clear that they’re not going to fool with any embryos where there’s any possibility, even if it’s somewhat remote, that they could be fertilized and become human beings.

What is this?

A slip? 

An attempt to deceive through repetition?

Play video

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
38 Comments

A sudden session of sweet silent thought

I just had a remarkable experience.  It may have been the strength and particular hue of the light in my room right now that triggered it.

In a flash a memory flooded back to my conscious mind of standing behind a chair at the table in the dining room of St. Agnes parish in St. Paul many years ago, in the earliest ’80s when I was a shiny new Catholic. 

There was once a remarkable culture to that place, often focused in that room around that table. 

Remarkable days and dead friends summoned in a remembrance of things past.

Posted in Linking Back |
14 Comments

Have media talking points been worked out about the PCED?

Keep your eyes peeled for a particular interpretation of the Pope’s intention expressed in his Letter of 12 March to bishops about the SSPX excommunications.

An assumption will now be advanced that the Pope is checking the Pontifical Commission "Ecclesia Dei" with which His Holiness is displeased.

For example, John Thavis in his CNS piece writes:  "Third, [the Pope] put the Pontifical Commission "Ecclesia Dei" on a shorter leash. By placing it under the control of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the pope effectively limited the commission’s ability to freelance agreements with traditionalist groups without proper attention to doctrinal differences."

Now I read that George Wiegel has predictably chimed in saying: "…there will be no more free-lancing from Ecclesia Dei, which had become a loose cannon careening around the ecclesial deck.  The reining in of Ecclesia Dei and its subordination to the Catholic Church’s principal doctrinal office also sends an important signal to the Levebvrist leadership,…"

It looks as if the talking points have been distributed.

I am not convinced that this is an accurate picture of what is happening, coordinated through it may seem to be.

Remember that the Pontifical Commission "Ecclesia Dei" was set up as an "ad hoc" commission, with a task and faculties.  The task and faculties must be modified according as exigencies require. Changing the task or structure of the PCED is not necessary a check or a reining-back.  The PCED exists at the pleasure of the Roman Pontiff for whatever purpose the Roman Pontiff aims it at.

The next step in the process with the SSPX is to set up a framework for discussion of the doctrine expressed in the Council’s documents.

Putting the PCED in closer alignment with the CDF would signal that the Holy See is serious about doctrinal talks, not necessarily that the Holy Father is displeased with the PCED.

Once Summorum Pontificum was in force in Sept. 2007 it seemed sensible to incorporate the PCED into the Congregation for Divine Worship.  I even had some conversation about that when not long ago I revisited the offices of the PCED where I once worked, lo those many years ago.

However, PCED no longer needs to issue faculties for the older Mass.  Summorum Pontificum took care of that.  If there are liturgical questions, I suppose the PCED could still respond or a new desk could be created in the CDWDS.  Summorum Pontificum designated the PCED as the reference point in disputes when priests don’t make the TLM available.  Let us keep in mind that in Sept. 2010, the three year period Pope Benedict mentioned to access Summorum Pontificum will come.  That may be the time for more restructuring.  It is the right time of year also, given the Curia’s annual ebb and flow.

I see the Holy Father’s comments about the PCED as being practical and purposeful rather than punitive.  The next step must be doctrinal talks.  The Holy Father stressed doctrine not discipline as the distinct obstacle.  It is entirely reasonable that the PCED should now work even more closely than it has in the past with the CDF, especially when Pope Benedict was still its Prefect.  They are even housed in the same building, the Palazzo del Sant’Uffizio.

Furthermore, it is hard to say that a Cardinal retiring at 80 would be because of the Pope’s displeasure for what he did or didn’t do.  All the Presidents of the PCED stepped down at 80 years old.  That is the way things work.  They lose their vote in the conclave and they don’t hold offices.

It is popular right now to scapegoat Cardinal Castrillon.  Whatever his role in the mishandling of the steps leading to the lifting of the excommunications may be, he was not as lonely a wolf as he is portrayed by many.  I understand that there was, in fact, some consultation of a group of curial heads before the lifting of the excommunication.  If something went wrong, and a target was needed, it is not hard to imagine that someone such as, say, the sostituto might work to keep the blame focused on a single point to be burned.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
27 Comments

Thavis of CNS on Pope Benedict’s Letter

John Thavis of CNS reacts to the Holy Father’s Letter to bishops about the lifting of the SSPX excommunications.

My emphases and comments.

Papal letter: Pointed, personal and from the heart
By John Thavis
Catholic News Service

VATICAN CITY (CNS) — In one fell swoop, Pope Benedict XVI has taken charge of the much-criticized realm of "Vatican communications" [From your keyboard to God’s ear, Mr. Thavis!]  following his lifting of the excommunication of four traditionalist bishops, including one who denied the extent of the Holocaust.

The pope’s letter to the world’s bishops, made public March 12, was remarkable on many counts:

— First, he candidly admitted mistakes in the way he and other Vatican officials handled the reconciliation move with the bishops of the Society of St. Pius X. Most specifically, he said they should have used the Internet to find out what millions of others already knew: that one of the four, Bishop Richard Williamson, was known for his radical views on the Holocaust.

— Second, the pope revealed how deeply stung he was by the criticism of those who felt he was "turning back the clock" or repudiating Catholic-Jewish dialogue. His line about even some Catholics attacking him "with open hostility" showed that even in his supposed isolation as supreme pontiff this is a man who cares deeply about the reaction among the faithful.

— Third, he put the Pontifical Commission "Ecclesia Dei" on a shorter leash. By placing it under the control of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the pope effectively limited the commission’s ability to freelance agreements with traditionalist groups without proper attention to doctrinal differences.  [I think much will depend on whether or not there is a still a Cardinal President apart from the sitting Prefect of the CDF.]

— Fourth, he strongly defended his outreach to the Society of St. Pius X to those in the church who consider the group marginal and unimportant. He described his task as preserving unity so that witness to the Gospel is credible, and warned that divisions in the church — the "biting and devouring" described by St. Paul in the church’s first century — are always counterproductive.

The 2,500-word papal letter was unusually pointed and direct, and showed Pope Benedict’s own skills as a communicator once he puts pen to paper. His acknowledgment of mistakes in communications and Vatican ignorance of the Internet was unprecedented.

"I have learned the lesson that in the future in the Holy See we will have to pay greater attention to that source of news," he said.

Coincidentally, his letter came as the Pontifical Council for Social Communications [sigh] was hosting a weeklong seminar on the church and "new media," with the idea that a new document may be needed to promote effective church use of online opportunities.

To many observers, the realignment of the "Ecclesia Dei" commission was a sign of disapproval [hmmmm] of how the commission’s president, Cardinal Dario Castrillon Hoyos, managed this phase of talks with the Society of St. Pius X. Cardinal Castrillon, who turns 80 in July, will probably leave his post soon.

Vatican officials have pointed to Cardinal Castrillon as the man who should have briefed the pope more fully on Bishop Williamson ahead of time. But the pope’s dissatisfaction may run deeper than that.

Since the excommunications were lifted, the society’s superior, Bishop Bernard Fellay, has insisted that his organization is far from ready to accept some teachings of the Second Vatican Council. In fact, Bishop Fellay has suggested that removal of the excommunications merely sets the stage for the real battle over Vatican II — a battle the pope has no interest in fighting.   [If it is framed in terms of battle, that may be true.  But this Pope demonstrates that he is at his best when tough questions are directly engaged.  I hold that, for example, the Pope knew exactly what he was doing with the Regensburg Address, which bore fruit.  The Pope is not afraid of what will emerge from even a hard discussion over Vatican II, provided that the truth is sought in humility.]

All this hints that perhaps the pope was not fully prepared for the society’s inflexibility on some of these points.  [I doubt the Pope would be surprised by that.]

Placing "Ecclesia Dei" under the doctrinal congregation also ensures that other Vatican agencies will be consulted on such reconciliation moves in the future, the pope said in his letter. That answered a specific complaint from Cardinal Walter Kasper, who coordinates dialogue with the Jews and who said his agency was never consulted on the latest concessions to the Society of St. Pius X.

The pope’s message to the wider Catholic world was just as direct and just as heartfelt. He said his overture to the traditionalists had a strategic purpose, that of building church unity in an age when the world seems to be rejecting the Christian message.

In three or four sentences, he summed up what he views as the challenges and [NB:] the primary objectives of his pontificate:

"In our days, when in vast areas of the world the faith is in danger of dying out like a flame which no longer has fuel, the overriding priority is to make God present in this world and to show men and women the way to God," he said.

As God disappears from the human horizon, he said, humanity is losing its bearings, with increasingly "evident destructive effects."

"Leading men and women to God, to the God who speaks in the Bible: This is the supreme and fundamental priority of the church and of the successor of Peter at the present time. A logical consequence of this is that we must have at heart the unity of all believers. Their disunity, their disagreement among themselves, calls into question the credibility of their talk of God," he said.

The pope’s plea was for mainstream Catholics to see outreach to the traditionalists not as a step backward but as an attempt to incorporate the adherents of extremism [What if it isn’t extremist to have hard questions about the Second Vatican Council?  Perhaps not all members of the SSPX are "extremists".] in a way that helps break down their rigidity and releases their "positive energies."

The pope said the church should "allow herself to be generous" and "be capable of overlooking various faults and making every effort to open up broader vistas" in order to promote this unity. Those are words that will likely be quoted in the future, and not only by Catholic traditionalists.

A couple of my spies have told me that there was, in fact, a commission put together to look at the question of lifting the excommunication before the fact.  If that is the case, then Card. Castrillon is being scapegoated by someone. 

We will see what actually happens.  Will the PCED’s faculties and mission be dminished or will it simply be redirected?  Remember: the PCED is actually described as an "ad hoc Commission".  It exists for a specific purpose.

I suspect that the Holy Father’s intention about the Commission are less an expression of lack of favor, but rather of the need to prepare the way for deeper talks with the SSPX.  The proper curial context for such preparation would be the CDF.  Putting the PCED under the CDF would be the right move.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
20 Comments

SSPX Superior Bp. Fellay on Pope Benedict’s Letter

Rorate is usually on the spot with things like statements from the SSPX’s leadership.

Here is the statement of SSPX Bp. Bernard Fellay about the Letter Pope Benedict wrote to bishops of the world about the lifting of the SSPX excommunications.

My emphases and comments.

Communiqué
of the Superior General
of the Priestly Fraternity of Saint Pius X [FSSPX / SSPX]

Pope Benedict XVI addressed a letter to the Bishops of the Catholic Church, dated March 10 2009, in which he made them aware of the intentions which guided him in this important step which is the Decree of January 21, 2009.

After "an avalanche of protests was unleashed" recently, we greatly thank the Holy Father for having placed the debate at the level on which it should take place, that of the faith. We fully share his utmost concern for preaching to "our age, when in vast areas of the world the faith is in danger of dying out like a flame which no longer has fuel".

The Church lives, in fact, through a major crisis which cannot be solved other than by an integral return to the purity of the faith. With Saint Athanasius, we profess that "Whoever wants to be saved should above all cling to the Catholic faith: whoever does not guard it whole and inviolable will doubtless perish eternally." (Quicumque Creed) [The sticking point, however, is this: who gets to say what "purity of faith" is?]

Far from wanting to stop Tradition in 1962, [The Pope in his letter wrote: "The Church’s teaching authority cannot be frozen in the year 1962 – this must be quite clear to the Society."]  we wish to consider the Second Vatican Council and the post-Conciliar magisterium in the light of this Tradition which Saint Vincent of Lérins defined as that "which has been believed everywhere, always, by all" (Commonitorium), without rupture and in a perfectly homogeneous development. It is thus that we will be able to contribute efficaciously to the evangelization asked for by the Savior (cf. Matthew, 28,19-20). 

The Priestly Fraternity of Saint Pius X assures Benedict XVI of its will to address the doctrinal discussions considered "necessary" by the Decree of January 21, with the desire of serving the revealed Truth which is the first charity to be shown towards all men, Christian or not. It assures him of its prayers so that his faith may not fail and that he may confirm all his brethren (cf. Luke 22 32).

We place these doctrinal discussions under the protection of Our Lady of Trust, with the assurance that she will obtain for us the grace of faithfully delivering that which we received, "tradidi quod et accepi" (I Cor. 15,3).  [The motto on the late Archbp. Lefebvre’s coat-of-arms.] 

Menzingen, March 12 2009

+ Bernard Fellay

 

Not bad, really. 

There still seems to be a touch of an attitude that they are in no way at fault on any point. The Holy Father did instruct them about freezing the Church at a point in time. 

Still, if they say they are not doing that, let’s believe them and then let them demonstrate that in concrete ways.

And let them be given the opportunity to demonstrate that!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
60 Comments

Today’s reworking of an ancient prayer in the Novus Ordo

I was struck by the Novus Ordo today, the so-called "Prayer over the gifts".  It is, in the 2002MR, a reworking of a prayer in the 1962MR, in its own turn from the ancient Gelasian and Hadrianum and Paduense Sacramentaries.

SUPER OBLATA (2002MR):
Praesenti sacrificio, quaesumus, Domine,
observantiam nostram sanctifica,
ut, quod quadragesimalis exercitatio profitetur exterius,
interius operetur effectu.

This is a reworked version of a prayer in the 1962MR on Ember Saturday in Lent, in the 1st Week:

SECRET (1962MR):
Praesentibus sacrificiis, quaesumus, Domine,
ieiunia nostra sanctifica:
ut, quod observantia nostra profitetur extrinsecus,
interius operetur
.

Perhaps some of you will take a crack at these and determine what the differences are.

Posted in LENT, WDTPRS |
17 Comments

WDTPRS: Thursday 2nd Week of Lent – Post communionem (2002MR)

We continue our project of looking at the Post communions of Lent:

Thursday – 2nd Week of Lent

This prayer was in the 1962MR on the Friday of the 2nd Week of Lent.  But it was the Secret!  Astonishingly, Bugnini’s all-consuming experts moved it to be a Post Communion.

POST COMMUNIONEM (2002MR):
Haec in nobis sacrificia, Deus,
et actione permaneant,
et operatione firmentur.

Actio can refer to an "action" or, more precisely, to liturgical celebrations of the sacred mysteries.  Sometimes the Eucharistic prayer is called an Actio.  In a sacristy you might see a little pro memoria card framed for priests indicating the name of the local bishop so that the priest can say his name properly "infra Actionem … during the Eucharistic Prayer".  Interestingly, operatio is not simply a "work" or "labor" but also a "religious performance, service, or solemnity, a bringing of offerings".  That meshes nicely with the deeper Christian meaning of actio and gives us a hint as to how to translate this prayer with something more than just a superficial rendering.  There is a conceptual connection between actio and operatio.

Permaneo, which is basically, "to stay to the end; to hold out, last, continue, endure, remain; to persist, persevere" is also, interestingly, "to abide in a way, rule, or mode of life, to live by, to devote one’s life to" as is attested to in the Vulgate.  The L&S confirms that firmo means, “to make firm or fast, to strengthen, fortify, support” and also, “to strengthen in resolution, to encourage, animate” or even “to confirm, show, prove; to affirm, assert, declare, promise the correctness or truth of a circumstance, statement.”  There is a conceptual connection between permaneo and firmo.

The Daily Missal (Baronius Press – 2007):
May these sacrificial offerings, O God,
both endure in us in action
and be confirmed in effect.

The words actio and operatio, conceptually related "doing" connected to the verbs ago and operor, both have a connotation of sacred liturgical service.  At the same time, they can simply point to our own daily undertakings.  These layers of meaning overlap and show us how there must be a continuity between how we participate at Holy Mass and how we act outside of the sacred precincts of the church or chapel we frequent.   The highest form of active participation is the reception of Holy Communion in the state of grace following a willed, active receptivity to what has been carried out in the sacred action of the Mass.  Christ is the ACTOR par excellence in the Mass.  In the actions of the priest, Christ is acting as the Head of the Body.  In the actions and receptivity of the congregation, Christ is in action as the Body, responding to and being directed by the Head.  Both together form Christ, Christus Totus, raising sacrifice on high to the Father.  Our participation then must be first and foremost active receptivity so that we have what is good to give back to God.

The et… et construction and the connects in concept between the pairs of words is high evocative.  Perhaps you will have some ideas about this.

Consider

actio <–> permaneo  ongoing
operatio <–> firmo    solid

 

Posted in LENT, WDTPRS |
Comments Off on WDTPRS: Thursday 2nd Week of Lent – Post communionem (2002MR)

A UK weekly The Universe will now publish TLM info

I received a press release from the Latin Mass Society in the UK.  They are undergoing lots of upheaval right now, but apparently they are still active.

This is about a Catholic weekly in England called The Universe.  Apparently, they are getting on the TLM bus along with The Catholic Herald and even the ultra-lefty weekly The Tablet.

This is firmly in the Brick by Brick Department.

13 March 2009

PRESS RELEASE FROM THE LATIN MASS SOCIETY

For Immediate Release

British Catholic Newspaper – The Universe – Introduces Special Weekly Page for Extraordinary Form (Traditional Latin Rite) News

After prompting from the Latin Mass Society of England and Wales, The Universe has introduced a weekly page of news and listings for the Extraordinary Form of the Roman Rite (Traditional Latin Rite). The page will commence in the issue of Sunday 15 March.

The Universe will also publish the full weekly calendar for the Extraordinary Form. This will be provided each week by Gordon Dimon, the LMS’s Senior MC, who also compiles the LMS’s annual Ordo which is used by priests worldwide.

John Medlin, LMS General Manager, said: “The Universe is obviously moving to catch up with The Catholic Herald which already has wide coverage of Traditional Rite affairs and even the ultra-liberal Tablet which publishes a weekly link to the Traditional calendar on the LMS’s website” (www.latin-mass-society.org).

He went on: “The Universe has dragged its feet for years in relation to the Extraordinary Form so this is good news. I will be asking all the LMS’s Representatives across England and Wales to send stories and pictures to The Universe.  [Good!  Do it, folks!]

“I think The Universe had found that its core ‘justice and peace’ market was ageing and collapsing and is urgently seeking to connect with younger generations who are developing a great interest in the Traditional Rite. The LMS will do all it can to help!”

Of the weekly Catholic papers in England and Wales, only The Catholic Times is now holding out against the Traditional trend, but apparently changes will soon be underway there as well.

Posted in Brick by Brick |
5 Comments

Rodari on the new Archp. of Westminster

Damian reports that Rodari reports…. {whew! pant!}… that the next Archbishop of Westminster will be an auxiliary of the same, H.E. Most Rev. Bernard Longley, age 53

Damian reports that he is not a member of the "Magic Circle" and that he is friendly to the older form a Mass…  always a good sign that he has his head screwed on forward, instead of.. you know… the other way.

Rodari was right about Archbp. Dolan and NY.

Whomever the Pope chooses, let some healing begin.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
15 Comments

QUAERITUR: Revive the Oath Against Modernism?

A priest reader sent the following:

I know that there is much being done to work toward restoring the Sacred Liturgy in the Latin Church… Have you heard any suggestion at all that the Oath again Modernism be reinstated as a safeguard to doctrinal integrity and against heresy?  In reading through it, it seemed to me that there are a lot of older clergy ordained in the late 1950s and very early 1960s who have been living perjury against their own solemn oath for decades.  Was, or is the idea that Vatican II threw this out, and it was no longer binding?

Good questions.

I have not heard it suggested anywhere that matters that the Oath Against Modernism be reclaimed as a sine qua non before ordination or taking a ecclesiastical office.

Could it be that too many men wouldn’t be able to swear to it?

In any event, I would be content were the Oath reinstated.

"But Father! But Father!", I can hear some of you exclaiming in frustration.  "What is this Oath?  What does it say?"

Glad you asked!  My emphases and comments.

THE OATH AGAINST MODERNISM

Given by His Holiness St. Pius X September 1, 1910.

To be sworn to by all clergy, pastors, confessors, preachers, religious superiors, and professors in philosophical-theological seminaries.

I . . . . firmly embrace and accept each and every definition that has been set forth and declared by the unerring teaching authority of the Church, especially those principal truths which are directly opposed to the errors of this day. [Consider the context of the late 19th and early 20th centuries.  This could still apply today.] And first of all, I profess that God, the origin and end of all things, can be known with certainty by the natural light of reason from the created world (see Rom. 1:90), that is, from the visible works of creation, as a cause from its effects, and that, therefore, his existence can also be demonstrated: Secondly, I accept and acknowledge the external proofs of revelation, that is, divine acts and especially miracles and prophecies as the surest signs of the divine origin of the Christian religion and I hold that these same proofs are well adapted to the understanding of all eras and all men, even of this time. Thirdly, I believe with equally firm faith that the Church, the guardian and teacher of the revealed word, was personally instituted by the real and historical Christ when he lived among us, and that the Church was built upon Peter, the prince of the apostolic hierarchy, and his successors for the duration of time. Fourthly, I sincerely hold that the doctrine of faith was handed down to us from the apostles through the orthodox Fathers in exactly the same meaning and always in the same purport. Therefore, I entirely reject the heretical’ misrepresentation that dogmas evolve and change from one meaning to another different from the one which the Church held previously. [This would be hard for some people to understand today.  There is a difference between development of doctrine and change of doctrine.] I also condemn every error according to which, in place of the divine deposit which has been given to the spouse of Christ to be carefully guarded by her, there is put a philosophical figment or product of a human conscience that has gradually been developed by human effort and will continue to develop indefinitely. Fifthly, I hold with certainty and sincerely confess that faith is not a blind sentiment of religion welling up from the depths of the subconscious under the impulse of the heart and the motion of a will trained to morality; but faith is a genuine assent of the intellect to truth received by hearing from an external source. By this assent, because of the authority of the supremely truthful God, we believe to be true that which has been revealed and attested to by a personal God, our creator and lord.

Furthermore, with due reverence, I submit and adhere with my whole heart to the condemnations, declarations, and all the prescripts contained in the encyclical Pascendi and in the decree Lamentabili, [remember the historical context.] especially those concerning what is known as the history of dogmas. I also reject the error of those who say that the faith held by the Church can contradict history, and that Catholic dogmas, in the sense in which they are now understood, are irreconcilable with a more realistic view of the origins of the Christian religion. [This would knock a few people out of their present offices.] I also condemn and reject the opinion of those who say that a well-educated Christian assumes a dual personality-that of a believer and at the same time of a historian, as if it were permissible for a historian to hold things that contradict the faith of the believer, or to establish premises which, provided there be no direct denial of dogmas, would lead to the conclusion that dogmas are either false or doubtful. Likewise, I reject that method of judging and interpreting Sacred Scripture which, departing from the tradition of the Church, the analogy of faith, and the norms of the Apostolic See, embraces the misrepresentations of the rationalists and with no prudence or restraint adopts textual criticism as the one and supreme norm. Furthermore, I reject the opinion of those who hold that a professor lecturing or writing on a historico-theological subject should first put aside any preconceived opinion about the supernatural origin of Catholic tradition or about the divine promise of help to preserve all revealed truth forever; and that they should then interpret the writings of each of the Fathers solely by scientific principles, excluding all sacred authority, and with the same liberty of judgment that is common in the investigation of all ordinary historical documents.

Finally, I declare that I am completely opposed to the error of the modernists who hold that there is nothing divine in sacred tradition; or what is far worse, say that there is, but in a pantheistic sense, with the result that there would remain nothing but this plain simple fact-one to be put on a par with the ordinary facts of history-the fact, namely, that a group of men by their own labor, skill, and talent have continued through subsequent ages a school begun by Christ and his apostles. I firmly hold, then, and shall hold to my dying breath the belief of the Fathers in the charism of truth, which certainly is, was, and always will be in the succession of the episcopacy from the apostles. The purpose of this is, then, not that dogma may be tailored according to what seems better and more suited to the culture of each age; rather, that the absolute and immutable truth preached by the apostles from the beginning may never be believed to be different, may never be understood in any other way.

I promise that I shall keep all these articles faithfully, entirely, and sincerely, and guard them inviolate, in no way deviating from them in teaching or in any way in word or in writing. Thus I promise, this I swear, so help me God. . .

I believe that if a person took this oath, he is still bound by it even though this specific is no longer administered to people in the positions described.   I have not heard that the Church released men from this oath if they took it.

 

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, Mail from priests |
38 Comments