Tornielli on Williamson and conspiracies to embarass the Pope

The intrepid Andrea Tornielli has a piece in Il Giornale today about, what else, SSPX Bp. Williamson and the Jews.

The great Fabrizio kindly did a rapid translation for us.

A conspiracy against the Pope behind the negationist bishop

By Andrea Tornielli

It is an unofficial dossier, of only a few pages, dedicated to the origins of the Williamson case, much read in the sacred palaces [that is, the buildings of the Vatican where the offices of the Curia are, especially the Apostolic Palace] these days. It is a dossier that reached the desks that count in on the Vatican side of the Tiber and that puts together dates and circumstances, suggesting that what happened in these latest days could be more than a series of coincidences.

According to the dossier, the filming and airing of the interview with the prelate denying gas chambers and the reality of the millions of  Jews dead during the Shoah, in the eve of the remission of the excommunication of the Lefebvrist bishops was somehow orchestrated by circles seeking  to put Benedict XVI in trouble. Circles that might have been helped by some opposition from within, someone contrary to the reconciliation with the Fraternity St. Pius X.
The dossier minimizes neither the absurd words pronounced by Williamson, nor the gravity of their coincidence with the Day of Memory, which especially hurt the sensibility of the Jewish world, but it hints to the possibility of interventions aimed at creating the case.

Williamson – says the dossier – was interviewed on November 1st 2008 “at the Bavarian seminary of the Fraternity St. Pius X”. The bishop was in Regensburg where he came to ordain to priesthood a Swedish former Protestant pastor. The bishop is reached by the journalist Ali Fegan, of the TV show “Uppgrad Gransking” (“Mission Research”). They talk for one hour. At some point, Fegan reminds Williamson certain negationist statements on gas chambers he had released many years earlier in Canada. The bishops answers by saying the well-known enormities, knowing that his words, in Germany, constitute a criminal offence: “for the things I am saying you could take me to jail since we are in Germany…”
The interview was aired on January 21st, the very day of the signing of the decree of remission of the excommunication.

 

 

The authors of the show guarantee that it was a coincidence, while the “Dossier Williamson” does not rule out the possibility that the info about the remission of the excommunication was somehow leaked to the Swedish network.  During the same  show there was also an interview with the French journalist Fiammetta Venner, a well-known militant of the homosexual movement and active in pro-choice campaigns. On the eve of last september’s journey of Benedict XVI to Paris and Lourdes, together with her lover Caroline Fourest – with whom she shares many anti-religious battles and ties to the Grand Orient of France – she authored a book titled “The New Papal Army. Legion of Christ, Opus Dei, Traditionalists”, very harsh against the Pope and against the Lefebvrists, accused of connections with the circles of the French far-right. The dossier insists on the French origin of the case and on the role played by Venner and Fourest in this story. On January 20, on the eve of the airing of the show, the German weekly Der Spiegel revealed in advance the contents of the interview and will go as far as to write that “the Central Council of Jews in Germany “ had been “already informed” of the negationist statements of the bishop.

But the decree had been already penned and personally delivered into Fellay’s hands by Card. Giovanni Battista Re, the head of the Fraternity St. Pius X, called to Rome for the occasion. Therefore, when the news of the Williamson interview begun to spread around, it was already to late to do anything. On January 20th, the Diocese of Stockholm and the head of the German Lefebvrists release two distinct communiqués to deplore all forms of anti-Semitism. The news was already in the open, but its scope and its consequences are not perceived in the sacred palaces.

A complicated mystery, then, or a series of coincidences? The dossier circulated does not contain evidence. It limits itself to compare hypothesis and data. One thing is sure: not many, in the Vatican, believe that the Williamson case was just a coincidence.

Paolo Rodari also has an interesting story.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
29 Comments

The REDPOLLS are coming! The REDPOLLS are coming!

The REDPOLLS are coming! The REDPOLLS are coming!
The REDPOLLS are coming! The REDPOLLS are coming!The REDPOLLS are coming! The REDPOLLS are coming!

Indeed, the Redpolls have come.

Yesterday I spotted this new (to me) bird, flock of them actually, at the Sabine feeders.

The REDPOLLS are coming! The REDPOLLS are coming!

You readers instantly illumined my mind by informing me that this is the Common Redpoll.

They are a bit more aggressive than other birds, and they so far have spent energy driving away the very similar Pine Siskin.

The REDPOLLS are coming! The REDPOLLS are coming!

This Chickadee is doing his usual grab and dash, so the Redpole hasn’t gone after him… yet.

The REDPOLLS are coming! The REDPOLLS are coming!

I am guessing that they have moved south from Canada in search of food during this already hard winter.

The REDPOLLS are coming! The REDPOLLS are coming!

There scientific name is Carduelis flammea, for obvious reasons.

The REDPOLLS are coming! The REDPOLLS are coming!

You can see the similarity to its cousin, Pine Siskin.The REDPOLLS are coming! The REDPOLLS are coming!

The REDPOLLS are coming! The REDPOLLS are coming!

In other news… this American Goldfinch is hanging around, doing that flapping thing to stay on the perch on this windy day!

The REDPOLLS are coming! The REDPOLLS are coming!

"But Father! But Father!", I can hear you saying.  "Enough about the Goldfinch!  What about that Navy Bean Soup you were making yesterday??"

The REDPOLLS are coming! The REDPOLLS are coming!

With a slice of a dark rye, it’s pretty good.

Posted in Fr. Z's Kitchen, My View |
10 Comments

POLL: St. Blaise Day Blessing

POLL: St. Blaise Day BlessingI am sure this is some sort of joke on the saint’s part, but whenever I get my blessing on St. Blaise Day within days I get a sore throat.

Still, it is a lovely custom which we should foster.

So… here is today’s WDTPRS POLL!

POLL CLOSED

Did you or will you have your St. Blaise Day throat blessing?

  • Yes (68%, 629 Votes)
  • No (32%, 292 Votes)

Total Voters: 921

Posted in POLLS |
60 Comments

Do any of you out there …

… use Quicktime PRO?

What’s the deal?  Is it worth it?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
9 Comments

The new Bishop of Linz, Austria – the left is freaking out

Many people have sent me notes about the new auxiliary bishop of Linz, Austria.  The left wing is going nuts over the appointment of this "ultra-conservative".

A kind reader translated an article from German, which I share with you here:

I Can Not Be Blackmailed Over Church Doctrine 

Gerhard Wagner is for celibacy, has no female altar servers in his parish and asks who is really being divisive in the diocese: The future auxiliary bishop did not disappoint at his introduction yesterday.

A few supporters applaud as Wagner enters the hall with Bishop Ludwig Schwarz. Bishop Schwarz is unhappy about the hefty reactions to Wagner’s appointment. "It was not pretty" he says. He reminds critical priests that they have sworn to be reverent and obedient to the Bishop. Then Wagner introduces himself and answers journalists questions.

Who is being divisive?

Wagner jokes "only one thing divides me from Bishop Schwarz: He is a Rapid supporter (Vienna Soccer Club), [it is a good sign when a man likes sports to some extent] and I’m a LASK fan (Linz Soccer Club)" Then he gets serious and speaks about the polarization in the diocese. "What unifies us, is our Catholic faith. Those who dissent should consider whether it is not really they who are being divisive. [excellent!]  I fail to see why I should portrayed as divisive when I step up in defence of the Church and align myself with the Pope. Something is not right there."  [Right!]

You cannot ignore the fact, says Wagner upon questioning, that the Second Vatican Council strengthened the role of the laity.The Church needs committed laymen. But a priest can only be replaced by a priest. It is not possible to take from a priest that "which belongs to the nature of the priesthood." "Celibacy shows that there are persons willing to completely give themselves for the Kingdom of God, and the people expect that too."

What is a punishment?

In the case of his controversial statements about hurricane Katrina and "spiritual pollution", Wagner says he didn’t write about "God’s Punishment". No one knows whether something is a punishment from God or not, he says. But we must not forget that God does set boundaries for us; just as parents who, when they punish a child, act out of love.

Confronted with the question, whether he is afraid of people leaving the Church as a result his appointment, the future auxiliary Bishop responds with another question: "Should we be continually adapting the doctrine of the Church to please those who threaten to leave tomorrow and the day after tomorrow? I say: We cannot be blackmailed. Of course, I would like to make an effort on behalf of each one." But in the end you can’t prevent someone from leaving.

Female altar servers are not required, says the pastor in response to the question about why there are none in Windischgarsten (Fr. Wagner’s parish). That is not a question of the faith. "At a certain age, boys and girls don’t want to have anything to do with each other. Then, when they do want to have something to do with each other, at 14, then they no longer want to become servers."

"Christian Roots"

The final question concerns the examination of islamic religion teachers. Wagner chimes in: "Islam is spreading because we are not conscious of our Christian roots." Turning to the journalists he says: "You should stop constantly beating up on the Catholic Church. With other religions you are far more circumspect."

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
53 Comments

Hunger

I have tonight been overwhelmed by the e-mail sent to me.

So many people have promised prayers…

…or asked for them.

You have so many questions.

People are so hungry.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
24 Comments

What a cleric sees

… during Mass.

What a cleric sees

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
21 Comments

Can you tell the difference?

Some years ago, when I was living in S. California, a priest friend showed up at the door saying gruffly, "Get in the car… I want to show you something."

He drove us to a supremely ugly building, which he admonished me to take in and think about. 

It was a country juvenile correction facility.

Then off we went again!

This time we went into the heart of downtown Los Angeles.

To the Cathedral.

We went up into the plaza in front of the Rog Mahal.

My friend said: "What does it remind you of?"

This little preface leads me to a piteously amusing post at The Crescat.

"Can you tell the difference"

That is… between some modernistic churches and some correctional facilities.

Samples.

Can you tell the difference?

and

Can you tell the difference?
 
Friends, when people don’t know who Jesus Christ is, or who the Church is, or who they are as Catholic Christians, then their architecture will go wrong.

How often have you seen a church that looks more like a municipal airport terminal or drive-thru bank than a sacred building dedicated to God?

I’m just askin’

Sometimes they look like jails.

Posted in I'm just askin'... |
71 Comments

Ft. Lauderdale, FL: Gregorian Chant Workshop 6-7 March

In the brick by brick department:

Hi Father,
 
Perhaps your readers would be interested in the following:
 
www.musicasacra.com/florida
Musica Sacra Florida is happy to announce:
 
Gregorian Chant Workshop
Sponsored by the Florida Chapter of the Church Music Association of America
in conjunction with the
Farquhar College of Arts and Sciences
at Nova Southeastern University in Fort Lauderdale
Friday, March 6th – Saturday, March 7th, 2009
 
 
This two-day workshop will present both beginning and advanced musicians with rehearsals and lectures that will enrich their knowledge of Gregorian chant and its use in the Roman Catholic liturgy.
 
Led by a faculty of chant specialists from around the state, attendees will learn more about the history of Gregorian chant and its role in the liturgy as well as experience the chant in the context of both the Divine Office and the Mass. Beginning chanters will be introduced to the basics of notation and rhythm according to the Solesmes method. Experienced chanters will learn new repertoire and advance their understanding of rhythmic and interpretive nuance. Resources and practical methods for the cultivation of Gregorian chant in the life of the parish will also be discussed.
 
This workshop is ideal for choir members, parish music directors, music students, teachers, parents, seminarians and anyone who is interested in learning about the heritage of sacred music within the Roman Catholic Church.
 
Registration fees are $35 and include the price of instructional materials and instruction. Participants are responsible for all their meals and housing during the conference. Payment is due upon arrival at the conference.

Posted in Brick by Brick |
4 Comments

SSPX leadership and Bp. Williamson having a hard time of it

Via CathCon, on top of things lately, we learn of a story in the Mittelbayerische Zeitung, namely, that the SSPX leadership is not satisfied with the apology made by SSPX Bp. Williamson.

Frankly, I thought Williamson’s apology to be pretty good.  Sure, it didn’t got into lots of details.  He didn’t exactly rub gravel in his hair. 

The translation is pretty rough.

Holocaust denier Williamson threatened with consequences

Bishop Fellay is to announce possible sanctions against Richard Williamson in the coming days.  [Let us be clear about this.  This would be entirely internal to how they get along.  The SSPX does not have authority to impose sanctions on anyone.] "Yes. I’m already in the course of action,"he said on Sunday outside of Mass in Zaitzkofen (Regensburg area), where the Society of St Pius maintains a seminar [sic] for priests. There the Lefebvre Bishop Richard Williamson apparently also gave the controversial television interview in which he denied the Holocaust of six million Jews. The Regensburg prosecutor is investigating a case of race hatred.

Fellay on Sunday gave no concrete indications of the implications of the Holocaust denial will have for Williamson in the Society of St Pius. A possible resignation or an official withdrawal [From WHAT?  The SSPX?  I doubt it.] Fellay would not confirm. "This is perhaps too much to say, but I do not see how Bishop Williamson now can exercise his office of bishop in many countries." [That leaves a lot of other countries.] Apparently, however, in any case a strong reduction of the work of Williamson is being considered.

Lefebvre Bishop Fellay was disappointed that Williamson last Friday, in the midst of worldwide uproar, had regrets over his interview, but had withdrawn nothing substantive. [In other words, Fellay was sorry that Williamson wasn’t more specific and clear.] "You see the situation in which we are. From this you can see that we are disappointed, "he said. Before the interview, he had known nothing of the anti-Semitic attitude of the British bishop. "As he did now, he has never spoken." He had not been aware that Williamson had "extravagant thought" on various topics. "I have, so to speak, to attribute that “to the Briton."  [AH YES!  the pesky "Briton"… painted blue, with a club, screaming as they come over the walls….]

Anti-Semitism was in the Society of St Pius an isolated case. "In each group there are always people on the edges." By Williamson word, wounds had been newly torn open. "I apologise to those who have been hurt by this and especially the Jewish people."

 

Even with this rough translation, you can see that things are heating up.  The SSPX is reacting with warmth, which indicates to me that even they have some sense of urgency in this matter.  I don’t think this is simple damage control, though clearly it is that too.  After all, they have a base and funding to think about if they are going to survive in a climate that will see less and less discretionary income amongst their followers.

So… what’ll it be?  Will it come to the point that Bp. Williamson will have to function ut sacerdos?  ut laicus?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
89 Comments