US Catholic Congressmen write to Pope Benedict about SSPX

This is from the website of a US Congresswoman of the 3rd Connecticut, Rosa L. D Lauro (D-CT).

Get this.  My emphases.

For Immediate Release
Friday, January 30, 2009

Contact: Adriana Surfas
202-225-3661
Click here for Printer Friendly Version 

Catholic Members of Congress Express Concern to Pope Benedict XVI over Bishop Williamson’s Denial of the Holocaust  [I wonder what their voting records are concerning abortion.  Cong. DeLauro is now going to instruct the Pope.]

Washington, D.C. – Nearly 50 Catholic Members of Congress wrote to Pope Benedict XVI to urge his direct repudiation of Bishop Richard Williamson’s public denial that the Holocaust occurred.

Below is the text of the letter.

January 29, 2009

His Holiness, Pope Benedict XVI Apostolic Palace 00120, Vatican City State, Europe

Your Holiness Pope Benedict XVI, As Catholic Members of Congress, we are writing to express our deep concerns with your decision to reinstate Bishop Richard Williamson to communion with the Catholic Church at the same time that Bishop Williamson publicly denies that the Holocaust occurred or that such was the policy under Adolf Hitler. We do not question your reasons for revoking the excommunication of Bishop Williamson or your right to do so, but we fail to understand why the revocation was not accompanied by an emphatic public rejection of his denial of the Holocaust. As such, we seek clarification on this important matter.  [They should read WDTPRS.]

[Now… they could have stopped there, but they have to grandstand now.]

Bishop Williamson has said as recently as this past November that, “historical evidence is hugely against 6 million Jews having been deliberately gassed in gas chambers as a deliberate policy by Adolf Hitler.” Yet, the Holocaust is a verifiable fact and as people of good will would agree, one of the darkest chapters in our history as a human family. There are still thousands of people amongst us – Jews and non-Jews – who can attest through eye-witness accounts to the horrors of the Holocaust. Bishop Williamson’s comments regarding the Holocaust echo those of neo-Nazis, Islamist extremists, racists and others who choose hatred and violence over peaceful co-existence among peoples of all races and ethnicities.

We understand that Vatican spokesman Fr. Federico Lombardi has said that this issue is unrelated to the reinstatement of Bishop Williamson and that you do not share in his views.   [But they ask anyway.  Why?] And we welcome your recent statement expressing "full and indisputable solidarity" with the Jewish people. But this is too sensitive an issue to be handled without a direct repudiation of Bishop Williamson’s views. As a spiritual leader and the head of the Catholic Church, we believe it is vital that you publicly state your unequivocal position on this matter so that it is clear where the Church stands on one of the most consequential events of the 20th century.  [The Church has stated, clearly, its position on the dignity of human life, when life begins, and the evil of abortion.  What are the records and statements of the people who signed this letter looking for a clear statement from the Church, from the Pope, on this matter?] To neglect to do so is to allow others to portray it as they wish and impede the progress made over so many years toward harmony and reconciliation.

Thank you for your consideration.

Respectfully,

ROSA L. DeLAURO
WILLIAM DELAHUNT
ANNA ESHOO
JAMES L. OBERSTAR
BART STUPAK
BILL PASCRELL
CHRISTOPHER P. CARNEY
GERALD E. CONNOLLY
MAURICE D. HINCHEY
JIM COSTA
PHIL HARE
JOSEPH CROWLEY
PETER DEFAZIO
PATRICK J. KENNEDY
DENNIS J. KUCINICH
JAMES P. MORAN
WM. LACY CLAY
RICHARD E. NEAL
ALBIO SIRES
PETER WELCH
TIM RYAN
TOM PERRIELLO
LINDA SÁNCHEZ
LUIS V. GUTIERREZ
CAROL SHEA-PORTER
MICHAEL F. DOYLE
DENNIS A. CARDOZA
JOHN LARSON
XAVIER BECERRA
GEORGE MILLER
FRANK PALLONE
BETTY McCOLLUM
JAMES A. McGOVERN
JACKIE SPEIER
CAROLYN McCARTHY
EDWARD J. MARKEY
NYDIA VELAZQUEZ
STEPHEN F. LYNCH
JOSE E. SERRAMO
SILVESTRE REYES
RAUL GRIJALVA
JOE BACA
BRIAN HIGGINS
MIKE THOMPSON
JERRY F. COSTELLO
DIANE WATSON
JOHN A BOCCIERI

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
77 Comments

Toronto’s Archbp. Collins on Pope Benedict and the SSPX

On the official blog of the Archdiocese of Toronto, H.E. Most Rev. Thomas Collins, Archbishop of Toronto offers observations about the lifting the excommunications of the four SSPX bishops and the subsequent ruckus in the press, especially concerning the Jews and whether Pope Benedict embraced an anti-Semite.

You can read the whole article at the link above.  Here is an important excerpt with my emphases and comments.

One important step in an effort to lead excommunicated bishops and especially their followers to end the division and return to the Church is to lift the excommunication that was imposed because of the unlawful ordination, and that has just recently happened as the Pope has made one more attempt to open the pathway for hundreds of thousands of followers of Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre to come back to the Church. The four bishops he ordained when he broke away were automatically excommunicated because they split the Church; now that excommunication of the four bishops has been lifted in an effort to heal the wound of that division. This is the most recent of several actions in years of patient work by Pope John Paul, Pope Benedict and others to try to bring home hundreds of thousands of Catholics.  [He did not use the word "schism".]

Apart from the fact that Pope Benedict is not known to be a fan of Swedish television interviews, in which one of the four bishops has revealed that he holds bizarre and evil opinions, it should be noted that the lifting of the excommunication is simply an important but limited step to help bring about the reversal of a move made years ago to destroy the unity the Church.

Williamson has clearly revealed himself to be a holocaust denier, but the Pope has not "embraced a Holocaust denier". Lifting the excommunications of the four bishops ordained by Lefebvre in an effort to repair the damage he caused is not in any way an award, nor a sign of approval, nor a blessing, nor an endorsement of the opinions or behaviour of any of the four Lefebvre bishops. [Exactly.] In any case, they are still suspended from priestly ministry, and it is now up to them and their numerous followers to respond to Pope Benedict’s action by taking the initiative to complete the restoration of unity. A hopeful sign is that the leader of the four bishops and their break-away church has now strongly condemned Williamson.  ["condemned"… too strong?]

Pope Benedict’s total opposition to anti-semitism and Holocaust denial has been made clear over the years. As recently as last week he stated: "I hope that the memory of the Holocaust may induce humanity to reflect on the unpredictable power of evil when it conquers the heart of man. May the Holocaust be for all an admonition against forgetting, against denial or reductionism, [You will find this word pop up once in a while.  It is a rendering of an Italian word, which describes reducing the scale of the Holocaust, diminishing the numbers, etc.] because violence against a single human being is violence against all." The Vatican’s official newspaper, L’Osservatore Romano, last week ran an article denouncing those who deny the Holocaust. You can find the text here. To suggest that the Pope in any way approves of those who deny the Holocaust is utterly unjust.

Bishop Sheen once said that there are not ten people in the country who hate the Catholic Church, but there are millions who hate the image of the Catholic Church that they have created out of misunderstanding. [Excellent quote.] Before people jump to conclusions and launch into impassioned condemnations of the actions of the Pope, simple decency and fairness dictate that they understand what they think they are disagreeing with, and not construct great castles of indignation upon the sandy foundations of mistaken information.

Archbishop Thomas Collins
January 30, 2009

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
12 Comments

QUAERITUR: retreats

Last night in Z-Chat someone raised a question about good retreats.

This is a good topic for us to discuss.

QUAERITUR: retreatsI think tough times are coming.  Knowing where good retreats are available could be very handy.

Too often people run into weirdos who suggest centering prayer focusing on their pet rock, or crystal, or doing the enneagram, and all that BS.

I have done retreats and I have heard from people what sorts of experiences they have had.

We really need concrete recommendations.  Concrete.  Not off hand comments.

Perhaps you readers can chime in.

We could use solid information based on experience about directed or guided retreats for individuals or groups (just men, just women).

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, The future and our choices |
60 Comments

A new visitor at the feeder and PENJING REPORT

It is a beautiful sunny day.
A new visitor at the feeder and PENJING REPORT
Today we have had some flurries and ice-crystals in the air.

This Pine Siskin is surrounded.

A new visitor at the feeder and PENJING REPORT

I have a new comer to the feeder!

These guys are unknown to me, at least in this plumage.

They have some pinkish feathers on their breasts and a bright red blaze on the top of their heads.

A new visitor at the feeder and PENJING REPORT

They are some sort of finch.

A new visitor at the feeder and PENJING REPORT

They are as picky as the others.  Note how they throw their food around!A new visitor at the feeder and PENJING REPORT

See the seed in the air?

A new visitor at the feeder and PENJING REPORT

The Chickadees are digging right now for their favorites, the black sunflower seeds.

A new visitor at the feeder and PENJING REPORT

Victory!

A new visitor at the feeder and PENJING REPORT

I will feel much the same when my Navy Bean Soup is ready.

It isn’t yet.

A new visitor at the feeder and PENJING REPORT

PENJING REPORTA new visitor at the feeder and PENJING REPORT

Profound health, as far as I can tell.  Glossy deep green leaves and new growth.

A new visitor at the feeder and PENJING REPORT

There are even little flowers coming.

A new visitor at the feeder and PENJING REPORT

There it is!

Candlemas proceeds through the day.

Posted in Fr. Z's Kitchen, My View |
14 Comments

SSPX Bp. Tissier de Mallerais: “we have the intention of converting Rome”

The fine Rorate has an English version of the interview SSPX Bp. Tissier de Mallerais did with La Stampa.

Here is, I think, the salient quote.

But do you think of turning back regarding your disagreements [with Rome]?

-"No, absolutely not. We do not change our positions, but we have the intention of converting Rome [to our positions], that is, to lead Rome towards our positions."

 

Remember in the days ahead that I have written again and again, that everyone who approaches the table for discussion of theological issues, must come with humility.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
56 Comments

SSPX Bp. Tissier: we’ll convert the Vatican – Reuters look at SSPX fallout

Trends are emerging.

Tom Heneghan, on the FaithWorld blog of Reuters, posted an interesting roundup about the fallout after Pope Benedict lifted the excommunications of the SSPX bishops.

One of the points he brings up is that one of the SSPX bishops, Tissier de Mallerais, hitherto a hard-liner, has said to La Stampa, that they wil covert the Vatian not the other way around.

Take a look at the piece is Reuters and check their page.

February 2nd, 2009
Vatican/SSPX — the fallout continues

Posted by: Tom Heneghan

The fallout from the SSPX issue continues to rain down on the Vatican. Several items over the weekend showed how messy it can get when the Vatican botches its presentation of a potentially controversial decision.

  • A demonstration against Williamson at the Vatican nunciature in Paris by several dozen Jewish protesters on Sunday. The Reuters photo below by Mal Langsdon shows a man holding a cartoon from the Paris daily Le Monde in which two SSPX bishops say in mock Latin “The gas chamber doesn’t exist.” Pope Benedict holds up a cloak which says “Down with Vatican II” and comments: “As long as they don’t say it in Hebrew, I’m not saying anything.” Will there be more of these elsewhere?

SSPX Bp. Tissier: we'll convert the Vatican - Reuters look at SSPX fallout

  • Bishop Bernard Tissier de Mallerais, one of the four SSPX bishops whose excommunications Pope Benedict lifted last week, told the Italian daily La Stampa (here in English) that the rebel prelates have no intention of changing their traditionalist views when they negotiate their reinstatement in the Roman Catholic Church with Vatican officials.” No, absolutely not,” he said. “We do not change our positions, but we have the intention of converting Rome, that is, to lead Rome towards our positions.” This is the man who in 2005 told the traditionalist U.S. weekly The Remnant “I will say, one day the Church should erase this Council.  She will not speak of it anymore.  She must forget it.  The Church will be wise if she forgets this council.” Until now, most attention has focused on SSPX Superior General Bishop Bernard Fellay and the SSPX Bp. Tissier: we'll convert the Vatican - Reuters look at SSPX falloutHolocaust-denying Bishop Richard Williamson. Fellay is considered the most moderate of the group and statements from the others are likely to take a tougher stand against any concessions to the Vatican.
  • (Photo: Bishop Bernard Tissier de Mallerais, May 2008/SSPX)
  • Several news outlets such as The Times and the BBC have picked up a story from Austria that the pope had approved the appointment of a new auxiliary bishop of Linz, Gerhard Wagner, who once described Hurricane Katrina as God’s punishment for sin and sexual excess in New Orleans and denounced the Harry Potter books for “spreading Satanism.” In a new interview with the Austrian Catholic agency Kath.net, he says “Islam is really a danger.” How much would you bet this would have gone unnoticed if there hadn’t been other negative news about the Vatican?

New statements and comments are popping up all over. A few trends emerge:

  • Denunciations of anti-Semitism by SSPX bishops. Bishop Fellay has made several such statements, each stronger than the previous one. His latest, to the French weekly Famille Chrétienne, calls Jews “our older brothers.” Fr. Franz Schmidberger, the head of the SSPX in Germany who has been quoted as saying the Jews must be converted, has also distanced himself from Williamson’s comments. While these statements have been welcomed, they have not answered the real question of whether the SSPX will accept Vatican II documents such as Nostra Aetate that changed the traditional Church position on the Jews (see Bishop Tissier above…).
  • Continued criticism of Bishop Richard Williamson and his denial of the Holocaust. Several Jewish and some Catholic leaders have said his apology to the Vatican for causing the uproar was not enough. The message is that he may have apologised and Pope Benedict may have condemned the Holocaust, but where are his full retractions, more direct criticisms of him and his denial or statements that people expressing such views have no place as office holders in the Church? The Central Council of Jews in Germany says it expects to see some “consequences” from the Vatican to prove it supports continued dialogue with and respect for Jews. One suggestion is that it suspend the procedure to beatify Pope Pius XII and later make him a saint.
  • Criticism of the Vatican for botching its public relations. This is going Catholic mainstream, with even Radio Vatican (German service says:“This concurrence of the lifting the excommunication and the Holocaust-denial by Bishop Williamson was fatal. Simply fatal.”) and Benedict’s close ally Vienna Cardinal Christoph Schönborn openly complaining about it. As veteran Vatican watcher John Allen wrote: “The way this decision was communicated was a colossal blunder, and one that’s frankly SSPX Bp. Tissier: we'll convert the Vatican - Reuters look at SSPX falloutdifficult to either understand or excuse.” Cardinal Karl Lehmann of Mainz openly criticised Cardinal Darío Castrillón Hoyos — head of the office dealing with the SSPX — of not doing his homework on Williamson’s controversial views.
  • Concern about a pattern in Benedict’s controversial statements. As Charlotte Knobloch, head of the Central Council of Jews in Germany, said: “We’ve heard the pope’s speech about Muslims in Regensburg, another statement about judging the Protestant church, then about evangelising Jews, the old Latin Mass, and now the rehabilitiation of a Holocaust denier. I don’t think this is a coincidence. The pope is a highly educated man. He says what’s being thought in the Church.”

    (Photo:Charlotte Knobloch, 24 Oct 2006/Arnd Wiegmann)
  • Investigations into anti-Semitism within the SSPX, such as here on the America magazine blog In All Things or John Allen’s All Things Catholic column.
  • Rumblings among Catholics who see Benedict as turning the clock back on many Vatican II reforms. Read this comment from Robert Mickens, the Rome correspondent of the London Catholic weekly The Tablet.
  • Petitions by concerned Catholics, run in France by the Catholic weekly La Vie (entitled No Negationists in the Church) and in Germany by the Church reform group We Are Church (entitled Full Recognition for Conclusions of Second Vatican Coouncil Demanded). There’s another French petition going around by fax.

Some recent Reuters copy on the controversy:

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on SSPX Bp. Tissier: we’ll convert the Vatican – Reuters look at SSPX fallout

More on Fr. Farinella: what he really wrote

Did you see my article about Fr. Paolo Farinella?  He is the Italian priest who said that in lifting the excommunications of the four SSPX bishops, Pope Benedict perpetrated a "rape" of the Church.

A reader, and old friend, sent a translation of the whole thing.

Here is the note my friend sent.  We should take a look at it before getting to actual translation.

As requested.

I think you should publish this hateful thing in its entirety. It is good to shine bright sunlight on the rot.

I also think you should mention, for your non-Italian based readership, that La Repubblica has long been a clearing house for this type of hate-filled anti-Church drivel.  The editor/founder, Eugenio Scalfari, has publicly called His Holiness “a thoroughly second-rate thinker.”

Is it not interesting how Don Farinella is perfectly free to be a “conscientious objector” to the magisterial pronouncement of the Pope in Summorum, and yet the Lefebvrists are mysteriously not free to be “conscientious objectors” to the Council?  (Of course, neither position is acceptable.)  At the end, after declaring that the Pope has abandoned the Catholic faith, he declares himself free to not recognize the authority of the Pope, in exactly the same way as the radical splinter groups like the SSPV did.  Fundamentally, the devil’s bag of tricks is pretty small.

Also, I would appreciate it, if you do publish this, if you could just mention that I tried to be very literal, and that no translation can really do justice to the vicious and sarcastic tone of this vile screed.  Some of the expressions (arrampicarsi sugli specchi, truppe cammellate) are pregnant with sarcasm in a way that doesn’t come out in English without a lot of explanatory notes.

That is a good preabmble.

Keep in mind my observation that, now that the implications of the news is really hitting the dissenters and progressivists, the real vitriol will start pouring out.

Let’s read Fr. Farinella’s observations. Mind you that what I sent was a bit unclear, insofar as the divisions of the article and translator’s comments are concerned, but you are smart and can sort it out. 

The Pope, the Lefebvrists, the Council

by Don Paolo Farinella

Is the Pope still catholic?

I should feel satisfaction in saying “I told you so”, but instead I feel bitterness and anger.  On September 14, 2007, opposing with all my might the introduction of the pre-conciliar Mass desired by the current Pope, I wrote in (the newspaper) “24 ore” a pamphlet  (Return to the Old Mass, Gabrielli Editore) in which I declared myself a conscientious objector, and, while everybody else played around with the legends about the “Mass in Latin”, I demonstrated that the explicit goal of the Pope was the abolition of the ecumenical council Vatican II.  Some people spoke of “exaggeration”.  Today, those who did not believe (me) at the time have the proof, and I hope no-one will reduce what his happening to merely internal affairs of the Church which have no interest for the rest of the world.

a) The return to opposition to the council

The revocation of the excommunication of the four schismatic Lefebvrists bishops is a rape perpetrated by the Pope against the Church, because, of his own initiative, he approves the position and defines that Vatican II never happened.  The Pope in fact does not ask the Lefebvrists beforehand for any act of acceptance of the teaching of the council as a condition for the revocation of the excommunication, but simply readmits them as if nothing had happened, taking a position against the Popes who suspended them a divinis (Paul VI) and excommunicated them as schismatics (John Paul II).  Either the Lefebvrists were schismatics, or the Pope who excommunicated them did so illicitly, since the conditions of the excommunication have not changed.  Or, the current Pope has made a mistake, a very big one.  On the same day of the revocation of the excommunication (January 24, 2009), the head of the schismatics, Fellay, in two different communiqués to his followers, writes:

[WHAT FARINELLA WRITES IN HIS ARTICLE, AS IF IT WERE A QUOTATION OF BISHOP FELLAY:]

“We are ready to write the Creed with our own blood, to sign the anti-modernist oath, we accept and make our own all the councils up to the First Vatican Council.  Yet we can but express some reservations concerning the Second Vatican Council a council “different from the others.” In all this, we are convinced that we remain faithful to the line of conduct indicated by our founder, Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, whose reputation we hope to soon see restored.

In the same way, in the talks that will follow with the Roman authorities, we wish to examine the deep causes of the present situation, and, in finding and appropriate remedy, to reach a solid restoration of the Church. … Our Fraternity wishes to be able to help the Pope ever more to put an end to the unprecedented crisis which is currently shaking the Catholic world. … We are also happy that the decree of January 21 2009 recognizes as necessary “meetings” with the Holy See; these meetings will allow the FSSPX to set forth the basic doctrinal reasons which it considers to be the source of the Church’s current difficulties.  In this renewed climate, we have the firm hope to quickly reach a recognition of the rights of the Catholic Tradition” (Menzingen 24 gennaio 2009. Bernard Fellay).

[WHAT BISHOP FELLAY ACTUALLY WROTE:]

“We are ready to write the Creed with our own blood, to sign the anti-modernist oath, the profession of faith of Pius IV.  We accept and make our own all the councils up to the First Vatican Council.  Yet we cannot but express some reservations concerning the Second Vatican Council which intended to be a council different from the others. (cf. Addresses by John XXIII and Paul VI)  NB how Farinella, by omitting the words in italics, and citation of the Popes,  makes it seem like “different from the others” is tendentious assertion of the Lefebvrists, rather the Popes’ own definition of the Council.  In all this, we are convinced that we remain faithful to the line of conduct indicated by our founder, Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, whose reputation we hope to soon see restored…."

NB: We also hope enter into these “discussions” – which the decree recognizes as “necessary” – on the doctrinal questions which are opposed to the perennial teaching of the Magisterium  (au magistere de toujours).  We cannot fail to recognize the unprecedented crisis which is shaking the Church today: the crisis of vocations, the crisis of religious practice, of catechism, of the frequenting of the sacraments.  Before us, Pope Paul VI spoke of an infiltration of the “smoke of Satan” and the “self-destruction” of the Church.  John Paul II did not hesitate to say that Catholicism in Europe was almost in a state of “silent apostasy”  A short time before his election to the Papacy, Benedict XVI himself compared the Church to a “ship that was taking on water from every side. All of these words in italics are omitted by Farinella, who seems to want us to believe that the “crisis” exists only in the minds of the FSSPX and the “apostate” Benedict XVI, not, of course, in his immediate predecessors, whom Farinella alone truly loves and understands.
So also, in these discussions with the Roman authorities, do we wish to examine the deep causes of the present situation, and, finding therein an appropriate remedy, to achieve a solid restoration of the Church.

[BACK TO THE ARTICLE]

b) Someone is shamelessly lying

Those like the Vatican Press Office, and the president of the Italian Episcopal Conference, Cardinal Angelo Bagnasco, who talk about a gesture of clemency and magnanimity on the part of the Pope, lie, knowing that they are lying, because they know all too well that the problems here are doctrinal, and have to do with only one question: “Is Vatican II at least a council like the others, the acceptance of which is essential to be Catholic, or else is it ad libitum, that is, at the discretion of each persons sensibilities, being only a minor council for a select group?”.  How can one reconcile the declarations of the head of the Lefebvrists, who, on the same day as the excommunications were revoked, publicly declared that they will never accept the Vatican II and its teaching for “basic doctrinal reasons” ?

There are no alternatives: either the Pope is lying, or the head of the Lefebvrists is lying, or they are both lying.  If the Lefebvrists can lay aside and disdain an ecumenical council, is it licit for a Catholic, while remaining Catholic, to refuse for doctrinal reasons the teaching of Benedict XVI, if he considers it harmful to the Catholic faith?  I think here we see can see pretty clearly what Don Farinella really wants out of all of this.

If the Lefebvrists can be re-admitted into the Catholic Church without having to explicitly accept the teaching of an ecumenical council, why does the Pope not make a similar “gesture of mercy” towards those Catholics who have been thrown out of the Church for “excessive progressivism”, guilty of considering the Council unfinished business? What place in the Church do the liberation theologians have, who have been persecuted, demeaned and driven out?  If the Council is not definitive, why use ‘two weights and two measures’ ?

Can I insist that my theological positions, diametrically opposed to those of the Lefebvrists, must have the same citizenship rights within the Church, thus putting an end to an ostracism and isolation that have lasted more than a quarter of a century?  Since all of the “prophecies” which I wrote in 2007 and earlier are coming true, should the bishop not ask for pardon and restore to me my dignity as a full-fledged Catholic which I believe I deserve?

From my point of view, I foresee and predict (as is said in the law: nunc pro tunc) that Benedict XVI’s next move will be a declaration that the Tridentine Mass must be regarded as the “ordinary form”, and the reformed Mass of Paul VI as the “extraordinary form” , this in order to reach within a reasonable time of about ten years the abolition of the latter, and the restoration of the Tridentine climate, to go out to the re-conquest of the modern world with the troupes of the traditionalists, trusted warriors of the restoration of medieval Christianitas.

c) Anti-Semitism as a theological foundation

Of the schismatic bishops, suspended a divinis, a certain Richard Williamson, had the impudence to deny the Holocaust on the very eve of his readmission to Catholic communion, which, by kind concession of the Pope, coincided with the eve of the Day of Remembrance of the Shoàh.  Nothing happens by chance, everything has a meaning and a symbolism.  Following the reactions within and outside the Church, the Vatican, the Italian Episcopal Conference, and the other “interested parties” manned the barricades to ‘make square the circle’ , without realizing that this is impossible.  For the Lefebvrists, anti-Semitism is a characteristic note of their theology, according to which the Jews are “deicides”, for eternity, unless they convert and recognize Jesus Christ as their Messiah and God.  In the letter of apology sent to the Pope by the confederate and head of the Lefebvrists, Bernard Fellay, he asks forgiveness of the Pope, but not of the Jewish people and all of the Jews who died in the concentration camps at the hands of the Nazis.  “The patch is worse than the tear” .  The Lefebvrists completely reject the conciliar document “Nostra Aetate” which speaks in positive terms of the Jewish religion, and in which is rejected for the first time the “deicide” as a fault of the whole people of Israel, assigning the responsibility only to the “Jewish authorities and their followers” at the time of Jesus (n. 4/866).

d) Popes make mistakes

In the Catholic Church, from a Catholic point of view, the Lefebvrists and Vatican II cannot coexist.  If they come in, It must go out; if It remains, they cannot enter.  In my opinion, in fact, the difficult part of the problem has not yet been resolved, and this reconciliation will bring more ruptures that anyone can imagine.  I pray that the Pope will retread his steps and take up again the Catholic faith which he has knowingly abandoned on the doorstep of the  Lefebvrists’ Fraternity.  Otherwise, we consider ourselves dispensed from recognizing his authority, as the Lefebvrists, have refused and continue to refuse authority  of John XXIII, Paul VI, and in part of John Paul.   All of this demonstrates that confusion reigns in the leadership of the Catholic Church, proves that Popes often infallibly make mistakes. Big time.

Remember folks, in the days ahead you will hear a mantra surrounding the theme that the Pope only excersises his ministry of unity when he tries to reconciled the left.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
37 Comments

QUAERITUR: Did Rome say “versus populum” is “the norm”?

From a priest reader:

I thought I read, when Mother Angelica opened her new shrine, there was somewhat of a dispute, because she wanted Masses said "ad Orientem" and others said she couldn’t.  The matter, I think, was appealed to Rome, and the decision came down that "the norm for Mass was facing the people."  I interpreted that as Sunday and Holy Day Masses had to face the people, but other Masses of devotion were open for discussion. 

Am I wrong?  Has Rome made a declaration such as this establishing the norm of orientation for Mass, or is it up to the celebrant, or whatever the local ordinary allows?  Would love clarification if you can get around to it. 

I don’t think Rome would ever have said that versus populum was the norm in such a way that ad orientem worship was or could be forbidden.

I am pretty tired right now, so I will let readers cope with the documents and citations to help you out.

But allow me to commend you for your interest in this matter.  Thank you!

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Mail from priests |
37 Comments

An alarming TLM at Toronto’s seminary

From Toronto Catholic Blog comes this.

Now… don’t freak out.  Just remember that this is a brick by brick process.

Some people will rush to all sorts of exaggerations.

Take the report for what it is worth.

I hope, frankly, it is all false.

First Traditional Latin Mass in 40 years results in liturgical abuse!

For the first time in forty years, the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass celebrated in the beautiful chapel at St. Augustine’s Seminary in Toronto would be something other than the Missa Normative of 1970. Bishop Attila Miklósházy, S.J. was the main celebrant.

In an unheard of experimentation with the Extraordinary Form of the Roman Rite, the Mass was “concelebrated” by Bishop Miklósházy and at least eight (8) other priests — a practice only permitted in the Ordinary Form and unheard of in the Extraordinary Form of the Roman Rite. The closest this Mass comes to concelebration is the ordination of a priest when the newly ordained is invited to assist in the Canon with the presiding Bishop. But this was not a concelebration as we understand it in the Ordinary Form—it was in fact the Bishop teaching the new priest to say the Mass.

Reports that the Mass would be celebrated have been known for a few weeks. In fact, it was made known ahead of time that the Mass would be celebrated versus populum. Perhaps, this could have been considered a valid alteration considering it is the Seminary and it would be helpful for the seminarians to view the rubrics. Yet, further investigation has revealed other serious liturgical abuses never anticipated by the motu proprio, Summorum Pontficum and as yet, unheard of in the blogosphere.

It seems that in addition to illicit concelebrating and facing the people the readings were in English. While this was anticipated in the motu proprio from an “approved translation” it is doubtful that Pope Benedict was referring to the New Revised Standard Version. [I don’t know what all that meant in Summorum Pontificum.  But the sensibilities of the congregation (in this case seminarians) ought to be respected.] One would assume that this would have at least been the translation in use in 1962, that of the Confraternity of Christian Doctrine.

It is also confirmed that Communion was received in the hand [This is not "wrong", in the sense that it is licit to do this.  But no one should be required.] and that a cone of silence has been ordered by the seminary rector, Monsignor A. Robert Nusca.  [Oh?]

 

There can be many things garbled or slightly distorted in reporting. 

I suppose more will come forth.

I people write me, I preserve anonymity.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
55 Comments

The seeping cracks are spliting open

I think this next week is it. 

This is probably the week we will start to see an acceleration of expressions of real hatred of the Holy Father and the SSPX. 

The nastiness is starting to seep out cracks in the foreheads of the progressivists which split open when Benedict lifted the excommunications.

These people are terrfied.

Ever since April 2005 they have been holding it in, waiting for a big reason.

After the first shock of last week, and the implication it holds for the Church and the discussion of the super-dogma of the"spirit" of Vatican II, they have collected their wits.

Reassured by a few of the bolder dissidents, the gerbils will – with the help of a sympathetic press – start treading out discouraging notes and articles.

Everything will be veiled by furrowed-brow thoughtful concern and barely concealed righteous outrage that the Jews were insulted or that the Council was impugned. 

"We were right about this Pope, you see.  We were right to be worried."

Watch how this accelerates during the week, now that they are crawling out into the light.

Be prepared to answer questions.  People will be confused by what they read in the press and hear from some Catholic sources.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
55 Comments