QUAERITUR: follow-up to “kissing the ring of a bishop”

Taking up issue of kissing a bishop’s ring, which we have look at before, this is from a reader:

I wanted to add a few comments about kissing a bishop’s ring outside of the liturgy. 

Technically there is no hard fast rule about genuflecting on the left knee, though this is often a pious custom.  During the liturgical actions, the genuflection to a prelate is always made on the right knee, because he has the fullness of Christ and is Christ at the altar. 

Also, one should only bow low to an auxiliary bishop when kissing his ring, because he is not the local ordinary. 

The confusing point about this is that traditionalists were so accustomed to genuflecting to Archbishop Lefebvre (who because of his personal rank one would genuflect to), that they continued the practice unaware with the four new bishops consecrated for the SSPX, who are actually only auxiliary bishops themselves.  Several SSPX priests attempted to correct this less-correct practice early on, but gave up after some time.  In any case, my 2 cents worth

 

Genuflecting on the left knee for a bishop: Yes, pious custom.  But it is a good one.  If one forgets and does so with his right knee, he won’t got to hell for it.

In liturgical actions, the genuflection is always on the right knee.  Good reminder!

One should bow, not genuflect, to an auxiliary.  Okay, he is not the ordinary.  Though I think one should always genuflect in the case of a Cardinal, anywhere, and probably a papal legate.

The "personal rank" of the late Archbishop Lefebvre and genuflecting: He wasn’t an ordinary anymore.  Why genuflect?

The four bishops consecrated by Archbishop Lefebvre are NOT auxiliary bishops.  They are not in union with the Holy See and therefore have no mandate which would indicate a genuflection.  However, I believe they often take to themselves trappings they would have had no right to use even in the old days.  Let’s us pray that their situation, and excommunications, can be taken care of soon, so that everything can be regularized.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Linking Back |
37 Comments

Canada: ramifications of the Crown losing a polygamy case

This worrisome bit came in from a friend:

Gentlemen,

I used to tell my students that after "gay marriage", the next social/legal barrier to crumble in the West will be against polygamy. The students looked at me incredulously. But I saved the best for last. After polygamy will come pedophilia: the fall of the barrier protecting minors from sexual acts with majors. Then they just looked at me stunned.

The logic is obvious. If marriage cannot be legally defined in the traditional way in order, at least, to protect children, then all barriers to forms of marriage are arbitrary. You cannot argue that having two parents of the same sex is any worse for children then having multiple spouses at the same time.

The pedophila argument is different, of course. It depends on the age that society judges an individual mature enough to make up his own mind about sexual relations. But the setting of any age above, say, 12 is arbitrary. Therefore what’s arbitrary implies an unjust discrimination.

…

From The Gazette, a Canadian paper.

The Crown likely will lose polygamy case against Blackmore

Lawyers warn that religious freedom would protect multiple marriages

MICHAEL SMYTH, Canwest News Service

Published: Saturday, January 10

Somewhere, right now, Winston Blackmore must be smiling.

The self-styled "Bishop of Bountiful" – Canada’s most high-profile polygamist leader – is being handed a show-trial platform to prove what he’s been saying for years: Taking multiple wives is a religious right and freedom, protected by the constitution.

As counter-intuitive as that might sound to people, he will have a very strong case. In fact, he will probably win, delivering the polygamist leaders in Bountiful a huge moral and legal victory.

B.C. Attorney-General Wally Oppal’s heart is in the right place. He cares about the women and children of Bountiful and believes they are being exploited. He’s trying to protect them.

But by bringing such a weak case against Blackmore and co-accused James Oler, Oppal’s efforts seem bound to backfire.

Blackmore’s lawyers will argue the fundamentalist practice of polygamy goes back more than 150 years in North America. They’ll point out polygamy is practised widely and openly around the world, including in places like Afghanistan, where Canadian soldiers are fighting and dying to preserve freedoms in that country.

They’ll argue the traditional interpretation of marriage between one man and one woman has been thrown open to wide liberal interpretation now that same-sex marriage has been legalized in Canada. And they’ll be right on every count.

I’m not saying I support polygamy, because I don’t. I’m just pointing out the reality: There’s a reason nobody has been charged with polygamy in this country for more than a century. It’s because the lawyers themselves know the charges won’t stick.

The experts in Oppal’s own ministry have said for years the Criminal Code section outlawing polygamy is outdated and unenforceable.

"It is in direct conflict with the freedom of religion guarantees in Section 2 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms," concluded one legal opinion sought by the B.C. attorney-general’s office. Several others said the same thing.

A 2005 study done for the federal Justice Department recommended the law against polygamy be repealed and the practice decriminalized, noting a conviction would result only in a "light penal sentence" anyway.

In other words, even if they buck the odds and the Crown can prove polygamy is still illegal in Canada, Blackmore would probably get a slap on the wrist. And the whole legal circus will cost taxpayers a fortune to boot. So what’s the point here?

Oppal should have followed the example set by the U.S. authorities who took down polygamist "prophet" Warren Jeffs on more serious charges like sexual exploitation. That’s the kind of charge that can be proven and stick in a court of law.

Instead, Oppal is proceeding with the flimsiest case possible. And the ramifications of losing are serious.

Consider this: If the polygamists win in Bountiful, what will be the reaction of Canadian Muslims? Many Muslim countries allow polygamy, though Canada currently does not allow Muslim immigrants to bring multiple wives into the country.

But if polygamy is recognized as a constitutional right in Canada, there’s nothing to stop Muslim groups from demanding recognition of their polygamist marriages and suing to have their multiple wives and children allowed into the country.

Is that what Canadians want? Will that stop the exploitation of women and kids? Wally Oppal should be careful what he wishes for.

 

That’s not all it will lead to.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
54 Comments

Lafayette, IN: regular TLM

From a reader:

Traditional Latin Mass to be offered: Una Voce of Lafayette, Indiana and the St. Rita Latin Mass Community are pleased to announce that there will be a regularly scheduled Traditional Latin Mass on the fourth Sunday of each month at St. Ann Church and Shrine. 

The first Mass in the Extraordinary Form will take place on Sunday, February 22, 2009 at 5:00 PM and will be followed by a pitch-in dinner in Memorial Hall across the street. 

Please bring a dish to share and join us!

Mass will be offered again on Sunday, March 22 at 5:00 PM at St. Ann’s and every fourth Sunday thereafter. 

For more information or questions, go to www.UnaVoceofLafayetteIndiana.org, email UnaVoceLafayetteIndiana@gmail.com.

Posted in Brick by Brick, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
4 Comments

Bp. Vasa: Those who profess to love God, but back abortion, are liars

The great bishop of Baker, Oregon, His Excellency Most Rev. Robert Vasa, speaks again in The Catholic Sentinel. 

We have written of Bp. Vasa before in these cyber-pages, here (about overcoming his own fear of speaking out) and here (on Sen. Biden and Speaker Pelosi).

My emphases and comments.

Bp. Vasa: Those who profess to love God, but back abortion, are liarsThose who profess to love God, but back abortion, are liars
By Bishop Robert Vasa

BEND — The Mass readings for the week between Epiphany and the Baptism of the Lord are taken from the First Letter of St. John. These readings are not always used for it often happens, depending upon the day on which Christmas falls, that the season of ordinary time begins immediately after the celebration of Epiphany. This year, however, the occurrence of Christmas allowed for a full week between these two post-Christmas celebrations and thus the readings from St. John’s first letter. As often happens, the daily Mass readings are both appealing and challenging. The reading of Thursday from I John 4:19ff is particularly appropriate in this year when the life issues are very much on the minds of pro-life persons.

The reason for the increased awareness and even concern on the part of the pro-life community is the specter of the Freedom of Choice Act (FOCA) which is highly rumored to be in the works at the federal level. It is this act which has stimulated the bishops of the United States to launch a massive postcard campaign  calling upon the House and Senate to abandon FOCA. While further details about the dramatic impact of FOCA on our American culture can be found in many places, I will simply say that it would establish abortion as a federally protected right and, as I understand it, preclude state limitation or regulation of abortion. Further, since abortion would be a federally protected right, it is very possible that even Catholic health care institutions and Catholic Physicians would be mandated to provide this heinous service.

Thus I strongly urge all who have a glimmer of concern for the lives of pre-born children to engage themselves in this postcard campaign. This is not an action which would limit or alter present permissive abortion laws, which some so-called Catholic pro-choice persons might object to, it would simply preclude a dramatic expansion of that permissiveness. [It aims at stopping FOCA.  That’s a good enough reason for such a campaign.]  Thus it would be very difficult for any Catholic, no matter how much in favor of abortion itself, to find a reason to refuse to participate in this campaign. [Oh? Look at this priest’s reaction to the post-card campaign] At the same time, I do not see how any Catholic senator or representative could vote for the passage of FOCA without recognizing that such a vote would constitute a direct and intentional declaration of their disdain for Catholic teaching. Such a vote would be tantamount to a public declaration of their intention to abandon the Catholic faith. [Excellent.] It would be imperative that the faith consequences of such a declaration be allowed to fall fully on the heads of those who would make it.  [Kmiec will now say that Bp. Vasa has been influenced by the vast right-wing conspiracy of vemon spitting bloggers who are trying to destroy relations between the Obama administration and the Holy See.]

The writing from St. John applies: “Beloved, we love God because He first loved us. If anyone says, ‘I love God,’ but hates his brother, he is a liar; for whoever does not love a brother whom he has seen cannot love God whom he has not seen. This is the commandment we have from Him: Whoever loves God must also love his brother.”

We of the Catholic faith certainly know that love of God is central to our tenets, this is the appealing part. It is hard to imagine a Catholic saying, “I am a Catholic in good standing but I do not love God.” But the inspired scriptures tell us that whoever does not love his brother or neighbor does not and, indeed, cannot love God. This is the challenging part. The people of Jesus’ day understood this and it was this understanding that prompted them to ask, “And who is my neighbor?” For all of us, and especially for Catholic legislators in every strata of government, it is necessary to declare, in conformity with the Natural Law and the teaching of the Catholic Church that, the pre-born child is our brother, our sister, our neighbor!

It may sound a little strong to state that legislators “hate” the pre-born child but hate is an absence of love and love means to wish another well. There is nothing about abortion that wishes the pre-born child well.  [Some, however, argue that it is better for the child not to be born than to be born into some kind of hardship.  The solution there is not to kill the child, but to love him after birth.] The preservation of abortion “rights” is already an absence of love for the pre-born child but the passage of FOCA could be construed as nothing less than active and positive disregard, even hatred, for these our brothers and sisters. To paraphrase St. John, “If anyone says, ‘I love God,’ but votes for FOCA, thus showing a disregard for his pre-born brother or sister, he is a liar.” Lots of things can be rationalized in government but I do not see any way in which any Catholic could rationalize or justify an affirmative vote for FOCA.

It is not necessary for your postcards to be as outspoken as this bishop but you do have an obligation to participate in this concerted effort to show love for the tiniest and most defenseless of our brothers and sisters. President-elect Obama made it very clear, prior to the election, that he would happily sign FOCA and the millions of Catholics who voted for him hopefully did so for reasons other than this promise and certainly not because of it. [Troubling.] It seems to me that it is particularly incumbent upon these same voters to make it clearly known to their representatives that their vote may not in any way be taken as a sign of support for FOCA. [Good point.]

Another way in which we show our affirmative love for our pre-born brothers and sisters is by way of our annual memorial on Jan. 22. This year the Diocesan Office of Pro-life Activities has scheduled a rosary and Mass at St. Joseph’s in Prineville on Thursday evening, Jan. 22. The rosary will commence at 6:30 p.m. with Mass beginning at 7 p.m. While I recognize that many parishes host similar memorial Masses to pray for the two-fold victims of abortion, the child and the mother, [and not only them] I invite any who can to join me at the rosary and Mass at St. Joseph’s in Prineville.

Regardless of how many years have passed since the Roe vs. Wade Supreme Court Decision and regardless of how prevalent and routine abortion has become in this country, the simple truth remains, it is an act of extreme violence to the pre-born child and to the distressed mother. Thus, if anyone says, “I love God” and still favors abortion, he is, to quote St. John, a liar. May we all live out faithfully what it means to love God.

 

Huge WDTPRS kudos to Bp. Vasa!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA, The future and our choices |
24 Comments

REVIEW: The General Principles of Ceremonies of the Roman Rite: For Inferior Ministers

REVIEW: The General Principles of Ceremonies of the Roman Rite: For Inferior MinistersTo restore continuity to the Latin Church’s liturgical worship, and by doing so supporting and accelerating his "Marshall Plan" to revitalize our Catholic identity after decades of enervation, Pope Benedict gave us Summorum Pontificum. 

It is a great gift to priests, especially younger priests, who will alter their ars celebrandi for the newer form as Mass as well.

Seminarians and priests of the Latin Church must learn to celebrate the sacred mysteries in their own Rite.  Ambrosian Rite priests should know the older and newer forms of that distinguished rite of Mass.  Romans must know their forms, traditional and post-Conciliar.  Training and resources must be provided so that they can reclaim what is rightfully theirs and yours.

Not only do Roman priests need these tools for the older Mass.  So do the lay people who serve for Holy Mass with the older, traditional Roman Rite.

To that end Romanitas Press has put out a booklet called:

The General Principles of Ceremonies of the Roman Rite: For Inferior Ministers by Louis J. Tofari.  (Abridged Edition)

REVIEW: The General Principles of Ceremonies of the Roman Rite: For Inferior MinistersHopefully by studying this book, inferior ministers (in the sense that they are not the priest, deacon or subdeacon), can become superior in serving Holy Mass.

This booklet, an advance of a forthcoming comprehensive edition, is geared for a "typical parish situation".  Therefore, the booklet doesn’t teach about how to use the biretta properly (what I call "birettiquette"), etc.. 
REVIEW: The General Principles of Ceremonies of the Roman Rite: For Inferior Ministers
On p. 9 there is a good paragraph about "Roman balance".

The author delves into deportment, uniformity, walking, sitting, turning, kneeling, genuflecting, bowing, sitting, standing still, gestures such as striking the breast, how to hold things, and one of the greatest challenges for servers and their training what to do with your hands.

The text is salted with Latin phrases, (with typos here and there).  I am not sure how many ten year olds will be planning their next move depending on the ratio accomodationis or adapt themselves ex actu functionis.  But certainly kids are smart, and if taught also these distinctions they can learn them with surprising speed.  Ceratinly thost who train servers should be aware of these divisions and categories of circumstances which can change how people do things during Mass.  No matter what, everyone should know terms such as in plano, and per longiorem.
REVIEW: The General Principles of Ceremonies of the Roman Rite: For Inferior MinistersREVIEW: The General Principles of Ceremonies of the Roman Rite: For Inferior Ministers
There is a section on lighting (and extinguishing) candles and what the priviledges of the sacred ministers are, as well as a glossary.

There are some photos and diagrams.

I was amused to find a little apologia (p. 7 ff.) about "rubricians". I have jokingly spoken of the need for a new group or order of priests called "The Rubricians", whose apostolate it would be to ferret out and correct liturgical abuses and teach the rubrics far and wide, aided of course by the faithful "Sacristines", a solemn yet joyful foundation of women who would get sacristies properly organized, stocked and teach the arts associated with care for the altar.  So, I was happy to read in the booklet about "misconceptions about rubricians" who are identified as those who have "made a special study of liturgical law".  For example, a common misconception about rubricians is "1. There are too many rubricians."  I agree.
REVIEW: The General Principles of Ceremonies of the Roman Rite: For Inferior MinistersREVIEW: The General Principles of Ceremonies of the Roman Rite: For Inferior Ministers
The booklet came with a card to be used by servers. Thhis contains the texts to be spoken when serving Mass, with interlinear pronunciation guide.  This might be useful to North American servers, since the pronunciation guide is colloquial rather than standard (the symbols for which might not be in common use by ten year olds… though… well … see above). 

The well organized card unfolds to reveal within, inter alia, more correction of errors.  There are lists of common errors together with a pronunciation key.

This is a good first edition of this booklet.  Those who train servers would find it useful.  So would priests!  Priests, and seminarians, need to know all these things even if they are not doing the training or serving Mass. 

As a matter of fact, I think it is a good idea for priests to serve Mass from time to time.

And when they do, they should be at least as prepared as the ten year old who, using this book, can easily toss out terms like per longiorem.

 

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, Brick by Brick, REVIEWS, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
22 Comments

Soup Day!

I like soup on cold days.

In these coming hard times… learn to make soup!

I found a great special the other day for leeks, that excellent vegetable so beloved of the Welsh.

I was inspired to make Potato Leek Soup.

Be sure to wash the grit out of the leeks.

I made a little bouquet garni from thyme and rosemary and added a bay leaf, which you will see below.

Soup Day!

Start with butter.  If you want to have a bit more depth, use a little bacon, which you would remove.

That is handy also for starting risotto.

You can use olive oil if you want.  Remember, it’s soup.  Be flexible and find what works best for you and your tastes.

Soup Day!

Chop your leeks and put them in the pan… I added a little onion I needed to use.

Don’t use too much of the green if you don’t want greenish soup.

Soup Day!

Cut the potatoes into small pieces.  Even large pieces will cook, don’t worry.

Soup Day!

In the meantime, your leeks are softening.  Move ’em around.

Soup Day!

Add the potatoes and a pinch of salt.

Cover the veg with chicken broth and put in the herbs and the bay leaf.

If you want, you can use a long strip cut from a long leek leaf as a string for the bouquet garni.

I was too lazy and just rinsed of the twist tie.  Sometimes I use (unflavored) dental floss.

The idea is this: make it so that you can pull it out.  And be careful: when herbs like rosemary or sage hit liquid, they can take over.

Soup Day!

Cook it down for a while.

Keep your heat low and stir it so that it doesn’t darken or burn.

Soup Day!

At this point you can go in several directions. 

You can leave it sort of rustic and serve it like this.  In that case I would add some cream or milk to taste and consistency.

You can puree it.  I did.

Soup Day!

Again, you can go with some cream.  I used a little reduction I made from sun-dried tomato and a touch of sour cream.

Add some "personality" through a tiny sprig of rosemary or little sticks cut from the leek.

Soup Day!

Yummy stuff.  Super easy.  Very fast. Nearly impossible to screw up so long as you keep the heat low while reducing.

Don’t be afraid simply to make it without fussing over a recipe.  It’s soup.  Fool around with it.

You could pair this with a Chardonnay.

It’ll freeze, btw.

I’m off to lunch.

Posted in Fr. Z's Kitchen |
35 Comments

Feeder report

Report on the feeder.

Since we are having a heat wave… it’s up to 3F… the birds are really out and eating.

Lots of American Gold Finches.

Feeder report

Feeder report

Feeder report

I think this is the Pine Siskin of interest.

Feeder reportFeeder report

Feeder report

One of the Gold Finches.

Feeder report

And the Chickadee… everyone has something to eat.

Feeder report

Posted in My View |
9 Comments

The 5th!

I had sort of wondered about her because of what they did to make her a) survive in the fleet b) survive on New Caprica, and then b) resemble the 6.

But.. there it is!

Is this misdirection?   A head feint?

Are you convinced?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
26 Comments

Correcting something in The Telegraph about the Apostolic Penitentiary and grave sins

I must correct something I read in the UK’s The Telegraph.

In an article on the recent open day with the Sacra Penitenzieria Apostolica, which handles issues of the internal forum, indulgences, etc., the Telegraph article said.. [my emphases and comments].

The Apostolic Penitentiary, or "tribunal of conscience", has been shrouded in secrecy ever since it was established by Pope Alexander III in 1179 and until now has never provided details of the cases it scrutinises.

They [the "cases" apparently] are considered so heinous [It seems as if the writer is trying to set up something that sounds ridiculous to the average reader by using such a strong word…] by the Catholic Church that only the Pope can grant absolution to those who perpetrate them.  ["perpetrating" is worse than "sinning" these days…]

…

While priests and bishops can deal with confessions of sins as grave as murder or even genocide, the tribunal is reserved for crimes which are viewed by the Church as even more serious.  [… and here it comes…. and won’t the Church seem silly once you get to the punch line…]

They include attempting to assassinate the Pope, a priest abusing the confidentiality of the confessional by revealing the nature of the sin and the person who admitted to it, or a priest who has sex with someone and then offers forgiveness for the act.

A third type of case that comes before the tribunal involves a man who directly participates in an abortion – even by paying for it – who then seeks to become a priest or deacon. …

 

What is going on here?

The writer is trying to say, I think, that the silly old Church is so self-important that she thinks that trying to belt the Pope or violate the Eucharist is more serious than genocide.   And no one really thinks abortion is so bad.  Therefore….

Let’s try to understand what the Church is really doing by saying that some sins are so grave that only the Holy See can lift the censures they incur.

The idea is this:

Some sins strike at the very heart of who and what the Church is. 

The role of Peter in the Church is so important for the life and nature of the Church that there is a special gravity in sins having to do with harming the person or name of the Roman Pontiff. 

The sacrament of Penance and the Seal of Confession is so important for the life of the Church that there is a special gravity when priests break it.

The sacrament of Penance and the ministerial priesthood which exercises forgiveness of sins are so important to the life of the Church that special penalties are imposed on priests who harm the faithful by attempting to absolve accomplices in sins against the Sixth Commandment.

Some sins strike at the very nature of the Church.  Therefore the Church requires that extra steps be taken in being reconciled with the Church after committing those sins.

This does not mean that the Church thinks that genocide is less "serious" than violating the Eucharist (although sins that offend GOD directly are graver in nature than those that offend man).  Of course the Church thinks genocide is serious!  

The point is that some sins receive special attention because of how they harm the Church, which is the means through which Christ desires that all people be saved.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
25 Comments

18 Jan: Will Pres. Obama react to this year’s proclamation of “National Sanctity of Human Life Day”?

From The Catholic League

BUSH PROCLAIMS PRO-LIFE DAY:
WILL OBAMA HONOR IT?
 
Yesterday, President George W. Bush proclaimed January 18 to be “National Sanctity of Human Life Day.” He said that “All life is a gift from our Creator that is sacred, unique, and worthy of protection.” The president emphasized that “we aspire to build a society in which every child is welcome in life and protected in law.”
 
The president received the praise of Catholic League president Bill Donohue:
 
“George W. Bush will be remembered as doing more to build a culture of life than any president. Not that his father and Ronald Reagan weren’t champions of life, too. The difference is that this president was faced with more challenges, and he made good on every one of them. From embryonic stem cell research and cloning to the Born Alive Infants Protection Act and partial-birth abortion, George W. Bush has been the pro-life community’s best friend.
 
“Barack Obama will soon be president. He is an avowed champion of abortion rights. When asked during the campaign when life begins, he balked, giving a lame answer. Bright as he is, Obama is not well informed about the most fundamental question of them all: What is the origin of human life? But even those who posit that no one can be sure must be inclined to offer protection to that which might be life. To assume otherwise is a game of chance no morally responsible society should tolerate.
 
“On January 22, the Right to Life March will take place in Washington, D.C. We know of President Bush’s honorable record. We now await to see what President Obama will say on the 36th anniversary of the infamous Roe v. Wade decision.”

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
116 Comments