QUAERITUR: Can I use an Angleus Press prayer book?

From a reader:

I wasn’t sure how to submit this for your column. By chance is there a provision in Canon Law relating to the use of materials put out by the SSPX and their publishing house Angelus Press?

As a gift I received a breviary – abridged 1962 edition. The text does not contain editorial content or other revisions favoring the SSPX, just the prayers for the Divine Office.

The book does not carry an Imprimatur.

Can I good conscience use this text or does it need to be burned?

Any help greatly appreciated.

This is a good question.

Yes, you can used this book.  No, you don’t have to burn it.

To my knowledge, the book doesn’t have anything in it which didn’t have an imprimatur before.

I enlisted the help of a canonist for this.

A breviary would more properly fall under the canons for liturgical books, 826, and 838. Therein we find that it is the prerogative of the Holy see to publish liturgical books. In the 1917 Code this prerogative was exclusive ("unius", c. 1257) and so other publishers needed delegation to do so. This is no longer the case, so Angelus Press, acting under the provisions of the 1983 Code, is perfectly capable of publishing approved liturgical texts – especially those, such as the 1962 breviary which (I believe) do not fall under and copywright law.
 
You are also right that ecclesiastical approval given to a text retains its force unless and until it’s withdrawn. So, subsequent editions of a text are not required to seek ecclesiastical approbation anew.
 
However, c. 826, 2 establishes that republishing liturgical books require an attestation by the Ordinary of the place of publication that it accords with the editio typica ("concordat cum originali"). The British commentary notes that a 1966 decree of the Congregation of Rites issued in 1966 gives the detailed regulations on this (AAS 58(1966) 169-171)….
 
So, you’re right – there’s certainly no need to burn the book, and I would have few qualms about using the texts (particularly if this is coming from someone who is not bound to the recitation of the Office), but at the same time, Angelus Press should not have published this without getting a "concordat" from the local Ordinary (I’m not sure where Angelus Press is actually located – their website gives an office address in Kansas City, MO, so the local ordinary would seem to be Bishop Finn or one of his Vicars General or Episcopal).
 
I think if I were a priest, deacon or religious bound to the Office, I would write to Bishop Finn, notifying him of this – he might (and Finn would be the right sort of Bishop for this task) be able to have one of his censors review the text and give it a "concordat" now. If Finn is indeed the Ordinary with jurisdiction over Angelus, he might be able to exert some oversight.

 

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, SESSIUNCULA |
62 Comments

New edition of the Missale Romanum (2002) on sale

A reader alerted me to this:

Not sure if you know of this already, but I thought you, and some of your readers, may be interested to know that the Missale Romanum edtio tertia emended by Pope Benedict XVI is now available for sale at a whopping US$337 or US$841.
 
http://www.paxbook.com/algorithmiS/servusPrimus?iussum=monstraScriptumEditum&numerus=31790
 
http://www.paxbook.com/algorithmiS/servusPrimus?iussum=monstraScriptumEditum&numerus=31791

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
26 Comments

Another Novus Ordo Mass ad orientem

From a reader:

I believe that you occasionally publish news of liturgical interest from various churches.

If you would like, please publicize that the 10:30 am Mass on Sunday mornings at Old St. Patrick in Ann Arbor, Michigan, is now being offered Ad Orientem every week by Father Gerald Gawronski (as well as all weekday Masses).

Attached are some pictures if you want to include any of them.

Another Novus Ordo Mass ad orientem

Another Novus Ordo Mass ad orientem

Another Novus Ordo Mass ad orientem

Brick by brick!

Posted in Brick by Brick |
52 Comments

“…wind through some dense copse…”

Many thanks for this to the Laudator Temporis Acti… for this and for something else he sent me recently!

Charles Burchfield, Journal (Feb. 22, 1912):

    Everyone is complaining about it. "Is it cold enough for you?" (most common); "This is the worst yet"; "I hoped we wouldn’t have any more of it"; "Hope it don’t last long"; etc. are among the common deprecatory remarks. I love it; I love a blizzard more than a calm winter day. I love nature in her wildest mood. A blizzard, a windy day, a thunderstorm—all of them I love. To experience any one of them is a veritable housecleaning of the mind; some of the dash and spirit of the wind enters into us; on such days we could conquer the world if necessary. Perhaps a calm quiet day has the same effect on someone else. For me, let me have a wild ragged sky, an icy wind, and some snow, and I am content.

    What I would not give to be out in the woods on days like this! The roaring of the wind through some dense copse would be the most enjoyable thing imaginable.

 

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
26 Comments

Weblog award polls are closed – many thanks!

Well, folks!

The polls are closed for the 2008 Weblog Awards.

Weblog award polls are closed - many thanks!

I thank all of you who participated.

It is important to keep our Catholic blogs in the first places in these award elections.

The award site says that they are going to check the voting logs for obvious cheating, and so the present vote counts may change.

You will be hearing fairly soon what the results are.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

Kmiec attacks ‘right wing’ Catholic bloggers

Get this… from CNA…

My emphases and comments.

Prof. Kmiec accuses ‘right wing’ Catholic bloggers of character assassination
Blames them for potentially “poisoning” Vatican-Obama relationship

Kmiec attacks ‘right wing’ Catholic bloggersWashington DC, Jan 13, 2009 / 11:53 am (CNA).- In his first lengthy article explaining his position after the election of President Barack Obama, Professor Douglas Kmiec is accusing “right wing Catholic bloggers" of distorting his position, attacking him personally, and potentially poisoning the relationship between the Holy See and the future administration of President Barack Obama.

In the article entitled “A Tangled Web. The Election & the Blogosphere,” written for Commonweal magazine, Professor Kmiec explains that “as the author of a book whose title asked Can a Catholic Support Him? –and whose contents answered with an enthusiastic ‘Yes, we can!’- I have felt the animosity of those with an insatiable desire for political payback.” 

“I’ve been subjected to unrelenting personal attacks launched from right-wing Catholic keyboards-blogs (and bloggers) so coarse and uncivil they make the insults of talk radio sound like actual journalism,” writes the law professor.

 “Further –he argues- the lack of civility that rules the right-wing Catholic blogosphere has infected mainstream Catholic journalism as well. In a syndicated assessment of the 2008 election, one usually thoughtful conservative columnist employed the following descriptions of Catholic Obama supporters: ‘decadent,’ ‘tribal,’ ‘immoral,’ ‘certainly stupid,’ ‘mindless,’ and in need of basic ‘adult education.’ And those were all in a single paragraph! Such highly concentrated rhetorical venom is not calculated to invite discussion.”

“My online tormentors,” Kmiec continues, “like to claim that their beef with me is my alleged abandonment of the prolife cause or willful misstatement of church teaching. Neither charge is true. I remain unabashedly prolife and I have never consciously misstated the doctrine of the church.”

“This essay,” Professor Kmiec further explains, “is not about abortion, but at least this much must be said: blog lies to the contrary, there is no real legislative interest in FOCA. The attempt to use FOCA to drive a wedge between the church and the incoming administration is unjustified”. [Let me get this straight…  Catholic opposition to FOCA does not in truth spring from fear about the consequences of unrestricted abortion or the consequences of that will have for hospitals and various professionals.  It is really about trying to drive a wedge between an Obama administration and the Holy See.  Right.  Got it.]  He then warns the U.S. bishops: “the bishops, having stated clearly their opposition to FOCA-and rightly so-should not allow the right wing to obscure what Obama shares with the church: concern for the poor; support for the average family; a commitment to ending an unjust war; and respect for our environment.”  [committment to FOCA]

“Unless the sore losers of November 4 manage to poison the well, the Holy See and the Obama administration should be working more closely together in service to others than any administration in modern memory,” he opines.

Going back to his criticism of Catholic bloggers, Kmiec writes that “the scurrilous remarks of conservative bloggers missed the point, which was that I and millions of others who voted for Obama did so not despite our Catholic faith but because of it.”

“A hate-filled blogosphere,” argues Kmiec, after defending the sincerity of Obama’s religious beliefs, “feeds a politics of odium, misleading people of faith and good will, diminishing and at times obliterating our ability to know one another.

“Sadly, neighbor-love is not what has overwhelmed my in-box since my Obama endorsement. Instead, right-wing blogs and their readers have launched missiles of hate, delivering ad hominem invective of an astonishing vehemence and crassness.”

Professor Kmiec later laments in his essay that “to be remade by a hateful blogosphere [I’m sensing a theme…] has its price, I’ve learned. I worry that such invitations to speak at Catholic colleges, and the fruitful exchanges these invitations make possible, will be fewer.”

“One member –he says- of the U.S. hierarchy whom I greatly admire has renounced our past association, writing, ‘We are not friends, professor,’ and answering my invocation of Christian brotherhood with a curt retort: ‘I do see you as a brother in Christ –a brother who is serving an evil end.’ The greatest personal price I have paid is the loss of old-and the preemption of new-friendships.”

Kmiec also confesses that when America Magazine’s blogger Michael Sean Winters speculated that the Obama administration might name him as ambassador to the Holy See, he was “flattered” and started seriously thinking about the possibility.  [hmmm…. so this essay is about…. what again…?]

But he claims that “neither God nor the president-elect had an opportunity to answer before the blogs were recycling their various calumnies, and adding now an anonymous voice allegedly saying ‘it would never happen.’”

Kmiec doesn’t reserve blame to “right wing” Catholic bloggers alone. In his essay, he says a role were played by “unfortunate remarks,” like the ones of Archbishop Raymond Burke calling the Democratic Party “the party of death,” and of Cardinal Francis Stafford at The Catholic University of America “describing some of the policies of the president-elect as ‘aggressive, disruptive, and apocalyptic.’”

But he returns to his accusations against “right-wing Catholic bloggers,” saying they are “acting as a thinly disguised political front for the GOP" and "remain fixated on the goal of precipitating an unnecessary war between the Holy See and America’s next administration. It is dismaying to see a few American prelates and their ‘anonymous’ Vatican commentators acting as witting or unwitting coconspirators in this divisive action.”

Nevertheless, Professor Kmiec takes solace in the fact that “blogs have not closed the mind of the new president and, like Lincoln, he bears ‘malice toward none’ and manifests ‘charity for all’.”

“Even spinning a pervasive web of falsehood, the right-wing Catholic blogosphere is no match for the self-evident truth of that golden rule-nor would its bloggers want to be, were they to indulge a microsecond of charitable thought before hitting the send button,” he concludes.

 

Sound a little one-track to you?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
87 Comments

QUAERITUR: bridesmaids and mantillas: yes or no?

From a reader:

Hello. My sister is getting married in March in an Ordinary Form Mass and I am a bridesmaid. I wear a chapel veil when I go to Mass, whether I assist in the Ordinary or Extraordinary Form.

My question: is there traditionally a "correct" headcovering for a bridesmaid?

Should I wear one of the small, circular veils that sits atop the head, as opposed to a longer (eg, shoulder length) veil? Should the bride be the only woman in the wedding party wearing an actual veil? (I will be the only woman other than the bride who will be wearing a hair covering at the Mass.)
 
Sorry if this is a crazy question! Thank you so much for your assistance.

It is not a crazy question, but I can’t give you an answer about "traditionally correct" in this case.  I simply don’t know what women did about this, "back in the day".

His dictis, I cannot see how a woman wearing a chapel veil in a Catholic Church is a bad thing or wrong or "incorrect".

I suppose you can argue that were such an apparition be so foreign in some parishes to provoke spasms and cause others to bleed from the eyes at the very sight, then it might be a good idea not to put it on.

Work this out with the bride and then let us know what you decided to do.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
65 Comments

QUERITUR: show tunes and wedding music

QUERITUR: show tunes and wedding music

From a reader:

The Catholic church where my daughter is getting married does not allow the song from Fiddler on the Roof, "Sunrise, Sunset", to be sung at the ceremony because it is not liturgical. 

The Catholic church where my wife and I were married allowed the song, which was sung as our mothers were escorted to their seats before the mass began. 

Could you clarify the rule if there is one?

 

A church is not a Broadway theatre.  A Mass or any liturgy of Holy Church is not a time for show tunes. 

A wedding is not a musical tune review.

A wedding, while a joyful moment for many involved, is not just a opportunity to indulge personal tastes.

Music in church should be sacred music.  It must be rooted in sacred texts and connected to and appropriate for the Church’s liturgy. 

I agree completely with the decision to ban that song from use in church.  It was entirely wrong for the other parish to permit it.

Sadly, this division in discipline and understanding of what Catholic liturgy is, what the sacrament of matrimony is all about, creates confusion among the faithful.  It gives them the impression that anything goes (to name another broadway show) and that if a priest sticks to the Church’s true understanding of what sacraments are and what liturgy is, then he is being "mean".

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
95 Comments

Still working on the video streaming things

I am playing around with the trial version of Vidblaster.  Great program!

It allows you to add effects and split screens for multiple webcams, etc., in far more effective way than I have been able to do it before.  Still working on the video streaming things

Slowly but sure… brick by brick… learning about this new technology.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
3 Comments

Brisbane: renegade parish in the news again

St. Mary’s in Brisbane is in the news again.

ABC (non commercial govt. station) had a video piece on the 7:30 report.   There is a transcript.

Check also these past entries here and here.

Here is a link to the video.

[WINDOWSMEDIA http://www.abc.net.au/reslib/200901/r330139_1487546.asx 320 257 false true]

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
43 Comments