At the conference

The conference continues in its second day.

I am having internet problems, as usual in Rome. 

Quickly, for the next session starts soon, I just wrote this for my weekly column in The Wanderer:

As I write, I am in Rome, attending a conference sponsored by a group called “Youth and Tradition”, but under the aegis also of the Pontifical Commission “Ecclesia Dei” (PCED).  The meeting marks 1st anniversary of Pope Benedict’s derestriction of traditional forms of Holy Mass, liturgy and the sacraments with his Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum.  There are three days of meetings and many speakers about sundry topics, mostly having to do with the character of the Extraordinary Form and how it responds in a particularly apposite way to some of the challenges Holy Church is facing in this modern age.  One of the interesting points I have picked up might also be of use to you readers.  The Vice-President of the PCED, Msgr. Camille Perl, remarked that with the anniversary of the Motu Proprio the “atmosphere” regarding traditional liturgy has changed, even though perhaps the “climate” has not.  His point is that a “climate” is a much longer term issue.  There is still a long way to go.  It has only been one year, very short in the life in the Church, and we must have great patience.  The Church has her cycles and her seasons.  I think that the silly season, and the period of distorted reform, is passing.  The atmosphere is changing.  The climate is changing too, but more slowly.  Slowly, but discernibly.  The seeds we sow now, or the roots we revive, will bear fruit in the future.  We can have the occasional hot October day in the part of the world where I grew up, and frosty nights in May.  But the seasons do change as the world turns, slides around the sun, and our lives are spun along with them.

 

In any event, I have taken lots of photos and made some audio recordings of talks.  There is a lot of "speech making" during the Q&A period, so those moments have been rather a disappointment.  Lot’s of hurt and frustration coming, especially from the Italians.

I think people in the US and UK should thank their lucky starts that the situation in their countries is what it is.  More about that down the line, perhaps.

BTW… I know that a Roman daily rather trashed what Msgr. Perl said yesterday.  His talk was good and realistic.  I noted with attention that he went after not only bishops who resist Summorum Pontificum but also religious superiors.

Ad ramos!

Back to the oars!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
32 Comments

The Rome Summorum Pontificum Conference begins

I am in Rome to attend the conference on Summorum Pontificum under the aegis of the Pont. Comm. Ecclesia Dei and the group Giovani e Tradizione.   The attendance is good and the talks, so far are good.

I am taking some photos and making some recordings, but I think our friend John Sonnen of Orbis Catholicus will have better photos than I.

We had a surprise visit from Card. Castrillon Hoyos, who spoke for a while.   Frankly, he said a few rather controversial things, some of which I found unsettling, some of which I agreed with.   He spoke to the problem of some traditionalists being impossible to satisfy.  

Is that not the case?  Honestly?

My old boss Msgr. Perl gave a very good talk this morning, and I will get to that later.  This afternoon Roberto DeMattei was stupendous.  A very smart talk.

I can share something about that last talk.  

De Mattei said that newer Mass grew out of a ethos which culminated in the 60’s, with the baggage that you can guess at: secularism. 

Next, an interpretive key of the Motu Proprio is that the older Mass was not abrogated and cannot be abrogated.  (About that last point I am not so sure, and I would like to know more about that.) 

He also added that the older Mass is not really subject to structural change.  This does not mean that the older form of Mass cannot ever change, but that structurally it is consistent with the earliest centuries even though some modifications took place along the way.

So…

Because the older form of Mass is what it is and comes from when it comes, since it wasn’t abrogated and won’t be, it is a "barrier" to the encroaching secularism which is shoving God to the realm of the private.  But I picked up that the TLM is not only a "barrier" but a "challenge".    Note the distinction: "barrier" is one thing, but "challenge" is another.  One is more reactive, the other proactive.  One is passive, the other active.

I think this might have been the most important insight of the day.

However, we must also pay attention to the vey important point that we are only one year out, with this Motu Proprio.  We need patience and prudence.

I will have other reports along the way.

In the mean time, I was out for lunch with a long-time friend and we had a very good lunch.  Tonight I am out for a plenary session of the Society for the Promotion of Chinese Restaurants in Rome.  We don’t, btw, always eat Chinese, because when we do we usually need to call a day or so in advance for the dishes we prefer.   But I digress.

It was a good beginning for the conference.

I continue to be in internet hell and I will post when I can. 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
84 Comments

Fr. Z now in Roma for a few days

Folks: A couple notes.

You can always tell when you are back in Roma.  The first thing that happened tonight is that a cabbie tried to rip me off.  Boy, did he make a mistake.  I explained the situation and he became very happy to take me where I needed to go at the proper rate.  It is amazing how addressing them by their operator number, from the plate on the inside of the door in on the driver’s side in the back, focuses their attention and alters their attitude.

I said that I would say a Mass for some of you who have been benefactors for the WDTPRS project.  Tomorrow I promised someone else an intention.  I will remember you who contributed on probably Wednesday morning, I think, probably in San Pietro. 

I may be internet connection challenged during my time in Rome.  I am once again in the clutches of the benighted.  Their blockheaded sense of what technology is here and that the 20th century is over, never ceases to amaze me.

If you are a friend, and must reach me… use my wdtprs.com e-mail for now and, if you call my 204 number, it will forward to one of my cellphones here.  I have so many phones and numbers I am starting to feel like a drug dealer.

So… I warmly recommend a measure of self-editing in the comboxes.   The mood I am in right suggests to me that if you post anything disrespectful about legitimate authority or another person participating here, when I get online and find your comments, I’ll probably just block your access.  It might not happen immediately, but it will happen.  I simply don’t need the headache and the extra work.

In any event, I am in Roma until Saturday morning, then back to London.

Londoners, et al… remember we are trying to get that blognic hammered out.

While here I will participate in a conference on Summorum Pontificum and see lots of friends.

Eating just may be involved.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
20 Comments

Vespers at Brompton Oratory and some thoughts

Yesterday I participated at Vespers at the Brompton Oratory in choro.  My, they are precise around the place, I can tell you.

The psalms are sung, as pretty much everything Gregorian as I can tell, with organ accompaniment.  That has the advantage of keeping the pitch from sliding, but it does detract, I think from the sound of it.  The style of singing psalms at the Oratory is both a bit brisk and on the light side.  I wonder if the sound of the clerics in the sanctuary can actually be heard in the nave.

Their precision of movement reveals confidence and practice.  It is second nature in many respects.

It reminded me that people (parish priests, mainly) who are aiming at introducing chant or the older form of Mass, shouldn’t get trapped in the thought that they have to be perfect from the very beginning.  Things take time.  They become more comfortable over time.

We mustn’t let the perfect be the enemy of the good, especially when starting out with something new.

Here is what things looked like at the Oratory from my perspective as they prepared to expose the Blessed Sacrament.

Vespers at Brompton Oratory and some thoughts

The music for Vespers:

3.30 pm   Solemn Vespers & Benediction
Music:
Vexilla regis prodeunt  Gregorian chant.  
Magnificat Tone 1  Lassus.
Adoramus te Christe  Nanino. 
Toccata I  Froberger.

Seeing Nanino there make me think of the late Msgr. Richard Schuler, who over his 33 years as pastor of St. Agnes in St. Paul, another place which had wonderful and precise Masses with great music, slowly built up a great liturgical program.   It was brick by brick.

Such a project presupposes that the priest has time to work on it, build it slowly.  There must be consistency in leadership and vision, which doesn’t happen if priests are being moved all the time.

At the end, there was Veneration of a Relic of the Cross at one of the side altars in the transept.  Yours truly is at the far end of the balustrade, in the center.  That photo and many more are to be found here.

Vespers at Brompton Oratory and some thoughts

Posted in My View |
28 Comments

Reminder: The Five Rules of Engagement

One year after its going into effect, here is a little reminder about how to engage the Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum.

Let us keep in mind that the Holy Father is still teaching bishops what this document is all about and we are waiting for a document with clarifications.

In that light, read again….

Fr. Z’s 5 Rules of Engagement for after the Motu Proprio is released:

1) Rejoice because our liturgical life has been enriched, not because "we win".  Everyone wins when the Church’s life is enriched.  This is not a "zero sum game".

2) Do not strut.  Let us be gracious to those who have in the past not been gracious in regard to our "legitimate aspirations".

3) Show genuine Christian joy.  If you want to attract people to what gives you so much consolation and happiness, be inviting and be joyful.  Avoid the sourness some of the more traditional stamp have sadly worn for so long.

4) Be engaged in the whole life of your parishes, especially in works of mercy organized by the same.  If you want the whole Church to benefit from the use of the older liturgy, then you who are shaped by the older form of Mass should be of benefit to the whole Church in concrete terms.

5) If the document doesn’t say everything we might hope for, don’t bitch about it like a whiner.  Speak less of our rights and what we deserve, or what it ought to have been, as if we were our own little popes, and more about our gratitude, gratitude, gratitude for what God gives us.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

Dude! Totally tubular!

His Hermeneuticalness is teasing me a little, I think.

This is a snip from what he posted over at his tubular place:

Fr Zuhlsdorf is in England and has managed to get on that interweb thingy by borrowing some of the electric rays from St Bede’s Clapham Park.

Now, as everyone knows, the internet is best described as a series of tubes. At Clapham Park, in advance of Fr Z’s visit, Fr Basden has arranged for some upgrade work to be done to install larger tubes so that lots of blogs can get through.

Dude! Totally tubular!

 

I hear he has performed his own upgrade in advance of my visit to Blackfen!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
6 Comments

Benedict XVI to French Bishops on TLM and Summorum Pontificum

Our friends at Rorate helpfully posted the following.  Pope Benedict XVI spoke to the French bishops on 14 September, which coincidentally the 1st anniversary of Summorum Pontificum coming into force.

Let us have a look at the pertinent text with my emphases and comments.

Here is a thought to carry with you as you start to read: I have maintained ever since the text of the Motu Proprio was issued that Summorum Pontificum is especially a gift to priests.  Part of the Pope’s plan to revitalize the Church’s identity must revolve around her worship… and her priests.  Learning the older Mass today changes priests.  Priests change their flocks.  Flocks change the world around them. 

Okay…

    It is never too often said that the priesthood is indispensable to the Church, in the very own interest of the lay faithful. Priests are a gift from God to the Church. Priests must never delegate to the faithful [those] functions which are related to their own mission. Dear Brothers in the episcopacy, I ask you to remain desirous to help your priests live in intimate union with Christ. Their spiritual life is the foundation of their apostolic life. You shall exhort them gently to daily prayer and to a dignified celebration of the Sacraments, particularly of the Eucharist and of Reconciliation, as Saint Francis de Sales did with his priests. Every priest should be able to feel glad to serve the Church. [Don’t be a stumbling block to priests.] At the school of the Curé d’Ars, son of your land and patron of all priests of the world, do not cease to repeat that a man can do no greater deed than to give the Body and the Blood of Christ to the faithful, and to forgive sins. …

[Watch this transition… from priesthood to…]

    Liturgical worship is the supreme expression of priestly and episcopal life, and also of catechetical teaching. [Note the connection with doctrine.  There is a reciprocal relationship between what we believe and how we pray.] Your mission of sanctification of the faithful people, dear Brothers, is indispensable for the growth of the Church. I was prompted to detail, in the Motu proprio Summorum Pontificum, the conditions for the accomplishment of this mission, [the Pope closely links the use of the old Mass with the missionl of sanctification!] in that which relates to the possibility of using both the missal of Blessed John XXIII (1962) and that of Pope Paul VI (1970). [In this statement it sounds like the two Missals are on equal standing.  And he is speaking of all priests, not some priests.] The fruits of these new dispositions have already seen [the light of] day, and I hope that the indispensable pacification of the spirits is being accomplished, thank God.  [The word "pacification" suggests the desired effect of reunification with separated groups and also a calming and healing of those who have been hurt for so long.]

    I comprehend your difficulties, [This is probably a reference to how some more traditional groups are also associated with certain political tendencies.] but I do not doubt that you will be able to reach, within reasonable time, solutions which are satisfactory to all, so that the seamless robe of Christ is not torn anymore. [Again the reference to reunification and preventing groups from splitting away from the Churc.]  No one is excessive within the Church. [This is perhaps both prescriptive and descriptive.  The idea here is that the Church is very large, capable of sheltering people of many points of view and aspirations.]  Everyone, without exception, must be able to feel at home, and never rejected.  [This is huge:  The Pope is telling the French bishops to stop their relentless stinginess in regard to the more traditional Catholics in France.  Alas, for far too long traditional Catholics – and among them especially priests – have been treated with great injustice  – and not just in France!] God, who loves all men and wills that no one be lost, entrusts us with this mission of Pastors, making us Shepherds of His sheep. We can only give Him thanks for the honor and the confidence He places upon us. Let us endeavor to always be servants of unity.

Benedict XVI
Meeting with the Cardinals and Bishops of France,
Hémicycle «Saint Bernadette», Lourdes
September 14, 2008

 

"Everyone, without exception, must be able to feel at home, and never rejected."

This is not carte blanche to think or do as you please and that, just because you choose to do it, bishops and priests have to accept it.

There is still the rule of law.  The rubrics still apply.  The Rule of Faith is still our guide.

The Pope said this to, and note these terms, French bishops on Summorum Pontificum and priests.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
52 Comments

John L Allen on Benedict XVI speaking about Summorum Pontificum

My friend John L Allen, always insightful, the nearly ubiquitous, fair-minding, former Rome correspondent for the ultra-left leaning, often dissident, National Catholic Reporter has something to say about the interview with Pope Benedict on the way to France.

On the airplane, the Pope spoke with reporters and answered a question about Summorum Pontificum.    He spoke with the bishops later.

My emphases and comments.

By JOHN L. ALLEN JR.Published: September 14, 2008

Catholicism is legendarily keen on tradition, which means there’s a traditionalist wing of the church pretty much everywhere. Nowhere else, however, are traditionalists so visible, and, at times, so fractious, as in France, [NB: France.   This flavors everything the Holy Father said.  And remember that as Prefect of CDF, and a close supporter of Ecclesia Dei, he dealt a great deal with the French on these and other matters.  He knows who he was speaking to and about.] making it all but inevitable that Pope Benedict XVI would address their signature issue while here – the old Latin Mass.

Benedict XVI’s 2007 ruling permitting wider celebration of the old Mass, in a document titled Summorum Pontificium, was widely interpreted here as a victory for the traditionalist camp. It unleashed negative reactions among moderate-to-liberal Catholics, and complaints reached Rome that a handful of bishops were resisting implementation of the decree.  [I think it was more than a "handful", but I agree they were the minority.]

Speaking today to the full body of French bishops in Lourdes, the pope offered more extended comments on Summorum Pontificium.

Some bishops have objected to the pope’s ruling not only on theological or ideological grounds, but also in terms of its impact on their authority. [This is the real problem for some bishops: Summorum Pontificum was unique in that it gave rights to priests.  Some bishops don’t like that idea.]  By allowing priests to choose when and where to celebrate the old Mass, some bishops argue, they have lost power to govern the liturgical life of their dioceses. 

Most French observers heard in those words a clear expectation from the pope that the bishops will not erect new obstacles to celebration of the old Mass.

“Everyone has a place in the church,” Benedict said. “Every person, without exception, should be able to feel at home, and never rejected … Let us therefore strive always to be servants of unity!”  [Ainsi-soit-il!]

Many traditionalists, for example, are wary of both ecumenism and inter-religious dialogue as they’ve developed after Vatican II, fearing that they lead to compromise or confusion about the differences between Catholicism and other creeds. They also tend to be critical of Vatican II’s teaching on religious liberty, worrying that it promotes relativism by treating all religions as equal, and on human dignity, suggesting that it can exalt the human person at the expense of God.

“Under the cover of a campaign to defend a certain type of liturgy, there is a radical critique of the Vatican Council, even outright rejection of some of its declarations,” said then-Archbishop Andre Vingt-Trois in 2006. Vingt-Trois is today the cardinal of Paris and the pope’s official host in France.

Both kinds of traditionalism have deep roots in France.

Pope Benedict XVI celebrates Mass to mark the 150th anniversary of Mary’s appearances to St. Bernadette Soubirous. (CNS ph oto/Jean-Philippe Arles, Reuters)Pope Benedict XVI celebrates Mass to mark the 150th anniversary of Mary’s appearances to St. Bernadette Soubirous. (CNS ph oto/Jean-Philippe Arles, Reuters) As he has during other recent trips, Benedict has offered a nod to traditionalist sensibilities while in France. Although he is celebrating the new, post-Vatican II Mass, Benedict is administering communion to people who kneel and receive on the tongue, rather than standing and taking the consecrated host in their hand. Some traditionalists believe that communion in the hand fosters a lack of respect for the Eucharist.  [And they would be right…. but it is not only "traditionalists" who think this.]

Critics sometimes charge that both John Paul II and Benedict XVI have bent over backwards to accommodate traditionalists, without making similar efforts to reach out to other alienated groups in the church which are often substantially larger. [HUH?  I shudder to think about who they are… and I have a few suspicions.]  Even in France, observers say that traditionalism, despite its high profile, remains a small minority.

Yet in a country where less than ten percent of all Catholics attend Mass, [I have heard 2%] and where only one in two baptized Catholics still identifies with the church, it doesn’t take huge numbers to make a stir.

In Europe, however, observers of the Catholic scene distinguish between two forms of traditionalism: the “Mediterranean” model, associated above all with Italy, where the guiding idea is the authority of Il papa re, the “pope-king”; and the “Gallic” model, rooted in France, which sees the pope as the guardian of a body of traditions which he cannot compromise without endangering the faith itself. As a result, the authority of the pope and the bishops is less central than the content of tradition itself.

There is more to the article, but this is a snip.  

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

Denver: 1st TLM in Cathedral in 40 years

From a reader:

Father:

Here are pictures from the Solemn High Mass at the Cathedral Basilica of the Immaculate Conception, in Denver Colorado. 630 people was the unofficial count of attendees.

I will put more up on our website on Monday as well. This was the first Traditional Latin Mass at the Cathedral in 40 years. The next Mass at the Cathedral will on November 9th with our Auxiliary Bishop of Denver, Rev. James Conley.  I am parishioner of Our Lady of Mt. Carmel Chapel in Littleton, Colorado. I am also the webmaster of the church website: www.olmcfssp.org

We have posted the pictures to our church photo gallery:

Thanks, Greg Truta

Information about this Mass below:

Solemn High Mass
Feast of the Exaltation of the Holy Cross
Sunday, September 14, 2008 at 3:00 p.m.
Mass of Thanksgiving on the Anniversary of the implementation of the Motu Proprio — Summorum Pontificum – and – The Twentieth Anniversary of the founding of the
Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter

Father James W. Jackson, FSSP – Celebrant – Chaplain Our Lady of Mt. Carmel
Rev. Joseph Hearty, FSSP – Deacon – Assistant Chaplain Our Lady of Mt. Carmel
Mr. Rhone Lillard – Subdeacon – Seminarian – Our Lady of Guadalupe Seminary

Next Mass is:
Solemn High Pontifical Mass
Feast of the Dedication of the Archbasilica of Our Holy Savior
(The Lateran Basilica)
Sunday, November 9, 2008 at 2:15 p.m.
Celebrant: Most Rev. James Conley, Auxiliary Bishop of Denver

Denver: 1st TLM in Cathedral in 40 years

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
12 Comments

Raleigh, NC: Bp. Burbidge – “I remain committed to the vision of our Holy Father”

From a reader:

Fr. Z – our Bishop Michael Burbidge continues to be a blessing to his flock, keeping the Holy Father’s "Marshall Plan" always before us, thank God.  See the Bishop’s letter on the anniversary of the Summorum Pontificum, below.

Link
 
Dear Brothers and Sisters in Christ,
 
On this Feast of the Exaltation of the Lord’s Holy Cross, and on this first anniversary of the implementation of our Holy Father’s Motu Proprio, Summorum Pontificum, I express my shared joy with everyone in our Diocese who is devoted to the Extraordinary Form of the Mass. It has been edifying for me, as your bishop, to witness how this great treasure of our Faith has served as a refreshing font of faith and beauty for so many.

During the past year, several priests have received training, both formally and informally, in the proper offering of the Extraordinary Form of the Mass. As a result, the celebration of the Extraordinary Form has been extended to several Parishes throughout our Diocese. I am grateful to Father Paul Parkerson for his leadership and for all those priests who have willingly and graciously made this a part of their parish ministry. They can be assured of my continued support.

I remain committed to the vision of our Holy Father, Pope Benedict XVI, as he shepherds the Church along the path of greater unity, continuity, reform, and renewal. The Motu Proprio, Summorum Pontificum, officially implemented one year ago, today, continues to be an essential part of that vision for which we should all be grateful.

Be assured of my continued prayers for you and all your families, and I ask that you remember me and all the priests of the diocese in your prayers. Additionally, I request that you please join me in praying for a great increase in vocations to the priesthood and religious life especially as you form your intentions for the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass.

Through the intercession of Mary our Mother, may Our Lord Jesus continue to shower His abundant blessings upon you and keep you always in His care.

Sincerely in Christ,
Most Reverend Michael F. Burbidge
Bishop of Raleigh

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
3 Comments