Vatican Blackout

I heard from my spies that last night there was a massive power outage in the Vatican. 

Apparently, the Vatican City State’s electricity totally failed for 10 minutes.

The lights did not go off in St. Peter’s Square because that power comes from outside the Vatican.  The lights on the facade of St. Peter’s went black.

I am just facetious enough to suggest that even had the power gone off during the day, it might not really have affected the efficiency of the Curia.

But I bet the Vatican’s gendarmes got pretty excited.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
3 Comments

QUAERITUR: WDSC116RS?

I received a note from a reader:

What does Sacrosanctum Concilium 116 really say?

Ecclesia cantum gregorianum agnoscit ut liturgiae romanae proprium: qui ideo in actionibus liturgicis, ceteris paribus, principem locum obtineat.

The sentence isn’t all that difficult, though you wouldn’t know that judging from the last few decades of liturgical music degradation.  But there are some words we must drill into.

Let’s drill at some vocabulary.

The diamond hard lexical drill bit the L&S reminds us that ut doesn’t merely introduce purpose clauses.  It also means "as".   Another word we must pay attention to is proprium. 

Proprius, a, um is an adjective meaning, "not common with others, one’s own, special, particular, proper".  It is the opposite of communis and alienus.  It is "one’s own, peculiar, special, characteristic, personal".  It picks up the meaning of "lasting, constant, permanent, perpetual", probably logically because it refers to a characteristic property or possession of something: "specially, peculiarly, properly, strictly for one’s self".  In English we have the word "proper", meaning not "correct", or "fitting" but in sense of "belonging or pertaining exclusively or distinctly to a person, thing, or group".   This is why in liturgy we talk about the prayers that pertain to a specific day as being the properium or the "proper".  This adjective is applied to cantus.   It is the cantus which is gregorianus cantus that is the cantus which is proprius.

Next we need to consider princeps, principis (from primus – capio).  It is an adjective here.   Princeps is "first in time or order" and "the first, chief, the most eminent, distinguished, or noble".    When the princeps is a substantive, or it is applied as an adjective to a person, that person is then the chief or director in a military or political sense, one who defines the orders and the direction.  This is where we get the English word "prince".

The verb agnosco means, "as if to know a person or thing well, as having known it before, to recognize: agnoscere always denotes a subjective knowledge or recognition".  By logical extension it means "as a result of this knowledge or recognition, to declare, announce, allow, or admit a thing to be one’s own, to acknowledge, own".   So, "recognize" has a very "complete" meaning.  It goes beyond mere recognition, in the sense of "oh yah, I’ve seen that before", and then moving on.

Finally, cantus is more than merely "chant", which is usually considered just something sung by a person.  Remember that on a bagpipe there is a "chanter".  Latin cantus is "the production of melodious sound, a musical utterance or expression, either with voice or instrument; hence, song, singing, playing, music".  Therefore, when it is applied to the human voice, it means "a singing, song" and when applied to instruments, "a playing, music".

Obtineo is "to take hold of, hold".  This seems to be an enduring concept, for logically obtineo is also, "to hold, have, occupy, possess; to preserve, keep, maintain, etc."  There is a sense of enduring in that "obtaining", a stability.

Then take note of that qui… obtineat construction.  Here it looks like that qui doesn’t simply introduce any old relative clause.  So, it is probably ut is, and it is therefore quî.  After all, we already had a different ut and the fellows who wrote this knew more than Latin baby-talk.

LITERAL VERSION:
The Church recognizes, as her own, Gregorian chant as the music proper the Roman liturgy: that therefore, other things being equal, it must preserve the chief place in liturgical actions.

Notice that I render the first cantus as chant and the second as music.  When cantus is defined by gregorianus it means chant, obviously.  When it is left by itself it is probably best to leave it as music. 

What is going on here.  There is an antecedent and a consequence.  Gregorian chant is the music which is proper for liturgy… therefore… it is the guiding reference point and chief choice among all types of music.  The ceteris paribus usually comes into play when there is an connection like this, or antecedent and consequent.  In other words, given the powerful connection between the two ends of the statement, there is a desire to rule out other factors.  Ceteris paribus actually strengthens connection, rather than weakens it.  It would take a truly weighty factor to override this consequence. 

SPUN-OUT VERSION:
The Church declares as her own, because she formally recognizes it, Gregorian chant as belonging to her as her distinctive music in order that, other factors taken into consideration in such a way they they don’t rule this out, it preserve the governing eminent place in liturgical actions.

I want to maintain "liturgical actions" rather than say simply "liturgy" or "liturgies".   "Liturgy" is abstract".  "Action" is something done by an "agent".  Both actio and agens are from ago.  The true actor in any liturgical actio is Christ acting thorugh His Body, the Church.  His voice is speaking and singing.  His are the gestures and motions.  Actor and actio are also juridical terms.

This paragraph of SC which is a juridical document, an Apostolic Constitution, is packed with juridical vocabulary.   Bear with me and let’s think like Romans for a few moments.

In ancient Roman law, men would have to formally recognize children as their own before they were considered to be their legal children, with rights to inherit, enjoy the family name, with all the gravitas and gloria that went with it, to have the association with the ancestors and the deeds they fulfilled for the Roman people, etc.  Otherwise, in disputed cases inheritance could be established by agnitio (agnoscere) by a solemn hearing.  An agnitio bonorum possessionis was a request made to a praetor to be granted possession of an inheritance as a successor.   A father would place his hand on a child or a man he was about to adopt and recognize him as his own and call him by name (nuncupare from nomen – capio). 

What SC 116 sounds like to me, what it really is, is nuncupatio, wherein Holy Church as the rightful holder of hereditary treasures, gloria, etc., places its parental hand on the genre of music, among many possible types of music, and says, "This one is mine.  This is my distinctive music, which bears my name ‘Roman Catholic’.  I give my name to it."

Here I want to backtrack to ceteris paribus. 

This phrase indicates the powerful bond between the first part and the second part: Gregorian chant is the music, above all kinds of music to be chosen in liturgical actions because the Church solemnly declares that this music, and not another, is her own characteristic music which she intimately identifies as her own.

Some will argue that that ceteris paribus indicates that when the circumstances of cultural conditioning, of tastes and times, change, then Gregorian chant is no longer the cantus proprius and that it no longer must be given the same consideration as in the past.

In other words, if you say that, before or during or since the Council which wrote SC 116 there has been a rupture in the way the Church sings and hears herself singing, then we can choose our own guiding paradigm of liturgical music, which may or may not include Gregorian chant, depending on the place, tastes, culture, etc.

Pope Benedict XVI has spoken eloquently and clearly about this "hermeneutic of rupture and continuity" used by those who have distorted the meaning of the texts and the event of the Second Vatican Council.  

His Holiness has proposed an interpretive principle that preserves continuity between past and present.  Summorum Pontificum, for example, indicates that there is continuity in the Roman Rite.

Furthermore, since the Council ended, Popes have on various occasions referred to Gregoran chant as having the primus locus.

So, the rupture approach rooted in a particular interpretation of the cetera no longer being "on an equal footing", seems not to be legitimate.  Nothing has happened in the Church since the Council that can legitimately "break" the bond between the Church’s claim in the first part of SC 116 and its consequent.

I want to work on this a bit more, but this is how I read SC 116… using a heavy drill.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, SESSIUNCULA, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM, WDTPRS |
23 Comments

WSJ: Wymynpryst Liberation Ordination

From the Wall Street Journal:

HOUSES OF WORSHIP
   
The Problem With Liberation Ordination [The choice of title is important.  Most of the feminist thing in the Church is rooted in a Marxist starting point.]
By KATHRYN JEAN LOPEZ
August 22, 2008; Page W13

A few weeks ago, a group called Roman Catholic Womenpriests staged what it called an ordination, [This writer gets it!  Brava!] vesting three Boston-area women in white chasubles and red stoles. It told the local papers that the ordinations were valid, despite the Catholic Church’s teaching to the contrary; it even asserted episcopal approval from a rogue bishop whose name it won’t reveal. But, as a statement from the Archdiocese of Boston put it: "Catholics who attempt to confer a sacred order on a woman, and the women who attempt to receive a sacred order, are by their own actions separating themselves from the Church." In other words: The ordinations were not Catholic.

Don’t tell that to Judy Lee, one of the "priests." She insists that the archdiocese’s pronouncement will be a dead letter: "We are Roman Catholics. . . . The all-male hierarchy and their legal traditions came along with the spiritual package that we embrace.  ["spiritual package"… ?!?…. Tradition?  Sacraments?  Regula Fidei?] We do not have to embrace both if they are contradictory." Bridget Meehan, spokeswoman for Roman Catholic Womenpriests, which claims 61 priests in North America, including one bishop, insists: "Nothing or no one can stop the action of God’s Spirit moving in the Church. . . . We are not discouraged by excommunication. In fact, in many ways, it is a catalyst for growth." Ms. Meehan, who was ordained in 2006, believes that a "more transparent, community model" can bring nonpracticing Catholics back into the fold.  [Sure!  Look what that has done for the Anglicans!]

The Womenpriests come from a dissenting feminist tradition in the Catholic Church — one in which a leading religious sister has even declared the Eucharist "defective and inadequate" for women. [Not part of their "spiritual package"….  What deep theological reflection… "spiritual package".] This tradition argues for renewing the church with a model "not geared to a hierarchy but inclusivity," as Ms. Meehan explains it. But those who are faithful to Rome argue that it is precisely the focus on the Eucharist — and Christ’s identity — that necessitates an all-male priesthood. In 1994, Pope John Paul II declared that "the Church has no authority whatsoever to confer priestly ordination on women."  [So… what is ordination for?  You have to ask what they think priesthood is for.]

Mother Assumpta Long, a statuesque, media-savvy Dominican sister in Ann Arbor, Mich., says that the Catholic Church already recognizes the equality of women — and that the dissenters confuse equality with identical opportunity. "All people are created by God equal in that we each possess an immortal and individual soul. [But] we are each unique in our talents. . . . Women are called upon to be mothers (spiritually and, for many in marriage, physically as well); whereas men are called upon to be fathers (spiritually and, for many in marriage, physically as well)." These sound like roles in a healthy family — not the artifact of a stifling, misogynistic patriarchy.

The same weekend as the "ordinations," I joined 30 fellow lay Catholics gathered in Birmingham, Ala., for a sold-out retreat at the Casa Maria convent. The retreat is run by a group of Dominican-Franciscan (they follow both saintly models) religious sisters. Now in their 18th year as an order, the Sister Servants of the Eternal Word are as far away as one can imagine from that scene in Boston.

"As an active woman religious working in the field of retreats and catechesis in the Bible Belt South, I have to say that I am far too busy . . . to feel slighted by the fact that the priesthood is not open to women," insists Sister Louise Marie, a member of the order. She suggests that if Catholics and non-Catholics understood what a "powerful role women religious have," they would never "feel sorry for [us]."

The Sister Servants, like many relatively new orders, are filled with young, orthodox enthusiasts. The nearby cloistered Poor Clare Nuns of Perpetual Adoration, seen on the Catholic Eternal Word Television Network, have a waiting list of young women wanting to join. Whenever they get more space, "there’s always someone right around the corner waiting to move in," says Sister Marie St. John, speaking for the group. Most of the new orders are members not of the notoriously liberal Leadership Conference of Women Religious but of the newer, more strict Council of Major Superiors of Women Religious. Their energy appears a personification of "the New Pentecost" that Pope Benedict XVI talks about, calling on faithful Catholics to be apostles in the modern world.

Not all religious sisters are happy. Overall, their numbers have been dwindling — from 179,954 in 1965 to 59,208 today, according to Georgetown University’s Center for Applied Research in the Apostolate. And some frustrated women "priests" do come from their ranks.

But the women’s ordination movement may well be dying. It has neither momentum nor standing within the church, and the momentum surrounding papal events and traditional orders appears to suggest that Catholic sentiment is flowing in the opposite direction. Sister Sara Butler, the author of "The Catholic Priesthood and Women: A Guide to the Teaching of the Church," says: "These women do not represent most Catholic women, and they do not represent most women religious."

A 2007 study found that 66% of those considering religious vocations were drawn to them most by a "desire to live a life of faithfulness to the Church and its teaching." The young women in this majority don’t feel the need to remake Catholicism in their own image. Christ’s is more than good enough for them.

Ms. Lopez is the editor of National Review Online.

My gloss… mutatis mutandis….

(This video is no longer available.)

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
35 Comments

Dems may have a Catholic pro-abortion VP candidate

Apparently Democrat Presidential "hope"full Barak Obama, the short-term senator from Illinois, has chosen as his VP running mate long-term Senator Joe Biden of Delaware.

Sen. Biden is pro-abortion, but against partial-birth abortion. 

On Meet The Press he said that he believes that life begins at conception:

Q: You have changed your position on abortion. When you came to the Senate, you believed that Roe v. Wade was not correctly decided and that you also believed the right of abortion was not secured by the Constitution. Why did you change your mind?

A: Well, I was 29 years old when I came to the US Senate, and I have learned a lot. Look, I’m a practicing Catholic, and it is the biggest dilemma for me in terms of comporting my religious and cultural views with my political responsibility.

Q: Do you believe that life begins at conception?

A: I am prepared to accept my church’s view. I think it’s a tough one. I have to accept that on faith. That’s why the late-term abortion ban, where there’s clearly viability.

Source: Meet the Press: 2007 "Meet the Candidates" series Apr 29, 2007

NARAL scores him at 36%.

NRLC scores him at 0%.

He voted against a ban on human cloning and for expansion of embryonic stem-cell research.

I would remind you only of what Archbishop Burke recently reiterated so clearly about the obligation of charity and denying Holy Communion to Catholic pro-abortion politicians.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
109 Comments

Oldie photo

I rediscovered a fun photo of yours truly being called on for a question by H.E. Archbp. Ranjith during a CDW sponsored conference on liturgy last December, as Card. Arinze looks on.

Oldie photo 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Oldie photo

NLM: examination of “Pastoral Music”‘s gloss of Mediator Dei

I direct your attention to the NLM which has posted an interesting entry taking to task the "The August/September issue of Pastoral Music, published by the National Association of Pastoral Musicians, is dedicated to liturgical ensembles. The pictures of musicians in various parish settings tell the story."

After Pastoral Music exalts photos of ghastly things, they print an "op-ed sized article called "Interior As Well As Exterior" by….Pius XII! It’s an excerpt from Mediator Dei (1947)".

You should attend to how the NLM piece examines what Pastoral Music does with Pius XII, in light of what Pius actually said and what Pastoral Music actually promotes.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
8 Comments

When priests don’t want to give Communion to those who kneel – more thoughts

I have gotten a lot of mail about how some priest harass people who kneel for Holy Communion.

The notes I have gotten break down in several categories.

First, there are those who think I somehow don’t know about this problem.   They will write along the lines: "I assure you this really does happen!  Don’t you care that they are trying to make us show disrespect to the Lord?"

To which I respond.  Don’t be silly.  Of course I know.   And I care.   Read the blog lately?

Second, there are those who urge me to do what I can to make "the Vatican" start to "punish" priests who do this.

To which I respond.  If there are liturgical abuses of rights, then proofs must be gathered and sent to the proper authority.  See this. But I would advise you to think a little less about "punishing" and more about "persuading".  What is it with some people anyway?  They leap to the "punishment" option so very eagerly.

Third, there are simply e-mails letting me know what experiences people have had.

Here is a typical note to exemplify what I mean (edited):

Dear Fr. Z,

Thank you for your blog and all that you do.  I began grad school at the University of ____ in mid June and have been attending daily Mass.  I wear a mantilla to Mass and receive communion kneeling and until yesterday I had not encountered any opposition.  However, yesterday, as I knelt, the priest (I believe the director of Campus Ministry) told me something along the lines of: "Don’t Kneel.  You aren’t supposed to kneel.  The Bishops say just to bow. Don’t kneel."  Taken aback, I didn’t say anything but I also didn’t get up.  He did give me Jesus, albeit reluctantly.  Am I correct that a priest cannot deny someone communion for kneeling?  I read in the GIRM that this is true, but I think it also says that the priest should explain to the person later why standing is the norm?  Does this mean that if he were to talk to me later and give me some reasons why I’m supposed to stand that he does have the right to deny me communion in the future? 

I respond saying that, yes, in the United States the Bishops have determined that the proper position to receive Communion is standing, with a gesture of reverence such as bowing before receiving. Sad but true.  Still, its the law for the USA.

That said, in 2004 the Congregation for Divine Worship and Discipline of the Sacraments issued a very strong Instruction called Redemptionis Sacramentum.  In this document we read:

[90.] “The faithful should receive Communion kneeling or standing, as the Conference of Bishops will have determined”, with its acts having received the recognitio of the Apostolic See. “However, if they receive Communion standing, it is recommended that they give due reverence before the reception of the Sacrament, as set forth in the same norms”.

[91.] In distributing Holy Communion it is to be remembered that “sacred ministers may not deny the sacraments to those who seek them in a reasonable manner, are rightly disposed, and are not prohibited by law from receiving them”. Hence any baptized Catholic who is not prevented by law must be admitted to Holy Communion. Therefore, it is not licit to deny Holy Communion to any of Christ’s faithful solely on the grounds, for example, that the person wishes to receive the Eucharist kneeling or standing.

[92.] Although each of the faithful always has the right to receive Holy Communion on the tongue, at his choice, if any communicant should wish to receive the Sacrament in the hand, in areas where the Bishops’ Conference with the recognitio of the Apostolic See has given permission, the sacred host is to be administered to him or her. However, special care should be taken to ensure that the host is consumed by the communicant in the presence of the minister, so that no one goes away carrying the Eucharistic species in his hand. If there is a risk of profanation, then Holy Communion should not be given in the hand to the faithful.

After several incidents of Hosts being taken this last year, such as was the case with a student in Florida and also with the idiot who stole the Host for the purpose of profanation by the idiot professor in Minnesota, I would say that the risk of profanation is much much higher than previously assumed and norms about Communion in the Hand should be rethought.  There are also the well-thought through explanations by Archbp. Ranjith, Bp. Schneider, and others.  But I digress.

You can kneel to receive Communion.  If a priest upbraids or admonishes you, publicly, at the time of Communion, he has seriously violated both your rights as well as decorum.

You do have recourse if these things happen.  If this goes on all the time, you have a duty to do something about it.  Here again is Redemptionis Sacramentum: 

6. Complaints Regarding Abuses in Liturgical Matters

[183.] In an altogether particular manner, let everyone do all that is in their power to ensure that the Most Holy Sacrament of the Eucharist will be protected from any and every irreverence or distortion and that all abuses be thoroughly corrected. This is a most serious duty incumbent upon each and every one, and all are bound to carry it out without any favouritism.

[184.] Any Catholic, whether Priest or Deacon or lay member of Christ’s faithful, has the right to lodge a complaint regarding a liturgical abuse to the diocesan Bishop or the competent Ordinary equivalent to him in law, or to the Apostolic See [important point] on account of the primacy of the Roman Pontiff. It is fitting, however, insofar as possible, that the report or complaint be submitted first to the diocesan Bishop. This is naturally to be done in truth and charity.

If you ever think you need to have recourse to higher authority because of liturgical abuses, etc., which are not corrected after you have calmly and charitably made your concerns known, here are some tips.   I warmly suggest that you read and follow them if you are going to write to bishops or the Holy See.

Remember: if you tell a story, it is hearsay.  It really helps to have proofs.  If something happens to you personally, it would help your cause if other people also wrote letters in which they describe what they saw and heard.  These would then be included with your own letter. 

Vatican offices generally can’t do much more than make a simple inquiry unless they are presented with some sort of evidence.  This also goes for writing to bishops, though in that case local bishops can more easily make inquiries.  

This is why it is always good to work your way UP the chain of authority: pastor first, then bishop, and finally the Holy See, remember that every Catholic always and at any time has the right to go directly to the Holy See. 

But if you work your way up the chain, you have more of a paper trail and, perhaps, more proofs to offer that the Holy See should take interest.  This is common sense.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
58 Comments

Sound pronunciation of Church Latin vs. spittle-flecked rigidity

I just got off the phone with a representative of a Catholic publisher.  He had some questions about the pronunciation of liturgical Latin.

His experience in digging into this issue is much the same as what I have found through the years, namely, people can get pretty worked up about this stuff.

Relax.

Remember that language is… well.. language.  There are no hard and fast rules to prescribe in human speech.

Sure, there are conventions and "standards" of pronunciation. 

I think we have all heard that "BBC English" was the "standard" for broadcasting the the UK for a long time.  The upper-midwestern accent of the US, such as Omaha, was the "standard" in American broadcasting to which everyone, such as Texans, had to conform.  It is usually held that the Italian of Lucca in Tuscany is the "purest" Italian or the French of, if I remember properly, Orleans, is their reference point in France.  In China, the official stand on Mandarin is the Beijing pronunciation. 

Insofar as Holy Roman Church is concerned, since at least the time of Pius X the Roman pronunciation of Church Latin was considered the language standard.  This has been reinforced more recently, in the time of Bl. John XXIII (e.g., in Ordinationes ad Constitutionem Apostolicam Veterum Sapientia Rite Exsequendam in AAS 54/6 (30 Maii 1962), p. 345 and n. 10.

So,… that would either make Rome the Omaha of the Church, or Omaha the Rome of American broadcasting…. hmmm….

For example, pick up your handy English edition of the Liber Usualis and you will find in the front a section called "Rules of Interpretation".  You will find therein not only directions about how to sing a scandicus and climacus, but also the values of vowels, diphthongs and consonants.

The Liber says:

"In good Latin diction – listen to Roman professor lecturing in Latin – the tonic accent stands out clearly" etc. 

And further…

"Our aim, in compliance with the wishes of his holiness Pius X, is to pronounce and speak Latin in the Roman Style so eminently suitable to Plainsong."

And more…

"Many have never learned the Roman pronunciation or know it imperfectly.  Besides its great importance in Plainsong it makes for that uniformity which inspired the Vatican Edition itself: Unus Cultus, Unus Cantus.  We therefore give a list of the correct pronunciation of the vowels and consonants to which reference can be made in case of doubt; it is advisable to peruse it from time to time."

 

The Liber is rather prescriptive, but… well… you have to say something more than "say it any way you want".  Still, I need to observe that finding a Romano di Roma is getting harder and harder… especially a well-educated Romano di Roma who knows Latin.  They exist, but they are getting rarer.

Also, note that the Liber is not talking about a French guy lecturing in Rome in Latin, but a Roman.  All of us are going to tend, to a greater or lesser degree, depending on one’s "ear" to impose the sound inventory of the mother tongue even on the well-practiced Roman style of ecclesiastical Latin.

So, we mustn’t be overly rigid about these things and wind up breathing spittle-flecked imprecations against someone whose pronunciation strays a bit from personal norms, or those in the Liber…. or elsewhere.

Nevertheless, we should stick to the Roman style to the best of our ability.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
92 Comments

QUAERITUR: Can pastors deny the use of the church to visiting priests/groups?

I got these questions via e-mail:

I have a question dealing with the proper understanding of the Motu Propio Summorum Pontificum.

A hypothetical diocese has a policy in which the Extraordinary Form is only allowed where explicitly permitted by the bishop but the Ordinary Form is permitted in any church in the diocese.  Is this consistent with Motu Propio Summorum Pontificum?  I would think that wherever the Ordinary Form is permitted the Extraordinary Form is also permitted since these are simply two different uses of the same rite.

This seems not to be consistent with the provisions of Summorum Pontificum.

As I read it, the Motu Proprio places these decisions in the hands the priests, not the bishops.  Bishops may not, it seems, forbid celebrations of the older form of Mass. 

Pastors can schedule Masses with the older form of Mass either on a regular basis or ad hoc.

A second question:  may a priest deny a local group the use of "his" church for the Extraordinary Form of the Mass?  Assume a local group has arranged for a visiting FSSP priest to come to town, the visiting priest has obtained faculties, and the local group approaches the pastor respectfully and courteously to ask whether thevisiting  FSSP priest may offer Mass on a single occasion at some time in which the church is not being used for something else.  Does the pastor have the right to refuse to allow the group & the FSSP priest access to the church?

Yes, I think a pastor of a parish could forbid a visiting priest and an outside group from doing something in his parish. 

Pastors of parishes (or those in charge of other churches and chapels) should extend to visiting priests the opportunity to say Mass. 

However, a pastor is not obliged to let visiting groups or priests move into his church and do what they please, even when what they desire to do is laudable.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, SESSIUNCULA |
23 Comments

PODCAzT curiosities: B16 & the snake v. Fr. Z & Fr. Finigan

Check out the PODCAzT page.

[uc]

UPDATE: 21 AUGUST 17:59 GMT

2289 – Pope and snake, et al.
2291 – Fr. Z and Fr. Finigan, et al.

And His Hermeneuticalness Fr. Finigan’s interview in PODCAzT 64 has taken the lead!

He is now beating the Holy Father and the big snake Sebastian in downloads and "listens".

__________________________

ORIGINAL POST (edited):

Here are links to the last few PODCAzTs:

068 08-08-04 Interview – Fr. Tim Finigan on the Oxford TLM conference; don Camillo (Part III)
067 08-07-29 St. Augustine on Martha, active v. contemplative lives; don Camillo (part II)
066 08-07-25 don Camillo (part I): VM – advice on getting TLMs & “pro multis”
065 08-07-19 St. Ambrose “On mysteries”; Interview: Fr. Robert Pasley
064 08-07-15 Bonaventure on Christ “the door”; Interview – Fr. Timothy Finigan
063 08-07-12 Interview: Fr. Justin Nolan, FSSP; consecrated hands, Holy Communion and the Rite of Baptism

As a note of interest, the interview with His Hermeneuticalness Fr. Finigan is now second in number of downloads and listens only to the video of Pope Benedict with a bunch of Australian critters, including the new famous python "Sebastian".

As I write:

2243 – Pope and snake, et al.
2015 – Fr. Z and Fr. Finigan, et al.

Finigan is behind only by about 200 accesses.  Give him a hand and get his numbers up!

I’ll post updates, below.

Also, a reader sent a note including an interesting question:

 

Sometimes you say things I would like to have separate from the rest of the programs. It would be easier to share with other people that way who need to hear some of the things you explain. Could you post or send me the audio of just part of a show? 

 

Well… thanks for that but… no and yes.

I say "No" first, because it take some work to make these audio projects.  Going back into my files and separating each section into a separate project would be a lot of work.

That said, "Yes", it is "possible".  Perhaps a "premium content" section could be arranged.  I would have to work out the details and terms, but it is something to ponder.

UPDATE: 29 July 01:04 GMT

2244 – Pope and snake, et al.
2028 – Fr. Z and Fr. Finigan, et al.

C’mon folks!

UPDATE: 29 July 14:19 GMT

2250 – Pope and snake, et al.
2051 – Fr. Z and Fr. Finigan, et al.

It looks as if the People have spoken, though we crept, not to say slithered up a little.

UPDATE: 30 July 16:06 GMT

2253 – Pope and snake, et al.
2072 – Fr. Z and Fr. Finigan, et al.

Better, but we could use more.

UPDATE: 31 July 16:18 GMT

2256 – Pope and snake, et al.
2079 – Fr. Z and Fr. Finigan, et al.

A questioner told me in an e-mail that the interview with Fr. Finigan helped with a decision to seek a TLM.

UPDATE: 2 August 17:22 GMT

2260 – Pope and snake, et al.
2102 – Fr. Z and Fr. Finigan, et al.

Better!  Keep at it, especially if you haven’t listened yet.  Tell others.

UPDATE: 5 AUGUST 00:19 GMT

2265 – Pope and snake, et al.
2115 – Fr. Z and Fr. Finigan, et al.

Creeping.

UPDATE: 8 AUGUST 03:26 GMT

2270 – Pope and snake, et al.
2246 – Fr. Z and Fr. Finigan, et al.

Creeping.

UPDATE: 21 AUGUST 17:59 GMT

2289 – Pope and snake, et al.
2291 – Fr. Z and Fr. Finigan, et al.

And Fr. Finigan has taken the lead!

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
12 Comments