o{]:¬)

Fr. Z is Moderator of the Catholic Online Forum and the ASK FATHER Question Box. The WDTPRS columns appear weekly in The Wanderer. Fr. Z lives in Rome, though he is often in the USA. He is available for retreats and conferences. E-mail
LOGIN


   Fr. Z on WDTPRS

↑ Grab this Headline Animator


Recent Posts
  • His Hermeneuticalness and Vatican webpages
  • 14 Oct: S. St. Paul, St. Augustine's - The Argument
  • Fr. Bux responds to the "not enough Scripture" argument against TLM
  • Benedict opens the synod
  • A Sunday Mass
  • Pontifical Commission "Ecclesia Dei" - BIG NEWS!
  • TLM Mass for Pius XII rescheduled
  • QUAERITUR: Spanish biretta

  • Recent Comments:

    • John Womack: *Remaining registered as a Democrat in order to influence the party is a defensible choice. By all...
    • John Womack: *John Womak: For your analogy to work, you would have to position Wilberforce as a member of a...
    • DoB: Chris Altieri, I’m not sure Dcns reservations can so easily be explained away. If the working document is...
    • Felix: 1. perhaps the greatest problem with the Novus Ordo readings is that most (almost all the laity) have...
    • Jordanes: Louis E. said: scientific fact,approached with a scientific eye rather than on a mission to find backing...
    • Louis E.: Avecrux, scientific fact,approached with a scientific eye rather than on a mission to find backing for the...
    • Tom Lanter: Fr. Z. Great view, wish I had been kneeling next to the photographer with my camera in hand. JMJ Tom...
    • Anne: This is the funniest thread I’ve ever seen on WDTPRS. It seems some folks are so young they actually do...
    • Fr. John Zuhlsdorf: Anne: I want to add something. Bishops have in a very serious way the cura animarum.  This...
    • Anne: Rick, in Bishop Vasa\’s diocese next door that pro-choice EMOE would have been released from all duties...

  • VOTE!
    My site was nominated for Best Religion Blog!

    Visit the new WDTPRS Store!
    Buy WDTPRS stuff!

    Calendar

    November 2007
    S M T W T F S
    « Oct   Dec »
     123
    45678910
    11121314151617
    18192021222324
    252627282930  


    Subscribe to ... The Wanderer

    Subscribe to ... The Catholic Herald - UK






    This blog is hosted by

    Joyent


    Thanks for the support!






















    Add to Technorati Favorites

    Add to Google Reader or Homepage

    Add to My AOL

    Subscribe in Bloglines

    Powered by FeedBurner


    Where Fr. Z will be:
  • Upcoming Events:
  • Events
  • 15 November 2007

    Thompson gets out a machete: UK resistance to Pope Benedict and true ecumenism

    CATEGORY: SESSIUNCULUM — Fr. John Zuhlsdorf @ 6:56 pm

    Over a The Daily Telegraph, Damian Thompson has an article which is going to irritate not a few people there on the sceptr’d isle.

    Here is a taste but you need to go read it yourself:

    The 80-year-old Pontiff is planning a purification of the Roman liturgy in which decades of trendy innovations will be swept away. This recovery of the sacred is intended to draw Catholics closer to the Orthodox and ultimately to heal the 1,000 year Great Schism. But it is also designed to attract vast numbers of conservative Anglicans, who will be offered the protection of the Holy Father if they covert en masse.

    The liberal cardinals don’t like the sound of it at all.

    Ever since the shock of Benedict’s election, they have been waiting for him to show his hand. Now that he has, the resistance has begun in earnest – and the Archbishop of Westminster, Cardinal Cormac Murphy-O’Connor, is in the thick of it.

    Thompson gives his opinion about How Card. Murphy-O’Connor is actively fighting the Holy Father at the level of the liturgy. 

    Cardinal Murphy-O’Connor was most displeased. Last week, he hit back with a "commentary" on Summorum Pontificum.

    ...

    A few years ago the ploy might have worked. But news travels fast in the traditionalist blogosphere, and these tactics have been brought to the attention of papal advisers.  [They cannot hide.]
    Thompson then goes after the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, "which spends most of its time promoting the sort of ecumenical waffle that Benedict abhors."

    Thompson got his machete out for this one and just about anyone involved in the issue of the return of Anglicans to communion with Rome get’s attention.

    • • • • • •

    Do I detect a slight lack of interest? Or is it something else?

    CATEGORY: SESSIUNCULUM — Fr. John Zuhlsdorf @ 1:32 pm

    The Vatican website sometimes raises questions.

    If you look at the online profile of the Pontifical Commission "Ecclesia Dei" you find that

    The commission has a president, Cardinal Angelo Felici, a secretary, Msgr. Camille Perl, and several assistants. A group of “permanent experts” composed of representatives of the dicasteries concerned offer their advice and expertise.
    If memory serves, Darío Card. Castrillón Hoyos has been the President since A.D. 2000.  Also there is now an adjunct Secretary who should be listed, Msgr. Mario Marini.

    On the other hand, we can zip over to the online profile of the Pontifical Committee for International Eucharistic Congresses.
    Presidente:
    Ecc.za Rev.ma Mons. Piero MARINI

    I believe Archbp. Marini was appointed to that post on 1 October of this year. 

    "Everything’s up to date at San Callisto… "

    I sense a parody song.  TF?  Where are you?

    • • • • • •

    Things are moving on the Sacred Music front and the old guard is frightened

    CATEGORY: SESSIUNCULUM — Fr. John Zuhlsdorf @ 1:03 pm

    The plenary session of the USCCB just jammed through a document of guidelines on sacred music, a document which was reclassified so that it didn’t need a recognitio from the Holy See. 

    In Rome, however, things in Rome are heating up over the issue of musica sacra, which the Council described as pars integrans in the liturgy.

    In the Italian daily La Stampa there are several articles of great interest.  La Stampa has a liberal bias. The way Italians use the term "teocon" is not the same as in the USA.  In the USA "theocon" points to religious people who share part of the neocon agenda (e.g., Novak, Weigel, etc.).  In Italy, "teocon" refers to people who are not really religious, but who share some common ground with Benedict XVI concerning politics and the public role of religion.  In the liberal mind of the Italian journalist, "teocon" is pejorative.  For Italian liberals the is usually sharply defined in templates.  In the poltical sphere, for example, you must be anti-American and you must hate President Bush.  If you don’t, you must a little stupid.  When we port this paradigm approach over to the Church scene, your vision of the Church is an entity marginalized from the public square, which might be useful only as an agent of social change, and not too intellectual, but rather very populist.   That is the enlightened way to see the Church.  If, however, you are interested in a Church with a strong voice in the public square, traditional and vigorous expressions of teach and liturgy, etc., then you must be rather shallow, sort of a neanderthal.  Thus, even traditional clergy get lumped into the "teocons". 

    La Stampa is quite worried about the return of conservatives within the Church, these "teocons", because it signals a deeper involvement of the Church in public life.  After last years referendum and the enormous "Family Day", that is nothing less than terrifying.  Thus, the issue of sacred music is going to make these liberals crazy, because it heralds something far more threatening.  The tables are being turned on the progressivists in the Church, and the progressivists are freaking out because the people being brought in are actually competent.  That must be scary.

    But let’s get at a couple of the piece in La Stampa.

    Canti gregoriani invece di chitarre ... Gregorian chant instead of guitars

    This whiny article laments the arrival of Catholic "teocons" on the scene.  They are lumping into "teocon" men like the new papal M.C. Msgr. Guido Marini.  The idea is that they are not really deep thinkers.  They are interested in dressing up, having pretty music according to their tastes, etc.  The ouster of (deep thinkers, forward looking visionaries like) Msgr. Piero Marini suggests to the jittery writers of La Stampa and their ilk that other men are at risk of losing their jobs, namely, Msgr. Guiseppe Liberto, Master of the Cappella Sistina.

    Liberto has sytematically been replacing more traditional chants and pieces with his own schlocky compositions.  He an Piero Marini were in synch.   La Stampa reveals is bias about the threat of a return to traditional liturgy and music.  The article basically says that if there is a return to more a traditional style of things (which clearly the writer thinks is going to happen) frogs will fall from the sky and active participation will be no more because of the selfish imposition of personal tastes on the universal Church by a few reactionary "theocons".  Attend: the opening of the article mentions that the 1st Sunday of Advent could be important for those watching sacred music matters.

    An interesting point: The first question is: Per chi stona il coro della Cappella Sistina…. This si a bit hard to put into English.  "For whom is the Cappella Sistina singing out of tune?"

    There is a another piece, "Oggi pensano a fare soldi con i dischi… These days they just want to make money off of CD’s"

    This is a brief interview with the Maestro Emeritus of the competing choir at the Vatican, the Cappella of the Basilica of St. Peter.  Msgr. Colino, a nice fellow but not the greatest choir director, was at least a proponent of Gregorian chant who had to battle against the current established by Piero Marini and his minions.  Colino lost, like Bartolucci, and got the boot.

    This interview is pretty bitter.  Colino blasts what is going on at the Lateran Basilica (under the charge of the Vicariate of Rome) where the goopy music of Msgr. Marco Frisina reigns supreme.  They record a lot of his stuff with the Diocesan choir and sell CD’s all over Italy where this music is lapped up like the cloying Karo-syrup it is and imitated in cathedrals and parishes.  Colino says that the proof of the terrible state of sacred music is demonstrated at the Lateran where "abominable things are happening.   Maestro Marco Frisina has zeroed out sacred music and rendered it all light, inconsistent and useless.  Frisina isn’t really player in the field of sacred music, even if thanks to the media everyone thinks he is a great composer."  There is more of the same.  Frankly, one can pick this up in nearly all major cities with cathedrals.  But I digress.  Colino is looking toward the 1st Sunday of Advent.  (Sound familiar?)  Colino sees Benedict, with moves like Summorum Pontificum to be trying to revive the Church’s tradition of sacred music.  At the end, Colino mentions the "theocons": "If the ‘theocons’ have set up their ideological banner so much the better: that can only be good for the Church."

    Then there is a piece quoting Liberto himself, the man whose job is probably on the line: "L’epurato: ho fatto dialogare le culture…  The man who’s been sacked: I started a dialogue between cultures".  The word "epurato" comes out of the political economic struggles in Italy: it means someone who was "purged" from a party or a worker who was fired.   This whole thing is being framed in political terms.  This piece is an apologia pro vita sua: "I composed a great deal of music, for nearly every large pontifical ceremony."  He then recounts what he thinks are his triumphs.  Personally, I remember nearly writhing through them in an endurance test between my sensibilities and the ability of the Sistine screamers to shatter my composure.  But I digress. "I always wedded my fresh new work with Gregorian chant.  I tried always to join the liturgy to living language, because of the challenge the Council bequeathed to us – so-called "aggiornamento" which consists exactly in opening the past to diverse cultures".  Do you see how this fellow was hand in glove with Mons. Piero Marini?  A nearly perfect paradigm of how sacred music is pars integrans in the liturgy.   

    We also read here a brief interview with Mons. Miserachs Grau of the Pontificial Institute for Sacred Music.  He is also the Maestro of the Cappella at St. Mary Major, one of the places in Rome with the longest and most distinguished musical tradition, along with St. Peter’s and St. Johns.  This fellow, in my opinion, is matter to Liberto’s anti-matter as far as theory of sacred music is concerned.  I have heard him speak and he is great.

    The title of the piece: "Everyone has created for himself his own repertory: thus, the destruction of the spiritual life."

    Again, La Stampa sticks to the "theocon" issue.  This is the point La Stampa is trying to hammer home with the average person.   They are shaping the readers view in anticipation of the changes that they sense are coming.

    "Q: What do you think about seeing classical music become part of the patrimony of the theocons.

    It seems to me there is emerging a sense of guilt over the obvilion tradition was thrust into.  Theocons have made this a point of an ideological battle.  This is seen also in the connection made between the defense of sacred music and Mass in Latin [NB: he probably is referring to the TLM here].  I appreciate their intentions, even if our position is not bound strictly to the old rite.

    Q: Do you see in embracing the theocons any risk of being used?

    No.  For us it is a question of art and faith.  Even if for them it is only a question of aesthetics, I can be a user fellow traveller, above all in at a time when those who were in control open the way to every sort of abuse.

    Q: What are you referring to?

    "The damage done to sacred music which has been tolerated for years at St. John Lateran, the Cathedral of Rome.  In the Lateran Basilica you hear absurdities, like arranging Gregorian chant with four voices.  If you can believe it, they suspend the music program during summer.  Everyone is creating his own repoertory for himself and up to now there has been only one result: the destruction of the spiritual life."

    You can see, the war is joined.

    And the USCCB is going to put out its guidelines on sacred music.  The document was reclassified so that it would not have to go to Rome for a recogitio.

    • • • • • •

    Pope Benedict’s 2nd encyclical is ready: Spe salvi? - UPDATED

    CATEGORY: SESSIUNCULUM — Fr. John Zuhlsdorf @ 9:41 am

    According Il Sole 24 Ore the Holy Father’s second encyclical is ready.

    The new document is said to be called Spe salvi, "Saved through hope" (cf. Romans 8:24).  Apparently there is another encyclical, a social encyclical in the works, but the document’s title is still being discussed.

    The encyclical on hope, however, could be released before Christmas, in fact around the first Sunday of Advent.

    Remember that the first encyclical was about charity.  Do you sense a pattern?

    The Pope worked on the encyclical during the summer.  The translations are being prepared.

    Pronta la seconda enciclica Si chiamerà «Spe salvi»

    La meditazione sulla speranza precede quella sociale che è ancora in elaborazione

    È pronta la seconda enciclica di Benedetto XVI. Si intitola "Spe Salvi" ("Salvi grazie alla speranza") e sarà pubblicata entro Natale. Un’enciclica sul tema della speranza, dunque, che precede quella sociale che, secondo quanto anticipa l’agenzia Apcom, «è ancora in alto mare». Su quest’ultima infatti «si sta ancora dibattendo sul titolo».
    La "Spe Salvi" è una meditazione sul tema della speranza cristiana che prende spunto dalla Lettera di San Paolo ai Romani, capitolo 8 versetto 24: «Poiché nella speranza noi siamo stati salvati».
    Il Papa ha lavorato all’Enciclica durante il soggiorno estivo a Lorenzago di Cadore. Ora il testo è pronto, anche se sulla data di pubblicazione ancora non si hanno certezze, visto che il testo è in fase di traduzione. Così come non è al momento possibile sapere la data della firma, che potrebbe essere la prima domenica di Avvento (periodo della speranza cristiana)o l’8 dicembre, l’Immacolata Concezione. L’Enciclica, come avviene tradizionalmente, uscirà in latino, italiano e, almeno inizialmente, in inglese, francese, spagnolo, tedesco. La prima Enciclica di Benedetto XVI, che porta la data di Natale, è uscita il 24 gennaio 2006 e si intitola «Deus caritas est».
    Intanto ieri durante l’udienza generale Benedetto XVI ha voluto formulare auspici per la «rinascita» dell’Iraq rivolgendosi ai familiari dei 19 italiani rimasti uccisi nell’attentato di quattro anni fa a Nassiriya. Il Pontefice, al termine, ha salutato personalmente alcune vedove, figli e parenti delle vittime, presenti sul sagrato della basilica vaticana nel quarto anniversario del tragico attentato.

     

     

    UPDATE 20:36 UTC 15 Nov  

    A reader sent in a note which I can summarize.  It concerns the Latin of the encyclical:

    A well-known Latinist working for the Holy See recounts that the Latin translation had been finished.  However, the Latin was very sloppy.  The work on translation of documents is commonly divided up.  The results can be uneven.  It was supposed to be cleaned up, but someone in the office "lost patience" and sent it to the printer anyway!  In any event, it should be out in Advent.

    UPDATE 19:30 UTC 16 </