QUAERITUR: more than one TLM on Sundays and feasts

A received a question from a reader about the number of TLMs which can be celebrated in a parish on a Sunday or feast.

In order to preserve anonymity, I will simply rephrase it.

Context: A parish where the TLM is celebrated regularly. The priest – otherwise friendly to the TLM – states that there can only be one celebration of the TLM in the parish on a day because Summorum Pontificum 5. § 2. says:

§ 2. Celebratio secundum Missale B. Ioannis XXIII locum habere potest diebus ferialibus; dominicis autem et festis una etiam celebratio huiusmodi fieri potest. … § 2.  Celebration according to the Missal of Bl. John XXIII can take place on weekdays; on Sunday, however, and feasts there can be also one celebration of this kind.

QUAERITUR: Does this mean that there can be only literally one celebration of Holy Mass with the 1962MR in a parish on a Sunday or feast?  Does this mean that – even if the pastor wants to put an additional celebration in the schedule in a stable way – he may not because of Summorum Pontificum 5. § 2?

 

RESPONDITUR: The intent of Summorum Pontificum is clear.  The TLM is to be made available to those who request it reasonably.  If there is great enough interest in the TLM to merit more than one Mass, there can be more than one placed in the schedule in a stable way. 

However, Summorum Pontificum is clear that there must be adequate provisions made for those who prefer to attend Mass in the Ordinary Form lest they be deprived of their rights. 

I have reason to believe that were a parish priest to write to the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei he would receive this same answer.

There are other issues to consider.  Since the Holy Father speaks of how young people are interested in the older form of Mass, and that his hope is that there will be mutual enrichment of the two forms of the Roman Rite, it makes perfect sense that there have to be adequate numbers of celebrations of Holy Mass with the 1962MR – in parishes – to satisfy these ends.  Not only do parish priests have to respond to requests for the older Mass, parish priests ought to make sure their folks know the older form through adequate exposure.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
7 Comments

“… perfecisti laudem…”

After I posted my request for good news, a reader sent this e-mail:

Reverend Father,

As regards both your request for good news and the recent discussion about ways of receiving Communion:

I teach Confirmation class at my parish, mostly using the Baltimore Catechism.

Today one of my best students, a terribly sweet 14-year-old girl, engaged me with 20 minutes of questions about the best way to receive Communion.  She asked about kneeling to receive and told me all about her distaste for unnecessary EMHCs, intinction by the laity, and the laxity of many children about their religion after they receive First Communion.  Perhaps her best quote: "I watch all those people receiving in their hands… I just think, what ARE you doing?

It struck me again how beautifully the Church’s traditional practices correspond to the universal, innate needs of our human nature.  She didn’t need any instruction from me to realize that these were the right things to do; in holy simplicity, she just got it.  Ex ore infantium perfecisti laudem.

Kid by kid, folks.

Posted in Brick by Brick, Just Too Cool |
14 Comments

My Roman rose (rosacea) vestments

My rose vestments.  It is a classic Roman set.

Ironically, they were given to me by an ultra-dissenter, once actually disciplined by the CDF.

He was getting rid of old stuff.

Posted in Just Too Cool, My View |
25 Comments

Blackfen’s Rose Vestments

Mulier Fortis has sent some images of the inaugural appearance of the solemn rosacea set at the mighty parish of Blackfen, that locus of terror for the progressivist Tabletites.  His Hermeneuticalness, Fr. Timothy Fingan is celebrant.

A good view of the cope.

Those of you who helped WDTPRS to "pound Fr. Finigan", helped with these vestments.

The humeral view is on the subdeacon to the right.

The humeral view on the subdeacon as he holds the paten.

An action shot: the genuflection during the Last Gospel.

I still think that tablets of the Decalogue should be applied to the back.

Posted in Brick by Brick |
10 Comments

Dorr, MI: TLM announcement, Gregorian workshop, maniple sighting

Fr. Robert Johansen of Thrownback has posted a note about an upcoming TLM at his parish on Laetare Sunday, … this coming Sunday.

There is a good shot of a maniple, btw.

Tie one on, Fathers!

Also, Fr. J asked me to mention a Gregorian chant workshop which is coming up on 28 March in Benton Harbor, MI.

Posted in Brick by Brick, Mail from priests |
4 Comments

A hopeful sign

We know that one robin does not make spring, but…

Yes, we have Robin.

Turdus migratorius has migrated back.  The ground is still pretty hard, and much of it snow covered where I am, but… well.. they’ll figure something out.

The usual suspects are still here, of course.

American Goldfinch is getting a new coat.  The males are getting brighter.

I am not sure if the Redpolls will stay or not.  I am pretty sure there have been more then one sort of Redpoll here this winter.

This Redpoll is having an intense breakfast.

This one is all puffed up and having an power nap.

Pretty much motionless for the better part of 10 minutes now.  He looks around occasionally.

The House Finch is around and looking for an opening.

And I hadn’t seen this guy for a long time. 

A pair of the hated Sciurus had shown themselves, and a single Tamiasciurus, not seen for a long time, appeared yesterday.   This ""timber tiger" is living up to his reputation of being Spermophilus, as he stuffs his cheeks with seeds.  The birds on the ground scatter when he… she? … dashes in for another load.

The doves are now beginning to coo.  You can see how their colors help to hide them from hawks.

Meanwhile, the Redpoll is still napping.  Several of them are at it now, after eating.  They seem to like to sit along the edge of the snow in the sun.

Posted in My View |
12 Comments

I think I can! I think I can!

Wall-E’s got nuthin’ on these guys!

This is from the Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Pasadena, Calif.

18 March 2009

One Mars Rover Sees a Distant Goal; The Other Takes a New Route

PASADENA, Calif. — On a plain that stretches for miles in every direction, the panoramic camera on NASA’s Mars rover Opportunity has caught a first glimpse on the horizon of the uplifted rim of the big crater that has been Opportunity’s long-term destination for six months[I think I can!  I think I can!]

Opportunity’s twin, Spirit, also has a challenging destination, and last week switched to a different route for making progress.

Endeavour Crater, 22 kilometers (14 miles) in diameter, is still 12 kilometers (7 miles) away from Opportunity as the crow flies, and at least 30 percent farther away on routes mapped for evading hazards on the plain. Opportunity has already driven about 3.2 kilometers (2 miles) since it climbed out of Victoria Crater last August after two years of studying Victoria, which is less than one-twentieth the size of Endeavour.

"It’s exciting to see our destination, even if we can’t be certain whether we’ll ever get all the way there," said John Callas of NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory, Pasadena, Calif., project manager for the twin Mars rovers, Opportunity and Spirit. "At the pace we’ve made since leaving Victoria, the rest of the trek will take more than a Martian year." A Martian year lasts about 23 months.

The image with portions of Endeavour’s rim faintly visible can be seen online.

Both rovers landed on Mars in January 2004 to begin missions designed to last for three months. Both are still active after more than five years.

For the next several days, the rover team plans to have Opportunity use the tools on its robotic arm to examine soil and rock at an outcrop along the route the rover is taking toward Endeavour.

"We’re stopping to taste the terrain at intervals along our route so that we can watch for trends in the composition of the soil and bedrock," Squyres said. "It’s part of systematic exploration."

The pause for using the tools on the arm also provides two other benefits. Opportunity’s right-front wheel has been drawing more electric current than usual, an indication of friction within the wheel. Resting the wheel for a few days is one strategy that has in the past helped reduce the amount of current drawn by the motor. Also, on March 7, the rover did not complete the backwards-driving portion of its commanded drive due to unanticipated interaction between the day’s driving commands and onboard testing of capabilities for a future drive. The team is analyzing that interaction before it will resume use of Opportunity’s autonomous-driving capabilities.

Meanwhile, on March 10, the rover team decided to end efforts to drive Spirit around the northeastern corner of a low plateau called "Home Plate" [ah… it is spring and baseball awakens the world again… even on Mars!] in the inner basin of the Columbia Hills, on the other side of Mars from Opportunity. Spirit has had the use of only five wheels since its right-front wheel stopped working in 2006. Consequently, it usually drives backwards, dragging that wheel, so it can no longer climb steep slopes.

Callas said, "After several attempts to drive up-slope in loose material to get around the northeast corner of Home Plate, the team judged that route to be impassable."

The new route to get toward science targets south of Home Plate is to go around the west side of the plateau.

Squyres said, "The western route is by no means a slam dunk. It is unexplored territory. There are no rover tracks on that side of Home Plate like there are on the eastern side. But that also makes it an appealing place to explore. Every time we’ve gone someplace new with Spirit since we got into the hills, we’ve found surprises."

JPL, a division of the California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, manages the Mars Exploration Rovers for the NASA Science Mission Directorate, Washington. More information about the rovers is at http://www.nasa.gov/rovers .

Posted in Just Too Cool |
14 Comments

Lack of interest in Africa

My energies and time are rather limited at the moment, so I may not give much space to issues of the Holy Father’s trip to Africa.

Still… the relative lack of interest shown by the secular media is interesting.

I suspect there are a couple factors.

First, they don’t want the Holy Father’s explanations of the dignity of human life and the need for solutions for AIDS, etc., that don’t include condom distribution to get out into public discussion.

Second, they don’t care about Africa.

It occurs to me that if it weren’t for the cute furry animals, most of the intellectual elite wouldn’t care if Africa fell off the face of the earth.  They don’t seem to give a tinker’s dam for the people.  They are not interested in solutions that work, only in projects that fit their ideological bent.

Otherwise how to explain why the wealthy West continues to stand by and watch the terrible suffering and upheaval in many parts of Africa?  How do we explain the left-wing’s imposition of aid tied to particular tools of social engineering?

I’m just askin’

I suspect that will change when they figure our that once China solidifies its ties with African nations, for access to resources.

Posted in I'm just askin'... |
34 Comments

Penjing Report

I am sure you are dying to know how Penjing is doing.

On a nice warm day Penjing is out catching some rays along with the rosemary, basil, thyme, sage and jasmine trees.

Posted in My View |
10 Comments

QUAERITUR: making vestments

From a priest reader:

I’m sure you’ve posted on this, but I cannot recall when…

I’m interested in who you would suggest to make a vestment, particularly a rose one, so it’s just right.

My preference would be either a Gothic style, or if I could see an example, perhaps something like the vestment our holy father wore some time back, which I’d describe as a very ample “fiddleback”—perhaps you recall the one I mean.

The Altar Society wants to donate this, and has $800 to put toward it. A full set with all the parts would probably be out of our reach, but we may be able to get several nice pieces.

 

You know… I think someone once did provide a link to a site with patterns for making vestments.

However, you should also consider purchasing vestments.

I was in the church goods section of Leaflet Missal in St. Paul, MN on Monday and there were a good selection of rose vestments in the so-called Gothic style having a good color, and not the nasty bright pink you sometimes see.  Ask for John in church goods at Leaflet.  Leaflet would be limited in the Roman department.

Remember: "fiddle-back" is a vague and misleading misnomer.  There is a sort of real "fiddle-back" which has Spanish influence I think.

Also, Gamarelli in Rome has the classic Roman cut, with all the necessary pieces.   They do low Mass sets or any number of pieces for whatever level of solemnity.

In the meantime, perhaps someone out there can dig up that site which had the patterns for vestments.

The classic modern Roman cut does have specific proportions for its design and certain details which are to be included, such as the pattern of the galloni or "orphries" or "trim" or whatever you choose to call it.  Sometimes people think that any chasuble with the squared sides is "Roman".  They aren’t.  For example, Roman vestments don’t have a big Cross on the back.

If you are looking for the pattern for the historic vestments, which Gamarelli would call the "taglio filipino", because of St. Philip Neri, I am not sure where you would get the pattern.  I suppose some day I could take the measurements from the vestment I have in that style.  I don’t have dalmatics for it, however. 

Maybe you good readers can help.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Mail from priests |
26 Comments