Old Mass/new Mass thoughts – part 2

A few days ago I posted a Request from Fr. Z for old Mass/new Mass thoughts, especially in view of your age.  I suggested that you e-mail me instead of just posting in the combox.  Wow, was that a mistake.   I have been inundated.

Here are more responses.Old Mass/new Mass thoughts - part 2

I’ll just post them with very little commentary.

Let’s set a few parameters.

  • Do your best to leave aside bashing of either form.  Since both are legitimate forms of Holy Mass, let’s accept that for this exercise and move on.
  • State your age, and if you are a cradle Catholic, revert, or convert and whether or not liturgy had anything to do with your once leaving the practice of your faith, your return to the Church or conversion.
  • Try to be brief.  Stick to a couple hundred words if you can.  Do a little editing.

We need to be able to explain ourselves to others when we discuss these matters, and provide the whys and wherefores for our liturgical choices.

Rather than make this a project for the combox, I suggest you send them to me by e-mail.  I will post them as I can. 

If you send an e-mail with your thoughts on this, put "Old Mass/New Mass" in the subject line.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
16 Comments

Some last images of San Francisco

I has been a few years since I have been in this interesting city.

From my hotel room.

Some last images of San Francisco

On the ferry.

Some last images of San Francisco

From my room.

Some last images of San Francisco

Some last images of San Francisco

I had forgotten how interesting this town is.

I look foward to coming back.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
13 Comments

more flying around

Off we go again.

more flying around

People who think this is glamorous must be nuts.

more flying around

You get nice views along the way.

more flying around

more flying around

more flying around

Well.. ginger ale is not very interesting.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
9 Comments

More on Celebrity Cruises and bias against Catholic priests

RMore on Celebrity Cruises and bias against Catholic priestsemember when I wrote about the probable anti-Catholic bias evidenced by Celebrity Cruises?   They have eliminated the services of Catholic priests for pretty much all of their cruises.

The Catholic League has this…

CELEBRITY CRUISES STIFFS CATHOLICS

January 14, 2010

Bill Donohue explains why the Catholic League is sharply critical of Celebrity Cruises:

Ten days before Christmas, we learned that Celebrity Cruises had just announced that beginning in 2010, it would no longer have priests on board to celebrate daily and Sunday Masses. We immediately followed up by questioning the cruise line about its new policy. Just this week we received a reply that said, “Out of respect for our guests of all religious faiths, Celebrity has chosen to align the religious services provided for Catholic, Protestant, Jewish and Interdenominational faiths effective January 4, 2010.” It added that religious services would be provided for “the major High Holy Holidays of each respective faith.”  [Get that?  "align".]

What this statement failed to note is the reason for the new policy. The following is an excerpt from the letter it sent to Catholic priests affected by the change in policy: “While we do meet the needs of many guests onboard by supplying a priest, we have recently encountered a great deal of negative feedback pertaining to the ‘selective’ support of one particular religion/faith. After many internal discussions, external research, and marketing investigations, Celebrity Cruises will only place Roman Catholic Priests on sailings that take place over the Easter and Christmas holiday.”  [Who could have complained?]

In other words, because some anti-Catholics objected to daily Mass onboard the ship, Celebrity Cruises threw the priests—and the lay Catholic men and women with them—overboard. [That’s about it.] Instead of standing on principle and telling those generating the “negative feedback” that no one is forced to go to Mass, and that tolerance demands respect for religious freedom, officials at Celebrity Cruises decided to yield to the bigots.

The Catholic League advises all Catholics to shop around the next time they plan to take a cruise, but not to waste their time checking out Celebrity Cruises.  [As I also suggested.  Choose another line.]

Contact: captainsclub@celebritycruises.com

Posted in The Last Acceptable Prejudice | Tagged
23 Comments

CNA: Pelosi’s archbishop slams her rationale for supporting abortion

For a few more hours I am in San Francisco, Congressional District of pro-abortion Catholic Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) Speak of the House.

Could it be that my visit…. nah…. no way…

Thus I was surprised to find the following, with my emphases and comments on CNA:

San Francisco, Calif., Jan 13, 2010 / 05:46 pm (CNA).- Archbishop George Niederauer responded today to Rep. Nancy Pelosi’s (D-Calif.) recent comments that she has “some concerns about the Church’s position respecting a woman’s right to choose.” Justifying her decision to support abortion by citing her free will “is entirely incompatible with Catholic teaching,” the archbishop insisted.  [Okay… and the next step iiiiissssszzzzz…..]

Speaker of the House, Nancy Pelosi told Newsweek’s Eleanor Clift in a December 21, 2009 interview that she disagrees with the Church on certain issues but considers herself a “practicing Catholic.”

[Read the incredible statement again…] “I have some concerns about the church’s position respecting a woman’s right to choose. I have some concerns about the church’s position on gay rights. I am a practicing Catholic, although they’re probably not too happy about that. But it is my faith. I feel what I was raised to believe is consistent with what I profess, and that is that we are all endowed with a free will and a responsibility to answer for our actions. And that women should have that opportunity to exercise their free will,” Pelosi said.

Archbishop Niederauer countered in his January 13 column, “Embodied in that statement are some fundamental misconceptions about Catholic teaching on human freedom.” God gave human beings the capacity to choose between good and evil in order to give them the gift of freedom, even at the cost of many evil choices, the archbishop said.

But this gift of freedom, the freedom wrongly cited in justifying a woman’s right to choose, ["right to choose" is really code for "choose in favor of abortion"] among other fallacies, does not justify the position that “all moral choices are good if they are free,” insisted Archbishop Niederauer, because “the exercise of freedom does not imply a right to say or do everything.”  [A corollary to this is, "I really struggled with this decision."  These days, The Struggle is supposed to be a free pass for whatever you choose to do. ]

Addressing those who advocate for “reproductive choice” while claiming to be Catholic, Archbishop Niederauer emphasized, “it is entirely incompatible with Catholic teaching to conclude that our freedom of will justifies choices that are radically contrary to the Gospel—racism, infidelity, abortion, theft. [Ehem… not that these are moral equivalents.]  Freedom of will is the capacity to act with moral responsibility; it is not the ability to determine arbitrarily what constitutes moral right.”

The belief in the validity of arbitrarily determining right and wrong is widespread both in and outside of the Church, the archbishop noted.

Touching on the meaning of one’s conscience, the San Francisco archbishop described it as “the judgment of reason whereby the human person, guided by God’s grace, recognizes the moral quality of a concrete act. In all we say and do, we are obliged to follow faithfully what we know to be just and right.”

“As participants in the life of the civil community,” [As Catholics in the public square….] Archbishop Niederauer wrote, “we Catholic citizens try to follow our consciences, guided, as described above, by reason and the grace of God. While we deeply respect the freedom of our fellow citizens, we nevertheless are profoundly convinced that free will cannot be cited as justification for society to allow moral choices that strike at the most fundamental rights of others. Such a choice is abortion, which constitutes the taking of innocent human life, and cannot be justified by any Catholic notion of freedom.”  [Do I hear an "Amen!"?]

 

WDTPRS applauds Archbp. Niederauer and invites Speaker Pelosi to conform her conscience to the teaching of the Church lest she risk a horrifying judgment.

 

 

Posted in Emanations from Penumbras | Tagged ,
30 Comments

America Magazine article about the dissident petition against the new translation

First, I have an ACTION ITEM for you WDTPRSers.
America Magazine article about the dissident petition against the new translation
I urge people to look at the petition "We’ve Waited Long Enough".

When you sign that petition, use a real name.   On the dissident petition, there are more signatures but a very high percentage of them are "anonymous" or even bogus.  Some creepy weirdo has tried several times to put my name on that petition.  That means there is no oversight or even concern that real people are signing it.

Let’s get on…

America Magazine
, published by the Jesuits, includes a piece by Fr. Peter Stravinskas about the online dissident petition against the new translation of the Roman Missal.

I have written several times about this online petition, which is hosted by the rector of the Cathedral of the Archdiocese of Seattle.. which leads to other questions.

My emphases and comments.

Defending the New Roman Missal
A response to Father Michael Ryan
Peter M. J. Stravinskas | FEBRUARY 1, 2010

In his essay “Why Don’t We Say, ‘Wait?’” (Dec. 14), Father Michael Ryan describes his involvement in the liturgical renewal following the Second Vatican Council. Let me begin my response to his article by doing the same.

…

[Let’s move along.]

In his essay, Father Ryan argues that not enough consultation has taken place, and that “we should just say, “Wait’” before implementing the new translations. I disagree. As a Web site set up to defend the new translation proclaims, “We’ve waited long enough!”

Ryan argues that the Roman Curia and other parties are involved in a “systematic dismantling of the great vision of the Council’s decree” and that the Congregation for Divine Worship is raising “rubricism to an art form,” with liturgy being used “as a weapon—to advance specific agendas.” In my view, present efforts are precisely seeking to reclaim “the great vision of the council’s” constitution. Over the years my various apostolates have provided me with a vantage point from which to consider liturgical life in this country and abroad. So much of what I have witnessed or had described to me by eyewitnesses has been nothing shy of a betrayal of the council’s great vision and, in my judgment, largely responsible for the rapid emptying of the pews.

What curial officials and the pope are arguing for, with the enthusiastic support of junior clergy, [v. the aging hippie set… or more benignly the older men who just don’t want to deal with another wave of changes.] is not a moribund “rubricism” [A vapid charge if there was one.  Rubricism?  With the Novus Ordo?  Is that even possible?] but a genuine ars celebrandi [cf. Benedict XVI’s Sacramentum caritatis.] that makes the sacred mysteries palpable. Not a few observers have noted that much of the liturgical change that occurred after the council—both officially sanctioned as well as in explicit violation of church law—would have been unthinkable to the council fathers. What is required now is a careful re-building process. [Brick by brick?] Is this “turning back the clock”? In some sense, it is. Permit me a mundane example. If a man is told by his physician that he must lose 50 pounds or face serious problems, he must “turn back the clock” to the time when he was lighter in order to save his life. Mutatis mutandis—that is what the church at the highest levels is calling us to do.

Father Ryan writes that “before long the priests of this country will be told to take the new translations to their people by means of a carefully orchestrated education program…” The author makes such efforts sound almost sinister, but in my book he is simply describing the process of catechesis. I hope that this process will be better handled than the “carefully orchestrated education program” that followed the postconciliar liturgical changes. In 1977 priests throughout the country were required to preach for three consecutive weekendsm, not simply on the issue of Communion-in-the-hand, but on why it should be done. [Perhaps we should ask priests to preach about why it should it done…. if you know what I mean.] Many priests who balked at the historically inaccurate catechetical materials were harassed by liturgical directors and even threatened by bishops with suspension. It seems that many of those who pushed for the reforms are waking up to find their program repudiated and have now become conservatives, opposed to change.

Father Ryan shares the concern of Bishop Donald Trautman of Erie, Pa., the former chairman of the Bishops’ Committee on the Liturgy, who has complained that the U.S.C.C.B. did not have a direct hand in the antiphons of the Missale Romanum. In a speech to the bishops conference in November, Bishop Trautman cited paragraph 36 of Sacrosanctum Concilium, which he argued gave the episcopal conferences the authority to produce and approve liturgical translations. Yet the paragraph in question in no way calls for what Bishop Trautman demands: it stipulates that episcopal conferences are to approve translations (not produce them), with subsequent approval by the Holy See.

Ironically, the very same paragraph of the conciliar constitution also states that, “The use of the Latin language, with due respect to particular law, is to be preserved in the Latin rites….Care must be taken to ensure that the faithful may also be able to say or sing together in Latin those parts of the Ordinary of the Mass which pertain to them.” In other words, if paragraph 36 had been followed in regard to the primacy of Latin, the Ordinary of the Mass would not have been translated into the vernacular in the first place!  [If people don’t like the new translation, they can always have Holy Mass in Latin and people can bring the book with the translation they prefer.]

Examining the TranslationAmerica Magazine article about the dissident petition against the new translation

Finally, Father Ryan highlights as examples of a liturgical agenda “at best trivial and at worst hopelessly out-of-touch” several new texts that are products of “flawed principles of translation.” I am delighted with the examples he proffers because each is, in fact, an exemplar of what is so important about the new translation project.  [I have written a zillion times on this.  Basically, it is okay sometimes for a translation to sound like a translation when that is the only way you can get to the content of the original.  Also, in my experience people find a stricter translation to be far more interesting, which serves to engage the mind and will.]

[…]

We are warned by Father Ryan to expect “discredit to the church” and “disillusionment to the people” if the new translation sees the light of day. He tells us of the “chilling reception” it has received in South Africa, in spite of a “careful program of catechesis in the parishes.” I beg to differ. There was no “program of catechesis” to speak of in South Africa and, in fact, some liturgical observers even argue that the translation was thrust onto the faithful precisely to cause a negative reaction. [EXACTLY!] Having conducted several workshops on the new texts over the past year, I can only attest to very positive reactions, from clergy and laity alike. [This isn’t hard.  Really… it isn’t.]

How did the final texts receive such overwhelming support from the American bishops, if they are so bad? Father Ryan contends that the bishops were just “worn down” by the Holy See and so caved in. I disagree. [Well… I think they were, to a certain extent.  They too recognized that this had gone on long enough.]  The majority of the bishops saw the merit of the work and were tired of the delaying tactics of a vocal if tiny minority of opponents. [They were indeed worn down… by the carping of the delayers.] Is this translation perfect? Of course not. No translation is, but we ought never make the best the enemy of the good. [sounds familiar….] It is a vast improvement over the uninspiring, banal and all-too-often theologically problematic texts we have been using for nearly 40 years. The New Testament speaks of chairos, an especially fortuitous moment. [Good point.  Though I think that should be kairos, no?  Isn’t kappa is usually transliterated with "k"?] We are approaching a liturgical chairos for English-speaking Catholics, which we should embrace with gusto.

In addition to Father Ryan’s article and the Web site he set up to summon support for further delays, he has also written to the rectors of all the cathedrals in the country seeking to rally them to his cause. His campaign has provoked a counterreaction among younger clergy and seminarians who have helped to set up the site “We’ve waited long enough.” The site has already garnered thousand of signatures and should give pause to Ryan and his supporters. It is these young priests, after all, who will be using these texts when our generation (God willing) will be participating in the Liturgy of Heaven, where language will not be an issue.  [A note about the counter petition below.]

Rev. Peter Stravinskas is the editor of The Catholic Response, publisher of Newman House Press and executive director of the Catholic Education Foundation.

I urge people to look at the petition "We’ve Waited Long Enough".

When you sign that petition, use a real name.   On the dissident petition, there are more signatures but a very high percentage of them are "anonymous" or even bogus.  Some creepy weirdo has tried several times to put my name on that petition.  That means there is no oversight or even concern that real people are signing it.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA, WDTPRS | Tagged , ,
25 Comments

Obama Administration debates requiring covering of religious symbols for federal funds

Catholics need to fight to keep and clarify a Catholic voice in the public square and the digital continent.

A reader alerted me to this entry on the WaPo blog On Faith.  It concerns what the Obama Adminstration might impose on religious institutions which accept federal funds.

I suspect this would impact the school voucher debate.

My emphases and comments.

Obama Faith Council Debates Religious Icons

By William Wan

Obama’s faith council [I wonder who is on that council…] is finalizing its draft report this week, and one of the key debates that emerged from the phone conference yesterday was whether there should be [So this is hypothetical?] rules requiring religious groups to cover up religious symbols if they receive federal funding for services. For example, if a church gets money for a soup kitchen, would it have to remove or put a cloth over all crosses, pictures, etc., every time it gets ready to feed the hungry?  [I know that sounds implausible… but consider how quickly things have been changing.]

That sparked a lively debate among council members that largely dominated yesterday’s two-hour teleconference.  [NB: They didn’t immediately shoot it down.] Melissa Rogers, director of Wake Forest’s Center for Religion and Public Affairs, who is leading the group tasked with solving such church-state issues laid ouit three possibilities the council could recommend:
1. Making such religious icons not allowed for federally funded services.
2. Allowing it only if no other religious neutral rooms ["religious neutral rooms"] are available and covering up such icons is impratical. [impractical!]
3. Not requiring removal of such icons but encouraging religious orgs to be sensitive about the issue.  ["be sensitive"?  What would that involve?  Walking through the halls sniveling a little?  Hand ringing?]

That led to a lengthy debate from which no clear consensus emerged. [Of coruse everything has to be done by consensus.]  As the council’s various taskforces finish up their reports, some thorny issues like this look like they’ll require footnotes or majority/minority opinion sections (ala supreme court).

The other significant news that emerged from the teleconference yesterday was that Rogers has been chosen by the group to be its official chairwoman and to coordinate the finalizing of the final report as the various taskforces wrap up their work.

Do they set policy or just make recommendations?

Who is on this council?

Remember Georgetown University!  Remember Notre Dame!

 

Posted in Our Catholic Identity | Tagged
38 Comments

QUAERITUR: If you wear an alb, do you need an amice?

QUAERITUR: If you wear an alb, do you need an amice?From a reader:

I just had a quick question: If a seminarian or anyone for that matter wears an an alb at Mass is it proper to wear an amice under it? I have a cassock and surplice but the "tradition" in my diocese has been that seminarians wear albs when sitting in choir at Mass or serving or whatever.

 

For the Novus Ordo, the general rule is that street clothes should be covered.  For clerics, for sacred ministers, that sometimes requires the amice if the alb is not constructed so as to cover the collar.

If you priests or deacons in Mass vestments with their Roman collars showing, they are under-dressed.

As far as lay people are concerned, I think the rule would still apply.

But I wouldn’t want the use of an amice to lead to any sense of "clericalization" of the lay people who use them.  If there must be servers in albs, perhaps it would be better to have those albs that entirely cover the next, thus eliminating the need for an amice.

Seminarians should use proper choir dress.   But if they are forced to use albs, then use the amice if necessary to cover street clothes.

For the Usus antiquior, priests must use an amice.  Servers would be in cassock and surplice.

His omnibus scriptis: If you don’t have an amice and one isn’t available, you go ahead as best you can without it.  You are not held to the impossible.   But be responsible beforehand and make sure you have what you need.   Don’t assume these days that parishes have amices unless they also have more traditional liturgical worship.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box | Tagged ,
10 Comments

A note about your responses to my query

I asked about your preferences, somewhat based on age, etc., about the new form of Mass and old Mass.

Responses are still coming in.

But I am on the road and staying in a place where there are also lots of techies who work for an internet concern… the same company – Joyent – that hosts WDTPRS!  Needless to say there is an incredible consumption of bandwidth here and I can barely move around.

I will start posting your responses soon!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on A note about your responses to my query

In the rubble of Haiti… priests and seminarians

I have read… could this be true?… Vatican Radio is saying…

The apostolic nuncio in Haiti, Msgr. Bernardito Auza, said that the cathedral and all the major churches and seminaries in Port-au-Prince were leveled by the most powerful temblor to strike the island in two centuries. Hundreds of seminarians and priests were trapped in the rubble, he told Vatican Radio.

 

May God preserve them

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
22 Comments