Fr. Bouyer and an anecdote about how the liturgical reform was imposed

Forgive the screwy formatting of the following.  It is taken from a mass e-mail from the editor of Inside The Vatican, Robert Moynighan.

It concerns the behind the scenes story of the post-Conciliar liturgical reform.  The characters involved are the famous liturgist Fr. Louis Bouyer and Paul VI.  This is a bit removed, but it is perhaps useful.

Letter from a Reader about the Liturgy

I just received this letter from a reader:

Dear Dr. Moynihan,

These newsflashes are really informative and important for many of us to help us understand what is going on in Roma.

Given some of the past (and somewhat unfinished) newsflashes, I was wondering if you had seen this, from Fr. Anthony Chadwick (TAC priest in France) on his Civitas Dei web site http://pagesperso-orange.fr/civitas.dei/reflections10.09.htm, translating from a French traditionalist email group:

(Note: here follows the text from the web site; the incident occurred in about 1974.)

==============================
 
October 3rd — Sainte Thérèse de l’Enfant Jésus (Roman calendar and a local Saint here in Normandy)…

Fr. Bouyer and an anecdote about how the liturgical reform was imposedFather Louis Bouyer (photo): I wrote to the Holy Father, Pope Paul VI, to tender my resignation as member of the Commission charged with the Liturgical Reform. The Holy Father sent for me at once (and the following conversation ensued):

Paul VI: Father, you are an unquestionable and unquestioned authority by your deep knowledge of the Church’s liturgy and Tradition, and a specialist in this field. I do not understand why you have sent me your resignation, whilst your presence, is more than precious, it is indispensable!

Father Bouyer: Most Holy Father, if I am a specialist in this field, I tell you very simply that I resign because I do not agree with the reforms you are imposing! Why do you take no notice of the remarks we send you, and why do you do the opposite?

Paul VI: But I don’t understand: I’m not imposing anything. I have never imposed anything in this field. I have complete trust in your competence and your propositions. It is you who are sending me proposals. When Fr. Bugnini comes to see me, he says: "Here is what the experts are asking for." And as you are an expert in this matter, I accept your judgement.

Father Bouyer: And meanwhile, when we have studied a question, and have chosen what we can propose to you, in conscience, Father Bugnini took our text, and, then said to us that, having consulted you: "The Holy Father wants you to introduce these changes into the liturgy." And since I don’t agree with your propositions, because they break with the Tradition of the Church, then I tender my resignation.

Paul VI: But not at all, Father, believe me, Father Bugnini tells me exactly the contrary: I have never refused a single one of your proposals. Father Bugnini came to find me and said: "The experts of the Commission charged with the Liturgical Reform asked for this and that". And since I am not a liturgical specialist, I tell you again, I have always accepted your judgement. I never said that to Monsignor Bugnini. I was deceived. Father Bugnini deceived me and deceived you.

Father Bouyer: That is, my dear friends, how the liturgical reform was done!

==================================

(The letter to me then continues):

Of course, this plays into the I think unfinished story you were recounting about Cardinal Gagnon’s investigation, and the aftermath. I must add that I saw on another traditionalist list group a few years back the comment from Prof. Luc Perrin (Strasbourg) that he himself had a typescript copy of Fr. Bouyer’s memoirs, which could not then be published due to family opposition or something of the sort, but that they contained bombshells…

 

You have to know that Paul VI was perhaps overly trusting.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
52 Comments

REVIEW: TUNA!

REVIEW: TUNA!People seem to be fascinated by tuna.

It might be that their interest in tuna comes from how funny sounding the word is: tuna.

Is it that a large percentage of their flesh and bones knit together from the childhood consumption of tons of the less than elusive tuna?  School children for decades have been fed gallons of tuna noodle casserole (or for those of you in Minnesota "hot dish"), sandwiches, salads, ice cream sundaes and malteds.

Well… those last two … not so much.

Speaking of being less than elusive, the other day I was talking with a priest friend and we determined that we are, in a sense, both ecclesiastical versions of Charlie the Tuna.  No matter how hard we try, churchy powers that be just don’t want what we are offering.  I need a photoshopped image of Charlie in clerical dress, a cassock or something.

Yah, I know.  I am about as much of a beatnik as Jaws.

I’m kidding of course, but you get the idea.  There’s humor in tuna.  Tunny is funny.

Chickens are funny too, but right now we are talking about toooooonah!

So, I thought it was important to alert you to a TUNA REVIEW.  WDTPRS needs more entries about tuna … and moose… but especially tuna.

Without ever having put tuna on my wish list, I have actually been given cans of tuna for Christmas. I have been sent cans of tuna by readers of WDTPRS! Tuna is important.  A friend alerts me to new tuna products!

Here is a TUNA REVIEW by way of Meanwhile, Back In The Kitchen.

This tuna has the advantage of being named after a region in Italy.  Can’t be bad, right?

Wednesday, October 14, 2009
Best. Canned. Tuna. Ever.

I am not kidding.

As my family knows, I am darned picky about tuna. Years ago, there was a brand usually sold to restaurants that I was able to get over the internet.

Mothers routinely would call or corner me and ask what I did to make tuna salad that their kids loved and mentioned to their mothers. "Easy," I said. "Just use albacore and real mayonnaise."  [Yes, folks.  Stick with real mayo for this.  But let’s not devolve into dressing disputes here.]

You would not believe how many faces of disgust I saw at the mention of real mayo. Our country is so messed up.  [A powerful indicator to be sure.]

However, I digress. My beloved tuna was discontinued, at least for public purchase. Sadness ensued. Accompanied by a quest to replace it.
REVIEW: TUNA!
I have been able to do so to varying degrees, finally settling for a kind sold at the Central Market. For $6 per can.

It was worth it. Just believe me. Not equal to my restaurant tuna but close enough. Then, of course, The Central Market discontinued carrying it in favor of their own brand which, you should excuse me, is something my cat would enjoy but not something I care to eat myself.  [Bad tuna in a can is nearly indistinguishable from cat food.]

Yes, HEB, just take it. Your tuna is not all that.

Back to the internet I went. Where I found Lazio tuna … which I completely bought myself. (Hark! Can you hear the angels singing?) Oh. my. goodness.

I didn’t know canned tuna could taste so very, very good.

I bought the oil-pack … just to be an anti-politically-correct-American.  [Of COURSE the oil-packed tuna!] As I said, the angels sang.

A canned filet with none of that weird stuff in the bottom of the can. A flavor where you can tell it actually came from a tuna … while still being distinctively canned tuna. Delicately salted but enough that you can tell there is salt. And packed in oil. Like when I was a kid! Although that wasn’t olive oil when I was a kid. I think it was … soybean oil? However, I digress again. Just believe me that this is a glorious products.

Go get yourself a sample.

Okay.  Now I have to find this stuff.

In my first search I found a Charlie the Tuna screensaver.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
37 Comments

4-9 Nov NYC (Solemn TLM 6 Nov) – BLOGNIC?

I will be in New York City from 4-9 November.   One of the things I will be doing is acting as celebrant for a Solemn TLM on 6 November.   More details about this to follow.

However, perhaps in advance we might give some thought to a Big Apple Blognic. 

Maybe a Saturday morning thing?

The Solemn Mass will be for First Friday, 6 November at 6:30 PM at the Church of the Guardian Angel in Manhattan (10th Ave. and 21st St.).  This link should take you to some pictures of the Church.

Posted in On the road, What Fr. Z is up to |
1 Comment

L’OssRom: smelling and spilling the coffee

Biretta tip to the one the only His Hermeneuticalness   o{]:¬)

This was in L’Osservatore Romano.

After they consumed some of their excellent coffee, we also got this:

On President Obama’s Nobel
A demanding prize

    Lucetta Scaraffia

    The decision to award the Nobel Peace Prize to Barack Obama took everyone more or less by surprise, first and foremost the President of the United States himself.  [Asusming, of course, that he didn’t consider himself entitled to it.]
    In fact in the past 90 years the Prize has never been awarded to an American President in office, fatally involved in political affairs, hence liable to take decisions contrary to peace. When Jimmy Carter won it in 2002, he had completed his mandate some years earlier.
    For this very reason commentators have been almost unanimous in describing the award as a way of pressuring Obama to favour pacifist decisions for the rest of his mandate.
    Moreover, on the basis of the decisions he has made so far, it would be difficult to describe the President as an outright pacifist. His provisions regarding American military involvement in Iraq and Afghanistan seem to fall between fidelity to the pacifist principles proclaimed during his electoral campaign and a more realistic policy, which some have even defined as a continuation of the "warmongering" Bush.  [In other words, we don’t know where he stands.]
    The American President’s is an oscillating policy, similar to his policy for the important bioethical issues and in the first place, abortion, which has sparked so many disputes among Catholics in the U.S.  [Since when has POTUS policy on abortion been "oscillating"?  It is as straight as the forceps abortionists use on the skull of a baby.]
    In receiving the sought-after recognition, Obama must remember that in 1979 he was preceded by Mother Teresa of Calcutta, who, in her official declaration on the occasion of the presentation of the Prize, had the courage to recall that the most destructive war, with the greatest number of "fallen", is the practice of abortion, legalized and facilitated even in international structures.
    Yet with the prospect of influencing the future of Obama’s presidential mandate, all the perplexities that invalidated the most authoritative nominations melted away.
    An example is the nomination of John Paul ii, proposed for years and a candidate since 1999 (when the Nobel Prize was awarded instead to Médecins sans Frontières) and especially in 2003, when he was considered a top favourite after his condemnation of the war in Iraq. In that year, many initiatives and a large part of the world seemed to be in favour of choosing him as the natural winner of the coveted Prize, and he was even considered the favourite by the bookmakers.
    However, the Committee appointed by the Norwegian Parliament established by Alfred Nobel to select the meritorious candidates did not choose him but preferred the Iranian jurist Shirin Ebadi.
    Pope Wojtyla was considered by the members of the jury to be too conservative in other areas and it was feared that by rewarding, with him, the Catholic Church, it would show favouritism to an important religious denomination at the expense of others.
    Such fears have apparently been surmounted in the much more controversial case of the award given to Obama.
    The Nobel Peace Prize has once again given rise to perplexity and criticism, since the criteria for its designation often seem to have been influenced by politically correct thinking.  [I would say.] Yet at the same time, as the Director of the Holy See Press Office declared, we cannot but rejoice at seeing President Obama’s efforts for nuclear disarmament recognized, along with his indisputable personal propensity for a policy oriented to obtaining peace rather than to affirming American power in the world.  [Which is what they are probably most concerned about.]

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
12 Comments

QUAERITUR: books to help seminarians understand the Novus Ordo by learning the TLM

From a priest reader who works in a seminary and is involved with helping seminarians learn how to say Mass (edited):

… I find it helpful to know the historic reasons behind even small gestures at Mass.  […]
 
Thus, I would like to prepare to pass along this wisdom by studying the Mass and absorbing, as much as I can, the reasons that we do what we do up there – so that the men are competent in, and devoted to saying the black/doing the red because they understand whence they come – and I find that if one wants to understand the parts/gestures/prayers/sequence of the novus ordo, he must study the TLM.
 
I read recently The Holy Sacrifice of the Mass by Fr. Nicholas Gihr, which was superb.  Might you have other book suggestions, either for me in preparation, or for the students, so as to understand the NO by understanding the TLM?

QUAERITUR: books to help seminarians understand the Novus Ordo by learning the TLMI haven’t read Gihr, but I have heard of it.

I am pleased that Father is taking this approach.  As young men learn the older forms or learn about them, they will have a better grasp of who they are as priests and what they do at the altar.

I think they could benefit from access to Jungmann’s The Mass of the Roman Rite, which will be in the library, but should be on all of their shelves without question.  It is a scholar’s approach.   More accessible is, perhaps, Romano Guardini’s little book Meditations before Mass. 

Also, have them look at the works of Klaus Gamber about ad orientem worship.

 

Perhaps some readers will offer other titles.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Mail from priests |
13 Comments

Which Catholics are happy with the health care vote?

From CNA:

Washington D.C., Oct 14, 2009 / 12:04 pm (CNA).- Chris Korzen, Executive Director of Catholics United, a non-profit organization that has consistently supported President Obama’s policies, released a statement yesterday thanking Senator Olympia Snowe for being the only Republican to vote in favor of the Finance Committee health care bill. However, the U.S. Catholic bishops remain far from comfortable with the legislation.

 

There’s more…

This morning in a skype conversation a priest friend of mine… a very smart friend… asked "Are the bishops starting to get it?"

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
5 Comments

Thanks!

Many thanks to the kind people who have contributed to the Feed Z Birds fund!  Thanks!

This winter they will eat by your donations.

Right now there is a good sale on feed going, till 18 October, at a wild bird store.  I will try to stock up while the sale is on.

Also, many thanks to TG of MO who checked the wish list and sent the flat of San Marzano tomatoes!  That is part of the Feed Z… Z fund. 

I will mark those cans, so when I use them I will remember TG who sent them.
Thanks!
Thanks!

Posted in Fr. Z's Kitchen, My View, SESSIUNCULA, The Feeder Feed |
3 Comments

10 “scientific” explanations against the Fatima Miracle of the Sun

Yesterday I reminded you that it was the anniversary of the Fatima Miracle of the Sun.

Today I found on Creative Minority Report a delightfully snarky examination of some reasons naysayers posited to explain what happened.

SCIENCE TO THE RESCUE!

Since this is just too good, here it is in full:

Top Ten Scientific Explantions of Miracle of Sun at Fatima

The Miracle of the Dancing Sun at Fatima which was seen by 70,000 people on October 13th, 1917 has been written about often. But many people continually attempt to explain away the vision of the sun dancing in the sky at a foretold time.

Avelino de Almeida, wrote articles for O Século, Portugal’s most widely-circulated and influential newspaper, which was pro-government and anti-clerical at the time. Almeida’s previous articles had been to satirize the previously reported events at Fatima but here’s what he wrote that day:

"Before the astonished eyes of the crowd, whose aspect was biblical as they stood bare-headed, eagerly searching the sky, the sun trembled, made sudden incredible movements outside all cosmic laws — the sun ‘danced’ according to the typical expression of the people."

But secularists have amassed an enormous amount of explanations as to why we should not believe our own eyes. Here are the astounding reasons they’ve amassed so we should believe nothing at all special happened in Portugal that great day.  [yes… this strikes the right tone!]

1. Stratospheric Dust. Steuart Campbell, writing for the 1989 edition of Journal of Meteorology, postulated that a cloud of stratospheric dust changed the appearance of the sun on 13 October, making it easy to look at, and causing it to appear yellow, blue, and violet and to spin. In support of his hypothesis, Mr. Campbell reports that a blue and reddened sun was reported in China as documented in 1983.  [On schedule, no doubt.]

2. ESP! (Always my favorite) Author Lisa Schwebel claims that the event was a supernatural (but non-miraculous) extra-sensory phenomenon. Schwebel notes that the solar phenomenon reported at Fátima is not unique – there have been several reported cases of high pitched religious gatherings culminating in the sudden and mysterious appearance of lights in the sky.  [Of course they do!  We hear about them all the time!]

3. Mock-Sun. Didn’t even know this existed but it’s worth a listen. Joe Nickell, a skeptic and investigator of paranormal phenomena, claims that the position of the phenomenon, as described by the various witnesses, is at the wrong azimuth and elevation to have been the sun. He suggests the cause may have been a sundog. Sometimes referred to as a parhelion or "mock sun", a sundog is an atmospheric optical phenomenon associated with the reflection/refraction of sunlight by the numerous small ice crystals that make up cirrus or cirrostratus clouds. A sundog is, however, a stationary phenomenon, and would not explain the reported appearance of the "dancing sun". So Nickell further suggests an explanation for this phenomena may lie in temporary retinal distortion, caused by staring at the intense light and/or the effect of darting the eyes to and fro so as to avoid completely fixed gazing (thus combining image, afterimage and movement). So the people shook their heads and though a mock-sun was dancing. All 70,000? Prety ridiculous, huh?  [But… but… it’s science!]

4. Dust cloud! Paul Simons, in an article entitled "Weather Secrets of Miracle at Fatima", states that he believes it possible that some of the optical effects at Fatima may have been caused by a cloud of dust from the Sahara.  [Good one!]

5. Ye ol mass hallucination theory. Author Kevin McClure claims that the crowd at Cova da Iria may have been expecting to see signs in the sun, as similar phenomena had been reported in the weeks leading up to the miracle. [Oh?  The sun moved around elsewhere before 13 October?] On this basis he believes that the crowd saw what it wanted to see. (Yeah because that happens all the time.) But McClure’s account fails to explain similar reports of people miles away, who by their own testimony were not even thinking of the event at the time, or the sudden drying of people’s sodden, rain-soaked clothes.  [Pesky details.]

6. UFO! It has been argued that the Fatima phenomenon was an alien craft. Of course, either that craft happened to come on the day that the three little children said a miracle would occur. Or the apparitions were all the works of little green men. This all sounds a lot more real than the Church’s explanation.  [I like this one.]

7. Solar Storm. A gigantic coronal mass ejection (CME) occurred. Every eleven years our sun goes through a period of solar storms and these storms have been with us for
centuries of recorded history. Solar flares emit high-speed particles that
cause the Northern Lights or Aurora Borealis. Well that explains it all right there. Because we all know the Northern Lights look exactly like the Sun dancing. Or not.  [Not.]

8. Peer pressure. Among a uniform people sharing a particular religious belief, it is very easy for individuals to feel social pressure to conform to whatever is seen as a part of "how things should be", for "true believers". 70,000 people. That’s pretty strong peer pressure especially for the people who saw it 20 miles away.  [Maybe the aliens from #6 had a PPAU or Peer Pressure Amplification Unit?]

9. Not everyone saw it. Astronomers noticed no dancing in the sky from all over the world. The dancing sun was a regional event thus disproving it. A quick question would be the fact that it was a regional event should prove that something out of the ordinary happened. If it happened worldwide it would be written off as simply an astronomical event because the whole world saw it.   [Yah… a little flaw in that argument.]

10. An Eclipse. These fellas don’t mind contradicting themselves. This would be a very very regional eclipse. Wouldn’t astronomers have noted the eclipse?  [I think we have been calculating eclipses for a while, unless once again the aliens of #6 interposed their ship, or maybe the rogue Planet X swept by… which, come to think of it, might have been noticed on its own.]

Bonus Reason:
11. Evolution. This is sadly from Institute of Physics, Catholic Univeristy of Louvain. Evolution has provided us with the infamous “zoom and loom effect”. It tends to appear when the brain is confronted with the two-dimensional retinal image of an object thatis situated at some unknown distance. The brain will then consider the possibility that it could come closer, by performing an illusory mental zoom, where the apparent size of the object isprogressively increased. This results from the fact that evolution preserved the tendency to take into account the possibility of a dangerous approach: a rapid evasive action could bebeneficial for survival. When the “idea” of an approach does not lead to any real danger, theperceived object returns to its normal place. Thus the dancing sun. Amazing. 70,000 people thought the Sun was a predator coming to eat them. When they realized the Sun had no teeth they "zoomed and loomed" it back to where it belonged. That might just be my favorite one.  [Good one.  I think we will all have to deal with this one seriously.]

So after listening to these level-headed scientists(?) explain away Fatima hasn’t it convinced you to join the Richard Dawkins fan club? Me neither.  

 

Wasn’t Richard Dawkins the one who proposed that, to explain the origins of life here, suggested that it was brought by aliens?

After all, that is so much more believable than, say, God.

Posted in Global Killer Asteroid Questions, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , , ,
13 Comments

The last acceptable prejudice

A writer in a Canadian newspaper considers the coverage of the unfortunate Nova Scotia bishop and comments in a refreshing way.

From the National Post with my emphases and comments.

The last acceptable prejudice

Michael Coren, National Post  Published: Wednesday, October 14, 2009

It was as predictable as an Orangeman putting on his sash or a latte coffee-drinker buying but not actually reading the latest risible volume from one of the new, inflated atheists. [zzzzzZAP] A former Roman Catholic bishop in Nova Scotia was charged with the possession of child pornography and within a day there were letters, blogs and articles explaining why the Church is doomed, why married and women priests have to be recruited and how this is entirely typical of those bloody awful Catholics who should really know their place.

Remember, Canada may have changed face but its establishment has never changed heart. As the premier of Northern Ireland said in the 1930s, "There are a great number of Protestants who employ Roman Catholics. I can speak freely on the subject as I have not a Catholic about my own place. Roman Catholics are endeavouring to get in everywhere. I appeal to Loyalists, therefore, wherever possible, to employ good Protestant lads and lassies."

Quite so. Today secularism is the ideology of fashion but Catholicbashing, the last acceptable prejudice in polite society, is the toxin the runs through the contemporary bloodstream of Western liberal society.

What Bishop Raymond Lahey is accused of doing is unspeakably awful, but an abuser no more represents the Church than a criminal politician represents democracy. [Do I hear an "Amen!"?]  But no, we are told, it’s inherent to Catholicism because the Roman Catholics won’t change with the times. Chronology, however, has nothing to do with it and the last thing the Church should do is change with the times. Fashions, just like bishops or politicians, can be bad. The Church listens to the Papacy and Magisterium, given to Christians by Christ Jesus while He lived and was present here among us.

Christ didn’t leave a bible but a guide and a guard: the pope, the Church, all shaping the faith long before the New Testament was written and available. So it’s not a question of choosing what to believe but choosing to believe. Protestants broke the direct tradition leading from God on Earth and many of their 22,000 denominations understand how a man who is a committed husband and father can also be constantly available to his flock. It’s surely inevitable that he will fail in one or all of those roles. Jesus was terribly politically incorrect when He only made men priests, and in affirming this, all of the direct descendants of St. Peter have similarly offended. But soul-saving religion is not about pleasing a human rights commission. No woman can ever rightfully say, "This is my body, this is my blood," no matter how loud she protests and no matter how many materialists pretend to care about what they mistakenly claim to be equality.  [Do I hear an "Amen!"?]

It’s always stunning to see how some Protestants accuse Catholics of sexism but simultaneously disregard Mary, the Mother of Christ and the most important woman in the history of the world. As for general anti-Catholics, they simply hate the Church for being a mirror that reflects their own failings and hypocrisy.

On a clinically practical level, celibacy has nothing to do with sexual exploitation. The abuse rates inside the Catholic Church are almost precisely the same as those in other Christian denominations, non-Christian religions, education, public service and virtually all institutions. It’s just that when a Catholic priest falls, the sound is oh-so-pleasing to a still vehemently anti-Catholic media and culture.

In spite of very occasional scandals and failings the Church is thriving and it’s this that most angers the chorus of critics. Hardly surprising. It’s been the case for 2,000 years.

-Michael Coren is writing a book titled Why The Catholics Are Right (McClelland & Stewart).

WDTPRS kudos to Michael Coren!

Posted in The Drill, The Last Acceptable Prejudice | Tagged ,
12 Comments

October Maples

From the Laudator:

Richard Wilbur, October Maples, Portland:

The leaves, though little time they have to live,
Were never so unfallen as today,
And seem to yield us through a rustled sieve
The very light from which time fell away.

A showered fire we thought forever lost
Redeems the air. Where friends in passing meet,
They parley in the tongues of Pentecost.
Gold ranks of temples flank the dazzled street.

It is a light of maples, and will go;
But not before it washes eye and brain
With such a tincture, such a sanguine glow
As cannot fail to leave a lasting stain.

So Mary’s laundered mantle (in the tale
Which, like all pretty tales, may still be true),
Spread on the rosemary-bush, so drenched the pale
Slight blooms in its irradiated hue,

They could not choose but to return in blue.

October Maples

October Maples

Posted in My View |
5 Comments