Nice, France: ONE Mass for the whole diocese on Pentecost

UPDATE 0019 GMT 30 May

One of the commenters, below, says that this report is not true.

Scroll down to see his comments.

_____________________

Our friends at Rorate have an entry which has me a little steamed.

Try to wrap your mind around this.  My emphases and comments.

    "’They’ truly desire the demise of the Catholic Church"

     Denis Crouan writing on the site of the Pro Liturgia association:

    Let us state the case clearly and with suitable vocabulary: A certain clergy are perpetuating the degradation of the Church…and consequently the disgust of the Faithful.

    The proof: On Sunday May 31, the Feast of Pentecost, there will be only one Mass offered in Nice for the entire diocese. It will be celebrated at the Palais Nikaïa (a concert hall – Mornac).  [Get that?  ONE MASS in the D. of Nice on PENTECOST.]

    Obviously, the Faithful who will not be assisting at this Mass (one can guess at what the “style” of this “celebration” will be) are invited to pray for all the Catholics of the department.

    Perhaps more telling is the fact that (according to the diocesan website) the Mass will be celebrated by none other than the Apostolic Nuncio.

    Merci à XA au Forum Catholique

Is it possible that this is true?   That someone made a decision that there would be only one Mass in a diocese for Pentecost? 

"But Father! But Father!", you are energetically about to write.  "Don’t you get it?  One Mass?  The birthday of the Church?  All the Christians gathered together and the Spirit descending…"

Blah blah blah

PIFFLE!

One Mass in a whole diocese for PENTECOST??

Will they sell tickets?

Will they dispense the people who can’t fit in the concert hall?

If no one shows up… what will that say?

What a terrible idea.  Is it possible that this is true?

I bet they even came up with a logo and theme music.

Posted in The future and our choices | Tagged , ,
63 Comments

PCED: Clarification on the use of the ancient Ambrosian Rite

PCED: Clarification on the use of the ancient Ambrosian RiteThere has been a very interesting development in regard to the use the older form of the Ambrosian Rite.

My understanding is that priests and laypeople in those regions where the Ambrosian Rite has historically been used have encountered great resistance from authorities who should be supporting their interest in the older form of the Ambrosian Rite, with the 1954 Missale Ambrosianum, as it was before it was reformed (the parallel of the 1962 Missale Romanum).

A priest friend of mine, Fr. Jeffry Moore, serving in the Diocese of Lugano is stationed at Ascona.  He has gotten involved in the matter and has obtained some results.  As a priest of the Diocese Lugano, he belongs to a bi-ritual clergy.  There are many places in the area where the parishes are distinguished as Ambrosian or Roman.  Fr. Moore’s church has the distinction being of both rites.  Altars are designated specifically for the Ambrosian Rite.   His church in the past actually had a different sacristy for the Ambrosian use. 

People in the region are very sensitive about their Ambrosian identity.

Fr. Moore wrote to the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei on 7 January 2009, which was hand delivered, and followed up with a meeting with Card. Castrillon Hoyos on 9 January together with 2 priests from Milan and 2 lay people.

At that time Fr. Moore was told that Summorum Pontificum applies also to the Ambrosian Rite.

Fr. Moore has now received a letter from the Secretary of the Commission , Msgr. Perl, as a follow up.

Fr. Moore asked me to put this up for all to see.

Here is (the author of the original letter to the PCED) Fr. Moore’s translation of that letter from the Italian original:

Reverend Father,

 Your letter of January 7, 2009 has had our attention but is still waiting for a reply.  You express a desire to “receive the comfort of having the approval of the possibility that also your Ambrosian students who ask for it can enjoy the benefits guaranteed by the Holy Father” in the Motu proprio “Summorum Pontificum”.

 While it is true that the Motu proprio of the Holy Father does not expressly cite the Ambrosian rite, it doesn’t exclude the other Latin rites; if the will of the Holy Father asserts for the Roman rite, considering that it is superior in dignity, consequently much more for the other Latin rites, including the Ambrosian rite.

 Wishing the blessings of the Lord on your pedagogical work, I greet you fraternally.

This is important not just because it applies to the Ambrosian Rite, but also for all the other Latin Rites which under law were in use before the reforms.  This would include the Dominican Rite, in which many religious have interest.

UPDATE:

A couple past entries on the issue of the Ambrosian Rite… here and here.

Posted in Brick by Brick, SESSIUNCULA, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM | Tagged
25 Comments

Kicking & Screaming!

There are some things you just can’t make up.

This is in from LA News with my emphases and comments:

Kicking & Screaming!Kicking & Screaming: Journo Dragged From Near Air Force One

By  CHRISTINA HOAG

Updated 9:08 PM PDT, Thu, May 28, 2009

A reporter for a small newspaper was forcibly removed from a press area near Air Force One shortly before President Barack Obama arrived at Los Angeles International Airport to depart California early Thursday.

Airport security officers carried the woman away by the feet and arms as she protested her removal.

She later identified herself as Brenda Lee, a writer for the Georgia Informer in Macon and said she has White House press credentials. The newspaper’s Web site says it is a monthly publication, and a Brenda Lee column is posted on it.

Calls to the newspaper and the White House press office were not immediately returned.

Lee said in a telephone interview with The Associated Press that she wanted to hand Obama a letter urging him "to take a stand for traditional marriage."  [Wait for the irony moment… and set down your beverage NOW… you have been warned….]

She said she asked a Secret Service agent to give the president her letter, but he refused and referred her to a White House staffer. Lee said she refused to give the staffer the letter.

"I said, ‘I’ll take my chances if (the president) comes by here,’" said Lee, who identified herself as a Roman Catholic priestess who lives in Anaheim, Calif. "He became annoyed that I wouldn’t give him the letter."  [I wonder if Joan Chitister will speak out now and say that these sorts of protests are out of line!  I mean…!]

Lee, who was wearing what she described as a cassock, said she protested when she was asked to leave.

"I said, ‘Why are you bothering me?’ They escorted me outside the gate," she said.

She said security officers allowed her to return when she promised she would not yell or wave, but then other officers arrived and told her to leave.

"I said, ‘I’m not leaving,’" she said. "They tried to drag me out." 

Two officers then picked her up and carried her out. An Associated Press photographer photographed the incident.  [PULITZER SUBITO!]

"I was afraid you could see under my clothes," she said, her voice choking up.  [With the ray-gun from the mothership.]

Lee, who said this was the second presidential event she has covered, was later released.  [I can hardly wait for the next one!  Will she replace Helen Thomas, I wonder?]

The incident occurred about 10 minutes before Obama arrived at the airport by helicopter to board Air Force One. He had been in Los Angeles to attend a Democratic National Committee fundraiser in Beverly Hills on Wednesday.  [You would have thought that to be a better venue for this.]

 

So now we finally know what priestesses do after ordination!

Bring on the big puppets!

Posted in Just Too Cool, Lighter fare, SESSIUNCULA |
41 Comments

Successful attacks by the enemy

A reader has sent me a photo taken clandestinely.

This may explain how the enemy maintains that sustained attack on the bird feeders.

This may even explain why I had no coffee beans this morning!

Posted in Lighter fare, SESSIUNCULA, The Feeder Feed |
8 Comments

The feeder

Some quick shots from the feeder.

There have been a lot of woodpeckers in the last few days and many few finches.

This Red-Bellied Woodpecker triumphantly comes up with a peanut.

The feeder

Brown Thrasher.  What a very different eye they have from most of the other birds who visit.

The feeder

They use their beaks to shove the food around until they find what they like.

The feeder

The feeder

This Hairy Woodpecker has driven off an Oriole.

The feeder

Too bad I didn’t have my camera handy as I saw this develop.

Mr. & Mrs. Purple Finch are on a date.  They are doing a little courting.

I saw them clacking their beaks together as the Missus flapped one wing only.

This must be some courting behavior. 

I only got this one shot in before a big woodpecker came in and they took off.

The feeder

And they eat… and eat… and eat…

The feeder

Red-Winged Blackbird proclaims his ownership of my lawn.

The feeder

Posted in SESSIUNCULA, The Feeder Feed |
8 Comments

Fr. Cutie

ALL: I know about Fr. Cutie.  You can stop forwarding e-mail. 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Fr. Cutie

John Allen on Pres. Obama and Miguel Diaz

From the National Catholic Reporter, the ultra-left wing dissenting weekly, the nearly ubiquitous John L. Allen has some obervations about Pres. Obama and future Ambassador Miguel Diaz.

My emphases and comments.

With Diaz nomination, Obama passes major Catholic test  [Passes a… what?  "Catholic" test?  We must discover what this strange claim might mean.]
By John L Allen Jr
Created May 28, 2009

By extending an olive branch to pro-lifers during his commencement address at Notre Dame, President Barack Obama seemed to pass his first major Catholic test. This week, by naming an envoy to the Vatican who doesn’t have a public track record of challenging the bishops on abortion, he’s in effect passed his second.  [Hang on.  I cannot pass over a claim that what Pres. Obama did at Notre Dame was "extend an olive branch" unless the wood of that branch was part of a Trojan Horse.  That was nothing less than subversion.  What "test" was he passing?  Does anyone think the President’s little suggestion of a "sensible conscience clause" was truly an irenic gesture?  See Novak and my own comments elsewhere.]

For extra credit, he demonstrated a good grasp of the changing demographics of American Catholicism by appointing a Hispanic. [Pres. Obama knows a voting block when he sees it.] Measured against what one might have expected from a pro-choice Democrat [VP Biden] and a non-Catholic, Obama’s Catholic report card so far appears to look pretty good.

On Wednesday, the White House announced the appointment of Miguel Diaz, 45, an associate professor of theology at the College of St. Benedict and St. John’s University, as the ambassador of the United States to the Holy See. Born in Cuba, Diaz and his family left when he was eight, eventually settling in Miami. He has working-class roots; his father was a waiter and his mother a seamstress. Assuming Diaz is confirmed by the Senate, [And this is the wind driving the many gears of the mill these days…] his first major task ought to be arranging a meeting between Obama and Pope Benedict XVI around the time of the G-8 meeting in Italy this July.

Early Vatican reaction seems positive. Archbishop Pietro Sambi, the pope’s ambassador to the United States, called the Diaz appointment “an excellent choice of a representative who knows both the United States and the Catholic Church very well,” in an interview on Thursday with Italy’s ANSA news service.

Sambi added that as a Cuban-America immigrant, Diaz also “is a good representative of Spanish-speaking Catholics” in America.

That’s not to say, of course, that the choice is utterly uncontroversial. [Safe to say.] Diaz served on a Catholic advisory board for Obama during the 2008 campaign, and recently signed a letter in support of the nomination of Kathleen Sebelius as Health and Human Services Secretary despite her record of favoring abortion rights. One conservative Catholic media outlet thus styled the Diaz appointment “the first payback of the Obama administration to Catholics who have been unconditionally supporting his policies and appointments.” The fact that the usual Catholic suspects in the pro-Obama camp immediately hailed the appointment has also stoked concern in more conservative circles.  [True.  If they are in favor of the appointment, something must be wrong.]

Yet Diaz is described by colleagues as broadly pro-life, and in any event he has never been among the most prominent Catholic apologists for a “soft” position on abortion. ["Broadly" pro-life.  Is that the right position for a Catholic?  "Broadly" could mean just about anything.] In that sense, no one in the Vatican is likely to style the appointment as provocative. [And even if it was not seen in a good light, some in the Secretariat of State would  set theological concerns aside for the sake of a meeting in July.] (Rome may have other concerns, chief among them the extent to which a fairly obscure theology professor from Minnesota is likely to carry serious political weight inside the Obama administration. That remains to be seen.)  [Why is that, Mr. Allen, because fly-over Minnesota doesn’t count for anything important?]

Some Catholics may also be alarmed by Diaz’s fondness for Latin American liberation theology, [D’ya think?] which became a bête noir of the Catholic right during the 1970s and ’80s due to its affinities with Marxism and class struggle. References to figures such as Gustavo Gutíerrez and Ignacio Ellacuría run through Diaz’s writings, and one news outlet referred to Diaz as a “Cuban liberation theologian” in its headline. [I wonder if that is fair.]  For the record, that’s not really accurate. In his writings, Diaz distinguishes between the “preferential option for the poor” in Latin America and the “preferential option for culture” in Hispanic theology in the United States, focused on the survival of Latino/a identity.  [Hmmm.  I must observe that Joseph Ratzinger uses some principles of Liberation Theology as starting points for a liturgial theology in his A New Song For The Lord.  Think about it: Christ is Lord and Liberator.  This is what Christ, the true Actor, is also in liturgy.  So, a citation of a liberation theologian doesn’t deserve an automatic censure.]

Anyway, Diaz is nobody’s idea of a radical. [Well… Mr. Allen needs to read the views of some of the people who comment here…. but I digress…] He’s never defended armed revolution, or celebrated a “church from below” in opposition to the hierarchy. His accent has been largely on the importance of community, especially in light of the struggles of immigrant families. In one paper he coined the phrase, “outside the survival of community there is no salvation,” a play on the traditional theological maxim extra ecclesiam nulla salus (“outside the church there is no salvation”).

Looking down the line, the key question is how Diaz’s term in Rome might shape up. [Indeed… inter alia many people become more Catholic after spending some time in Rome…] In that light, the distinctive thing about being the Ambassador to the Holy See is that it’s very much an “ideas” job, which means that it’s better suited for an academic than many other diplomatic assignments one could imagine. The ambassador doesn’t have to worry about trade relationships, security questions, visa policies, and so on — the nuts-and-bolts matters that loom large in most diplomatic postings. The embassy also doesn’t have a large staff or internal bureaucracy. As a result, the ambassador has considerable scope to think outside the box, at least by the normal standards of overseas diplomacy.

The Diaz appointment would seem to open the door to partnerships with the Vatican in at least four areas.

…

I will let you read the rest over there and come back to discuss it here.

The four areas are Immigration, Cuba, North-South Solidarity, Changing Demographics.

Mr. Allen, a friend of mine, is usually an asute observer and thought-provoking analyst.  He is, IMO, dead wrong about what Pres. Obama did at Notre Dame.  But his first look at Miguel Diaz is interesting.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA, The Drill | Tagged , , , ,
41 Comments

Thanks to readers

Some thanks are do to readers.
Thanks to readers
Thanks to readersFirst, JP of CA sent a USB hub which has allowed me more easily to connect several webcams for the sake of the Z-Cam.  This hub actually works.  With the other hub, for one reason or another, more than two cams would lock everything up. 

JK of OH sent two delightful books.  The Wine of Certitude: A Literary Biography of Ronald Knox by David Rooney.  Also, JK sent The Death of a Pope by Piers Paul Read.

I have read the Evelyn Waugh’s biography The Life of the Right Reverend Ronald Knox Fellow of Trinity College, Oxford, and Pronotary Apostolic to His Holiness Pope Pius XII.  I am quite interested in what Rooney has to say.  Also I have heard some good things about the novel, a thriller.

I also received, The Death of a Pope by Piers Paul Read, published by Ignatius Press.

Thanks to readersI am also very grateful to those of you who have sent donations via the donation button.  They are very helpful, especially for the continual feeding of the winged eating machines, who greedily descend day in and day out.

Thanks to readers

Posted in SESSIUNCULA, The Feeder Feed |
3 Comments

Ugly as sin

"Beauty is in the eye of the beholder", it is said.

Rubbish.

Beauty beauty cannot be separated from truth.

Some things are simply ugly, both by design and by intention.  They are ugly because they are deeply false.

Some "artists" hate their subjects, and what they produce reflects that sentiment.  Think of the art of Francis Bacon.

On other occasions, I have sadly had to write about what is going on at Stefansdom, the Cathedral of Vienna and in that Archdiocese.

Here is another sad establishment.

Don’t watch this unless you are not easily angered.

Here is the text on the e-mail which alerted me to this:

On May 27 the rector of St. Stephen’s Cathedral in Vienna blessed a controversial bust of Sr Restituta Kafka who was murdered by the Nazis during Second World War and declared blessed by Pope John Paul II.  The bust was produced by the Austrian artist Alfred Hrdlicka. He is an atheist and describes himself as a "Stalinist". Hrdlicka was personally commissioned by Cardinal Christoph Schoenborn of Vienna to produce the sculpture.

I just don’t get it.  Why would someone pay for this, much less bless it, much less display it, much less not then prosecute the man who made it for a hate crime.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
72 Comments

A notice posted on the doors of a church

From a priest reader:

Making a visit at a church near my residence, my attention was drawn to a notice posted on the main inner doors, which I reproduce below.

Since the greater the number of people involved in distributing Holy Communion, the greater the likelihood of spreading disease, it is reasonable to conclude that the employment of Extraordinary Ministers of the Eucharist will also cease until further notice: one wonders why this is not mentioned…

SWINE INFLUENZE [sic] NOTICE

While Swine Influenza is not yet a problem in Australia;

1. Holy Communion will be distributed only under ONE KIND until further notice.

2. Those people who currently Communion [sic] on the tongue could think about receiving on the hand.

3. This is to reduce the likelihood of spreading disease within our Community this winter.

A good question is raised: the usually unnecessary employment of many Ministers of Communion would increase the risk of spreading disease, right?

On a side note, when I was distributing Communion at Sunday Masses last week, at a parish where very many people kneel at the rial and receive on the tongue (what a blessing), hundreds of Communions, there was precisely zero contact between my fingers and any tongue.  It was more reverent, there was far less risk of profanation, it was faster without being rushed.

Posted in Mail from priests |
27 Comments