The ultra-left-wing National Catholic Reporter has an editorial in which they reveal their darkest fear:
…the goalposts have shifted in the U.S. episcopacy in the past decade – and they have swerved in a decidedly rightward tilt on both the ecclesial and political spectrums .
As you read this mournful baying of desperation, keep in mind that the NCR editors know they have lost the Catholic identity debate.
Catholics cannot be pro-abortion. NCR and their pack are still weakly proposing we can be soft on a politician’s pro-abortion agenda if they are doing other good social justice things. They claim this will really result in a reduction of the number of abortions anyway.
They know now that they have lost that argument because it is being made clearer and clearer from pulpits and in the blogosphere and press that Catholics cannot support abortion. We can differ on how to help the poor but we cannot compromise on the fundamental human right: the right to life precedes the right to liberty and the pursuit of happiness.
What follows in this long NCR editorial is a demonstration of desperation. Because they have lost the Catholic part of the argument they now fall back on the only weapon they have left: party politics.
They seek to paint anyone, any bishop especially, who strays their progressivist dogma as shills of the Republican party. This talking point has been actively distributed also through party operatives. They, and not the bishops who oppose the decision of Notre Dame to bestow an honor on the aggressively pro-abortion politicians, are the true party operatives.
Be patient and read through this editorial, which manifests dissent from Catholic doctrine on abortion.
Read it as if it were part a coroner’s inquest on the death of a man by drowning.
Jesuit Fr. John Langan (see story [1]) [see my take] is an exceptionally clear thinker. He makes the necessary distinctions seem obvious. [I agree that he is a clear thinker. I agree that he makes distinctions, which is the mark of any good teacher. However, I think he is by his distinctions, "nuances", leading the reader off the path and into the dark wood.]
“The bishops are certainly right to condemn the moral evil of abortion and to warn us against the individualism, selfishness and greed which have had such a devastating effect on American culture and family life as well as on our financial institutions,” Langan, Cardinal Joseph Bernardin professor of Catholic social thought at Georgetown University, told a Capitol Hill symposium last month. “But if they think they make their witness more credible and more effective by developing a quasi-excommunication of the Democratic Party [emphasis added] and by aligning themselves with politicians who think that combining pro-life slogans with American chauvinism and exercising American military power without regard to international criticism constitutes an adequate response to evil in the world, they are sadly mistaken.” [Two things. The bishops he mentions are NOT criticizing President Obama, or Notre Dame, for reasons of party politics. This is a key talking point of the left and of the Dems themselves. Remember that letter from a Democratic Party operative I posted? That letter included: "It is good to frame the debate that this ND "scandal" is about supporting the Republican platform’s view of life issues." The bishops are not politicizing this, but those who are partisan supporters of the pro-abortion President clearly are.]
Langan hits the nail squarely. [Driving it more deeply into the coffin of the Catholic pro-life cause. I don’t think that is his intention, but it is the effect.]
The proximate cause of the latest anti-Obama tirade among the Catholic conservative cognoscenti, including many U.S. bishops, is the University of Notre Dame’s invitation to the president to deliver the May 17 commencement address. Most Americans, [For NCR, Kmeic Catholics, etc., the numbers are more important than the actual principles.] and most Catholics for that matter, have paid the brouhaha little attention — they have other things on their minds. [So what?]
A story with legs
But among the professional Catholic crowd — those like the editors of this newspaper and activists left, right and center [an interesting phrase…. usually "activist" is synonymous with the left…] who make their livings tracking and commentating on the vicissitudes of American Catholic life — this is, as they say in the news business, a story with legs.
Say the conservatives: How dare America’s premier Catholic university provide a prestigious platform and an honorary degree to the leader of a political party that embraces the “culture of death.” Obama, we are told repeatedly, “is the most pro-choice president in history.” [NO! See what they did here with that phrase "the leader of a political party"? Once again they are framing the issue by partisan politics. The opposition to the decision to bestow an honor on Pres. Obama comes from his aggressive pro-abortion agenda, not his political party membership.]
Say the liberals: Kudos to Notre Dame for engaging the president and his administration, which stands with us on so many issues and appears poised to make abortion reduction a genuine commitment even as it rejects steps to criminalize the practice. [Again… notice how the writer soft-peddles the core issue along the lines laid out by Kmiec, etc. Pres. Obama is really pro-life! See? Also, NCR is trying to convince you that Notre Dame is engaging the President. The bishops and others who have opposed Notre Dames decision would not have done so if it truly were a matter of "engaging" the President. Notre Dame is bestowing an honor on him.]
We side, perhaps not surprisingly, with those who welcome the president to Notre Dame. [Dog bites man. Film at 11.] The Catholic community should engage [watch for this word "engage". This is one of the ways they dodge the real issue.] the president and his administration, laud it where appropriate, challenge it when it falls short. That’s not only good church practice, it’s our obligation as citizens.
Yes, there will be protests and the like in South Bend, Ind. (as there are when any president visits a college campus). One extremist Catholic group, the misnamed “Cardinal Newman Society,” [so says the extremist paper the National Catholic Reporter. Remember… for the ultra-left there are no extremists except those of the right.] claims hundreds of thousands of signatures on a petition protesting Obama’s appearance. (There’s money in outrage, apparently: Witness the society’s recent fundraising efforts tied to the petition. That e-mail appeal notes, “If necessary, the Cardinal Newman Society will go broke to help stop the Notre Dame scandal” — fat chance that — even as it urges recipients to “send … even a small (tax-deductible) contribution.”) [My my… that smacks of bitter jealousy.]
Nevertheless, we anticipate that the president will be warmly received at Notre Dame (particularly by the graduating seniors) [and the leftist Catholic press will be sure to show their adoring faces and record their cheers as if that is evidence in support of their position] and will use the opportunity to speak directly to the nation’s Catholic community. [What a thrill for Catholics. Actually, in most of the conversations I have had lately, the consensus is that Pres. Obama probably sees this as a perfect occasion to drive a wedge between poorly-formed weak-identity Catholics and their bishops.]
The larger question, however, remains: How have we gotten to the point where an influential and vocal number of Catholics use the occasion of a presidential address on a college campus to vilify not only the invitee but also those who invited him? [Sorry, but expression of opposition to a pro-abortion agenda and pandering to political power is not to "vilify".]
The answer to that is provided by Langan. The Obama Notre Dame speech is simply the latest occasion (and the effort dates back more than a decade) for partisan [there it is again… they keep hammering that this is because of party politics] conservative Catholics to issue a “quasi-excommunication of the Democratic Party.” In other words, it is mostly about politics.
Some quick history: In September 2003 high-ranking members of the administrative committee of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops met with some leading conservative Catholics, including the then head of “Catholic Outreach” at the Republican National Committee. By July 2004, by which time pro-choice Catholic John Kerry had secured the Democratic presidential nomination, the full body of bishops approved a statement in which they said they would not countenance providing a “platform” or “honor” to pro-choice politicians and activists, or to those otherwise at odds with church teaching on issues such as gay marriage, at Catholic venues. [Right. The opposition was to their positions not the party.]
The bishops’ ban, to say the least, lacked nuance, ["Bless me ordained minister, I have lacked nuance." What imbeciles those nuance-lacking bishops were!] making no distinction between politicians and others who would use a church-affiliated venue to promote policies condemned by the bishops, and those invited to speak on unrelated public policy issues. [Huh?] Further, the policy failed to take into account that the bishops have little practical say over the administration of most Catholic universities, which are typically overseen by boards of directors made up largely of laypeople. [And when will Ex corde Ecclesiae be implemented? The problem is that most of our Catholic institutions have slowly but surely been alienated from a clear relationship to the Catholic Church. They are more CINO than Catholic.]
Who gets a pass
The policy, moreover, was largely impossible to enforce. When Vice President Dick Cheney spoke at The Catholic University of America in Washington in 2005 to address the question of Social Security reform, few took note that he was opposed to a church-supported constitutional amendment banning gay marriage, to say nothing of his advocacy of the “intrinsic evil” of torture. [Is that an accurate description of his position? Does the former VP advocate an "intrinsic evil"?] He got a pass. [The question is: Did the former VP receive an honor at that event? Or was CUA engaging the former VP? There is a difference… let’s call it a nuance…. between inviting a person to speak and bestowing an honor.]
Likewise, when President George W. Bush spoke at St. Vincent College in Latrobe, Pa., at its commencement, few if any objections were raised to the president’s position on embryonic stem cell research (his administration was at odds with the bishops in this area), or the president’s support for exceptions to a total ban on abortion, or his failure to call for a repeal of Roe v. Wade. (There were some protestors, students and professors mostly, who objected to the Bush record on war and torture.) [Did the former President receive an honorary doctorate in law at that event?]
Still, the ban on honors and platforms provided support to bishops and others who would use it to make partisan attacks and arguments.
“We know … that adherents of one political party would place us squarely on the road to suicide as a people,” wrote Rockford, Ill., Bishop Thomas Doran in 2006. [What is he writing in 2009?] Said Doran: “No doubt, we shall soon outstrip the Nazis in doing human beings to death.”
Wrote papal biographer and influential conservative pundit George Weigel: “The Republican Party is a more secure platform from which Catholics can work on the great issues of the day than a party in thrall to abortion ‘rights,’ gay activism, and a utilitarian approach to the biotech future that is disturbingly reminiscent of Brave New World.” [So? I cannot see how Weigel’s comment are either a) wrong or b) relevant here.]
Just last month, Robert W. Finn, bishop of the Kansas City-St. Joseph, Mo., diocese, declared before an audience of Missouri and Kansas antiabortion advocates, “We are at war!” The combatants in this struggle “may be atheists or agnostics, or of any religion, including Christian or Catholic” who oppose the church’s efforts to make abortion illegal. (Finn heads a diocese where a favored parish recently offered a Mass for which the intention was the “conversion of Barack Obama.”) [And that is wrong… why? Also, wasn’t that for his conversion on the issue of abortion?]
In his speech, Finn noted that “those who vied for the leadership of our country last November offered Americans a clear choice in this regard,” [Remember… NCR wants you to think that that was an endorsement of the Republican candidate. It wasn’t. It was merely an observation that one candidate is the most aggressive pro-abortion politician we have in the public eye to date.] which might come as news to those who thought John McCain’s priorities, whatever his political posturing, did not include overturning Roe v. Wade. In fact, McCain famously waffled on the issue during his many years in the Senate and, according to testimony from his pro-life congressional colleagues, frequently stood in the way of legislative efforts to restrict abortion.
Litmus tests [Which are bad.]
Earlier this month, Scranton, Pa., Bishop Robert Martino continued his strange crusade against his state’s junior senator, Democrat Robert Casey. Casey, with a largely pro-life voting record, is slated to give the commencement address at King’s College in Wilkes Barre.
Martino’s litmus test this time was Casey’s vote in favor of the nomination of Kathleen Sebelius to head the Department of Health and Human Services. “I do not believe [Casey] has the moral stature to stand before the graduates of a Catholic college to address them about their futures and the challenges they will face when on the most important issue of the day — the sanctity of human life — he cannot muster the courage to oppose the pro-abortion agenda which is currently being promoted in Washington,” said Martino. [And neither can the National Catholic Reporter.]
It did not seem to matter to Martino that the country might need a HHS chief in the midst of a pandemic flu outbreak or that, whatever Sebelius’ merits, the pro-choice Obama administration would have a pro-choice HHS department head. [So… the country "needs" a head of HSS and therefore we should just go ahead and install her?]
Meanwhile, New Orleans Bishop Alfred Hughes says he will boycott commencement at that city’s Xavier University because the featured speaker is Donna Brazile. Brazile, a New Orleans native who has worked tirelessly to help the city rebuild after Hurricane Katrina, is most certainly pro-choice, but is also known for urging Democrats to be less doctrinaire on the issue. [No one will say that her efforts to help New Orleans weren’t good. But those efforts aren’t the point. Oppositon to a person for his or her position on abortion does not mean that those who offer that opposition think that everything the person does is worthless. But the point is that if you cannot uphold a person’s right to be born, the other rights human beings have really fade into irrelevance.]
In Catholic Democratic Party circles it is frequently said that only a small number, a handful really, [at last count more than 70 diocesan ordinaries issued statements of opposition to Notre Dame. Is that a handful?] of conservative bishops are banging the drum for the Republican Party. [This is the point of the editorial. They are desperate for you to be convinced that the bishops are opposing the Notre Dame scandal because of party poltics. That is their main talking point.] And yet, more than 60 U.S. bishops have expressed opposition to the Notre Dame Obama speech. [Isn’t it more?] Why is it assumed by progressives that most of those who remain silent do so because they support a more liberal line?
No, the goalposts have shifted in the U.S. episcopacy in the past decade — and they have swerved in a decidedly rightward tilt on both the ecclesial and political spectrums. [And so we get to the real sore spot, their dark fear.]
This is how they wrap up their case…. read it again:
… the goalposts have shifted in the U.S. episcopacy in the past decade — and they have swerved in a decidedly rightward tilt on both the ecclesial and political spectrums.
And again, aloud …
… the goalposts have shifted in the U.S. episcopacy in the past decade — and they have swerved in a decidedly rightward tilt on both the ecclesial and political spectrums.
As that democrat party operative wrote in a letter:
It is good to frame the debate that this ND "scandal" is about supporting the Republican platform’s view of life issues.


Welcome to another rapid installment of What Does the Prayer Really Sound Like?




















