New Archbishop of Oakland

We are all very happy about the news that Oakland has a new Archbishop in His Excellency Most Reverend Salvatore Cordileone (NB: could there be a better name for a bishop?  Literally "Savior Lionheart").

What I find interesting is this photo sent by a reader of His Excellency in the not so common mantelletta.

New Archbishop of Oakland

Bishops use it, and so do judges of the Roman tribunals and canons.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
55 Comments

McInerny on Notre Dame’s “vulgar lust”

This is in The Catholic Thing written by the gentleman scholar Ralph McInerny, for many years a professor at the University of Notre Dame.

He tackles the problem of the University of Notre Dame’s invitation to President Obama.

My emphases and comments.

The Catholic Thing
COLUMNS
Monday, 23 March 2009 
Is Obama Worth a Mass?    [A allusion is to the reconciliation of the Bourbon King Henry IV after his Protestantizing apostacy: "Paris is worth a Mass".]
By Ralph McInerny
   
Now that the abortion president [I think it might be fair to beef that up as "the Abortion President"] will be honored and feted and listened to at Notre Dame’s commencement, the question becomes, who will say the commencement Mass?  [Indeed.]

The University of Notre Dame has officially and with much self-satisfaction invited President Barack Obama to address its 2009 graduates and to receive an honorary law degree. Not to put too fine a point on it, this is a deliberate thumbing of the collective nose at the Roman Catholic Church to which Notre Dame purports to be faithful. Faithful? Tell it to Julian the Apostate.  [I believe they are feeling the pressure of their contumacious move and have therefore also offered something to Mary Ann Glendon, far far more deserving.]

That someone who procures or advocates abortion thereby excludes himself from communion with the Church has been clear doctrine all along, and increasingly bishops have found the courage to tell those Catholic politicians who are the great enablers of abortion legislation that they cannot receive Holy Communion. Is it any worse to celebrate such a politician as Barack Obama? So where does that put ND President Father Jenkins? He can hardly say Mass without receiving the body, blood, soul, and divinity of Our Lord Jesus Christ, so doubtless he will recuse himself and have someone else say the Mass. [A very good question.  If Fr. Jenkins says Mass publicly for this even, there could be a risk of scandal.] But to whom will he go? All his cohorts must come under the same cloud as he. Perhaps the pastor of the president’s erstwhile church in Chicago will be invited to harangue the assembled graduates and parents and faculty – those who can bring themselves to attend commencement this year. Why not? [Indeed.  What was his name?  Jeremiah Wright.  Or perhaps the strange Catholic priest who was so much in the news, Pfleger.]

Perhaps because, having been reminded of the sermons he heard over the years, Barack Obama distanced himself, as they say, from the fiery orator at whose feet he sat for decades. [After all, Paris vaut bien une messe!]  In this, whatever his motives, he has perhaps pointed a way for the Notre Dame administrators to redeem themselves. Perhaps they are unaware of Obama’s record on abortion. Perhaps they have not been paying attention to what he has already done as president. On being reminded of all this, and mindful of the parlous position this puts them into vis-a-vis the Church if they thus celebrate the president, perhaps they will as publicly rescind their invitation as they have issued it? Don’t count on it.

For one whose fifty-four year career as a member of the Notre Dame faculty is coming to an end this June, it is a bitter thing to reflect on the 2009 commencement speaker. It is of course convenient to have an excuse to absent oneself from the festivities. Listening to commencement addresses is the penalty that graduates must pay to receive their diplomas. One can count memorable commencement speeches on the cuticle of one finger. They are ceremonial occasions that will be little remembered and less celebrated. One has groaned at previous selections, but the invitation to Barack Obama is far from being the usual effort of the university to get into warm contact with the power figures of the day.  [read: "shameless pandering"] It is an unequivocal abandonment of any pretense at being a Catholic university.  [which is worse than shameless pandering, actually] And it is in sad continuity with decades of waffling that have led with seeming inevitability to it.

No event was more crucial for Catholic universities than the infamous 1967 Land O’Lakes statement in which the assembled presidents of Catholic institutions declared their freedom from the supposedly baleful influence of Catholic orthodoxy. They would continue to call themselves Catholic, but the definition of the term was constantly under construction. And this by institutions whose task is decidedly not to define what Catholicism is. And now we have come to the point where the University of Notre Dame is publicly excluding itself from allegiance to and acceptance of one of the most fundamental of Christian moral truths, mentioned explicitly in the Didache and again and again over the centuries. [Dr. McInerny writes with the blistering clarity of a magnifying glass.] Abortion is an essentially evil act, both from the viewpoint of natural morality and from the explicit teaching the Church. There is no way in which an individual, a politician or an institution can finesse that fact.

By inviting Barack Obama as commencement speaker, Notre Dame is telling the nation that the teaching of the Catholic church on this fundamental matter can be ignored. Lip service may be paid to the teaching on abortion, but it is no impediment to upward mobility, to the truly vulgar lust to be welcomed into secular society, whether on the part of individuals or institutions.  [Bravo. Perfect.]
Some years ago, Archbishop Michael Miller in his Vatican capacity as overseer of Catholic education, said in an address at Notre Dame [!] that the Holy Father was considering prohibiting the use of “Catholic” by institutions whose behavior contradicts that use. By inviting Barack Obama to be the 2009 commencement speaker, Notre Dame has forfeited its right to call itself a Catholic university. It invites an official rebuke. May it come.  [I suspect that the present Prefect of the Congregation for Catholic Education, Card. Grocholeski, will do nothing.  That is what ND is betting on.  Then the silence from the Holy See will be proclaimed as a precedent, even an approval of their contumacious invitation.]

Ralph McInerny is a writer of philosophy, fiction, and cultural criticism, who has taught at Notre Dame since 1955.

Thank you, Professor McInerny.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
75 Comments

QUAERITUR: liturgical purple

A reader sends:

I know you have made the explanation clear for the true liturgical color of "rose," but could you please give a brief lesson on the true liturgical color of "violet"? It seems when the seasons of Advent and Lent arrive, we see all different shades and hues of violet or purple.  How did the color of "Roman violet" evolve into "purple?"

Roman violet or "Roman purple" is violaceus. 

Part of our problem with understanding liturgical purple is the loose use of the term "purple".  "Purple" can be all sorts of different colors, ranging between the reddish and the bluish.  On the other hand violaceus or "Roman Purple" is in modern times considered to be a specific color on the reddish side close to the color of the gemstone amethyst.  But historically our colors varied.

Remember that dies for cloth were obtained from plants and sea animals.  The famous case of the ancient world is the fabulously expensive purple dye, "Tyrian purple", made from the murex, a sea critter who totes around a spiny seashell.  Muricidae are unfortunate enough to have a tiny gland producing a purple goo endowed with a marvelous staining quality.  The difficulty of finding the little creatures, which were best fished in the “dog days” when the “Dog Star” Sirius was high during the summer, and the sheer quantity needed to make enough dye to matter, made purple cloth very expensive indeed.  The best and most famous was from shores of Tyre. 

The word “purple” itself came in time to signify anything expensive or precious.  In Jerome’s Vulgate you can look up spoils of battle in 1 Maccabees 4:23 for a reference to purpura marina. The Roman senators were distinguished by a band of purple, called a laticlavium, on their toga praetexta.   Purple robes were eventually worn only by Emperors.  In the Church the reddish-orange color worn by cardinals is today still called in Italian “porpora sacra” for in earlier times they were a more purple hue.  Today, the Cardinal’s "sacred purple" is closer to scarlet.

I digress.  Back to the "amethyst" color of "Roman purple".  In ancient times the naturalist C. Plinius Secundus (Pliny the Eldar  +AD 79) speaks of amethyst as a tint, "amethystum inebriatur Tyrio" (cf.  9, 41, 65, § 139).

So, Roman purple is really a color, through what has been take to be "purple" has shifted through the centuries.  If memory serves the old Sacred Congregation for Rites defined a specific shade of violaceus, "Roman purple", with a sample of fabric as the standard or point of reference.

So our violaceus gets translated into the obvious "violet", which is a real and specific color as well as a loosely used term for a darker color, and also into "purple", which is also a loose term for a range of colors from the reddish to the bluish.  Some people prefer to say that purple is on the redder side and violet is on the bluer side.

This is how some folks want to say that during Lent we should use the reddish Roman purple, which true violaceus and during Advent we should use the bluish purple, or a shade so close to blue that it really is blue.

I think if you were going to be picky or a purist, a true liturgically psiloligical doryphore, we would want to be use "Roman purple".

In any event, just as in the case of Roman rose or rosacea the term violaceus is a precise color, but the term is loose.  Purple or violet has drifted around the spectrum over the centuries and we shouldn’t be overly picky.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

QUAERITUR: more than one TLM on Sundays and feasts

A received a question from a reader about the number of TLMs which can be celebrated in a parish on a Sunday or feast.

In order to preserve anonymity, I will simply rephrase it.

Context: A parish where the TLM is celebrated regularly. The priest – otherwise friendly to the TLM – states that there can only be one celebration of the TLM in the parish on a day because Summorum Pontificum 5. § 2. says:

§ 2. Celebratio secundum Missale B. Ioannis XXIII locum habere potest diebus ferialibus; dominicis autem et festis una etiam celebratio huiusmodi fieri potest. … § 2.  Celebration according to the Missal of Bl. John XXIII can take place on weekdays; on Sunday, however, and feasts there can be also one celebration of this kind.

QUAERITUR: Does this mean that there can be only literally one celebration of Holy Mass with the 1962MR in a parish on a Sunday or feast?  Does this mean that – even if the pastor wants to put an additional celebration in the schedule in a stable way – he may not because of Summorum Pontificum 5. § 2?

 

RESPONDITUR: The intent of Summorum Pontificum is clear.  The TLM is to be made available to those who request it reasonably.  If there is great enough interest in the TLM to merit more than one Mass, there can be more than one placed in the schedule in a stable way. 

However, Summorum Pontificum is clear that there must be adequate provisions made for those who prefer to attend Mass in the Ordinary Form lest they be deprived of their rights. 

I have reason to believe that were a parish priest to write to the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei he would receive this same answer.

There are other issues to consider.  Since the Holy Father speaks of how young people are interested in the older form of Mass, and that his hope is that there will be mutual enrichment of the two forms of the Roman Rite, it makes perfect sense that there have to be adequate numbers of celebrations of Holy Mass with the 1962MR – in parishes – to satisfy these ends.  Not only do parish priests have to respond to requests for the older Mass, parish priests ought to make sure their folks know the older form through adequate exposure.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
7 Comments

What rose… isn’t

"I said rose… ROSE…."

What rose... isn't

Still… it is good to see Laetare observed in a special way.

And I guess there are roses that color, after all.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
47 Comments

Get z updates quickly

Get z updates quicklyDon’t forget to follow Fr. Z on

TWITTER: @fatherz

PLURK: fatherz

I do that facebook thing too, but it leaves me scratching my head.

Also… I don’t answer my skype calls for wdtprs but I listen to voicemail and sometimes use the really interesting ones in my PODCAzTs.  (Check out the last one, btw.) 
Get z updates quickly
Get z updates quickly

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
3 Comments

SOMETHING BIG with a positive twist

About 100 people have sent me a note about the Bishop of Killala in Ireland being told by the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei that,  nooooo…. he really can’t prevent the implementation of Summorum Pontificum.

I posted on this a couple days ago.

It has a sort of positive title, I know. 

Maybe some readers didn’t pay as much attention.

You might want to take a look!  It’s pretty interesting!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
9 Comments

“… perfecisti laudem…”

After I posted my request for good news, a reader sent this e-mail:

Reverend Father,

As regards both your request for good news and the recent discussion about ways of receiving Communion:

I teach Confirmation class at my parish, mostly using the Baltimore Catechism.

Today one of my best students, a terribly sweet 14-year-old girl, engaged me with 20 minutes of questions about the best way to receive Communion.  She asked about kneeling to receive and told me all about her distaste for unnecessary EMHCs, intinction by the laity, and the laxity of many children about their religion after they receive First Communion.  Perhaps her best quote: "I watch all those people receiving in their hands… I just think, what ARE you doing?" 

It struck me again how beautifully the Church’s traditional practices correspond to the universal, innate needs of our human nature.  She didn’t need any instruction from me to realize that these were the right things to do; in holy simplicity, she just got it.  Ex ore infantium perfecisti laudem.

Kid by kid, folks.

Posted in Brick by Brick, Just Too Cool |
14 Comments

My Roman rose (rosacea) vestments

My rose vestments.  It is a classic Roman set.

Ironically, they were given to me by an ultra-dissenter, once actually disciplined by the CDF.

He was getting rid of old stuff.

My Roman rose (rosacea) vestments

My Roman rose (rosacea) vestments

My Roman rose (rosacea) vestments

Posted in Just Too Cool, My View |
25 Comments

Blackfen’s Rose Vestments

Mulier Fortis has sent some images of the inaugural appearance of the solemn rosacea set at the mighty parish of Blackfen, that locus of terror for the progressivist Tabletites.  His Hermeneuticalness, Fr. Timothy Fingan is celebrant.

A good view of the cope.

Those of you who helped WDTPRS to "pound Fr. Finigan", helped with these vestments.

Blackfen's Rose Vestments

The humeral view is on the subdeacon to the right.

Blackfen's Rose Vestments

The humeral view on the subdeacon as he holds the paten.

Blackfen's Rose Vestments

Blackfen's Rose Vestments

An action shot: the genuflection during the Last Gospel.

Blackfen's Rose Vestments

I still think that tablets of the Decalogue should be applied to the back.

Posted in Brick by Brick |
10 Comments