Irish Augustinian priest slimes Pope Benedict in the press

The Pope’s enemies are crawling out from the dens in order to attack the Pope.  The braying and baying is getting more organized.

In the 13 Feb. IrishTimes.com we find this attack on the Pope

My emphases and comments.

Friday, February 13, 2009 
Holocaust-denying bishop’s rehabilitation is ‘crowning disgrace’ of Benedict’s career

PATSY McGARRY, Religious Affairs Correspondent

THE ATTEMPTED rehabilitation [The first problem is what on earth "rehabilitation" means.  If it really is "rehabilitation", wouldn’t that be a good thing?  But the writer is probably like many journalists who neither understands much about the Church nor really thinks forgiveness or mercy is a good thing.  Once you are tarred, you can never be a good person again.  That is so common in the press.] by the Vatican of Holocaust-denying bishop Richard Williamson has been described as “the crowning disgrace of Pope Benedict’s career” by controversial Augustinian priest Fr Iggy O’Donovan.  [We could tell you more about Iggy, and might before this is done.]

He has also said that change initiated by Vatican II in the Catholic Church has become “a debacle”.  [He got that right, but not in the same way I think.]

Announced 50 years ago, Vatican II, “this noble venture”, was now “on life support”. [the term "drama queen" comes to mind]  “Almost from day one insidious attempts were made to undermine conciliar reform,” he wrote in an Augustinian newsletter.  [So… does this position have some official support of Iggy’s province?] “If anything illustrates this latter point it is the recent announcement, on the 50th anniversary of the convocation of the council, of the lifting of the excommunication of the bishops illicitly ordained by Archbishop Lefebvre.”

In 2006 Fr O’Donovan was bound to silence [not being very silent, I see] and removed from a teaching post in Rome by the Vatican after he concelebrated an Easter Sunday Mass in Drogheda with local Church of Ireland rector Rev Michael Graham.

“We are now at a juncture where Rome demands total conformity with papal ideas and ideals in all things and not merely in those which are essential to the unity of Christian and Catholic faith,” he said.  [This guy is completely confused.  The point is that Rome is emphasizing that there can be various views.]

“That is all very well but when the Holy Father is ‘accident prone’ (as the present incumbent is) the potential for damage to the church is incalculable. “The recent case of the rehabilitation of … Richard Williamson is a prime example of this.” 

President Barack Obama had “been quick to come out and admit he ‘screwed up’” in proposing Tom Daschle as health secretary.

“In the case of Williamson Pope Benedict certainly ‘screwed up’ and must be as forthcoming as Obama in admitting it,” he said.

[The Augustinians were right to silence this guy.]

He continued: “how a German-born Pope (and a former member of the Hitler Youth to boot) [What a slime.] could not foresee the furore that would follow the rehabilitation of a man who denies the Holocaust leaves me baffled. It is the crowning disgrace of Pope Benedict’s career.”

Reuters adds: Pope Benedict said yesterday that “any denial or minimisation of this terrible crime is intolerable, especially if it came from a clergyman.

The pope also confirmed that he was planning to visit Israel. Vatican sources say the trip is expected to take place in May.

 

I think anyone in Ireland reading this should express their opinions of Fr. Iggy’s comments to his superiors.

The Archdiocese of Dublin lists the Provincial of the Irish Augustinians.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
25 Comments

Chant CD by Norbertines in California: fundraiser

Chant CD by Norbertines in California: fundraiserI received a copy of a CD of Chant by the Norbertine’s at St. Michael’s Abbey in Orange, CA.

They are using this CD to raise much needed money.

If you buy it, you are helping them.

The disk is not bad.  You can tell that the chant is not a novelty for them, which is the important thing.

I have included some cuts from the CD on the stream of Radio Sabina.

The some Norbertine Chant versions aren’t quite the same as you would hear in regular Gregorian Chant.

You can learn something about them here on this YouTube.  It talks about the Abbey.

I remember many years ago meeting their old Hungarian Abbot when he visited Msgr. Schuler in St. Paul.  I have known a couple of the other Fathers there also.

Play video

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
5 Comments

Archd. of St.Paul/Mpls: additional TLM

From a reader:

Perhaps you know already, but here are excerpts from my pastor, Fr. Bryan J.B. Pedersen, writing in today’s bulletin from Sacred Heart Catholic Church in Robbinsdale, MN (http://sacredheartrobbinsdale.org/):

"Over the last few months I have been praying a great deal about pastoral generosity. This is so because I have been receiving requests in written form and also verbally from some parishioners, and other Catholics who live in the western suburbs of Minneapolis, for me to celebrate a weekly Sunday Mass in Latin. …

"Because of the requests made by our Holy Father to be generous to those who desire the older form of the Mass, and because I am one of the few priests in the Archdiocese capable of responding to such requests. Therefore for these reasons and in a spirit of generosity I have decided on an experimental basis to add a third Mass to our Sunday Schedule in the extraordinary form of the Mass. … The additional Mass on Sunday will begin on March 1st, which is the first Sunday of Lent, and will ordinarily start at 11:30 am. The additional Mass will be in the extraordinary form using the Roman Missal in use in 1962 per the instruction of our Holy Father Pope Benedict XVI. One of the reasons the additional mass will be on an experimental basis is due to the fact that I must determine if the requests I have been receiving do in fact constitute a stable group who will respond with generosity to our parish. The additional Sunday Mass will initially be celebrated at the Side Altar of St. Mary in the transept. If the number of people attending the older form of the Latin Mass is greater than initially expected then I will shift to using the main altar in the sanctuary. For the time being the Mass will be a low Mass, which means that it will be without music."

Posted in Brick by Brick, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
23 Comments

Congratulations Archbp. Dolan

WDTPRS congratulates Archbishop Timothy Dolan on his translation to the Archdiocese of New York.

From what my priest friends in NY have told me about the last few years, this move may come as a relief.

Of course this leaves open an important see in the US, Milwaukee. 

There is a growing interest in that healing diocese for the older forms of liturgy.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
33 Comments

QUAERITUR: Do I have the right to a wedding or funeral TLM?

From a reader:

A TLM community blog included the following entry. Is it correct in asserting that everyone, everywhere has a right to a nuptial or funeral TLM?

"It is also important to remember that anyone, at any parish, anywhere is entitled to a Traditional Latin Mass for their marriage or their funeral. ….. Tell your friends! Perhaps they don’t know that they are entitled to be married and even buried the same way their family has been for centuries."

 

I don’t know what blog that might have been, but my inclination is to say NO, we do not have the right to a nuptial or funeral TLM.  We have the right to a nuptial or a funeral Mass, but not necessarily a TLM.

Because this gets into an area for which I am not expertly trained, I consulted a canonist I trust.

Here is his answer, which strikes me as on the mark (my emphases).

 

Personally, I think it’s unfortunate that our legal system went in the direction of "rights" full bore after the Council. To me it always seems a bit…American, maybe?… to talk about rights and the sacraments.
 
That said, I think it’s a stretch to maintain that Summorum pontificum has given the faithful the right to have the sacraments or funerals celebrated according to the usus antiquior. They certainly have the right to request that, and the right to expect that their request will be treated with respect. They don’t have the right to force a priest to celebrate an EF wedding or funeral against his will, nor do they have the right to expect that the bishop will produce a priest out of thin air to provide them with the fulfillment of their desire.

The law establishes that all the faithful (not just the lay faithful) have "the right to worship God according to the prescripts of their own rite approved by the legitimate pastors of the Church" (c. 214). Since our rite now includes both an ordinary and extraordinary form, I don’t see how a priest who provided the ordinary form of the liturgy, properly celebrated, could be seen as violating the right of the faithful who request a funeral or wedding. Article 9 of SP gives the pastor the right to utilize the former ritual "bono animarum suadente," which places the discretion clearly in his hands, not in the hands of those who request it for themselves.
 
I also maintain, that if we talk about rights, we need to speak in equal voice about obligations and responsibilities – the faithful have a responsibility to foster and encourage vocations, to support their pastors, to maintain full communion with the Church, to evangelize, to assist the poor, etc (see cc. 208ff).
 
It’s important that we not start looking at the Church as some entity outside of ourselves, from whom we demand the sacraments according to our need. 

 

I think that is a well-balanced answer. 

I am certainly in great sympathy with those who want the TLM not only for special occasions, but for everyday worship.  But that will come about only if in the future we have fostered vocations and given proper support to our legitimate aspirations.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
26 Comments

Plurk… not just a stomach noise

Plurk... not just a stomach noiseI am STILL figuring out what Plurk is, and how to use it.

I had originally signed up with father_z but I won’t be using that.

Right now I am using the same as my twitter address: fatherz

Also, I am trying to integrate Plurk (‘scuse me!) with Facebook and Twitter.

In the meantime, to lift my spirits as I descend into the cruelty of yet another tool of social communication sure to grind my already fraying mental energies to the breaking point, vote for WDTPRS in the Bloggers Choice Awards.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
21 Comments

Wangaratta: TLM

A reader sent this:

Summorum Pontificum Wangaratta (Victoria Australia) now has Mass on the 2nd and 4th Sunday of the month at 5pm in Delaney Chapel, St. Patrick’s Wangaratta. See blog for more info. www.wlms.blogspot.com

Posted in Brick by Brick |
6 Comments

Benedict XVI’s Angelus for the Feast of the Cathedra

Benedict XVI's Angelus for the Feast of the CathedraToday during the Sunday Angelus, a Sunday which is also the Feast of the Cathedral of Peter, the Holy Father made pointed comments relevant, I believe, to the debate going on about the eventual reconciliation of the SSPX and whether there can be differences within the Church.

This Sunday there also falls the Feast of the Cathedra of St. Peter, an important liturgical recurrence which highlights the ministry of the Successor of the Prince of the Apostles.  The Cathedra of Peter symbolizes the authority of the Bishop of Rome, called to perform a distinguishing service with respect to whole People of God. 

Immediately after the martyrdom of Sts. Peter and Paul, the Church of Rome was recognized to have the primatial role in the whole Catholic community, a role already attested in the second century by St. Ignatius of Antioch (Ai Romani, Pref.: Funk, I, 252) and by Saint Irenaeus of Lyon (Contro le eresie III, 3, 2-3). 

This unique and specific ministry of the Bishop of Rome was reaffirmed by the Second Vatican Council:  [I am adding the Latin and giving a standard English translation of the Council citation] [Inde etiam in ecclesiastica communione legitime adsunt Ecclesiae particulares, propriis traditionibus fruentes, integro manente primatu Petri Cathedrae, quae universo caritatis coetui praesidet (Cf. S. IGNATIUS M., Ad Rom, Praef.: ed. FUNK, I, 252.), legitimas varietates tuetur et simul invigilat ut particularia, nedum unitati noceant, ei potius inserviant.]

"Moreover, within the Church particular Churches hold a rightful place; these Churches retain their own traditions, without in any way opposing the primacy of the Chair of Peter, which presides over the whole assembly of charity (Cfr. S. Ignatius M., Ad Rom., Praef.: Ed. Funk, I, p. 252.) and protects legitimate differences, while at the same time assuring that such differences do not hinder unity but rather contribute toward it." 

Dear brothers and sisters, this feast offers me the occasion to ask you to assist me ["accompagnarmi"] with your prayers, so that I can accomplish faithfully the profound responsibility Divine Providence has entrusted me as the Successor of the Apostle Peter.

 

The Pope said that, because he is Peter, he lifted the excommunications of the SSPX bishops in the service of the unity of the Church.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
24 Comments

Wash DC: Sunday Vespers during Lent

From a reader:

Sung Vespers will be held at 4 PM on the Sundays of Lent at the Basilica of the National Shrine of the Immaculate Conception, followed by the regularly scheduled 4:30 Mass. 

The first two Sundays of Lent, Vespers will be held in the Crypt Church.  It will be help in the Great Upper Church the Remaining Sundays.  This was done during advent as well, and may become a year-round event depending on the turnout.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
22 Comments

Fr. Finigan responds

His Hermeneuticalness has glossed The Tablet‘s hit piece by Elena Curti "That was not my Mass".

Fr. Finigan responds saying:

Fr. Finigan responds

This is not my Mass (#1)

A picture says a thousand words.

In the meantime… ?!? … what the…!?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
66 Comments