Thanks are due!

I want to pass long thanks to some of you who have recently used the donation button on the left side bar and on some posts.  I am very grateful.  From time to time I collect the names of those who have made donations and, when I say Mass, I remember you at the altar.  It is an honor and duty to pray for benefactors.

Thanks are due!Also, some of you have shown support for WDTPRS by casting your vote in the Bloggers Choice Awards.  Let’s keep our Catholic blogs at the top of all the lists!   This award site requires registration, which is pesky – I know.  Your help is appreciated.

I have received a few items from my amazon.com wish list, et al., which I would like to acknowledge.

First, I received music CD’s of the Norbertines in Orange, CA and from St. John Cantius in Chicago, that being a disk of music for Holy Week.  I look forward to them and will share some of it on Radio Sabina.  The St. John’s Christmas music disks are excellent.

I received an electric heating element for the birdbath another person sent, I couldn’t tell who.  I am a little hesitant to set this up.  The heating coil looks… well.. pretty serious.  I am afraid I will wind up with Siskin Stew.  Experiments are in order.

Thanks are due!BK of NJ fired off a small digital voice recorder which will be very useful when I ramp up the PODCAzT projects I would like to get going.  It could be useful for on the spot interviews, etc.  Also, I suspect I will find other good uses… pro memoria.

RR of IN sent Ciceronian Controversies which are translations of letters of great Italian Renaissance humanists, such as Poliziano and Pietro Bembo.  It should be interesting.

A real prize came in the form of a condensor microphone which connects by USB port.  This mic should reduce background hiss and make recording things much easier.  The invoice didn’t indicate who sent it.

I am contemplating a new format for PODCAzTs and ways to reduce their production time and raising production quality.  I want to create a template and fit each project into predefined time segments.

I am very grateful for your kindness, support and good wishes.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
6 Comments

Pelosi instructed by Pope Benedict XVI – UPDATED

Today Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi (D-CA), well-known for her pro-abortion career in politics despite her profession of Catholic faith, met briefly with His Holiness Pope Benedict.

Here is a statement from the Press Office:

Following the General Audience the Holy Father briefly greeted Mrs Nancy Pelosi, Speaker of the United States House of Representatives, together with her entourage.

His Holiness took the opportunity to speak of the requirements of the natural moral law and the Church’s consistent teaching on the dignity of human life from conception to natural death which enjoin all Catholics, and especially legislators, jurists and those responsible for the common good of society, to work in cooperation with all men and women of good will in creating a just system of laws capable of protecting human life at all stages of its development.

 

I have not seen any photos from the meeting.

I wonder… is the teaching of the Church clear now Mrs. Pelosi? 

She got it from the top.

But she might have gotten it from her own bishop, with whom she said she would meet.

A spokesman for Archbp. Niederauer of San Francisco said on 13 Feb:

     “While she initially accepted the archbishop’s invitation to a pastoral meeting, she has not been able to arrange such a meeting on her schedule, despite our putting forward several available dates,” …

UPDATE 1653 GMT

Pelosi Statement Following Meeting With Pope Benedict XVI

Last update: 10:09 a.m. EST Feb. 18, 2009
WASHINGTON, Feb 18, 2009 /PRNewswire-USNewswire via COMTEX/ — Speaker Nancy Pelosi issued the following statement today following a meeting at the Vatican with his Holiness, Pope Benedict XVI:

"It is with great joy that my husband, Paul, and I met with his Holiness, Pope Benedict XVI today.

"In our conversation, I had the opportunity to praise the Church’s leadership in fighting poverty, hunger, and global warming, as well as the Holy Father’s dedication to religious freedom and his upcoming trip and message to Israel.

"I was proud to show his Holiness a photograph of my family’s Papal visit in the 1950s, as well as a recent picture of our children and grandchildren."
SOURCE Office of the Speaker of the House 

She says it is a "conversation".  She mentions only what she thought was important enough to reveal.

Fair enough. 

The Holy See mentions in its release what the POPE thought most important to reveal.

The mismatch between the two statements suggests to me that she was either unmoved by the content of what the Pope said to her, or embarrassed. 

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
45 Comments

I’m just askin’

From a priest reader:

Everyone is insisting that the SSPX accept Vatican II.

Can we insist that everybody accept Trent?

Posted in I'm just askin'..., Mail from priests |
75 Comments

Manila: Benedictine altar arrangement

A reader sent a photo of the "Benedictine" arrangement of an altar Manila, at St. Peter the Apostle Church.

Apparently this is not permanent, but it is a step in the right direction.

Manila: Benedictine altar arrangement

Posted in Brick by Brick |
13 Comments

A fine essay stating the issues in the Church’s conflicts

An alert reader sent me this, from The Harvard Salient, a fortnightly student publication. 

My emphases and comments.

Rediscovering Tradition in the Modern Age

February 16, 2009 by Brian

Pope Benedict wisely reconciles four Lefebvrist bishops

By Kevin M. Neylan

On January 26, Pope Benedict XVI found himself at the center of another major controversy after revoking the excommunications of four schismatic, [opps.. oh well…] traditionalist bishops, in an effort to reconcile them to the Roman Catholic Church. The press has focused most of its attention on one of the four, Bishop Richard Williamson, who has declared publicly that the Nazis never killed more than 300,000 Jews and never used gas chambers.

Surely Williamson’s outrageous views are nothing short of ludicrous. No term of reproach is too harsh. Indeed, the Vatican Secretariat of State demanded that Williamson “must absolutely, unequivocally and publicly” recant his position on the Holocaust if he wishes to serve as a bishop in the Church. [Point: he isn’t serving as one at this time] It declared further that Bishop Williamson’s statements are “absolutely unacceptable and firmly rejected by the Holy Father,” although they were “unknown to the Holy Father at the time he revoked the excommunication.” During his visit to France this September, the pope spoke vehemently about the Church’s opposition to “every form of anti-Semitism, which can never be theologically justified.”

Despite the undeniable tension occasioned by Bishop Williamson’s divisive remarks, Oded Wiener, director general of the Chief Rabbinate of Israel, praised the pope’s condemnation as “a giant step forward” and “an extremely important statement, not only for the Jewish people, but also for all the world.” “This was the sign the Jewish world has been waiting for,” agreed Ronald S. Lauder, president of the World Jewish Congress.  [*sigh*]

However, the pope’s repeated denunciations of anti-Semitism have done little to temper the firestorm of outrage erupting from the Catholic left. [NB: "the Catholic left"]  But the unremitting furor — and panic [got that right] — evinced by the likes of leftist priest Hans Küng belies the fact that their uproar has less to do with the Jews, and much more to do with the pope’s signaled intent to reexamine the legacy of the Second Vatican Council with an eye more sympathetic to tradition that has the staunch proponents of modernist dogma now in a frenzy.   [Well said.  This is what I have been proposing as well.]

Bishop Williamson’s absurd remarks have been an unfortunate sideshow, [right] distracting from the true source of the controversies that have welled up over the past few years: after decades of adapting and modernizing, will the Catholic Church continue to affirm the sacred union between faith and reason, [Oooo… good one!] and the reality and comprehensibility of an eternal moral order, without either of which meaningful religious and political dialogue becomes impossible? [One of the Pope’s points at Regensburg.] Or will the Church embrace pluralism ad absurdum, and crack its head against the hard wall of moral relativism?

The four newly reconciled bishops were declared to have incurred automatic excommunication under Pope John Paul II in 1988 after Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre, founder of the traditionalist Society of St. Pius X, consecrated them without Vatican approval. Archbishop Lefebvre rebelled against the sweeping reforms the Church underwent after Vatican II (1962-1965), which sought to bring the Church into step with the modern world; according to Pope John XXIII, the Council meant to “distinguish between what is sacred principle and eternal gospel and what belongs rather to the changing times.”

There is nothing objectionable about John’s stated goal. However, many of the liturgical and theological changes that ensued served not merely to distinguish the eternal from the temporal. On the contrary, some of the reforms—including many that were enacted after the Council and never approved by a synod of bishops—along with the increasingly modern and even postmodern moral paradigms that both contributed to them and are perpetuated by them, serve instead to undermine the very idea of sanctity, to cast grave doubt upon the possibility of eternal truth. As Professor John Casey at Cambridge University explains, rather than allowing the “liturgy… [to] ‘illumine our changing times with its unchanging beauty and greatness,’ those who altered the Mass after Vatican II thought it possible to create a form of worship that was illumined, indeed determined by the changing times.”  [spot on]

If it is not already apparent, more is at stake here than liturgical reform. Pope Benedict’s reconciliation of the four Lefebvrist bishops, and his implicit approval of the traditionalist philosophical framework they endorse, [hmmm… this might over state the issue a little.] should be seen as part of a long and much needed effort aimed at driving back the tide of moral relativism that pervades our age. After all, the first necessary element of the traditional framework is belief in moral objectivity, which of course entails the existence of certain intrinsically good and evil acts. Further, it must be held that all humans, as rational moral agents, are inherently capable of coming to know the natural law although it exists outside the realm of individual preference.

Now, this is assuredly not to say that the Lefebvrists’ conclusions on theological or social matters are all correct, or that the pope either should or does endorse them. Rather, [pay attention] the crucial point is that once we abandon a traditional moral framework we are powerless to draw any conclusions about what is right and wrong. As C.S. Lewis wrote, “From within the Tao itself comes the only authority to modify the Tao… Outside the Tao there is no ground for criticizing either the Tao or anything else.” In other words, the moment we step outside an objective order we forfeit any sturdy moral ground from which to condemn certain courses of action or modes of behavior—like, for instance, anti-Semitism.  [A nice turning of the tables.]

Indeed, insofar as the legitimacy of modern society depends upon the authority of the state to enforce justice, to secure “fundamental rights” and liberties, etc., the crippling effects of pluralism gone mad—an inability to say definitively that certain things are right and others are wrong—erodes the foundations of the social order and guarantees to spoil the countless material fruits modernity has borne.

[This is good…] But many of the Catholics who oppose the pope’s recent actions have different priorities. They appear less concerned with discovering truth—some, including one or two of those who currently populate the theology department of my beloved Jesuit high school, will not even stipulate to the existence of truth. [!] Instead, they prefer the misguided pursuit of watered-down religious dialogue for its own sake, as an end in itself. This agenda was made clear by a controversy that sweltered over the summer.

Last July the pope drew the ire of many of the same leftists now in a tizzy after he issued the Apostolic Letter “Summorum Pontificum,” which freed [emancipated] Catholic priests to celebrate the Tridentine Mass whenever they desired. The Tridentine Mass is the traditional Roman Rite of the liturgy, celebrated by the Church for many centuries before falling out of practice after Vatican II. It is high irony indeed that the Tridentine Mass, which is breathtaking in the beauty of its Latinate ritual and mystery and has inspired brilliant artists, poets, and composers for centuries, should be dogmatically suppressed by those same “progressives” who purport to champion religious freedom. As Prof. Casey recounts, “The parish priest of a famous Jesuit church, politely asked whether he would make some traditional Masses available, responded with unconcealed rage. (This church advertises a children’s liturgy, Japanese Masses, services for Brazilians and Filipinos, but apparently drew the line at the ancient Roman liturgy).” The Latin was thought too un-modern, the solemnity too inaccessible to other religions, the force too damaging to religious dialogue.

Without doubt religious dialogue can be a source of enormous good and ought to be encouraged always. However, the extreme pluralism advocated by certain modernists now up in arms, both within and outside the Church, flows from a conviction that all religion is, to a large extent, inscrutable, so deeply embedded in individual or cultural conviction as to operate beyond the faculties of reason. Few beliefs could be more damaging to the prospect of religious dialogue or moral rectitude.

As Pope Benedict stated in his brilliant, but widely misunderstood and controversial, Regensburg Address in 2006:

“Theology rightly belongs in the university and within the wide-ranging dialogue of sciences, not merely as a historical discipline… but precisely… as inquiry into the rationality of faith. Only thus do we become capable of that genuine dialogue of cultures and religions so urgently needed today. In the Western world it is widely held that only positivistic reason and the forms of philosophy based on it are universally valid… A reason which is deaf to the divine and which relegates religion into the realm of subcultures is incapable of entering into the dialogue of cultures.”

Therefore, religious dialogue must not be pursued with some naïve belief that all religions are more or less equal in their reasonableness or their potential to stultify. [Excellent.] Nothing could be more misguided, not to mention subversive of the fruits of real dialogue. However, our self-imposed divorce between faith and reason, and the blind embrace of pluralism, are two sides of the same coin. Both have the effect of sapping society of the very framework that allows virtue to flourish, that allows modernity’s material goods to be put to their best uses.

Insofar as the Second Vatican Council encourages the Church to engage other faiths in meaningful dialogue and to adapt to a world dominated by modern political institutions, it was right and proper to do so. However, Pope Benedict is equally correct to rein in the post-Conciliar excesses by trying to shore up a traditional moral and philosophical framework: in short, to preserve the marriage between Judaic religion, Greek thought, and European heritage, which allowed the Church and civilization to flourish for nearly two millennia. Few tasks can be considered more important, either for the future of the Roman Catholic Church or the future prosperity of modern civilization.

 

Save The Liturgy.  Save The World.

Kudos to the author.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
38 Comments

Jacksonville, FL: 23 Feb – TLM Adult Education

From a reader:

ADULT EDUCATION:  THE NOVUS ORDO AND THE TRADITIONAL LATIN MASS
 
The Adult Education Ministry will meet on Monday, February 23rd, at 7PM in the Cody Center.  The topic is "The Traditional Latin Mass and the Novus Ordo- The Two Forms of the Roman Rite."
 
The alternative form of the Mass is now more widely available as a result of Pope Benedict’s Motu Proprio (2007) to those who prefer the ancient usage.  The two forms of the Roman Rite are:  the Ordinary Form (the Mass of Paul VI, 1969) in English or Latin, and the Extraordinary Form (known as the Mass of John XXIII, the Traditional (Tridentine) Mass, in Latin only.
 
The basic differences and principal features will be contrasted in terms of prayers, music, vestments, mood, and rubrics.  Both forms are equal, mutually enriching, and fulfill the Sunday obligation.  "There is certainly a difference of emphasis, but a single fundamental identity that excludes any contradition or antagonism between a renewed liturgy and the preceding liturgy,"  Pope Benedict XVI.  Come and enjoy a lively discussion.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
17 Comments

Pray in a special way. Offer your mortifications.

The liberals have sensed that the Holy Father is weak right now and they are attacking.

Bishops in Austria have risen up against the appointment of a bishop.

Several bishops have issued decisions or statements in some way related to the older form of Holy Mass.  For example, the Cardinal in Manila put out an insulting set of "guidelines".  The Cardinal of Westminster stuck his thumb in the eye of the LMS. 

Sundry leftist wonks have had op-ed pieces in the secular and Catholic press whining and wringing their hands about the SSPX and now liberal priests who habitually let those wonks think for them, are now feeding the trash they swallowed to their flocks.

I made this observation a while back: the attacks on the Holy Father are going to increase and descend in viciousness.

Pray for the Holy Father.

Ask God, if it is His will, to let you bear some of the burden of suffering.

Offer some penances, prayers, fasting or alms as you pray for our Holy Father.

Ask the holy guardian angels of those who are attacking the Holy Father and his vision for the Church, to help the Holy Spirit open their hearts.

Pray that Pope Benedict will be given the strength to make changes around himself.

Pray that he will, if need be, change those whom he, with trust, chose to cooperate in his heavy mandate.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
74 Comments

Author of “one of the dumbest things I have ever read” is back again!

From time to time… well… pretty often actually, readers send me blurbs written by their parish priest and published in their Sunday bulletin.

Let’s have a look at this, from Fr. Patrick Wissman, pastor of Sacred Heart in Bolivar MO. 

We have seen this fellow before on WDTPRS.  He wrote one of the dumbest things I have ever read.

He doesn’t confine himself to writing dumb things.  He is also nasty.

The reader wrote: "I thought you might like to hear his latest opinions.  I especially like how he compares them to parasites and fleas."

My emphases and comments.

February 8, 2009   Fifth Sunday in Ordinary Time

PASTOR’S COMMENTS

Dear Parishioners,
February (meaning ‘cleansing’) is for us a time of winter’s cold and weather. I suppose the intent is to say that the very cold temperatures will kill the’ bugs’ that are outside. [Watch the parallel is is setting up.] The fleas, ticks and parasites that can’t take the extreme cold will be done away with. The warm-up that is occurring is typical of Missouri weather. The changeability is a sign that there is some struggle in nature to get us ready for springtime. Perhaps there is some global climate change showing itself.

Britain had the biggest snow it has had for some 18 years. The pictures of London blanketed with 6 inches of snow was reminiscent of-the age of Dickens.

The news this week of Pope Benedict lifting the excommunication on four bishops that were ordained without any legitimacy was strange. The previous Popes have dealt in different ways with the St. Pius X Society (a heretical group that refused to accept Vatican II and it’s documents of change) [I think Father doesn’t understand what heresy is… rather… the definition of heresy.] . Their leader was a certain Archbishop Lefevre [sic] of Switzerland. It is our belief [the royal we?] that the changes of Vatican II are the works of the Holy Spirit. That Archbishop refused to accept the changes and was especially recalcitrant concerning the Liturgical renewal and an ecumenical approach to the Protestant denominations. [It would be accurate to say a false ecumenical approach.] The Holy Father in a desire to bring wondering sheep back to the fold, lifted excommunication of four Bish­ops. That excommunication had been put in place by Pope John Paul II. The news that caught the world by surprise was that one of those Bishops held anti-Semite views and de­clared that there were no gassing of Jews under Hitler’s Third Reich. Evidently the Pope was unaware of  his position. Pope Benedict has reconsidered and in today’s (Wednesday) noon address in Rome he said that the lifting of the excommunication for that Bishop was dependent on him recanting his anti-Semite position. The shame of this is that the Pope was unaware concerning this rebellious and disobedient cleric! The Jewish leaders loudly questioned the Pope’s first action and said that Catholic-Jewish Dialogue was now seriously jeopardized. Today the leader of Germany Angela Merkel voiced her opinion on the matter. I think this is what made the Pope reconsider. [Reconsiderrrrr …. what exactly?]  In Ger­many anyone who denies the Holocaust in any significant way is considered a criminal and subject to a jail term.

What happened here? I am afraid it is the old problem that has been around for ever! The Ivory Tower syndrome. The Pope is so isolated from ordinary life that he is very much out of touch with the reality of the world. He is surrounded by people who feel they need to agree with him.   [He is parroting the likes of Reese and his blather on WaPo.]

The allowing of Latin liturgies (Mass and sacraments) by choice of priests is the same thing. [Remember: the libs are terrified of worship which is manifestly God-centered.] These people that the Pope is trying to bring back into the fold are lacking in faith and are self seeking and above all disobedient. I think they are the hypocrites in the church of today.  [And yet look at this attitude toward the Pope.  In front of his whole parish, he is running down the Pope.  In his bulletin.  If he does this in his bulletin, imagine what he says "off the record" to his parishioners.  This priest demonstrates little spirit of obedience toward the Holy Father’s determinations about the SSPX or Summorum Pontificum. Who is the hypocrite?]

And we know how Jesus dealt with the hypocrites. He called them ‘whitened sepulchers’ and false leaders. I think the Pope has fallen into on indefensible position and for all the good will he has, he is out of touch. It is interesting that the Pope makes mistakes. This can only remind us of what infallibility means. In the Catholic Church it is the Church that is infallible, not the Pope alone. It is only in unity and with consultation that the Pope shares any infallibility. [He accuses the SSPX of being "heretical" and says they don’t accept Vatican II.  Fine.  Father should actually read the Council documents and discover what the Church actually says about the teaching office of the Church.  The Pope can teach infallibly without consulting anyone.  He can do so entirely on his own.  What Father suggested veers rather close to heresy… unless he is simply uninformed.]  A good learning moment for all of us. As of yet, I don’t know if this Bishop will recant. If he doesn’t, then it should be clear that he does not live by the Holy Spirit. [And now he is judging the soul of another because of he expressed something which is an historical error, not a doctrinal error.]

Let us pray for the Church!   

Fr Pat   
Pastor: Rev. J. Patrick
Wissman    patwissman@windstream.net

He started with fleas and ticks, and how the cold is supposed to kill them.

He is trying to get people to turn on the freeze.

What a guy.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
48 Comments

Plurk… more than a stomach noise?

First, its the internet…Plurk... more than a stomach noise?

then…

bulletin boards
listservers
IRC
forums
blogs
facebook
twitter

Will someone please explain what Plurk is?

 

 

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
30 Comments

F. Finigan on the The Tablet and “going loud”

From the site is His Hermeneuticalness, Fr. Finigan.

It should have maximum visibility.  Check his site for comments.

Parish dispute "goes loud"

In late October, one of my parishioners sent an email to various others, including myself, the Archbishop and the Area Bishop, complaining about various aspects of the Liturgy as celebrated at Blackfen. The discussion rather took off and many different points were raised over a lengthy exchange of emails that became difficult to keep track of.

Eventually, in the midst of preparations for Christmas, I circulated a paper ("Sacred and Great") that I wrote in an attempt to help people to understand the nature of the Liturgy and its development, and to counteract misunderstandings about the Liturgy.

Bishop Pat Lynch (the local area Bishop) was very helpful and, after Christmas, met with those who were unhappy as well as with a small group of those who like the usus antiquior and those who are neutral but don’t see any problem in having it as part of parish life.

I had thought that things had calmed down a bit, but last Thursday, Elena Curti of the Tablet was waiting for me after Mass to speak to me about the "split" in my parish. That day, unfortunately, I had commitments all day until 10pm and was not able to talk at length but she went to meet some of those who were unhappy (and who had initiated this contact) and we arranged a phone call for Friday, when we spoke for half an hour or so. Elena asked me later for some contacts who might be sympathetic to the Liturgical practice in the parish.

So by Sunday, quite a lot of people now knew about the impending article. After Mass, I took off for a couple of days break I had planned a while back (first day off since Christmas) and by the time I got to my destination, there was a text message telling me that it had all "gone loud" as they say. See:

Damian Thompson (Holy Smoke) Is the Tablet planning a hatchet job on Fr Tim Finigan?
Fr Z (What Does the Prayer Really Say?) Is The Tablet declaring war?

Reading those posts and associated comments, I am deeply grateful for the expressions of kindness and support as well as the many emails that I have received from journalists and others round the world. Please pray for my parish and for all the parishioners that we can live peaceably with the different forms of the Liturgy that the Church allows.

(Just one small clarification: I do not say four Masses on Sunday; I have one Saturday evening Mass and three on Sunday. Therefore I can say all these Masses without infringing canon law. In fact, I usually have a supply priest to say one of the English Masses.)

The paper Sacred and Great, as is obvious from some of the particular refereces to Blackfen, was originally written for parishioners and therefore I have not made it publicly available before. I was intending to edit out some of the local references and expand it for publication as a small book – and will do this when time permits. However, now that others have gone to the press, (and indeed made my paper available to the Tablet) there is no longer any reason not to let my readers have it. I hope that you will like the paper and find it helpful. (Feel free to link to it, quote it etc.)

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on F. Finigan on the The Tablet and “going loud”