On Westminster, Card. Murphy-O’Conner and Archbp. Burke

If a visiting priest comes to a parish, or a visiting bishop comes to a diocese, there are formalities to observe.  Visitors need approval, tacit or formal.  For the most part this approval is truly a mere formality: the visitor is welcomed, Masses are celebrated and talks are given.  Every one is happy and everyone looks good in the end.

From time to time, however, you hear of bishops or parish priests refusing to let visitors celebrate public Masses.  I remember a story about the Cardinal Archbishop of Los Angeles being disinvited from saying Mass in another diocese in the Archbishop’s own province.  Shocking!

Remember: group of lay people cannot simply invite a priest into their parish for Mass without consulting and get permission from the pastor.  A group of lay people, or even priests, cannot simply invite a visitor bishop to speak or say Mass without consulting the local bishop.

Priests and bishops understand this.  I get that all the time: "O Father! O Father! Come to Black Duck! You have to come say Mass for us at St. Ipsidipsy!  That would be great!"   I respond: "If and when the parish priest there invites me, I will consider it."

The usual reason for refusal of permission or an invitation is that the formalities are not followed and the organizing group and local bishop or priest are not on good terms. 

Since the locum tenens has all the power, reasonable or goofy the group is hosed.

On Westminster, Card. Murphy-O'Conner and Archbp. BurkeWe are hearing that His Eminence Cormac Card. Murphy-O’Connor, the lame-duck Archbishop of Westminster has refused permission to His Excellency Archbishop Raymond Burke, Prefect of the Signatura, to celebrate a Pontifical Mass organized by the Latin Mass Society.

I know Archbishop Burke personally.  He would not have accepted an invitation and confirmed it had he thought formalities weren’t going to be observed.  He would have wanted a "nihil obstat", as it were, from the local bishop, in this case Card. Murphy-O’Connor.  Archbp. Burke is precise. I can see him saying "Sure, that date is good.  But I will need a letter from the Cardinal, just to be sure." Heads of dicasteries also usually have to consult with the Secretariat of State when they are going to leave Rome and do something high profile… just to be sure.

Formalities are not important.. until they are.

Card. Murphy-O’Connor is fully within his rights to make the determination about a visiting bishop coming to celebrate a Pontifical Mass in his cathedral or anywhere else in his diocese. 

That doesn’t mean he should have exercised them now, and in this way.

Who knows if this could have been avoided?  Maybe.  Maybe not.  Yes, the Latin Mas Society ought to have been more diligent in the formalities. Had they been, the formalities could not be an excuse for saying Archbp. Burke couldn’t sing the Mass.  

The real reason would have been more obvious than it is.

Frankly, I think we are seeing here a pretty blatant smack-down from the Cardinal.  I suspect he doesn’t like any of this Latin stuff.  He used his power to spoil something that would have been a great event.  He slammed the door on someone dear to the supporters of the TLM and close to Pope Benedict’s vision.

That is what happens when you have hostility on both sides and one side has the power.

People are genuinely and reasonably upset.

Nevertheless, though I marvel at this decision of the Cardinal Archbishop of Westminster to stick his thumb in the eye both of the Prefect of the Signatura and the LMS, including many of his own flock who are no doubt badly hurt, no matter that this is a brutta figura before the whole world, can I say it is a surprise?  

When the former papal MC Archbp. Piero Marini, liturgical uber-progressvist and spiritual son of Annibale Bugnini, wanted to have a splashy party for the book that came out under his name – a clear rebuke to Pope Benedict and defense of Bugnini – the Cardinal Archbishop of Westminster rolled out the red carpet and welcomed him.

When a musical piece entitled the "99 Names of Allah" was slated for Westminster Cathedral, the Cardinal rolled out the carpets – not prayer rugs exactly, for it wasn’t openly a service of false worship – and welcomed the event in his cathedral, despite the fact that many of his subjects wondered at the move.

So… we ask: Would it have been such a terrible thing to have welcomed Archbishop Burke?

For them?  Yes.  It would have been terrible!  

The progressivist establishment smells some blood in the water around the Holy Father’s little boat.  The Pope is presently being tossed about, so they are helping a little more water wash over the gunwales.  

On my planet, things might have gone a little differently.

Okay… so the formalities were not followed.  In that case, the Cardinal Archbp. might have had his secretary call the leadership of the LMS and ask them to present themselves at a certain time.  Over a nice soothing cup of tea, the Card. Archbp. would then graciously but firmly let them know that Archbp. Burke will be welcomed, but if they should ever invite someone of his status without consulting again, permission will be denied.  Let the LMS know that he will host Archbp. Burke and that the staff of the cathedral will cooperate: but they are also to cooperate and consult.

But this isn’t my planet.

It is time to regroup.  

The outgoing Card. Archbishop of Westminster isn’t going to pay any attention to what I say, that’s for sure.  I hope that some of the members of the LMS will.

My advice is to embrace whomever the Card. Archbishop of Westminster delegates to celebrate that Pontifical Mass.  Embrace him warmly, with the charm I experienced from some of the folks in the LMS when I have visited London.  If it is one of the auxiliary bishops, make this experience be for him both pleasant and edifying.  He will still be auxiliary when the new Archbishop of Westminster is assigned.  He will no doubt give his impressions of what it is like – really – to work with the LMS, etc.

No matter what offense was offered to the Holy Father in this graceless move, no matter what kick of sand at the Prefect of the Signatura, the best way forward is to be cheerful, charming and enthusiastic about having a Pontifical Mass in Westminster Cathedral. 

Make it stunning. Make it memorable.  

After all, it is no small thing to have a Pontifical Mass in Westminster no matter who the bishop is.

Sadly, and I see this happen time and time again with traditional Catholics as individuals or as groups, when there is some setback or disagreement, rather than close ranks and work to overcome, someone gets his or her nose bent out of shape, takes his bat and ball, and goes home in a huff.  

Unfortunately, we more conservative, traditional Catholics can be our own worst enemies.

And the libs count on that.

Whatever else might happen, I urge the membership of the LMS to take this very calmly, with grace, and make the best of things no matter how bad this hurts or offends.  

Everyone is watching.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
71 Comments

stuffed

My car has been running badly. It didn’t have any giddyup and the milage was very bad. I contemplated this until I remembered the story to me by a guy about how mice stuffed his wife’s car’s air cleaner full of dog food.

The other day I found a mouse near the birdseed in the garage.

hmmmm

stuffed

Posted in My View, SESSIUNCULA |
40 Comments

Turning Tables

I belong to a literary group, comprised – including retired profs of literature, history and philosophy – mainly of very educated priest friends and a pair of physicians. Over years we have read through all the Divine Comedy, some Milton. we are now focused on T.S Eliot.

We read aloud, discuss, and then enjoy a nice meal. We in the penultimate sessiuncula we drilled into The Cocktail Party.

And so I delved into interlibrary loan and obtained LPs of the original cast recording! At first the library said they would not request it if I did not have a record player but I said I had access.

The disks came from a small remote college library – what an amazing service. Then I forgot them at home as I hit the road.

Turning Tables

I was going to play and record them digitally. Returning home I found my disks on the chair where I left them.

With two days left on my loan I wondered what to do. Then I remembered years ago clearing out old stuff from the house… among them an old LP cassette deck system.

Turning Tables

Digging, I found it fired it up and am now happily listening and recording so that I can review it again.

Turning Tables

Turning Tables

Turning Tables

It is a work of extraordinary depth and wit, as one would expected from the greatest English language poet of the 20th century.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
21 Comments

The Market

Dont you love Chinese and other Asian markets?

The Market

The Market

The Market

The Market

The Market

The Market

The Market

The Market

Posted in Fr. Z's Kitchen, My View, SESSIUNCULA |
50 Comments

Light day

I am going to have a light internet morning and day while I run errands and travel a bit.

Back later. 

I will get the z-cam up running this afternoon or evening.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

Detroit: 18 March TLM @ National Shrine of The Little Flower

From a reader.  The info sent in the e-mail was a little thin and it was too much work to dig for more.  But I can pass this on.

The Archdiocese of Detroit’s largest parishes in terms of the number of registered families,

With over 12,000 parishioners and elementary, middle, and high schools.  The National Shrine of The Little Flower will host a special Tridentine Mass on Wednesday March 18 at 7:00.  More details can be found here.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
17 Comments

A TLM first impression

The old adage is: You only have once chance at a first impression.

I am always interested to read about first impressions from participating at Holy Mass celebrated with the 1962 Missale Romanum.

This is from a reader.  Edited and with my emphases and comments.  For the whole piece go here.

I am one of your blog readers, and I attended my first Mass in the Extraordinary Form this morning, after considering it for some time.
It was such an awesome experience!  I wrote a blog post about it here.

Below is the text of the post, if you’d like to read it that way.

Mainly, I just want to let you know what an inspiration you and your blog have been to me!  I rejoined the Church less than 4 years ago, and have had lots of learning and catching up to do.  I was never even really aware of the EF until I started reading your blog and a few others.  I really appreciate it.  It is our right as Catholics to be able to know and experience our patrimony, [precisely] and thank God that we have people like you to help expose us to it!

Thank you for all that you do.  I love WDTPRS!

God be with you; you are in my prayers every day, with all of our priests!

Heather Barrett

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

My first encounter with the Extraordinary Form

Well, it’s just after 9 AM–the time when I might just be getting out of bed on any other Saturday–and I’ve just returned from my first Mass in the Extraordinary Form (EF)!  My parish offers it every morning, Monday-Saturday; or rather, an FSSP priest offers it at my parish.  I figured the familiar surroundings would make me less nervous about going, and that the daily Mass might be simpler to start out with.

…

And now for my impressions…

Well, it was very different from the Ordinary Form (OF), and I felt a little clumsy and a little lost at times.  That didn’t trouble me, because it was only to be expected, right?  Maybe I could have taken more time to prepare myself a little better beforehand, but I didn’t want to start coming up with excuses not to go!  I felt like this was something I really needed to do.  And as with all the "threshold-crossing" moments of my life, the devil was already giving me enough grief about it, trying to discourage me and distract me–I wasn’t going to give in!

No matter how clumsy and lost I might have felt, I did not feel like an outsider.  Reading some other people’s accounts of attending Mass in the EF, I’ve gotten the impression that they have felt sort of like outside observers, like aliens in a foreign land.  I think that is wont to happen if one regards the EF as something foreign or alien. [good]  I regard it as part of my own culture and civilization, part of my patrimony, my inheritance, my treasure. [right!]  This is the kind of Mass my family and ancestors knew.  Like many things handed down from previous generations, it may seem new and different, maybe strange or hard to understand in ways, but it’s still mine.  It’s part of me and I’m part of it.

More than anything I was fascinated and full of wonder! [The point of worship is to experience awe at transcendence.]  I don’t know if I will ever let another Saturday go by without attending morning Mass in the EF.  I feel drawn to it now. [mysterium tremendum et facscinans]  I want to leave behind my clumsiness and disorientation.  I want to know and understand it better.  And I want to participate and enter into it even more fully.

I’m baffled at how some people have said that they don’t get to participate in the EF.  If anything, I think it demands much more focused and alert participation than the OF. [Precisely!  Anyone can do stuff.  It takes real focus to participate with active receptivity.]  The priest prayed most of the prayers silently, and I was reading them to myself.  Reading is a different process than listening, a different encounter with the words and, in this case, the prayers.  I consider it a more active process. [!]  While I read along, I was carefully listening for cues like bells ringing and the priest’s uttering aloud the opening words of certain of the prayers.  I also glanced up to watch for gestures like bows or genuflections or what part of the altar he was standing at.

The overall effect that this process had on me was a dual one:

On one hand, through the act of reading, I felt like the prayers were more my own and that I was playing a more personal, individual, and active part in the Mass.  In the OF, it’s easy to sort of shut down and slip into a more passive watching and listening to the priest, as if he’s the one who actually "performs" the worship, especially the Eucharistic Prayer, and we’re just the "audience." [This is counter-intuitive for many people, but it is profoundly true.  This is expecially the case when the ordinary form is celebrated versus populum instead of ad orientem.]  I suppose that’s possible with any Mass, but by reading the prayers myself, I felt more unified with the priest, more like I was acting with him and imitating him.  He read the prayers, I read the prayers.

…

But this morning’s Mass really emphasized that for me.  I saw the priest and his role in a different way.  And I realized what a blessing the priest is–what a leader, an advocate, and intercessor we have in him.  And I realized how much I needed and wanted him there for me.  As he prayed before the Crucifix, I sensed that he was carrying my prayers and those of everybody else on his shoulders.

I’ve never been to a Mass celebrated ad orientem before, so I’d never really thought about that before.  …

…

Posted in Brick by Brick, SESSIUNCULA, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM | Tagged ,
32 Comments

Is The Tablet declaring war?

Apparently England’s weekly The Tablet, which nearly succeeds in making the NCR look moderate, has in its crosshairs Fr. Tim Finigan.

Damian Thompson of Holy Smoke has sounded the claxon. 

Is The Tablet declaring war?As you know, Fr. Finigan, His Hermeneuticalness, is just about the most well-balance priest around.  He teaches at Wonersh Seminary, is a parish priest, writer, blogger and all around gentleman.  He offers his flock both the Novus Ordo and the TLM in harmony.  I would work as this man’s assistant any time.

For an example of what Fr. Finigan does for his parish, look at his report for their "Day with Mary".  Edifying.

I have been getting reports from various sources that more than one writer for The Tablet is flecked with spittle about Pope Benedict and his vision for the Church, especially over what he has been doing regarding liturgy. 

My antenae extended a few centimenters when I saw Damian’s piece.

Let’s have a look, with my emphases and comments.

Is the Tablet planning a hatchet job on Fr Tim Finigan?
Posted By: Damian Thompson at Feb 15, 2009 at 13:49:33

Fr Tim Finigan, author of the Hermeneutic of Continuity blog, is one of the finest parish priests in the country: a scholar, evangelist and pastor who is as happy spreading the Gospel over a pint in the pub as he is from the pulpit. But now there are rumours that the Tablet is planning a hatchet job on him, for the grave crime of… saying the Latin Mass. [Well… let’s rather say Mass in Latin and move on…]

Fr Tim, PP of Our Lady of the Rosary, Blackfen, Kent, says three new rite Masses on a Sunday and one in the Extraordinary Form. [3:1] In other words, he is inspired by Pope Benedict’s vision of the older and newer liturgies existing side by side, enriching each other.

As in most parishes, however, there is a small group of Tabletistas who, in true "liberal" fashion, are not satisfied that most Masses in Blackfen use the Missal of Paul VI; they want to deprive other parishioners of the rights granted to them by Summorum Pontificum. So who do they go running to?

Step forward Ms Elena Curti, deputy editor of the Bitter Pill, whom I last saw ashen-faced with rage while Cardinal Castrillon Hoyos was explaining the fine print of the Motu Proprio. She is a zealot even by the standards of that dreary rag. I think we can look forward to an article in this week’s issue stirring up trouble in Blackfen.  [I think we Catholic bloggers should take it very ill were The Tablet to target Fr. Finigan.]

As it happens, dozens of priests in Fr Finigan’s diocese of Southwark routinely ignore the Vatican’s guidelines on the celebration of Mass, filling the sanctuary with unnecessary "Eucharistic ministers" and disfiguring ancient prayers with unauthorised improvisations. Indeed, this happens all over the country. But these abuses don’t get reported to the Tablet.

Why don’t we change that? If Ms Curti is so interested in "divisive" liturgies, then perhaps orthodox Catholics should give her a ring on ____ or email her [ECurti@thetablet.co.uk]. I’m sure she’d be thrilled to hear from you!

Again… I think we Catholic bloggers would take it very ill were The Tablet to attack Fr. Finigan or hurt his parishioners.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
61 Comments

Rome in the slow lane

Rome in the slow laneIt is axiomatic that Rome doesn’t move quickly.

Rome in the slow lane

PS: I shut down the Z-Cam for a couple days.

Posted in My View, SESSIUNCULA |
3 Comments

Hysteria

Fr. Longenecker, about whom I have always written with charity, has stepped over the line.

Apparently living in a place where he admits maniples are …. and I can hardly bring myself to write… rare, he has nearly frothed that the ferraiuolo is truly his own, that it is not borrowed. 

I will no longer give his… or whosesoever it was … ferraiuolo more attention, unless he should show up in one for supper at the Sabine Farm (an occasion, I might add, becoming less and less likely).

It would be best not to, you know, "disturb" him longer on that point.

His maniplely-deprived frustration has reduced him to name-calling.  Who knows what might be next!

Thus, I turn my back on that ferraiuolo, casually kick the sand… er um… snow from my feet and move on down the road to different topics.

Hysteria

Oh… by the way… that is something entirely different, though your average priest familiar with the ways of Rome will recognize it right away.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
58 Comments