A Host found on the floor: a priest teaches his flock about Communion

This came from a reader:

It is from St. Paul’s in Philadelphia, where Fr. Gerald Carey is pastor.  The sender introduces the situation. 

Dear Father,
 
Due to recent sacrileges to the Blessed Sacrament at St. Paul Parish in Philadelphia, the pastor, Father Gerald Carey, had the following letter placed as a special insert into the weekly parish bulletin.  If only more priests would do the same.

In the following, my emphases and comments.
 

LETTER REGARDING A RECENT SACRILEGE AT SAINT PAUL
AND REVERENCE TOWARD THE BLESSED SACRAMENT

    Last week I was deeply upset about the fact that our maintenance man found a Sacred Host on the floor of the church while he was sweeping.  I can’t tell you how upsetting this was for me and how much this made me so sick to my stomach.  After speaking about this to a few people, they told me that this was not the first time that this has happened here at Saint Paul Parish.  I didn’t know whether to be upset with the individual who committed this despicable act of irreverence toward the Blessed Sacrament or myself for not being vigilant enough as a priest in watching people receive so as to ensure that they have consumed the Host completely in front of me at the Altar.  [Oh Father… you can’t watch everything.]

    I am not that old (41), and I remember as a child how the priests, nuns and my mother and father taught me how precious our Lord was in the Blessed Sacrament and how this was not just a “piece of bread” but truly the very Body and Blood, Soul and Divinity of Jesus Christ – Bread from Heaven!  At that time no Catholic in my parish and most others would ever dream of touching the Host because of this belief.  [Amen and amen.  The priest’s hands are consecrated for this.]  I received my First Holy Communion in 1976 and was the last class only permitted  ["permitted"…. sigh…] to receive on the tongue then the Church granted an “indult” to receive both in the hand and on the tongue in 1977.  I remember us being told that this was an ancient practice and that both ways can be “just as reverent”.  [Right.  Yah.]  This may be true, and trust me I know that there are many who do receive on the hand reverently.  But, I also believe that overall, we as Catholics have gotten way too casual in our demeanor toward the Blessed Sacrament and I believe that those who do not receive Communion in the hand properly have in many ways diminished our understanding and belief in the Real Presence of Jesus Christ.  [It is a hard thing to have to say, but I agree.  It is not the fault of most people who do.  This has been a matter of creeping incrementalism, a nearly imperceptible shift.  When you change how we pray, right down to our posture and gestures for receiving Communion, you change our belief about the Eucharist.]  In every assignment I have had, I have encountered this problem.  Who would have ever thought that looking just 30 years back, we would even have to have this conversation; finding the Blessed Sacrament on the dirty floors of our churches, in hymn books, or taken God knows where else?  [That’s right.]

At the present moment, the Church allows for Communion given either in the hand or on the tongue.  The person receiving has the complete freedom to choose which way he or she wants to receive.  [Well… sort of.  If the priest thinks there is danger of profanation, he can insist, but generally he is right.  People do have rights.]  I myself, any priest and any Extraordinary Minister will always respect that decision and we will never look differently upon any individual for doing so.  I personally have always struggled in my heart with this decision by the Church to allow this to happen and I myself don’t prefer it and I struggle to believe that it has helped to increase reverence, awe and devotion among Catholics toward our Lord present in the Most Blessed Sacrament.  But, I must be obedient as a priest and I must allow for what the Church allows.  I have no authority to change this practice but as your Pastor, I do have an obligation to do all I can to safeguard and defend the Eucharist and to promote reverence toward Our Lord when I see an abuse.  [I think he is making himself clear.]

    With all this being said, [sounds like an ablative absolute… his dictis…] on the reverse side of this paper I have provided an instruction concerning the proper and reverent way to receive Communion in the hand in hopes that it will foster greater reverence to our Lord in the Most Blessed Sacrament if anyone chooses to receive that way.  [Though we hope they won’t.]  I remind you, that this manner of receiving is optional (not required) and the more time honored practice is receiving directly on the tongue.  Even our present Holy Father requires Communion on the tongue at his Masses.  I encourage all of you to really pray about this and to reflect upon what you are doing at the moment of receiving our Lord present in the Most Blessed Sacrament.  One Host lost is one too many for me.  May God help anyone who treats the Blessed Sacrament with such disrespect and may God help all of us to regain again a “sense of the sacred” in our Catholic churches.

      May the Heart of Jesus in the Most Blessed Sacrament be praised adored and loved with grateful affection at every moment in all the tabernacles of the world, even until the end of time.  Amen.

Sincerely yours,

Father Carey

Huge WDTPRS kudos to Fr. Carey.   Good job Father!

We are in your corner and thank you for your firm and charitable instruction.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
47 Comments

Just askin’ about the CCHD

If I am not mistaken… is this next weekend scheduled, at least in some dioceses, to collect money in parishes for the Catholic Campaign for Human Development?

Maybe I am mistaken.

If I am not mistaken didn’t the CCHD give money to ACORN?

I’m just askin’…

Posted in I'm just askin'... |
68 Comments

A prayer request

I have an urgent prayer request.

Please keep this in mind, in your charity.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

Adding my name to “An Open Letter to President-Elect Barack Obama”

Originally posted at Vox Nova with many signers:

An Open Letter to President-Elect Barack Obama

November 14, 2008

President-elect Barack Obama,

As American Catholics, we, the undersigned, would like to reiterate the congratulations given to you by Pope Benedict XVI. We will be praying for you as you undertake the office of President of the United States.

Wishing you much good will, we hope we will be able to work with you, your administration, and our fellow citizens to move beyond the gridlock which has often harmed our great nation in recent years. Too often, partisan politics has hampered our response to disaster and misfortune. As a result of this, many Americans have become resentful, blaming others for what happens instead of realizing our own responsibilities. We face serious problems as a people, and if we hope to overcome the crises we face in today’s world, we should make a serious effort to set aside the bitterness in our hearts, to listen to one another, and to work with one another

One of the praiseworthy elements of your campaign has been the call to end such partisanship. You have stated a desire to engage others in dialogue. With you, we believe that real achievement comes not through the defamation of one’s opponents, nor by amassing power and using it merely as a tool for one’s own individual will. We also believe dialogue is essential. We too wish to appeal to the better nature of the nation. We want to encourage people to work together for the common good. Such action can and will engender trust. It may change the hearts of many, and it might alter the path of our nation, shifting to a road leading to a better America. We hope this theme of your campaign is realized in the years ahead.

One of the critical issues which currently divides our nation is abortion. As you have said, no one is for abortion, and you would agree to limit late-term abortions as long as any bill which comes your way allows for exceptions to those limits, such as when the health of the mother is in jeopardy. You have also said you would like to work on those social issues which cause women to feel as if they have a need for an abortion, so as to reduce the actual number of abortions being performed in the United States.

Indeed, you said in your third presidential debate, “But there surely is some common ground when both those who believe in choice and those who are opposed to abortion can come together and say, ‘We should try to prevent unintended pregnancies by providing appropriate education to our youth, communicating that sexuality is sacred and that they should not be engaged in cavalier activity, and providing options for adoption, and helping single mothers if they want to choose to keep the baby.’”

As men and women who oppose abortion and embrace a pro-life ethic, we want to commend your willingness to engage us in dialogue, and we ask that you live up to your promise, and engage us on this issue.

There is much we can do together. There is much that we can do to help women who find themselves in difficult situations so they will not see abortion as their only option. There is much which we can do to help eliminate those unwanted pregnancies which lead to abortion.

One of your campaign promises is of grave concern to many pro-life citizens. On January 22, 2008, the 35th anniversary of Roe v. Wade, when speaking of the current right of women in America to have abortions, you said, “And I will continue to defend this right by passing the Freedom of Choice Act as president.”

The Freedom of Choice Act (FOCA) might well undermine your engagement of pro-life Americans on the question of abortion. It might hamper any effort on your part to work with us to limit late-term abortions. We believe FOCA does more than allow for choice. It may force the choice of a woman upon others, and make them morally complicit in such choice. One concern is that it would force doctors and hospitals which would otherwise choose not to perform abortions to do so, even if it went against their sacred beliefs. Such a law would undermine choice, and might begin the process by which abortion is enforced as a preferred option, instead of being one possible choice for a doctor to practice.

It is because of such concern we write. We urge you to engage us, and to dialogue with us, and to do so before you consider signing this legislation. Let us reason together and search out the implications of FOCA. Let us carefully review it and search for contradictions of those positions which we hold in common.
If FOCA can be postponed for the present, and serious dialogue begun with us, as well as with those who disagree with us, you will demonstrate that your administration will indeed be one that rises above partisanship, and will be one of change. This might well be the first step toward resolving an issue which tears at the fabric of our churches, our political process, our families, our very society, and that causes so much hardship and heartache in pregnant women.

Likewise, you have also recently stated you might over-ride some of President G.W. Bush’s executive orders. This is also a concern to us. We believe doing so without having a dialogue with the American people would undermine the political environment you would like to establish. Among those issues which concern us are those which would use taxpayer money to support actions we find to be morally questionable, such as embryonic stem cell research, or to fund international organizations that would counsel women to have an abortion (this would make abortion to be more than a mere choice, but an encouraged activity).

Consider, sir, your general promise to the American people and set aside particular promises to a part of your constituency. This would indicate that you plan to reject politics as usual. This would indeed be a change we need.

 

To which I add my name with the others:

Sincerely,

Fr. John Zuhlsdorf

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
19 Comments

What we learn from the internet

What we learn from the internet.

What we learn from the internet

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

A Mass in Wolfsthal in the Archd. of Vienna

UPDATE 19 Nov. 1948: GMT

I received this statement from Erich Leitenberger, the spokesman for His Eminence Christoph Card. Schönborn, Archbishop of Vienna.

This regards the entry below, where a video of the Mass in question is posted. 

 

Dear Father Zuhlsdorf,

regarding Your blog on the celebration of His Eminence in Wolfsthal I would like to beg you to publish my communiqué of yesterday for the orientation of your public.

Kind regards
Erich Leitenberger
Spokesperson for H.E. Card. Schönborn

The statement, sent to me in English.  I touched up the spelling slightly:

Some people have taken serious offense in the Holy Mass for young people which was celebrated by the Viennese Cardinal Christoph Schönborn on the 16th of November in Wolfsthal, a village close to the Austrian-Slovakian border.

In contrast to the presumption, due to the in many ways amateurish und unrealistic recorded broadcasting by Gloria TV, it must be clearly stated that in this celebration in no way any kind of liturgical specifications have been violated.

The Eucharistic bread was unleavened and its shape strictly followed the shape which has been used in the Middle East since the 1st century. The “flat cake” is similar to that form used in Mossul in these days – this is the metropolis located at river Tigris where Christians still testify the truth of Jesus with their own blood.

Werner Pirkner, the spiritual councilor for the Holy Mass in Wolfsthal, and Stephan Bazalka, coordinator of the Catholic Youth, paid highest attention to the fact that when breaking the bread no tiny little piece of bread ever touched the floor.

Those who have dared, tempted by a fragmentary news coverage, to bring forward accusations against the archbishop of Vienna, may contemplate, repent and ask God for his forgiveness. Let us pray all together for the Holy Church!

 

I am grateful for the statement from the spokeman for the Cardinal.

A few points.

First, we all want to give the young people and the Cardinal Archbishop the benefit of doubt.  The video production values may not have been the highest, but they were certainly of sufficient quality to show some of the things which happened.  That said, it is sometimes hard to tell what was happening when.

For example, while the spokesperson said that no liturgical specifications were violated, that is rubrics, etc., I am unfamiliar with the rubrics which directs us to write petitions on balloons.  Perhaps that was before Mass. I don’t know.

Also, I am not sure what material the vessels were made from.  Perhaps those were, in fact, the very best that community had available.  But I believe that it may have been some kind of glazed pottery or glass.

I am sure that at the altar, the greatest care was taken when breaking the Eucharist in its substantial form.  However, the video shows young people holding in their hands large pieces of the Eucharist and eating from them bit by bit.  It seems to me that this creates a great risk for profanation of the Eucharist. 

It am not sure why it is in any way relevant, in the Archdiocese of Vienna, what sort of bread is being used in Mossul on the Tigris.  That Christians are still suffering in Mossul doesn’t constitute a good reason for using their style of bread for the Eucharist.  It might be a good reason to share that bread together at a reception after Mass, but not during Mass.  That is just my opinion.

Finally, I cannot in my wildest imagination that the Cardinal Archbishop of Vienna was involved in the planning of what we saw in the video.  Surely this is what he discovered on his arrival.  I recall His Eminence from many years ago in Rome when the Catechism was in preparation.  He was very kind.  Surely, this is one of those situations wherein a visting bishop is surprised to find all sorts of well-meaning people doing objectively absurd things and, being very kind, not wanting to hurt them. 

Let this be a lesson to us all.

END UPDATE

ORIGINAL ENTRY

Rivaling everything ridiculous done during the three days of darkness in LA, Vienna [actually Wolfsthal] has thrown its miter into the ring for sheer liturgical dopiness. 

Behold a video of Card. Schoenborn’s Mass in Wolfsthal for a gathering of young people.

(This video is no longer available.)

I think his use of the pallium makes it all that much more solemn, don’t you?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
327 Comments

CORK, Ireland – 22 Nov – Requiem TLM

CORK, Ireland - 22 Nov - Requiem TLMA friend wrote to inform us that…

St. Colman’s Society for Catholic Liturgy

St. Colman’s Society for Catholic Liturgy is pleased to announce that Requiem Mass in Latin will be celebrated for the Holy Souls according to the Missal of Blessed John XXIII at St. Patrick’s Pro-Cathedral Church,  Fermoy, Co. Cork, on Saturday, 22 November 2008 at 11 am.

All are welcome to attend and are encouraged to pray for the happy repose of the faithful departed.

Please note that a partial indulgence applicable to the souls in Purgatory is available, under the usual conditions, to any of the faithful who visits a cemetery and prays for the dead (cf. Enchiridion Indulgentiarum [1999],  concession 29, §2, 1°, p. 75).

 

It is very good to have that reminder of the indulgence.   This is IMPORTANT.

Posted in Mail from priests |
14 Comments

Coffee and donuts at St. Joan’s in Minneapolis

UPDATE 19 Nov 15:10 GMT

The Recovering Dissident Catholic has something to add:

People ask me, often, what brought me around. This is it. Right here. It is THE LORD. Communion is not just some communal parish meal like having coffee and cookies before or after Mass. Holy Communion is receiving THE LORD. You are not a Protestant! Quit believing like one!

 

________________________

I have on more than one occasion quipped that while many parishes have coffee and donuts on Sundays after Mass, St. Joan of Arc in my home town of Minneapolis was the only place I had ever seen coffee and donuts during Mass.

Now comes this from Fr. Jim DeBruycker, the pastor, writing to his flock in the Sunday bulletin of 16 Nov 2008.

Please read this while giving Father the benefit of the doubt, imagining what he has to contend with there, after all the years of looniness:

1. Using the Egan room as a hospitality room for coffee and cookies has become quite successful, too much so I fear. A number of people are bringing coffee and cookies to mass, which is not polite and is often messy, it makes it hard to sing and makes a mockery of the communion fast. Please no refreshments during the liturgy.

2. Intinction, dipping the host, is not part of the Latin rite. But what is bothering the communion distributors even more are people dipping their fingers in as well. I am ordering new chalices with wider brims. Please be careful and, when at all possible, drink from the cup.

3. Finally, the communion ministers who stand in front of the gym exit to the school building are complaining that they have to wrestle with parishioners leaving mass early. Communicants are being jostled out of line as early leavers try to reach the school doors. If you are leaving early, please leave by the parking lot doors. Thanks for your courtesy! – JRD

 

Where to begin…?

1. The Instruction Redemptionis Sacramentum states:

[92.] … [S]pecial care should be taken to ensure that the host is consumed by the communicant in the presence of the minister, so that no one goes away carrying the Eucharistic species in his hand. If there is a risk of profanation, then Holy Communion should not be given in the hand to the faithful.

[103.] … If [intinction] is employed, however, hosts should be used which are neither too thin nor too small, and the communicant should receive the Sacrament from the Priest only on the tongue.

[104.] The communicant must not be permitted to intinct the host himself in the chalice, nor to receive the intincted host in the hand. As for the host to be used for the intinction, it should be made of valid matter, also consecrated; it is altogether forbidden to use non-consecrated bread or other matter.

The reason one cannot receive an intincted Host in the hand is because of the Precious Blood and how it starts to dissolve the Host.  There is risk of profanation.  Redemptionis Sacramentum mentions profanation several times.  It is a serious concern.

Also, the Eucharistic fast is law there both the dispose the communicant and protect the Sacrament from profanation.  And Fr. DeBruycker is right: it is rude.  But it beyond rude, isn’t it?  Isn’t it sacrilegious?

2.  "dipping the Host is not part of the Latin rite".  Well.  It is permitted by law in the Latin Rite but it is to be controlled very carefully.   Reinstituting Communion on the tongue would really help solve this problem of people a) self intincting which they are not to do, and then doing it wrong.  Ironically, people cite St. Cyril of Jerusalem as a way to defend the very imprudent practice of Communion in the hand.  We hear forever blah blah that St. Cyril of Jerusalem said: "When thou goest to receive communion go not with thy wrists extended, nor with thy fingers separated, but placing thy left hand as a throne for thy right, which is to receive so great a King, and in the hollow of the palm receive the body of Christ, saying, Amen.".  (Myst. cat. 5.1)

Let’s read this more closely:

In Lecture XXIII in On the Mysteries 5, Cyril describes the communicants actions.  Follow along now with my emphases:

21.  In approaching therefore, come not with thy wrists extended, or thy fingers spread; but make thy left hand a throne for the right, as for that which is to receive a King. And having hollowed thy palm, receive the Body of Christ, saying over it, Amen.  So then after having carefully hallowed thine eyes by the touch of the Holy Body, [they touched it to their eyes] partake of it; giving heed lest thou lose any portion thereof; for whatever thou losest, is evidently a loss to thee as it were from one of thine own members.  For tell me, if any one gave thee grains of gold, wouldest thou not hold them with all carefulness, being on thy guard against losing any of them, and suffering loss?  Wilt thou not then much more carefully keep watch, that not a crumb fall from thee of what is more precious than gold and precious stones?  [For good reason Holy Church grew in her understanding of the Sacrament and moved away from this practice in both East and West.]

22.  Then after thou hast partaken of the Body of Christ, draw near also to the Cup of His Blood; not stretching forth thine hands, but bending, and saying with an air of worship and reverence, Amen, hallow thyself by partaking also of the Blood of Christ.  And while the moisture is still upon thy lips, touch it with thine hands, and hallow thine eyes and brow and the other organs of sense. [They touched their eyes and ears and nose with the Precious Blood.] Then wait for the prayer, and give thanks unto God, who hath accounted thee worthy of so great mysteries.

So, if we are going to be liturgical archeologists, what about the Precious Blood!   But if we can’t do that with the Precious Blood, then why should we be able to touch it at all unless consuming it?  Why should lay people touch the Host?  Are a priest’s hands not consecrated for this? 

Frankly, I don’t think new chalices are going to solve the problem.  Getting rid of the practice altogher will solve the problem.

And just how do they tell the difference between the donut crumbs and the spills of coffee, anyway?

3. Picture the scrum at the doorways.  I am sure that Fr. DeBruycker is concerned that some decorum be preserved in church.  But could he have mentioned that leaving church before Mass is over is, shall I say it, wrong?

I dunno, folks.  I know that Fr. DeBruycker has a real job on his hands there.  If you want a priest to pray for, he would be a good choice.  I am sure there are a lot of things to clean up at St. Joan’s and it will take time.

But … whew…  what to do?   Close it?  Reform it?   I am glad it’s not I there.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
52 Comments

Some nonsense from Andrew Sullivan

The young scholarship seeking Papist says that "Andrew Sullivan goes on a tear" after he hears about the Cardinal Stafford’s comments:

"The Vatican hierarchy has become radicalized under Benedict and John Paul II – so much so that they see the West since the 1960s as entirely a creature of resistance to Humanae Vitae, the papal declaration that all non-procreative sex is a moral evil.  But the notion that the recent election of Obama is a sign of the Apocalypse has, until now, been restricted to Protestant loonies. Until now…"

 

First, the Church does not say that "non-procreative sex is a moral evil".  The Church teaches that sexual acts must be open to the transmission of life.

Secondly, he has no special insight into the end times.  He can say nothing about whether we have arrived or not.  We just don’t know.

Thirdly, he sounds rather like the anti-Catholic Richard McBrien, who says much the same about Popes Benedict and John Paul.

Fourthly, his statement smacks of anti-Catholic bigotry.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
29 Comments

lunch

A few shots:

lunch

lunch

lunch

lunch

lunch

And while I was having my lunch, … what a difference a few minutes make.

lunch

lunch

Posted in My View |
18 Comments