Archbp. Naumann: most important issue to Catholics is abortion

A friend alerted me to this from the site of Kansas Liberty:

My emphases and comments:

Archbishop defends church’s ‘rights and responsibility’ to teach morals
Naumann says most important issue to Catholics is abortion

Last week the Roman Catholic archbishop of Kansas City, Kan., declared abortion should be the most important issue for Catholics to consider when deciding on who to vote for in the upcoming presidential election. This week, observers are still discussing the impact of the comment.

Archbishop Joseph Naumann, said other problems facing the United States today, including the war in Iraq, should be considered less important than the right to life.

“The church in the United States always cherished its rights and its responsibility to form the moral (conscience) of the country,” he said during his visit at University of Kansas’ Dole Institute of Politics.

Naumann did not endorse a specific candidate however.

Democratic presidential candidate Barack Obama is an abortion supporter.  During an April 2008 forum he told the audience, “Those of us, like myself, who believe that in this difficult situation it is a woman’s responsibility and choice to make in consultation with her doctor and her pastor and her family. I think we will continue to suggest that that’s the right legal framework to deal with the issue. But at least we can start focusing on how to move in a better direction than the one we’ve been in the past.”  [When was it that Sen. Obama described a baby as a "punishment"?]

Obama’s running mate, Sen. Joe Biden, a Catholic, also supports abortion, as does Kansas Gov. Kathleen Sebelius, another Catholic Obama supporter and a target for criticism by Naumann who has asked her to avoid taking communion.

    In contrast, Republican presidential candidate John McCain and vice presidential candidate Sarah Palin oppose abortion. Both are Protestant.

During a portion of questioning on abortion during the 2006 Alaska governor debate, Palin was asked how she would feel about abortion if her own daughter was the victim of rape and became pregnant.

    Palin replied, “I would choose life,” and said she would only support abortion if the mother’s life were in danger.  [Not a perfect position, but better than the alternative.]

According to the Faith and American Politics Survey, which was sponsored by Faith in Public Life and conducted by the Public Religion Research, both Catholic participants and the general public listed the economy as the most important issue to consider in the 2008 presidential election. The general public ranked abortion ninth in the top-10 list of most-important issues to consider for the 2008 election, trailed only by same-sex marriage. [Wow.]

    “The economy is just dominating almost every aspect of the election,” Dan Cox, the director of research and co-founder of Public Religion Research, told Kansas Liberty. “Interestingly enough Catholics look very similar to the general voting population on a bunch of items.”

Cox said Obama is also doing better with pro-life supporters than McCain is doing with the abortion supporters.

“Thirty percent of participants who said that abortion should be illegal in all cases said they are going to vote for Obama and out of those who said they think abortion should be legal in all cases, 25 percent say that they are voting for McCain,” he said.

According to the poll, Catholics 35 years of age and older are generally divided between McCain and Obama, while younger Catholics support Obama over McCain by 15 percent.

    Younger Catholics also differ with older group of Catholics on the issue of abortion with approximately 60 percent of the younger Catholics believing abortion should be legal in all or most cases, only half of the older group agrees. However seven out of 10 Catholics said they would vote for a candidate who disagrees with them on abortion.

The survey took a national sample of 2,000 adults and was conducted between August and September of 2008. Fred Solis, director of communications for the Catholic Diocese of Wichita, said the church does encourage its members to vote, but that it refrains from suggesting one candidate over another.

    “Certainly one of the foremost thoughts and beliefs that we Catholics hold is the dignity and respect for life as that is central and fundamental to our beliefs,” Solis told Kansas Liberty. “We as a church try to form a consciousness and share with the people of church what our thoughts and beliefs are and basically let them take those things into consideration when they go to the polls.”

Solis said the Catholic church’s stance on the importance of life isn’t something that is only vocalized during the election season.

“This is a position that has been constant for practically as long as the church has been in place and is not something we start to share or try to elevate our beliefs on every four years or whenever there is an election,” he said.

Paul Johnson, political science professor at the University of Kansas, said he felt abortion was less of an issue in the 2008 presidential campaign than it was in the 2004 or 2000 elections.

    “There is an even split in the public’s opinion on the issue so neither side can gain advantage by making a big deal out of it,” Johnson told Kansas Liberty. “So they are getting advantages by emphasizing other issues.”

In a 2001 US census, 50,873,000 respondents identified themselves as Catholics, which was a slight increase from the 1990 poll.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
11 Comments

QUAERITUR: Can a bishop forbid a priest to say Mass ad orientem?

From a priest reader.  This is edited to preserve anonymity.  My emphases:

Dear Fr. Z.: I have been transferred to a new assignment.  At that time I determined to celebrate Mass ad orientem. 

The bishop has received letters of complaint and through the Vicar General has asked me to turn around. 

I wish to know if the Bishop has any canonical power over me on this issue?

First, thank you for trying to bring your parish to a superior way of offering worship to Almighty God.

Second, I am not a canonist.   Therefore, I consulted a canonist.

Here is the slightly edited answer I received.

Canonically, it would not seem that the bishop has the right to outright "ban" ad orientem celebrations of the liturgy. Bishop Foley in Birmingham tried to do so, and was informed by the CDWDS [Congregation for Divine Worship and Discipline of the Sacraments] that his decree lacked effect. He then altered the decree to state that no ad orientem celebration of the Mass could be televised – which the CDWDS did not overturn.
 
So, it would seem that the bishop could make ad orientem celebrations difficult. He could, for example, mandate that at least one Mass per day be offered versus populum – [If a bishop cannot block ad orientem worship, can he really mandate versus populum?  If the priest has the right to celebrated ad orientem then how can he be told he cannot?  Interesting.] making it unwieldy in some parishes to reorient the sanctuary for each Mass.
 
It would be important to know – has this priest been assigned as pastor? If he’s been assigned as pastor, then it would be quite difficult for the bishop to remove him simply for celebrating Mass ad orientem – difficult, but not impossible. If he’s been assigned as pastor for the usual six-year term, and the bishop is nearing the end of his episcopate, and the pastor has significant support from his parishioners, then this might be a battle worth fighting (if so – urge him to keep a file with EVERYTHING in writing – if he has a phone call with the Vicar General, write up a letter to the VG immediately after hanging up saying, "What I heard in our phone call was XYZ. If my understanding is incorrect, please write to inform me of what you meant.").
 
In short, the Bishop can’t forbid what the universal law permits, but he can "regulate" it – (e.g., he couldn’t ban the use of the First Eucharistic Prayer, but he could say, for the First Sunday of Lent, I require all parishes to use the Second Eucharistic Prayer…). If he tries "regulating" too extensively, the CDWDS has demonstrated that they will happily step in if priests and faithful complain.

This is a pretty convincing answer.

The bishop cannot ban ad orientem worship but he might be able to regulate it to some degree.  I suppose this would also extend to the language of the liturgy.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, Mail from priests |
21 Comments

K of C’s: radio ad features heartbeat of 10-week-old unborn child

REPOST:

This is interesting:

Knights of Columbus airs pro-life ‘heartbeat’ radio ad

New Haven, Oct 6, 2008 / 08:25 pm (CNA).- A new Knights of Columbus radio spot featuring the heartbeat of a 10-week-old unborn child and urging listeners to vote pro-life has begun airing on radio stations around the U.S.

As the heartbeat plays, a woman’s voice says: “Listening to this makes me wonder – why would anyone question that her life has begun?”

“Vote your heart. Vote Pro-Life,” it concludes.

“The fact that the child whose heartbeat we hear is alive is simply a matter of science,” Supreme Knight Carl A. Anderson said in announcing the beginning of the ad campaign.

“We believe that it is vital that America’s pro-life community make it clear that they will reserve their votes for candidates of either party who are committed to protecting life from conception to natural death,” he continued.

The ad will be broadcast until the November 4 U.S. elections. A similar ad is planned for broadcast in Canada before the country’s October 14 election.

 

Kudos to my fellow Knights of Columbus.

Speaker Pelosi… Senator Biden… are you listening?

Catholic voters… are you listening?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on K of C’s: radio ad features heartbeat of 10-week-old unborn child

QUAERITUR: Bought a Baronius Missal… how to set up the ribbons

Here is a question from a reader.

It brings up good questions.  People often come to see their beloved old hand missals for Mass as treasures, dear old friend, a life-long companion. 

Thus, they probably use their hand-missals in very different ways… depending in part on the missal itself, of course.

Perhaps you might have a little discussion with this fellow.

I don’t use a hand missal very often, obviously.

Hello Fr. Z.  I’m a seminarian, and our bookstore got in a few 1962 missals from Baronius Press.  I bought one but don’t know where to start.  How should I setup the ribbons?  Is there a guide, like the Ordo put out by the Paulist Press, that helps you figure out what page you should be on given the day?  Thanks for any help you can give me.

 

 

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box |
43 Comments

On the way home

After my travels I am finally heading back to the Sabine Farm.

So…. yet another airport.

On the way home

On the way home

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

Nice photo from the Pontifical Mass

This is from the Pontifical Mass at Old St. Patrick’s last Saturday.

Nice photo from the Pontifical Mass

Posted in My View |
32 Comments

Don’t worry

His Hermeneuticalness has a great post about happiness in the present moment over at his excellent place.

Here is a portion of it.    Do go visit him, however.  He ranges from Stocism, eschatology, to … and I love it when he does this … another exposition of Richard Dawkins for the crass dolt he really is.

I also love the story of St John Fisher’s final hours in the Tower. On 22 June 1535, when the Lieutenant of the Tower of London came to tell him that he was to be executed that morning, there was this exchange:

‘Well,’ quoth the Bishop, ‘if this be your errand hither, it is no news unto me; I have looked daily for it. I pray you, what is it a’clock?’

‘It is,’ quoth the Lieutenant, ‘about five.’

‘What time,’ quoth the bishop, ‘must be mine hour to go out hence?’

‘About ten of the clock,’ said the Lieutenant.

‘Well, then,’ quoth the bishop, ‘I pray you, let me sleep an hour or twain. For I may say to you, I slept not much this night, not for fear of death, I tell you, but by reason of my great sickness and weakness.’

In other words, "Although I am going to have my head chopped off in a couple of hours, I’m a bit tired and I’d just like to get a little more sleep."

Perhaps St. John Fisher can intercede in the matter of the upcoming elections in the USA.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
8 Comments

“If we do not believe in miracles, we do not ask for them.”

I found this on a refrigerator.   Then I discovered that I wrote it.

I guess that memory isn’t what it used to be.

This was from a post I did on the 2nd miracle of St. Gianna Molla. 

(This is also the first time I have ever posted from a Mac.) 

Saints are presented to us by Holy Mother Church for “the two I’s”: imitation and intercession.
As all Christians are called to imitate Christ, we also must experience self-emptying and the Cross, abandonment to providence and self-donation. We must be willing to lose everything.
We are not alone: the Church Militant and the Church Triumphant are closely knit, interwoven in charity. We on earth mustintercede for each other and believe and ask for the intercession of the saints.
God makes use of the weak to demonstrate His might and love.
If we do not believe in miracles, we do not ask for them. If we do not ask for them, they will not be granted.
Our life of faith is noticed by non-believers and they are not unaffected.
What a difference a bishop can make.
How often do you invoke the help of the saints and holy angels?
God’s ways are not our ways.
No one is too small to be an occasion of grace for others.
 

Posted in Classic Posts |
11 Comments

Monsignori

There is an old phrase.

"What’s the difference between a regular priest and a monsignor?"

Answer: "None, though most monsignors forget that.

Well… there are monsignors and there are monsignors.  It is both a church honor given to some priests and a title applied more broadly.

Check out Shouts and Fr. Selvester’s good posts on "monsignors" and ecclesiastical heraldry.

Here is a tease.

Monsignori

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
34 Comments

KC Blognic underway!

The blognic is underway! We started later because Mass at Old St Patrick’s started late and went long. Coffee is hot and strong.

KC Blognic underway!

KC Blognic underway!

KC Blognic underway!

KC Blognic underway!

KC Blognic underway!

Posted in Blognics, On the road, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
21 Comments