Card. O’Brien writes hard letter to PM Gordon Brown!

My friend Fr. Blake of St. Mary Magdalen in Brighton has posted a letter of His Eminence Keith Patrick Card. O’Brien, Archbishop of St Andrews and Edinburgh, to Prime Minister Gordon Brown.

OPEN LETTER TO THE PRIME MINISTER

28 October 2008

Dear Gordon

I write this open letter to you on a matter of immediate urgency, namely tomorrow’s debate in the Lords on the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill. Although I was relieved that last week’s debate in the Commons on the Bill did not address the issue of abortion, I remain convinced that the Bill is misguided and certain sections are potentially most harmful.

Among these is Schedule 3 which has never been properly discussed in Parliament. It provides for taking tissue from incapacitated adults and children without their consent for the express purpose of creating embryos for research. [hideous] It will be debated in the House of Lords tomorrow (Wednesday 29 October) with Government support.

The Bill could allow for the derivation and use of human eggs from the ovarian tissue of aborted baby girls, a proposal which was first aired by the HFEA in 1994. The HFEA public consultation at that time showed that 83.2% of the 9,000 respondents opposed the practice, and even the few in favour underlined the necessity of consent.

Should this Bill become law, removing tissue from incapacitated adults or children, without their specific consent in order to create animal-human hybrid or other embryos would be permissible, as would creating artificial sperm or artificial eggs from bone marrow or even cord blood.

The grotesque implications of these procedures are utterly horrifying. [You can say that again.] The proposals in this Bill represent a breach of 50 years of ethical medical research. They by-pass the Declaration of Helsinki, the Human Tissue Act, the Mental Capacity Act and the Human Rights Act. Removing parts of people’s bodies without their consent, utterly flies in the face of all BMA and GMC guidance on consent to research.

Such behaviour was last seen under the Nazis. Following the liberation of the concentration camps in 1945, the full horrors of the Nazi’s atrocities were revealed to a shocked world. The hideous savagery of their experiments convinced the civilized world that such practices must be outlawed forever. I am appalled that you are promoting a Bill which seeks, by stealth, to create a regime where extracting tissue and cells from human beings no longer requires their consent or involvement.

I am staggered that you would endorse legislation, which describes the creation of embryos from a person without their consent as ‘non-invasive’ and which enshrines the concept of ‘presumed consent’ in UK law. This legislation would set a nightmarish precedent, by allowing scientists to experiment on those lacking capacity – in the absence of explicit consent – largely as they see fit. [And as they interpret "capacity".]

I urge you to amend Schedule 3 of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill as a matter of great urgency and human decency.

Yours sincerely in Christ

+ Keith Patrick Cardinal O’Brien
Archbishop of St Andrews and Edinburgh

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
17 Comments

An election prayer

Election Prayer

by Fr. John A. Hardon, S.J.

Lord Jesus Christ, You told us to give to Caesar what belongs to Caesar, and to God what belongs to God. Enlighten the minds of our people [in] America. May we choose a President of the United States, and other government officials, according to Your Divine Will. Give our citizens the courage to choose leaders of our nation who respect the sanctity of unborn human life, the sanctity of marriage, the sanctity of marital relations, the sanctity of the family, and the sanctity of the aging. Grant us the wisdom to give You, what belongs to You, our God. If we do this, as a nation, we are confident You will give us an abundance of Your blessings through our elected leaders. Amen.

Composed by Father John Anthony Hardon, S.J.

Imprimatur: +Rene H. Gracida, Bishop of Corpus Christi, July 7, 1992
Published by Eternal Life in 1992

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
12 Comments

Willmington: Bp. Malooly corrects Sen. Biden in the newspaper

His Excellency Frances Malooly, the new Bishop of Willmington, Delaware, had an op-ed piece the other day in the News-Journal.

This is the diocese of pro-abortion vice-presidential candidate Sen. Joseph Biden (D-DE).

My emphases and comments.

    Catholic Church has made no exception regarding abortion since ancient times

    In his interview with The News Journal published Oct. 19, Sen. Joe Biden presents a seriously erroneous picture of Catholic teaching on abortion. He said, “I know that my church has wrestled with this for 2,000 years,” and claimed repeatedly that the Church has a nuanced view of the subject that leaves a great deal of room for uncertainty and debate.  [The ability to learn, to correct mistakes, is sign of reasonably intelligent people.  Sen. Biden has been instructed, clearly and publicly, from various sources in such a way that he cannot be any longer unclear about the Church’s true positions.  Therefore, he is either being willfully deceptive or he is incapable of learning.]

    This is simply incorrect. [probably dishonest too] The teaching of the Church is clear and not open to debate. Abortion is a grave sin because it is the wrongful taking of an innocent human life. The Church received the tradition opposing abortion from Judaism. In the Greco-Roman world, early Christians were identifiable by their rejection of the common practices of abortion and infanticide.  [Ancient Romans didn’t seem to like it much either.]

    The Didache, probably the earliest Christian writing apart from the New Testament, explicitly condemns abortion without exceptions. It tells us there is a “way of life” and a “way of death” and abortion is a part of the way of death. This has been the consistent teaching of the Church ever since.

    It was also the position of Protestant reformers without exception. It was the teaching of Pope John XXIII as well as Pope John Paul II. It is the teaching of Pope Benedict XVI and the bishops of the Church, including me as shepherd of this diocese.

    Some ancient and medieval theologians did see a difference between early abortions and ones that occurred later in term because with the limited medical knowledge of the time they did not know then what we scientifically know now: that a fetus is a living human being from conception.

    Nevertheless, they universally condemned all abortions.

    Of course, we now know that a fetus is a living human being from the very start. Thus, abortions take innocent human lives no matter when they occur. Since there is no gradation in the Church’s teaching on abortion, there is no way the medically obsolete division of pregnancy into three trimesters by Roe v. Wade can have any bearing on the rightness or wrongness of abortion. Taking an innocent life in the womb is wrong at any stage of pregnancy.

    The Declaration of Independence lists life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness as God-given rights. Life is listed first, and it is the principal function of the state to protect the lives of citizens. This understanding of the state’s primary obligation to protect human life is also fundamental to Catholic social doctrine to which the senator points. Without life all other rights are meaningless.

    This Sunday, all the parishes in the Catholic Diocese of Wilmington will pray the Litany of St. Thomas More, martyr and patron saint of statesmen, politicians and lawyers. [Hmm… not a litany approved for liturgical use.  But I guess if the bishop is doing it, it’s approved!] We will ask St. Thomas More to intercede so all statesmen and politicians may be courageous and effective in their defense and promotion of the sanctity of human life. We hope [and pray] Sen. Biden will carefully listen to the Church’s 2,000 years of testimony on abortion and that he will join in the defense and promotion of the sanctity of life.

    Most Rev. W. Francis Malooly, bishop, Catholic Diocese of Wilmington

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
19 Comments

Is there a correlation?

I think it would be interesting to explore whether there is any overlap in the list of US bishops who have been supportive of Summorum Pontificum on the one hand, and the list of US bishops who have made strong public statements about life issues in the last, say three months.

Off the top of my head, think of Bp. Morlino of Madison and Archbp. Burke once of St. Louis.

Someone should look at this.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
31 Comments

Bp. Gracida: Catholics can’t vote for pro-abortion candidates

From a reader about the Bishop of Corpus Christi, Texas:

Catholic Bishop Rene H. Gracida Releases Radio Ad Stating no Catholic can Vote for Barack Obama in Good Conscience

MEDIA ADVISORY, October 24 /Christian Newswire/ — Today – perhaps in an eleventh hour answer to prayer for the unborn – Bishop Rene H. Gracida has released a stunning radio ad concerning Catholics voting for Barack Obama. His ad is recorded in English and Spanish.

Bishop Gracida boldly states:

"This is Bishop Rene H. Gracida, reminding all Catholics that they must vote in this election with an informed conscience. A Catholic cannot be said to have voted in this election with a good conscience if they have voted for a pro-abortion candidate. Barack Hussein Obama is a pro-abortion candidate."

The commercial can be heard in English and Spanish at www.randallterry.com.

Bishop Gracida has offered this radio spot without charge for all who want to use it. All faithful Catholics are invited to download the mp3 file, and place this ad on their local radio station(s).
They must simply contact their local radio station (s), and pay for the ad as an "independent expenditure." The station can download the audio file to play on the radio. The mp3 file is also available at www.randallterry.com.

Moreover, permission is granted for the ad to be downloaded, sent as a file, or posted on any web site in America.

If this ad receives the airplay it deserves, it could sink Obama’s campaign by jolting Catholic voters back to their senses and moorings. Over 50% of Catholic voters have been seduced into ethical quicksand by errant Catholics who are partisan supporters of Obama and have betrayed the lives of innocent unborn children.

Contact: Randall Terry. 904 687 9804
Christian Newswire

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
62 Comments

More photos of the Old St. Patrick’s consecration online

The site Kansas Catholic has some great photos of the consecration of Old Saint Patrick this last weekend.  Check it out!

Here are a couple teasers.

More photos of the Old St. Patrick's consecration online

More photos of the Old St. Patrick's consecration online
 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
9 Comments

A Sabine view

Just because it’s pretty.

A Sabine view

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

“Pronto, Vaticano”

Years ago, when I worked in the Vatican and cellphones were not yet an option, placing some calls required you to go through the Vatican switchboard.  So, I can attest to much of the substance of this article.

Here is a great piece in the LA Times.

Vatican switchboard sees a human touch as the answer

Maria De Cristofaro / For The Times

The multilingual Sister Maria Grazia, front, handles calls mostly from Asia, Africa and the Americas. Quite a few people say they need an exorcist.

For 50 years, callers to the Holy See have found the sweet voice of a nun at the other end of the line. The sisters field half a million calls a year from the friendly, the loud, the troubled.

By Sebastian Rotella

8:16 PM PDT, October 27, 2008

Reporting from Vatican City — Telecommunications technology of the early 21st century has produced a phenomenon known as "phone hell": an audio inferno where callers are tormented either by mechanized voices or human ones with less soul than the machines.

But the opposite exists. It can be found here in a simply furnished second-floor room where multilingual nuns in gray habits answer phones with an unfailingly sweet-voiced greeting: "Pronto, Vaticano" (Hello, Vatican).  [YES!  That’s it!]

For 50 years, the nuns of the order of the Sister Disciples of the Divine Master have operated the Vatican switchboard. They are the gatekeepers of the Holy See.

The sisters field half a million calls a year from all over the world. They assist the friendly, the loud, the troubled. They help the faithful negotiate a labyrinthine Roman Catholic Church bureaucracy whose instincts tend toward discretion, if not mystery.  [I would say, rather, obfuscation.]

Sister Maria Clara, the 55-year-old chief operator, is gentle and bespectacled, her Italian tinged with her native Korean. After 11 years on the switchboard, she sees her job as a blessed calling.

"People ask us: ‘So you really work on Christmas? You work on Easter?’ " she said. "Of course we do. The church is a mystic body. I feel that we are the heart of the church. And the heart never stops."

Behind her, half a dozen colleagues murmured into headsets. They occasionally consulted Bible-sized directories next to their computer terminals.

Many calls were routine inquiries about papal activities, hotels, museums. That information is available in a recorded message as well, but church officials want to preserve an oasis in the often harsh subculture of switchboards.

"People are adamant, they say, ‘I don’t want to be answered by a machine!’ " said Andrea Mellini, the gray-bearded director of the Vatican’s telecommunications department. His staff includes an Austrian engineer and 10 nuns from locales as diverse as India and Poland. "I like to think this is the most human call center there is. We can treat people the way others do not."

It takes time, skill and diligence for the operators to figure out the internal workings of the Vatican, Mellini said. Their average age is close to 60.

Sister Maria Grazia, 71, became an operator 14 years ago after serving as a missionary in Africa. The robust, jolly Italian speaks English, Spanish, French and Korean and gets by in other languages too. Most of her calls come from Asia, Africa and the Americas. And she talks to quite a few people who say they need an exorcist.

"It’s hard to tell whether they are psychologically ill, whether they are in the grip of a sect or whether it is something else," she said.

At least once a day, someone insists on speaking, urgently and directly, with Pope Benedict XVI himself. The sisters respond with tact and prudence. They never say an outright "No."

Instead they try to learn more and see if a priest, the Vatican press room or a church official can help.

"Sometimes they won’t be satisfied with even a bishop — their problem can only be solved by the pope," Sister Maria Grazia said.

Some callers cross the line between tormented and deranged, between lonely and abusive.

Most of those calls, however, take place during the midnight shift when a skeleton crew of male operators — civilians, not priests — takes over.

The sisters work from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. They recognize and tolerate certain regulars. One frequent caller identifies himself as Saint John the Baptist. He’s harmless, though he gets touchy if they don’t address him as "Saint John."

"He asks me to pray with him, and I do," Sister Maria Clara said earnestly. "Sometimes I have to put him on hold to take other calls. But he waits."

A poster near her desk depicts Don Giacomo Alberione, the founder of the 94-year-old Pious Society of Saint Paul to which the sisters’ order belongs. Alberione’s image is juxtaposed against telecom towers emitting waves and the word "Evangelism."

Alberione’s life work focused on the church’s communications and media activities: books, radio, film, the press. In the 1950s, Pope Pius XII gave him the mission of modernizing the Vatican’s phone system.  [And they should be getting right on that any time now.]

"And because he was also a visionary when it came to the equality of women, he decided that the sisters should be the ones to staff the switchboard," Mellini said.

The Vatican has accepted modernization; the sisters will get some state-of-the-art pointers soon during a seminar with an outside expert. But the sisters are determined that some things will never change.

"At least when they call us they don’t hear a machine, they hear a voice," Sister Maria Grazia said. "There is always a voice."

Rotella is a Times staff writer.

rotella@latimes.com

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
12 Comments

Thanks to readers and Penjing update

It is time once again to thank you readers for… well.. several things.

Thanks to readers and Penjing updateFirst, I repeat my gratitude to those of you who voted for WDTPRS on the Blogger’s Choice Awards.  WDTPRS came in first, as you may recall.  Your support keeps the Catholic blogs at the top of the "religion" categories in these award sites.

BTW.. wasn’t I supposed to get a Veyron for winning one of these things?  Hmm…

Second, many thanks to those of you who have used the donation button on the side bar and some other posts, such as the PODCAzT entries.  Your support Thanks to readers and Penjing updateis more important than you probably realize.  Not only is it a great boost psychologically, but it also is helping to take care of some other necessary things. 

Thanks to readers and Penjing updateThird, some of you have used the wishlist recently.  When I returned to the Sabine Farm from my recent trip the east coast and then Kansas City, I found a couple boxes waiting for me with goodies inside.  First, thanks to JH of MN for the copy of Politics and the Order of Love: An Augustinian Ethic of Democratic Citizenship by Eric Gregory.  Not, perhaps, entertaining reading, but the book should be useful.  Thanks!

Also, sincere gratitude goes "down under" to SS of NSW.  SS of NSW sent a box with all sorts of little boxes inside, all wrapped up.  I will save them for later this evening.  I will probably have to lift my spirits after what is probably going to be a nightmare session at the dentist today to address a pretty serious problem.  Grrr.  These will do the trick, I think.

Thanks to readers and Penjing update

PENJING REPORT

On my return to the Sabine Farm, I found that Irohamomiji is still clinging to a single leaf.  Pretty dismal.

Penjing has also dropped a bunch of leaves, but there is new growth also. 

Here is penjing with the newest amazon arrival.

Thanks to readers and Penjing update

And near my workspace to get the little sun this late time of the year can offer.

Thanks to readers and Penjing update

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
4 Comments

Card. Castrillon responds to some questions about Summorum Pontificum

A kind reader alerted me to a interesting set of responses from His Eminence Dario Card. Castrillon Hoyos to questions about Benedict XVI’s Summorum Pontificum.   The Q&A is, interestingly enough, posted on clerus.va, the website of the Congregation for Clergy.  Under Card. Castrillon, Clergy developed their own web presence, apart from the Vatican’s efforts to stall the Church’s proper use of the internet.  But I digress…

The tireless crew over at NLM has declared that they are working on a translation of the whole thing, but here is the first part, which is the most interesting.  The original is in Italian:

Responses of the Cardinal President of the Pontifical Commission "Ecclesia Dei" to certain queries

From the Pontifical Commission "Ecclesia Dei" began to receive frequent questions about the reasons for the Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum, some of which were grounded in the prescriptions of the 3 October 1984 document Quattuor abhinc annos sent by the Congregation for Divine Worship to presidents of bishops conferences, the President of the same Commission, His Eminence Dario Card. Castrillon Hoyos considered it opprtune to give the following responses:

QUESTION: Is it licit to make reference to the Letter Quattuor abhinc annos in order to regulate questions pertaining to the celebration of the Extraordinary Form of the Roman Rite, namely, according to the Roman Missal  of 1962?

ANSWER: Obviously, no.  Because with the publication of the Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum the prescriptions for the use of the 1962 Missal emanating from Quattuor abhinc annos, and successively from the Motu Proprio of the Servant of God John Paul II Ecclesia Dei adflicta, have lapsed. 

In fact, the same Summorum Pontificum, beginning with article 1, explicitly affirms that: "the conditions for the use of the Missal established by the previous documents Quattuor abhinc annos and Ecclesia Dei adflicta have been replaced".  The Motu Proprio enumerates the new conditions.

Thus, one cannot make reference to the restrictions for celebration with the 1962 Missal established by those two documents.

QUESTION:  What are the substantive differences between the last Motu Proprio and the two preceding documents pertaining to this matter?

ANSWER: The first substantial difference is certainly that now it is licit to celebrate Holy Mass according to the Extraordinary Rite without any longer the need for special permission, called an "indult".  The Holy Father Benedict XVI established, once and for tall, that the Roman Rite consists of two Forms, to which he desired to give the name of "Ordinary Form" (the celebration of the Novus Ordo, according to the 1970 Missal of Paul VI) and the "Extraordinary Form" (the celebration of the Gregorian Rite, according to the 1962 Missal of Bl. John XXIII) and he confirmed that this 1962 Missal was never abrogated.  Another difference is that in the Mass celebrated without people, every Catholic priest of the Latin Rite, whether secular or religious, can use one or the other Missal (article 2).  Moreover, in Masses without people or with people, it pertains to the pastor [parish priest] or the rector of the church where one intends to celebrate, to give the permission for all priests who present a "celebret" given by their own Ordinary.  If these (pastors) should deny permission, the bishop, according to the norm of the Motu Proprio, must provide that the permission be conceded. (cf. art. 7).

That is the first part.  After this, there is an exploration of the work of the Commission of Cardinals in 1986.   I don’t see any purpose in reduplicating the work being done over at NLM, so I will leave that to them.

However, there are interesting things to consider in the responses above.

First, I have heard from time to time how, incredibly, critics of Summorum Pontificum have in fact tried to quote Quattuor abhinc annos and Ecclesia Dei adflicta against Pope Benedict’s prescriptions. 

Second, directly in the face of those who are still claiming that the 1962MR reallywas abrogated, the Cardinal President is reminding everybody that, no, it really WASN’T.

Third, notice that the second response refers not only to the regulation of the use of the older form by pastors of churches, but also rectors.  It is not stated explicitly in Summorum Pontificum that rectors also have this right, though it is reasonable to assume they do.  So, are we glimpsing something of the now infamous clarification document that we have been waiting for for so long? 

Fourth, notice what impact that second response would have on, say, a shrine a priest is visiting.  

During my recent trip to Emmitsburg, where the Shrine of St. Elizabeth Ann Seton is located, I was told that to this day priests have been refused the right to say Mass with the 1962 Missale Romanum.   There is even a sign to that effect in the sacristy at the Shrine.  So… if a priest wanted to say Mass there, a reasonable request, the bishop would have to be informed that an obstacle was placed in the priest’s path.   This would have to apply to pilgrimage places as well, such as Fatima, Altotting or Lourdes.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
22 Comments