4 million today!

We hit the 4,000,000 mark for visits today!

That’s 4 mil since I started using Sitemeter.

Who was it?

UPDATE:

It’s done!

Flensburg, Schleswig-Holstein

Visitor’s Time         Sep 28 2008 10:49:04 pm
Visit Number         4,000,000

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
32 Comments

The Pope people forget to remember

Say a prayer for His Holiness Pope John Paul I, who unexpectedly died on this day in 1978.

The Pope people forget to remember

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
17 Comments

Observations of a priest new to the TLM

From a priest reader:

I hope priests continue to write in.  I would like their contributions to be a regular feature here.

Fr. Z.,

I am a pastor who recently began offering Mass in the Extraordinary Form.

In fact, today marked my third Sunday! I have a reflection on my experience that I’d like to share with you. It is, perhaps, related to the story on the altar rail you posted recently. [Here and here.]

Offering Mass in the EF is difficult. I think I spent a few hours learning the OF. In fact, in a couple of hours, anyone could learn to do all the page turning and gestures of the OF. On the other hand, I spent probably 20 to 30 hours learning the EF.

Also, you would have the add the three years I spent studying Latin in the Seminary.

My point is simply this: whether consciously or unconsciously, there is no one in the congregation who could say "I could do that." 

In the EF the priest and the people would sense more strongly that the priest is doing something out of the ordinary (no pun intended); that he is doing something that no one else could do.

This practical reality helps to disclose his ontological reality.  Just thought I’d share that with you.

Thanks for that!  And keep up the good work!

 

In his observation that the Ordinary Form is so simple that anyone could learn to do it in a short period of time, the writer brings to my mind a serious error made by those who support the ordination of women and those who don’t grasp what a "minister" is the in Catholic sense.

Priesthood and ministry are not merely grounded in "doing stuff".  If that were the case, then it would make sense to put in those positions the people who do the better job of it.  Saying Mass, or being a minister in the deeper sense goes beyond simply being the one who can do the job better than others who might have been chosen.

I think this could also apply to the "altar girl"/server issue.  Just because some girls could do a better job serving than some boys of the same age doesn’t mean that it is a good thing for girls to serve Mass.

At a certain point we must check ourselves to see if we are falling into this trap when we consider ministry in the Church.

Posted in Mail from priests, SESSIUNCULA |
40 Comments

Where are you?

I am always fascinated to see how many different places around the world whence people are when they visit WDTPRS.

Here is a snapshot of the last few minutes.

(These places are sometimes approximations.)

Bloomington, Illinois
Salt Lake City, Utah
Tup, Sao Paulo
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Odessa, Texas
Rochdale
Windsor, Ontario
Boston, Massachusetts
Gainesville, Florida
Belize
Newtownabbey
Farnham, Surrey
Columbus, Ohio
Prague, Hlavni Mesto Pr…
London, London, City of
Zanesville, Ohio
Ambler, Pennsylvania
Grand Rapids, Michigan
Ambler, Pennsylvania
Grand Rapids, Michigan
Birmingham
Wakefield, Massachusetts
Spokane, Washington
Nova Iguau, Rio de Jane…
Latrobe, Pennsylvania
York
Grande Prairie, Alberta
Troy, Michigan
Sigmaringen, Baden-Wurt…
Glasgow, Glasgow City
Montpelier, Vermont
Cincinnati, Ohio
Paris, Ile-de-France
Dartford, Kent
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania
Saint Paul, Minnesota
Coldwater, Michigan
Galway
New York
Saint Marys, Ontario
Manchester
Portland, Oregon
Memphis, Tennessee
Lincoln, Nebraska
Crawfordsville, Indiana
Raleigh, North Carolina
Nova Iguau, Rio de Jane…
Crawley, West Sussex
Grand Rapids, Michigan
Washington, District of…
Memphis, Tennessee
Washington, District of…
Manchester, New Hampshire
Austin, Texas
Watford, Hertford
Maynooth, Kildare
Manchester, New Hampshire
Espoo, Southern Finland
Brooklyn, New York
Milan, Lombardia
Braga
Salem, Oregon
Cambridge, Massachusetts
Kansas City, Missouri
San Diego, California
Claremont, North Carolina
Yonkers, New York
Pleasureville, Kentucky
Swindon
Charlotte, North Carolina
Colorado Springs, Color…
Madrid
Dorchester, Dorset
Waterloo, Iowa
London, London, City of
Bowie, Maryland
Tacoma, Washington
Steubenville, Ohio
Emmitsburg, Maryland
Rome, Lazio
Brussels, Brussels Hoof…
Fayetteville, New York
Sheffield
Bronxville, New York
Blue Springs, Missouri
Groton, Massachusetts
Cleveland, Ohio
Chandler, Arizona
Blackwater, Missouri
Waterloo, Ontario
Flint, Michigan
Ojai, California
Middletown, Connecticut
Hamburg
Cannock, Staffordshire
Klasard, Skane Lan
Manila
Quebec
Lake Charles, Louisiana
Cardiff
Atlanta, Georgia
Chicago, Illinois
Salt Lake City, Utah
Winnipeg, Manitoba
Minneapolis, Minnesota
Bel Air, Maryland
Santiago, Region Metrop…
Newburyport, Massachuse…
Anchorage, Alaska
Iselin, New Jersey
Portland, Oregon
Lansing, Michigan
Columbus, Ohio
Trenton, New Jersey
Albuquerque, New Mexico
Washington, District of…
Auburn, Michigan

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
29 Comments

Card. Castrillon’s intro to new edition of Fortescue/O’Connell

A new edition of The Ceremonies of the Roman Rite Described edited by Alcuin Reid is being produced.

A kind soul sent me the text of the introduction to the edition by the President of the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei, His Eminence Dario Card. Castrillon Hoyos.

Let’s have a look with my emphases and comments.

It is a pleasure for me to present this fifteenth edition of Ceremonies of the Roman Rite Described, the first edition to appear since the Motu Proprio of our Holy Father, Pope Benedict XVI, Summorum Pontificum, dated 7th July 2007, definitively clarified that the rites according to the liturgical books in use in 1962 were never abrogated [Just in case it wasn’t clear to those who continue to claim that the older rites were abrogated.]  and that they truly constitute a treasure that belongs to the entire Catholic Church and should be widely available to all of Christ’s faithful.  [NB: widely available because they belong to the "entire" Church.  The consequence of this is that priests should bring these treasures to people even when they haven’t asked for them.] It is now clear that Catholics have a juridical right to the more ancient liturgical rites, ["juridical right"] and that parish priests and bishops must accept the petitions and the requests of the faithful who ask for it. ["must"  What this doesn’t clarify is the rights of priests not to use the Extraordinary Use.  Do priests have the right to refuse to celebrate the Extraordinary Use?  If that is the case what right do they have to refuse to use the Ordinary Use?  Can they refuse one and not be permitted to refuse the other?] This is the express will of the Supreme Pontiff, legally established in Summorum Pontificum in a manner that must be respected by ecclesiastical superiors and local ordinaries alike.  [I remember that John Paul II in Ecclesia Dei adflicta said this in stronger terms.  He was nearly entirely ignored.]

The Holy Father is pleased at the generous response of many priests to his initiative in learning once again the rites and ceremonies of the Sacrifice of the Mass and of the other sacraments according to the usus antiquior so that they may serve those people who desire them. I encourage priests to do so in a spirit of pastoral generosity and love for the liturgical heritage of the Roman Rite. Seminarians, as part of their formation in the liturgy of the Church, should also become familiar with this usage of the Roman Rite not only in order to serve the People of God who request this form of Catholic worship but also in order to have a deeper appreciation of the background of the liturgical books presently in force. Hence it follows that all seminaries should provide such training as a matter of course.   [I wonder how that is going this year.]

This book, a classic guide to the celebration of the Church’s ancient Gregorian Rite in the English-speaking world, will serve priests and seminarians of the twenty-first century – just as it served so many priests of the twentieth – in their pastoral mission, which now necessarily includes familiarity with and openness to the use of the older form of the sacred liturgy. I happily commend it to the clergy, seminarians and laity as a reliable tool for the preparation and celebration of the liturgical rites authoritatively granted by the Holy Father in Summorum Pontificum.

I congratulate the distinguished liturgical scholar, Dr. Alcuin Reid, for his care and precision in ensuring that this revised edition conforms to the latest authoritative decisions with regard to these liturgical rites. As Pope Benedict XVI wrote in his letter which accompanied Summorum Pontificum: “In the history of the liturgy there is growth and progress, but no rupture.” The Gregorian Rite [There is that term again.] is today a living liturgical rite which will continue its progress without losing any of its riches handed on in tradition. [That’ll freak a few people out.] For as the Holy Father continued, “What earlier generations held as sacred, remains sacred and great for us too, and it cannot be all of a sudden entirely forbidden or even considered harmful. It behooves all of us to preserve the riches which have developed in the Church’s faith and prayer, and to give them their proper place.” May this book assist the Church of today and of tomorrow in realising Pope Benedict’s vision.

Darío Cardinal Castrillón Hoyos
President
Pontifical Commission “Ecclesia Dei”
25 September 2008

 

This introduction is very strong but it raises questions.

We really need some clarifications from the Holy See about a range of issues.

But it is not necessary to make clear that Card. Castrillon continues to make strong statements about the will of the Holy Father in this regard.  If it weren’t true, he wouldn’t be repeating the same things.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
25 Comments

What Does the Samizdat Really Say?

I found this great comment on the blog of Damian Thompson Holy Smoke about the London Blognic (here and here).

A few nights ago I joined a group of Catholic bloggers in a pub in Victoria. They included the world-famous Fr Z from America, Fr Tim Finigan and Mac McLernon ("Mulier Fortis"). We felt like a group of East European dissidents swapping samizdat literature in the 1970s.

LOL!

 

For those of you born after the Cold War, "samizdat" is a Russian term for how dissidents against Soviet Communist oppression would create and circulate literature.

What Does the Samizdat Really Say? 

Posted in Linking Back |
3 Comments

A Protestant Pastor reacts to the Communion rail entry

When I see that someone has linked back to WDTPRS, I will sometimes go find out what is going on.  I often find gems.

For example, on the blog Power, Love, Self-Discipline a pastor of a United Church of Christ parish reflects on what I wrote here about Communion rails. 

Here is a large part, but you should go check out what he wrote in full.

A Protestant Pastor reacts to the Communion rail entry
I was on the blog yesterday of Father John Zuhlsdorf, a Catholic priest and prolific writer on all things Catholic and liturgical. If you follow the link, you’ll find an entry concerning altar rails.  Apparently, there are churches (even Catholic churches) that are tearing them out, seeking to reduce the distance between a priest and a parish that this physical dividing line inevitably causes.  But is this a good thing?  Father Z finds this to be a disturbing trend, and he argues for the usefulness of the altar rail.  But I want to draw your attention to one of his arguments in particular:

Lay people and the ordained have different roles in the liturgy. They have their own particular places. When you blur those places by making them less distinct, you undermine something important in the hearts and minds of the clergy and congregation.  When you constantly tell people that they are being empowered by being given things to do and places to sit or stand that cannot be distinguished from what the clergy do, you are really telling them that on their own they aren’t good enough. They are really not good enough unless they do things priests do, or sit where they sit.


This blew me away because it perfectly describes me.  Part of the reason I wanted to be a minister is because it seemed like I couldn’t be the best Christian I could be unless I was a minister.  All the best Christians I knew were pastors (I now see how wrong that was), which suggested to me that clergy were on another spiritual plane that couldn’t be accessed unless on was clergy.  Furthermore, if it was acceptable for me to preach as a 15-year-old, then I wasn’t doing enough, and was therefore less of a Christian, when I wasn’t preaching.  The thought never entered my mind that I may have a vital role to play in worship as a member of the congregation. 
I wonder if I would have felt this way if there were a greater distinction between clergy and congregation growing up, if the creep of egalitarianism wasn’t so strong.  What if there were places I wasn’t allowed to go on the altar?  What if someone had explained to me that there are things the pastor does that the congregation can’t do, and things the congregation does that the pastor can’t do?  What if I knew that both are essential for worship (and, by extension, we do great harm to the worship of the church when we don’t show up)?  I wonder if I would have valued the sacraments and the preaching of the Word more if I had a better understanding of the differences between ordained and lay.
…

I applaud this fellow’s questions. 

The writer, Pastor Sam Chamelin is 25 years old.

 

Posted in Linking Back |
10 Comments

QUAERITUR: Who should receive Anointing of the Sick?

A reader asks:

I have a friend who is undergoing foot surgery soon. Although it is minor surgery, she will be under general anesthesia for over two hours. Her sister ended up in a coma for two weeks following a surgery so she wants to make sure she has her ducks in order confession, anointing of the sick etc. She went to our pastor and wanted to make an appointment for anointing and he said that it was not serious enough surgery and that cannon law dictates she can’t receive it. He commented that the faithful don’t know enough cannon law to understand it is an abuse of the sacrament to give it so freely. Is this right? And is there abuse in giving the sacrament freely to those who are sick?  My friend is very upset about it. Your advice would be very welcome . Thank you for your help father. My prayers are with you.

In my opinion the priest is both right and wrong.

He is right that the sacrament should not be given frivolously.  And it is very often given frivolously!

For example, I have seen regularly scheduled Masses at a parish for seniors wherein everyone, even the young people who brought the seniors, troops up to be anointed.  That is an abuse of the sacrament for more than one reason.

First, though some of those people were pretty old, no one was in obvious danger of death.

Second, this sacrament should if possible be received in the state of grace.  If a person is incapacitated, the sacrament of Anointing also forgives sins, but if a person is capable of confessing he should confess properly and receive absolution before being anointed.

Third, group anointing like that both reduce respect for the sacrament and nearly always insure that the sacrament is improperly administrated.

So, people who are sick with a cold probably shouldn’t be given this sacrament. The Second Vatican Council said that "’Extreme Unction," which may also and more properly be called ‘anointing of the sick,’ is not a sacrament for those only who are at at the point of death.  Hence, as soon as anyone of the faithful begins to be in danger of death from sickness or old age, the fitting time for that person to receive this sacrament has certainly already arrived." [SC 73]

The problem is that everyone is always in danger of death, which comes to us we know not when.

Let us remember that Anointing was and still is called Extreme Unction… the word "Extreme" does not mean that you are giving it on a skateboard or you are using huge amounts of oil. 

It means that a person is "in extremis", that is, "in danger of dying".

IMO, I think she could be anointed due to the reason that she is going to have general anesthesia.  For me that is a deciding factor.  General anesthesia is always risky business, no matter what the actual surgery is, minor or major, because it often involves inducing paralysis and it requires airway management.

I am cautious about whom I anoint and for what reason.  I insist on regular confession and absolution, preferably after Mass with Communion, and then in close proximity to the actual surgery which must be risky enough to warrant this "danger of death" sacrament. 

My view of general anesthesia, even as highly developed as it is now, is such that I see it as an great enough risk to warrant anointing.  Other priests may not agree, and they are free to.  I have made my decision after discussions with physicians, including an anesthesiologist, and after having witnessed surgeries from the observer’s position next to the place where the anesthetist or anesthesiologist works, and after my own experiences of anesthesia.

In this case, I think it would be okay to seek the sacrament from another priest if the pastor does not want to administer it.

At the same time, I think it is good that the priest is diligent about the care of the Sacrament of Anointing.  He shouldn’t be overly criticized.  He seems to be taking it seriously, which is positive.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
49 Comments

San Diego TLM news

This sketchy news comes from San Diego.  I am guessing by "tommorow" he means "Sunday"

Folks… if you send news, send complete information.

I wanted to tell you that tomorrow, our Bishop, His Excellency Robert Brom, will be celebrating mass at St. Anne’s in SD.
Tomorrow will be the last day the parish will be in use for normal parish function, starting monday the parish will be dedicated solely to the celebration of the Extraordinary rite the Priestly Fraternity of St. Pius the X [?!?  Perhaps the Fraternity of St. Peter?] will be taking over the parish, renovating it and it will be made the diocese’ first parish to be dedicated exclusively to the venerable older form of the mass. The Parish it located just south of downtown, It is an excellent location for the largest possible accessibility.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
20 Comments

Telegraph: ten commandments for bloggers

Apparently other Christian groups are envious of the Vatican’s infamously strange  "ten commandments for driving" and they have begun to put out their own lists.

Here is a story from The Telegraph in the UK:

Bloggers given new Ten Commandments by church leaders

Christian bloggers have been given a new set of ‘Ten Commandments’ aimed at delivering them from the temptations of online arguments.
 
By Alastair Jamieson

Ten Commandments for Christian bloggers: No. 3 You shall not misuse your screen name by using your anonymity to sin

The guidelines have been drawn up at a conference in London by the Evangelical Alliance in response to concern at how religious blogs can quickly descend into vitriol.

The commandments, based on those delivered to Moses by God at the top of Mount Sinai, order bloggers not to "make an idol" of their web space, not to misuse their screen name by using anonymity to sin and to remember the Sabbath by taking one day off a week from blogging. They also order: "You shall not use the web to commit or permit adultery in your mind."

The Evangelical Alliance is an umbrella group founded in 1846 that represents thousands of churches of most denominations nationwide

Bloggers are commanded to honour their fellow bloggers and not to get too upset by their mistakes. They shall not murder the reputation of another blogger, shall not give false testimony against a fellow blogger and shall not steal the blog content of another.

Bloggers are also told to be content with their own creation and not to covet their neighbour’s blog ranking. Many thousands of blogs have sprung up in the past few years, offering easy access to online opinion forums to any user of the internet.

The "instant access" nature of most blogs means people posting comments often do so in the heat of passion and rarely stop to reflect, as they would if giving a lecture or writing a letter.

The result can be intemperate and sometimes foul language aimed at either the author of the blog or other contributors.

Krish Kandiah, executive director of Churches in Mission, said: "These commandments are virtual rather than set in stone, but are offered to the blogging community as a way to link the Ten Commandments with the art of blogging.

"In the ever-changing information age, what we need is wisdom for life, and God communicates wisdom to our culture through the Bible on every issue from social justice to social networking."

Mark Meynell, senior associate minister for All Souls Church, Langham Place, London, said: "The internet is merely the latest step in the evolution of human communication – and so like any other new medium, it presents us with huge opportunities as well as challenges.

"It is essential that Christians make the most of it because we believe we have good news that is as relevant to those in cyberspace as it is for those in real space."

Ten commandments for bloggers:

1 You shall not put your blog before your integrity
2 You shall not make an idol of your blog
3 You shall not misuse your screen name by using your anonymity to sin
4 Remember the Sabbath day by taking one day off a week from your blog
5 Honour your fellow-bloggers above yourselves and do not give undue significance to their mistakes
6 You shall not murder someone else’s honour, reputation or feelings
7 You shall not use the web to commit or permit adultery in your mind
8 You shall not steal another person’s content
9 You shall not give false testimony against your fellow-blogger
10 You shall not covet your neighbour’s blog ranking. Be content with your own content

May I remind you of the "Internet Prayer" I wrote some years ago, now in many languages:

A prayer before logging onto the internet:
Almighty and eternal God,
who created us in Thy image
and bade us to seek after all that is good, true and beautiful,
especially in the divine person of Thy Only-begotten Son, our Lord Jesus Christ,
grant, we beseech Thee,
that, through the intercession of Saint Isidore, Bishop and Doctor,
during our journeys through the internet
we will direct our hands and eyes only to that which is pleasing to Thee
and treat with charity and patience all those souls whom we encounter.
Through Christ our Lord.   Amen.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
2 Comments