Ineffable irony and the USCCB

A priest WDTPRSer helped me to a chuckle today:

Dear Fr. Z,

First, thank you for your blog.  I’ve been following it faithfully for about 2 years and I always find something interesting and informative.  You are providing a great service to the church! [Thanks!]

I have a few parishioners with whom I meet once a month to talk about the liturgical reform and Benedict’s Papacy.  Our fundamental question is whether the Mass we have today is the Mass intended by the Council Fathers.  To keep it from descending to opinions, we are limiting our study primarily to magisterial documents.  It is informative for them and edifying for me to see an interest in the Church and her liturgy.

This past week we decided to consider the USCCB  Norms for distribution of Holy Communion under both kinds:

As a point of observation it is [NB] written by the American bishops  [!] and received the recognitio in 2002. 

When I reread the document is preparation for our meeting I about swallowed my teeth when I read paragraph 4, especially considering the failed vote to approve the most recent "Grey Book" based on some "high falutin’" word choices. 

Here is the first sentence:

4. The eyes of faith enable the believer to recognize the ineffable depths of the mystery that is the Holy Eucharist.

Do you notice the irony?  I simply had to stop and let out a good laugh.

Me too… but I can’t quite put words to it.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
29 Comments

QUAERITUR: Visiting priest and baptism with the OLD Rite

Here is a question from e-mail, useful for people and priests alike:

Dear Fr. Z.,

We are expecting our 6th baby in August and I asked our "Sunday" priest if he would come up to do the baptism at our local parish.   He said he would.  So, this morning I went and asked our local priest (brand new pastor here) if it would be OK with him.  He said since the Baptism would be in the old rite, he would have to check with the diocese to see if it would be OK. 

Is that required for a Baptism? 

He went on and on about how he could not just choose to say the Latin Mass because of uniformity.  I asked if that was really the case since the Pope had given permission to priests last year.  I  am just curious if that is the case.  He is an Indian priest and sometimes with the language and cultural barrier, I wonder if we don’t understand eachother too well.

First, kudos.  Have more babies.

Second, you are not asking for Mass.  You are asking for a Baptism.

Third, a pastor of a parish can use the old Rituale Romanum whenever he considers it opportune (in other words all the time).  He does NOT need permission.  And he can let any visiting priest (or his assistant) use the old rites also.  No problem.

Pope Benedict’s Summorum Pontificum says:

Art. 9, § 1.  Similarly, a pastor, everything having been well though out, can grant permission for using the older Ritual administrate of  the sacraments of Baptism, Matrimony, Penance and Annointing of the Sick, as the good of souls suggests.

So, a pastor can allow another priest to use the older Ritual and he can use it, obviously, himself.

No permission is needed from anyone but the pastor himself.

I would recommend against calling the chancery on this, to avoid getting some half-informed bloke ignorantly opining incorrectly or perhaps knowingly trying to confuse the issue with misinformation.

Best wishes and congratulations.

 

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, SESSIUNCULA |
8 Comments

QUAERITUR: A Latin among Easterners: what gives?

Another question from e-mail:

First allow me to say how much I, as a young convert, have enjoyed and learned a great deal from your blog.  My question is, what is the status on Latin Rite Catholics participating in Masses according to the forms of other Catholic rites.  For example, there is a Byzantine Rite parish not to far from where I live and I would like to go there one Sunday and see what it is like.  I assume that I am allowed to receive communion but does it also count as my Sunday obligation?  This is probably a very stupid question and my gut reaction is that it is acceptable to do so.  However, I don’t want to commit a blunder through ignorance.

Also, while discussing Eastern Rites.  When at an Eastern Orthodox church (say on a tour or something), should I still genuflect to the altar?  It is, of course, Christ within but I don’t know if that is acceptable form in Eastern Rite churches.

First, I should say that I, too, am a convert.  And when I started exploring the Church I also was interested in the Eastern Rites and sought them out.  Happily, in my home town the main Churches were represented.  It was fascinating.  Also, for a couple summers I live with Ukrainian Catholics in Rome on the Aventine Hill and got to know their Divine Liturgy quite well.  They liked me: I have a big bass voice and there was plenty to do with it.

Yes, as a Catholic you can go to Mass or Divine Liturgy at any of those Eastern Catholic Churches with their own Rites.  You can participate in the proper ways (you are a baptized Christian and a Catholic, after all) and receive Holy Communion.

Also, according to the 1983 Code of Canon for Latin Church Catholics you fulfill your Sunday or Holy Day obligations by attending the Divine Liturgy because they are also celebrating, obviously, in Catholic Rite.

Remember that they will have their own customs.  You want to be respectful and careful.  I don’t think anyone would look at you cross-eyed if you genuflected: that’s how we Latins do it, after all.  If you prefer, you could bow deeply as the Easterners tend to do.  As you please.

Sometimes their Divine Liturgies can be rather long, so figure that into your morning.

BTW… when you receive Communion, you will probably receive under both kinds administered by the priest with a small spoon.  Small pieces of the Host, sometimes like little "croutons" will be in the chalice with the Precious Blood.  The priest will put a small amount of the Precious Blood into your mouth together with Eucharistic Body.   If this is how you see Communion is being distributed, just tilt your head back with your mouth open, the priest will do the rest.  Do NOT close your mouth around the spoon, as some Latins do the first time.

I suggest that you go to participate in as many different Catholic Churches as possible, noting the similarities and differences.  They will only help you understand better your own Latin Catholic heritage.

If after Mass you talk to the priest, feel free to ask him questions.  Sometimes they will use terms you are not familiar with, but they are familiar enough with dealing with Latins to know how to put things.

So, go and breath from both your Catholic lungs, Eastern and Western.  And enjoy the incense.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, SESSIUNCULA |
25 Comments

QUAERITUR: When does the “clerical state” begin?

I got this question via e-mail:

Father,

In societies that use the 1962 Missal, when does a man become a cleric?  The current 1983 Code says they become a cleric at the diaconate.  Do societies like the FSSP and ICK have an indult?  I know they have an indult to continue the subdiaconate, but are the subdeacons clerics?

This is the old question of when the clerical state begins… and we are not talking about being hired out of Madame Ethel’s Secretarial and Finishing Academy… though.. well… best leave that one alone.

For this question, everything depends on the 1983 Code of Canon Law.

Canon 266.1: "A person becomes a cleric through the reception of the diaconate and is incardinated into the particular Church or personal prelature for whose services he has been advanced."

In the old days, under the old 1917 Code, the clerical state began when a man received his First Tonsure.  In fact, the tonsure was the sign of the clerical state and for a very long time all clerics had to maintain the tonsure, in the case of most priests a round spot shaved on the top of their head… assuming they had hair there, of course.  Some of us have pretty dramatic natural tonsures.   Religious would have their heads shaved with a small band, or crown of hair around their heads.

Keep in mind the difference between the "religious" state and the "clerical" state.  Men can be under vows in an order or institute of religious or consecrated life and not be a cleric.  Not all religious are clerics and not all clerics are religious.  "Cleric" refers more to a man who is incardinated, rather than under vows.

Historically, the clerical state was important for matters of jurisdiction in the case of prosecution (in some places clerics could not be tried in secular courts) and also who could have a "benefice", or a grant of the income deriving from property owned by the Church.

Until 1972 the four Minor Orders were clerics states, defined by the Council of Trent.  After a man was tonsured, he would be "ordained" (though these are not sacramental Holy Orders as some medieval theologians thought)

  • Porter or Ostiarius
  • Lector,
  • Exorcist
  • Acolyte

While these were orders for clerics, they did not require a promise or vow of lifelong celibacy.  That started with the next Order, Subdiaconate. 

The Major Orders were:

  • Subdeacon
  • Deacon
  • Priest

Paul VI suppressed the minor orders in 1972, requiring that candidates for the diaconate and priesthood be "installed" in the stable ministries of Lector and Acolyte, the Acolyte subsuming the tasks of the old Acolyte and the Subdeacon.

The traditionalist groups such as the FSSP and the ICK, as well as others, have permission to put their men through the paces of the Minor Orders.  However, none of these old orders makes a man a cleric.  They can cut all the hair they want, but only ordination as a deacon makes a man a cleric, under law.  So, in these traditional groups, we have to distinguish between their own internal customs, what they chose to do within their communities, and how the Church’s law sees the situation.

When the clerical state begins is very important for the Church’s laws.  The clerical state exacts certain duties and there are censures which are applied to clerics.  Also, the clerical state makes it possible to hold some offices in the Church.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, SESSIUNCULA |
22 Comments

PODCAzT 64: Bonaventure on Christ “the door”; Interview – Fr. Timothy Finigan

PODCAzT 64: Bonaventure on Christ "the door"; Interview - Fr. Timothy FiniganToday I have an interview with His Hermeneuticalness himself, Fr. Timothy Finigan.   We talk togther about Summorum Pontificum and matters liturgical and spiritual.  I think you’ll find this pretty interesting.

But first, we hear from St. Bonaventure (+1274) speaking to us from across the centuries in his De itinerario mentis in Deum (The journey of the mind to God).  This is the in Office of Readings for the Saint’s feast in the post-Conciliar calendar.  In the older, traditional calendar, we observed the Seraphic Doctor’s feast yesterday.

I then drill into a couple of his remarks, especially talking about how entering a church for Holy Mass prepares us for an encounter with Mystery.

https://wdtprs.com/wp-content/legacy/audio-archive/podcazt/08_07_15.mp3

The iTunes feed is working again… mysteriously.  Check it out!

Some of the last offerings (check out the PODCAzT PAGE):

064 08-07-15 Bonaventure on Christ “the door”; Interview – Fr. Timothy Finigan
063 08-07-12 Interview: Fr. Justin Nolan, FSSP; consecrated hands, Holy Communion and the Rite of BaptismPODCAzT 64: Bonaventure on Christ "the door"; Interview - Fr. Timothy Finigan
062 08-06-26 Interviews with and by Fr. Z; What has Bp. Fellay really said?
061 08-05-17 Pope Leo I on a post-Pentecost weekday; Fr. Z rambles not quite aimlessly for a while
060 08-05-16 Pentecost customs; St. Ambrose on the dew of the Holy Spirit
059 08-05-15 Leo the Great on Pentecost fasting; Benedict XVI’s sermon for Pentecost Sunday
058 08-05-14 Ember Days; Chrysostom on St. Matthias; Prayer to the Holy Spirit
057 08-05-13 John Paul II on the unforgivable sin; Our Lady of Fatima and the vision of Hell
056 08-05-12 Octaves – Fr. Z rants & Augustine on Pentecost
055 08-05-03 Tertullian, again; Fr. Rutler and Fr. Z on Archbp. Marini’s book
054 08-04-29 Pro-Abortion Politicians and Communion; St. Ambrose and Emperor Theodosius

PODCAzT 64: Bonaventure on Christ "the door"; Interview - Fr. Timothy Finigan

Posted in PODCAzT |
27 Comments

WYD Opening – some video

Here is a video piece from CTV about the opening of WYD:

(This video is no longer available.)

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
15 Comments

A blogger’s experience of the Novus Ordo in Latin

I am concerned about something.

I am concerned that with Summorum Pontificum the use of Latin will be segregated to the Extraordinary Form.

We must have far more Latin in all Masses.

So here is a blog piece from Esperu.

 

Okay, so based on the descriptions I’d read on various Catholic blogs, and studying the theology of the liturgy, I’d reached the conclusion that the best Mass for me to attend would be an ordinary form (yclept "Novus Ordo") Mass, in Latin, with the priest facing with the people ("ad orientem"). [facing "toward the East" with people "toward the people".]

A little research revealed that there was such a Mass on Sundays within about 1/2 hour from my home. So, on a recent Sunday I attended. I didn’t bring the wife and kids, since I didn’t think a 4-year-old would tolerate it very well, and my wife didn’t seem to have any interest.  [I think parents will say that children do pretty well with the Latin, especially Gregorian chant!]

First thing to note — despite the summer weather, everyone was dressed modestly. This is nice, but not really different from my home parish, which holds ordinary form Masses in English on Sundays. There were noticeably more mantillas than I’m used to, but this wasn’t a surprise.

The priest entered, and I noted he was wearing one of those "fiddleback" chasubles. I realize this is a matter of aesthetics, but the fiddleback looks to me like a short scapular. This has two effects: implying that the priest is a religious, even when diocesan; [Hmmm… this is not something I have ever heard.] also, since it’s short, it looks like he’s heading out to work in the fields wearing a tapestry, rather than preparing to celebrate liturgy.  [Strange… but oh well.]

Enough fashion. This particular Mass was most disappointing because of the mannerisms of the priest. This priest delivered everything, whether Greek, Latin, or English, in a kind of bored sing-song that seemed to imply nothing other than "all right, let’s get this over with." I don’t know anything about this priest, but he’s not the only reverend who could really use a quick tour with Toastmasters.  [A lot depends on the priest’s ars celebrandi.]

There didn’t seem to be much rhyme or reason to which prayers were in Latin, and which were in English. Okay, I understand why you say the propers in English, since no-one in the congregation (even this priest, I suspect) knows enough Latin to do an on-the-fly translation like Fr. Z. The strange thing to me was that the commons were either in Latin or English without any discernible pattern. The paternoster in Latin makes sense, but then the "Deliver us" in English. Isn’t that part of the same prayer? The congregation seemed puzzled how to answer. "For the Kingdom…" came out in English.  [Sounds like someone should talk to that priest.]

Personally, I’d prefer that the creed be left in the vernacular, since I think it’s important for people to be reminded in their own language what it is they are professing, but I acknowledge arguments for putting it in Latin. 

In fact, after attending this Mass, I’m kind of inclined to give up on Mass in Latin any time in the future. I just don’t get the appeal. I’d rather know what it is I am saying, and what is being said. It engages my mind much more in the moment. I don’t begrudge anyone their Latin Masses, but I think I’ll take a pass.

Let me put in a plug for the altar boys. [Sensible.] These guys have been very well taught. The thurifer especially knew his stuff, and did a great job with the incense. I’d say the team of 6 altar boys was probably the most well-rehearsed I’d seen in a long time.

So, here’s one thing I really liked. Ad Orientem. Once you’ve seen this, you’ll never want to go back to "versus populum." So much of the Eucharistic prayer, and the actions of the priest, just make so much more sense when the priest is offering up the Eucharist to the Lord, rather than to the congregation. (I’m exaggerating to make a point.) It’s clear when the priest turns to the people and invites them to participate, that this is exactly what he is doing. Also, the elevation of the species turns into a great high-point of the Mass (especially with that incense!) rather than just a momentary gesture.

I hope that Ad Orientem takes off throughout Christendom. [Actually, it did.] That’s really the way to go to Mass. Latin — take it or leave it. I’ll leave it, thanks.

I hear there is an extraordinary form Mass about 20 minutes away on Wednesday mornings. I’ll see if I can get to it some time soon. Based on this experience, I’m not anticipating liking it much, but I’m willing to give it a try.  [Do some homework first, perhaps?]

I respect these opinions. 

It sounds as if the priest might be trying to work Latin into the parish liturgies in pieces.  

More Latin, folks.  Far more.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
105 Comments

Letter to priests from the Congregation for Clergy

The latest letter to priests from the Congregation for Clergy:

Letter to priests from the Congregation for Clergy

 Dear brother priests,

On the occasion of the August 4th feast of St. John Marie Vianney, the Curé of Ars, I greet you cordially with all my heart, and I fraternally send you this brief message.

The Church knows today that there is an urgent mission, not only “ad gentes,” but also to those Christians living in areas and regions where the Christian faith has been preached and established for centuries and where ecclesial communities already exist.  Within this flock, the mission, or the missionary of evangelization, has as its target those who are baptized but who, for different circumstances, have not been evangelized sufficiently, or those who have lost their initial fervour and fallen away.  The postmodern culture of contemporary society – a relativist, secular, and agnostic culture – exerts a strong erosive action on the religious faith of many people.
The Church is missionary by its very nature.  Jesus told us that "the sower went out to sow" (Mt 13:3).  The sower does not limit himself to throwing the seed out of the window, but actually leaves the house.  The Church knows that it cannot remain inert or limit itself to receiving and evangelizing those who are seeking the Faith in its churches and communities.  It is also necessary to rise up and go to where people and families dwell, live and work.  We must go to everyone: companies, organizations, institutions and different fields of human society.  In this mission, all members of the ecclesial community are called: pastors, religious and laity.
Moreover, the Church recognizes that priests are the great driving force behind daily life in local communities.  When priests move, the Church moves.  If this were not so, it would be very difficult to achieve the Church’s mission.

My dear brother priests, you are the great richness, the energy, the pastoral and missionary inspiration in the midst of the Christian faithful, wherever they are found in community.  Without your crucial decision to "put out into the deep" for fish ("Duc in altum"), as the Lord himself calls us, little or nothing will happen in the urgent mission, either "ad gentes" or in the territories that have previously been evangelized.  But the Church is certain that it can count on you, because it knows and explicitly recognizes that the overwhelming majority of priests – despite our weaknesses and human limitations – are worthy priests, giving their life daily to the Kingdom of God and loving Jesus Christ and the people entrusted to them.  These are the priests who are sanctifying themselves in their daily ministry and who are persevering until the harvest of  the Lord.  Only a small minority of priests have gravely deviated from this mission, and the Church seeks to repair the harm that they have done.  On the other hand, it rejoices in and is proud of the immense majority of its priests, who are good and exceedingly worthy of praise.
During this Pauline Year, and pending the Synod of Bishops on the Word of God to be held in Rome next year in October [Ummm… this year… right?], we call those who are receptive to this urgent mission.  May the Holy Spirit enlighten us, send us, and sustain us, so that we might go forth and proclaim once again the person of Jesus Christ, crucified and resurrected, as well as His kingdom!
 I greet you again, dear brothers, remaining always at your disposal.  I pray for you all, especially for those who suffer, for the sick and for the elderly.

Vatican City State, 15 July 2008

Claudio Cardinal Hummes
Emeritus Archbishop of São Paolo
Prefect of the Congregation for the Clergy

UPDATE: Wed 16 July – 1252 UTC

This came via e-mail:

The Synod of Bishops on the "Word of God", mentioned in the letter sent yesterday, will be celebrated in October of 2008. We regret the error. Congregation for the Clergy

There it is.  Perhaps part of this document was written last year, when the Pauline Year was accounced.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
16 Comments

CDWDS changes in November?

Rorate picked up from Paolo Rodari of Palazzo Apostolico an article stating that, in November, His Eminence Francis Card. Arinze will be replaced as Prefect of the CDWDS by H.E.Antonio Card. Cañizares Llovera, Archbp. of Toledo.

It seems reasonable to assume that such a rare November change would revolve around the fact that Card. Arinze will celebrate his 50th Jubille as a priest on 23 November.  Last week Card. Arinze told me that on that day he will celebrate a solemn Mass at San Clemente Cathedral in Velletri (His Eminence is the Cardinal Bishop of Velletri Segni).

I have received a zillion e-mails about this issue of Card. Arinze and Card. Cañizares Llovera, but I think I must simply support the opinion expressed on Rorate, which is reasonable, insofar as the timing is concerned. I am not so certain that Card. Cañizares will be the new Prefect.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
13 Comments

Mozart Orchestral TLM 1st Mass in St. Louis

A kind reader sent links to YouTube videos of a first Mass this past Sunday July 13, 2008 at the Oratory of St. Francis de Sales in St. Louis.  It is for the first Mass of Fr. Henrique Fragelli of the ICK.

Alas, none of the video’s show the Mass, but rather show only the band choir and schola.

The Oratory choir and supplemented with members of the St. Louis Symphony Orchestra (trumpet, violin, cello, timpani).  This reminds me of the way Msgr. Richard Schuler set up the Twin Cities Catholic Choral.  I am reminded of Msgr. Hellriegel as well. 

The band does a reasonably good job of it and the schola is quite competent. Also, there are undesirable solos by an ankle-biter.

They broke the video into smaller chunks, each having a rather long text intro and exit, alas.  I wonder if that was necessary.

In any event, here is one of the six.  They seemed to be out of the regular order of Mass as they were sent to me, so I just picked one.

Play video

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
28 Comments