A fascinating development in Paris

A friend alerted me to something truly fascinating.

Here is a photo.

This is the Very. Rev. Msgr. François Fleischmann celebrating Holy Mass with the 1962 Missale Romanum at the Chapelle Saint-Paul in Paris.  Msgr. is a canon, and the chancellor, and the episcopal vicar for marriages, etc etc. 

"But Father!  But Father!", you are perhaps saying, with furrowed brow and head scratching. "Big deal!  So a monsignor is saying the old Mass.  I know it’s in Paris, in France, not exactly friendly to traditional Masses over all, but… so what?"

You see, Msgr. Fleischmann was head of the Vatican Secretariate of State’s French Section for a very long time.  If memory serves he left there in abut 2000.  He seemed in those days to have loathed anything and everything having to do with the older Mass, and kept a little data base of the names of anyone in France who wrote to the Holy Father about these issues.  He was generally the sort who, as one of my friends puts it, would shoot into a bush if I thought a traditionalist might be behind it.

So, in Paris, this fellow is saying the older form of Mass and WDTPRS applauds him.   The Cardinal Archbishop of Paris will be pontificating soon.  

What do I get from all this?  Well… not anything terribly concrete.  But, based on my knowledge of how things usually work, I am thinking that someone has said something to the powers that be in Paris, and elsewhere in France.  I suspect we may see signs of the ice cracking as the Marshall Paln continues.

The Holy Father is going to France in September, if memory serves.  He will meet with the bishops.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
19 Comments

Where are you?

It has been a while since I gave you a snapshot of different places in the world where some of you readers are when you visit WDTPRS.

These place names are only approximations.  Don’t worry if you don’t see your town.  The internet node you are using might not be your actually city or town name.  Also, I cut out the entries that simply say "United States", or "unknown". 

Puyallup, Washington
Orland Park, Illinois
Washington, District of…
Houston, Texas
Hamden, Connecticut
Paraaque, Rizal
North Port, Florida
Austin, Texas
Fall River, Massachusetts
Lancaster, Pennsylvania
Farnham, Surrey
Brooklyn, New York
New York
Orange, Connecticut
Wilmington, Massachusetts
Long Beach, California
Nashville, Tennessee
Coatbridge, North Lanar…
Charlotte, North Carolina
Lisbon, Lisboa
Cincinnati, Ohio
Saint Paul, Minnesota
Houston, Texas
Bucharest, Bucuresti
Stevens Point, Wisconsin
Miami, Florida
Fountain Valley, Califo…
Portland, Oregon
Rome, Lazio
Saint Louis, Missouri
Algonquin, Illinois
Taiping, Perak
Vienna, Wien
Rome, Lazio
Loretto, Tennessee
Delray Beach, Florida
Miami, Florida
Cambridge, Massachusetts
Houston, Texas
Louisville, Kentucky
Bethpage, New York
Santa Fe
Chicago, Illinois
Milan, Lombardia
Woodbridge, Virginia
Chesterville, Ohio
Brussels, Brussels Hoof…
Denton, Texas
Leatherhead, Surrey
Kilgore, Texas
Anderson, South Carolina
Holy See (Vatican City State)
Chapel Hill, North Caro…
Puerto Rico
Chicago, Illinois
New York
Brooklyn, New York
Saginaw, Michigan
Houston, Texas
Chicago, Illinois
Lanuvio, Lazio
Pine Lake, Georgia
Curitiba, Parana
Cocentaina, Comunidad V…
Geldrop, Noord-Brabant
Memphis, Tennessee
Otsego, Michigan
Chicago, Illinois
Lake Oswego, Oregon
Manchester, New Hampshire
Rome, Lazio
Schmallenberg, Nordrhei…
Lafayette, Louisiana
Lawrence, Kansas
Monroeville, Pennsylvania
San Antonio, Texas
London, London, City of
Jamestown, North Dakota
Bel Air, Maryland
Little Rock, Arkansas
New Orleans, Louisiana
Washington, District of…
Lafayette, Louisiana
Schmallenberg, Nordrhei…
Lawrence, Kansas
Monroeville, Pennsylvania
San Antonio, Texas
London, London, City of
Jamestown, North Dakota
Bel Air, Maryland
Little Rock, Arkansas
New Orleans, Louisiana
Washington, District of…
Newark, Ohio
Charleston, West Virginia
Plano, Texas
Adelaide, South Australia
Guthrie, Oklahoma
Jasper, Alabama
Columbus, Ohio
Haverhill, Massachusetts
Toronto, Ontario
Winnipeg, Manitoba
Washington, District of…
Stockholm, Stockholms Lan
Baltimore, Maryland
Evansville, Indiana
Kansas City, Missouri
Huntsville, Alabama
Lincoln, Nebra 76
El Cajon, California
Anaheim, California
Charlotte, North Carolina
Troy, Michigan
Palatine, Illinois
Rochester, Minnesota
Chicago, Illinois
Collegeville, Minnesota
New Bloomington, Ohio
Pasadena, California
Cincinnati, Ohio
Richardson, Texas
Arlington, Virginia
Washington, District of…
Pasadena, California
Douglasville, Georgia
Cary, North Carolina
Fresno, California
Washington, District of…
Cincinnati, Ohio
Holliston, Massachusetts
Norcross, Georgia
Bydgoszcz, Kujawsko-Pom…
Cambridge, Massachusetts

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
12 Comments

17th century Marian Apparition approved in France

With a tip of the biretta to te Cafeteria:

From the IHT

A Roman Catholic bishop said Sunday that the church has officially recognized that the Virgin Mary appeared to a teenage shepherd girl in the French Alps starting in the mid-1600s.

The announcement marks the first time the church has recognized apparitions of the Virgin Mary in France since those in southwestern Lourdes 150 years ago, the diocese of Gap and Embrun said.

Speaking at Mass in Laus in remarks broadcast nationally on France-2 television, Monsignor Jean-Michel di Falco Leandri said he recognized the "supernatural origin" of the apparitions to 17-year-old shepherd girl Benoite Rencurel starting in 1664 and running through 1718.

The bishop, in an interview on France-Info radio, said the decision meant the church "has committed itself in an official way to say to pilgrims ‘you can come here in total confidence.’" The recognition process involved a panel of experts including two theologians and an investigating judge, he said.

Radio Vatican’s Web site said some 30 cardinals and bishops from around the world were expected for the Mass in Laus, to attend the "celebration" of the recognition.

Officials at Notre-Dame-du-Laus church say that after four months of daily apparitions starting in May 1664, the Virgin Mary asked Rencurel to build a church and a house to receive priests.

The sanctuary, which was founded by Rencurel, today welcomes some 120,000 pilgrims a year, at times providing healing oils based on a method that the Virgin Mary was said to pass on to the shepherd girl, the officials said.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
35 Comments

Some interesting ideas for your evening viewing

This is in from Space Weather:

ETA AQUARID METEOR SHOWER:  If you see a meteor flit across the sky tonight, it could be a piece of Halley’s Comet. Earth is crossing a stream of dusty debris from Halley and this is causing the annual eta Aquarid meteor shower. Sky watchers in the tropics and southern hemisphere (where the shower is most intense) could see as many as 70 meteors per hour during the dark hours before dawn on Monday, May 5th, and Tuesday, May 6th.  The show is diminished at northern latitudes where rates may be 15 meteors per hour or less. 

MERCURY AND THE MOON:  Innermost planet Mercury is emerging from the glare of the sun and putting on its best show of the year.  A good time to look is Tuesday evening, May 6th, just after sunset when the crescent Moon glides by Mercury in the darkening western sky. A sky map and photos are available at http://spaceweather.com.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
1 Comment

Excellent Pastor’s Page: Fr. Welzbacher strikes again!

Pretty often the "pastor’s page" of parish a parish bulletin offers pretty thin gruel indeed.

At times, however, they can be a truly useful tool.  Take for example what went on via the bulletin in Greenville!

Then there is the weekly offering from Fr. George Welzbacher. 

Here we have this week’s comments with my emphases:

Pastor’s Page
By Fr. George Welzbacher
  
May 4, 2008

  Thoughts on Pope Benedict’s "Journey of  Hope"

   Many years ago, if memory holds true, there was a television game show in which contestants were asked to identify which of  the two or more candidates claiming, each of them, to be a certain particular person was "the real McCoy". At the end of the contest, after each candidate had made his pitch, the program’s impresario announced in stentorian terms: "Now will the real ["Mr. Smith", or whoever] stand up?" I was reminded of this during Pope Benedict’s recent visit to the United States. While watching his appearances and listening to his words, and comparing what he was saying with what the exponents of a revisionist, "progressive" Catholicism have been saying for lo! these many years, I kept hearing a voice in the background saying "Now will the real Catholic Church stand up!", as Pope Benedict’s face, humbly and serenely smiling, filled the screen.

   Pope Benedict’s basic message, a message of "the real Catholic Church," is a message of hope, a hope based on Christ’s promise that ‘The truth will make you free" (John 8:32), the truth, that is to say, taught by Christ and transmitted by His Church under the everlasting guidance of the Holy Spirit, an eternal and unchanging truth that reflects the unchanging nature of God and the unchanging nature of man. [authentic "liberation theology"]  This is the truth that "progressive" Catholics have sought to "revise," particularly as it governs sexual behavior. When Humanae Vitae (the encyclical letter Pope Paul the Sixth signed on July 25, 1968 ) reasserted the age-old teaching of the Catholic Church that the use of the sexual power is restricted to the union of husband and wife in the life-long commitment of marriage and that the procreative potential of the sexual power can never be actively obstructed, a gang of rebel priests publicly rejected this papal teaching, led by such intellectual mediocrities (though widely applauded demagogues) as Father Charles Curran, a professor of moral theology at Catholic University whose shabby thinking , a perfect match for his sloppy prose, is on display forever in his book entitled Absolutes in Moral Theology? Joining Father Curran Father Richard McBrien, whose two-volume work entitled Catholicism was quite properly censured by America’s Catholic bishops for its multitude of errors. The errors referenced by America’s bishops for correction have survived, uncorrected, in the work’s subsequent editions.

   Such priests as could claim for their false teaching the prestige of an academic chair were soon seconded by a bold chorus of parish and religious order priests, who moved perhaps by a desire to be compassionate, though in this case such compassion would be a compassion falsely defined, swiftly set up a counter-magisterium to their own liking – one is reminded of Aaron’s revolt against Moses – according to which the practice of contraception was enthusiastically praised as the "responsible" choice. Once this initial repudiation of a single teaching of Christ’s Church had gained widespread acceptance, abetted by legions of priests who with a spectacular lack of courage in defending the truth began to counsel their parishioners privately to judge the matter for themselves, rather than to rely on the voice of the Holy Spirit speaking within Christ’s Church, very predictably the rest of the precepts governing sexual morality were successively allowed to fall one-by-one into oblivion. Soon what used to be called (and is still rightly considered to be) "living in sin", that is to say cohabitation without life-long commitment, came to be regarded by many as an acceptable practice. And once the separation of the sexual power from its procreative purpose was taken for granted, approval of sterilization and homosexual lifestyles soon inevitably followed. Finally – again in the name of compassion – approval of abortion began, timidly at first and then with gathering speed, to find support among Catholics, Catholics, that is to say, who are disposed still to identify themselves as Catholic but for whom the voice of St. Peter’s successors, charged with obeying Christ’s mandate to "establish the brethren", has come to count for very little. The coup de grace for a united Catholic front against abortion came with the assurances given to Catholic politicians by Jesuit Father Robert Drinan, for ten years, though without the required ecclesiastical permission, a representative in Congress from the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, who taught that one may cast a vote to promote abortion with a clear conscience, as long as one is "personally opposed" to abortion; one cannot you see, impose his own religious scruples on the public domain. In the interests of accepting so sophistical an excuse for mass murder a blind eye has to be turned to the basic truth that a directly intended attack on innocent human life violates the natural law, the law that governs all of mankind, whatever one’s religious convictions, the law that is "written on the hearts of men" (Romans 2:15), the law that expresses itself in the spontaneous judgment that certain acts are so disordered as to be always and everywhere evil. Therefore to act in response to that spontaneous, moral judgment is not to impose the peculiar precepts of a particular religion or a culture; particular  culture; it is to bow to the dictates of a universal law rooted in the very nature of man. Whether one is Roman Catholic or Buddhist or a card-carrying atheist, the directly willed murder of the innocent is something human beings instinctively recoil from, since it fundamentally violates the dignity of man and, by depriving him of life, deprives him of all other rights.

   In his First Letter to Timothy St. Paul refers to a certain Hymenacus and Alexander, two Christians about whom we otherwise know nothing, who "by rejecting conscience … have made shipwreck of their faith." (1 Timothy 1:19). In that same first chapter of 1 Timothy St. Paul gives examples of the kinds of sinners whose sins will cause them to suffer shipwreck in the faith: "manslayers, immoral persons, sodomites, kidnappers, liars, perjurers, and whatsoever else is contrary to sound doctrine." (1 Timothy 1:10). In effect St. Paul is telling us that if we fail to shape our behavior in accord with our faith, we will very soon shape our faith to accord with our behavior. That formula fits the so-called "progressive" Catholic quite well. As St. John tells us in his Second Letter: "Anyone who goes ahead and does not abide in the doctrine of Christ does not have God; he who abides in the doctrine has both the Father and the Son" (2 John :9). There is a kind of "progress" that means turning our backs on God.

   Pope Benedict has come to our shores to rescue those who have suffered shipwreck in the faith, or at least to rescue those who are willing to accept the terms that will permit such rescue. Such terms of rescue call fundamentally for a return to the "sound doctrines of which St. Paul speaks, the doctrine protected and proclaimed in Christ’s Church ("the pillar and bulwark of the truth"-1 Timothy 3:15) by the Holy Spirit against the devil’s ceaseless attempts to subvert that doctrine. As Pope Benedict announced, "A people of hope is a people willing to make a change," a people willing to make whatever changes in their lives may be needed to bring them into harmony with Christ’s truth. Whatever may have been the previous course of their lives, if they are willing now, under the grace of God, to change course and and to take Christ’s teachings as the only true compass, they can find their way home to safe haven through "all of life’s tempestuous seas." That is his message to us.

   Pope Benedict invites each one of us to examine his conscience and to make whatever changes in our lives need to be made. Let us pray that we will do so, and let us pray for those in whose confused and sin-darkened minds the voice of Peter, speaking through Benedict, has perhaps stirred some awareness that through an obedient return to sound doctrine a new way of life can open up, a new way of life that offers hope.

 

That, my friends, is how it is done.

WDTPRS solemn high kudos to the great Fr. W!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
17 Comments

A blog about the TLM at Lourdes

You all might want to go check out the new blog about the TLM at Lourdes called… wait for it…

TLM Lourdes.

Oddly, I have never been to Lourdes, and this gives me greater incentive to visit.

This blog seems to be mostly about when the TLM will be celebrated at that great Marian shrine.

It seems to have been created by one of the English speaking chaplains at the Shrine.

FYI

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
11 Comments

Great chair!

Now this is a seriously festive chair!

The Holy Father went to the Basilica Liberiana for a recitation of the Holy Rosary (it’s May, after all).

He also had on a great stole over his white "paschaltide" mozzetta.

Here is Papa near a Pope-Magnet:

The tassle is actually from his pectoral Cross.

Here is the other view:

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments

Great news in Oceanside, CA!

Great news from California came by e-mail:

Great news in Oceanside, CA!The pastor of St. Margaret’s, Fr. Cavanna Wallace, announced at today’s morning Mass that, beginning tonight, the 6:00 PM Sunday Mass will be offered in the Extraordinary Form (1962 Missal).

The last few months, he had been offering a Novus Ordo Mass in what he called "a more solemn manner"- ad orientem, [YAY!] gradually adding in more and more Latin.  This past week, he went on a week-long retreat, devoting it to studying and prayer in preparation for the EF Mass.  [This priest gets it!]

At the end of Mass this morning, Father Wallace gave a beautiful explanation of the change.  He admitted that the "older form" takes more concentration and work, for the priest as well as the congregation.  He stressed its emphasis on mystery and reverence, and mentioned that a sort of "cross-fertilization" of these could occur with our ordinary Sunday Mass. [YES YES YES!  This is the "gravitational pull" !]  He told us it helps take the focus away from the personality of the priest, and puts the focus on the Personality of God.  He announced that Communion will be distributed at an altar rail, to be received on the tongue.

If anyone would like to participate in this "historic" occasion, you are welcome to attend tonight’s 6:00 PM Mass.

St. Margaret’s Catholic Church
4300 Oceanside Blvd.
Oceanside CA 92056

Parish website:   http://oceanside4christ.com/

I wish I could be there.  How wonderful for this parish!

WDTPRS gives solemn high "You Get It!" kudos to Fr. Cavanna Wallace! 

How many times have I written that as priests learn the older form, everything will start to change?  Knowledge and use of the older form of Mass will affect how priests celebrate the Novus Ordo. 

This is inevitable.

Will there be vast changes over night?  Of course not.

But Pope Benedict’s Marshall Plan is working. 

Brick by brick, my friends, brick by brick!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
9 Comments

Time: Benedict may have killed off American Catholic liberalism

This in from Time.  Let’s see what is going on, with my emphases and comments.

Saturday, May. 03, 2008
Is Liberal Catholicism Dead?
By David Van Biema

He may not have been thinking about it at the time, but Pope Benedict, in the course of his recent U.S. visit may have dealt a knockout blow to the liberal American Catholicism that has challenged Rome since the early 1960s. He did so by speaking frankly and forcefully of his "deep shame" during his meeting with victims of the Church’s sex-abuse scandal. By demonstrating that he "gets" this most visceral of issues, the pontiff may have successfully mollified a good many alienated believers — and in the process, neutralized the last great rallying point for what was once a feisty and optimistic style of progressivism. [Let’s see how he backs up this bold claim.]

The liberal rebellion [the correct word] in American Catholicism has dogged Benedict and his predecessors since the Second Vatican Council of 1962-65. "Vatican II," which overhauled much of Catholic teaching and ritual, had a revolutionary impact on the Church as a whole. It enabled people to hear the Mass in their own languages; embraced the principle of religious freedom; rejected anti-semitism; and permitted Catholic scholars to grapple with modernity.

But Vatican II meant even more to a generation of devout but restless young people in the U.S. rather than a course correction, Terrence Tilley, now head of the Fordham University’s theology department, wrote recently, his generation perceived "an interruption of history, [cf. hermeneutic of rupture] a divine typhoon that left only the keel and structure of the church unchanged." They discerned in the Council a call to greater church democracy, and an assertion of individual conscience that could stand up to the authority of even the Pope. So, they battled the Vatican’s birth-control ban, its rejection of female priests and insistence on celibacy, and its [imagined] authoritarianism.

Rome pushed back, and the ensuing struggle defined a movement, whose icons included peace activist Fr. Daniel Berrigan, feminist Sister Joan Chittister, and sociologist/author Fr. Andrew Greeley. Its perspectives were covered in The National Catholic Reporter, Commonweal and America. Martin Sheen held down Hollywood, and the movement even boasted its own cheesy singing act: the St. Louis Jesuits. [ROFL!] The reformers’ premier membership organization was Call to Action, but their influence was felt at the highest reaches of the American Church, as sympathetic American bishops passed left-leaning statements on nuclear weapons and economic justice. Remarks Tilley, "For a couple of generations, progressivism was an [important] way to be Catholic." [Great paragraph!]

Then he adds, "But I think the end of an era is here."

To some extent, liberal Catholicism has been a victim of its own success. Its positions on sex and gender issues have become commonplace in the American Church, diminishing the distinctiveness of the progressives. [Aside from the fact that those positions are … well… wrong.] More importantly, they failed [operative word: failed] to transform the main body of the Church: John Paul II, a charismatic conservative, enjoyed the third-longest papacy in church history, and refused to budge on the left’s demands; instead, he eventually swept away liberal bishops. [More on this, below.] The heads at Call to Action grayed, [cf. "aging hippies"]  and by the late 1990s, Vatican II progressivism began to look like a self-limited Boomer moment. [YES!]

Then, the movement received a monstrous reprieve. The priest sex abuse scandal implicated not only the predators, but the superiors who shielded them. John Paul remained mostly silent. A new reform group, Voice of the Faithful, arose; the old anger returned, crystallizing around the battle-cry "They just don’t get it."

Benedict’s visit, however, changed the dynamic. And that’s a problem for progressives. Says [liberal] Fr. Thomas Reese, a senior fellow at Georgetown University’s Woodstock Theological Center whom Benedict famously removed from his previous job as editor of America, "Reform movements need an enemy to organize against. As most bishops have gotten their acts together on sex abuse, they have looked less like the enemy and more like part of the solution. Enthusiasm for reform declined. With the Pope’s forthright response, it will decline even more."

Not everyone agrees. Says Voice of the Faithful spokesman John Moynihan, "That’s funny; I just came from a meeting of COR (Catholic Organizations for Reform), and there were a lot of people very buoyed up. We can now say to people, ‘We have made a difference, and if you stick with us we are going to make a further difference’." Adds [liberal] Peter Steinfels, a former editor of Commonweal, now a director of Fordham’s Religion and Culture Center, "I think there is continuity in terms of the issues and the questions about whether Church structures can be altered." He notes that a social justice group, Catholics in Alliance for the Common Good, formed just three years ago.

But the familiar progressives-versus-Vatican paradigm seems almost certain to be undone by a looming demographic tsunami. Almost everyone agrees that the "millennial generation," born in 1980 or later, while sharing liberal views on many issues, has no desire to mount the barricades. [I wonder if their enthusiasm for "liberal views"is all that great?] Notes Reese, "Younger Catholics don’t argue with the bishops; they simply do what they want or shop for another church." And Hispanic Catholics, who may be the U.S. majority by 2020, don’t see this as their battle. "I’m sure they’re happy that the celebration of the Eucharist is in the vernacular," [really?  I wonder what they will do as Benedict’s Marshall Plan continues to develop?] says Tilley, "but they don’t have significant issues connected to Vatican II."  [Right.  I agree with what Fr. George Rutler wrote in his review of Archbp. Marini’s book (listen to my PODCAzT on it): Vatican II means as much to young people as Nicea II and Lateran II.]

And so, unless Benedict contradicts in Rome what he said in New York, [Why on earth would he do that?] the Church may have reached a tipping point. This is not to say that the (over-hyped) [?] young Catholic Right will swing into lay dominance. Nor will liberal single-issue groups simply evaporate. But if they cohere again, it will be around different defining issues. "It’s a new ball game," admits Steinfels. As Tilley wrote recently in Commonweal regarding his fellow theologians, "A new generation has neither the baggage nor the ballast of mine. Theirs is the future. Let’s hope they remember the Council as the most important event in twentieth-century Catholicism."  [They are more likely to say, "Council?  What Council?"]

Let’s see.

On his comment that John Paul II "swept away liberal bishops"….

People have very often asked me how John Paul II could have appointed all those strange bishops or allowed strange bishops to remain in their places?  How could he have knowingly appointed his enemies?  And surely some of them were appointed knowingly or left in place.  He couldn’t micro-manage all selection of bishops.  So, he must have had some purpose for this.

I think one of the great things John Paul did for the Church was do drag it back from the edge of schism, not on the right, but on the left.  He did it by slowly shifting the world’s episcopate around.  He did it patiently, not trying to change things too quickly, lest moving too fast sparked off true revolt.  If he swept away liberal bishops, he had to start with a little hand-held brush rather than get out the big push broom.  So, he had to allow the appointment even of enemies in some places, but as the years went on, he could pick up the pace.  

A perfect explanation?  No.  But it explains a lot.

The Time article bears some consideration. 

Posted in Classic Posts, SESSIUNCULA |
77 Comments

Changes for Vicariate of Rome

The great Camillo Card. Ruini, one of the pivotal figures in the Italian Church’s recovery of her voice in the public square and close collaborator of the late John Paul II and now Benedict XVI, is retiring soon from his post as Vicar of Rome. 

Apparently Agostino Card. Vallini, presently at the Segnatura will replace him.

Changes are coming.

People are buzzing that Bp. Rino Fisichella, Auxilliary of Rome and Rector of the Lateran University will go to the CDF to replace Archbp. Angelo Amato as Secretary.  Amato is rumored for a Prefect spot, at Saints or maybe Divine Worship.

WDTPRS is hoping for a future Cardinal Ranjith!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
10 Comments