Assigning blame

The political and cultural left is going to blame the shooting of Rep. Giffords on the Tea Party, the pro-life movement, talk radio, Glen Beck, Sarah Palin, all Republicans, Pres. Bush, Pope Benedict, Catholic priests … you get the idea.

Lefties are going to say that they… those people on the righthave raised public discourse to “vitriol”… which, of course, automatically means that people will start shooting.

However, my friend The Motley Monk caught the following.

There’s one little problem with this one-sided presentation of the evidence.  What those talking heads and bloggers have not and do not want introduced into evidence is that Ms. Giffords was also named on a “Target List” posted by none other than one of their heroes, the founder of the website Daily Kos, Markos Moulitsas.  On June 25, 2008, he wrote: “Not all of these people will get or even deserve primaries, but this vote certainly puts a bulls eye on their district” (italics added).

If we go back to look at the rhetoric of the left, I bet you will find far more violent imagery, even violent suggestions, than in the rhetoric on the right.

Posted in Biased Media Coverage, Throwing a Nutty | Tagged
155 Comments

TSA thoughts and vitriol

I had a chance this morning to see some of Fox News Sunday.  One of the guests was Rep. James E. Clyburn (D-SC)

I took particular note of one of his statements.

Complaining about going through airports, which they have to do pretty often, he said:

“We’ve had some incidents where TSA authorities think that Congresspeople should be treated like everybody else.”

I wonder if the Congressman realizes how that sounds.

While I agree that a member of Congress is unlikely to be a candidate for airline terror plots, yes, as elected representatives they should have to do what everyone else does… including pay their bills and avoid getting into debt.  As a matter of fact, perhaps members of Congress should have to go through TSA screening twice each time until they get the budget and debt disaster under control.

BTW… in the wake of the shooting Congresswoman Giffords and the others in Arizona, keep your ears tuned for the word “vitriol”, especially coming from the political and cultural left.

Meanwhile…

[CUE MUSIC]

When you have had a tough day watching elected officials stick their feet in their mouths in front of millions of people, why not have a steaming WDTPRS mug full of Mystic Monk Coffee?

With Mystic Monk you’ll not only be sharp enough to avoid these suicidal soundbites, you’ll be good-humored when you hear them uttered by others.

Face it, Mystic Monk Coffee makes you smarter and more patient.

What’s wrong with that?

And if you haven’t tried their coffee before, you might start with Monk’s 4 Favorites, which will give you the chance to try different blends.  Free shipping for the USA with that one.

Mystic Monk Coffee!

It’s swell!

Posted in Random Thoughts | Tagged
10 Comments

1 Peter 3:15

Take a look at this:

Posted in Our Catholic Identity, The future and our choices | Tagged
50 Comments

Risible exegesis

Dear readers,

You can stop sending links about the … scholar… who suggests that one of the Magi was a woman.

And to think that modern scriptural “scholars” have the nerve to mock Patristic exegesis.

Have you ever seen any modern exegete reason on the basis of anything like the three “arguments” used in this case to “demonstrate” that one or more women could have been among the Magi (“magoi”)?

If it were anything other than a feminist argument, the exegete would be laughed out of any university that employed her!

Posted in Throwing a Nutty |
40 Comments

PODCAzT 114: Sing those Litanies!

Inspired by something I did recently in New York City, in this audio project I get into Litanies, namely, singing Litanies, not just reciting them.  I guess this is also a PRAYERCAzT.

Litanies are beautiful expressions of faith, hope and love, especially when they are sung.

There are six Litanies approved for liturgical recitation by the Latin Church.  Most of have heard the Litany of Saints.  However, many have probably not heard, for example, the Litany of St. Joseph, much less participated in it sung.

I also talk about what St. Augustine said about singing and loving.

Using the useful little Cantus Selecti, published by the monks of Solesmes, I show you how to sing the Litany of the Sacred Heart, and also the Litany of Loreto in honor of of the Blessed Virgin in three different tones, and finally the Litany of St. Joseph.  In the back of the Liber Usualis there are two of these tones, as well as the notation for St. Joseph’s and the Sacred Heart’s.  I once had notation for the Litany of the Holy Name and for the Litany of the Precious Blood, but I couldn’t find it.

Along the way I have an excerpt from my own ordination in 1991: the Litany of Saints as we were prostrated on the ground, ending with the prayer by the late Pope, John Paul II.  Many thousands of people singing the responses.

This is a “how to” project.  Perhaps you can start singing litanies where you are!

113 10-12-12 More winter poems
112 10-12-08 Winter poems
111 10-12-23 4th Eucharistic Prayer; don Camillo (Part IX); digressions included
110 10-08-19 Learning the Roman Canon in Latin for Seminarians
109 10-08-17 A dust up in ancient Carthage and parishes that schism
108 10-07-23 The new translation of the 3rd Eucharistic Prayer; Fr. Z digresses and rants
107 10-07-01 Most Precious Blood and your sins; Interview with Fr. Finigan

https://zuhlsdorf.computer/podcazt/11_01_07.mp3

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, PODCAzT, PRAYERCAzT: What Does The (Latin) Prayer Really Sound L | Tagged ,
16 Comments

It’s a 1st Friday today: WDTPRS POLL

It is the First Friday of January and of a new year of salvation.

Think about 1st Friday devotions.

WDTPRS POLL

Do you observe 1st Friday and/or 1st Saturday Devotions?

View Results

Posted in Our Catholic Identity, POLLS |
43 Comments

A priest’s first time out as deacon for a Solemn TLM

On the blog Called By Name we have the description from Fr. Kyle Schnippel, Director of Vocations for the Archdiocese of Cincinnati, about his first time as deacon for a Solemn TLM.  My emphases and comments:

Introibo ad Altari Dei…Last night, I had the opportunity, for the first time, to attend/assist/celebrate a Traditional Latin Mass for the first time in public. (While on retreat after Christmas, I said a daily TLM in private, which is much preferable, to me, than saying the NO in private, but I’ll get to that in a later post, hopefully.)

Those following my twitter feed (@fatherschnippel) noticed the following yesterday, late morning: “Message to Cinci folk: TLM at OSM, 7:00 PM, tonight, Epiphany Solemn Mass, urs truly as Deacon”

Yep, first time: Deacon at a Solemn High Mass! A bit of training from a very good MC, and off we went. To say it is different than the NO Mass is, umm, selling it a bit short. I am still trying to get my head around the experience.

First thought: strangely, it is much harder to ‘pray’ this Mass than the NO as a priest. [This notion of “praying” the Mass as a sacred minister needs some attention.   The fact that you are doing it reverently is itself a kind of prayer.  There are different ways to pray, after all.  It is great to pray with meditation, but paying attention to what you are doing is also a good thing.  Liturgical action has, for the sacred minister, also a practical issue: being workman-like.  You can’t pray as a sacred minister as if you were attending Mass, or you were celebrating privately with leisure.  Also… how is it you pray during the Novus Ordo?] At least these initial run throughs (with rusty Latin), I am so concerned with the Rubrics, the hand positions, the genuflections, the kissing the altar, hand, etc., I’m trying to get through it rather than ‘pray’ it. [That’s okay.  Pray later.  You’ll get used to doing this and, when it is more comfortable, you’ll also have some space to pray.  But first and foremost, your role as deacon is pretty busy: you have a job to do.] In TLM, it is not about the priest, it is about the ritual, the ceremony, the prayers; entering into a timelessness, almost. The prayers are beautiful in their wording, if sometimes wordy, even in the Latin (which can really get me tongue tied!)

Another thought, from a friend who was attending her first TLM: Afterwards, as we were digesting the experience over sandwiches at Cinci’s oldest bar, her comment was: ‘It seemed, ummm…, more masculine.’ The guys at the table agreed: if NO Masses were celebrated like that, there would be more vocations. [Do I hear an ‘Amen!’?] (leading a participant to quip this morning in a note: “Father, have you told your boss and your other priest friends that a very orthodox mass (even NO) with a very rigorous/demanding altar server program would help encourage vocations?” Well, we know it, harder to implement.

The chants (and the choir was really great last night!) all reflect that timelessness. Certainly, in TLM, there is not a notion of ‘I don’t get anything out of Mass,’ even the laity have to work to pray along.

Another buddy, also attending his first TLM, tried to follow along at first, but dropped the little red hand missal and just decided to soak it in. I think he was still trying to put it into words, too. (I really hope he was joking with the ‘needed more “active participation”!’ line!) [He needs, perhaps, a deeper understanding of “active participation”?]

Anyway, there is another chance to see me ply the trade of the deacon tonight, for the monthly ‘First Friday’ Mass at Old St. Mary’s in Cincinnati’s Over the Rhine. Hopefully, I won’t be quite as lost, be able to enter the prayer a bit more and ultimately, soon, be able to step up to the top step of the altar and bat leadoff for the Solemn High Mass.

As a contrast, since I hadn’t had my own Mass yet, I then celebrated a Low Mass at the same altar, with just two servers and maybe a few others at first in the Church. At least there, I was mostly getting the hang of things.

[…]

WDTPRS KUDOS to Fr. Schnippel.

I am struck by the contrast between this diocesan Vocations Director, and those who were in my home diocese back in the day.  They were either trying to keep me out seminary or, once I was in, were actively trying to get me out.  What fond memories I have of the vocations director who, having trashed me during my reviews, later came out of the closet in the pulpit of a church, wrote a nasty editor about the Church for the local paper, and then left the active priesthood… only to be welcomed back later with no requirement that he recant his publicly contumacious editorial.

Times have changed, of course.  Slowly but surely things are changing.

UPDATE:

I think I fixed the combox.

Have at!

Posted in Brick by Brick, Mail from priests |
22 Comments

NYC – 30 Jan – TLM and talk by Martin Mosebach

In New York City on Sunday the 30th of January, there will be a Solemn Mass at 5 P.M. at the Church of Our Saviour at 59 Park Avenue (at 38th Street) followed by a lecture in the undercroft at 7 P.M. by prize-winning German novelist and writer on the liturgy Martin Mosebach.  The subject of the talk will be “The Old Roman Missal: Loss and Rediscovery”.

Mass will be celebrated in the “Extraordinary Form” with music provided by the St. Mary’s (Norwalk, CT) Schola Cantorum: Palestrina’s Missa sine nomine, motets by Palestrina and Victoria, and all the proper Gregorian chants.  David Hughes directs the Schola.

Posted in The Campus Telephone Pole |
10 Comments

WDTPRS – Epiphany – a “thunderclap”

“Epiphany” comes from the Greek word for a divine “manifestation” or “revelation”.  The antiphons for Vespers in the Liturgy of the Hours reflect the ancient tradition that Epiphany was thought to be the day not only on which the Magi came to adore the Christ Child, but also the very day Jesus changed water into wine at Cana, and also the day He was baptized in the Jordan by St. John.  All three events reveal Jesus as more than a mere man: He is God.   There are many “epiphanies” or “theophanies” in Scripture, such as when Moses encountered God in the burning bush (Exodus 3).

The celebration of Epiphany stretches back to the Church’s earliest times.   In the Greek East, Epiphany was of far greater importance than Christmas, which was a relative latecomer.  In the Latin West, Christmas developed first, Epiphany later.  In many countries people exchange presents on Epiphany, in imitation of the Magi bringing their gifts.  Epiphany falls on 6 January, the twelfth day after Christmas, as in “On the Twelfth day of Christmas, my true love gave to me…”, and also the title of Shakespeare’s play Twelfth Night.  In the reformed, post-Conciliar calendar Epiphany is usually transferred to a Sunday so that more people can attend that Mass.  I think it is a mistake to transfer important feasts like Epiphany in Christmastide, and Ascension Thursday in Eastertide.  These feasts are pegged to the key celebrations of Christmas and Easter for a reason.  When we transfer these feasts to Sunday, we diminish the meaning of the entire liturgical year. As our obligations as Catholics are made ever more lax and easier to fulfill, a subtle signal is sent that none of our obligations, practices or teachings are important enough to warrant a sacrifice.  

When you move Twelfth Night to Seventh Night we get short-changed.

Exquisite customs grace Epiphany.  The most famous is the blessing of chalk used to hallow homes. On the lintels of the doors the priest writes with the chalk “20 + C + M + B + 11”, i.e., the year and initials of the names of the Magi indicated in Rituale Romanum: Gaspar (G and C being related), Melchior et Baltássar.  The names of the Magi are traditional, not scriptural and some ancient authors thought there were as many as 24.   Some say “C + M + B” stands for “Christus Mansionem Benedicat… May Christ bless this dwelling”. Clever. Probably wrong.

Water is blessed at Epiphany because of Christ’s Baptism in the Jordan.  People give presents and enjoy King Cake and Lamb’s Wool (a drink made from cider or ale with roasted apples, sugar and spices).  Apple trees were blessed by pouring cider on them!

In Italy children wait for “la Befana” (from Italian “Epifania”). La Befana is old woman who was invited by the Magi to accompany them on their journey to find the newborn King. She declined because she was busy sweeping her house. Later, she realized her error followed the Magi but never caught up.  Thus, la Befana is still searching for Jesus, zooming around Harry Potter-like on her broomstick.  Santa-like, however, she visits homes and leaves toys and candy for good children, and the nasty lumps of coal for the naughty.

In today’s technological society, instead of coal she and jolly old St. Nick would do better to leave an obsolete cellular phone or maybe a first generation X-Box.

Santa gets cookies and milk by fireplaces to sustain him on his way, but Italians appropriately leave wine and oranges for la Befana.

COLLECT (1962MR):
Deus, qui hodierna die Unigenitum tuum gentibus stella duce revelasti:
concede propitius; ut, qui iam te ex fide cognovimus,
usque ad contemplandam speciem tuae celsitudinis perducamur.

This prayer, in the 8th century Gregorian Sacramentary, survived the scissors of the Annibale Bugnini’s post-Conciliar reform as the Collect in the Novus Ordo.  Your revelatory Lewis & Short Dictionary manifests celsitudo as, in older Latin, a “loftiness of carriage”. In later Latin it points to “majesty”, as in the title “Highness”.  The ending of revelasti is “syncopated” (abbreviated) from revelavistiStella duce is an ablative absolute (duce is from dux).   The adjective hodiernus, a, um, is “of this day, today’s”, so hodierna dies literally is “today’s day”, stronger than a simple “today”.  Perhaps we could say, “this day of days” or “this of all days”.

SLAVISHLY LITERAL CROWBAR:

O God, who this very day revealed your Only-begotten, a star having been the guide,
graciously grant,
that we, who have already come to know You from faith,
may be led all the way unto the contemplation of the beauty of Your majesty.

2008 CORRECTED ICEL:
O God,
who on this day revealed your Only Begotten Son to the nations
by the guidance of a star,
grant in your mercy
that we who know you now by faith
may be brought to behold
the beauty of your sublime glory
.

2010 REVISED CORRECTED VERSION:
O God, who on this day
revealed your Only Begotten Son to the nations
by the guidance of a star,
grant in your mercy
that we who know you already by faith
may be brought to behold
the beauty of your sublime glory
.

In this life we know God only indirectly, by faith.  This is St. Paul’s “dark glass” (1 Cor 13:12) through which we peer toward Him in longing.  In the next life we will not need faith. We will have direct knowledge.  In the phrase usque ad contemplandam speciem (a gerundive construction indicating purpose) we pray to be brought “all the way to the beauty” of God “which is to be contemplated”.  Our encounter with His beauty will increase our knowledge of Him, and therefore our love, for all eternity.  This is what we were made for: His glory and splendor.  St. Hilary of Poitiers (+367) spoke of the gloria of God as a transforming power which will divinize us, conform us more and more to His image.  In our Collect, note the move from faith to knowledge in the Beatific Vision. Christ is the visible image of the invisible God. He is the Beauty and Truth of the Father.

Our Catholic faith, our splendid liturgy both show forth God’s truth and beauty.  Proper worship requires the most accurate, the most beautiful words, actions, and music we can summon from human genius.  What we do and say in church should be a foretaste of heaven and the Beatific Vision.  Think simply of the effect music has on people.  A couple years ago in National Review Michael Knox Beran wrote that, “if good music does not always save the soul, bad music never does. When the electric guitar sounds during the Sacrifice of the Mass, the cherubim weep(“Mysterious Encounters – Benedict XVI resurrects the aesthetics of the Mass”, 24 Dec. 2007). Holy Church is reclaiming her great liturgical treasury, especially since Pope Benedict gave us Summorum Pontificum.  The new translation of the Novus Ordo Missale Romanum will help.

Participation at Holy Mass should be truly full, conscious and active.  We actively engage all we see and hear so as to receive what God offers through our Holy Church’s sacred mysteries.  We will have our own “epiphanies” during Mass. We will have moments of revelation about ourselves and the state of our soul, or what we ought to do in life.

Remember that the Word, who is God eternal, became flesh also in order to reveal us more fully to ourselves (cf. Gaudium et spes 22).  In the life to come, only the pure may see God.  Is this not enough of a motive to participate actively, with interiorly active receptivity, in this encounter with mystery?  Seek cleansing of your sins through confession and sacramental absolution.  The reality of our unavoidable judgment must at some point dawn upon us like a thunderclap.  When you finally grasp that you must one day die and face judgment, you will understand why Holy Mass must be nothing other than an encounter with mystery, and not a distracting celebration of ourselves.

When you go to Mass, go like Moses.  He removed his sandals before the burning bush.  He peered through the cleft in the rock as God passed.  Be like Paul peering through the shadowy glass. Imitate the Magi, whose penetrating sight fixed on nothing other than the coming of the mysterious King, in whose perfect image something of the invisible Father is revealed.

Posted in WDTPRS | Tagged
27 Comments

REVIEW: New editions of 1962 altar missals

I was recently sent a beautiful reprint of  Benziger Brother’s 1962 Missale Romanum.  It is from from Preserving Christian Publications.  This is a fine book, beautifully bound, and very useful.

I am so grateful to have it, since my original 1962 edition is showing some wear.  I will remember to pray for the intention of the one who sent it.

I wrote about this edition before, here and about the Vatican edition here.  (I still want one of the those spiffy Vatican volumes.)

I recently had the chance to compare this reprint edition, from Preserving Christian Publications, side by side with the reprint by the Vatican Press of the typical edition.  I used them on alternating days for a week.

The photos are from my iPhone in a poorly lit sacristy, but they more than suffice.

PCP on the left. Vatican on the right.

PCP edition.

PCP has differently colored ribbon.

Vatican edition, all the ribbons are red.

PCP on the left, Vatican on the right.

PCP… that is an American dime for perspective.

Vatican.

PCP

The PCP, since it is the Benziger edition, has supplemental texts in the back for the USA.  The Vatican edition doesn’t have that, of course.

PCP has special prefaces.

Here is the PCP edition art style.

The Vatican’s art style.

Included in the back of the PCP edition was a loose sheet which has an adhesive edge with a strip you can remove so as to fix it into the book.  It is of the Tabella Temporaria Festorum Mobilium.

It includes dates up to and including…

I think most of the “discontinuity and rupture people” will be long gone by then.   Actually, much sooner than that.

Tick by tick.

Heh heh heh.

Finally… I lately used both editions, alternating days, at the altar for Mass.   Found that the PCP edition laid open a little better, but that my be because it had been in use a little longer.  My new edition lies open well.

Meanwhile….

Brick by brick.

Posted in Brick by Brick, REVIEWS | Tagged ,
19 Comments