L’Osservatore Romano: criticizing the questioners

If you haven’t yet seen this, you will want to hop over and have a look at Sandro Magister‘s always useful place.

In this case, Magister presents the back-to-back responses in the Vatican’s semi-official daily L’Osservatore Romano to two theologians in the more traditional camp who have called for a reexamination of the Second Vatican Council.   Inos Biffi and (Archbp.) Agostino Marchetto responded to the books of Msgr. Brunero Gherardini and Prof. Roberto de Mattei.

These books have been out for a while but only now is L’Osservatore Romano getting around to talking about them.

You might be saying, “But Father! But Father!  What do you think of the timing of these articles in L’Osservatore?”

I think that the beatification of Pope John Paul II is right around the corner and that the media spotlight is turning to Rome, and questions being raised about the beatification and about the present state of the Church.

In any event, check out Magister’s site.

The Disappointed Have Spoken. The Vatican responds

Inos Biffi and Agostino Marchetto reply in “L’Osservatore Romano” to the traditionalists Brunero Gherardini and Roberto de Mattei, who criticize the current pope for not having corrected the “errors” of Vatican Council II

by Sandro Magister

ROME, April 18, 2011 – Two of the “greats disappointed by Pope Benedict” on whom www.chiesa reported in a recent article have been the special focus of “L’Osservatore Romano,” with two consecutive and authoritative reviews of their latest books.

The “disappointed greats” are those traditionalist thinkers who had initially placed hopes in the pontificate of Joseph Ratzinger and in his restorative action, but then saw their expectations betrayed. And now they are making their discontent public.

Their disappointment comes above all from the way in which the current pope interprets and applies Vatican Council II.

Because it is there, in this Council, that is found the root of the evils present in the Church, in the view of these thinkers.

In particular, this is what has been written and argued in the latest books by Professor Roberto de Mattei and Canon Brunero Gherardini, the one from the historical point of view and the other from the theological point of view.

The aforementioned article from www.chiesa provides a concise summary of their theses:

[…]

Read the rest there.

Posted in Biased Media Coverage, The Drill, The future and our choices | Tagged , , , , , , , ,
9 Comments

Brick by brick in Wyoming

I like Wyoming.  I spent time there as a kid.  My mother grew up there. Carmelites in Wyoming will send you great coffee.  Wyoming Catholic College, which I have visited, has the Extraordinary Form of Mass and Eastern Divine Liturgy, teaches the Trivium and Quadrivium, horsemanship and how to shoot guns. The air is as clean as is the spirit there and their goals are as high as the mountains they get to ride in a hike through.

Speaking of Wyoming Catholic College, check this out.

[wp_youtube]wiriitr8i8E[/wp_youtube]

Brick by brick.

Posted in Brick by Brick, Just Too Cool | Tagged
25 Comments

Your Good News

Do you have any recent good news for us all?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
55 Comments

QUAERITUR: Inserting a ditty into the reading of the Passion

UPDATE:  A reader in a comment below shows that I was wrong about my answer.  But I am going to claim that I am also right, depending on which country you are in.  It was inconceivable to me as I was answering this that such a thing could be permitted, so I didn’t double check the Novus Ordo rubrics in different countries, through my bad, my bad, my – like – totally bad.

I think this is a really BAD idea to have this as an option anywhere, but… they didn’t ask me.

That said, and with my mistake in mind:

_____

From a reader:

During the reading of the Passion today, the choir jumped in at random moments to sing part of “What Wondrous Love Is This”. That feels wrong; is it?

What part of Say The Black – Do The Red don’t they understand?

I was unaware that the text of the song “What Wondrous Love Is This” was in the Gospel.

This strikes me as well-intentioned, but ultimately condescending to the congregation.

It is as if the people and priest who organized this had such a dim view of the intelligence of the congregation that they thought they had to spiff-up the Gospel.

The Gospel narrative wasn’t enough on its own.

Furthermore, it reveals an attitude of superiority in regard to the Church’s liturgical worship: we can do anything we want to it.

I recommend you send the priests and “liturgy committee”, Say The Black – Do The Red mugs.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, Liturgy Science Theatre 3000 | Tagged , ,
45 Comments

When agendas trump logic

One of the worst pieces of reasoning I have seen in a while…. almost as bad as that recent stupid piece in TIME about the new translation .

Get a load of this, from the Telegraph.

First homosexual caveman found

Archaeologists have unearthed the 5,000-year-old remains of what they believe may have been the world’s oldest known gay caveman.

The male body – said to date back to between 2900-2500BC – was discovered buried in a way normally reserved only for women of the Corded Ware culture in the Copper Age.

The skeleton was found in a Prague suburb in the Czech Republic with its head pointing eastwards and surrounded by domestic jugs, rituals only previously seen in female graves.

“From history and ethnology, we know that people from this period took funeral rites very seriously so it is highly unlikely that this positioning was a mistake,” said lead archaeologist Kamila Remisova Vesinova.

“Far more likely is that he was a man with a different sexual orientation, homosexual or transsexual,” she added.

[…]

Good grief.

A male body is found in a grave pit with females, and doesn’t have the usual man stuff around him, therefore he has to have been a homosexual.   The noble enlightened primitives respected Glak’s wishes and buried him as a female.

There’s good archeology for ya.

I have other explanations.

  • There were lots of deaths at the time and Glak’s tribe did, in fact, make a mistake.
  • They were hiding the true location of Glak’s burial for some reason.
  • They hated Glak and wanted to humiliate him in the eternal Mammoth Hunting Ground.
Posted in Throwing a Nutty | Tagged ,
46 Comments

Benedict XVI’s Palm Sunday Sermon

With my emphases and comments:

Dear Brothers and Sisters,

Dear young people! [Pueri, indeed.  Palm Sunday has associations with World Youth Day, I believe.]

It is a moving experience each year on Palm Sunday as we go up the mountain with Jesus, towards the Temple, accompanying him on his ascent. [The Pope reminded us in his 2nd volume of Jesus of Nazareth about the literal ascent from the very low Sea of Galilee to the much higher Jerusalem.] On this day, throughout the world and across the centuries, young people and people of every age acclaim him, crying out: “Hosanna to the Son of David! Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord!” [And then many of them turned on Him.  Let’s not forget that.  We do to.]

But what are we really doing when we join this procession as part of the throng which went up with Jesus to Jerusalem and hailed him as King of Israel? Is this anything more than a ritual, a quaint custom? Does it have anything to do with the reality of our life and our world? To answer this, we must first be clear about what Jesus himself wished to do and actually did. After Peter’s confession of faith in Caesarea Philippi, in the northernmost part of the Holy Land, Jesus set out as a pilgrim towards Jerusalem for the feast of Passover. He was journeying towards the Temple in the Holy City, towards that place which for Israel ensured in a particular way God’s closeness to his people. He was making his way towards the common feast of Passover, the memorial of Israel’s liberation from Egypt and the sign of its hope of definitive liberation. He knew that what awaited him was a new Passover and that he himself would take the place of the sacrificial lambs by offering himself on the cross. He knew that in the mysterious gifts of bread and wine he would give himself for ever to his own, and that he would open to them the door to a new path of liberation, to fellowship with the living God. He was making his way to the heights of the Cross, to the moment of self-giving love. The ultimate goal of his pilgrimage was the heights of God himself; to those heights he wanted to lift every human being. [So far he is developing a theme of rising, even aiming high.]

Our procession today is meant, then, to be an image of something deeper, to reflect the fact that, together with Jesus, we are setting out on pilgrimage along the high road that leads to the living God. This is the ascent that matters. This is the journey which Jesus invites us to make. But how can we keep pace with this ascent? Isn’t it beyond our ability? Certainly, it is beyond our own possibilities. From the beginning men and women have been filled – and this is as true today as ever – with a desire to “be like God”, to attain the heights of God by their own powers. All the inventions of the human spirit are ultimately an effort to gain wings so as to rise to the heights of Being and to become independent, completely free, as God is free. [Think of the Tower of Babel… genetic manipulation….] Mankind has managed to accomplish so many things: we can fly! We can see, hear and speak to one another from the farthest ends of the earth. And yet the force of gravity which draws us down is powerful. With the increase of our abilities there has been an increase not only of good. Our possibilities for evil have increased and appear like menacing storms above history. Our limitations have also remained: we need but think of the disasters which have caused so much suffering for humanity in recent months. [In a sense we suffered from the earthquake in Japan because of Original Sin, but the Holy Father seems to be saying something more immediate and about technology.]

The Fathers of the Church maintained that human beings stand at the point of intersection between two gravitational fields. First, there is the force of gravity which pulls us down – towards selfishness, falsehood and evil; the gravity which diminishes us and distances us from the heights of God. On the other hand there is the gravitational force of God’s love: the fact that we are loved by God and respond in love attracts us upwards. Man finds himself betwixt this twofold gravitational force; everything depends on our escaping the gravitational field of evil and becoming free to be attracted completely by the gravitational force of God, which makes us authentic, elevates us and grants us true freedom.  [This is Augustinian.  In ancient times, people thought that gravity was a characteristic of the thing itself rather than an external force that worked on the object.  In ancient thought, things sought to go to the place they belonged, to their place of rest where they were in balance.  Augustine describes love in terms of weight, or gravity.  Amor meus pondus meum… my love is my weight.  When you love, love draw to what you love.  In the case of the human soul and mind and heart, we are necessarily drawn to God, the source and goal of our being.  Therefore, we must always be restless until we are with God, our perfect place of rest.  When we force ourselves to go to something else, a false resting point, we cannot be at rest or happy or in harmony with our end.]

Following the Liturgy of the Word, at the beginning of the Eucharistic Prayer where the Lord comes into our midst, the Church invites us to lift up our hearts: “Sursum corda!” [Hearts up.] In the language of the Bible and the thinking of the Fathers, the heart is the centre of man, where understanding, will and feeling, body and soul, all come together. The centre where spirit becomes body and body becomes spirit, where will, feeling and understanding become one in the knowledge and love of God. This is the “heart” which must be lifted up. But to repeat: of ourselves, we are too weak to lift up our hearts to the heights of God. We cannot do it. The very pride of thinking that we are able to do it on our own drags us down and estranges us from God. God himself must draw us up, and this is what Christ began to do on the cross. He descended to the depths of our human existence in order to draw us up to himself, to the living God. He humbled himself, as today’s second reading says. Only in this way could our pride be vanquished: God’s humility is the extreme form of his love, and this humble love draws us upwards.

Psalm 24, which the Church proposes as the “song of ascent” to accompany our procession in today’s liturgy, indicates some concrete elements which are part of our ascent and without which we cannot be lifted upwards: clean hands, a pure heart, the rejection of falsehood, the quest for God’s face. [That note about purity isn’t just for the young people.] The great achievements of technology are liberating and contribute to the progress of mankind only if they are joined to these attitudes – if our hands become clean and our hearts pure, if we seek truth, if we seek God and let ourselves be touched and challenged by his love. All these means of “ascent” are effective only if we humbly acknowledge that we need to be lifted up; if we abandon the pride of wanting to become God. We need God: he draws us upwards; letting ourselves be upheld by his hands – by faith, in other words – sets us aright and gives us the inner strength that raises us on high. We need the humility of a faith which seeks the face of God and trusts in the truth of his love.

The question of how man can attain the heights, becoming completely himself and completely like God, has always engaged mankind. It was passionately disputed by the Platonic philosophers of the third and fourth centuries. For them, the central issue was finding the means of purification which could free man from the heavy load weighing him down and thus enable him to ascend to the heights of his true being, to the heights of divinity. Saint Augustine, [And here he is!] in his search for the right path, long sought guidance from those philosophies. But in the end he had to acknowledge that their answers were insufficient, their methods would not truly lead him to God. To those philosophers he said: recognize that human power and all these purifications are not enough to bring man in truth to the heights of the divine, to his own heights. And he added that he should have despaired of himself and human existence had he not found the One who accomplishes what we of ourselves cannot accomplish; the One who raises us up to the heights of God in spite of our wretchedness: Jesus Christ who from God came down to us and, in his crucified love, takes us by the hand and lifts us on high.

We are on pilgrimage with the Lord to the heights. We are striving for pure hearts and clean hands, we are seeking truth, we are seeking the face of God. Let us show the Lord that we desire to be righteous, and let us ask him: Draw us upwards! Make us pure! Grant that the words which we sang in the processional psalm may also hold true for us; grant that we may be part of the generation which seeks God, “which seeks your face, O God of Jacob” (cf. Ps 24:6). Amen.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , ,
5 Comments

Confessions during the Triduum

Each year one sees confusion about the Sacrament of Penance during the Triduum.

Some priests, liturgical experts, and even diocesan liturgy offices wrongly claim the rubrics of the Missal or “Sacramentary” forbid the sacrament of Penance.

However, this claim is incorrect.

Here is what the texts really say.

The previous 1970 and 1975 editions of the Missale Romanum (the Novus Ordo) said of Good Friday and Holy Saturday (BTW… the language of this rubric goes back to Pope Innocent III +1216):

Hac et sequenti die, Ecclesia, ex antiquissima traditione, sacramenta penitus non celebrat… On this and the following day, the Church, from a most ancient tradition, does not at all celebrate the sacraments.

However, since this is in the Missal (the book for MASS), sacramenta refers only to the Eucharist, Holy Mass, and not the other sacraments.

The Congregation for Divine Worship and Discipline of the Sacraments (CDWDS) clarified this in its official publication Notitiae (1977 – no. 137 (Dec) p. 602).

In the 2002 edition of the Missale Romanum at paragraph 1 for Good Friday all doubt is removed.

The above cited text has been amended to say (the change with my emphasis):

Hac et sequenti die, Ecclesia, ex antiquissima traditione, sacramenta, praeter Paenitentiae et Infirmorum Unctionis, penitus non celebrat… On this and the following day, the Church, from a most ancient tradition, does not at all celebrate the sacraments, except for (the sacraments of) Penance and Anointing of the Sick.

Priests can indeed, and probably should, hear confessions on Good Friday and on Holy Saturday.

Who can forget the image of the late and soon-to-be-beatified Pope hearing confession in St. Peter’s Basilica on Good Friday?

Here is a bonus tip, speaking of confessions.

As I have posted before, it is both permitted and often appropriate for confessions to be heard during Holy Mass on other days of the year!

Want proof?  Try the CDWDS document Redemptionis Sacramentum 76 and also the Congregation’s Response to a Dubium in Notitiae 37 (2001) pp. 259-260.

Having a priest in a confessional before and even during Mass on Sundays and feasts could be a way to revive the use of this ailing but essential sacrament.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, Brick by Brick | Tagged , ,
19 Comments

Getting ready for Palm Sunday

We are getting ready for Palm Sunday.

20110417-104011.jpg

20110417-104025.jpg

20110417-104037.jpg

20110417-104050.jpg

20110417-104059.jpg

Posted in Brick by Brick, Just Too Cool, Our Catholic Identity, SESSIUNCULA, What Fr. Z is up to | Tagged ,
10 Comments

YOUR Palm Sunday and Holy Week

Give us a description of Palm Sunday at your parish as well as what is going on during Holy Week before the Triduum begins.

For my part, I will be involved with the Palm Sunday in the Extraordinary Form at Holy Innocents in Manhattan (NYC).   Mass today will have Gregorian chant for the Ordinary and Proper.

Posted in Brick by Brick | Tagged ,
56 Comments

Cincinnati: Extraordinary Form Triduum

I had a note from St. Mark’s Chaplaincy and Una Voce Cincinnati that the Triduum including Tenebrae will be celebrated in the Extraordinary Form.

For further information about any of these services, please call (513)
393 9872.

Posted in Brick by Brick | Tagged
Comments Off on Cincinnati: Extraordinary Form Triduum