SAY THE BLACK mug sighting … in the wild!

Buy WDTPRS stuff!I received a nice note from a priest reader who … well… let him speak for himself:

I attach some photos taken in the monks’ refectory at the St Louis Abbey on Easter Sunday, where I and two of my colleagues from the Liturgical Institute had the privilege of making a Holy Week retreat. When we saw this mug appear, we knew we’d have to let you know.

 

SAY THE BLACK mug sighting ... in the wild!

I think there are many priests out there, those dedicated to rather poorly considered liturgical abuses, who would appreciate one of their own!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
2 Comments

QUAERITUR: putting collection under the altar during offertory

A reader queries:

Our diocesan liturgist claims that it is ok with Canon law to put the monetary offers under (literally in my parish, there’s an opening under the altar stone, between the supports of the table part) the altar.   She says that the GIRM (which I quoted on the subject) does not have the weight of canon law.  [FAIL.]

I am pretty sure she’s wrong, [She is wrong.] and you seem like the sort of priest who could point me to where she is wrong.  Is there anything written to the effect of GIRM is the law of the Mass, and Canon Law is the law of (whatever Canon Law deals with)?

I consulted a canonist just to be sure to get the right language for this fundamental response which any priest or "liturgist" – lay or ordained – ought to know in order to claim anything close to competence.

Canon 2 of the 1983 Code of Canon Law for the Latin Church pretty much destroys the argument of the diocesan liturgist:

"For the most part, the Code does not determine the rites to be observed in the celebration of liturgical actions. Accordingly, liturgical laws which have been in effect hitherto retain their force, except those which may be contrary to the canons of the Code."

This acknowledges several important things – first of all, liturgical law is truly law – not just "guidelines."

Secondly, the Code is not the place to look for liturgical law. The Institutio Generalis Missalis Romani (hereafter GIRM) was duly promulgated as law in accord with canons 7 and 8.
 
John Huels (a canonist who holds a lot of weight – mostly deservedly – among liturgists – though no weight at all concerning anything else and for pretty serious reasons) states in his book Liturgy and Law:

The major sources of universal liturgical legislation for the Latin Church are the norms contained in the liturgical books, the canons on the liturgy in Book IV of the Code, and other current legislative texts issued by the Holy See. The canons of the Code for the most part do not specify matters dealing directly with the celebration of the liturgy. Such laws are found principally in the liturgical books in two forms: the rubrics and the praenotanda…. Both rubrics and praenotanda are overwhelmingly ecclesiastical, not divine, laws and are subject to the general norms of the Code on ecclesiastical laws. They are equal in weight to the canons of the Code and to other universal ecclesiastical laws. (p. 84 ff)

 
Article 73 of the GIRM has the same canonical weight as a canon. 

Shall we have a look?

The Preparation of the Gifts

73. At the beginning of the Liturgy of the Eucharist the gifts, which will become Christ’s Body and Blood, are brought to the altar.

First, the altar, the Lord’s table, which is the center of the whole Liturgy of the Eucharist,70 is prepared by placing on it the corporal, purificator, Missal, and chalice (unless the chalice is prepared at the credence table).

The offerings are then brought forward. It is praiseworthy for the bread and wine to be presented by the faithful. They are then accepted at an appropriate place by the priest or the deacon and carried to the altar. Even though the faithful no longer bring from their own possessions the bread and wine intended for the liturgy as in the past, nevertheless the rite of carrying up the offerings still retains its force and its spiritual significance.

It is well also that money or other gifts for the poor or for the Church, brought by the faithful or collected in the church, should be received. These are to be put in a suitable place but away from the eucharistic table.

NB: "These are to be put in a suitable place but away from the eucharistic table."

AWAY from the altar.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, Brick by Brick, SESSIUNCULA |
21 Comments

UN Judge Says Pope Should be Prosecuted at International Criminal Court

Another one for "Is It Stupidity Or Just Bigotry" file….

From C-FAM:

UN Judge Says Pope Should be Prosecuted at International Criminal CourtUN Judge Says Pope Should be Prosecuted at International Criminal Court

By Susan Yoshihara, Ph.D.

April 8, 2010 (C-FAM) – In London last Friday, a high ranking United Nations (UN) jurist called on the British government to detain Pope Benedict XVI during his upcoming visit to Britain, and send him to trial in the International Criminal Court (ICC) for “crimes against humanity.”

Geoffrey Robertson touted his status as a UN judge in an article he published last week, in which he argued that jurists should invoke the same procedures that have been used to indict war criminals such as Slobodan Milosevic, to try the Pope as head of the Roman Catholic Church, who he said is ultimately responsible for sexual abuse of children by Catholic priests.  [Did he just compare Pope Benedict to Slobodan Milosevic?  How stupid is this guy?  Or is he simply a bigot?]

Robertson is one of five select jurists in the UN’s internal justice system responsible for holding UN officials accountable for corruption and mismanagement. [So, perhaps he – a judge – should stick to looking at UN officials and keep his mouth shut about others?] His article was published in both the United States and Britain and reported on by the Associated Press.

     Professor Hurst Hannum of the Fletcher School at Tufts University told the Friday Fax that it would be a “real stretch” to use the ICC since that court’s jurisdiction is mainly reserved for crimes during war. ["war crimes"] More likely, Hannum said, is that Robertson and likeminded experts would invoke the principle of “universal jurisdiction” so that national courts all over the world could detain the pope whenever he stepped foot on their soil. Critics say the principle, already used in practice, is a violation of sovereignty as it is enshrined in the UN Charter.

     Yet Robertson insisted that the ICC could be used as long as the Pope’s sovereign immunity was waived and as long as jurists can show that the sex abuse scandal was carried out on a “widespread or systematic scale,” the way that child soldiers were used in the wars in Sierra Leone and the way that sex slaves are traded internationally.

     Robertson, a tort lawyer, argued that prosecution at a higher level of the Church is necessary to get more money for victims of clergy sexual abuse in cases where dioceses have gone into bankruptcy. He specifically pointed out the fact that the diocese of Los Angeles has already paid $660M in damages and Boston has paid $100M.

One prominent law professor told the Friday Fax, “Without in any way minimizing the seriousness of the alleged offenses of Catholic priests, it would be a grave mistake to the laws of human rights to permit a trivializing of the responsibility to protect, and to play into the hands of American contingency-fee lawyers.”

 [Read this closely…]    Another human rights lawyer told the Friday Fax that the article could be part of a broader campaign.  Robertson has long campaigned to strip the Holy See of its permanent observer status at the UN, and has publicly referred to the Holy See “the world’s largest NGO.”

     When a campaign was launched to oust the Holy See from its status in 1999, UN Member States rallied around the Vatican, and in 2004 the General Assembly voted unanimously to expand that status. It is unclear whether UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon knew about Robertson’s leanings before appointing him to his current position.  [Someone should ask him.  Hey!  CNN!  FoxNews!]

Posted in The Last Acceptable Prejudice, Throwing a Nutty | Tagged
44 Comments

QUAERITUR: priest doesn’t hold the Host for consecration

Buy WDTPRS stuff!I received this by e-mail:

I went to daily Mass this morning and unfortunately had a priest who does not take the rubrics very seriously. There were several things that were not exactly correct, but the major things I noticed were that he kept his hands loosely folded throughout the Eucharistic Prayer and also that he pronounced the words of Consecration without taking the bread in his hands. After he saying the words of the Consecration, he picked the PATTEN with one hand and held it up, doing the same thing with the chalice. So he never touched the Hosts until Communion. This is pretty substantial and while I doubt if it was invalid, I just wanted to get your thoughts on this. I think that priest needs a lot of prayers for this among other things.

 

That was valid but highly illicit.  Remember, that a priest also validly consecrates hosts in a pyx or ciborium without touching them.  Touching is not needed for validity.

I would address myself first to the priest and ask why he does what he does.  If he is amenable, you might ask him to look over the rubrics with you. You might also want to give him a Say The Black… Do The Red coffee mug to punctuate the event.

Even in the lame-duck Sacramentary in the USA we find in the 1st Eucharistic Prayer … and this is consistent with the other Eucharistic Prayers:

The day before he suffered

He takes the bread and, raising it a little above the altar, continues:

he took bread in his sacred hands…

Say The Black… Do The Red.  Right?  Is this hard?

If he is uncooperative in that regard, or repulses you, I would immediately address myself to the local bishop, in writing, explaining exactly what the facts are without editorializing, and send a copy to the Congregation for Divine Worship and Discpline of the Sacraments.  A photo would be helpful.  The Congregation, or any ecclesiastical authority, is loathe to do anything unless there are proofs that something is going on.

In any event, the people of God have the right not to have priests screw around with the rubrics.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
6 Comments

24 April: Pontifical TLM at the National Shrine in Washington, DC

WDTPRSers… put out the word.  Fill the Shrine!

At 1:00 pm on 24 April at the National Shrine of the Immaculate Conception in Washington DC there is to be a Pontifical Mass celebrated by His Eminence Dario Card. Castrillon Hoyos, former President of the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei.  This will be the 5th anniversary of the election of His Holiness Benedict XVI.
donate
The Ordinary of the Mass will be a polyphonic Mass setting sung by a professional choir, while the Propers will be Gregorian chant, chanted by an experienced men’s schola.

The National Shrine of the Immaculate Conception is the United States’ patronal church, and for that reason this Mass is an event for all Americans.

Thethis Mass will be broadcast on EWTN.  The broadcast required additional funding.  Therefore, there is a kind request that people who are interested in seeing such a broadcast might give a donation of at least $5 through THIS PAGE.  $5 in honor of the 5th anniversary of the election of Pope Benedict seems reasonable.  Of course you could give more.  

It will be wonderful to have this Pontifical Mass in the National Shrine broadcast and thus made available to so many more… thus to further Pope Benedict’s vision to revitalize our Catholic identity especially through a true renewal of our liturgical worship in continuity with Tradition.

For a quick look at the latest on the Mass check out www.pontificalmass.org
Follow the planning of the Mass on twitter.
View and track the event on FaceBook

Fill the Shrine!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
37 Comments

Of Private Mythologies and Indigo Buntings

I am waiting for the Indigo Buntings to arrive.  Thanks to a couple recent donations, I have a special feeder out for them with millet seed, which they prefer.

I also found this nice piece on the blog Anecdotal Evidence. 

It caught my eye not only because of the Bunting reference, but also because of the quotation of John Ciardi, who is well-known inter alia for his translations of Il Poeta… as well as a certain word!

Friday, April 09, 2010

`Let There Be Bread and Seeds in Time’

In memory, uncommon events, often the humblest, turn into private mythology. [Nice.] Seated alone at our kitchen table in Saratoga Springs, N.Y., some ten years ago, I stared idly through the sliding glass doors and across the deck into the wild cherry trees bordering the rear of our property. From the left entered a flash of unnatural blue, settling among the bobbing branches. The mind takes its time. I thought first of shimmering fabric, a silk scarf, before the analytical powers kicked in: an indigo bunting, perhaps the third or fourth I had ever seen. In seconds it fled.

I questioned the reality of what I had just seen, like the witness to a crime (or a miracle) who doubts the evidence of his eyes. It was not only the bird’s unlikely beauty that made its abrupt appearance feel unreal, but its sense of prepared unexpectedness. I wasn’t looking for it but it arrived and I felt ready to see it. I felt like a theatergoer who discovers the play he expected has been scrapped for another, and is pleased. John Ciardi’s “Bird Watching”:

“Every time we put crumbs out and sunflower seeds something comes. Most often sparrows. Frequently a jay. Now and then a junco or a cardinal. And once – immediately and never again, but as commonly as any miracle while it is happening, and then instantly incredible for – ever – the tiniest (was it?) yellow warbler as nearly as I could thumb through the bird
book for it, or was it an escaped canary? Or simply the one impossible bright bird that is always there during a miracle, and then never?

“I, certainly, do not know all that comes to us at times. A bird is a bird as long as it is there. Then it is a miracle our crumbs and sunflower seeds caught and let go. Is there a book to look through for the identity of a miracle? No bird that is there is
miracle enough. Every bird that has been is entirely one. And if some miracles are rarer than others, every incredible bird has crumbs and seeds in common with every other. Let there be bread and seeds in time: all else will follow.”

Ciardi suggests the uncanny, ineffable [OH! THE HUMANITY!] and wonderful arrive unbidden. We can prepare ourselves, live and look and think in such a way – “Let there / be bread and seeds in time” – as to ready us for the miracle, the yellow warbler, the indigo bunting, but such things don’t arrive on demand.

 

A great blog post.

Of Private Mythologies and Indigo Buntings

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

The editorial offices of Hell’s Bible

It looks as if at least one editorial cartoonist has gone my point about Hell’s Bible.

The editorial offices of Hell's Bible

I am not sure who did that cartoon, but I would like to buy him a beer.

UPDATE 1400 GMT:

Your readers amaze me.  No sooner do I put this out there, but the great Fr. GM writes to say:

Sean Delonas of the NY Post. He also painted the altar mural at St. Agnes on 43rd St.. (In NYC).

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

Pius XII … er um… Homer… er um… someone nodded

Homer nods all over the place.  He can nod at times even in papal documents… or at least the online versions of papal documents on the Vatican website.

A reader caught this blooper, which given the recent climate of hostility being created by the New York Times I thought especially amusing.

From the reader:

This, in the following link to Pius XII’s encyclical on St. Bernard from 1953:
 

The "Doctor Mellifluus," "the last of the Fathers, but certainly not inferior to the earlier ones,"[1] was remarkable for such qualities of nature and of mind, and so enriched by God with heavenly gifts, that in the changing and often stormy Times New Roman in which he lived, he seemed to dominate by his holiness, wisdom, and most prudent counsel. Wherefore, he has been highly praised, not only by the sovereign Pontiffs and writers of the Catholic Church, but also, and not infrequently, by heretics.
 
(I kid you not — it’s right there!)

Seeing is believing, they say… so I sought and I found:

Pius XII ... er um... Homer... er um... someone nodded

Posted in Lighter fare |
11 Comments

Springtime for priestesses in the Diocese of Springfield

I received this from a reader by e-mail.  I had to do a double-take.

The story is on the site of the Intelligencer of Edwarsville, IL in the Diocese of Springfield.

Easter Vigil

Published: Monday, April 5, 2010 10:53 AM CDT
Photo by Rachael Wilbur

On Saturday evening members of St. Boniface Catholic Church and St. Andrews Episcopal Church gathered together as one celebrating the ritual “Blessing of the Fire and Lighting of the Candle.” Both Father Jeffrey Goeckner (foreground) and Reverend Virginia Bennett (background) led the services in front of St. Boniface School as part of the Easter Vigil. The event marked the first time the neighboring churches combined their individual ceremonies in to one.

Okay folks… I don’t know what sort of ceremony that was… but if it was the beginning of the Easter Vigil service and Mass, then this is appalling.  If it was not the beginning of the Vigil Mass, then it still looks very bad.

The person who sent the note added this:

A joint Easter Vigil celebrated by St. Boniface Catholic Church and St. Andrew Episcopal Church.  It is bad enough that the pastor of the latter is a (purported) priestess, Virginia Bennett, but worse when you consider that she is a flaming liberal in a "moderate" Episcopalian diocese.  The Episcopalian Diocese of Springfield used to be part of the conservative Anglo-Catholic "biretta belt" in the Episcopal Church, but its recently retired bishop, Peter Beckwith (b. 1939, Bp. 1991-2010) introduced priestesses into his diocese, the first one of its bishops to do so.  However, he is conservative in other respects, and a couple of years ago a controversy between Bishop Beckwith and Priestess Bennett made it into the news.  The bishop was due to make a pastoral visit to St. Andrews, at which he was to confirm several persons.  Among them was a "partnered lesbian," whom Priestess Bennett had prepared for confirmation, telling her that her "partnered status" was no obstacle — but when she told the bishop (who seems to have been alerted to it by one or more parishioners) he refused to confirm the said lesbian, saying that her "lifestyle" was "inappropriate."

Well, that’s par for the course in the Episcopal Church today, even in "conservative" dioceses, but it is sad and strange that she should be honored in this way by a Catholic priest and thus be allowed to deceive Catholics into thinking that she is a real priest(ess).

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
17 Comments

The Pfleger-ization of the Catholic Church… in Chicago

On Real Clear Politics I found this piece by conservative pundette Michele Malkin about some current liberalizing temdencies in the Catholic Church.

My emphases and comments.

April 9, 2010
The Pfleger-ization of the Catholic Church
By Michelle Malkin

So much that you need to know about the Catholic Church’s social policy problems [Along the line she will have to define her terms.  I don’t think "social policy" and "social teaching" can be conflated.  If she makes this rookie mistake, she will stumble into the same hole Glen Beck fell into.] can be summed up in one word: Chicago. On race, abortion, guns, immigration and "community organizing," Catholic Church officials in the Windy City have forged unholy alliances with radical left-wingers and enablers who undermine the faith — and the faithful. [Again, the Church has a body of social teaching.  If in Chicago, or other localities, Catholics have gone to the zoo on social issues, that is to be laid at the doorstep of stupidity, not documents such as, for example, Centesimus annus.]

Exhibit A: the Archdiocese of Chicago’s Office for Racial Justice and one of its most notorious priests, the Rev. Michael Pfleger. This week, Chicago Cardinal Francis George — who also happens to be president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops — presided over a gala ceremony honoring Pfleger with a "lifetime achievement award" for his "service in pursuit of dismantling racism, injustice and inequalities on behalf of African Americans and all people of color."

How, pray tell, has Pfleger achieved the officially sanctioned Catholic vision of "racial justice"? [Okay… this seems to be something of a distinction.] By aligning himself with the nation’s worst racial demagogues and using his pulpit at the St. Sabina Catholic Church on Chicago’s Southside to promote poisonous identity politics.

Pfleger (who is white) grabbed the spotlight during the 2008 presidential campaign with jive-talking defenses of his fellow race-hustler and President Obama’s spiritual mentor the Rev. Jeremiah ("God damn America!" and "AmeriKKKA!") Wright and Jew-bashing hate-monger Louis (Judaism is a "gutter religion") Farrakhan. The racial justice award-winner called the latter a "great man" and welcomed him to his church.

Pfleger, a member of the Catholics for Obama Committee, stoked further racial division by mocking Hillary Clinton’s skin color and accusing her of "white entitlement." It’s one thing to ridicule Hillary’s sense of political and ideological entitlement as part of the Clinton dynasty. But the demagogic emphasis on her race was beyond the pale.

Screamed Pfleger while wearing his Roman Catholic collar during a guest appearance at Wright’s Trinity United Church of Christ:

"I really believe that (Hillary) just always thought, ‘This is mine (congregation laughter, hoots). I’m Bill’s wife. I’m white. And this is mine. And I jus’ gotta get up and step into the plate.’ And then out of nowhere came, ‘Hey, I’m Barack Obama.’ And she said, ‘Oh, damn! Where did you come from? (crowd goes nuts, Pfleger screaming). I’m white! I’m entitled! There’s a black man stealing my show. (sobs!)’ She wasn’t the only one crying! There was a whole lotta white people crying!"

On a roll, Pfleger mustered up his best Wright imitation and let loose on the entire country, proclaiming: "America is the greatest sin against God."

Pfleger has also embraced hate-crime hoax engineer Al Sharpton. Outraged Catholics across the country called on the archdiocese of Chicago to remove Pfleger. In response, Cardinal George meekly suspended Pfleger for two weeks over his "partisan" remarks — and has now honored him for his "service" to "racial justice."

The sermon in 1 Corinthians 15:33 teaches us that bad company corrupts good character. Have they forgotten?

In an e-mail exchange with Pfleger this week, he indignantly accused me of not telling the "truth." When I quoted his own toxic words back to him, he accused me of being "mean-spirited." ["Shut up!", he explained…]

This rogue Catholic priest has been arrested for vandalizing billboards in his community; threatened to "snuff out" a gun shop owner (Pfleger claims he didn’t mean to imply he would kill the businessman, just expose his private home address); [?!?] and flouted church rules limiting tenure. When the archdiocese attempted to enforce its two-term limit on Pfleger, he taunted them to "have the balls to fire" him. They didn’t — and Pfleger continues to serve indefinitely. [Sounds like a serious leadership problem.]

Mimicking Planned Parenthood and the death lobby, the Chicago archdiocese [Ouch!] defended late-term-abortion supporter Obama as "pro-choice" rather than "pro-abortion" this week [The Archdiocese?  An office of the Archdiocese?] — and did nothing in 2003 when Pfleger put radical-leftist actor Harry Belafonte on the St. Sabina pulpit to rail against former President George W. Bush’s pro-life policies.

Cardinal George did think it worthy of his time to condemn the "hate literature" of Illinois Catholic columnist Tom Roeser, who raised his voice against the church’s pedophilia scandal and criticized the willingness of Catholic Church leaders to sign on to the Obamacare sellout for the sake of "social justice."

For years, the far-left Catholic Campaign for Human Development forked over funding to Chicago-based, Saul Alinsky-trained outfits that employed then-community organizer Obama. [Ouch!] And the Chicago archdiocese has also lobbied aggressively alongside open-borders groups to undermine immigration enforcement, to halt homeland security raids against employers breaking immigration laws and to demand mass amnesty.

As if the massive global sex-abuse scandal that cost at least $3 billion in litigation and inflicted immeasurable pain and grief on Catholic molestation victims hasn’t done enough damage to its credibility, the Pfleger-ization of the Catholic Church goes on unabated. And the likes of Cardinal George are doing nothing to stop it.

This is not the Catholic Church I was raised in. It has left me.  [Problem: She knows better than to conflate what is going on in Chicago, and admittedly other places, with "the Catholic Church".]

 

Damning, to be sure.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , , ,
28 Comments