Camille Paglia on Richard Dawkins

It doesn’t surprise me at all that the always interesting Camille Paglia thinks Richard Dawkins is a twit.

… I was recently flicking my car radio dial and heard an affected British voice tinkling out on NPR. I assumed it was some fussy, gossipy opera expert fresh from London. To my astonishment, it was Richard Dawkins, the thrice-married emperor of contemporary atheists. I had never heard him speak, so it was a revelation. On science, Dawkins was spot on — lively and nimble. But on religion, his voice went "Psycho" weird (yes, Alfred Hitchcock) — as if he was channeling some old woman with whom he was in love-hate combat. I have no idea what ancient private dramas bubble beneath the surface there. As an atheist who respects and studies religion, I believe it is fair to ask what drives obsessive denigrators of religion. Neither extreme rationalism nor elite cynicism are adequate substitutes for faith, which fulfills a basic human need — which is why religion will continue to thrive in our war-torn world.

 

Ooorah!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged ,
13 Comments

HELP WDTPRS!

VOTE!

My site was nominated for Best Religion Blog!HELP WDTPRS!

There were a few hundred votes a while back.

Now there are… not a few hundred.

Keep our Catholic blogs out in front!

And while I’m at it.HELP WDTPRS!

You can follow me on Twitter.

There is also Plurk. 

There is also Facebook, which I look at once in a while.

You can also pick up the WDTPRS feed and post it on your own blog.

Also… I put a Google thingie on the side bar.

HELP WDTPRS!

UPDATE:

You might also take note of the Bloggies.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
15 Comments

Who will be next?

No doubt the staff of L’Osservatore has this as their hermeneutic. Biretta tip to an old friend DW….    o{]:¬)

From Stuff White People Like:

Before you begin hanging around with white people, you should know that all white humor comes from three sources: The Simpsons, Monty Python, and The Onion.

After L’Osservatore sang its paean to The Simpsons, will these two be next?

 

I must add that something is missing.

The Far Side.

Perhaps others?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
45 Comments

A comment on the death of Mary Daly

Many people asked me why I wasn’t commenting on the death of Mary Daly.

Okay… here is something.

From New American with my emphases and comments:

A comment on the death of Mary DalyBoston College and Its Radical Feminist ‘Catholic’
Written by Jack Kenny   
Friday, 08 January 2010 10:05 

For those who had not noticed, Mary Daly died last Friday. Daly was a feminist theologian who taught for 35 years at Jesuit-run Boston College in Massachusetts. She was, it seems safe to say, the Boston Globe’s kind of Catholic.

The Globe’s editorial tribute to her is running today under the headline "Requiem for a feminist." [After all, Sen. Kennedy got one.] It is possible to be both a feminist and a Catholic. Though Daly was clearly more feminist than Catholic, a case could be made that she was really neither.

Was it feminism, really, to bar male students from some of her courses? Or was it just an arrogant, spiteful gender pride? According to her biography, Daly, who earned a Ph.D. in English in addition to her degrees in theology, was influenced by "thinkers ranging from Thomas Aquinas to French feminist Simone de Beauvoir to Virginia Woolf." [Probably just an exercise in being post-modern clever, just like, say, a White House official who says she is influenced by Mother Teresa and Mao Zedong.] Saint Thomas might blush to find himself in such company. A theologian in a church that calls God our Father and does the same for the patriarch Abraham, Daly was a sworn enemy of "patriarchy," to which she attributed most, if not all, of the ills of both the church and secular society. After her first book, The Church and the Second Sex, she moved from "reformist" to "radical, post Christian feminist." And, of course, the Jesuits at Boston College must have thought it a bright, broad-minded idea to keep on the faculty of an allegedly Catholic college, a theologian who was a "post-Christian feminist."

The Globe finds it "remarkable in hindsight that she taught at a Catholic university for more than 30 years." That begs the question of whether Boston College is either a university (it calls itself a "college," after all) or Catholic. Because the Jesuits at BC are not "into" cashiering a theologian who describes herself as a "radical lesbian feminist." They are more likely to force out someone who faithfully upholds and proclaims unaltered the doctrines and creeds of the "One Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church" that have come to us from Christ through the Apostles. That is exactly what happened [!] more than 60 years ago when four BC professors who insisted on defending and proclaiming the dogma "Outside the Church There is No Salvation" were shown the door at broadminded, ecumenical Boston College. That started the theological battle that brought about the silencing and even the bogus "excommunication" of Father Leonard Feeney, a Jesuit who defended the fired professors and forced Archbishop and later Cardinal Cushing to take a stand on the controversy. That Cushing did, by putting Father Feeney and the Saint Benedict Center, where he lived and taught, under interdict and eventually driving them out of the diocese.  [Some ideas are more equal than others.  But there is no real equivalence between what Daly pushed and what Feeney pushed.  What Feeney promoted, agree or not, was a hard line position which was grounded in a serious teaching of the Church.]

Now one can choose between the vision and dogma of Father Feeney and the crusade of Saint Benedict Center and the vision of the feminist dogma of Mary Daly. The difference is [as I just said…] that one has the weight of history and church tradition behind it and the doctrine in question has been dogmatically proclaimed by three popes and two councils of the Roman Catholic Church. The radical feminism of Daly has no such pedigree to recommend it. Guess which one Boston College has chosen, again and again and again. The same one the Boston Globe has chosen, again and again and again. [The Boston Globe does not pretend to be a Catholic publication.  It isn’t a Catholic publication.]

That is why Mary Daly is praised on the editorial page of the Boston Globe and the successors of Father Feeney are not. [Welllll… why would they be in her obit?] Mary Daly may already have discovered that being praised by the Boston Globe doesn’t help when one enters eternity. [Just a whiff of litotes, wouldn’t you say?] She may have discovered that Heaven has done to a "radical lesbian feminist" what she did to male students at Boston College who wished to enroll in one or more of her courses. Heaven is, by definition, a wonderful place. But it is also, by definition, exclusionary.  

"…et pro multis effundetur…."

Posted in SESSIUNCULA, The Drill | Tagged , ,
76 Comments

Goofy wymympryst ideas in Cincinnati… again

From the blog Ten Reasons, with my emphases and comments:

"Carries an imprimatur from the Archdiocese of Cincinnati"

Goofy wymympryst ideas in Cincinnati... again
Carol Ann Morrow, assistant managing editor [and thus not just a staff writer or sometime contributrix] of St. Anthony Messenger magazine, published locally [that is, in Cincinnati] by the Franciscans at St. Anthony Messenger Press, defends the Catholic priestess movement in the Cincinnati Enquirer: [Does that sound like giving public scandal?  The Cincinnati Archdiocese has had more than its share of this goofy though bothersome problem, by the by.]

Gail Finke (”Your Voice” 1/7/10) will not soon be eligible to be a doctor OR a priest. [Watch the reasoning here…] She would need to study for BOTH professions. [See a problem with that?  Being a doctor is surely a profession and a "vocation", in some real senses of the word.  But it is not one to which one is called by a divinely instituted Church.  Graduating from med school does not impart an indelible mark on the soul.  Being a doctor might change your way of seeing the world and people, and even expose you to maladies, but it does not effect an ontological change.  Once you die, you are no longer a doctor.] She implies that the women who are ordained are not prepared by both study and by calling to be so. That is an incorrect assumption on her part. She thinks the refusal of any competent medical licensing board to give her a medical license is comparable to the Roman Catholic Church’s refusal to ordain women. It is not. The licensing board checks education, credentials and worthiness and probably does a background check. If one meets all those criteria, one will receive a license whether man or woman.

The “licensing board” of the Church is being challenged to reconsider its criteria. [See any problem with this?  The "licensing board" of a profession, say, medicine, law, etc., can determine their own criteria for those who would join them.  In the case of the Church’s "licensing board", they received their criteria from a higher authority.  The Church’s "licensing board" doesn’t have the authority to change those criteria.] This challenge is rooted in a study of Scripture and the ancient traditions of the Church. They are subject to debate in the view of many members of the Church, members who wish the Church and the vocation of the priesthood well, not ill. [Ummm…. no, not really.  They are not subject to debate.  They are to be accepted as defined, definitively taught by the Church.  The Church does not have the authority to change that teaching.]  Ms. Finke’s readiness for either profession is inadequate.

It is not clear to many women and men that women are unqualified–by education, calling or gender–for the priesthood. [A woman can be exceptionally well educated in all the things priests must be concerned with, but no woman ever has a "call" from the Church.  No woman can ever be ordained a priest.]  It may be that the licensing boards are not in touch with their ultimate supervisor. [This seems to be a suggesting that the Church is not doing what Jesus Christ wants by not simulating the ordination of women.  Is that a good suggestion for someone who edits a Catholic publication should be making?] That requires openness to dialogue and faithfulness to prayer.  [So… the idea here is, "Let’s dialogue until the Church agrees with my desires.]

Carol Ann Morrow

Union

She is also the author of the publisher’s "Quick Look at the New U.S. Catechism" and a Catholic Update devoted to Mary Magdalene (‘natch). [The idea here is that Mary Magdalen was the "apostle to the apostles".  I think you are supposed to glean from this that women can be ordained.]  As I’ve written before, one of the small but certain things our new shepherd can do to indicate a new direction for the diocese is revoke the rubber stamp imprimatur his predecessor gave to St. Anthony Messenger Press.

I don’t think that the St. Anthony Messenger should be judged by the aberrant musings of an editor in a different publication.  You don’t have to be a faithful Catholic to check spelling and formatting.

However, this would be a good occasion to start paying very close attention to what St. Anthony Messenger is publishing and judge them fairly based on what they produce.

Posted in Brick by Brick, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , ,
36 Comments

Another extravagant food entry

It’s time for some shots of really extravagant food!

Yesterday for lunch, I splurged on …

Another extravagant food entry

… and… wait for it …

Another extravagant food entry

I included the sprig of parsley to annoy the creepy people who think we should be rubbing gravel through our hair and drinking water from sidewalk puddles… which – come to think of it – would be hard to do this time of year.

The grilled cheese sando and tomato soup with crackers were very tasty, which was probably a bad thing.

And for today! 

I admit, this, like the sandwich above, was homemade… from actual leftover chicken bones and … meat!

I bought the little ravioli.  Was that wrong?

Another extravagant food entry

More evil parsley, I know.
 

Posted in Fr. Z's Kitchen, Lighter fare |
53 Comments

Opening of Holy Door in Santiago de Compostella

Opening of Holy Door in Santiago de CompostellaThere are some super cool photos of the opening of the Holy Door in the Spanish pilgrimage site Santiago de Compostella.  This is a Holy Year for St. James.   By sure to check them out on the site of the eye candy specialists, NLM.

Here are a couple.

Note the great Spanish birettas!

Opening of Holy Door in Santiago de Compostella

Opening of Holy Door in Santiago de Compostella

Opening of Holy Door in Santiago de Compostella

There is a possibility I will be chaplain to a pilgrimage to Spain for the Holy Year.  I must say the photos whet my appetite. The pilgrimage would involve the older form of Holy Mass and some walking (seashell, hat and staff optional), as is traditional in order to obtain the certificate. 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
30 Comments

The Feeder Feed

There was a lot of snow and a lot of cold and a lot of wind.The Feeder Feed

The birds are doing their best.

The Feeder Feed

Posted in The Feeder Feed |
13 Comments

Catholic League: Pres. Obama renominates anti-Catholic lawyer

The Catholic League has this to say about Pres. Obama’s renomination of an anti-Catholic lawyer who once compared pregnancy to slavery.

OBAMA RENOMINATES ANTI-CATHOLIC LAWYER

Catholic League president Bill Donohue calls attention to the decision of President Obama to renominate Dawn Johnsen to head the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel:

Most of the critics of Dawn Johnsen focus on her strong pro-abortion record. While that is disturbing, a pro-abortion president can be expected to staff his administration with such persons, and no one doubts President Obama’s position on this subject. But it is an entirely different matter when a president selects bigots to work for him.

Dawn Johnsen is not someone who simply takes issue with the Catholic Church’s pro-life position: she wants to punish the Church. In the late 1980s, she joined a cadre of anti-Catholics to strip the Catholic Church of its tax exempt status. The charge? The Church was guilty of violating IRS strictures because it took a strong pro-life position. The lawsuit failed.

The person who led this assault was Lawrence Lader, co-founder of NARAL with Dr. Bernard Nathanson. (Nathanson later dropped his pro-abortion position, became a strong pro-life advocate and converted to Catholicism.) At the time the two men founded NARAL, Lader, according to Nathanson, liked to refer to the Catholic Church as “our favorite whipping boy,” maintaining that his goal was to “bring the Catholic hierarchy out where we can fight them. That’s the real enemy.” (Italics in the original.) That was in the late 1960s. Twenty years later, Lader published a vicious book assailing the Catholic Church, and it was at this time that he launched his bid—assisted by Johnsen—to break the Church.

This is who Dawn Johnsen is. She is a person who is so fueled with hatred of the Catholic Church that she would like to destroy it. Having failed to secure her appointment last year, Obama has decided that he just can’t proceed without her. How telling.

Johnsen is not the first anti-Catholic chosen by Obama, but she is by far the most extreme and the most dangerous.

I remind you all to read THIS.

Posted in Emanations from Penumbras, The Last Acceptable Prejudice | Tagged
33 Comments

Brick by brick at the Mother Church

Brick by brick at the Mother ChurchThanks to John Sonnen of Orbis Catholicus I can dip into the bowl of liturgical eye candy with this image of the Prefect of the Congregation for Divine Worship in a Pontifical TLM at the main altar of St. John Lateran in Rome.

Brick by brick.

Brick by brick at the Mother Church

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
14 Comments