QUAERITUR: odd elevation style

From a reader:

My family attended a Novus Ordo Christmas Vigil Mass with a visiting priest. During the major elevation (This Is My Body), he elevated the host with one hand (his right) while the other held on to the altar. He did the same at the next elevation of the cup. I have never seen this done in the fifty years I’ve attended Catholic Masses (both old and new rite). The elevation has always been two hands, thumb and forefinger. Is this valid or licit, both or neither.

Maybe the priest has bursitis. The would have been improper for sure in the traditional form of Mass in the Roman Rite. Both hands are designated and for good reason: to steady the chalice. You also create a symmetry that way. I do not believe there is ant indication if both hands for the Novus Ordo. Thus, while what you saw is a departure from the Roman way, a rupture of continuity as it were, I don’t think it was illicit.

NOTA BENE: If I am not mistaken, and I am dredging my memory here, does the Novus Ordo GIRM instruct the priest at the offertory to raise the paten with the host and the chalice with the wine with water using both hands?   If that is the case, then it seems fitting that the elevation would similarly be with both hands.

I have seen older priests do this one-handed, btw, because they have shoulder troubles.

Don’t assume a strange motive.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
47 Comments

Card. Daly

Prayers are requested by some readers not only for the Church in Ireland, but especially right now for retired Cahal Card. Daly.

Ireland’s most senior Cardinal, Cahal Daly, has been taken Belfast City Hospital where he is said to be seriously ill. It is understood he being treated at the coronary care unit. Cardinal Daly, 92, became Archbishop of Armagh and Primate of All Ireland in 1990 and served in this role until his retirement in 1996. He was created Cardinal in 1991.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
2 Comments

Benedict XIV

After the time I spent in a course from the Congregation for Causes of Saints, my fingers – mainly from muscle memory I think – tend to type Benedict XIV instead of Benedict XVI.

Here is a wonderful painting of Papa Lambertini (+1758) by Pierre Hubert Subleyras at the Met.  It is a relatively new acquisition.

Benedict XIV was a fascinating guy and there are many amusing anecdotes about his ways and wit.

He was a brilliant canonist who gave us what is still pretty much still today the procedures followed for the causes of beatification, miracles, martyrdom, canonization, etc.

Benedict XIV

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
6 Comments

Where you are

Here is a small snapshot of the last few minutes of visitors to the blog.  The locations are in some cases estimations.

Rome, Lazio
Carnwath, South Lanarks…
Waterbury, Connecticut
Cheshire, Connecticut
Orlando, Florida
Nashville, Tennessee
Louisville, Kentucky
Chicago, Illinois
Greenville, North Carol…
Tucson, Arizona
Correggio, Emilia-Romagna
Madrid
Boone, North Carolina
Dublin
Pearl, Mississippi
SHREVEPORT, Louisiana
Manila
Buffalo Grove, Illinois
Farmington, Michigan
Bismarck, North Dakota
Norfolk, Virginia
California, Maryland
Saint Paul, Minnesota
Waterford, Michigan
Minneapolis, Minnesota
Markham, Ontario
San Diego, California
Sweden
New York
Keansburg, New Jersey
Houston, Texas
Pennsauken, New Jersey
Jersey City, New Jersey
Dartford, Kent
Stony Point, New York
Perryville, Missouri
Louisville, Kentucky
Forth, South Lanarkshire
Cranberry Twp, Pennsylv…
Saint Petersburg, Florida
Toronto, Ontario
Vienna, Wien
Dallas, Texas
Toronto, Ontario
Vienna, Wien
Dallas, Texas
Lans, Buenos Aires
Olathe, Kansas
Tyler, Texas
Peoria, Arizona
Cleveland, Ohio
Pineville, Louisiana
Columbus, Ohio
Madison, Wisconsin
Corbin, Kentucky
Indianapolis, Indiana
Toronto, Ontario
Simpsonville, South Car…
Breda, Noord-Brabant
Bradford, Ontario
Austin, Texas
Cincinnati, Ohio
Minneapolis, Minnesota
Victoria, British Colum…
Danbury, Connecticut
Bolton
Bergen, Hordaland
Marlborough, Massachuse…
Clinton Township, Michi…
Fort Myers, Florida
Itapema, Santa Catarina
Wake Forest, North Caro…
Boise, Idaho
Topeka, Kansas
Granby, Massachusetts
Kearny, New Jersey
Wilmington, North Carol…

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
23 Comments

Good news?

What’s going on?   Have any good news to share?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
30 Comments

Card. Etchegaray

We read on VIS from yesterday that Roger Card. Etchegaray, 87, underwent an operation for the broken femur (upper leg bone) he received as a Christmas gift from the wacko who pulled Pope Benedict down.

Please remember Card. Etchegaray in your prayers for a smooth recovery.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
9 Comments

A day in New York

A wonderful day in NYC.

It was warm and sunny.  Here is a nice view of my favorite tall building, the Chrysler Building, with its shining hubcaps.

A day in New York

After lunch we caught a train to Columbus Circle and then had a stroll in Central Park.

A day in New York

And then into the Metropolitan Museum of Art, for a few hours.

I hadn’t seen the Ancient Greek holdings for a while, so we spent some time in that collection.

Here is a fine Attic red-figure terracotta kylix from about 515-510 BC.  It is even signed and has the owner’s name incised into the bottom in Etruscan letters.

A day in New York

An illuminated MS with the 1st Psalm.

A day in New York

This is a Madonna and Child by Carlo Crivelli from 1480.

A day in New YorkA day in New York

“But Father! But Father!”, you might be saying.  “Why is there a cucumber hanging from the corner?  Isn’t that a little strange?”

Perpend.

Here is my take.

What is interesting here are the symbols that form a chiasmus or X in the composition, therefore a Cross.

At your 2 and your 7 are respectively symbols of Original Sin and Evil One, the apple and a nasty little fly.

The Christ Child doesn’t like the look of the fly at all.

A day in New York

The other symbols are at your 10 a cucumber or gourd and at your 5 a crack in the balustrade.  The lines of the chiasmus pass through the center where the Christ Child’s hands gently clutch a type of goldfinch.
A day in New York
The cuke, very much like the gourd, is associated with the story of Jonah and the whale and therefore the Resurrection.

The goldfinch is a little tougher, but I recall something about a legend that a goldfinch tried to help Christ on the road to Calvary by landing on His Head and pulling out one of the thorns.  The red feathers on the heads of some species of goldfinches suggest this.

I figured you might be missing shots of birds at my feeders.  Here are some substitutes.

The crack in the balustrade, because it is juxtaposed to the gourd, I am guessing is a reference to the cracking and splitting in the Holy of Holies.

So here we have a story of our redemption in the shape of a Cross in the composition.  And the Christ Child, recoiling from the nasty fly, symbol of corruption, finds comfort in the little goldfinch.

Okay.. this is why it takes me a long time to explore galleries.

My guy St. Augustine in a polychrome statue from 15th c. Burgundy

A day in New York

And we were at the lighting of the Christmas tree!

A day in New York

I have a video of the lights coming up on the tree, but it is too big to transfer at the moment.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , , , ,
12 Comments

Lunch under the bridge

I met two friends after Mass for lunch at Pershing Square under the bridge at Grand Central Terminal.

Best. Corned Beef Hash. Anywhere.

Lunch under the bridge

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
9 Comments

Other incidents concerning the Vatican and security

The intrepid Italian journalist Andrea Tornielli has an interesting piece today.  Here is my fast translation of a key bit:

A car driven by an unbalanced young man entered at high velocity into the Vatican bypassing both the check of the Swiss Guard and that of the Gendarmes, and almost hit a priest who was coming out of the ceremony for the 1st Vespers of Advent presided over by the Pope.  Moreover, some days later, a car of the Vatican Gendarmes with a Vatican City State license plate was struck by a few pistol shots while parked near a Rome restaurant on the via Aurelia Antica.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
20 Comments

Sunday in the Octave of Christmas – Holy Family

Sunday in the Octave of Christmas - Holy FamilyIn the Novus Ordo, today is the Feast of the Holy Family.  We are also observing Sunday in the Octave of Christmas.

A liturgical “octave” is an eight day period following and including the feast. In a way, the Church suspends time so that we can “rest” within the mystery we have celebrated while contemplating it from different angles.

Perhaps you have gone to a museum and seen a magnificent statue, such as Michelangelo’s David in Florence.

Glancing at it for a moment is not enough; you want to spend some time.

You look at it first from this direction, then another. You walk around it to see it from various points of view.

Considering our human weakness, a single day per year does not suffice to gather in the different dimensions of the mystery of a great feast.  An octave allows us to reflect on a feast in different ways.

For example, Pius Parsch, a prominent figure of the Liturgical Movement during the 20th c., wrote in The Church’s Year of Grace that the feasts of Sts. Stephen, John the Evangelist, and the Holy Innocents permit us to approach Christ, the new born King, first as martyrs, then as virgins, then as virgin-martyrs.

Theologically speaking, an octave anticipates the eternal bliss of heaven in which we will consider God in His glory.

Think of it this way. God created the world in six days and on the seventh, the Sabbath, He rested. This cycle of seven repeats itself while the world endures. The eighth day is therefore beyond the cycle of seven. It symbolizes an eternal state, the perfect unending Sabbath of heaven. As a Church, during the octave – perceived as a single continuous day – we imitate the hosts of heaven in their abiding contemplation.

Advent prepared us for the coming of the Lamb, both at Bethlehem and the end of time. Christmas too marks both comings. After Christmas we gather around the manger of Bethlehem and contemplate Jesus who is also the Lamb of the book of Revelation. We are like the Magi who adore Him, but we are also like the heavenly multitude of 144,000 who “follow the Lamb wherever he goes” (Rev 14:4). In both ways we remain in the Lord’s presence.

On 1 January we celebrate the Solemn feast of Mary, Mother of God (in the traditional Roman calendar the Feast of the Circumcision when Christ shed His Blood for us for the first time). Thus, at Christmas the wooden Crib already points to the wooden Cross, and beyond to the goal of heaven made possible now for the children of a common Father. Mary stood at the foot of both.

Consequently, we honor Mary with great solemnity in the Christmas octave. By her participation in the salvific shedding of her Son’s Blood Mary gives us an important example of sacrificial love.

God Incarnate chose to begin manifesting this sacrificial love, which reached its culmination on the Cross, in the family home.

Together with Mary and His earthly father Joseph, Christ began to reveal something of the unity of love within the most perfect of communions, the Holy Trinity.

It is fitting to celebrate the Holy Family within the Octave of Christmas when we contemplate the coming of the Lord in imitation of that final, perfect communion with God to be enjoyed only by the blessed in heaven.

The family is a paradigm of all other human relationships. The Holy Family teaches us, who are still in this world but moving inexorably toward our judgment and final goal, how to live – together – in this present state of “already, but not yet”.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
5 Comments