Who’s the important one?

Many prelates from around the world would stay at my residence in Rome when they would come for business with the Roman curia.  As a result, at mealtimes you would find yourself eating with Bp. X or Archbp. Y or Card. Z from here there and everywhere.  At a certain point you start to take a little less notice of these fellows as they would come and go.

In one case, I recall for several days being on pretty much the same schedule as a visiting priest from Argentina.  He was a very pleasant fellow, whose Italian wasn’t perfect, but it wasn’t bad.  He was clearly very smart and had a serene and affable way about him, though he wasn’t loquacious.  We chatted for some days and enjoyed company at meals.  Normally, I would just stick to small talk with visitors, and let them guide how far they wanted to talk about their business.

Then one day as I was leaving the palazzo, he was getting out of a car and coming in, wearing under a greca the house cassock, fascia, and zucchetto of a Cardinal of Holy Roman Church. 

It turns out that it was Jorge Card. Bergoglio I had been lunching with.

Since he had impressed me simply as a person, I started paying more attention to him and what he had done.  I asked around and learned a little about this S. American prelate.

When the Holy Father John Paul II died, I was pretty convinced that Card. Bergoglio was papabile, and didn’t rule out that he had the potential of being elected.  His draw back for that prospect was more than likely his membership in the Society of Jesus.  Card. Bergoglio is a Jesuit, and there has never been a Jesuit Pope.

The gentlemanly Sandro Magister has a post on Card. Bergoglio, and I recommend it.

Effectively, Card. Bergoglio thinks that baptism should be given more freely even to the children of those who are not practicing their faith.  Some time ago, Pope Benedict also said something along these lines, explaining that when he was younger, he had a more restrictive view.  The Church in S. America is facing a horrible challenge from secularism and relativism on the one hand, fundamentalist sects on the other.

Here is a big chunk of the article, though I recommend that you read the whole thing:

Who's the important one?[…]

In some parts of Europe, baptizing a child has already become the exception, requiring an unconventional decision. But now, the number of unbaptized infants, children, young people, adults is also rising in Argentina.

This decline in the practice of baptism is the result of a weakening of family ties and a withdrawal from the Church. Some of the clergy have drawn this conclusion: where they see the signs of faith being extinguished, they maintain that it is right to decline to administer the sacraments.

But in Argentina today, the Church authorities are moving in the opposite direction.

Already in 2002, the archdiocese of Buenos Aires and the diocese in the surrounding area had published an instruction urgently recommending the baptism of both children and adults, and explaining how to overcome resistance to the celebration of the rite.

But now the bishops of the area have returned to the task with a booklet entitled "El bautismo en clave misionera," which reproduces the 2002 instruction and supplements it with other guidelines for parish pastors.

So beginning this year, the most conscientious pastors are regularly holding "baptism days," on which they administer the sacrament to children and adults in situations of poverty or with broken families, who have been helped to overcome their own uncertainties and those of the people around them.

Cardinal Bergoglio has explained the meaning of all this in an interview with the international magazine "30 Days":

"The child has no responsibility for the condition of his parents’ marriage. The baptism of children can, on the contrary, become a new beginning for the parents. A while ago, I baptized the seven children of one woman, a poor widow who works as a maid and had her children by two different men. I met her on the feast of Saint Cajetan. She said to me, ‘Father, I am in mortal sin, I have seven children and have never had them baptized, I don’t have the money for the godparents and for the party… I saw her again and after a little catechesis I baptized them in the chapel of the archepiscopal residence. The woman said to me, ‘Father, I can’t believe it, you make me feel important’. I said to her, ‘But madam, what do I have to do with it? It’s Jesus who makes you important."  [Do I hear a big "Amen!"?]

Bergoglio is anxious not to extinguish a tradition typical of the most remote areas of Argentina, in those towns and villages where the priest comes only a few times a year:

"There, popular piety feels that children must be baptized as soon as possible, so there are men or women known by all as ‘bautizadores’ who baptize the children when they are born, in anticipation of the arrival of the priest. And when he arrives, they bring the children to him so that he can anoint them with holy oil, completing the rite. When I think about it, I am reminded of the story of those Christian communities in Japan that were without priests for more than two hundred years. When the missionaries returned, they found all of them baptized and all of them sacramentally married."

The cardinal continues:

"The conference in Aparecida urged us to proclaim the Gospel by going to meet the people, not by waiting for the people to come to us. Missionary fervor does not require extraordinary events. It is in ordinary life that mission work is done. And baptism, in this, is paradigmatic. The sacraments are for the life of men and women as they are. They may not make big speeches, but their ‘sensus fidei’ grasps the reality of the sacraments with more clarity than many specialists do."

What reemerges here is the ancient and still unresolved dispute between a Church of the elite, a pure, minority Church, and a Church of the masses, populated also by that immense sea of humanity for whom Christianity is made up of a few simple things.

In Italy, for example, the dispute came up again during the last major national conference of the Church, held in Verona in October of 2006. On that occasion, one position held by the "rigorists" was precisely that of withholding baptism and the other sacraments from those believed to be unfit because they are not practicing.  [A position which can be argued and defended.]

It is a dilemma that Joseph Ratzinger himself experienced personally as a young man, and finally resolved in the same direction indicated by Cardinal Bergoglio. This is what, as pope, Ratzinger himself said in replying to the question from a priest of Bressanone, in a public question-and-answer session with the clergy of the diocese on August 6, 2008.

The priest, named Paolo Rizzi, a pastor and professor of theology, asked Benedict XVI a question about baptism, confirmation, and first communion:

"Holy Father, 35 years ago I thought that we were beginning to be a little flock, a minority community, more or less everywhere in Europe; that we should therefore administer the sacraments only to those who are truly committed to Christian life. Then, partly because of the style of John Paul II’s Pontificate, I thought things through again. If it is possible to make predictions for the future, what do you think? What pastoral approaches can you suggest to us?".  [What an excellent question to put to Peter.]

Pope Ratzinger responded:

"I must say that I took a similar route to yours. When I was younger I was rather severe. I said: the sacraments are sacraments of faith, and where faith does not exist, where the practice of faith does not exist, the Sacrament cannot be conferred either. And then I always used to talk to my parish priest when I was Archbishop of Munich: here too there were two factions, one severe and one broad-minded. Then [wait for it….] I too, with time, came to realize that we must follow, rather, the example of the Lord, who was very open even with people on the margins of Israel of that time. He was a Lord of mercy, too open – according to many official authorities – with sinners, welcoming them or letting them invite him to their dinners, drawing them to him in his communion.

"Therefore I would say substantially that the sacraments are naturally sacraments of faith: when there is no element of faith, when First Communion is no more than a great lunch with beautiful clothes and beautiful gifts, it can no longer be a sacrament of faith. [So, he is not saying we should apply no criteria.] Yet, on the other hand, if we can still see a little flame of desire for communion in the faith, a desire even in these children who want to enter into communion with Jesus, it seems to me that it is right to be rather broad-minded.

"Naturally, of course, one purpose of our catechesis must be to make children understand that Communion, First Communion is not a ‘fixed’ event, but requires a continuity of friendship with Jesus, a journey with Jesus. I know that children often have the intention and desire to go to Sunday Mass but their parents do not make this desire possible. If we see that children want it, that they have the desire to go, this seems to me almost a sacrament of desire, the ‘will’ to participate in Sunday Mass. In this sense, we naturally must do our best in the context of preparation for the sacraments to reach the parents as well, and thus to – let us say – awaken in them too a sensitivity to the process in which their child is involved. They should help their children to follow their own desire to enter into friendship with Jesus, which is a form of life, of the future. If parents want their children to be able to make their First Communion, this somewhat social desire must be extended into a religious one, to make a journey with Jesus possible.

"I would say, therefore, that in the context of the catechesis of children, that work with parents is very important. And this is precisely one of the opportunities to meet with parents, making the life of faith also present to the adults, because, it seems to me, they themselves can relearn the faith from the children and understand that this great solemnity is only meaningful, true and authentic if it is celebrated in the context of a journey with Jesus, in the context of a life of faith. Thus, one should endeavour to convince parents, through their children, of the need for a preparatory journey that is expressed in participation in the mysteries and that begins to make these mysteries loved.

"I would say that this is definitely an inadequate answer, [Gosh… see how harsh and rigorous Pope Benedict is?  The former "enforcer" of doctrine?] but the pedagogy of faith is always a journey and we must accept today’s situations. Yet, we must also open them more to each person, so that the result is not only an external memory of things that endures but that their hearts that have truly been touched. The moment when we are convinced the heart is touched – it has felt a little of Jesus’ love, it has felt a little the desire to move along these lines and in this direction, that is the moment when, it seems to me, we can say that we have made a true catechesis. The proper meaning of catechesis, in fact, must be this: to bring the flame of Jesus’ love, even if it is a small one, to the hearts of children, and through the children to their parents, thus reopening the places of faith of our time."

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, Our Catholic Identity, SESSIUNCULA, The Drill | Tagged , , ,
37 Comments

Damian Thompson’s obervance of the 40th anniversary of the Novus Ordo

I see that Damian Thompson has his blade sharpened:

My emphases and comments:

November 30th, 2009

Happy 40th birthday, Novus Ordo!

It is 40 years ago today since the New Mass of Paul VI was introduced into our parishes, writes Margery Popinstar, editor of The Capsule. [Blue or Red, I wonder.]  We knew at the time that this liturgy was as close to perfection as humanly possible, but little did we guess what an efflorescence of art, architecture, music and worship lay ahead!  [That’s a good way to put it.]

There were fears at first that the vernacular service would damage the solemnity of the Mass. How silly! Far from leading to liturgical abuses, the New Mass nurtured a koinonia that revived Catholic culture and packed our reordered churches to the rafters.

So dramatic was the growth in family Mass observance, indeed, that a new school of Catholic architecture arose to provide places of worship for these new congregations. Throughout the Western world, churches sprang up that combined Christian heritage with the thrilling simplicity of the modern school, creating a sense of the numinous that has proved as irresistible to secular visitors as to the faithful.

For some worshippers, it is the sheer visual beauty of the New Mass that captures the heart, with its simple yet scrupulously observed rubrics – to say nothing of the elegance of the priest’s vestments, which (though commendably less fussy than pre-conciliar outfits) exhibit a standard of meticulous craftsmanship which truly gives glory to God!

The same refreshing of tradition infuses the wonderful – and toe-tapping! – modern Mass settings and hymns produced for the revised liturgy. This music, written by the most gifted composers of our era, has won over congregations so totally that it is now rare to encounter a parish where everyone is not singing their heads off! Even the secular “hit parade” has borrowed from Catholic worship songs, so deliciously memorable – yet reverent! – is the effect they create. No wonder it is standing room only at most Masses!

Did Archbishop Annibale Bugnini, who birthed this kairos, have any idea just how radically his innovations would transform the Church? We must, of course, all rejoice in his imminent beatification – but, in the meantime, I am tempted to borrow a phrase from a forgotten language that – can you believe it? – was used by the Church for services before 1969: Si monumentum requiris, circumspice.

 

 

 

Posted in The Drill | Tagged
93 Comments

Off to Cape Canaveral!

Today is my day trip to Cape Canaveral and the Kennedy Space Center!

Off to Cape Canaveral!

I had been here many years ago. how things have changed! I did enjoy the Rocket Park.

Off to Cape Canaveral!

I thought the Soviet era Soyuz was pretty interesting.

And I thought the American astronauts were brave.

I bet the first cosmonauts who looked at this stuff on the outside just shrugged as thought….

Off to Cape Canaveral!

… "Hey… what could go wrong?"

Off to Cape Canaveral!

 

Imagine jamming yourself into a VW Beatle, sitting it on top of a stick of dynamite 36 stories tall, and telling them to light the fuse.

Off to Cape Canaveral!

And once you were up there, staying up there in the VW fully dressed in all sorts of stuff for days.

Off to Cape Canaveral!

With less computing power than my mobile phone.

Mission control has less computing power than my mobile phone.

Off to Cape Canaveral!

Off to Cape Canaveral!

Off to Cape Canaveral!

Amazing.

Off to Cape Canaveral!

Off to Cape Canaveral!

Posted in My View |
17 Comments

iBreviary – the iPhone app

Do any of you have an iPhone and have iBreviary installed?

I do. 

I don’t know if any of you have the same experience, but I don’t think it is being updated.

More often than not, I refresh and there are no texts available.

Is this just me?

Do we need to warn people off this app?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
30 Comments

Some recent posts

Some recent posts:Some recent posts

 
 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Some recent posts

Your good news

As you start your new work week, tell us all some of your good news.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
37 Comments

Fr. Rawley Myers, RIP

I understand that Fr. Rawley Myers has died.

Requiescat in pace.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

Fr. Robert Fox – RIP

I understand that Fr. Robert Fox has passed away on (U.S.) Thanksgiving Day.

May he rest in peace.

Fr. Fox was a great apostle of Our Lady of Fatima and her message.

Fr. Robert Fox - RIP

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
8 Comments

“Bishooooops, don’t let your chapels grow up to be discooooos….”

Every once in a while, walking about in Rome you come across a forlorn little ex-church or chapel, now serving as a nightclub or art gallery or worse.   It’s like something out of a cartoon.

I know of a once beautiful minor seminary bought by a fundamentalist bible school.  They use the old chapel as a cafeteria.

This comes from AFP:

Don’t turn our churches into nightclubs, urges Vatican

(AFP) – 3 days ago

VATICAN CITY — The Vatican on Thursday warned Italy’s bishops against letting deserted churches be transformed into nightclubs if the decision was taken to sell the places of worship.

Archbishop Gianfranco Ravasi, the Vatican’s new culture commissar, urged "the greatest caution" after announcing that Roman Catholic churches with few worshippers could be sold off.

He gave the example of a church in Hungary which was "transformed into a nightclub and where striptease took place on the altar."

The archbishop, who is president of the Pontifical Council for Culture, said dwindling numbers of worshippers at some churches meant it now made sense to sell, or even destroy, the buildings.

"Faced with falling number of worshippers, a phenomenon which we are also unfortunately witnessing in the centre of Rome, churches without any artistic value and which need significant work can be sold or destroyed," he told reporters.

Italian bishops’ groups would be responsible for deciding whether the sites should be sold, said Ravasi, adding each case would be separately assessed.

What ever happened to the old cathedral of Los Angeles, St. Vibiana?

BTW… if you go to that AFP article, and you don’t really have to, they have a picture of the wrong bishop and identify him as Ravasi.  The bishop in the photo is actually Most. Rev. Sergio Pagano, BB.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged ,
24 Comments

Australia: Holy See tells Catholic diocese not to host Anglican ordination of women

Yes, you read that correctly.

I picked up this story from an Australian source theage.com.au.

I get the sense that, in the past, the local Catholic diocese in Victoria had allowed Anglicans to have ordinations in a

My emphases and comments.

Vatican ban on offer to Anglicans
BARNEY ZWARTZ
November 28, 2009

THE Vatican has ordered a Victorian bishop to withdraw an offer to let Anglicans ordain deacons in a Catholic church tomorrow because four of the seven are women.

Bendigo Catholics and Anglicans have both expressed sadness [Why am I not surprised?] at the decision, which comes a month after Pope Benedict XVI told Anglicans they were welcome to become Catholics and keep their Anglican identity.  [Ummm…. yah.   But, that identity doesn’t include things against the Christian faith, right?]

Sandhurst Bishop Joe Grech offered Bendigo Anglican Bishop Andrew Curnow use of the city’s oldest Catholic church for the celebratory service because the Anglican cathedral is closed for repairs.

Bishop Grech said yesterday that he had checked widely before offering St Kilian’s, and had the approval of the Papal Nuncio (ambassador), Archbishop Giuseppe Lazzarotto.  [Did any of them check ahead of time who… or what… was scheduled to be ordained?]

But he was ordered to withdraw the offer by a Vatican department – he did not want to say which – after a Catholic complained to Rome about the planned service. 

”It had wider ramifications, and the conclusion was it was better not to have it,” Bishop Grech said.

”I was saddened, obviously. I was disappointed I couldn’t help more, but there is tremendous rapport between us and the Anglicans. They know it’s not a snub, it’s the doctrine of the church.”

Sandhurst Vicar-General John White also said he was disappointed. ”We believe we have a very good working relationship with the Anglicans, and there was no way we were endorsing their theological stance for the ordination of women – it was a generous offer to help when they could not use their own facility.”  [Really?  So, if someone, for example, opens up his home to a guy who, for example, want to have a political campaign and helps raise money and so forth, neither of them are endorsing each other’s positions?  Would they allow, for example, worshipers of Moloch to have one of their services in the church?  Extreme examples, I know.  But somewhere along the line the question has to be asked: Is this right?]

Anglican theologian Charles Sherlock – a member of the Anglican Roman Catholic International Commission, which is discussing theological rapprochement between the churches – said it was particularly disappointing because Bishop Grech had been so generous.

‘‘It is disappointing that he is not allowed to act as he thinks best for the people of God in Bendigo,” Dr Sherlock said.  [But is it not important that your counterparts in ecumenical dialogue are also true to their identity?]

Anglican Dean Peta Sherlock (Dr Sherlock’s wife) said the Anglicans would hold tomorrow’s ordination at St Andrew’s Uniting Church instead, and were grateful for the hospitality.

”I think it’s indeed sad. Catholics in Bendigo are shocked by it. They say ‘it’s not us’, and we say ‘we know’. It was a fantastic good news story, and now it’s gone.”  [And it is still a fantastic news story, because that ordination is not happening in a catholic church.]

Dean Sherlock said the Anglican cathedral closed in January. ”There’s bits falling off. Anything cement or mortar has perished.”  [There is a metaphor here somewhere.   …. Nope.. it’s gone.  I hope they can fix their building!]

She said restoring the cathedral would cost $5 million. An appeal had been launched, which so far had raised $20,000.

”We are worshipping in the hall next door and having fantastic fun. We sit closer together, talk to each other and sing much better. [Well… that’s what is all about, after all.] But it’s the big stuff we can’t do: weddings, funerals, ordinations.”

Local Catholics criticised the decision and apologised to Anglicans in letters to the Bendigo Advertiser. Beryl Rokesky wrote: ”I was ashamed to call myself a Catholic … Contrary to what we were taught in Catholic schools, Catholics aren’t the only ones who will end up in heaven.”  [Have you seen the reporter – to this point – quote someone who was happy about the decision?  No?]

Peter Bugden wrote that the decision was evidence that the Roman Curia was concerned with power and control, and that Christianity had been usurped by Churchianity.  [Wow.  That’s clever.]

Bishop Curnow is on retreat with the seven ordinands and could not be contacted.

 

I suspect some people in Bendigo, in the diocese of Sandhurst, might be pleased that a simulation of a sacrament won’t be taking place in their church.

Too bad the reporter didn’t have the integrity to do some… what’s the word…. you know… reporting?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , , , ,
18 Comments