Brick by brick in St. Louis

Pope Benedict’s vision, his "Marshall Plan", will not be implemented in a day or a year or even a few years. 

But it is happening.

This "Marshall Plan" revolves around a revitalization of Holy Church’s worship. 

To this end, Pope Benedict gave us Summorum Pontificum and other tools and gifts, such as his own example.

I am pleased that more and more people have the opportunity to participate at Masses celebrated with the older, traditional Missale Romanum.  These experiences will help also to correct the way the newer form of Mass is celebrated.

There are some institutes and fraternities of priests dedicated to this cause.

But what I think is really needed in dioceses, first and foremost, is not so much some specialized group to come in and do what other can’t do.  What is truly necessary is that diocesan priests and seminarians take charge of this vision.  Diocesan priests and seminarians, ideally with the full support of the local bishop, must make this project their own.  All these other groups play their good and necessary role, but when the diocesan clergy take up this challenge – and it will happen, folks – this "Marshall Plan" will really pick up speed. 

With that preamble, I share this from a reader in St. Louis:

As someone who enjoys your blog very much, I wanted to share with you some pictures of a Solemn Pontifical High Mass that took place in St. Louis, Missouri on Saturday, Sept. 19. It was celebrated by Archbishop Raymond Burke, Prefect of the Apostolic Signatura, on the occasion of the 90th anniversary of the Carmelites of the Divine Heart of Jesus.

What I think was most remarkable about this seven-month project was that it was completely organized and executed from scratch by diocesan priests and seminarians, in an oratory that was not designed for this sort of big liturgy. It was a wonderful experience to see how beautiful and prayerful a Liturgy a relatively small group enthusiastic and dedicated diocesan men can organize.

I think all of us that took part in the Mass were left with great hope for the future. I hope that, at the least, this Mass can serve to inspire others to save the liturgy. The resources are out there, it just takes zeal and love of the Church.

A couple photos:

Brick by brick in St. Louis

Brick by brick in St. Louis

Posted in Caption Call, Emanations from Penumbras, Mail from priests, WDTPRS |
5 Comments

Someone… please calm McBrien down before he hurts himself?

From his platform in Dissenters Weekly (aka NCR), Notre Dame’s Richard McBrien, professor of theology, attacks Pope Benedict’s liturgical vision. 

My emphases and comments.

Reversing the liturgical field
by Richard McBrien on Sep. 21, 2009

Judging from the comments, some readers thought last week’s column on the "Year for Priests" unduly pessimistic about the present state of the Catholic Church. To the contrary, one of latest developments inside the Vatican only underscores the point of that column.

According to a report late last month by Andrea Tornielli in the Italian daily Il Giornale, the prefect of the Vatican’s Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments, Cardinal Antonio Cañizares Llovera, met with Pope Benedict XVI on April 4 (the fact that we have a precise date is significant) to present a list of proposed changes to the liturgical norms for the celebration of the Eucharist.

The proposals were said to have been formally approved at a meeting of the congregation in March, and were designed to "restore a greater sense of the sacred" to the celebration of Mass. [Which is precisely what McBrien objects to.  He would probably have Mass reduced to a horizontal and merely human experience.]

Among the proposals that had been approved by the congregation in March and presented to the pope early the next month were calls to end the practices of receiving Communion in the hand and having the priest celebrate Mass facing the congregation.

Once the story was leaked to the press, however, there were denials (of sorts) from the Vatican. Undoubtedly, Vatican officials were miffed by the leak and a statement was issued by the deputy director of the Vatican Press Office, Passionist Fr. Ciro Benedettini, that said only that "for the time being there are no institutional proposals for a modification of the liturgical books used at present."

Some Vatican observers predict that the delay may last as much as a year, or until the matter quiets down. [It would take that long anyway, since it is the practice of the Congregation to study and consult.]

But what is clear is that something is in the works and it is entirely consistent with what Roman sources have been hearing for some time about the pope’s desire to return gradually to Communion on the tongue as the normative practice. [Hang on…  Communion on the tongue IS the normative practice.  Communion in the hand is an aberration which is permitted according to decisions of conferences, of diocesan bishops and, in the case of risk of profanation, parish priests.]  At the same time, the Pope knows full well that such a highly controversial reversal of current practice could never be accomplished in an instant. [And the Pope has already written about patience in liturgical reform.]

The practice of Communion in the hand was originally granted by the Vatican’s Congregation for Divine Worship on May 29, 1969 (before it was combined with the Congregation for the Discipline of the Sacraments by Pope Paul VI in 1975), in response to requests from various episcopal conferences, including that of the United States, and with the explicit approval of Paul VI.  [But this is not the whole story.  What McBrien is ignoring here is that the practice began and continued for years contra legem, against the Church’s law.  But this would his his preferred way of making changes to his liking, no?  Forget about the church’s law.  Do whatever you find self-actualizing in this moment.]

Lest anyone question Benedict’s personal preference in this matter, it should be pointed out that, beginning on the feast of Corpus Christi last year, those receiving Communion from the pope must do so only on the tongue. He has also expressed support for restoring the practice of the priest’s celebrating Mass "facing the East," which means in plain English with his back to the people.  [Only if by "plain language" you mean "inaccurate clichés".]

Given the possibility that such reversals (sometimes referred to as a "reform of the reform") [He would think of this as a reversal. But when something has gone wrong – and so much has gone wrong – your choices are either the ignore the problem and blunder along or retrace your steps and fix the problem.] will eventually be mandated, one can only imagine the confusion, frustration and anger that many priests and laypeople will experience.  [What is the assumption here?  McBrien’s assumption is that this would be imposed suddenly, without explanations or catechesis.   Of course this is nothing but fear mongering, which is the perennial tool of those who themselves are fearful.]

Today, if individual Catholics choose to receive the sacrament on the tongue, they are free to do so. Eucharistic ministers — priests and laypeople alike [Correction: lay people are not "Eucharistic ministers".  They can be "Ministers of Holy Communion".] — respect their wishes. The great majority, however, prefer to receive Communion in the hand and continue to do so.

But this proposal, if enacted, would actually prevent Catholics from making that choice for themselves. They would be denied the option, approved by Paul, that has been available to them for the past 40 years, namely, to receive Communion in the hand or on the tongue. [Yes, indeed.  You would think that someone who has tried to write about Church history would understand that part of a reform means saying "no" to something that has been going on for a while.  And didn’t Paul VI also issue Humanae vitae?  What about that?  We should adhere to what Paul VI issued, right?]

The so-called "John Paul II priests" [NCR’s nightmare..] would very likely be happy with such a reversal of practice and would ostentatiously deny giving Communion to those with outstretched hands. [Why "ostentatiously" here?  Why the slur?  Why not talk about some people who go to a TLM and "ostentatiously" refuse to receive on the tongue?]  However, many other priests, whether old enough to have been shaped by Vatican II or not, would ignore the mandate and continue to distribute Communion in the hand to those who requested it. [And that is McBrien’s ignoble wish.]

[Now we see McBrien in the role of drama queen…] What would happen as a result of this tug of war at Communion time? Would some bishops threaten priests with suspension? If so, how many priests would expose themselves to such a penalty? If the numbers were large, how would the church be able to compensate for the additional decline in the number of available priests?  [The fact is that younger priests will implement the law they are given to implement. The older priests will just retire or die.]

[CLICHE ALERT!] Mandating the celebration of Mass with the priest’s back to the congregation [I wonder if he know how foolish this sounds to people who know anything about this issue?] might pose an even greater problem, except in churches built before the Second Vatican Council and still with main altars facing the rear wall. But such churches are probably in the minority today. The architectural problems would be exceeded only by the pastoral dislocations.

May none of this come to pass.

Year by year these priests of discontinuity and rupture are retiring or dying.  The biological solution is quickly taking care of them. 

He can see in his mind’s eye that faithful "John Paul II priest" standing by, ready to open the door for him to make room for the walker.  Another is holding McBrien’s hat with a smile.  Yet another is telling the visiting nurse not to forget to get more Depends.  Perhaps they are taking the old guy down to the park or out for a ride.

These young priests will in charity come to visit McBrien and sit with him and listen to his stories about the halcyon days of the "spirit of Vatican II" and listen to him rail about how his life’s work came to nothing.

And when this old dissenter comes to his final breaths, a "John Paul II priest" will come in his cassock, surplice and stole to give him last rites in Latin using the pre-Conciliar Rituale Romanum.

The clock is ticking for McBrien and his crowd.  

tick…

tick…

tick…

tick…

tick….

Someone... please calm McBrien down before he hurts himself? 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
54 Comments

Late summer evening

I don’t think there will be many more evenings like this.

Late summer evening

The three bonsai trees.

Late summer evening

Can you believe this is the same Japanese maple as a few weeks back?

Late summer evening

Quite a contrast to what I was dealing with last week.

Late summer evening

That was not the first time that screen appeared.

I don’t know who this fuzzy critter is.

Late summer evening

The Chinese elm.

Late summer evening

PENJING REPORT

Penjing has been thriving on the deck, day in and day out.

Still nothing to say.

Penjing is blooming.

Late summer evening

Late summer evening

Posted in My View, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
20 Comments

webcam problem

I have noticed that, for quite a while, I haven’t been able to get rid of the bluish tinge on my webcam feeds.

I have been looking around for solutions and have not found anything especially helpful.

Ideas?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
9 Comments

The Feeder Feed

There are zillions of Goldfinches around right now.  Their young are all squeaking for attention like diminutive squeeze toys.  In the meantime, TEAM GOLDFINCH is hard at the seed sock.

The Feeder FeedThe Feeder Feed

I have some House Finches yet.

The Feeder Feed

I have also noticed a sharp uptick in the number of Nuthatches.  They are starting to band together with the fearless Chickadee.

Posted in The Feeder Feed |
Comments Off on The Feeder Feed

Destin, FL: dog at Mass

I was alerted by several people to the following.

In Destin, FL, the parish priest involved his dog in the Mass.  Well.. here is the e-mail.

"The video [shows] one of many liturgical abuses during Sunday Mass, which also included a plug before Mass for Father’s favorite dog shampoo (As he set the bottle of shampoo on the altar while continuing to talk about it and then made some in the congregation smell it)."

You decide.

Liturgical abuse?

I guess I could understand that perhaps the priest’s dog could find its untrammeled way into church.  He might want to go check out his master regardless of what he was up to. 

That could be more amusing than sacrilegious.  Right?  I mean, we are reasonable about odd things that happen through no one’s fault.

This seems to be a bit more than that.

Here is the video.  It does not include anything about the dog shampoo.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
65 Comments

Pope Benedict to new bishops: Care for priests!

From CNA:

Bishops receive advice from Pope on caring for priests

Castel Gandolfo, Italy, Sep 21, 2009 / 10:43 am (CNA).- As he does every year, the Holy Father hosted a congress for all the bishops who were consecrated this past year. Noting that helping priests is an essential task for a bishop, Pope Benedict reminded the prelates to urge priests to seek "intimate and personal union with Christ."

Addressing the recently-consecrated bishops at Castel Gandolfo today, the Holy Father recalled the importance of "not forgetting that one of a bishop’s essential tasks is that of helping priests – by example and fraternal support – to follow their vocation faithfully and to work enthusiastically and lovingly in the Lord’s vineyard."

Priests, said the Pope, must "remain united to the Lord; this is the secret of the fruitfulness of their ministry." Increased workload, difficulties, and the new requirements of pastoral care "must never distract us from intimate and personal union with Christ. Our readiness and openness to people must never diminish or overshadow our readiness and openness towards the Lord."

"The time that priests and bishops consecrate to God in prayer is always time well spent," he emphasized. "This is because prayer is at the heart of pastoral work, it is the ‘lymph’ which gives it strength, it is a support in moments of uncertainty and discouragement, and an endless source of missionary fervor and of fraternal love towards everyone."

Focusing more closely on priestly life, Pope Benedict stated that, "At the heart of priestly life is the Eucharist." The Pontiff also pointed to a devout recitation of the Liturgy of the Hours as "one special way to prolong the mysterious sanctifying action of the Eucharist throughout the day." In addition, priests can participate in Eucharistic adoration, ‘lectio divina’ and the contemplative prayer of the Rosary, he said.

With the Church celebrating the Year for Priests, the Pope turned to its patron, St. Jean Vianney, who "showed us the importance of priests’ immersing themselves in the Eucharist and of educating the faithful in the Eucharistic presence and in communion." 

As I read this, I had the sense that something was missing. 

This CNA article seems to focus on bishops telling priests what they ought to be. 

That just doesn’t ring right with what I know about Pope Benedict and what he has written about priesthood in the past.  It seemed to me, as I read this CNA article, that the other half was missing.  Yes, bishops should urge priests to be good priests, but the bishops themselves are personally responsible to see to their care.

So, I turned to the Italian text, here.

"The imitation of Jesus the Good Shepherd is, for every priest, the obligatory path of his own sanctification and the essential condition for exercising pastoral ministry responsibly.  If this pertains to priests, it pertains that much more to us, dear brother bishops.  And it is important not to forget that one of the essential duties of the bishop is precisely to help priests, by example and with fraternal support, to follow their vocation faithfully and with work with enthusiasm and love in the Lord’s vineyard.

On this point, in his Post-synodal Exhortation Pastores gregis, my venerated predecessor John Paul II observed that the gesture of the priest, when he puts he own hand in the hands of the bishop on the day of his priestly ordination, binds them both: the priest and the bishop.  The new priest chooses to entrust himself to the bishop and, for his part, the bishop commits himself to take care of those hands."

There is more of note, but that bit struck me as being essential to the report on the event.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
5 Comments

Card. Cipriani again! Communion on the tongue, kneeling. “Our souls are at stake.”

Remember the story from 23 August about Cardinal Cipriani in Lima, Peru?

Cardinal Cipriani wants

  • a communion plate or paten to be used
  • reception on the tongue
  • kneeling

Now comes this 30 September from a reader in Peru:
Card. Cipriani again! Communion on the tongue, kneeling. "Our souls are at stake."

Dear Father Z,
 
This is wonderful news, and yet it is a logical consequence: Holy Communion at the Cathedral of Lima, Perú, now is distributed only to the faithful kneeling.

For that purpose, two kneelers were put before the steps of the high altar at the moment of Communion, just like the Pope does at his Masses. This can be seen in the attached picture.
 
Here is the link.
 
And here is my translation of some important remarks the Cardinal made during his homily precisely about this:
 
"The most respectful way of receiving the Eucharist is kneeling and on the tongue. We must recover a sense of respect and reverence due to the Eucharist, because the love to Jesus is the center of our christian lives. Our souls are at stake."

The whole piece from the Archdiocese of Lima:

At Sunday Mass on September 20, at the Cathedral Basilica of Lima, Cardinal Juan Luis Cipriani exhorted the faithful to adore Holy Eucharist at the more than 70 adoration chapels that were build throughout the Archdiocese of Lima on occasion of the Year of the Eucharist and the Continental Mission, thus making Perú’s capital city a "Eucharistic city".
 
‘Lima is a Eucharistic city with more than 70 adoration chapels, where the Lord is exposed, where you can visit Him, because He hears you and helps you. We must adore Him and let your heart be filled with joy and the beauty of his wisdom’ the Cardinal mentioned during his homily.
 
The Archbishop explained that the most solemn and recommended way of receiving Communion is kneeling and on the tongue. In this sense, the faithful who participated at Mass at the Cathedral received Communion under these indications.
 
‘The most respectful way of receiving the Eucharist is kneeling and on the tongue. We must recover a sense of respect and reverence due to the Eucharist, because the love to Jesus is the center of our christian lives. Our souls are at stake.’ he mentioned.

Posted in Fr. Z KUDOS, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged , , , ,
32 Comments

Petition to Notre Dame Pres. Fr. Jenkins: Please drop the charges again pro-lifers

From TFP Student Action:

Petition to Notre Dame Pres. Fr. Jenkins: Please drop the charges again pro-lifersURGENT petition to Notre Dame: Please drop the charges
By TFP Student Action  
September 10, 2009

The 88 outspoken pro-lifers peacefully walked onto Notre Dame’s campus in May to be the voice of the unborn – when pro-abortion president Obama was honored there – and were arrested for trespassing.  Among those arrested were Fr. Norman Weslin, several Catholic nuns, Norma McCorvey, the “Jane Roe” of Roe v. Wade, and Ambassador Alan Keyes.

Sign the “Drop the Charges” petition

Lifesitenews.com reports:

    “While witnesses say pro-Obama protesters were allowed to roam free, the arrested individuals were singled out for displaying any pro-life message — including slogans on the sanctity of life, photographs of aborted children, a large wooden cross, and images of Mary.”

The double standard is rather shocking, isn’t it?

The University of Notre Dame, as the original complainant, has the choice to drop the charges pending against the 88 pro-lifers.

Therefore, your signature is very important right now because, according to reports, the president of Notre Dame “has repeatedly refused to seek such leniency or even answer the pro-lifers’ requests for dialogue.”  (Lifesitenews.com: 09-04-09)

Join this urgent petition.  Pass it along.  Post it on Facebook, on blogs, and get the word out.

Kindly ask Fr. Jenkins to drop the charges

Respectfully contact Fr. John Jenkins, president of Notre Dame:

Office of the President
400 Main Building
Notre Dame, IN 46556
Phone: 574-631-3903
Email: president@nd.edu This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Posted in Emanations from Penumbras | Tagged ,
11 Comments

“I cover my head when I worship.”

From KansasCity.com comes this, with my emphases and comments.

Never mind the problems with terminology, dig right in and read to the end.

My spirit came alive through Latin Mass

I cover my head when I worship. I am not a Muslim woman but a Roman Catholic who attends Tridentine Mass.

Like millions of other cradle Catholics, I grew up with the simple, easy-to-follow liturgy performed in English across America. Officially it’s known as the Novus Ordo (New Order) Mass and was introduced 40 years ago by Pope Paul VI. [That "easy to follow" stricture sure has has been two-edged.]

Novus Ordo was a response to the Second Vatican Council in the early 1960s, which declared that “the rites are to be simplified, due care being taken to preserve their substance.”

Simplified it was, but substance? What I learned about my faith in those early years you could’ve stuck inside a fortune cookie.

Not surprisingly, then, I fell away from my faith in college — like so many other students — because the foundation of my beliefs was a pile of sand, not the solid rock of Christ. I stopped attending Mass and neglected my spirituality altogether.

At one point I attended a couple of Greek Orthodox worship services. I remember there being something alluring in the stunning and elaborate series of rituals that I saw there.

A seed had been planted, it turns out, one that would grow as I became older and realized a spiritual yearning growing inside me. One day I was recalling that experience warmly and realizing I wanted that kind of worship in my life. I wondered if my own church, the Catholic Church, offered something similar.

And that’s how I found myself at Our Lady of Sorrows in downtown Kansas City, and heard for the first time what Mass sounded like to countless generations of believers prior to Vatican II. It was in Latin, so I had no idea what the priest was saying. The strange old rituals of this Mass, what I’d come to know as the “smells and bells,” were completely foreign to me.

But it had me right away. I realized that very first hour that I had come home. The beauty and the reverence of this rite struck a chord deep inside of me that resounds to this day.

Since I began attending the Tridentine Mass, I’ve come to appreciate the substance and textures of my faith that were never evident to me before. My husband still doesn’t attend church, and my mother-in-law refers irreverently to the “doily” I wear on my head during Mass.

But it’s not just about smells, bells and knowing what Agnus Dei means. For me, it is about experiencing the fullness of my faith.

Jennifer Leeper is one of 13 contributors writing the Faith Walk column. Reach her at faith@kcstar.com.

Posted in Brick by Brick |
13 Comments