QUAERITUR: SSPX wedding

From a reader:

My cousin is soon to be married in a SSPX church, a church which his family has been attending for twenty years, since he was in fourth grade. I read on a Catholic website that such a wedding was not valid or even licit, and that it was not a lawful marriage. Is this all true and correct? In their current situation, what would make such a marriage valid? Would the marriage be valid if it were held in a Catholic chapel and the ceremony performed by a priest who is diocesan approved?

Furthermore, does my family have the obligation to inform my relatives of the dangerous situation into which they are entering? They typically dismiss any opposition on their chosen way of life, and are quite adamant in believing that they are doing the right thing.

 

All sacraments must have proper matter and form in order to be valid.  For a marriage to be licit and valid, recognized by such as the Church, there must be a minister who witnesses the marriage for the Church as a part of the proper form.  The minister is generally a bishop, priest or deacon, but sometimes permission can be given to a lay person to witness the marriage.  But, the fact remains that for the marriage to be valid and licit there must be, as part of the form, an authorized witness.

SSPX priests are suspended a divinis from the moment of their ordination.  They do not have faculties from proper authorities to witness marriages, nor can those faculties be assumed. Thus, the marriages they witness are not licit or valid.  They would have to be validated by the Church.

However, they might be entering a lawful marriage, in the sense that the SSPX priest could very well be registered with the state and could legally witness a civil marriage.  As a matter of fact, some ex-priests do a rent-a-priest thing because they are still legally registered with the state.  Their marriages would be civilly legal, but not valid or licit – just as those of the SSPX priest.

Does "your family" have the obligation to inform your relatives?  I cannot answer that. You stated that they tend to ignore what they are told.  You said that your cousin has been attending this chapel for decades.   This is their world view.  They are rooted in it.

As a result, would having a talk with them do any good?  Would it do harm?  Would it drive them farther from your ability to influence them for the better?  Would they be easier or harder to help back into unity with the Church if you told them this or avoided their wedding? 

I cannot answer that for you.

In the meantime, I am sure that they are trying to do the right thing as they see it.  Their problem is a problem, but it is not necessarily one of faith or of commitment. 

Patience is very important.  Kindness is going to be the key.  So many families have been divided by this thing some people call a "schism"….  though we are avoiding that word these days.   Card. Castrillon, President of the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei, has been stating that the SSPX is not in schism and we have to go with that.

Try to find the way that will help to heal rather than making a point with the result of greater division.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
134 Comments

Is it just me….

… or are things very slow on the Catholic blogosphere today? 

Very slow on Twitter also, or so it seems.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
29 Comments

ante diem xvi kalendas januarias

With the help of rogueclassicism:

ante diem xvi kalendas januarias

Saturnalia (day 1) — major, popular festival in honour of Saturn with banquets, the wearing of soft caps (pilei), and general good cheer. Shops and schools were closed, gambling was legally permitted, gifts were exchanged and masters might even wait on their servants. Obviously this festival is often seen as a precursor to our modern-day Christmas celebrations …

246 B.C.E. — the Torah is translated into Greek (obviously not in one day)

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
11 Comments

Where some of you are

Here is a snapshot from the last few minutes of where people are (more or less) when they log in.  These are approximations and I edited out "unknown" and "United States", etc.

Washington, District of…
Stockton-on-Tees
Toronto, Ontario
Utica, Michigan
Pompano Beach, Florida
London, London, City of
Drums, Pennsylvania
Thornwood, New York
Los Angeles, California
Bloomington, Indiana
Cedarburg, Wisconsin
Mcmechen, West Virginia
Muldrow, Oklahoma
Woburn, Massachusetts
Atlanta, Georgia
Indianapolis, Indiana
Chillicothe, Ohio
Rome, Lazio
Chicago, Illinois
Cape Canaveral, Florida
South Portland, Maine
Framingham, Massachusetts
Saint Paul, Minnesota
Cuba, Missouri
Bronxville, New York
Bowie, Maryland
Berkeley, California
Gainesville, Florida
Rochester, Minnesota
Cambridge, Massachusetts
Hastings, Nebraska
Bristol, Rhode Island
Cincinnati, Ohio
Beaumont, Texas
York
London, London, City of
Bloomfield Hills, Michi…
Bemidji, Minnesota
Austin, Texas
Saint Louis, Missouri
Nutley, New Jersey
Holzkirchen, Bayern
Minneapolis, Minnesota
Cambridge, Massachusetts
Lincoln, Nebraska
Edison, New Jersey
Cocentaina, Comunidad V…
Edison, New Jersey
Washington, District of…
Chicago, Illinois
Katy, Texas
Aurora, Colorado
Indianapolis, Indiana
Manassas, Virginia
Midland, Texas
Guelph, Ontario
Mossor, Rio Grande do N…
Tylersport, Pennsylvania
Delft, Zuid-Holland  
Highland Mills, New York
Mascali, Sicilia
Cleveland, Ohio
Baltimore, Maryland
Powell, Ohio
Columbus, Ohio
Coventry, Rhode Island
Tallahassee, Florida
Buenos Aires, Distrito …
Gavirate, Lombardia
Waterford Works, New Je…
Lolo, Montana
Bradford, Ontario
Essex, Ontario
Alexandria, Virginia
Des Moines, Iowa
Richmond, Vermont
Groton, Connecticut
Sheffield
Leominster, Massachusetts
Ainring, Bayern
Mississauga, Ontario
Brookline, Massachusetts
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
Winter Park, Florida
Staffordsville, Virginia
Applecross, Western Aus…
Graham, Alabama
Seattle, Washington
Fort Myers, Florida
Katowice, Slaskie
Singapore
Fairfax, Virginia
Naples, Florida
Newport News, Virginia
Marlia, Sao Paulo
Grand Junction, Colorado
London, London, City of
Imperial, Missouri
Tuscaloosa, Alabama
Washington, District of…
Lakewood, Ohio
Bismarck, North Dakota
Manaus, Amazonas
Plymouth
Raleigh, North Carolina
Bethpage, Tennessee
Woburn, Massachusetts
Woburn, Massachusetts
Pawtucket, Rhode Island
Ogden, Utah
Midville, Georgia
Philadelphia, Pennsylva…
Vigonza, Veneto
Kingston, Ontario
Montclair, New Jersey
Saint Paul, Minnesota
Rochester, Minnesota
Amarillo, Texas
Moline, Illinois
Glendora, New Jersey
Portland, Oregon
Pullman, Washington
Wildwood, Florida
Chicago, Illinois
Norfolk, Virginia
Manchester, New Hampshire
Santa Fe
Cincinnati, Ohio
Austin, Texas
Brooklyn, New York
Meriden, Connecticut
Gibsonia, Pennsylvania
Anderson, Missouri
Wildwood, Florida
Norfolk, Virginia
   

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
22 Comments

Signs of Pelagianism

My friend Fr. Ray Blake, the distinguished pastor of St. Mary Magdalene in Brighton has a good commentary on his blog today.

Signs of Pelagianism

Pelagianism: I hate it, but it is very British. It is really a variant of Arianism which says God did not truly become Man, because Jesus was not truly God.

Pelagianism denies the action of Grace in the world, man is saved by his own goodness and efforts, rather than by God.

It is what we do, rather than what God does that matters, therefore the value of the sacraments is the psychological effect they have in our lives, rather than the direct intervention of God. It denies the power of Grace, of the role of the Blessed Virgin, of miracles, of the power of prayer: Pelagians above all would deny the role of the Holy Spirit, of His act of sanctification. Wherever there is attempt to place man at the heart of the faith, there we should expect to find Pelagianism.

Pelagianism expects Man to be strong rather God’s grace to be powerful. Catholicism, or as we could call it, mainstream Christianity, acknowledges mankind is weak and wholly dependant on those things God gives him.
Signs of the Pelagian:

The Church is a human construct, there is nothing or little of Grace about it.

The Liturgy and prayer is about how it makes us feel. Feelings rather than Grace are important.

Revelation is not a given, something given for today and all time, but something of that past that depends on our interpretation.

Ultimately Pelagianism says God is irrelevant to society and to the individual.

Pelagians tend to have a poor view of mankind, what see is what you get, because their is no room for Grace. It is also elitist, insofar as it values a human being by his goodness, his talents, his skills, his willpower.

Devotion to the Blessed Virgin is the destroyer Pelagianism, her whole being was about saying yes to Grace, and being the Mother of God she became the source of Grace. Her life shows the effects and power of Grace

Perhaps another sign of of the Pelagian is a defense of the lame-duck ICEL translations and resistance to the norms of Liturgiam authenticam..

Posted in Mail from priests |
26 Comments

A purpose of Summorum Pontificum

There is a wonderful phrase in Latin…

Repetita iuvant.

The Pertinacious Papist has a good reminder:

Una Voce America’s Nota (No 39, Fall 2008) carries the following brief excerpt from the address of Pope Benedict XVI to the Bishops of France on the Anniversary of his Motu Proprio, Summorum Pontificum:

Sunday, September 14, 2008 It is never too often said that the priesthood is indispensable to the Church, in the very own interest of the lay faithful. Priests are a gift from God to the Church. Priests must never delegate to the faithful [those] functions which are related to their own mission. Dear Brothers in the episcopacy, I ask you to remain desirous to help your priests live in intimate union with Christ. Their spiritual life is the foundation of their apostolic life. You shall exhort them gently to daily prayer and to a dignified celebration of the Sacraments, particularly of the Eucharist and of Reconciliation, as Saint Francis de Sales did with his priests. Every priest should be able to feel glad to serve the Church. At the school of the Curé d’Ars, son of your land and patron of all preists of the world, do not cease to repeat that a man can do no greater deed than to give the Body and the Blood of Christ to the faithful, and to forgive sins….

Liturgical worship is the supreme expression of priestly and episcopal life, and also of catechetical teaching. Your mission of sanctification of the faithful people, dear Brothers, is indispensable for the growth of the Church. I was prompted to detail, in the motu proprio Summorum Pontificum, the conditions for the accomplishment of this mission, in that which relates to the possibility of using both the missal of Blessed John XXIII (1962) and that of Pope Paul VI (1970). The fruits of these new dispositions have already seen [the light of] day, and I hope that the indispensable pacification of the spirits is being accomplished, thank God.

I comprehend your difficulties, but I do not doubt that you will be able to reach, within reasonable time, solutions which are satisfactory to all, so that the seamless robe of Christ is not torn anymore. No one is excessive within the Church. [If you are within the Church you are, by definition, not excessive.] Everyone, without exception, must be able to feel at home, and never rejected. God, who loves all men and wills that no one be lost, entrusts us with this mission of Pastors, making us Shepherds of His sheep. We can only give Him thanks for the honor and confidence He places upon us. Let us endeavor to always be servants of unity.

[Acknowledgement: from "Strong words on Summorum Pontificum," Una Voce America – Nota (No. 39, Fall 2008), p. 2.]

Posted in SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
9 Comments

“In rigorous hours…”

"In rigorous hours..." 

With a tip of the biretta to the Laudator….

Robert Louis Stevenson, Winter:

    In rigorous hours, when down the iron lane
    The redbreast looks in vain
    For hips and haws,
    Lo, shining flowers upon my window-pane
    The silver pencil of the winter draws.

    When all the snowy hill
    And the bare woods are still;
    When snipes are silent in the frozen bogs,
    And all the garden garth is whelmed in mire,
    Lo, by the hearth, the laughter of the logs –
    More fair than roses, lo, the flowers of fire!

"In rigorous hours..."

 

Posted in My View |
4 Comments

QUAERITUR: servers sitting on steps during TLM

From a reader:

Have you any information regarding alter servers sitting on the steps of the sanctuary during a TLM Mass? This is occurring in a local parish during the times when the celebrant sits (while the choir sings the Creed and Gloria) and when he does the readings in English from the pulpit (even during the Gospel when the congregation is standing).

 

I know that servers sit on the steps at certain times during a Pontifical Mass, but I don’t know of other situations.

Perhaps the readers have seen this done.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
19 Comments

WDTPRS: Last Days of Advent: 17 December

We have come to the last days of the Church’s preparation for the feast of the Nativity of the Lord.

COLLECT:
Deus, humanae conditor et redemptor naturae,
qui Verbum tuum in utero perpetuae virginitatis
carnem assumere voluisti,
respice propitius ad preces nostras,
ut Unigenitus tuus, nostra humanitate suscepta,
nos divino suo consortio sociare dignetur.

This ancient prayer is from Gelasian Sacramentary as well as Rotulus 31 published together with the Veronese Sacramentary. It was not in any pre-Conciliar edition of the Missale Romanum.

 

LITERAL VERSION:
O God, creator and redeemer of human nature,
who desired Your Word to assume flesh
in a womb of perpetual virginity,
look propitiously on our prayers,
so that Your Only-Begotten, now that our humanity has been taken up,
may deign to integrate us into His own fellowship.

You see in this prayer how the will of the Father and the Son are perfectly in harmony. We ask the Father that the Son will deign…

We have again a confluence of the different Advents of the Lord, at Bethlehem in the past and as Judge in the future. Christ took up our flesh in the Incarnation. He took up our flesh in His own Person at the Assumption. He desired to share our lot (Latin sors). We ask to be sharer is of His lot (con-sors).

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
4 Comments

grrr

I have been trying to get usteam to work on the old laptop I put in the chapel.  I think more people can watch ustream at once, whereas only 7 can watch at the same time with the present service.

Ustream keeps crashing my browsers.

grrr

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
8 Comments