BLOGNIC ALERT: Philadelphia – Thursday evening!

I believe we have locked down the time and place for the Philadelphia blognic.

I can be at the Irish Pub at 20th & Walnut in the Rittenhouse Square area Thursday evening, 23 October, from 6:00-8:00 pm.  MAP.

Other bloggers and clerics who read and post are especially welcome, though it is a weeknight and we all know how busy you are.

I suggest that if someone arrives a little early they might stake out an area.  Thursday is Game 2 of the World Series, which starts at 8:00 pm.  I suspect the place will be pretty amped up. 

Before the blognic, I hope to spend time in the afternoon at the Museum, which closes at 5:30 pm on Thursday.   I suppose I would then walk to the Pub, depending on the weather, perhaps with a visit to the Basilica on the way. 

I have never seen the Basilica here.  More on that as the day approaches.  

As is the case for all blognics everywhere, this is very informal.  People can order food for themselves, for others, or not.  Order whatever you want to sip, for yourself, for others, or not, it’s up to you.  There is no other agenda other than meet each other, chat and have some fun. 

That the Phillies are in the Series is icing on the cake!   That’ll just make this more memorable.  

TO COMMENT GO HERE

Posted in Blognics, On the road, What Fr. Z is up to |
Comments Off on BLOGNIC ALERT: Philadelphia – Thursday evening!

The Lion of Denver on Catholics supporting pro-abortion candidate Sen. Obama

With a biretta tip to American Papist for this….

The Lion of Denver on Catholics supporting pro-abortion candidate Sen. Obama Archbishop criticizes Obama, Catholic allies (AP)

Denver Roman Catholic Archbishop Charles Chaput labeled Barack Obama the "most committed" abortion-rights candidate from a major party in 35 years while accusing a Catholic Obama ally and other Democratic-friendly Catholic groups of doing a "disservice to the church."

Chaput, one of the nation’s most politically outspoken Catholic prelates, delivered the remarks Friday night at a dinner of a Catholic women’s group.

His comments were among the sharpest in a debate over abortion and Catholic political responsibility in a campaign in which Catholics represent a key swing vote.

Coverage here from CNA and Zenit has the full text of the Archbishop’s address.

update, excerpt from Abp. Chaput on the "Catholic" argument for Obama:
To suggest — as some Catholics do — that Senator Obama is this year’s “real” pro-life candidate requires a peculiar kind of self-hypnosis, [OH!  well said!] or moral confusion, or worse. To portray the 2008 Democratic Party presidential ticket as the preferred “pro-life” option is to subvert what the word “pro-life” means.
… I think [Kmiecs’] activism for Senator Obama, and the work of Democratic-friendly groups like Catholics United and Catholics in Alliance for the Common Good, have done a disservice to the Church, confused the natural priorities of Catholic social teaching, undermined the progress pro-lifers have made, and provided an excuse for some Catholics to abandon the abortion issue instead of fighting within their parties and at the ballot box to protect the unborn.
… The one genuinely new quality to Catholic arguments for Senator Obama is their packaging. Just as the abortion lobby fostered “Catholics for a Free Choice” to challenge Catholic teaching on abortion more than two decades ago, so supporters of Senator Obama have done something similar in seeking to neutralize the witness of bishops and the pro-life movement by offering a “Catholic” alternative to the Church’s priority on sanctity of life issues. I think it’s an intelligent strategy. I also think it’s wrong and often dishonest.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
32 Comments

The new Coadjutor of Cincinnati on Summorum Pontificum

With a tip of the biretta to Fr. Fox of Bonfire of the Vanities, and in the wake of the news that H.E. Most Rev. Dennis Schnurr has been translated from Duluth to be the new Coadjutor Archbishop of Cincinnati to replace H.E. Daniel Pilarczyk, it is good to go back to review what Archbishop Schnurr said about Summorum Pontificum when it was released.

Let’s "turn back the clock" for real for a moment and have a look, with my emphases and comments.

This originally appeared in the August 2007 newsletter of the Diocese of Duluth

Dear friends in Christ,

Last month, [that is, 7 July 07, when the text of the Motu Proprio was released] The Northern Cross [diocesan paper] reported on the Holy Father’s decision to relax restrictions on the use of the Tridentine Mass, the Latin-language liturgy that predates the Second Vatican Council. [It was also the Mass during the Council.] Pope Benedict XVI said that Mass celebrated according to the 1962 Roman Missal, commonly referred to as the Tridentine Rite, should be made available in every parish where groups of the faithful desire it. The Holy Father’s decision was promulgated on July 7 under the title “Summorum Pontificum” and will take effect on Sept. 14, the feast of the Exaltation of the Holy Cross.

Over the past weeks, I have received questions about the implementation of these norms in the Diocese of Duluth. Put quite simply, of course, the response is that, on Sept. 14, “Summorum Pontificum” becomes the universal law of the church. As such, the norms must be followed in every parish and diocese throughout the world.  [You know… that is an excellent way of putting it.  I wonder if there is a connection between the sorts of bishops who issued statements like this and where and how quickly they are being "promoted"… if we can call the heaping of additional responsibilities and burdens on them "promoted"!  I am not sure I would call it that!]

Practically speaking, I anticipate some challenges with implementation in the Diocese of Duluth. Primary among them is one that the Holy Father himself mentioned in a cover letter to “Summorum Pontificum,” which he addressed to the bishops of the world: “The use of the old Missal presupposes a certain degree of liturgical formation and knowledge of the Latin language; neither of these is found very often.” In order to celebrate the Tridentine Rite, or the “extraordinary form” of the Mass as it is called by “Summorum Pontificum,” a priest must be suitably qualified. This means that, [watch what happens] for a legitimate use of the extraordinary form, a priest must have the minimum[!] rubrical knowledge of the Mass as it was celebrated before the Second Vatican Council and the minimum [!] linguistic ability to reverently and precisely recite the prayers of the Mass in the Latin language. [You might remember that His Eminence Card. Egan was one of the first out of the gate reacting to Summorum Pontificum.  Card. Egan experience canonist as he is, rightly pointed out that the qualifications indicated in the requirement that a priest be qualified or capable, idoneus, are that he be able to pronounce the Latin properly.  That is, Card. Egan pointed out the minimum qualifications.  We always interpret law so as to favor people.  Thus,Summorum Pontificum does not require expertise, but rather a sufficient capability.  This is very important.  In some places, bishops wrongly sought to impose an undue requirement about some level of expertise beyond the minimum necessary to say Mass in a legitimate way.  They even said they would "test" priests.   Clearly, this was also a way of creating obstacles to the implementation of Summroum Pontificum at the same time as it was a way of fostering competence.  Of course we all hope that the priest will have more than the minimal tools in his toolbox, but it is improper to impose undue restrictions on priests, whom the law favors in this regard.]

It should be remembered that the Second Vatican Council did not prohibit the use of the Latin language in celebrating the Mass. [RIGHT!] The Mass that is celebrated in our parishes today can properly be celebrated by any priest in either the English or Latin language, or for that matter in any other language, provided that the texts used have been authorized by the Holy See.

What the Second Vatican Council did do was modify some of the prayers of the Mass, allow for the priest to celebrate Mass facing the people, [allow for, not require] and promote greater participation on the part of the faithful in the celebration of the Mass.

“Summorum Pontificum” aims to provide more ready access to the Mass as it was celebrated prior to the modifications permitted by the Second Vatican Council. [And those modifications were really very few indeed.  The Consilium went way beyond its mandate and then hoodwinked and bullied them into acceptance.]  In addition to the Latin language and position of the priest at the altar, the difference between the celebration of the Mass as permitted by “Summorum Pontificum” (pre-Vatican II) and the celebration after the Second Vatican Council (post-Vatican II) might be summarized as displayed in the box that appears on this page. [I don’t have that part.]

In the cover letter to the bishops that accompanied “Summorum Pontificum,” Pope Benedict mentions what prompted him to make access to the pre-Vatican II Mass more available: “At the time of the introduction of the new Missal, it did not seem necessary to issue specific norms for the possible use of the earlier Missal. .. . Afterwards, however, it soon became apparent that a good number of people remained strongly attached to this usage of the Roman Rite. . . . [Others] desired to recover the form of the sacred liturgy that was dear to them . . . because in many places celebrations were not faithful to the prescriptions of the new Missal, but the latter actually was understood as authorizing or even requiring creativity, which frequently led to deformations of the liturgy which were hard to bear. . . . And I have seen how arbitrary deformations of the liturgy caused deep pain to individuals totally rooted in the faith of the Church.”

These latter comments of Pope Benedict XVI echo those of his predecessor, Pope John Paul II: “It must be lamented that, especially in the years following the post-conciliar liturgical reform, as a result of a misguided sense of creativity and adaptation, there have been a number of abuses which have been a source of suffering for many. A certain reaction against ‘formalism’ has led some, especially in certain regions, to consider the ‘forms’ chosen by the Church’s greatest liturgical tradition and her Magisterium as non-binding and to introduce unauthorized innovations which are often completely inappropriate.

“I consider it my duty, therefore, to appeal urgently that the liturgical norms for the celebration of the Eucharist be observed with great fidelity. These norms are a concrete expression of the authentically ecclesial nature of the Eucharist; this is their deepest meaning. Liturgy is never anyone’s private property, be it of the celebrant or of the community in which the mysteries are celebrated.. . . Our time, too, calls for a renewed awareness and appreciation of liturgical norms as a reflection of, and a witness to, the one universal Church made present in every celebration of the Eucharist. Priests who faithfully celebrate Mass according to the liturgical norms, and communities which confirm to those norms, quietly but eloquently demonstrate their love for the Church” (“Ecclesia de Eucharistia,” 52).

With these words, we are reminded that, in the churches and chapels of this diocese, the observance of liturgical norms cannot be arbitrary. [RIGHT!  Old Mass or new Mass… SAY THE BLACK and DO THE RED!] If Mass is to be celebrated according to the extraordinary form, it must be celebrated by a priest who has the minimum rubrical knowledge of the Mass as it was celebrated before the Second Vatican Council and minimum linguistic ability to reverently and precisely recite the prayers of the Mass in the Latin language. [There it is again…"minimum".] In such instances, too, the congregation must participate in the Mass by observing all the liturgical norms and using prayer books that translate the prayers and rubrics for them.

When Mass is celebrated in our churches and chapels, whether according to the ordinary rite or the extraordinary rite, there are also important liturgical norms that help to raise the mind and heart to God through the sacred mysteries celebrated. [Well said.]  Here I mention just a few, but I encourage those who are interested to give a full reading to the “General Instruction of the Roman Missal” (GIRM) promulgated by Pope John Paul II in 2001.

Before the celebration of the Mass, “it is commendable that silence [God bless this bishop.]  be observed in the church” (GIRM, 45). The chalice and other sacred vessels are to be made from precious metals. If they are made from less than precious metals, at least the chalice and paten are to be gilded on the inside. The use of glass or ceramic chalices, patens or ciborium is not permitted (GIRM, 328-329). For the priest, the chasuble is to be worn over the alb and stole (GIRM, 337). On entering and leaving the church, all genuflect to the Most Blessed Sacrament if the tabernacle is present in the main body of the church (GIRM, 273-274). The tabernacle is to be located either in the sanctuary or in a chapel that is connected to the church and suitable for private adoration and prayer (GIRM, 315). If churches do not have a chapel that is truly distinct and separate from the main body of the church, the tabernacle is to be located in the sanctuary. During the celebration of the Mass, people “should kneel beginning after the singing or recitation of the Sanctus until after the Amen of the Eucharistic Prayer, except when prevented on occasion by reasons of health, lack of space, the large number of people present, or some other good reason” (GIRM, 43).

In his encyclical “Sacramentum Caritatis,” Pope Benedict XVI reminds us that the faithful adherence to the liturgical norms has for 2,000 years sustained the faith life of all believers (38). This is the purpose of liturgy, regardless of the language in which it is prayed and celebrated.

With prayerful best wishes, I am

Most Reverend Dennis M. Schnurr

 

It seems as if Archbp. Schnurr may have a a slightly different point of view than Archbp. Pilarczyk.   However, it would be unfair to pit them against each other, who will have to work in harmony until such time as Archbp. Schnurr takes over as Ordinary.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
19 Comments

Institute of St. Philip Neri – new church

I was pleased to get this e-mail… worry I don’t have time to translate it – the news that the Institute of St. Philip Neri in the other Berlin (Germany) closed the deal on a new church.

This excellent "brick by brick" news indeed!

Institut St. Philipp Neri – Nachrichten
Der Kauf der Kirche ist abgeschlossen!
 
Sonntag, 19. Oktober 2008
Im Namen + des Vaters
und des Sohnes
und des Heiligen Geistes.
Durch die Gnade des Dreieinigen Gottes, die Fürsprache Seiner Jungfräulichen Mutter, des hl. Joseph, der hl. Afra, des hl. Philipp Neri, des hl. Simeon Franziskus und aller Heiligen, sowie durch Ihr Opfer und Gebet und das vieler anderer Gläubiger können wir voll Freude mitteilen:
Die St. Afra-Kirche
ist nunmehr endgültig Eigentum
des Instituts St. Philipp Neri.

Voll Dankbarkeit erneuern wir daher am Christkönigsfest, dem 26. Oktober 2008, vor dem Levitenamt um 10.30 Uhr die Weihe des Instituts an die Muttergottes und grüßen ihren Bräutigam. Die hl. Messe endet mit der Weihe an das Herz Jesu und dem feierlichen
Te Deum.
Nach der Liturgie sind Sie herzlich zu einem kleinen Empfang eingeladen.
Diejenigen, die an diesem Tag nicht in St. Afra sein können, bitten wir, sich im Geiste mit unserem dankbaren Lobpreis zu verbinden.
Für das Institut St. Philipp Neri
Dr. Gerald Goesche, Propst

Indeed… let there be sung Non nobis and Te Deum.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
5 Comments

A note to readers

Folks, I like discussion.   I really do.

But I must make some observations.

First, when I post an entry on some topic, that really is the topic I intend to post about.   An entry with a combox is NOT an invitation to you to turn that thread into a discussion about any old thing.  Don’t drag entries off topic.  What that does is create more work for me.  If you want to have a combox, stick to the subject.  You can e-mail questions and as time and topic permit, I can post some on the blog.  This is happening more and more recently it seems.  It’s pretty annoying.

Second, if you simply want to spew or grind your teeth against someone, especially the duly appointed shepherds of the Church, don’t even think of posting here.  If you do this in a way that suggests you are uncapable of self-editing, I will block your IP address.  We can a little… litle venting, but it must remain respectful.  Make your points without being nasty.

That’s it for now.

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on A note to readers

Meeting seminarians

One of the great things about traveling is meeting good people along the way.

Tonight three seminarians made their way from St. Charles Borromeo Seminary to Mater Ecclesiae for a period of adoration before the Blessed Sacrament exposed in the church for Forty Hours Devotion.  They rang the door of the rectory and asked Fr. Pasley if I was around and… wouldn’t you know… I was!

So we sat and shot the breeze for a little while.  

These are really good fellows and their dioceses should be very pleased to have them.

Seminarians impress me more and more.

Here we are with Fr. Robert Pasley, the locum tenens at Mater Ecclesiae.

Meeting seminarians

I also learned to my delight that one of these men is a mutual friend of some faithful WDTPRS readers, both in the blog and the print version.  A shout out to them as well!  As a matter of fact, they helped him learn how to serve the TLM, thus contributing an important dimension to his future work as a priest.

Posted in My View |
11 Comments

Mater Ecclesiae in Berlin, NJ: Forty Hours – Day 2

One of the main themes of WDTPRS is Save the Liturgy – Save the World.

I think that the way we, as a Church and as small communities within the Church, worship God in liturgical prayer, affects the whole world.

Celebrate Holy Mass well, the world is positively affected.

Celebrate Holy Mass poorly, the whole world is harmed.

I think the rite of Mass, rites of the sacraments, rites of our devotions make a difference to the world.

After long reflection, I think that the older form of these rites accomplishes these things more effectively.

And so the devotion we call the Forty Hours Prayer, originally intended precisely to ask God’s help to avert calamities through worship before the Blessed Sacrament solemnly exposed, it sorely needed today.

And it should be done correctly.

In Fortescue/O’Connell (p. 333) we read that the Clementine Instruction (which governed the Quarant’ore Prayer, Forty Hours) said:

A sign (e.g., a shield) or banner should be placed over the door of the church, bearing a symbol of the Blessed Sacrament, that people may see that the Forty Hours are being held there. 

Naturally this comes from a place, Rome, where people as they walked about – which is most common – passed in front in numerous churches.

Here at Mater Ecclesiae this is what you find as you come to the main entrance to the church.

Mater Ecclesiae in Berlin, NJ: Forty Hours - Day 2

To the left of the door, but very prominently displayed, there is a shield with a symbol of the Blessed Sacrament.

Mater Ecclesiae in Berlin, NJ: Forty Hours - Day 2

Within, day and night, people are praying for you and for the world.  The Blessed Sacrament is never left alone.  A few people are there even in the middle of the night.

Mater Ecclesiae in Berlin, NJ: Forty Hours - Day 2

Later this afternoon, there will be the second sung Mass.  The undersigned will be the celebrant.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
9 Comments

Card. Castrillon pontificates at Ss. Trinita in Rome

The FSSP is celebrating their anniversary in Rome.   Our friend John Sonnen of Orbis Catholicus has posted some video of a Mass at the "personal parish" in Rome for the TLM and older forms of sacraments, the historic church where St. Philip Neri began the still extant confraternity, Santissima Trinita dei Pelegrini.   Cardinal Castrillon, President of the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei was the celebrant.

Play video

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

More praise of autumn colors

While most the leaves are down at the Sabine Farm, here in the East they are staring to change.

Two sessions of autumn colors for me this year.

In honor of that happy development…

From the Laudator…

More praise of autumn colors

James Hayford, One Fall Day:

One fall day of high color and high wind
The trees will glitter on a hundred hills
As all their leaves, their longest journey starting,
Reserve their bravest gesture for departing.

Jasper Francis Cropsey, River Landscape in Autumn

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
3 Comments

QUAERITUR: Can priests say 3 Masses on both 2 and 3 November?

A priest reader asks:

I have always said all three Masses on All Souls day.  This year it will happen on Nov.2 for the OF  and on Nov. 3 for the EF. I am inclined to say all three Masses on both days.  Our diocese has ruled that the Saturday night Mass be for All Souls day.  I will have two morning OF Masses on Nov.2  which will be for all souls day, and I have the EF Mass in the afternoon on Nov. 2 which needs to be 25th SUN after Pentecost.   Interesting?

 

Yes… interesting!

This year All Souls falls on a Sunday.  In the Ordinary Form, All Souls bumps the Sunday.  In the Extraordinary Form’s calendar, the Sunday bumps All Souls to Monday 3 November.

So, we Latin priests of the Roman Rite have two All Souls this year. 

Given that Holy Church says we have two Uses of one Roman Rite, and we can use the Roman Rite when we want, and since Canon Law says we can say three Masses on All Souls, and since we only keep one stipend on All Souls, and since we interpret law in the Church in a way that favors us, yes… I think we can say three Masses on both 2 and 3 November.

Interesting!
 

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, Mail from priests |
22 Comments