QUAERITUR: the seventh candle

I had a note from a priest with a question:

Dear Father,
 
I have had a TLM at my Parish, which I celebrate, every Sunday since last November and is going great. But my question is about what I see in the way The Holy Father celebrates Mass in extraordinary form with a cross and 6 candles in the altar, a seventh candle behind the cross because he is Pope. Is this to be an "expected" way of what is to be on the altar for the celebration of Mass?  (ordinary or extraordinary form?)

First, the Holy Father is saying Mass only in the Ordinary Form, so far.  But the use of the seventh candle, next to the Cross at the center of the altar, is a very old custom.

This is not just something that the Roman Pontiff does.

The seventh candle could be used for Pontifical High Mass when celebrated by an Ordinary in his diocese (or by the Pope anywhere, of course).

The seventh candle, placed in the middle and in line with the other six, should be a little higher. This pushes the crucifix a little out of line… which also emphasizes it, in my opinion. Pope Benedict is acutely sensitive to the position of the Cross during Holy Mass.

So… this is an old Mass element enriching the new Mass.

It also rather explodes the Bugnini notion that the old ways of doing things shouldn’t be assumed to be the way we ought to do things in the Novus Ordo.

So, is this to be expected?  I think so.  I think that priests who are preparing for the coming of the bishop to the parish should use the Benedictine arrangement, if they are still having Mass versus populum and be sure to add the seventh candle.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box, Mail from priests |
14 Comments

Holy Smoke: Are traditional Catholics losing hope? – Fr. Z responds

Over at Holy Smoke of Damian Thompson there is a thread sure to provoke some conversation.

It seethes frustration.

And I have no doubt that in some respects he is right about the topic he tackles.  But at the same time I think he might be missing some important points.

Let’s have a look with my emphases and comments.

Is Pope Benedict losing the confidence of the Latin Mass faithful?

Just over a year ago, Pope Benedict’s decree liberating the traditional Latin Mass came into effect. But it contained so many loopholes that liberal bishops have been able to sabotage it – and a much-needed clarification from Rome has still not appeared.  [And it must be said that that is entirely the decision, or non-decision, of the Holy Father.  The Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei completed its part of the work a long time ago.]

Pope Benedict XVI has an intense vision of liturgical reform

The mood among traditionalist commentators is gloomy – much gloomier than they are prepared to admit on their blogs. [I am not sure by which psychic powers he knows this… but let’s read on…] Meanwhile, Latin Mass enthusiasts in England and Wales are bewildered that the number of weekly Sunday Masses in the Old Rite has barely increased since before Summorum Pontificum.  [That is a matter of stats, not psychic powers, and we must accept this.]

The bishops of England and Wales, three quarters of whom regard the Motu Proprio as a mistake, are playing a clever game. Yes, they are more willing to give permission for weekday Tridentine Masses, or Sunday Masses once a month. But (a) they are still firmly in control of Latin Mass provision, which was not the Pope’s intention; and (b) outside London, the number of weekly Sunday Masses in the Old Rite is tiny.  [A couple problems here.  If this is the case, the problem does not lie with Pope Benedict.  The problem lies not even so much with hostile bishops, though they are not to be discounted.  The problem lies with parish priests who don’t have the backbone to implement Summorum Pontificum in their parishes.  The Motu Proprio might be vague on some points, but it is not vague about who implements the document in parishes.  PP’s don’t need permission from the bishop.  So, there is a lack of will on the part of Parish Priests.  There also may be a lack of will and, it must be said, savvy among those who desire the TLM.  We cannot live in a dream world where, like good cartesians, we think things into being.  Peope have to act, and act intelligently, carefully, diplomatically, … but they have to act.]

Take a look at the website of the Latin Mass Society. Its list of regular traditional Masses tells a sad story. Arundel & Brighton, East Anglia, Lancaster, Menevia, Middlesbrough, Wrexham – there is not one weekly traditional Sunday Mass in these dioceses, according to the LMS.

Other dioceses offer perhaps one or two, some predating Summorum Pontificum. Funnily enough, one bishop who has instituted a Sunday Tridentine Mass is dear old Arthur Roche – the key word being "instituted", meaning that it is very much his decision, under his control. [And that is the problem everywhere.  If the field is ceeded to bishops alone to implement the Motu Proprio, then people and their priests have no one to blame but themselves.]

No cathedral in England and Wales offers a weekly Sunday Mass in the Old Rite, so far as I can tell, which is a disgrace. And no Latin Mass communities have been set up in England and Wales, in sharp contrast to the situation in the United States. "There’s no demand for them," say the bishops. But the point is that the admittedly limited demand for the traditional services is NOT being met – and the Pope’s wish that a new generation of Catholics be introduced to the treasures of the old liturgy is just a pipe dream.  [This raises a question which cannot be avoided.  If there is limited demand, or no demand for TLMs, what can one expect if bishops and priests don’t offer them?  I think my positions are pretty clear: priests should educate their flocks so that they want the TLM.  But… that’s me.  We must recognize that many priests a) don’t share that goal and b) already have plenty to do and c) know that the bishop can make their lives very difficult.]

But if the bishops of England and Wales (and of many other countries) are playing fast and loose with Summorum Pontificum, that’s because Pope Benedict XVI is allowing them to.  [When I see this sort of thing, I am torn.  On the one hand, Popes, bishops, priests, should look upon those in their charge with a measure of paternal respect and, giving them the benefit of the doubt, treat them like adults and let them do what they are to do.  On the other hand, and perhaps my years spent with St. Augustine now show forth, we sadly see all too often that people don’t do what they ought and that intervention becomes necessary. So… the question winds up being: how much intervention is the right amount of intervention?  Should the Pope micromanage?  Shout?  Suspend?  Punish?  Many people quickly jump to the statement that the Pope should PUNISH to the right of him and to the left.   From what I know of this Pope, and I knew him before he was elected, this man is not the punishing or micromanaging sort.  He doesn’t like or want conflict.  He believes in the good in people and that they will come to see reason and act accordingly.  He sets his example in that direction…. and there we have another problem.  But I suspect we’ll get to that down the line.]

The original document was not tightly drafted: it left plenty of room for confusion about what constituted a "stable group" of the faithful who were entitled to demand access to the older form of Mass. [The flip side is that tightly drafted documents cannot be interpreted with as much flexibility.]  Did the group have to be rooted in one parish, or predate the papal decree? Cardinal Castrillon Hoyos, head of the Pontifical Commission Ecclesia Dei, has indicated that the answer is "no" and that the Pope wishes people in every parish to have access (of some sort) to the 1962 Missal.

But these were off-the cuff remarks made in response to a question I asked him at a press conference before the big Westminster Mass boycotted by the local bishops: they have not been clarified or amplified by Ecclesia Dei. Why not?

Meanwhile, although the Pope is slowly changing the style of his own liturgical celebrations to bring them more into line with the historic practices of the Church – to de-Bugninify them, if you like – there is still not the slightest indication that His Holiness will celebrate Mass in the Extraordinary Form publicly. Why? No one knows the answer.

Let us be blunt about this. If the Pope were to die tomorrow, he would be remembered for many fine achievements, most of all his encyclicals, but his liturgical reforms would peter out. [We are back to the psychic powers again.]  Summorum Pontificum would remain on the statute book, but the Magic Circle in England and its powerful allies in the Vatican and Europe would quietly suffocate the work of Ecclesia Dei.

My guess is that the next Pope will be as theologically conservative as Benedict, but is unlikely to possess his blindingly intense vision of a liturgical reform in which the pre- and post-Vatican II liturgies revive each other. That reform is not yet properly under way, and the Pope is in his 80s. No wonder traditionalists are alarmed.

In so many ways I share many of the thoughts and sentiments in the above.   I understand there are many people who have wanted a lot more and a lot faster. 

But at the same time, I must underscore that Summorum Pontificum is now in force… something a few years ago was hardly to be dreamed.

It is entirely natural to strain against the snaffle when the goal has suddenly come into view.  But let’s be realistic about more than one dimension of this.

The Pope, if he is dithering, is not the only one dithering. 

I don’t know about this for sure… but perhaps we are seeing greater success in the USA with the implementation of Summorum Pontificum because Americans tend to do something rather than reflect about what ought to be done and then wring hands that it isn’t yet so.  I will grant immediately that there are far stronger ideologically convinced enemies of the TLM and Summorum Pontificum in the UK and the continent, making their implementation very difficult indeed.  I have spent a long time in Italy and found far more savage… and more stupid… opposition to anything traditional there than in my native USA.  So, I admit that the good people in England, Wales, Scotland have a very hard time ahead of them.

But they have, nevertheless, also the power to do something about it and not merely to sit being gloomy.

First, have a reality check.  If there are only a couple people in a parish who are interested in having the older Mass, and the priest isn’t interested, your choices are fairly clear.  Either get the priest interested or take it on the road.  Face it: Father "I’m-not-interested" isn’t going to add a Mass for three people.  

So, you have to band together into large groups and begin working on priests who are more amenable.  Charm them.  Provide them with materials.  Pray and fast for them.  Press diplomatically and gently.  BE THERE to do the work.  Get involved.  Figure it out.

Is the priest afraid of the bishop?   Help the priest.  Keep working on the bishop.  Carefully.  Pray for him, perhaps using the Bux Protocol for praying for bishops: ask St. Joseph to intercede with God that He will either open the bishop’s eyes or close them permanently.  Remember: the biological solution is going to be important for the future of the TLM.  Therefore, work on the younger priests and on seminarians.  Do you best to promote vocations to the priesthood among bright young men and boys who are interested in these things.

Do your best to open hearts.

Some people, the gloomy sort, will say that I am too optimistic or delusional or that I don’t understand what resistance they are facing.

I think I do understand, that I have my eyes pretty wide open, and that from my perspective I have seen what is possible whereas they, perhaps have not.

Let me underscore this with a quick story.

When I was working for the PCED we were having a terrible exchange with an American bishop.  People wanted the old Mass, and he refused absolutely.  They petitioned, he rejected.  They sent us the copies of the petitions, he would deny there was any interest.  Volley of letters after volleys of letters back and forth across the Atlantic.  He would say he never got petitions, we would mail back copies of his acknowledgement of the petitions to the lay people who had sent them.  He would write a stern letter reminding us to mind our own business, we would write back saying that this was our business.  It became uglier and uglier. 

One day a letter came from him that was so nasty it simply couldn’t be borne.  I wrote a draft of a response entirely proportioned to the tone and content of that bishops letter.  I wrote a draft designed to end the issue.

When the Cardinal came in, this was the great Augustine Card. Mayer, first President of Ecclesia Dei – now very old and ailing – please I beg you to pray for him in his infirmity and suffering – he eventually called me in to go over the various drafts that had to go out.  At last we came to The Letter.

Card. Mayer, who was nearly 80 at the time, and who had been a monk, expert at the Council, abbot, professor, curia Secretary, Prefect, is perhaps the holiest man I know, had a practically perfect grasp of English.  He would make subtle changes in the language of all the letters he would sign.  So there was no surprise at all when he said,

"Here you write X.  Do you suppose we could say Y?"

There was no question but that we could, but that was his style.  He was ready to hear a reason for or against, but he was usually right with each "suggestion".

We went on to the next word in that manner… and the next… and the next, until – both of us chuckling a bit – there was nothing at all left of what I had written and the page was filled with corrections and cobwebs of lines and marks.

At last, I said "Clearly Your Eminence wants something else.  It’s my job to make your job easier.  Give me some direction."

He paused and looked at the large Murillo painting of the Blessed Mother on the wall of the office for a while and then said:

"At a certain point we must stop arguing and try to open their hearts."

With that I went back to my desk, pondered this for a while, and then rapidly wrote a short letter of response to that American bishop.

I took it in to the Cardinal, who make a minor change here and there, and off it went.

A few weeks later we received news from people in that bishop’s diocese that, not only had the bishop permitted the older form of Mass, he came to celebrate it himself for them.

What did I write?

After the usual clink of incense at the beginning, common to all curia letters, I merely wrote that we regretted greatly the way our correspondence had gone and its tone.  We hoped that it might improve.  But given the earnest desire of the people in his diocese, …

"Would Your Excellency please not open your heart to these people and help them?"

That seems to have been the real problem, after all. 

At a certain point, arguing isn’t going to achieve the result you desire.  Sometimes you must strive to open hearts.

That experience still lies at the heart of what I think is possible in the implementation of Summorum Pontificum. 

Yes, there are great and obvious obstacles.  But we have to do our very best that we ourselves do not become obstacles.

Could the situation be better?  Of course. 

But it isn’t.  

I don’t blame anyone for being sad or frustrated, which is very normal.  But I hope people will consider some new approaches, rather than blame others.

Therefore, given the way the winds are blowing and the gloomy skies, perhaps a change of tack is in order, a shifting of the sails.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
47 Comments

Londoners: Oyster Card’s chip can be hacked for info – interesting

When I was in London recently, I used my Oyster Card all the time.  Very handy.

I read this story and pass it along to my new and old friends in London.

Oyster card hack details revealed
By Peter Price
Click reporter

Londoners: Oyster Card's chip can be hacked for info - interesting

Oyster card on Tube map, Getty

The Oyster card is used on London’s travel network.

Details of how to hack one of the world’s most popular smartcards have been published online.

The research by Professor Bart Jacobs and colleagues at Radboud University in Holland reveals a weakness in the widely used Mifare Classic RFID chip.

This is used in building entry systems and is embedded in the Oyster card used on London’s transport network.

Publication of the research was delayed by legal action taken by the chip’s manufacturer.

Paper chase

Prof Jacobs and his team first identified the vulnerability in a research paper that was due to be published in March 2008.

However, the release of the article was delayed after chip manufacturer NXP attempted to secure a court injunction against its publication.

The paper was finally released on Monday at the European Symposium on Research in Computer Security (Esorics) 2008 security conference held in Malaga, Spain.

Sensitive data stored on the Mifare Classic chip is protected by a unique number that acts as a key. When the chip, or a card bearing it, is placed near a reader it transmits and receives information based on its key. The security of the system depends on the key remaining secret.

In March Prof Jacobs and his colleagues discovered a flaw in the chip’s design which makes those keys easy to calculate and copy.

"Once we knew how the system worked and what the vulnerabilities were, it turned out to be very simple to actually clone cards, steal someone’s identity and enter a building as someone else", he said.

London Underground sign, BBC

The researchers travelled on the Tube using cloned cards

After making the discovery the researchers informed the Dutch government and the chip’s manufacturer, NXP.

When it knew about the research NXP moved to delay publication by seeking an injunction.

Steve Owen, vice president of sales and marketing – identification at NXP Semiconductors, told the BBC’s Click programme that it was motivated to take legal action to give its customers time to update their systems.

"We sought the injunction to cause a delay, not to completely stop the publication," he said.

Mr Owen recommends that the card alone should not be relied upon for secure access to buildings.

"We do not recommend the use of Mifare Classic for new installations," said Mr Owen. "We are working with customers to review their security."

Spot check

The Mifare Classic is widely used on many public transport systems including the Oyster card in London. The researchers say their security flaw can be used to copy cards. They claim to have even been able to adjust the amount of credit stored on a pre-pay card.

Earlier this year members of Prof Jacobs’s team visited London to test their findings, travelling on the London Underground using a modified Oyster card.

Shashi Verma, director of fares and ticketing at Transport For London, told the BBC its system spotted the security breach.

"We knew about it before we were informed by the students," said Mr Verma

He stressed that the Mifare Classic chip in the Oyster card is only part of a larger system. "A number of forensic controls run within the back office systems which is something that customers and these students have no ability to touch."

"We will carry on making improvements to the security of the Oyster system."

Speaking in July, security expert Bruce Schneier said: "As bad as the damage is from publishing – and there probably will be some – the damage is much, much worse by not disclosing."

Mr Schneier said it was a "dangerous assumption" to think that the researchers were the only ones that knew about weaknesses with Mifare.

"Assume organised crime knows about this, assume they will be selling it anyway," he said.

Commenting on the publication of their research, Prof Jacobs told Click the information being disclosed was: "not a guidebook for attacks".

This report will be broadcast in this week’s edition of Click on Saturday 11 October at 1130 BST on the BBC News Channel. It will also air on BBC World – check here for transmission times.

 

Also check this from Engadget:

Oyster Card RFID hack gets detailed

Londoners: Oyster Card's chip can be hacked for info - interesting
The vulnerability of cards based on the Mifare Classic RFID chip (like the Oyster Card used for the London Underground) has been known for some time now but, unsurprisingly, some pesky legal business has prevented the complete details from being published. That has now finally been cleared up, however, and Professor Bart Jacobs and his colleagues from Radboud University have promptly published their complete paper online. What’s more, NXP Semiconductors, makers of the Mifare chip, are also now commenting on the matter, and saying that it never intended to completely stop publication of the research, but rather that it simply wanted to give customers time to update their systems. NXP’s Steve Owen also adds that the company now doesn’t "recommend the use of Mifare Classic for new installations," and that it’s "working with customers to review their security." Those looking to dig in can find the paper at the link below and, in case you missed it the first time around, there’s a video explaining the basics after the break.

[Via BBC Click]

Here is a video:

Play video

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
5 Comments

NCR: Richard McBrien interview on “one issue” politics

NCR: Richard McBrien interview on "one issue" politicsThe increasingly cliche ultra-lefty National Catholic Reporter has an interview with the long-time Notre Dame University sourpuss dissenter Fr. Richard McBrien.

My emphases and comments.

Theologian says one issue bishops violate their own teaching
By tfox
Created 10/06/2008 – 19:48

By THOMAS C. FOX
Published:
October 7, 2008

Kansas City, Mo.

Bishops who make a case for one-issue politics or openly oppose a political candidate are in violation of the guidelines set out repeatedly in their own documents on political responsibility, said noted theologian [and plagiarist] Fr. Richard McBrien in a recent talk here.

McBrien of Notre Dame University, [Why is he still on the faculty?] author of a number of major works on Catholicism, including the recently published The Church: The Evolution of Catholicism, was speaking to an overflow, mostly Catholic audience of several hundred at a Unitarian Church in Kansas City, Mo. [Yah… that’s about right…]  His talk was hosted by a group of lay Catholics who run a speaking forum called “Topics to Go.”

In his talk, McBrien listed five Catholic principles, taken from Catholic teachings, that he said can be applied to the current political process.

1. Although bishops and other Catholic officials have the constitutional right to participate in public policy debates and in the political process generally, they impose certain limits upon themselves as a matter of prudence.

2. Catholic voters and their bishops should examine the positions of the candidates on the full range of issues as well as their integrity, philosophy and performance.  [This last Sunday I gave a sermon in which I made sure people knew to watch out for "code language" like "full spectrum" of Catholic teachings.  This language is used when people want to dissolve the "life" issue into a big soup of other issues, and thus down play its importance.]

3. Catholic voters and their bishops must not forget the distinction between moral principles and their application in the political order. It is possible to agree on an important moral principle and yet disagree, in good conscience, on the way that principle is applied in the political order.

4. Because there is a distinction between the moral law and the civil law, Catholics and others–-Christians and non-Christians alike – cannot expect that every element of the moral law, as they understand it, can or should [Really?  Votes decide that through their elected executives, legislators and, I suppose, judges.] be translated into civil law.

5. Given the principle of sacramentality, [?] in the final analysis the most effective way for the church and its members–-or for anyone–-to influence public policy is by force of their own example.  [Uh huh.  That might mean not vote… stay outside the process.  Or maybe "don’t make waves… go with the herd".  It seems not to mean, vote for the right position.  After all, trying to shape society is not in contradistinction to voting properly.]

McBrien cited a statement by the Administrative Board of the United States Catholic Conference issued in March 1984 titled, "Political Responsibility: Choices for the ’80s." In that statement the bishops wrote that they “specifically do not seek the formation of a religious voting bloc; nor do we wish to instruct persons on how they should vote by endorsing candidates.”   [But bishops and priests can and must instruct people about fundamental principles, including which issues have greatest importance.]

He said that following a 1984 attack by Cardinal John O’Connor on then Democratic vice-presidential candidate Congresswoman Geraldine Ferraro from the steps of St. Patrick’s Cathedral the bishops added the words “or opposing” after the word “endorsing.” This has been the policy of the U.S. bishops since, having been re-affirmed in statements of 1991, 1995, 1999, 2003 and 2007.  [BTW… remember that individual bishops are not bound by these statements of conferences.]

He cited last November’s election policy statement, which reads: “The consistent ethic of life provides a moral framework for principled Catholic engagement in political life and, rightly understood, neither treats all issues as morally equivalent nor reduces Catholic teaching to one or two issues. … Catholic voters should use the framework of Catholic teaching to examine candidates’ positions on issues affecting human life and dignity as well as issues of justice and peace …”

McBrien noted that the U.S. bishops’ policy was most recently reiterated in a letter to The New York Times that appeared Sept. 24, written by Bishops William Murphy of Rockville Centre, N.Y., and Nicholas DiMarzio of Brooklyn, N.Y.

The letter made the point that the bishops do not teach that abortion is the only issue, but that it is an issue of high moral importance, [only "high" importance?  What did the letter really say?  – See a comment below, where someone posted the what they wrote.] which nevertheless must be seen within the context of "the whole teaching of the church on justice and peace, serving the poor and advancing the common good …”  [Notice that this is the "full range" thing again.]

In a question and answer period, on a different subject, he asked the audience to imagine a scenario in which President Bush “were in office for life and that he had the authority to make appointments to the U.S. Supreme Court and throughout the federal court system at will, without even a U.S. Senate to hold hearings and vote on the nominees.”

“That’s exactly what Pope John Paul II — or any other pope for that matter — was able to do in his long term of office, and that is why the Catholic church finds itself today — and especially during the height of the sexual-abuse crisis in the priesthood — with such a dearth of pastoral leadership.”  [Incredible.  He just did two things.  First, he has argued that bishops should be elected by the people rather than appointed by a kind of dictator for life.  Second, he negatively criticized Pope John Paul for the type of bishops he appointed.]

McBrien said John Paul’s greatest failing, as pope, were the bishops he named. [See?] “Men were appointed bishops or promoted within the hierarchy on the basis of loyalty to the Holy See rather than on the basis of pastoral aptitude, theological sophistication and leadership skills.”  [Why is this guy still on the faculty of Notre Dame?]

McBrien added that he prefers Benedict XVI to John Paul II because of their difference in style. “Benedict tends to be laid-back and self-effacing, in contrast to John Paul II who usually occupied center stage, the theologian explained. “John Paul II tended to personalize the papacy to the point where agreeing or disagreeing with his devotional preferences, spirituality and theology became, for many inside and outside the Vatican, the touchstones of fidelity to Catholicism.”  [I don’t think that criticism is well-grounded.]

Fox is interim NCR executive editor

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
68 Comments

The “Mail from priests” category

WDTPRS has a new category:

Mail from priests

Some of the most interesting feedback and news I get is from priests (and bishops) who are readers.

I like to be able to share more mail from priests with WDTPRSers.

If you are a priest, I assure you that I will maintain your anonymity if you write to me.

However, if you are writing about what happened in a public event, such as a solemn Mass or what you said in your sermon on Sunday, I will probably talk about where it was and I will probably include names, etc.  After all, it was public.

But, Reverend and dear Fathers and brothers, I will keep your name and location out of the entries if you request it. 

The important thing is that you feel free to write in with your observations and reflections, news and insights.

I also hear from bishops from time to time.  If you ever want to say anything to this very wide readership, I will help.

Click here for my E-mail.  If you put something catchy in the subject line, such as "From Fr. …. to Fr. Z" I will spot it more quickly.

Keep in mind that I get an avalanche of e-mail as it is.  I might not use everything I get and I may not respond to your mail right away or at all, depending on how life is going.  You understand, I’m sure.

Also, a request to all WDTPRsers….

I would like to go back through posts from the past and add them to this category.  Will you help?   If you find a post that fits this category, will you send me the LINK?  Or maybe post it here below?  I can add the tags.

Many hands will make lighter work.

Someone took on and completed Sept 2008, btw.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
11 Comments

A newbie to the TLM writes with observations after which Fr. Z rants

From a reader (edited and with my emphases and comments.  This is very good for people who went to a celebration of the older form of Mass and had a hard time with it, who found it difficult to follow along.

Thank you for your blog keeping Catholics informed about the Traditional Latin Mass and the various issues surrounding it. I am 49 years old and though my memories of the TLM have long faded I have a very vivid recollection of the specific mass I attended as a child where reception of the Eucharist was changed from going up to the railing and kneeling to receive to lining up along the centre aisle of the church and receiving on the hand. (a silly story I won’t get into)
 
I have always desired to attend a TLM to "see what it would be like". I was away from my home in Halifax, NS this past weekend visiting Oswego, NY for a conference. While there, looking for a Church to attend for Sunday Mass, to my surprise I noticed that St. Marys Church offered a 1:00 pm TLM. I went.

I do not understand Latin. In spite of being provided with a good Latin/English missal I had a great deal of trouble following the mass. I did not know how to pronounce the responses. There was, as I have read in the past, parts of this mass that were said silently. (By the way the mass was said by Father Morisette and despite my ignorance it was evident even to me that it was very well done.)  [NB: The critical importance of the priest’s competence and also his style.]
 
I love this mass. It is so appropriate. [He didn’t understand it and had a hard time following it… but he got it anyway.  Read what’s next… ]  It’s not about me but God. I want to emphasize that my experience was not an emotional one (emotions can be passing and flighty) rather it was an experience of faith. Those who built this mass up centuries ago knew exactly what they were doing. The mass honours God the way He should be honoured. It brings to my mind the last part of Malachi 1:14 – "For I am a great king, says Yahweh Sabaoth, and among the nations my name inspires awe"  [A constant point of my writing and preaching and talking when I mention the point of any Mass is that it must produce "awe at transcendence", and encounter with mystery.]
 
As far as all of the difficulties mentioned above..I don’t mind! I can learn. The problems I encountered are not with the mass – they are with me. [Not the Mass.  That is humble.] I need to brush up on my faith and on the TLM and perhaps on Latin.
 
I live in the Halifax area of NS. We used to have a Latin Mass Society here. I don’t know if it is still around. To my knowledge there are no TLMs in my diocese…if there were any nearby I would start going. 

A good note.

No… a great note.

Folks, it is okay not to understand everything on the intellectual level.  There is also comprehension at a deeper level.

I wonder very often about what people really "get" from Mass when so many things have been simplified into order to increase "intelligibility" or to "aid comprehension".  

Sure, we gain something when we use the vernacular. 

But do we not also lose something? 

Something beyong the content of the prayers, which is of course also compromised in translation? 

Do we not lose also a sense that what is going on is important in a vital, mysterious, awesome, challenging, even frightening way?

What do the prayers really say? 
  There is a psychology to our worship as well.  Just as anything in human affairs, when you make something very familiar, you increase the risk of it not seeming important anymore.

I think people who are curious about the TLM, the older form of Mass, and who are perhaps afraid of it or anxious that they will not understand, should relax and perhaps let themselves be a little afraid. 

After all, these are sacred mysteries. 

This is an encounter with mysterium tremendens et fascinans.

Go ahead… be afraid, be very afraid.

Not in the sense of base fear, but of awe and reverence.

It’s okay not to understand everything.  It’s okay to be a little uncomfortable, for Mass to sieze you and take you where you would prefer not to go.

So often people require entertainment and distraction from the encounter with mystery, which is nothing other than a confrontation of the central mystery we face each day, namely, that even though our Lord rose from the dead, we still must die and pass to our judgments we know not how.  We are confident as Christians, and joyful at God’s promises, but this is a fearful mystery.

It is precisely what is being represented in Holy Mass.

It is okay not to understand it all. 

It is okay to be overcome with awe.  

It is okay to struggle with it.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
35 Comments

Synod – Day 2: some points

There were 23 5 minute interventions on the Second Day of the Synod.

Among the points made, these could be interesting.

The so-called biblia pauperum is still important.  "The bible of the poor", is comprised of non-literary works, such as icons, images, hymns, windows, etc.  These things are helps to lectio divina as well.

Some expressed a concern about "arbitary interpretations" of Scripture coming from some exegetes and from the media, especially having to do with films that have any biblical theme, or in non-scientific (scholarly) publications which can also confuse even priests.  It was repeated that in Latin America this is a problem.  Latin America has 43% of the Catholic faithful and in the last 40 years, the Church has lost 15% of her members.

Some want easier translations. 

A "general homiletic directory" for priests was proposed.  Homilies should not be boring.  [We need a Synod to help us with that?]  And should be "joyful".   [Oh really?  Always?] 

The 8 member post-Synodal committee was elected with Archbp. Ravasi as its head.  They will propose the themes from the Synod to the Holy Father.

UPDATE 20:50 GMT:

A curiosity: For those of you who care, you can call into the Holy See Press Office for an automated recording with a brief summary in Italian of some of the barebones of the day’s work of the Synod.

Yes, the sound quality (at least today) really was as bad as this.  But I expected little else.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
4 Comments

K of C’s: radio ad features heartbeat of 10-week-old unborn child

This is interesting:

Knights of Columbus airs pro-life ‘heartbeat’ radio ad

New Haven, Oct 6, 2008 / 08:25 pm (CNA).- A new Knights of Columbus radio spot featuring the heartbeat of a 10-week-old unborn child and urging listeners to vote pro-life has begun airing on radio stations around the U.S.

As the heartbeat plays, a woman’s voice says: “Listening to this makes me wonder – why would anyone question that her life has begun?”

“Vote your heart. Vote Pro-Life,” it concludes.

“The fact that the child whose heartbeat we hear is alive is simply a matter of science,” Supreme Knight Carl A. Anderson said in announcing the beginning of the ad campaign.

“We believe that it is vital that America’s pro-life community make it clear that they will reserve their votes for candidates of either party who are committed to protecting life from conception to natural death,” he continued.

The ad will be broadcast until the November 4 U.S. elections. A similar ad is planned for broadcast in Canada before the country’s October 14 election.

 

Kudos to my fellow Knights of Columbus.

Speaker Pelosi… Senator Biden… are you listening?

Catholic voters… are you listening?

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
9 Comments

A Sestri la “TLM” si costruisce “mattone su mattone”

In Italy there have been problems with the implementation of Summorum Pontificum, along the lines of what Msgr. Perl explained at a conference last month in Rome, despite the rosy picture painted by the new Archbishop of Florence and Secretary of the CEI (Italian Bishops Conference).

I picked up from the Papa Ratzinger Blog today news from an article in Il Secolo XIX good news about a TLM celebrated in Sestri Levante, in Liguria in the province of Genoa. 

A TLM was offered in the little church San Pietro in Vincoli, in the historic center of Sestri.  This was the first TLM there since Summorum Pontificum.  There were not so many younger people, as we tend to see in the US and England, but the place was full. 

Apparently the group had been rebuffed by various priests. The local bishop designated Fr. Mario Ostigoni, a priest from Chiavari, to say Mass for the people. 

Mattone su mattone, amici, mattone su mattone.

We need lots of patience and solidarity in prayer. 

Fast and pray for priests, that their hearts will soften and minds open.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
6 Comments

Pius XII’s baptismal font

You should check the photos of Pius XII stuff my friend John Sonnen has posted on his site Orbis Catholicus.  He always has interesting photos.

Pius XII's baptismal font

Pius XII's baptismal font

Here is the Rome font where the little Roman born baby, Eugenio Pacelli, received the Sacrament of Holy Baptism. The font is now located at the Carmelite parish of St. Pancrazio, in Rome.
 

San Pancrazio is up on the Gianicolo, next to the entrance to the Teresianum.  It is, if memory serves, the last of the Roman Stations after Easter, for Dominica in albis.  There are also catacombs there, but they are hard to visit.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
Comments Off on Pius XII’s baptismal font