Philadelphia Blognic – Sunday 21 Feb – 4-6 PM

[uc]

The best time for the Philadelphia Blognic II is Sunday, 21 February, in the afternoon from 4:00-6:00 pm.  

I made a slight change to accommodate those who want to attend Vespers at Mater Ecclesiae in Berlin, NJ.

The same location as last time: Irish Pub at 20th & Walnut in the Rittenhouse Square area.

That’s the score!   I hope some of you will be able to attend.  Happily it is a Sunday, so we will be able to relax a bit.

{democracy:45}

Posted in Blognics |
22 Comments

QUAERITUR: It is hard to learn the “Tridentine Mass”?

From a priest reader:

I’ve been a priest since 1984 and when I was ordained my bishop did not look favorably on the traditional Latin Mass.  Therefore my seminary training at St. Meinrad did not include any mention of the Tridentine Mass, other than the occasional joke about it.  I love to celebrate the Sacrifice of the Mass in English because I know what I am saying, but continue to be drawn to the traditional Latin Mass because of its solemnity, history and beauty.  My question to you is, how hard is it to learn to celebrate the Tridentine Mass?  I earned a "D" in Latin back in college, and have been told by a former Latin teacher to stick with English.  I don’t have a gift for languages.  For the past three years, during Lent in my parish, we have chanted the Pater Noster at Mass, and I still have to have the words in front of me.  I am not good at memorization.   I’ve seen two different workshops available, one offered by the Canons Regular of St. John Cantius and the other by the Priestly Fraternity of St. Peter.  Any recommendations?  Comments?

 

Thanks.  I am sure there are many priests who hesitate even to start because they think it must be really hard.

That said, it is sure going to be hard for some priests, but not impossible.

Think about it this way: there were many generations of men who learned how to say Mass who weren’t exactly rocket scientists.  Right?  If they did it, anyone can do it.

It helps a great deal to have strong Latin.  But a priest is to be idoneus, suitable, to say Mass.  He must have the minimum tools for Mass.  He must be able to pronounce the words properly, at the very least.  He doesn’t have to be a Latin expert. 

The workshops mentioned above are very good.  They will be able to steer you toward good tools.

Memorization is important, but not an absolute obstacle: that’s why we have books and altar cards on the altar!

It can be done.

Finally, you would also need to make it clear to any overly zealous trad lay people that if they decide to snipe at you from the pews because they think you didn’t wiggle your pinky finger the right way at the third comma according to the final authority in all things rubrical – their own recollection of how old Msgr. Guido O’Leary did that at St. Ipsidipsy in Tall Tree Circle when they were ten and following their authoritative St. Joseph Daily Missal – then they can just wait… and wait…. and wait … until the good is no longer the enemy of the perfect.

I think, dear Father, the best thing to do is just to start. 

Build it up, brick by brick, and you will find that it isn’t so hard as all that once you get used to it.

That said, I invite PRIESTS to chime in with their comments about learning to say the TLM.

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Brick by Brick, Mail from priests |
13 Comments

Vatican’s top 10 albums for a desert island (not making this up, I swear)

I wonder if this list was vetted by Pope Benedict… from the increasingly weird L’Osservatore Romano, via CNA:

‘Thriller’ makes Vatican list of top 10 albums

Vatican City, Feb 19, 2010 / 12:36 pm (CNA).- The Holy See’s newspaper has released its picks for the "top ten" albums "to take to a desert island."  Among the selections are works from the Beatles, Pink Floyd and Michael Jackson’s "Thriller."  [This list doesn’t date any of their thinkers, does it.]

Offering a list of favorites as "musical resistance" to the "growing tide of festival songs" released at this time of year in Italy, the Vatican paper, L’Osservatore Romano (LOR), suggests that its own "modest manual can indicate the way of good music."  [Really… I didn’t make this up.]

The Beatles’ "Revolver" is "definitely the first work to recommend," notes the Vatican daily.  [?! I like the album.  Really, I do… but… is this what I want on a desert island?] The paper then cites some of its tracks which "anticipate the rock revolution represented by Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band" and still today manage to produce "goosebumps."  [ROFL!]

Pink Floyd’s disc, "Dark Side of the Moon" is "extraordinarily enjoyable" and the words, described as "extremely beautiful," don’t come anywhere close to giving it justice, LOR states.

Michael Jackson’s "Thriller," the Vatican paper continues, is a "masterpiece of the king of pop,” precisely because Jackson added his innovative style to the previously-stereotyped “black music.”  [You can’t make this stuff up.]

The article is the latest from LOR in a list of commentaries on elements of popular culture, covering everything from disappointment in the "stale" plot of Avatar to praise for The Simpsons’ "realistic and intelligent writing," although the newspaper deplored the "excessively rude language, violence and extreme choices by the scriptwriters" in the series.

Rounding out the list of musical favorites "to take to a desert island" are albums from Paul Simon, Oasis, Santana and U2, as well as discs from Donald Fagen, Fleetwood Mac and David Crosby.

 

Okay… fun playlist.  I am eclectic as any (with the exception, I think of Michael Jackson in any form)… but… this?

Respondeo dicendum:  Let’s load these up on the Holy Father’s iPod and see what his reaction is.

Posted in Lighter fare | Tagged
58 Comments

A couple useful chant links

In previous weeks I have been saying that Gregorian chant just isn’t that hard and that it can be introduced in parish worship.  It really must be in cathedrals and major churches, right?

My friend Jeffrey Tucker over at NLM and of Sacred Music has a couple interesting and useful posts.

Sing the Offertory During Lent

Finally, a great tutorial CD for chant

 

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes | Tagged ,
5 Comments

From the LCWR: Lenten Carbon Fast 2010 Calendar (not making this up)

STAGE DIRECTION:  Rod Serling enters from stage left, turns to the camera:

"Consider reason #6475 why the Holy began an Apostolic Visitation of women religious in the United States of America."

From a reader:

Sometimes I wonder if I am in another dimension…

The Archdiocese of Washington Environmental Outreach Committee (why do we need this) and the [wait for it…] Leadership Conference of Women Religious have [this gets better…] a Lenten Carbon Fast 2010 Calendar advising on how we can all be neo pagans…er, take "40 carbon fasting actions we can consider part of our lenten preparations."

CLICK HERE FOR A PDF

Even more ridiculous, it’s administered with the help of the Greater Washington Interfaith Power and Light, an "ecumenical" effort to find an "authentic religious response to climate change." (read the first comment here from a representative)

I sent an email asking the diocese if they really thought that this was an authentic and reasonable response to the Holy Fathers call in Caritas in Veritate for responsible stewardship while avoiding "neo paganism or pantheism" by putting nature before humans (not to mention souls).

I just think, living in a diocese where you know many are not availing themselves of the sacraments and do not believe in the True Presence, this is worse than a distraction from Lent, it’s nearly a religion in itself.

They just don’t see how silly that all is, do they.

Posted in Lighter fare | Tagged
32 Comments

QUAERITUR: can lay people bless ashes?

From a priest reader:

I had occasion to witness an Ash Wednesday liturgy at [a boy’s school] in [___].  As there was no priest planning to be available, the liturgy was conducted by teachers and students.  After some readings, the students were invited to extend their hands and to pray a prayer of blessing over the ashes which were then put on the foreheads of the students by other students.

Am I wrong in thinking that there is nothing in Catholic theology to justify a blessing of ashes on Ash Wednesday by  a group of laypersons?

No, Father, I do not think you are wrong.  Lay people can’t bless in that manner and it was abusive to give them the impression that they could. 

I suppose that in the absence of a priest if the students were going to do things with ashes, careful explanations should have been given about what sacramentals are, what priests do, the difference between the priesthood of priests and of the baptized, etc.

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
12 Comments

Repeal of ‘don’t ask, don’t tell’ and military chaplains

For those priests and seminarians out there considering military chaplaincy during this administration…

From CNA with my emphases and comments:

Repeal of ‘don’t ask, don’t tell’ could affect military chaplains’ religious freedom

Washington D.C., Feb 19, 2010 / 07:49 am (CNA).- Proposed changes [?!?  How about: "Pres. Obama’s State of the Union Address announcement about…] allowing homosexuals to serve openly in the military could marginalize military chaplains from religions which consider homosexual acts sinful, a religious liberty group has warned.

Alliance Defense Fund (ADF) Senior Counsel Kevin Theriot said that if the military is forced to promote homosexual behavior [which is the right way to put this, by the way] there will be “open conflict between the virtues taught by chaplains and the moral message delivered by the military.”

“In such a conflict, it’s obvious who will win and who will lose,” Theriot claimed. “If the state favors the demands of the homosexual activists over the First Amendment, it is only a matter of time before the military censors the religious expression of its chaplains and marginalizes denominations that teach what the Bible says about homosexual behavior.”

A Feb. 17 letter from the ADF to President Barack Obama and Secretary of Defense Robert M. Gates lists many possible conflicts centering on whether chaplains could sincerely adhere to their religious beliefs and still conscientiously preach and counsel while serving as military chaplains.

Problems may arise concerning whether chaplains must allow soldiers who openly engage in homosexual behavior to lead worship services [ugh] or to serve in other lay leadership roles. Another concern for the ADF is whether chaplains may make public statements critical of homosexual behavior or military policy on the issue.

The ADF cited previous civilian conflicts between religious liberty and laws concerning homosexual behavior.

“Military chaplains who have volunteered to defend the liberties protected in our Constitution shouldn’t be denied those very same liberties,” Theriot argued.

He warned that forcing chaplains to “deny the teachings of their faith” in order to serve in the armed forces is a “grave threat” to the First Amendment and to the spiritual health of those in military service.

“We urge you to reconsider your decision and avoid this collision with America’s most cherished and fundamental freedom of religious liberty,” the ADF letter stated.

Posted in Our Catholic Identity, The future and our choices | Tagged
21 Comments

Musing on Summorum Pontificum

I noticed in John Zmirak’s article on "trads" that he picked up on a phrase I have been using for quite a while regarding Benedict XVI’s Motu Proprio Summorum Pontificum.  I have been calling SP Pope Benedict’s "emancipation proclamation".

Zmirak wrote in his piece that "many of our bishops answered it with liturgical Jim Crow."

I guess that means that those who don’t want to implement Summorum Pontificum "segregationists".

Posted in Our Catholic Identity, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM | Tagged , ,
17 Comments

A great Lenten observation by Fr. Blake

Great phrase from Fr. Blake of St. Mary Magdalen in Brighton:

"Lent is not an orgy of Pelagian self improvement"

Posted in LENT | Tagged
16 Comments

“broadcast” to “narrowcast”

In the National Catholic Register (which you can distinguish from the other NCR because the Register is Catholic), there is an offering by our friend and recent recipient of a WDTPRS coffee mug Fr. Dwight Longenecker about priests and blogs… something I believe I know a little about.

Fr. Longenecker makes a good distinction, which it is useful to repeat here.  He is talking about the how older forms of social communication connect with people compared to newer forms:

The term “broadcast” applies to “casting the net” [The image Pope John Paul used when speaking about the use of the internet.] as well as the simple method of sowing seeds by casting them wide across the field. While these images work well for traditional broadcasting, we should be aware of the fundamental shift that is going on within the world of media.

The shift is from “broadcast” to “narrowcast.” Put simply, the old method of publishing — radio, television and film production — was to produce the work and then send it out to the widest possible audience. It was expensive to produce a book, a radio show, a movie or television program, so the producer had to distribute his work to a vast audience in order to make a profit.

Technology now allows us to “narrowcast” instead of “broadcast.” Anyone can produce a “radio show.” It’s called a podcast, and it costs virtually nothing.
I can produce video clips just by talking to my laptop, which has a built-in camera and microphone. I can produce leaflets and articles and distribute all of this material instantly to a global audience through the Internet.
While broadcasters distributed widely to a comparatively local audience, narrowcasters distribute globally to a narrow audience.  [While this is certainly true in the case of most bloggers, some are using those same simple tools but are able to reach a very large "field" or "catch" indeed.  So, this doesn’t have to be perceived as a narrow audience.]

This shift means that audiences for all forms of Internet media are selecting not only what they want to view, read and listen to, but also when they want view, read and listen. [While they always have, this is a good point.  There is so much out there, and it is so much easier to get at from the desktop or a phone, people are choosing what works for them within the parameters of their time and interest.  Think about how TV was 40 years ago.  There were a very few channels… and mostly nothing on.  Now there are zillions, and mostly nothing on.  But you can choose your nothing from a greater range.  I am facetious, but you get my drift.   Talk radio changed radio. The phenomenon of cable news and satellite dishes has changed news.  The blogsophere is another effect.  Alternative media are very influential.] This is a very important distinction, and one that impacts how priests should use the Internet for evangelization.

Posted in The Drill | Tagged , , , , ,
7 Comments