Card. Heenan from across the decades

Let’s bump this up:

A friend told me about this quote. So, I looked it up!

Cardinal Heenan addressed the Synod the day after the experimental Mass had been presented and said he did not know the names of those who had proposed the new Mass but it was clear to him that few of them had ever been parish priests.

"At home," he said, "it is not only women and children but also fathers of families and young men who come regularly to Mass. If we were to offer them the kind of ceremony we saw yesterday we would soon be left with a congregation of women and children."

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
97 Comments

Expert consultation needed: what is this thing?

One of the great things about having so many readers for this blog, is the vast range of expertise you can bring in when interesting topics arise.

And so, people with some experience of silver can help me with this.

What is this thing?

Expert consultation needed: what is this thing?

I spotted it in a flea market when walking around today.

Expert consultation needed: what is this thing?

Does it have something to do with keeping toast or some other breakfasty bready thing warm and perhaps carrying on a service tray?

Expert consultation needed: what is this thing?

What is this for and what is it called?

Expert consultation needed: what is this thing?

Anyone?

Posted in Just Too Cool |
24 Comments

QUAERITUR: priest consecrating the people during Mass?

From a reader:

I thought I had heard it all until—
 
I attended a Mass tonight during which the priest said:
 
"Tonight, Lord, we offer You these people and these gifts… we ask you to bless them and make them holy…. so that they might become… the Body and Blood… of Our Lord Jesus Christ."  He motioned towards the congregation with the words "these people" and towards the unconsecrated bread and wine with "and these gifts…"
 
I hope that the priest was not trying to "consecrate" the people…  but from the logic of this sentence, that’s what it sounded like.
 
What do you make of this?  Is this a liturgical abuse?  What, if anything, can be done about it?

 

Priests don’t consecrate people at the consecration during Holy Mass.  Priests consecrate the bread and the wine for the people, who in their turn are uniting themselves to what the priest is doing.

Yes, that strange interpolation is a liturgical abuse. 

The priest had a text provided for him in the book.  He chose instead to make something up on his own, at the most important part of Mass.   He violated your right to have a Mass celebrated according to your rite.  Furthermore, he created confusion by what he did.

If he regularly says this, I would have a discussion with the pastor of the parish, if that priest is not the pastor.  Otherwise, I would write to the bishop. 

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
26 Comments

The Met: Cloisters edition

Did you know that The Cloisters provides air conditioning? Here is a detail of a Spanish altarpiece of the late 15th c.

The Met: Cloisters edition

Theodosius arriving at Ephesus, in a series about The Seven Sleepers from Rouen about 1200.

The Met: Cloisters edition

If only … Spanish crucifix c. 1200. Virgin and Child in Majesty c. 1100.

The Met: Cloisters edition

Bee on Fuller’s Teasel. (next to Our Lady’s Bedstraw)

The Met: Cloisters edition

Espaliered Pear

The Met: Cloisters edition

Posted in On the road, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
8 Comments

Saturday Morning Manhattan Blognic Underway!

We have gathered at Think Coffee on Mercer.

Nice and calm compared to the other day!

So far 6 here.

Saturday Morning Manhattan Blognic Underway!

A couple more have joined.  Nice and quiet!

Saturday Morning Manhattan Blognic Underway!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
7 Comments

A Met afternoon

To stay cool I have returned for while this afternoon to the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

A Met afternoon

The American Tobacco Company issue of the legendary Honus Wagner in the “White Borders” series (1909-10)

A Met afternoon

A crozier head of ivory from Lombardy c. 1350-1375.

Fit for a S. African Bishop!

A Met afternoon

Some German glass from 1444:

A Met afternoon

A lovely young woman who died c. AD 120-140 in Egypt.

A Met afternoon

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
5 Comments

FINAL: Saturday morning 10 JULY Manhattan BLOGNIC

I have found a place for the blognic for Saturday morning.FINAL: Saturday morning 10 JULY Manhattan BLOGNIC

9:30-11:30 am (I may get there a little early)
Think Coffee
248 Mercer Street
(between 3rd and 4th Streets)
New York, NY

They have three locations so be sure to go to the MERCER shop.

Please add a comment in the combox. 

{democracy:72}

Posted in Blognics, SESSIUNCULA |
11 Comments

Another attempt to juxtapose ordination of women and clerical abuse of children

The managing editor of the liberal U.S. Catholic needs some aggiornamento.

In this editorial piece, he almost gets it right.  He does pretty well until he gets to the end where he lurches into a total failure.

Let’s have a look with my emphases and comments:

Sex abuse and women’s ordination?
Friday, July 9, 2010
By Bryan Cones

Great news from the Vatican, according to Catholic News Service: New norms against the sexual abuse of children will double length of time a victim has to bring charges from 10 to 20 years after the victim’s 18th birthday. It will also extend the penalties for sexual abuse of children to those who abuse the mentally disabled.

Bad news: The new norms will simultaneously add to the list of grave offenses against the sacrament of holy orders the "attempted ordination of women." Seriously? [Yes… seriously.  And there are reasons for this.  But does he have reasons? We’ll soon find out!]

Why is that bad? First, the "attempted ordination of women" already brings with it automatic excommunication, so making it one of the "delicta graviora" is redundant. Second, it conflates two completely separate issues, and in effect, or at least in the minds of many people who will read the news, seems to equate the "attempted ordination of women" with the rape and torture of children.

Quite frankly, it is an outrage to pair the two, a complete injustice to connect the aspirations of some women among the baptized to ordained ministry with what are some of the worst crimes that can be committed against the least of Christ’s members.  [woah… he is going off the rails…]
 
Furthermore, if I were a member or supporter of the Roman Catholic Womenpriests movement, I would be opening a bottle of champagne right now. The Vatican has in effect given legitimacy and momentum to what is still an incredibly tiny movement with this clumsy legal manuver, tantamount to the United States dropping a nuclear weapon on Luxembourg–only more ridiculous because this will do absolutely no damage to women’s ordination movement. It is more like a gift. None of those women are afraid of excommunication any longer; indeed, it is now the Vatican that appears fearful. [Okay, there’s a point. Nevertheless, there is need for a procedure to deal with the cases.  Furthermore, he seems to be criticizing something he has not yet seen.  I wonder if the new procedures are intended to deal with priests who support the women’s ordination thingy, rather than with the wymyn themselves.]

This decision boggles the mind: The faithful have been justly demanding for nearly a decade clear guidelines for dealing with the sexual abuse of children, along with just punishments for both offenders and bishops who have abetted these crimes. What we have gotten is half of what we have been asking for (still no sanctions for bishops), [good point] along with a completely unconnected and unnecessary [?] condemnation of the ordination of women. [And here he falls apart completely…] This is especially ironic given that many Catholics, and I include myself among them, see the absence of women in positions of power in the church as a contributor to the ongoing sex abuse crisis. [FAIL!]

This move is a mistake, plain and simple, imprudent at best, at worst a serious further blow to Rome’s already damaged credibility.

Along the way he made some good points, and people may argue about them.

But, he does not seem to realize that the there is now mounting evidence of sexual abuse of children by women.  SNAP, as a matter of fact, has been after the LCWR to work with them.  The LCWR has been stone-walling SNAP.

Read THIS.

If he thinks that having women in positions of power would have curtailed the abuse of children by those in power, he is dreaming.

Keep your eye on SNAP and the LCWR.  One day we will see SNAP protesting outside meetings of the LCWR…. and for good reason.  I look forward to US Catholic covering that story, alongside the reporters of the National Catholic Fishwrap and America.

Posted in Clerical Sexual Abuse, The Drill |
19 Comments

South African Bishop stands against Benedict XVI’s restoration of the Church

South African Bishop stands against Benedict XVI's restoration of the ChurchThe National Catholic Fishwrap reproduced on its site a talk given by South African Bishop Kevin Dowling (about whom WDTPRS has written before).  I think they were especially interested to support Bp. Dowling’s talk, because he attacks what he called "restorationism". 

He doesn’t like the path Pope Benedict, especially, has set us on.  (He doesn’t really distinguish very well between John Paul’s and Benedict’s pontificate, by the way, and we are not surprised.)

As for the context, Bishop Dowling gave the talk to a sympathetic group and thought he was off the record.  This talk, therefore, reflects his real thinking, and the thinking of a still large group in the Church.

There is so much in this talk that is just plain wrong it is too hard here to interject all points we would require. Let’s take just two points from His Excellency’s talk and drill at them for a bit.

Here is a central point of His Excellency’s talk, to save you some time:

“The Southern Cross [South Africa’s weekly Catholic newspaper] about 3 or 4 weeks ago published a picture of Bishop Slattery with his "cappa magna". For me, such a display of what amounts to triumphalism in a church torn apart by the sexual abuse scandal, is most unfortunate.”

We must respond: Episcopal miters are medieval in origin, too, Excellency. So are the bishops’ rings, crosiers and coats-of-arms.

You use all three.

Do you feel “triumphalistic” when you think of the sexual abuse scandal during Mass?

Perhaps while you’re at it, you’d like to tell Eastern Rite Catholics and Eastern Orthodox hierarchs to simplify their vesture as well? They use crowns!

And don’t forget the Archbishop of Canterbury and all the women Anglican bishops!!

A second point… and I think this is what is going to permit His Excellency to experience at first hand an examination by the CDF of his … notions:  Bp. Dowling doesn’t seem to think that the Church exercises its teaching Magisterium unless through an Ecumenical Council.  Perpend:

Lest we do not highlight sufficiently this important fact. Vatican II was an ecumenical council, i.e., a solemn exercise of the magisterium of the church, i.e. the college of bishops gathered together with the bishop of Rome and exercising a teaching function for the whole church. In other words, its vision, its principles and the direction it gave are to be followed and implemented by all, from the pope to the peasant farmer in the fields of Honduras.

Since Vatican II there has been no such similar exercise of teaching authority by the magisterium. Instead, a series of decrees, pronouncements and decisions which have been given various "labels" stating, for example, that they must be firmly held to with "internal assent" by the Catholic faithful, but in reality are simply the theological or pastoral interpretations or opinions of those who have power at the centre of the church. They have not been solemnly defined as belonging to the "deposit of the faith" to be believed and followed, therefore, by all Catholics, as with other solemnly proclaimed dogmas. For example, the issues of celibacy for the priesthood and the ordination of women, withdrawn even from the realm of discussion. Therefore, such pronouncements are open to scrutiny — to discern whether they are in accord, for example, with the fundamental theological vision of Vatican II, or whether there is indeed a case to be made for a different interpretation or opinion.

Let’s see.  There are some doctrinal questions to be asked about His Excellency’s positions.

Just for an example I recall Ordinatio sacerdotalis, by which John Paul II definitely clarified that the Church has no authority to ordain women.  It was later clarified by the Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith that the teaching of Ordinatio sacerdotalis is part of the deposit of faith.

Then also does His Excellency really believe that the teaching of a Council overrules or places constraints on the teaching authority of the Pope?   So it would seem.

Should the Bishop need to pick up some extra miters and rings, along with his inevitable frequent flier miles, the shop Euroclero is directly across the street from the Palazzo Sant’Uffizio.

Play video

Posted in Our Catholic Identity, SESSIUNCULA, The Drill, Throwing a Nutty | Tagged , , ,
32 Comments

Archbp. Carlson: “You cannot be “pro-choice” (pro-abortion) and remain a Catholic in good standing”

Catholic politicians who promote abortion should not receive Holy Communion.

In the Saint Louis Review of the Archdiocese of St. Louis, His Excellency Most Reverend Robert J. Carlson has laid it on the line.

My emphases and comments.

Good Catholics cannot be pro-choice; The Fifth Commandment demands respect for life as God’s most precious gift

Submitted on July 06, 2010

By Archbishop Robert J. Carlson

God’s law in the Old Testament is clear and unambiguous: You shall not kill. Jesus is even more demanding: Every one who is angry is liable to judgment. [Hmmm… I think this a qualification: there is proper anger as well, as demonstrated perfectly by the Lord from time to time.  He is not subject to judgment for having been angry with the money-changers.  But… we know what H.E. means!]

Sins against the Fifth Commandment are easy to commit. Any time we think, speak or act out of anger or hatred or jealousy or revenge, we abuse God’s commandment that we respect His most precious gift, the gift of life — especially human life.

Human life is sacred because, from its beginning until its natural end, it involves the creative action of God. The Fifth Commandment forbids direct and intentional killing as gravely sinful. God alone is the Lord of life. No one has the right to end arbitrarily what God has begun, and sustained, through the gift of His love.

In the account of Abel’s murder by Cain (Genesis 4:8-12), Scripture reveals the presence of anger and envy in humankind, consequences of original sin, from the beginning of recorded history. God declares this as wicked, and He asks the question to be answered over the ages: "What have you done?" Today this question is asked not only of those who kill someone, but also of those responsible for violence, anger, hatred and vengeance in any form.

It is a shame that there are so many violent words expressed between members of the same family day in and day out. Anger and intolerance are also pervasive in our Church and in society. Such attitudes are destructive and sinful. They are of the Evil One and not of God.

The Fifth Commandment does not stop someone from self defense, because someone who defends his or her own life is not guilty of murder. Legitimate defense can be not only a right but also a grave duty for someone responsible for another’s life, the common good of the family or the security of a nation. We risk our lives to protect ourselves and others because we value human life and freedom so dearly. They are gifts from God that we are bound to cherish and defend.

Since the first century, the Church has addressed the moral evil of abortion and the killing of a defenseless baby in the womb. People who are casual about the sin of abortion and [Here we go!] who choose to view it as a political issue rather than the serious moral issue that it is are guilty of violating the Fifth Commandment. [AND….] You cannot be "pro-choice" (pro-abortion) and remain a Catholic in good standing. That’s why the Church asks those who maintain this position not to receive holy Communion. We are not being mean or judgmental, we are simply acknowledging the fact that such a stance is objectively and seriously sinful and is radically inconsistent with the Christian way of life.  [And, if Communion should not be received, it should not be given.]

The Fathers of the Second Vatican Council said, "God, the Lord of life, has entrusted to men the noble mission of safeguarding life, and human life must be protected with the utmost care from the moment of conception: Abortion and infanticide are abominable crimes" ("Gaudium et Spes," No. 51.3). [People forget about that citation.  Don’t forget it!] That’s why formal cooperation in an abortion constitutes a grave offense. The Church attaches the canonical penalty of excommunication to this crime against human life (see canons 1398,1314, and 1323-1324).

The Fifth Commandment also directs us to work for justice and peace — avoiding war whenever possible — and to limit the use of capital punishment to the most extreme (and rare) circumstances required to protect human life. Only God has the right to take the life of another human being. When we take that action into our own hands — in self-defense or in defense of others — we had better be sure that all other options have been exhausted!

In addition, euthanasia or deliberately taking of the life of someone who is sick, dying, disabled or mentally ill is morally unacceptable. The Church calls for the ordinary care owed to a sick person, but medical procedures that are burdensome, dangerous or extraordinary are not necessary. If you are unsure about the moral implications of health care procedures that are being proposed for someone you love, contact your pastor or the archdiocese’s Respect Life Apostolate.  [I don’t think the sister hospital administrator in Phoenix sought counsel from the Diocese of Phoenix.] They will be happy to help you consider approaches that are in accordance with our Church’s teaching about care for those who are sick or dying.

Taking proper care of our health, respecting others and showing respect for the dead are all matters covered by the Fifth Commandment’s demand that we reverence God’s most precious gift — human life.

 

WDTPRS kudos to Archbp. Carlson!

This is part of the effort toward the "new evangelization".

Posted in Emanations from Penumbras, New Evangelization, Our Catholic Identity, The Drill | Tagged
21 Comments