The dumbest thing about excommunication I have seen to date

I think it was CMR which suggested that NCR’s piece on excommunication might be the stupidest thing you read today.  I stress today. (NCR is sure to writer about it again some time.)

It is hard to imagine that a writer can get so many things wrong in one article, but St. Louis U’s Ronald Modras has changed the height of the bar.

Lemme save you some time and make two little points.

First, liberal NCR types would have you believe that excommunication is outdated, silly, ineffective, irrelevant… take your pick.

But if excommunications are so irrelevant, why did they throw a nutty when the Pope lifted an excommunication of an SSPX bishop?

Furthermore, the Modras offers this:

Are Catholics ever allowed to see abortion as the lesser of two evils? In the face of such moral dilemmas, the automatic excommunication is intended to leave no doubt as to where the church’s leadership stands. Whether that lessens the number of abortions is at least doubtful.

Doubtful?  Ummm… does anyone seriously think that the number if abortions would not rise if the Catholic Church were to change its stand about abortion or give the impression that it was changing its stance by doing away with excommunication as a penalty?

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
18 Comments

The Feeder Feed and Penjing Report

Another dimension of the feeder….

Mr. Grosbeak paying attention to junior.

The Feeder Feed and Penjing ReportThe Feeder Feed and Penjing Report

Please help feed the birds.  They are on short commons right now.

PENJING REPORT
Some first aid followed by benign neglect have served to bring Penjing back from the edge of the grave.

I returned to find Penjing positively thriving, as are Irohamomiji and Penzai.

The Feeder Feed and Penjing Report

The Feeder Feed and Penjing Report

The Feeder Feed and Penjing Report

Posted in SESSIUNCULA, The Feeder Feed | Tagged
10 Comments

If only they could get that partnership on track!

Which of these pairs doesn’t belong:

  1. Pope John XXIII – Pres. KennedyIf only they could get that partnership on track!
  2. Pope John Paul II – Pres. Reagan
  3. Pope Benedict XVI – Pres. Obama

In his piece called "Obama and Benedict: A partnership delayed, but not yet denied", Allen is trying with all his might to push a nexus between Pres. Obama and Pope Benedict as if they were somehow comparable to Reagan and John Paul II. 

But here is the interesting paragraph you probably missed this because you were probably still laughing:

Obama seems anxious to move the ball on other elements of his agenda, at least some of which (such as immigration reform) create the possibility of common cause, not conflict, with the bishops. The White House has an eye on both the 2010 and 2012 elections, when the 67 million Catholics in America will once again be “in play.” Senior Vatican officials, meanwhile, are anxious to show that the papacy has not been paralyzed by the sexual abuse crisis. (Gian Maria Vian, the editor of L’Osservatore Romano, told me this week in Rome that one reason the paper has not devoted a tremendous amount of space to the subject is because they don’t want to seem obsessed with it.)

Does this look like collusion to frame the relationship between Pres. Obama and Pope Benedict in closer terms than the rest of the world would want to imagine?

Cui prodest?

Apparently, both Pres. Obama and Pope Benedict have been too "distracted over the past twelve months" by other things to get to work on that partnership they surely want.

Pope Benedict is so overwhelmed with the sex abuse crisis that he is now writing his third book on the Lord before the second is even translated.

Pres. Obama is so overwhelmed with oil gushers and immigration and jobs that he has had to cut down his golf time. 

Neither of them have the time to pick up that darn phone and make that call!

 If only they could get that partnership on track!

Posted in SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
23 Comments

Of Radio D.J.’s, chainsaws, and an abortion clinic in Rockford

This is from LifeSite about the abortion clinic in Rockford, IL, about which WDTPRS has posted before (here and here).  The people who run this clinic are particularly creepy.

My emphases and comments.

Abortion Clinic Owner Responds with Chainsaw as Radio Blares: ‘God Bless Pro-Lifers!’

By Kathleen Gilbert

ROCKFORD, Illinois, July 9, 2010 (LifeSiteNews.com) – Staff at the Rockford abortion mill, which has been blaring the radio through its speakers to drown out pro-life counselors for several weeks, got an unpleasant surprise Friday morning when a local D.J. found out what his show was being used for.

LifeSiteNews.com has reported numerous times on the bizarre Rockford abortuary, which has taken to taunting pro-life witnesses with signage and other paraphernalia mocking Christianity and Jesus Christ, and even directing personal insults at local pro-lifers. (See coverage here)

The facility’s latest form of harassment, blasting a radio talk show through its outdoor speakers to keep women from hearing the message of pro-life counselors gathered outside, backfired when D.J. Doug McDuff’s scheduled talk show guest cancelled, and he opened the phone lines for comment. [Excellent.]

Seeing his chance, Rockford pro-life veteran Kevin Rilott whipped out his cell phone and was on air within seconds, loud and clear outside the abortion centre where he was standing. Rilott took the opportunity to explain to McDuff and his listeners how the radio station, WNTA, was being used to silence pro-lifers’ attempt to help mothers in need. [God bless the creator of cellphones!]

McDuff, none too pleased, decided to take matters into his own hands. "God bless pro-lifers! God bless pro-lifers! God bless pro-lifers!" the D.J. shouted. [!]

One of the staff members, who was walking from across the parking lot at that moment, was so aghast, Rilott told LifeSiteNews.com, that "I thought she was going to have a heart attack."

"The abortion mill nurse who heard this began waving her arms around her head like she couldn’t believe what was being broadcast over the abortion mill public address system," related Rilott. "The look of almost terror and confusion on her face was priceless as she scrambled into the mill."

The D.J. then gave Rilott airtime to explain how those who keep vigil outside the Rockford mill come "to offer love, help, and hope to mothers in need," and to request prayer for mothers in need and an end to abortion.

[But wait! There’s more!] The landlord of the abortion mill, still determined to drown out both the radio and the pro-lifers, charged outdoors with a chainsaw running. [!] But even that was not enough to prevent at least one mother from hearing the message and choosing life for her baby.  [Do you suppose the chainsaw might also have had an influence on that decision?]

Rilott said that a woman who had entered the clinic earlier in the morning left after the incident, before the abortionist arrived for the day. "She certainly heard it inside the clinic, and when she left she gave us a big smile and thumbs-up, and she left before the abortionists arrived," he told LSN. "So it was a good day."

 

 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
19 Comments

Archbp. Gill Hellin (Spain) calls for civil disobedience of new abortion law

From CNA, which does a good job reporting news where Spanish is spoken:

Spanish archbishop calls for civil disobedience of new abortion law

Madrid, Spain, Jul 13, 2010 / 01:11 pm (CNA).- Archbishop Francisco Gil Hellin of Burgos warned this week there is no right to kill an innocent human being and therefore no obligation to obey to the new law on abortion. Rather, “direct opposition without distinction” must be mounted, he said.
 
“Let’s be clear: this law is not a law, although it is presented as such by some politicians and lawmakers.  It is no law because nobody has the right to take the life of an innocent human being. For this reason it is not obligatory.  Moreover, it demands direct opposition without distinction,” the archbishop said in a letter.
 
He underscored that reason cannot recognize abortion as a right because it constitutes the killing “of a person who is not guilty.”  “The right of a person to exist who has already been conceived, although not yet born, is not a belief stemming from any religion.  One does not need to be a believer to hold that an innocent person has the right to be defended and respected in his or her integrity.  Common sense dictates that one cannot take a human life in order to solve another problem or to “get money or votes,” he said.
 
The archbishop went on to say it is a “fallacy to assert that this law was passed by a majority in Parliament and that it represents the will of the majority of citizens, or if the Constitutional Court upholds it, that opposing it would be disobedient and would warrant sanction.”
 
“The fallacy consists in giving politicians, judges or citizens a right they do not have.  And nobody has the right to legislate the killing of an innocent person,” Archbishop Gil Hellin said.  He urged Spaniards to help all mothers who are in difficult situations and to support motherhood “with all the means at our disposal” in order to “halt this plague of abortion that, in Spain alone has already destroyed more people than all those who live in the cities of Zaragoza, Cordoba and Burgos.”

 

I wonder what His Excellency would say to openly Catholic politicians who vote for such laws and who then present themselves for Holy Communion.

Kudos to Archbishop Gil Hellin.

Posted in Emanations from Penumbras | Tagged ,
13 Comments

King Arthur’s Round Table identified?

King Arthur's Round Table identified?From The Daily Mail:

King Arthur’s Round Table ‘found’ – except it’s not a table, but a Roman amphitheatre in Chester

By Nigel Blundell

His is among the most enduring ­legends in our island’s history.

King Arthur, the gallant warrior who gathered his knights around the  Round Table at Camelot and rallied Christian Britons against the invading pagan Saxons, has always been an enigma.

But now historians believe they have uncovered the precise location of Arthur’s stronghold, finally solving the riddle of whether the Round Table really existed.

And far from pinpointing a piece of furniture, they claim the ‘table’ was in fact the circular space inside a former Roman amphitheatre.

The experts believe that Camelot could in fact have been Chester Amphitheatre, a huge stone-and-wood structure capable of holding up to 10,000 people.

They say that Arthur would have reinforced the building’s 40ft walls to create an imposing and well fortified base.

The king’s regional noblemen would have sat in the central arena’s front row, with lower-ranked subjects in the outer stone benches.

Arthur has been the subject of much historical debate, but many  scholars believe him to have been a 5th or 6th Century leader.

The legend links him to 12 major battles fought over 40 years from the Scottish Borders to the West Country. One of the principal victories was said to have been at Chester.

Rather than create a purpose-built Camelot, historian Chris Gidlow says Arthur would have logically chosen a structure left by the Romans.

‘The first accounts of the Round Table show that it was nothing like a dining table but was a venue for upwards of 1,000 people at a time,’ he said.

‘And we know that one of Arthur’s two main battles was fought at a town referred to as the City of the Legions. There were only two places with this title. One was St Albans, but the location of the other has remained a mystery.’

Researchers, who will reveal their evidence in a television documentary this month, say the recent discovery at the amphitheatre of an execution stone and a wooden memorial to Christian martyrs suggests the missing city is Chester.

Mr Gidlow said: ‘In the 6th Century, a monk named Gildas, who wrote the earliest account of Arthur’s life, referred both to the City of the Legions and to a martyr’s shrine within it.

‘That is the clincher. The discovery of the shrine within the amphitheatre means that Chester was the site of Arthur’s court – and his legendary Round Table.’

Posted in Just Too Cool | Tagged ,
14 Comments

horrible

Oh dear…

horrible 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
21 Comments

Keep repeating: “Anglicanorum coetibus… Anglicanorum coetibus…”

We should all be ready on the bank with good towels and disinfectants as Anglicans begin swimming the Tiber.

Benedict XVI is the Pope of Christian Unity

From CNN we learn that the Protestant Anglican Church in England rejected even the compromise about women "bishops":

My emphases and comments.

Women bishops vote threatens to split Church of England

The Church of England inched closer to allowing women bishops this weekend, with a vote that traditionalists warned could split the church.

The church’s governing body narrowly rejected a measure that would allow parishes that oppose women bishops to have an additional male bishop. [They rejected even the compromise.]

The proposal, floated by Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams (pictured) – the titular head of the Church of England – was an attempt to satisfy conservatives.

Campaigners for women bishops hailed the vote as a victory. [HUZZAH!]

But traditionalists said the ballot "has made it very difficult [read: impossible] for those who in conscience cannot accept the ministry for women priests and bishops."

The vote happened Saturday at the General Synod, the three-times-a-year meeting that sets policies for the Church of England.

Williams, who is also nominal head of the worldwide Anglican Communion, proposed the measure along with John Sentamu, the Archbishop of York.

The rejection of the compromise was greeted with a "slightly stunned silence," said the Rev. Miranda Threlfall-Holmes.

"Everyone was aware instantly of how close it was, [with] a slight gasp from everybody, thinking, ‘Oh no, we only lost that by the skin of our teeth’ or ‘only passed that by the skin of our teeth,’" she said Sunday.

The Church of England is probably still a couple of years away from having women bishops. If this week’s General Synod approves them, as expected, parishes across the church then have at least a year to consider the matter before a future General Synod casts a final vote on the issue.

Chris Sugden of the conservative Anglican Mainstream movement said the vote showed that conservatives were actually the majority.

"Although this group is portrayed as a minority, [I love that…. "portrayed".   The liberals are so consistent.   They always want to paint the majority of conservatives as if they are the fringe.] those who do not want a winner-take-all, scorched-earth policy, are a majority in Synod," he said.

He denied that the vote was about whether or not to ordain women bishops, saying the Church of England had already decided to go ahead with that. [!]

Instead, Sugden said, the vote was about keeping the church together.  [I wonder how that double tabernacle thing is working.]

The failed compromise was so "that those who cannot accept women bishops can still be part of the Church of England," he said. "We believe in freedom of conscience, in religious freedom," he said of conservatives.

But he said a split was not inevitable, with two days to go before the General Synod concludes.

"Forty-eight hours is a long time in the life of a synod," he told CNN Sunday. "There is a lot of water to flow under the bridge. A lot of conversations are taking place."

The Catholic Group in Synod, another conservative group, suggested it would continue to fight against women bishops.

"The process in General Synod is not over and we would wish to be involved in the ongoing discussions as to a way forward that includes all loyal members of the Church of England," it said in a statement.

But a campaign called Women in the Church hailed the vote.

"We’re tying hard not to use the word victory, but yes it is," said Sally Barnes, a Women in the Church representative.  [Another blow to unity!]

"You can’t have a church where we’re all supposed to be one in Christ and then treat women as if it’s the faulty half of creation," she told CNN Sunday.

"People don’t need protecting against women, it’s not a Christian concept. It’s not how Christ treated women," she argued.  [Ho hum.   If their orders are invalid anyway, why not just do it… get it over with…. move on to a brighter future?]

Under Church of England rules, for a measure like the one proposed by Williams and Sentamu to pass, it needed majority support from three different groups: bishops, priests and lay leaders.

Bishops and lay leaders backed the measure, but priests narrowly rejected it, meaning it failed.

The Anglican Communion – of which the Church of England is the British branch – is the world’s third-largest Christian denomination, with about 77 million members worldwide.

It’s facing serious strains over the ordination of women bishops and gay priests, and the Catholic Church has reached out to disaffected Anglicans, raising the possibility that conservatives could leave en masse.

 

Benedict XVI is the Pope of Christian Unity

He has approved the mesures to facilitate the unity of Anglicans who don’t want to be involved with this stuff anymore.  

Anglicanorum coetibus …. keep repeating… Anglicanorum coetibus….

Posted in Pope of Christian Unity | Tagged , , , , ,
37 Comments

NCR and Sipe on “Scandal vs. crisis”

Ex-priest Richard Sipe has a piece in the National Catholic Fishwrap:

My emphases and comments:

Scandal vs. crisis; PR vs. raw data
by A.W. Richard Sipe on Jul. 09, 2010

Examining the Crisis

Ron Westrum, professor of sociology at Eastern Michigan University, suggests that organizations react in a series of stages to “anomalous reports.” [This is interesting…] They are: 1) suppression, 2) encapsulation, 3) public relations, 4) local fix, 5) global fix, and 6) investigation of root causes. He came to his formulation through the study of the battered child syndrome that many people, even professionals, found hard to admit was a widespread phenomenon.

It is not difficult to match the trajectory of church response to allegations of hidden clergy sex abuse against Westrum’s model. It’s a good fit.

Even in the United States the church is not near the final stage — the process of resolving root causes. [What will he offer as a "resolution"?  Will it involve a change to the Church’s discipline of celibacy or the "ordination" of women?] Since the eruption of revelations in 2010 spotlighting sexual activity by priests across Europe it is obvious that even the U.S. church is still suspended between public relations and “fixes.” People in the pews need to know and evaluate the bishops’ public relations efforts against the raw material in church files. [Ah… it’s the "Watergate" approach.] Those documents indicate what the bishops (pope) knew and when they knew it.

The church in the United States and Ireland worked hard at the suppression and encapsulation of the sex abuse among its ranks. The Vatican and Europe are struggling with that now, but the public relations fight everywhere is reinvigorated. Roman minions [Just in case you thought Sipe could write an objective piece…] have begun pointing fingers and are repeating the defenses the United States suffered throughout the past two decades.

Pope Benedict XVI is raising the PR stakes by flirting with the idea that the “sin is inside the church” at the same time that he blames the devil for the scandal. But he is still stuck on scandal and avoiding the crisis. Nonetheless, the public relations program follows a programmed pattern beginning with accusations of “anti-religion.” [But… that doesn’t deal with the possibility that that’s true!  That at least in part it is anti-religion.] The PR sequence is organized and transparent enough to diagram — “there is no crisis; the media is causing the scandal; there may be a “few bad apples” causing a problem; [But that it true.] if any, it is only a small problem; there is a problem, but no bigger than in any other organization; [Also, true, though the Church must have a higher standard.] abuse is not connected with celibacy; [There it is!] abuse is a societal problem; homosexuals cause it; [What were those statistics again?] we have done more than any other organization to combat with the problem of child abuse.” [They have.]

After 20 years the schema is familiar to most U.S. observers. However, a new crop of bishops is recycling the old pattern — beginning by blasting the press for reports of clergy malfeasance as unfair and anti-Catholic, anti-clergy, anti-religion. [Two things: The press forced the Church to do something.   The press also has its own agenda.] One recent example: Timothy Dolan, archbishop of New York, accused The New York Times of bias: “It is not hyperbole to call prejudice against the Catholic church a national pastime,” he wrote on his blog. The attack was against Catholic columnist Maureen Dowd’s spirited defense of nuns — Laurie Goodstein’s reports on a dying 22-year-old abandoned son of a still active priest — and the paper’s lack of “outrage” at reports of pedophile attacks in an ultra-Orthodox Jewish community. From the Vatican, Cardinal William Levada, also reprimanded the Time for what he termed “attacks on the Holy Father concerning sex abuse” within the church. He pronounced them “deficient by any reasonable standards of fairness.”

Dolan’s rant is reminiscent of Bernard Law, [Huh?] Cardinal of Boston in 1992 rankled by news reports about Fr. James Porter who admittedly abused 200 minors in five dioceses. Law riled against a biased anti-Catholic secular press he claimed was actually causing the scandal by writing an overblown account. “By all means,” he said, “we call down God’s power on the media, particularly the Globe.” That didn’t work. More stories came out.

The public relations efforts of the church have voiced interesting spins. In 2000 Sr. Mary Ann Walsh, spokesperson for the U.S. Catholic Bishops Conference, asserted twice on national TV, “I’m convinced that ’99 and 44/100%’ of priests keep their celibacy.” ("99 44/100% Pure" is the old Ivory soap slogan.) In 2004 Bishop Wilton Gregory proclaimed that the problem of clergy abuse was “history.” In 2010, a John Jay spokesperson preparing a report for the bishops declared that Catholic clergy abuse is a historical and time-limited phenomenon.

Catholic clergy abuse stories in the United States now generally meet a media-weary reception. Does this mean that the crisis is over? No. The public relation efforts whether from the Vatican or home grown, so far are aimed at control of a scandal and its aftermath.

Every Catholic boy and girl learned in grade school that “scandal” should be avoided at all costs. We may not have known any formal definition, but we knew it was bad. Public school kids and non-Catholics should never be given a reason to criticize our church. A scandal is “a widely publicized set of allegations that damage the reputation of an institution, individual or creed” and we have it.

The scandal has partly gone cold — it is old news. Most people now know that some Catholic priests are sexually active, some abuse minors, and bishops try to cover up. [What the press doesn’t say is how much the Church has done to deal with the problem.]

The Catholic crisis remains. One key to addressing the crisis, and ultimately in fixing it, is in the review, revelation, and analysis of the documents that record the behavior of the clergy. That factor made The Boston Globe’s reporting seminal and preeminent in making “hidden events” available for reform (Westrum, defines hidden events as an “occurrence so implausible that those who observe it hesitate to report it because they do not expect to be believed.”). Bishops fight to keep the truth (documents) secret.

The church has not yet addressed the crisis; in fact, most bishops are still resistive and mired in an old familiar pattern of obfuscation if not deceit. [Are they?  Can that be backed up?] Public relations efforts are aimed at damage control, not change. Crisis presents a decisive turning point that demands a “fix.” Two lay Catholics chosen by the bishops to chair the National Review Board, Governor Frank Keating and Justice Anne Burke, rendered their opinions: Keating said bishops operate like “cosa nostra”; Burke pronounced a judgment that the bishops are primarily interested in pursuing “business as usual.”

Investigative reporter, Jason Berry already notable for forcing the crisis of abuse into U.S. public attention in 1984, labored intensively and extensively for a full decade to help victims of Fr. Marcial Maciel Degollado tell their story of abuse, only to witness a 2004 PR photo of Pope John Paul II embracing and blessing this notorious founder of a religious order. [How much can really be made out of that?] There can be no doubt that the pope heard the stories about Maciel [That I am not entirely sure about…. but it is possible.  Certainly the Sec. of State at the time knew what was going on!] and discounted them as he had the well-founded reports of sex abuse by Cardinal Groer in 1995. The Vatican’s belated official verdict on Maciel in 2010 — that he was dismissed in 2006 for immoral behavior, criminal acts and demonstration of “a life devoid of scruples and authentic religious feeling” — can hardly compensate for the laborious pain of discovery in addition to the rejection and humiliation involved in the battle to speak truth to power that Berry and the victims had to endure for two decades.

A more intrepid and dedicated advocate for victims of clergy abuse than Fr. Thomas Doyle is impossible to find. He describes his 25-year crusade for justice, accountability and transparency as “wading through a cesspool of toxic waste.” These men among others working to document facts and reveal healing truth are neither anti-religion nor anti-Catholic. Indubitably there are temptations to despair as we read what bishops have done and continue to do in their effort to deny truth and destroy evidence behind a pious PR curtain.

Those of us who have reviewed church documents — raw data including the depositions of bishops — and write about what we find do know what bishops knew about abuse and when they really knew it. There are records. We are not interested in scandal. [Some are.] We are concerned with the welfare of children. We are interested in a crisis that distorts and destroys peoples’ lives and hope. We are interested in change–reform of a corrupting system and concerned about religious hypocrisy. We are respectful of a church that does much good despite its corruption. [And I think we know what that agenda includes.]

PR campaigns by the bishops and the Vatican evade the historic and monumental crisis of epic proportions that is upon us. That is an additional scandal. The crisis awaits a fix.

[Richard Sipe is a mental health counselor and author who earlier spent 18 years as a Benedictine monk and priest.]

There is much of merit in this article.  But I believe the writer goes off the rails on certain points.

The part at the top was pretty interesting.

Posted in Biased Media Coverage, Clerical Sexual Abuse, SESSIUNCULA | Tagged
31 Comments

QUAERITUR: pamphlets about TLM for parishes

From a reader:

I am trying to raise awareness of the TLM and Summorum Pontificum in my diocese.  I am considering developing a pamphlet to pass out at different parishes in order to do this.  However, before I reinvent the wheel, I was hoping someone else in an English speaking country has already done this.  Could you please make a post that would allow us to share information and find out what is out there in the Catholic world along these lines? It would certainly save me a great deal of time and perhaps others as well.

 

I think it is commendable to want to raise awareness of the TLM among people who may not know much about it.

I don’t know of any resource already available for this project.  

That said, I am sure that people here will now chime in with their suggestions.

But I must add some caveats.

Again, I think it is commendable to want to make the TLM known and loved.

But do exercise prudence and respect for the authority of a parish’s pastor. 

Don’t just go around sticking things in churches.  Pastors of parishes have the right to determine what is placed in the church.

Also, be prudent in regard to what you distribute outside other churches.

Finally, be sure that the material is not disrespectful of priests, bishops or the Novus Ordo.  

“Soyez toujours le plus doux que vous pourrez, et souvenez-vous que l’on prends plus de mouches avec une cuillère de miel qu’avec cent barils de vinaigre… Always be as gentle as you can and remember that one catches more flies with a spoonful of honey than with a hundred barrels of vinegar." – St. Francis de Sales

 

Posted in "How To..." - Practical Notes, ASK FATHER Question Box, Brick by Brick, SUMMORUM PONTIFICUM |
18 Comments