QUAERITUR: What do about about a liturgical abuse in the Eucharistic Prayer

From a reader:

I was at Mass today. It was a First Holy Communion. There were many things that were obviously not right, but one thing stood above the rest of the usual novelties and abuses. It was the Eucharistic Prayer. I know it didn’t seem right to me, however I am not at all familiar with the GIRM or with what is actually permitted, especially for so-called children’s liturgies. However, I’m pretty sure it wasn’t right.

Anyway, I lifted this from the Mass booklet that was produced. [Excellent.. they actually printed it.]

I was wondering if you could advise me on what exactly is going on here and what might be done to address this issue.

This is what the reader sent:

This was the Eucharistic Prayer. The congregation were encouraged to say the bits in bold.
Lord, accept these gifts of bread and wine we offer you on this happy day. In your fatherly love watch over and protect all the boys and girls who receive your body for the first time today, may this mystery of unselfish love, increase their love for you and for each other. We ask this through Christ our Lord. Amen.
The Lord be with you.
And also with you.
Lift up your hearts.
We lift them up to the Lord.
Let us give thanks to the Lord our God.
It is right to give God thanks and praise.
God, our loving Father, we are glad to give you thanks and praise because you love us. With Jesus we proclaim your praise.
Response:  Glory to God in the highest.
Because you love us, you gave us this great and beautiful world. With Jesus we proclaim your praise:
Response:  Glory to God in the highest.
Because you love us, you sent Jesus your son to bring us to you and to gather us around him as the children of one family. With Jesus we proclaim your praise:
Response:  Glory to God in the highest.
For such great love we thank you with the angels and saints as they praise you and sing:
Holy, holy, holy Lord, God of power and might….
Blessed be Jesus, whom you sent to be the friend of children and of the poor. He came to show us how we can love you, father, by loving one another. He came to take away sin, which keeps us from being friends, and hate, which makes us all unhappy. He promised to send the Holy Spirit, to be with us always so that we can live as your children.
Response:  Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord. Hosanna in the highest.
God our Father, we now ask you to send your Holy Spirit to change these gifts of bread and wine into the body + and blood of Jesus Christ, our Lord.
The night before he died, Jesus your Son showed us how much you love us.
When he was at supper with his disciples, he took bread, and gave you thanks and praise. Then he broke the bread, gave it to his friends, and said:
Take this all of you, and eat it: This is my body, which will be given up for you.
Response:  Jesus has given his life for us.
When supper was ended, Jesus took the cup that was filled with wine. He thanked you, gave it to his friends and said:
Take this, all of you, and drink from it: This is the cup of my blood, the blood of the new and everlasting covenant. It will be shed for you and for all so that sins may be forgiven.
Response:  Jesus has given his life for us.
Then he said to them: Do this in memory of me.
And so loving Father, we remember that Jesus died and rose again to save the world. He put himself into our hands to be the sacrifice we offer you.
Response:  We praise you, we bless you, we thank you.
Lord our God, listen to our prayer. Send the Holy Spirit to all of us who share in this meal. May this Spirit bring us closer together in the family of the Church, with Benedict, our Pope, Joseph, our bishop, and all who serve your people.
Response:  We praise you, we bless you, we thank you
[……]

And so it went like this until the end of the Eucharistic Prayer.

At Holy Communion time, all the first communicants and their parents were invited to stand in an arc around the altar, and the priest shook hands with them all (perhaps 40 or 50 people) and distributed Holy Communion first to the first communicants, then to their parents.

I didn’t know there is any form of any Eucharistic Prayer that looks like this.  I did find this, however.  There are Eucharistic Prayers for Masses with Children.  I don’t use Eucharistic Prayers for Children.  I don’t think there should even be Eucharistic Prayers for Children.  I don’t think it is right to talk down to children when you don’t have to and when the occasion is, how to put this… not childish.

Also, I am unaware that it is permitted for people to gather around the altar in that manner.

I am also pretty sure that the priest is to receive Communion before others, not after.

What I would suggest you do when you have a doubt about something – and when you have something printed – is to send a copy of the booklet to the local bishop asking the bishop if [X] is approved.  I am assuming that the pastor of the parish has been unresponsive.

If that doesn’t produce a good anwer, or any answer, send also a copy of your letter to the bishop and a copy of the booklet to the Congregation for Divine Worship and Discipline of the Sacraments.

Ask if this is permitted and what approve book this comes from.

Address:

His Eminence
Antonio Card. Canizares Llovera
Prefect of the Congregation for
    Divine Worship and Discipline of the Sacraments
Palazzo delle Congregazioni
P.za Pio XII
00120 VATICAN CITY

Posted in ASK FATHER Question Box |
26 Comments

Prayer request

Please pray for David, who died recently.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
26 Comments

The past is past, the future is perfect… perfect game #20

When ever I go to a ball game, or turn on a ball game… that by default that is of course baseball… I always thing… maybe this time… who knows….

Will I see an unassisted triple play?
Will I see the cycle?
Will I see… and this in a hushed whisper…. perfect game?

Today there was a perfect game… and I could have been watching!!

Halladay throws MLB’s 20th perfect game

By Alden Gonzalez / MLB.com

05/29/10 9:09 PM ET

MIAMI — Phillies right-hander Roy Halladay retired all 27 batters he faced to pitch the 20th perfect game in Major League history on Saturday night at Sun Life Stadium.

Halladay is coming off a rough outing against the Red Sox, when he gave up seven runs (six earned) in 5 2/3 innings. But the Marlins were unable to figure out his mix of cutters, fastballs, changeups and curveballs while striking out 11 times.

The 33-year-old came into the game 6-3 with a 2.22 ERA. The last Phillies pitcher to hurl a no-hitter was Kevin Millwood on April 27, 2003 against the Giants. The only Phillies pitcher to throw a perfect game is Jim Bunning in 1964.

The Phillies held a 1-0 lead through five after Chase Utley’s line drive bounced off the glove of Marlins center fielder Cameron Maybin in the third inning, allowing Wilson Valdez to score from first base. 

The past is past, the future is perfect... perfect game #20 

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
20 Comments

Oremus Pro Pontifice – Let us Pray for the Pope

From the the Enchiridion of Indulgences, #25:

A partial indulgence is granted to the Christian faithful who, in a spirit of filial devotion, devoutly recite any duly approved prayer for the Supreme Pontiff (e.g., the Oremus pro Pontifice):

V. Let us pray for our Pontiff, Pope Benedict.

R. May the Lord preserve him, and give him life, and bless him upon earth, and deliver him not to the will of his enemies.

Our Father.  Hail Mary.

Let us pray.

O God, Shepherd and Ruler of all Thy faithful people, look mercifully upon Thy servant Benedict, whom Thou hast chosen as shepherd to preside over Thy Church. Grant him, we beseech Thee, that by his word and example, he may edify those over whom he hath charge, so that together with the flock committed to him, may he attain everlasting life. Through Christ our Lord. Amen.

REQUEST: If you have ordered or received some of these buttons or mugs, etc., could you send photos?  Also, send a note if any of these has started or helped a conversation.!

___

In light of the attacks on Pope Benedict which are sure to continue in the media, I thought it would be a good idea to pray more frequently for the Holy Father and to help you remind others to do the same.

Here are some trinkets which you might consider in this cause.

With the help of "Vincenzo", the official WDTPRS photoshopper, I made a cafepress store for buttons and the like.

Oremus Pro Pontifice - Let us Pray for the Pope

If you are in the USA…

Get Pro Pontifice stuff here.Oremus Pro Pontifice - Let us Pray for the Pope

If you are in the UK…

You can get the Pro Pontifice stuff here.Oremus Pro Pontifice - Let us Pray for the Pope

If you are an Aussie …

You can get Pro Pontifice stuff here.Oremus Pro Pontifice - Let us Pray for the Pope

If you are a Canadian …

You can get Pro Pontifice stuff here.Oremus Pro Pontifice - Let us Pray for the Pope

There are also mugs and a hat and some shirts and the like.

There are as well packs of 100 buttons in different sizes which you could distribute to people.

Play video

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
5 Comments

PRAYERCAzT: 1st Vespers & Compline – Trinity Sunday (Breviarum Romanum)

No frills 1st Vespers with the Breviarium Romanum for the tired brethren.

And Compline.

Posted in PRAYERCAzT: What Does The (Latin) Prayer Really Sound L |
Comments Off on PRAYERCAzT: 1st Vespers & Compline – Trinity Sunday (Breviarum Romanum)

WDTPRS: Trinity Sunday

At the end of Holy Mass this morning I noted the simple but weighty rubric:

Post Missam expirat tempus paschale.

We have come back around to the Tempus per annum.

But we don’t go green quite yet.  Sunday is Trinity Sunday, that day many well-read and well-catechized Catholics dread for the absurdities they hear from the pulpit.

In the early Church no special day was designated for the Most Holy Trinity, but to combat the Arian heresy Catholics developed Creeds as well as an office for Sundays having canticles, responses, a preface, and hymns.  In the ancient Gregorian Sacramentary we find prayers and the Preface of the Trinity.  Pope John XXII (+1334) ordered a universal feast in honor of the Trinity on the first Sunday after Pentecost.  This day was raised to the dignity of a First Class feast by Pope St. Pius X (+1914).  It was made a Solemnity for the Novus Ordo. 

WDTPRS: Trinity SundayThere is a wonderful logic to the timing of this feast.  We focus on the Son’s Ascension to the Father, then the Holy Spirit on Pentecost, and then the Triune God the Sunday after.  Today we celebrate our constant profession of belief in doctrine of a Holy Trinity, the most fundamental of Christian truths and most mysterious of all dogmas.  God the Father created us through the Son. God the Son redeemed us and revealed us more fully to ourselves (GS 22). God the Holy Ghost sanctifies us in our Holy Church.

COLLECT – (1962MR):
Omnipotens sempiterne Deus,
qui dedisti famulis tuis, in confessione verae fidei,
aeternae Trinitatis gloriam agnoscere,
et in potentia maiestatis adorare Unitatem:
quaesumus; ut, eiusdem fidei firmitate,
ab omnibus semper muniamur adversis.

LITERAL TRANSLATION:
Almighty everlasting God,
who granted to Your servants, in the profession of the true Faith,
to recognize the glory of the eternal Trinity
and to adore Its Unity in the might of majesty:
we beseech You; that, in the steadfastness of that same Faith,
we may always be defended from all adversities.

One of the things I appreciate in this prayer is the acknowledgment that we have adversities in this life, even deadly spiritual enemies.  The transforming power of the Holy Trinity, dwelling in our souls when we are in the state of grace, gives us power in the face of our challenges.

Let’s right away have a look at how they changed the Collect for the Novus Ordo.  The old language, preserved by the liturgical expert scissor and paste-pot jockeys engaged by the Consilium, is underscored.

COLLECT (1970 Missale Romanum):
Deus Pater, qui, Verbum veritatis
et Spiritum sanctificationis mittens in mundum,
admirabile mysterium tuum hominibus declarasti,
da nobis, in confessione verae fidei,
aeternae gloriam Trinitatis agnoscere,
et Unitatem adorare in potentia maiestatis
.

Obviously this is a hybrid glued together from part of the 1962 Collect and something else, perhaps a new composition. 

However, I found the noteworthy phrase admirabile mysterium used to describe the doctrine of the Trinity in the Gesta collationis Carthaginiensis habitae inter Catholicos et Donatistas … the minutes of the meeting that took place in Carthage in June 411 between Catholic and Donatist bishops. St. Augustine of Hippo (+430) was a major player at that conference. That and confessio verae fidei suggest that this prayer, though of new composition, is essentially founded on Augustine’s work on the Most Holy Trinity, which should not surprise.

LITERAL TRANSLATION:
O God the Father, who, sending the Word of Truth
and the Spirit of sanctification into the world,
declared Thy wondrous mystery to men,
grant us, in the confession of true faith,
to recognize the glory of the eternal Trinity,
and to adore its Unity in the might of majesty.

We should spend time on the language common to both of these Trinity Sunday Collects.

First, note the direct address to God the Father.  Then, I catch references to manifestations (epiphanies) of the Trinity in Scripture and of the glory of God as a bright cloud: at Jesus’ baptism by St. John in the Jordan when the Holy Spirit was seen as a dove and the voice of the Father was heard (cf. Luke 3); when Jesus was transfigured before the eyes of Peter, John and James (cf. Matthew 17).  God made known the wondrous mystery (admirabile mysterium) that He is Three in One, a Trinity of divine Persons, God the Father, God the Word of Truth, God the Spirit of sanctification, One God.  It is necessary foundational part of true Faith (vera fides) that we recognize (agnoscere) God to be Triune.  This is something that man can reason toward on his own, as ancient Greek Neoplatonic philosophers did, but only by the gift of Faith does he profess (confiteor) this mystery in an authentically Christian way.

An important word in the prayer is maiestas.   Maiestas is conceptually related in the writings of the Latin Fathers, to gloria.  In early Latin Fathers such as St. Hilary of Poitiers (+368), St. Ambrose (+397) and in early liturgical texts, maiestas/gloria means far more than simple fame, or splendor of appearance. Latin liturgical gloria and maiestas are related to biblical Greek doxa and Hebrew kabod.  “Glory” and “majesty” express man’s recognition of God as God and of the salvation won for us by Christ. Simultaneously, “glory” is a characteristic of God, a power He will share will us, by which He will transform us.  “Glory”, therefore, in our liturgical prayers has an eschatological sense, since it refers to the Last Things.  God’s transforming glory, to be shared more fully in heaven, is foreshadowed in Moses’ meetings with God, when He came like a cloud (Hebrew shekinah).  After these meetings Moses’ face was transformed and shone like the sun.  In this Collect we adore the gloria Trinitatis, the maiestas Unitatis, which has potentia.  In the mighty Lewis & Short Dictionary, potentia means “might, force, power.” 

Here in this vale of tears we must strive to give glory to the Most Holy Trinity in all that we do, think and say.  May the Holy Trinity give us even here in anticipation a share of that divine glory, in saving and actual graces. May our relationship with the Holy Trinity shine in how we treat our neighbor.  

Also, as a curiosity, priests might want to listen to these if they must sing Holy Mass in Latin, especially in the older, traditional form:

PRAYERCAzT 29: Trinity Sunday (1962MR)
PRAYERCAzT 02: Preface of the Most Holy Trinity

And even this…

033 07-06-03 Augustine on loving “too late”; the Trinity; leaving Roma

Posted in SESSIUNCULA, WDTPRS |
10 Comments

Priests v. Satan: the abortion industry’s public acts of anti-Catholic hate speech

Excuse the profanity in the images included with the following.  It is necessary to know what what drives those behind the culture of death (hint: the Enemy of the soul).

From the Pro-Life Corner:

Rockford Abortion Mill Continues Vicious Attacks On Catholic Priests
As number of abortions decline in Rockford, the abortion mill seems to be (rightly) blaming the spiritual power of Priests.
 
Rockford IL,  May 29, 2010  – In September of 2008 a group of Catholic Priests began praying every week at Rockford’s abortion mill special prayers of the Church that the abortion mill be cleansed from evil.  Immediately, the pro-life women who sidewalk counsel at this abortion facility noticed a dramatic decline in the numbers of mothers coming for abortions and a tangible rise in the numbers of mothers who choose life at the abortion mill driveway.
 
An unofficial count of mothers entering the mill within a month of these devout Priests praying showed the abortion totals to be cut at least in half. This is also when signs started appearing in the mill windows attacking Catholic Priests. [OORAH!]
 
On Friday May 29th, the abortion mill sank to a new low even for them.  As a Priest was quietly praying the prayers of the Church accompanied by a seminarian, [And here it comes…] someone inside the building that houses the Northern Illinois Women’s Center put a sign that clearly stated, "F…. Your Perverted Priests."
 
 Catholic Priests have also had to endure personal insults from the abortion mill landlord and security guard.  The car of one Priest has been egged by an abortion supporter at this mill.  A Priest has also had a hand-written sign taped to his car while he was quietly praying on the sidewalk in front of the mill.  The sign read, "I Rape Children." [Thanks a lot, you sick and wicked … brothers.  Thanks for this gift that keeps on giving.]

Priests v. Satan: the abortion industry's public acts of anti-Catholic hate speech

One thing is certain.  This abortion facility and its supporters know one of the major reasons their numbers of dead babies have gone down [along with profits] is because the committed, faith-filled, and courageous Catholic Priests are praying consistently that the evil that surrounds and drives the abortion industry is replaced with the grace of Jesus Christ.  In Rockford these Priests and their prayers have saved countless lives and souls.  That’s why this mill hates and attacks them in this vicious manner.
 
As one Rockford area pro-lifer said, "This group of Priests has prayed at this mill no matter the weather, intimidation, and mocking threats they have faced.  In the spirit of Jesus Christ, they have responded to these attacks with prayer, humility, and love."
 
A Rockford man said of one of these Priests, "Last winter on a day with the wind chill well below zero, Father was in prayer on the sidewalk with his coat open.  Everyone told him he needed to cover up better, but Father knew that people entering the mill needed to know a Priest was there.
One young Hispanic woman looked at Father, saw his collar, and saw him praying for her.  She immediately left the mill and never returned."
 
It is the hope of the Rockford Christian community that Rockford city officials will look into the long and hate- filled history of the abortion mill and come to a decision that this kind of bigotry is not acceptable in our city.
 
As for these holy men who pray and work for life and for an end to the demonic inspired culture of death in Rockford,  we owe them our support, prayers, and grateful thanks for leading us in this battle against sin, Satan, and death.  [Do I hear an "Amen!"?]

Priests v. Satan: the abortion industry's public acts of anti-Catholic hate speech

In the person of Christ the Head . . .

1548 In the ecclesial service of the ordained minister, it is Christ Himself who is present to His Church as Head of His Body, Shepherd of His flock, High Priest of the redemptive sacrifice, Teacher of Truth. This is what the Church means by saying that the priest, by virtue of the sacrament of Holy Orders, acts in persona Christi Capitis:

It is the same Priest, Christ Jesus, whose sacred person His minister truly represents. Now the minister, by reason of the sacerdotal consecration which he has received, is truly made like to the High Priest and possesses the authority to act in the power and place of the Person of Christ Himself (virtute ac persona ipsius Christi).

Christ is the Source of all priesthood: the priest of the old law was a figure of Christ, and the priest of the new law acts in the Person of Christ.
1549 Through the ordained ministry, especially that of bishops and priests, the presence of Christ as Head of the Church is made visible in the midst of the community of believers. In the beautiful expression of St. Ignatius of Antioch, the bishop is typos tou Patros: he is like the living image of God the Father.

 

For a few more days this is still the Year of the Priest.

What the people in that clinic seem not to understand is that when they point hatred at priests in public, they are drawing attention to priests in public, priests whom all but the most dense or hardened will immediately understand are not the sort of priest who would harm children.

Posted in SESSIUNCULA |
46 Comments

Being “judgmental”. Fr. Finigan hits for six!

My friend His Hermeneuticalness has hit for six.

Here is a sample.  But definitely go over to his place and spike his stats even while reading the rest of this excellent entry.

My emphases and comments:

    Judge not, that you may not be judged. For with what judgment you judge, you shall be judged: and with what measure you mete, it shall be measured to you again. (Matt 7.1-2)

How often do we see this verse quoted in response to Catholic blog posts? Criticise the public actions of a politician or a high-ranking ecclesiastic and you can be sure that someone will say that you should not be "judgmental". Should bloggers cringe in shame at failing to observe the teaching of Our Lord in the Sermon on the Mount? I think we can reasonably take a deeper look at this. [Do I hear an "Amen!"?]

We cannot "judge" someone in the way that God judges us. (He will judge us, by the way.) [As a matter of fact, we will receive His judgment whether we want it or not.  But His mercy is ours for the asking.] We do not have the right to make such a judgement, or in fact the information on which to base it. Only God knows the subjective state of an individual’s soul. So even if we consider the infernal columns’ brutal repression of the rising in the Vendée, the Mexican campaign against priests such as St Christopher Magellanes, the shooting of the intellectuals in Mao’s China or Pol Pot’s Cambodia, Lenin and Stalin’s atrocities (or indeed the Nazi concentration camps) it is still only God who can judge the individual’s state of soul. Nevertheless, we can and should judge all of those publicly known horrors as objectively evil.  [We human beings are made in God’s image, with an intellect and the ability and obligation to make judgments.  Not as God judges, but according to the Truth.  We have our intellect and also the help of authority for the process of making judgments about that which is good, true and beautiful.  To refuse to make judgments about such things is to deny our humanity.]

In the case of politicians who have voted in favour of abortion, embryo experimentation, assisted suicide, and passive euthanasia, we are entitled to look at their voting record and to make an objective judgement that what they have voted for is wrong, and call them to account for it. A public figure, making public decisions, in the public square, [open actions in the public square!] may be subjected to reasonable judgement as to the rightness or wrongness of their public actions. The political life of the country would not function without the people being able to express their opinions in such matters.

[…]

Posted in The Drill | Tagged
11 Comments

SHOCK! A Cardinal is pro-life!

I got to know Marc Card. Ouellet in Rome.  He is a stand up guy.

So, I tuned in when I saw this from CWN:

Cardinal Marc Ouellet expressed astonishment at the reaction to his recent statement that abortion is a moral crime that cannot be justified even in the case of rape. In response, a newspaper columnist said he hoped the cardinal would die a slow and painful death, […you mean… like a baby as it is being snuffed out?] while the National Assembly of Quebec unanimously expressed its support for free access to abortion.

“When it comes to a religious figure or the imposition of a religious doctrine in Quebec, people are going to speak out,” said Ainsley Jenicek of the Quebec Federation of Birth Planning.

“For the unborn, there is not justice. He is the weakest human being; nobody is protecting him,” the cardinal said as he reflected upon the reaction to his remarks. “I am aware that in Canada, in Quebec in particular, you will not reform society at the moral level by teaching morals first. It will be through a new evangelization.”

“If you do not meet Jesus Christ, it is very difficult to accept the teaching, the moral teaching of the Church,” he added. “I am aware of that, even if what we teach is coherent at the rational level.”

Source(s): these links will take you to other sites, in a new window.

Posted in Biased Media Coverage, Emanations from Penumbras, SESSIUNCULA, The Last Acceptable Prejudice | Tagged
10 Comments

Of rotted fish juice lunch and of gardens and of feeders

I want to thank EC of NY for lunch today.  EC of NY sent some garum… yes… garum.  I have written about garum several times (check here and here.), but most recently in the form of colatura, a super concentrated pickled fish reduction from southern Italy.

Of rotted fish juice lunch and of gardens and of feeders

We know how ancient garum was prepared and we have a garum factory and many containers in the ruins of Pompeii. The naturalist Pliny describes its making from the intestines of fish, macerated in salt and left in the sun for one to three months, where the mixture fermented and liquefied.

You can buy your garum using amazon!  And it is nearly always on my wishlist.. for obvious reasons.

It has a lot of protein and B vitamins!

Garum is good for you!

Seneca was, however, sceptical.  "Do you not realize," wrote Seneca in a letter (95)- generally a killjoy –  "that garum sociorum, that expensive bloody mass of decayed fish, consumes the stomach with its salted putrefaction?"  Garum sociorum was imported from Spain, after all.

Well… garum wasn’t all that expensive in its lower grades or when made domestically.  It was consumed rather like is modern descendent ketchup – really – by everyone.  There were some very fancy expensive concoctions of garum, however, just as there are boutique designer ketchups now.

To use your garum or colatura, cook pasta… very thing "angel hair" works best for this.  A classic serving size of pasta for men is 100 grams. I use about 75 grams these days.

Meanwhile, chop up garlic and hot peppers and parsley, very fine, and put it all in a bowl.

Put a tablespoon of garum over the chopped stuff.

Let the pasta cool a bit and drain very well.  Add the cooked pasta and stir together.

Eat wolfishly.

Crave constantly.

In the meantime, sun helps not only to liquify your fish guts but also for the growing of tomatoes.

Of rotted fish juice lunch and of gardens and of feeders

Planting requires beer…. which the ancient Romans called fermentum… and zythus… and cerevisia.

Of rotted fish juice lunch and of gardens and of feeders

Meanwhile, this hummingbird is having a rest on the very peak of my feeder apparatus.

Of rotted fish juice lunch and of gardens and of feeders

No beer, however.

This very young Yellow-Bellied Sapsucker is catching some rays – they typically look up like this, by the way.

Of rotted fish juice lunch and of gardens and of feeders

Posted in Fr. Z's Kitchen, SESSIUNCULA, The Feeder Feed | Tagged , ,
9 Comments